Sunday, June 16, 2024

Weekend Data Dump

When I see a lighted mass drone show, I get a shiver. Because I see a future show that spells out "Allahu Akhbar" before the drones scatter and plunge to the ground where they explode.

Well, one big difference is that we were liberating a friendly city--not taking an enemy city: "Brown and other top officials have cited American operations in places like Mosul, where they believe the United States held itself to a higher standard than Israel is using in Gaza, as they voice frustration with Israel."

Even if Ukraine was getting a couple wings of F-16s right of the bat, they aren't wonder weapons. So don't get your hopes up. Ukraine will compel Russia to be a bit more cautious in using aircraft. And Ukraine will have occasional offensive opportunities. But not a silver bullet.

Sad: "Once more, the Russian GLONASS is in trouble. The problem is a familiar one, too many GLONASS satellites are ending their service lives, usually seven years, and Roscosmos, the Russian space agency, does not have the money to replace all of the GLONASS satellites." But we need good INS.

China's GPS: "China has a long-range plan for Beidou that includes adding new features and somehow achieving market dominance by 2040. China likes to announce long range goals like this, then quietly forget about it when the promised future never arrives." But experts wrongly swoon over their planning.

New car smell stinks: "Chinese military corruption is so bad that China is presently incapable of invading Taiwan. President Xi made the appalling discovery last year that China’s navy and air force were so bereft of spare parts as to be mission incapable, and particularly so for several months of constant combat."

Keep out: "The Eastern Shield will cover Poland's border with Belarus and its border with Russia's Kaliningrad Oblast (on the Baltic Sea)." It's a modern wall to stop weaponized migrants and a quick "take and talk" Russian offensive. Good. As long as it doesn't hinder a NATO invasion of Kaliningrad.

If the traditional parties addressed voter worries, the voters wouldn't have sought alternatives: "Far-right parties rattled the traditional powers in the European Union and made major gains in parliamentary elections Sunday, dealing an especially humiliating defeat to ... Macron." Macron? LOL.

Things in Iran should mysteriously blow up: "Yemen's Houthi damaged two commercial vessels in missile attacks in the Gulf of Aden in the last 24 hours as part of the militia group's ongoing campaign against international ocean shipping, U.S. Central Command (CENTCOM) said on Sunday."

Huh: "[A half dozen Israeli reservists say] Biden’s diplomacy is actually dragging out the Gaza war he is pressing Israel to bring to an end. By restraining Israel, they said, Biden is preventing the Jewish state from defeating or deterring its genocidal enemies." I called that one. 

Yikes: "US and Canadian officials are investigating after a 689-foot ship collided with an underwater object and began taking on water in Lake Superior, the US Coast Guard says."

The U.S. remains on a "break" in its relationship with Turkey and is used to it. I concur. Actively "repairing" relations with Turkey under Erdogan means offering concessions to his Islamist-leaning rule and all that flows from it. Let's wait for the Turks to give us reason to restore our relationship.

Is Islamist terrorism "noise" building up to to major attacks in the West?

Is American naval power on a permanent downward slide? Well, turning that around has a major problem. Losing naval superiority would be very bad for America.

I don't like making a big deal of European Union elections. Talking about how important the results are falls into the EU plan of making the EU important. A more powerful EU with more power for the right will eventually be an all-powerful EU under the left. The proto-imperial EU never wastes a crisis.

Flash Point: South China Sea: "The June 1–June 10 war-fighting exercise began with an air assault on mock enemy forces to allow the deployment of U.S. and Filipino soldiers who secured an area, which served as a staging ground before a major offensive."

Myanmar: "Many of the army generals were surprised at how suddenly and quickly the troops in the north lost their will to fight and either deserted or joined the rebels. These attitudes spread quickly." I hope this will happen to Russia's army. And before our aid resumed, some small worry it could happen to Ukraine's.

Goodlife: "The island nation of Cyprus in the eastern Mediterranean has, for Russia, been useful as a wretched hive of scum and villainy where local politicians and businesses, especially banks, make a lot of money by allowing Russia to do whatever it wants." Cyprus  backs Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Defeating Daniel Ortega in the 1980s wasn't enough. Communists always need a stake through the heart to make sure.

Oh, I heard the French Mirage-2000 planes going to Ukraine will be able to fire Scalp cruise missiles. That's a good capability for the small number. How long will it take to get them in operation?

A different kind of human wave assault: "Finnish authorities fear the peace and quiet of places like Hoilola could soon be shattered by the arrival of large numbers of asylum seekers - part of what Helsinki sees as a 'hybrid war' being waged by Russia against the West."

No: "American aircraft carriers persevered over the challenge of Imperial Japan’s Kamikaze attacks, Soviet bomber long-range anti-ship cruise missiles, and will likely again over China’s anti-ship ballistic missiles." Our carriers never faced Soviet or Chinese threats. Our one success is 80 years old. This is key.

Defeating a PLA invasion of Taiwan "hinges on quickly building and deploying thousands of new drones that would swarm the Taiwan Strait and keep China’s military busy until more help can arrive, according to the top U.S. military official in the Pacific." Note that drones are to buy time--not be the silver bullet.

Is America losing the Arab world over Gaza? I have my doubts. After 8 months the "street" is less noisy than our college campuses. Given time after major operations end, sympathy will wane. If I'm wrong what are we to do? "Free" Palestine from the river to the sea? Is gaining genocidal "friends" really our goal?

Getting the theory right on what defeating China in a war over Taiwan means. Lots of thoughts and theories. But no mention of driving the invaders into the sea, as I explored in Military Review.

Coping with the birth rate collapse. I've long suspected Europe will seek a solution in clones; Asia in robots; and America in immigration. With some overlap, so no solution is pure. Maybe medical science will extend productive life significantly, buying time. Or maybe birth rates will recover.

Ukraine seems to have damaged one of Russia's few Su-57, where it and other aircraft almost always "sit in the open without any sort of shelter, let alone hardened ones." Thank God we wouldn't be penny wise and pound foolish like that with our planes out in the western Pacific, right? Tip to Instapundit.

Oh, please: "Why is President Biden still treating Iran as if it were our friend or ally? His actions — such as honoring Ebrahim Raisi, ... lobbying [Europeans] not to censure Iran at the [IAEA], and ignoring Iran’s steady march to nuclear weapons — make no sense." Of course it makes sense. Via Instapundit.

Good: "The U.S. has added three more companies to a list that bars imports from firms allegedly involved with Uyghur forced labor in China, according to a U.S. government notice posted online on Tuesday."

I call BS on this one: "If the alliance is to reach its century mark, the transatlantic partners must shift much of the responsibility of continental security to Europeans themselves. " Shifting NATO to Europe doesn't "save" NATO--it just gives Europe to the EU, even if it takes 25 years.

Being fourth on our to-do list saves them: "Around 20 North Korean troops briefly crossed into the southern portion of the Demilitarized Zone over the weekend, prompting South Korean forces to warn the intruders by firing shots and using loudspeakers[.]" But if South Korea and Japan make their own list ...

It's been closed for more than two months: "The Port of Baltimore’s shipping channel, in its entirety, is open for business as of Monday evening." Imagine our problems during war with multiple ports shut down for months. We'd go faster during a war, right?

Congress may demand the Pentagon get supplies through to our forces in the western Pacific over Chinese efforts to disrupt the supply lines.

Good: "The United States will send Ukraine another Patriot missile system[.]" I don't know what "system" means. A single launcher? A battery? I suspect the latter, but I don't know.

Russian manpower shortages. I'm not sure that the description of soldier unrest is significant. Is it enough to affect units? And if Ukraine can't attack on a large scale to exploit shaken units, it might not matter unless unrest escalates to army-level collapse.

FFS, we can even ef up a proven design from abroad: "[A GAO report] into the failings of the US Navy’s Constellation-class frigate programme, detailing incomplete designs and the build of the first-in-class being 'at a standstill', indicate concerning similarities with the ill-fated Littoral Combat Ship (LCS)."

Huh: "Six Russian nationals suspected to have terror ties to ISIS have been arrested in a coordinated sting operation spanning Los Angeles, New York and Philadelphia, The Post can exclusively reveal." Our mythical over-the-horizon capabilities didn't stop them "over there." A "Russian" named "Mohammad." 

Chutzpah with Chinese characters: "China's defence ministry on Tuesday warned the Netherlands to restrain actions of its naval and air forces after the Netherlands' defence ministry said Chinese fighter jets approached a Dutch ship unsafely in the East China Sea.

Accepting defeat: "Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan said on Wednesday that a peace treaty with Azerbaijan was close to completion but that his country would not accept Baku's demands that it change its constitution."

Welcome wagon: "The U.S. Navy has deployed warships and aircraft to track a Russian naval flotilla after the Russian vessels sailed less than 30 miles off South Florida’s coast on Tuesday[.]" But we won't maneuver unsafely around them. 

Yeah: "The recent arrest of Admiral Robert Burke on corruption charges is an indication of the decline in the quality and integrity of our general and flag officers (GFOs) ... Too many reached that rank by being skilled bureaucrats, not making enemies, and keeping superiors happy." We have a problem.

The European so-called Parliament is "susceptible to the pressure of lobbyists and well-organised vested interests. As a result, even the most well-meaning politicians, once they get to Brussels, tend to get sucked into its bubble." Like I've said, the EU wins just by playing their rigged game. Populists will be absorbed.

Chest-beating Putin's flinging of nuclear poo has predictable consequences: " In a rare reference to the Western nuclear arsenal, NATO chief Jens Stoltenberg on Wednesday highlighted the alliance's efforts to adapt its capabilities to current security threats, taking note of Russia latest nuclear rhetoric and drills."

Germany prepares for a larger and longer war by getting more recruits: "'The new model includes basic military service of six months with an option for additional voluntary military service of up to an additional 17 months,' the document said."

The U.S. widened sanctions against Russia: "Wednesday’s package targeted Chinese companies which help Russia pursue its war in Ukraine and raised the stakes for foreign financial institutions which work with sanctioned Russian entities." Move and counter-move. 

Speed bump removed: "NATO defense ministers gathered Thursday hoping to agree on a new plan to provide long-term security assistance and military training to Ukraine amid Russia’s full-scale invasion, after Hungary promised not to veto the proposal as long as it’s not forced to take part."

Start now, the job is big and Western planes will arrive slowly: "Ukrainian forces may be conducting an effort aimed at degrading Russian air defenses, which, if successful, could enable Ukraine to more effectively leverage manned fixed-wing airpower in the long run."

As we watch the Houthi interdict Red Sea shipping with Iranian weapons and help (via Instapundit), remember that this has long been an objective of mullah-run Iran. 

Israel-approved: "Israel has ordered another 25 F-35 fighters, which will give Israel three F-35I squadrons. ... The radars and electronic countermeasures provide the pilot with an integrated view of the surrounding air space. This degree of situational awareness gives the pilot an enormous advantage in combat[.]"

Russian soldiers go to Ukraine to die for Putin. Western intelligence agencies should be all over social media available to Russians praising each and every Russian soldier that dies in Ukraine as a hero lifting the glory of Putin.

We'll soon find out if it works: "Russia has moved one of its S-500 air defense systems, the most advanced it has, to the occupied Crimean Peninsula to protect the Kerch Bridge, Ukraine’s spy boss said Wednesday."

That makes more sense: "A ship that took on water in Lake Superior likely had a stress fracture in its hull, the U.S. Coast Guard said Tuesday, backing off an initial report that the freighter had struck something below the surface last weekend." 

Thanks Russia, but you don't have to go to all this effort. We're willing to sink your ships off your coast: "The U.S. Navy has deployed warships and aircraft to track a Russian naval flotilla after the Russian vessels sailed less than 30 miles off South Florida’s coast on Tuesday" We're thoughtful that way.

The flow continues: "A new wave of Euro-Atlantic armaments are due to flow into the Ukraine’s Armed Forces inventory in the coming weeks and months."

Not everything sucks in Navy shipbuilding. Well, La De-frickin' Da. I'm not soothed. From "Don't give up the ship. Fight her 'til she sinks." to "Don't commission the ship. Change her 'til she's too expensive."

Tar. Feathers: "Aside from a few forward locales, the United States does not invest in robust shelters for its combat aircraft, which is increasingly looking like a stark vulnerability." Are planes are hard to shoot down. It's far easier to see them--and destroy them--on the ground.

And yet when jihadi terrorists kill us at home in large numbers, we'll act all surprised and establish a commission to tell us how the terrorists got into America. We'll probably be told that our border is super secure because only 0.0002% of all the illegals who entered America in the last 3+ years were terrorists.

Canada blames "climate change," but whatever: "Canada looks on track to meet NATO’s military spending guideline by the end of the decade, ... , notably by boosting investment in the Arctic near its shared border with Russia as the region warms quickly because of climate change."

Happy 249th birthday, U.S. Army! "On June 14, 1775, 249 years ago, the Second Continental Congress founded a united army to bring the 13 colonies together in the fight for independence from Great Britain. The U.S. Army was officially born." I know what present I want!

Rather than deep strike missions as I guessed, the French-madeMirage-2000 might specialize in air defense both protecting Ukraine's new Swedish AWACS and exploiting their information.

Spread out the responsibility: "The U.S. and its allies will agree this week to a plan to put NATO in charge of efforts to arm and train the Ukrainian military, marking a shift away from what so far has been an American-led endeavor."

The length of time it is taking to get F-16s in Ukrainian hands is near-criminal. We could have accelerated this process. 

Oh: "[The] Bharatiya Janata Party, is now in decline, reinforcing the theory that the fifth-largest economy in the world is far too diverse for any single political force to dominate. India will now be bogged down by internal political and economic issues that will limit its ability to project geopolitical influence."

The Marines send their replacement for the AAV7 out to exercise: "The U.S. Marine Corps used their new ACV (Amphibious Combat Vehicle) in an overseas training operation in the Philippines."

Blowback: "Russian threats against NATO have forced NATO to become more united and ready for war.  ... [The collapse of the USSR] led many nations to ... reduce their military spending and demobilize many of their troops. The Russian invasion of Ukraine changed all that ... " Strategery.

I'm skeptical: "NATO countries have 'comfortably exceeded' a target of placing 300,000 troops on high-readiness as the alliance grapples with the threat from Russia, a senior alliance official said Thursday." How many are combat brigades? Past commitments relied on sailors for the big number.

Demonizing Saudi Arabia is leaving a mark: "The expiration of the petrodollar agreement represents a significant shift in global power dynamics. ... the global financial order is entering a new era. The U.S. dollar’s dominance is no longer guaranteed." Shocking. This seems like a big deal. Tip to Instapundit.

Resisting Russia risks nuclear war? So Russia might nuke us for helping Ukraine fight Russia's unjustified invasion? I say if Russia is willing to start a nuclear war over that, what makes anyone think we could deter Russia from using nukes if Putin invades and directly fights NATO next? Let the Wookie win ... 

More Europeans are rejecting the far-left/Islamist, anti-Semitic alliance. That's not "far right". That's a survival instinct finally kicking in. 

Even with a legal ruling on Manila's side, Peking has the PLA: "The Philippines has asked a United Nations body to formally recognize the extent of its undersea continental seabed in the South China Sea, where it would have the exclusive right to exploit resources[.]"

Potemkin Putin bravado: "[Ukraine's] foreign ministry said: 'It is absurd for Putin, who planned, prepared and executed, together with his accomplices, the largest armed aggression in Europe since World War Two, to present himself as a peacemaker.'" Russia's big demands lead me to think they are weakening. 

Is Germany the sick man of Europe? "It is now little more than a 'developing country'. Its stock market is a 'junk shop' selling old tat. And its reputation as a place to do business has 'never been so bad’.'" I used to soothe myself that politicians need a long time to wreck a country. Tip to Instapundit.

NATO needs a more powerful Europe? Hard pass. NATO needs more powerful European states. Don't confuse unified political Europe with Geographic Europe of sovereign states. A more powerful political Europe will destroy NATO--which is bad for America and Europeans.

Jihadis, Wagner, and decline at the corner of No and Where.

The Marine armed robot dog.

In a dangerous world, replacing our aging Minutman III ICBMS is vital.

The idea that everything is going according to Hamas' plan is nonsense. Nobody plans to get their asses kicked. Hamas hoped to crush Israel by successfully brutalizing Israelis and inspiring the world to join them in destroying Israel. There's a history of Westerners saying fighting jihadis is counterproductive.

Asian countries may have to adopt the advice to "never start a land war in Asia."

Our new federal holiday, Juneteenth, is on June 19th. It was politically motivated. But Republicans should embrace it. Free, Black, Union soldiers under a Republican president marched into Texas to inform Black slaves that they were free citizens because their Confederate Democrat masters were defeated? No-brainer.

With Ukraine there with its friends, the main value of the recent peace summit in Switzerland is to reject Putin's false claim that Russia--the invader!--is the side interested in peace while Ukraine stands in the way.

People claimed the Iraq War was "breaking" the U.S. Army when it was enduring 1,000 KIA in a calendar year? Yet Russia's army in this war could be losing that many soldiers every week--for over two years now--and is doing just fine? How is that army not fragile? Yet how would we know?

Good grief, they weren't the first things we attacked? "CENTCOM said the US military destroyed seven radars in Houthi-controlled areas of Yemen, which had allowed 'Houthis to target maritime vessels and endanger commercial shipping.'" We spend too much time sending messages rather than destruction. 

Sad statistics: "Mohanad el-Balal is one of many Sudanese civilians doing everything they can to ward off a devastating famine – and there is one man whose photograph he will never forget." But until they are crowned Queen of the Victim Prom, they'll get no pier, no outrage, and no help for their tragedy.

Given the state of the sainted international community, I'm shocked it's that many: "Nearly 80 countries called Sunday for the 'territorial integrity' of Ukraine to be the basis for any peace agreement to end Russia’s two-year war[.]" Although Ukrainians have to decide to suffer to achieve that goal.

Saturday, June 15, 2024

Perhaps Europeans Aren't Ready for Democracy

Are European youth losing faith in democracy? Hard to say because the Definitions Section is oddly missing.

Is democracy in Europe losing support? 

Data from numerous surveys show that consistent support for democracy across Europe is already quite low. And if demography is destiny, it looks like public support for democracy will continue to fall, with Europe possibly reaching an inflection point where nondemocratic forms of government not only take root but flourish.

How do we know this?

According to the Open Society Foundation’s 2023 global poll, which Comms Hub advised on and analyzed in Europe, only 38 percent of Germans aged 18 and up are consistent supporters of democracy. In France, the number stands at a paltry 27 percent, while Italy and Poland clock in at less than 45 percent.

Will the youth view remain that way as they age? That's the worry:

Demography need not be destiny, but without a greater understanding of the problem, democratic decline is a very probable outcome. The question is, what can be done to bolster support for democracy among Europe’s youth before it’s too late?

Oddly, in a story about European demographics, there is no mention of the disproportionate share of Moslem immigrants of both the legal and illegal kind in Europe. Maybe a closer look at the demographics would be revealing.

I mean, if you want to discuss attitudes of the younger demographic, maybe the attitudes of people without the social norms of rule-of-law democracy would be important to note. Which also might explain at least some of the rise of anti-democratic opinions of native Europeans who see elected leaders refusing to discuss this aspect of demographics. And who try to shame and vilify those native Europeans for even worrying about the adverse effects of that trend.

Or maybe demographics is a minor factor as Europeans simply slip back to autocratic norms without robust American leadership:

I had to be reminded by this author that our long period of influence in Europe during the Cold War had a role in making Europe truly democratic:

It is easy to forget--and this was a useful reminder to me--that Europe with its autocracies and monarchies was not fully part of a free West (although obviously part of the Western tradition) until we rebuilt Western Europe in that template after World War II. And NATO expansion after defeating the Soviet Union was more explicit in demanding democracy and rule of law for new members.

Of course, since I wrote that Russia invaded Ukraine and American leadership has revived. But Europeans of the EU variety still fret about American leadership. 

Of course they do. Their roots are in nondemocratic norms.

NOTE: The image was made from DALL-E. 

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Friday, June 14, 2024

Force Resign 2030

I remain very worried about Marine transformation. It is too broad and even in the Pacific theater where it could make sense fails on its own justifications. Worse, it didn't have to happen to get the needed capabilities.


Force Design 2030: 

How did the United States Marine Corps transform itself from the world’s premier expeditionary force-in-readiness to a poor parody of the French Maginot Line in just four years?

Ruining the Marine ability to fight ashore against tough opponents is a high price to pay for a marginal anti-ship gain:

The Marines have essentially destroyed the combined arms capability of the operating forces to stand up 14 Naval Strike Missile (NSM) batteries and 3 Tomahawk Land Attack Missile Batteries.  The Marines intend to only keep 3 NSM batteries permanently forward deployed, while the sole purpose of the other 11 batteries is to serve a rotational pool of manpower and equipment. The Corps’ contribution to the other services’ anti-ship capabilities is minimal and duplicative. Worse, the other services are all investing in long-range, hypersonic missiles while the Marines are largely buying short-range, subsonic missiles that will be obsolete in the near future, if not already. The end result is that Marines will be marginalized, at best, on far flung island with ineffective missiles.

And that assumes the detachments work.

I've been worried about the weak anti-ship capabilities--on the assumption for argument's sake that killing land capabilities is a price we should pay to help the Navy.

The authors slam the logistics of the situation. And rightly so on operating concept and means. As I recently observed:

I have many worries about the Marine plans. 

In many ways the Marines could be setting the stage for a fight like the Guadalcanal campaign of World War II (in a Land Warfare Paper) when the Japanese expended a huge amount of men and ships to sustain a garrison on Guadalcanal.

The Marines could well be isolated bait that draws in the Navy to try to rescue them while the Chinese use their missiles and planes to hammer the would-be rescuers who don't want to leave any man behind. 

Taking on the Japanese 1942 role doesn't seem wise.

Or maybe the Navy prudently but regrettably lets the Marines wither on the vine the way the Navy had to let the defenders of Bataan be marched off the the deadly prison camps in 1942.

I think the authors' argument about holding islands is the weakest--if true--because clearly the Marine concept doesn't intend their anti-ship detachments to hold their ground. They are supposed to shoot and scoot, however weak those two capabilities are.

The Marine Corps is officially dismissing and ridiculing criticism of their transformation. But nothing said or done so far reduces my worries. 

Tragically, we had an alternative path using the Navy Expeditionary Combat Command that would have ended this risky scheme before it got started. 

UPDATE: Have no doubt, the Marines have devastated those land warfare capabilities:

The United States Marine Corps is no longer capable of effectively conducting combat operations across the spectrum of conflict.

And let me repeat that even if transforming Marine units in the western Pacific to sink PLAN ships is the correct move, why "transform" the entire Marine Corps?

[Oops, I accidentally incorporated this update into the post, thinking it was scheduled rather than not already posted.] 

UPDATE: Huh:

One of the mysteries of the Marine Corps’ decision to concentrate on an anti-ship mission in the South China Sea is whether or not the joint force combatant commander responsible for the region even wanted this Marine Corps contribution. The current Indo-Pacific commander has not yet weighed in on the subject. A recent war game conducted by the Center for Strategic and International Studies found the Stand-in Force concept to be duplicative and less effective than capabilities already possessed by other services and unable to contribute “heavily” in most scenarios. 

But other than that, forward ... march!

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Thursday, June 13, 2024

The AFRICOM Queen Works!

United States Navy expeditionary sea base vessels provide AFRICOM with an asset to increase American partnerships in Africa based on whatever the country needs.


USS Hershel "Woody" Williams in action: 

one of the few U.S. military vessels to almost continually transit African waters, as part of collective U.S. government efforts to build and sustain partnerships in a region America considers vital to its national security interests. ...

The crew’s experiences during a recent exercise underscored the challenges the Woody Williams faces as one of the few U.S. military vessels to almost continually transit African waters, as part of collective U.S. government efforts to build and sustain partnerships in a region America considers vital to its national security interests.

International terrorism, drug smuggling, Chinese interest in building an Atlantic naval port and a growing Russian military presence all come into play in this region.

The sailors aboard the only Navy ship assigned to the U.S. Africa Command area of responsibility know that their role is unlike many others in the service.

“We’re pretty much a floating embassy,” said Petty Officer 3rd Class Gabriel Gajda, a yeoman assigned to the ship. “We go to countries almost no one goes to.”

It's a whole-of-government effort on one hull. Do read it all. 

I like to flatter myself that I prodded this Navy capability with this proposal in Military Review for the Army to deploy such a ship using modularized auxiliary cruisers.

Because the need for this type of ship to engage African countries across a broad spectrum of activities is greater in an age of great power competition when resources are diverted to other theaters. 

But the Navy has stepped up to provide the capability. Assuming one ship is enough. 

As an aside, I'd pay good money to have one of this class christened The AFRICOM Queen. But my clever names  never  get adopted.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Wednesday, June 12, 2024

What Part of Opposing Enemies and Supporting Allies is Bad?

Withdrawing from the Iran deal wasn't enabling an ally to drag us into a war. It was ending a gift to mullah-run Iran to facilitate its drive to acquire nuclear weapons. It was an attempt to prevent an enemy ("Death to America!") from starting an even more destructive war.

This Geopolitical Monitor analysis is bizarre to me:

A cardinal tenet of realpolitik advises against allowing a minor ally to precipitate a major conflict. Presently, from the perspective of the US security framework, we are observing a disintegration at the very core of what might be termed the emergent US order on a macro scale. ...

Foremost among these was Washington’s unilateral exit from the nuclear accord with Iran, a move that underscored a willingness to forsake treaty commitments — even at the cost of alienating European allies — in favor of aligning with Tel Aviv’s stance.

First off, what treaty commitment is the author talking about? The Iran nuclear deal was not a treaty--by State Department design. Obama didn't want it to be a treaty because it could not have passed the Senate super majority requirement. The deal was just a document that a number of parties picked up off a desk and took home!

The author has a point about not letting a minor ally drag us into war. I've noted that flaw in the Obama era "leading from behind" fad. There's a reason so many of our allies lack sufficient ammunition now. Our plan after World War II was to hobble their ability to wage war on their own but resupply them if we face a common enemy. And allies were happy to offload the cost on America. 

Until now. America's inability to live up to that ammunition deal has killed it. We need allied production.

But tying that reality of alliance management to ending the absolutely horrible Iran nuclear deal is nuts. The deal was based on Iranian and Western lies:

We're willing to pretend that Iran isn't even seeking nuclear weapons. Just in time for the Monday "deadline" for a final agreement.

Which means we won't have leverage to complain that the mullahs are seeking nuclear weapons contrary to an agreement.

And which also means that Iran can portray themselves as an innocent victim of Western aggression that suffered under sanctions for no good reason other than to starve poor Moslem children.

Once we start pretending, what's the limit? I'm sure that we will then pretend the deal worked right up until Iran tests a nuclear weapon (perhaps first in North Korea) and announces that it has already deployed a half dozen weapons of the same design.

And we'll pretend Iran's nuclear status really doesn't matter.

And the deal was aided by media lies.

Hell, the whole point of the deal was to "balance" the Middle East with a strengthened--now with moderation!--Iran on once side and the Gulf Arabs on the other. Ah, Smart Diplomacy!®

The persistent love of Obama and Biden for mullah-run Iran is the most bizarre aspect of this bizarre analysis.

And the two other reasons the author gives to bolster his claim that America is forfeiting its leadership in the Middle East are the American defeat in Afghanistan and America's support for Israel.

Sure, needlessly losing the Afghanistan war hurt us. It may have emboldened Iran and its little pet pyschos like Hamas and the Houthi.

But does supporting Israel against Iran's Hamas and Houthi proxies really hurt American influence?

Doesn't backing an ally despite international and domestic pressure make Arab autocrats a little more confident in American support? Confidence that the author says defeat in Afghanistan shook, remember.

I say America pretends Iran isn't waging war on America and that sucking up to Iran hurts confidence in American support.

Doesn't the lack of a reaction in the Arab "street" to support Hamas show that Israel isn't the real regional problem? I mean, Arab states had to settle for exciting America's street:

Observers stunned at the campus-based protest movement on behalf of Hamas have come to learn that this protest movement is far from spontaneous, but has in fact been lavishly financed and developed for years by leading left-wing philanthropies along with Arab states in the Middle East.

Doesn't all this make Arab cooperation with America to face their historic and now aggressive Iranian enemy more rather than less likely?

Geopolitical Monitor often seems just bizarre to me.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Tuesday, June 11, 2024

Significant Air Force Market Share Shrinkage

It was futile for the Air Force to cling to owning the close air support mission even as it resisted providing it to ground forces. And as the Air Force waged that budget battle, it let the Space Force put a glass ceiling over the Air Force.

Artillery and aircraft aren't obsolete. But: 

In many respects surveillance and attack quadcopters have replaced artillery and air strikes because the quadcopters can attack immediately when they find a target.

That's long been my view about the fate of the Air Force:

We need a space service. There are rumors of machines that could take the Air Force into space. But if the Air Force blows its opportunity to aim high, another perhaps independent space service will eventually be created. And the ground forces will take the missions the Air Force blindly insists on trying to keep when technology is putting many of those missions in equipment that fits in rucksacks.

There is an expanding market in the air and the space above it, and a shrinking market near the ground. The Air Force has long resisted the ground support missions in favor of strategic missions. Now the Air Force is recanting?

The Air Force is foolish to fight for a disappearing market for their ground support services.

Aim high, Air Force. That's your future. And we need you there, dominating the new high ground.

And about the big guns for that matter. As RUSI notes:

UAVs may redistribute the balance of missions assigned to different systems, but they do not eliminate the requirement for traditional artillery.

I guess it isn't really fair to suggest the Air Force ignored space. But rather than aim high to embrace space like I urged them to do nearly two decades ago, the Air Force is seeing technology eliminate their close air support role down low--which it didn't like to do anyway--even as the Air Force lost space in the new high ground to that separate Space Force that I warned them about, too.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Monday, June 10, 2024

The Winter War of 2022 Tries to "Understand" Russia

I really don't get the impulse of some conservatives to validate Russia's demand to give them free people to create a buffer zone. No more than I understood the zeal of liberals in the Cold War to "understand" the Soviet Union and its conquests up to the Elbe River in Europe.

Russia invaded Ukraine to push their western border further west as it has done in the past. Russia has been attacking and gaining ground slowly. But American military aid has resumed:

While Russia is mounting attacks at several points along the front line, “we have chances to change the situation in our favor,” Ukrainian armed forces Commander-in-Chief Oleksandr Syrskyi said Wednesday on Telegram.

Some understand Russia's objective. Recognizing that Russian "line in the steppe" gives people freed from Soviet control to Russia: 

[The] West erred disastrously in extending delusions of NATO membership to a country whose borders reach within a few hundred miles of Moscow, and that Russia—not just Putin—was left with little choice but to draw a line in the steppe.

That phrase about a line in the steppe implies that Russia is finally stopping aggression. And saying Zelensky's term of office has expired without noting that Ukraine's constitution makes that perfectly legal when it is invaded is meant to imply Ukraine is no better than Russia. So no big deal if it falls to Russia.

Shame on that author.

And NATO didn't conquer those former vassals of the USSR. They asked to join. Because they understand what it is like to be controlled by the thugs in Moscow. Once freed of that control, they sought to make sure it wouldn't happen again. 

Ukraine is resisting Putin's effort to march west, but even now after two years of heavy casualties Russia is seeking Ukraine's surrender--even if it is just a little bit for now--and drive a wedge between the West and Ukraine by portraying Ukraine as uninterested in "peace". The territory gained and that wedge would make the next round of conquest easier.

Face it, it is futile to expect Russia to be satisfied with even all of Ukraine as a buffer. Russia accepts no limits to their buffer zone. Hell, Russia will claim it has little choice but to keep redrawing its line further west.

And if some here want to "understand" Russia's desire to control countries on their western border--wherever Russia draws it--because of a history of invasions from the west, why can't these Americans understand why America needs a buffer in Europe? And with Russia the biggest threat, why it must be kept as far east as possible?

And consider that despite invasions of Russia from the west, the most lasting conquest came from the east when the Mongols ruled Russia for centuries. And the biggest threat to Russia's territorial integrity comes from China--not NATO. No matter how much Russia has tried to disguise it, Russia has been appeasing China in an effort to buy time. But it's getting worse for Russia.

Invading Ukraine made it worse rather than being the signal victory allowing Russia to pivot east. 

I've long wanted to welcome a sane Russia into the West. I thought they were preparing to at least downgrade NATO as the primary threat. But no, they decided we're their enemy. And demonstrate they are far from sane. 

Feeding Ukraine to Russia--even if you do it in stages to dull your conscience--is no way to protect America.

UPDATE (Monday): If so, Russia doesn't think they've yet missed their opportunity:

Ukraine's military says there are clear signs that Russian forces are getting ready for a major push in the east, where a stalemate continues despite months-long heavy fighting and intensive daily shelling by Moscow's troops.

In unrelated news, Russia is made for war and its "autocratic leaders always position their aggression as defense, and the Russian people invariably go along with it." If so, no buffer will satisfy Russia's so-called security worries.

UPDATE (Friday): The Russians lie. And they invade for no reason. Don't believe Russian lies about their unprovoked and illegal invasion of Ukraine:

Western media continues to report that Russian President Vladimir Putin is interested in a negotiated ceasefire in Ukraine, although Kremlin rhetoric and Russian military actions illustrate that Putin remains uninterested in meaningful negotiations and any settlement that would prevent him from pursuing the destruction of an independent Ukrainian state.
Help Ukraine send body bags back to Russia. That's the only way to achieve anything even remotely similar to "peace."

NOTE: ISW updates continue here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Sunday, June 09, 2024

Weekend Data Dump

The idea that Israel is committing genocide is wrong and offensive. In 8 months of war, Gazan casualties are largely the legal responsibility of Hamas. As for Hamas, consider the Israeli casualties if Hamas had been able to rampage inside Israel for 8 months at the rate of October 7, 2023: 288,000.

Perhaps we've been hasty, comrades: "North Korea said on Sunday it will stop sending trash-filled balloons into South Korea, after the democratic nation pledged to take “unbearable” steps in retaliation." North Korea demanded the end of South Korean civilian propaganda balloons sent north.

The burden of defense should fall on them, too, IMO: "Dozens of ultra-Orthodox protesters blocked roads in Jerusalem on Sunday as Israel's Supreme Court heard arguments in a landmark case challenging a controversial system of exemptions from military service granted to the religious community."

To be fair, he has experience in mayhem and murder at home and abroad: "Former Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad registered as a candidate on Sunday for the upcoming election to the office he held between 2005 and 2013, Iranian media reported."

I flew to and from military training, adding just one day at either end. So I don't get this at all: "sending [Ukrainian] personnel to train in NATO states ... increases the delay in deploying soldiers as Ukraine must transport these personnel to and from NATO states."

Oh? "Another Russian milblogger claimed that Russian forces are employing a new 'carousel' tactic during raids on Urozhaine [that] allows Russian tanks to continuously fire on Ukrainian forces both at a standstill and while maneuvering." LOL!

Oh: "A former Navy vice chief of naval operations faces up to 30 years in prison after he was arrested Friday along with two business executives on criminal charges involving a U.S. government contract bribery scheme while in uniform, according to the Justice Department." Another substitute for victory.

Of course the EU is in favor: "The European Union is considering setting up its own air defense shield after bloc leaders threw their support behind a Greek-Polish initiative to that effect this week." This is in NATO's lane.

That will help sink every Russian ship and blockade their ports: "Sweden plans to acquire anti-aircraft guns for its fast-assault boats to counter drones and helicopters, as officials have warned that the Baltic Sea could become a flashpoint with Russia."

China tries to drive the Philippines away from territory China illegally claims with coast guard water cannons: "But were that aggression to result in the death of a Filipino citizen, Marcos said, it would be 'very, very close to what we define as an act of war.'" China is playing with fire.

AFRICOM: "Over the past two weeks, roughly 8,100 military forces from nearly three dozen countries maneuvered throughout Tunisia, Ghana, Senegal and Morocco as part of the war games held this year as militaries confront new challenges in increasingly volatile regions."

Strategpage reviews the Black Sea campaign and says the Kerch Strait bridge is already unusable to trains or heavy traffic. I did not know that. Without Western recon and targeting, Ukraine couldn't have achieved this.

Update on the Hamas War: "There is growing dissatisfaction in the West and the Middle East with the Palestinian leadership failures and rampant corruption." This would explain why Israel has gotten more time than I expected to attack. And why only the Western campus/communist "street" has exploded.

The B-21 is torn between "a new Air Force war-fighting concept called 'pulsed airpower' — concentrating airpower at certain times and places to set up windows of opportunity for the other airpower. ... [versus] ... past Air Force goals of creating air dominance and air superiority in combat zones."

Defense chief Austin said we are moving beyond a hub-and-spoke model in Asia to "a set of overlapping and complementary initiatives and institutions propelled by a shared vision and a shared sense of mutual obligation." Still hub and spoke. But the spokes to America are now mini-hubs--but not an Asian NATO.

I missed this news from over a year ago: "13[th Dutch] Light Armoured Brigade completes integration between Dutch combat brigades and German divisions[.]" I did not know the goal was complete integration of brigades.

All for one and nukes for all: "The Royal Netherlands Air Force (RNLAF) announced that the F-35A will fully take over the Dutch nuclear role tomorrow, June 1 ... its weapons are provided under a NATO nuclear sharing agreement arrangement."

Given that a virus could be weaponized to strike us at home, it should matter that the "scientific" response to the Covid-19 Wuhan Flu for the public might as well have been wearing garlands of garlic around our necks, pouring salt across doorways, and chanting appeals to St. Fauci. We have to do better than that. 

About that solid Iran-China alliance: "China held its stance on three disputed islands in the Gulf on Monday despite Tehran's anger at Beijing for describing the Iran-controlled islands as a matter to be resolved with the United Arab Emirates." Iran took them 50 years ago.

I guess Russia is at war with NATO: "Poland has arrested 18 people on allegations of pursuing hostile activities or planning sabotage on behalf of Russia and Belarus, including plans to assassinate Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the interior minister said Monday."

We really need to end America's Ten Year Medium Term Rule on spending to defeat national security threats. 

Interesting: "Central Asian states gradually shaking Moscow’s control and forging new ties with the West while Russia distracted in Ukraine[.]" I assumed China would exploit that. Is that move by Central Asian states a major opportunity for the West to flip Russia?

Some controversy--fake?--about Dutch plans to build submarines capable of carrying American Tomahawk cruise missiles.

Apparently destroying Hamas with military action should have been eschewed in favor of letting Hamas defeat itself. I love fantasy tales! The author says it is a "smarter strategy" but it's just Smart Diplomacy.®

Oh, please: "It’s taken more than half a year, but, finally, President Joe Biden has publicly unveiled an Israeli plan that could end the bloodshed in Gaza." Hamas won't stop wanting to slaughter Jews. So there is no "end" to bloodshed in Israel. This is at best Hamas "reloading" and not an "end" to bloodshed.

FFS, "climate change" is the least of our military's problems.

Hair trigger: "Philippine troops stationed on a warship grounded on a disputed South China Sea shoal held on to their weapons after Chinese coast guard boats came very close to the ship but they did not point their guns at them, military officials said on Tuesday."

The 2014 pledge was to be met this year: "The number of NATO members meeting the military alliance’s defense spending benchmark could reach 23 nations this year — an all-time high prompted by the war in Ukraine, the U.S. permanent representative to NATO said Monday."

How to earn the Air Force Cross: "An Air Force combat controller dodged bullets, artillery shells and even direct fire from enemy tanks as he coordinated U.S. firepower against an oncoming battalion of Russian and Syrian tanks and fighters in early 2018."

Good: "Italy will send a second SAMP/T air defence system to Ukraine[.]"

NATO aid: "In addition to unveiling the package in July, an estimated 32 countries are finalizing a series of bilateral agreements to support Ukraine ahead of the summit, with 13 finalized so far, according to Julianne Smith, the U.S. ambassador to NATO."

All your sea are belong to us: "A Philippine fishing vessel was traversing Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea when two Chinese Coast Guard ships fired water cannons at both sides of the boat."

Air defense: "In April Germany shipped the second truck-mounted Skynex low-altitude anti-aircraft system to Ukraine. ... Skynex is an updated version of the earlier Skyranger 30, a turret-mounted air defense gun system armed with a 30mm autocannon[.]" Are our old Vulcans sitting in desert storage? 

Turtle tanks. 

The A-10 was designed for close air support and no Air Force asset to replace it was. But the A-10 was designed for 1970s air defense environments. That's gone. The author hints at the real problem, saying "The A-10's unique features and dedicated pilots contribute to an unmatched close air support culture."

Up to 400,000 soldiers and 300,000 civilians died in the recent Tigray War: "Despite the intense human suffering, this 'forgotten' war has not garnered the international attention it desperately needs." Well of course not! It's not like anybody wants to crown those Ethiopians as the Queen of the Victim Prom!

Stereo chest beating and nuclear poo flinging.

If India's new tough stance against China means China will be more violent in its subliminal war to capture disputed territory, India had best be prepared to win any clash that occurs. Quietly accepting repeated losses to China for decades hasn't convinced China to accept the border. Let the Wookie win, eh?

India's Modi declares electoral victory despite losing its majority: "Although Modi's Bharatiya Janata (Indian People's) Party (BJP) gained the most votes, it will have to rely on its two coalition partners to form a government."

It's nice to have options: "Photos have emerged showing a U.S. Navy F/A-18E/F Super Hornet carrying what appears to be an air-launched version of the hugely versatile SM-6 missile, also known as the RIM-174." But it might just be for some testing purpose rather than being a launching option.

Russia's Baltic Sea surface fleet will have quite the gauntlet to run: "Finland is the latest Nordic country to beef up its coastal defense with the planned acquisition of over a dozen self-propelled artillery systems to protect the country’s territorial waters in the Baltic Sea."

West Berlin (East): "The Philippine military chief on Tuesday said the Chinese coast guard seized one of four food packs dropped by a plane for Filipino navy personnel at a territorial outpost that has been surrounded by Chinese vessels in the disputed waters of the South China Sea." We could help.

This seems prudent: "Threatened by Pyongyang’s burgeoning stocks and varieties of ballistic missiles and rockets, South Korea is moving forward with a key class of interceptor weaponry."

Secretary of Defense Austin visited China's ally Cambodia in an effort to pry the country away from China. It's worth the effort. Nothing will change soon. Who knows what might happen in the future?

Stuck on stupid: "Right now the American navy has none of those clever and effective Ukrainian UAVs and USVs." Remember the Ukrainians rely on expensive NATO surveillance and targeting capabilities.

War: "[Russia's] tank reserves could keep the fighting going for another two or three years. Beyond that the heavy troop losses and the fact Russia is the invader and not defending Russia itself as was the case during World War II, popular support for the war in Ukraine is falling rapidly." Putin's boasts are hollow.

The Army's proposed V-280 tilt-rotor is intended to match the Marine strategy in the Pacific of deploying sensors and missiles to small islands and coastal areas. But the Army didn't neuter itself for one mission in one part of the globe as the Marines did.

Good: "Satellite images gathered on May 27 show that China has deployed its most advanced J-20 stealth fighter jets less than 150 kilometres from the boundary with India in Sikkim." I like it when China is forced to split assets between the sea and inland.

But other than that, Russia is a fine future friend to make by throwing Ukraine under the bus: "From Czechnya to Georgia to Syria, Russia has demonstrated bellicosity, cruel targeting, torture, deportations and disappearances of civilians including children, and ferocious lust for territory and domination."

It's nice of them to practice coming all this way, but in war we'll sink them as they depart their home ports: "The U.S. has been tracking Russian warships and aircraft that are expected to arrive in the Caribbean for a military exercise in the coming weeks[.]"

I think it is stupid and only helps Hamas, but it is good--if expensive--practice: "The U.S. military hopes to reinstall a pier for ferrying food aid into Gaza later this week and have the aid moving again days after that, Pentagon spokeswoman Sabrina Singh said Wednesday."

There's no evidence government policies had any impact on containing Covid-19. CONUS isn't a sanctuary. But kinetics aren't the only weapon. We need to do better if an enemy attacks us with a virus. Because our military is affected. Via Instapundit.

Rogue 1 drone.

The Abrams. And its competition.

This writer laments: "No one is really campaigning, in this [EU parliamentary] election, on what is arguably the most critical question for Europe’s future at this point in time: how to maintain or indeed restore its role and standing in the world." The EU only cares about the power to have a foreign policy.

China continues to choke Hong Kong to death. Xi is killing the goose that laid the golden eggs. And sadly, since Hong Kongers don't joyously murder and rape, they die in darkness. Nobody will crown them Queen of the Victim Prom.

Russia provoked NATO into taking Putin's threats seriously: "The 53rd iteration of NATO’s Baltic Operations series of exercises is set to be the alliance’s largest amid the inclusion of new members and security concerns with Russia."

The Air Force is buying the Norwegian JSM to equip F-35s. 

GAO report on funding for Ukraine.

This problem will have more dire consequences in the winter: "Russian missile and drone strikes have caused significant long-term damage to Ukraine's energy grid, and Ukraine will reportedly face even greater energy constraints in summer 2024."

HALO: "An air-launched air-breathing hypersonic anti-ship cruise missile that is now in development for the U.S. Navy could also arm its ships and submarines." I'm assuming they don't fit in VLS cells and that they're too expensive for widespread use.

I mentioned I don't pay as much attention to China's space program. I should. Apollo was a mere Moon pageant. China plans Moon stations that "will form the basis of China’s Earth-moon space economic sphere and position the country as a leader in human deep space exploration activities." Tip to Instapundit.

Atlantic Council advice includes reactivating U.S. 7th Army in Germany; moving the Navy’s European headquarters in Naples to Britain; moving NATO strategic headquarters from Norfolk, Va. to Washington, D.C. or Paris; and moving Joint Force Command Brunssum from the Netherlands to Poland.

Excellent: "The Air Force is 'very close' to being able to rapidly update electronic warfare systems with fresh battlefield data in a matter of hours[.]"

Crawl, walk, run, eh? "Russia-adjacent NATO member Finland has no plans to invite U.S. or other alliance troops to be stationed in the country permanently, Finnish President Alexander Stubb said June 6."

A new American package of military assistance to Ukraine announced.

It's been a while since we had 203mm or 175mm guns (dropped for MRLS): "Russia and Ukraine both use the same heavy artillery weapon, the 2S7 Pions 203mm (eight inch) self-propelled howitzer, ... This cannon fires 103 or 110 kg shells 37.5 kilometers, or 55.5 kilometers using a rocket assisted shell."

UAV warfare: "UAV warfare is increasingly common and dominating some combat zones. Tactics and techniques are also evolving as Ukraine and Russia both experiment with new tactics, techniques, and UAV designs." I think fighter drones are the next step to stop UAVs--and then to escort them.

Modularized auxiliary cruisers can be equipped a new way: "Commercial cargo ships can carry hundreds of armed UAVs equipped with satellite communications so operators anywhere in the world can control them." The USVs need an expensive surveillance and targeting systems, of course.

I think the retired admiral needs to review his oath to uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States. He's way outside his lane. Telling citizens to shut up is no way to restore teetering public confidence in our military flag officers. But he does explain a lot about the Navy, no?

We were told we should get out of Afghanistan and stop spending money on helping our friends in Afghanistan defeat the Taliban and other jihadis. We've spent billions since retreating in 2021 that effectively props up the Taliban government. So we just switched sides. How's that working out?

As long as we don't bind our companies in red tape, they'll beat China to the Moon and beyond: "SpaceX's massive Starship rocket achieved its first ever splashdown during a test flight Thursday, in a major milestone for the prototype system that may one day send humans to Mars."

Fancy that: "the United States and Taiwan conducted unannounced and ‘unplanned’ exercises in the West Pacific during ‘routine encounters’ between the two navies in the open ocean according to a Reuters report citing unnamed sources." Stuff happens.

China is losing the chip war: "Amid intensifying competition, Biden exploited American dominance in semiconductors to gain an advantage and hold back China’s technological and economic progress."

Send the Russians to their buddies the Chinese to ef up their space program: "NASA and the Russian space agency, Roscosmos, still have not solved a long-running and worsening problem with leaks on [a Russian module that is part of] the International Space Station." Sadly, we need Russia. Tip to Instapundit.

Last week I noted the vague "attacker" in Germany. And now we know the stabbing spree in Mannhheim was by an Afghan man: "This latest violence is part of a gathering storm of Islamist stabbings, riots, and violent demonstrations engulfing the West, with Europe at the center of the maelstrom." Via Instapundit.

Somalia will strengthen jihadis to maintain the fiction of a united Somalia: "The move is the latest instance of the SFG giving priority to scuttling Ethiopia’s port deal with the de facto independent breakaway Somaliland region over the counterinsurgency fight against al Shabaab." You recall that issue.

Estimating casualties in Ukraine so far at 500,000 Russian dead and wounded--not including private military companies, like Wagner, losses; Ukraine at 200,000 dead and wounded. I have no idea if these are WAG or based on solid information.

Russia's military is a corrupt shambles. But: "The Kremlin’s chilling nuke stockpile - possibly as many as 6,000 larger strategic bombs and 10,000 battlefield tactical weapons would make Russia the top global nuclear threat." Seriously, how many work? Nukes are on an island of competence in a sea of corruption?

Five? "French President Emmanuel Macron announced that France will provide Ukraine with five Dassault Mirage 2000-5 fighter jets and will begin training Ukrainian pilots this summer."

I feel sorry for the innocent Gazans who die because Hamas terrorists use them as human shields (including by dressing like civilians which makes it hard to distinguish them) and refuse to surrender to save them. But every time I see a hate-filled pro-Hamas rally in America, I want to ship MOABs to Israel.

With an eye on Iran, no doubt: "Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) officially unveiled an air-launched version of its LORA (Long Range Artillery), a short-range ballistic missile originally developed for surface launch." I wonder if Ukraine could put something like that together.

Russia has coped with sanctions. But high defense spending is the major reason for growth: "'Longer term, you are destroying the economy,' believes Chris Weafer, founding partner of Eurasian consultancy firm Macro-Advisory. 'There is no money going into future development.'" Sanctions aren't worthless.

Strategic warfare: "Russian setbacks in Ukraine and anger at European NATO countries for supporting Ukraine have led Russia to strike back at European countries with a sabotage campaign. The Russians have paid criminal networks in Europe to carry out these attacks." Arrests make recruiting hard.

Dying for Putin: "There are increasing incidents of Russian officers shooting their own troops for not advancing against the enemy, or trying to flee when the Ukrainians attack or employ missiles or armed UAVs (Unmanned Aerial Vehicles). ... most of the details come from Russian social media."

There were heavy Gazan casualties in Israel's hostage-rescue mission. Oh well. Hamas started the war with war crimes. Hamas defends itself while committing war crimes--including using Gazan human shields. Hamas would have killed hostages if given time. Those "concerned" can urge Hamas to surrender.

Help: "National security advisor Jake Sullivan said Sunday the United States offered help with the rescue of four Israeli hostages over the weekend but did not specify how."

No more mister nice guy: "South Korea on Tuesday fully suspended the 2018 Comprehensive Military Agreement with North Korea following several days of North Korea sending trash-filled balloons across the border and jamming GPS signals."

Saturday, June 08, 2024

The FPV 9/11

Will small first-person viewer (FPV) drones be combined with the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks to create airliner-based FPV suicide drones?

To strike deeper inside Russia, Ukraine converted a small single-engine plane into a suicide drone:

A Ukrainian uncrewed aerial vehicle (UAV) that hit Russia's Tatarstan region this week was likely a modified Aeroprakt A-22 Ukrainian-made light aircraft, several experts said, offering insight into one of Kyiv's deepest drone strikes to date.

What kind of damage could a larger airliner inflict if it was converted into a flying suicide drone?

Could Ukraine take down the Kerch Strait bridge with such a weapon if other assets could suppress or exhaust air defenses at the bridge?

Could terrorists control such a plane with FPV technology and use it to attack our cities? Perhaps auto-pilot gets the plane to the vicinity where an operator takes over. Perhaps the operator is close to the target if a distant operator faces too much lag in control responsiveness. Or maybe lag is irrelevant to a large stationary target.

Or good God, could a plane with passengers and crew from a real airline be converted so that involuntary martyrs disguise the nature of the weapon and delay a shoot-down order until it is too late? 

I mean, just videoing a plane with real passengers being shot down by a fighter would be powerful propaganda against the targeted state. Proof of the suicide drone nature of the plane would take time to catch up with the false propaganda. And some would never believe any proof.

Just a periodic thought that red lines my pucker factor.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Friday, June 07, 2024

America Pretends Iran Isn't Waging War on America

How can progressives believe mullah-run Iran is just a friend America hasn't tried hard enough to make?

We must inflict never-ending pain on Iran--not just on its expendable proxies: 

The U.S. and Britain struck 13 Houthi targets in several locations in Yemen on Thursday in response to a recent surge in attacks by the Iran-backed militia group on ships in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden[.]
Iran continues to wage war on America and we don't want to admit it. Remember when Smart Diplomacy® returned in early 2021?

The Biden administration gets its first two-fer by aiding our enemy Iran and harming our ally Saudi Arabia.

Biden grants his first big favor to Iran: 

President Joe Biden is cutting off US support for "offensive operations" in Yemen and appointing a special envoy to push for a diplomatic solution to end the six-year civil war.

When Biden was vice president, the administration ideal was "leading from behind" where allies fought wars that benefited America. The Saudis did that and now Biden will punish them for fighting the Iran-backed Houthi in Yemen.

Lack of American support and ammunition will make Saudi air strikes less accurate and more likely to cause unintentional civilian casualties. Which helps the Houthis. Which makes Iran's nutball mullahs smile and bask in the knowledge that they always knew Allah would rescue them from the Great Satan. 

The administration justification is that "This war has to end." Sure. But it would be nice if America didn't help our enemies end the war with a victory. Gosh, I sure missed "Smart Diplomacy!"

It is really so strange--totally unexpected, really--that it failed! 

The United States finds that its record of pro-Iran objectives are interfering with getting open and full Arab cooperation in resisting Iran's proxy maritime offensive in the Red Sea and Horn of Africa.  

So we didn't make mullah-run Iran a friend; and our allies worried about Iran are skittish about relying on America to fight Iran's proxies. Normally being hit with the reality stick as much as we've been battered since 2009--with that exception from 2017 through 2020--would lead us to reconsider our policy.

But Biden can't quit the mullahs.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.