Wednesday, May 22, 2024

Keep the NATO Insurance Policy

Americans opposed to NATO mistakenly think that Europeans wouldn't bleed to defend Europe. And these opponents of NATO overlook the benefit to America of keeping Europe friendly.


FFS, defending Europe is not a gift to Europeans: 

The European members of NATO have the population and resources to more than adequately counterbalance the Russian threat, but they lack the will to do so. For 75 years, Europe has been the dependent child of the United States, relying on American military might, including its nuclear umbrella, for its ultimate security.

Look. I understand the frustration of Democrats suddenly becoming anti-Russian. But rather than reflexively choosing the opposite policy of political foes, Republicans should say, "Welcome to the party, pal."

Protecting Europe to prevent it from being a launching pad for an attack on America across the Atlantic is in our security interest:

We found that a dominant power in Europe--or even small powers unrestrained by friends in Europe--could project power across the Atlantic to reach America.

With more power, America found that it could influence events in Europe rather than just be jostled around as near-helpless collateral damage or worse in European rivalries and conflicts.

You may think I invoke a ridiculously hypothetical threat. But it is a longstanding American objective, as described by George Friedman[.]* ...

Dismissing the threat from the Atlantic is only possible because we've been so successful since World War II in preventing a threat from Europe extending its reach across the Atlantic in a persistent manner. And dismissing the potential threat from Russia this century ignores that Russia would be much more powerful if it can seize or dominate significant portions of Europe's economic, financial, technological, demographic, and military power.

We've paid a price when we have not maintained that buffer zone. Europe has actual and even greater military potential under control of an enemy, whether that enemy is an invader or from internal sources.

When America has just a few Army brigades in Europe, it is ridiculous to say that America defends Europe. European troops would do the majority of the fighting and dying. We do provide the vast majority of supporting forces and capabilities that help weave more narrowly focused European capabilities into a coherent whole. Russia would be happy to have NATO destroyed or weakened.

As for nukes, do we really want Europe to have a large nuclear arsenal? Isn't it in our interest to make sure nobody else can really start a nuclear war?

Remember, too, that Trump worked to strengthen an alliance that benefits America in many ways. We certainly want Europeans to spend more on defense. And they are finally starting to do that. 

Increased European defense efforts will help keep Russia at bay. But NATO has another purpose. You recall the classic justification for NATO--keep the Russians out, the Americans in, and the Germans down. Germany doesn't seem to be a problem anymore. Although some worry. I think the European Union is the political entity NATO must keep down.

And the EU knows it. Killing NATO is the wet dream of the proto-imperial European Union as much as it is Russia's objective. We must not forget that the anti-democratic EU threatens to undermine an under-appreciated victory of the America-led NATO over European autocracy:

Europe without American help has the economic, demographic, and scientific base to keep a weakened Russia out of Europe. But if left on its own, Europe's long history of autocracy will return and risk a Europe that again poses a threat to America.
And once again I will remind you that if you are determined to slash America's military commitment to Europe to focus it ... somewhere else, you can ... celebrate! The Strategy Fairy already granted your wish to slash America's European deployment.

If you want to remove significant numbers of American troops out of Europe at this point, you'd need to dig up our military cemeteries and return them home.

We bled to repel threats in World War I, World War II, and the Cold War. After all that, the conventional threat to Europe is pinned in Ukraine at a fraction of the cost of those hot and cold wars. Yet some think it is strategy to walk away and let the Russians advance west as they clearly say they want to. I say, no. No buffer zone will dull their paranoia.

And these anti-NATO writers--who now disguise it by saying they just want it to be "dormant" until needed--compound their error by saying America should let the EU take charge of defending Europe. This fails to recognize it for what it is and will invite the EU to emerge as the threat from within.

I'd rather keep a hostile Russia as far east as possible and suppress the EU threat at a relatively cheap price built on past sacrifices lest the price we need to pay to keep Europe from being a threat to America rises in blood and treasure--again. 

UPDATE: Can Europe defend itself?

Along NATO’s eastern flank, member states are ramping up defenses against any future Russian aggression. Two years of war in which Kremlin forces killed tens of thousands of Ukrainians has convinced NATO that what was once unthinkable is no longer. The plan is for hundreds of thousands of troops to eventually be rotated among its border states, with alliance members such as Germany planning a permanent presence. 

But will it be enough? To match a militarized Russian economy, NATO members must spend a lot more on defense. And the possibility of Donald Trump taking power again has them worried America will shirk its commitment, emboldening Vladimir Putin. 

No doubt that if Russia defeats Ukraine, Europe will need to spend more. As will America. But Europe has the economic, scientific, and demographic power to defeat Russia.

But please take the Trump hysteria over there with a grain of salt. Europeans default to worrying about America being too weak--or too strong--in its capabilities or leadership.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Tuesday, May 21, 2024

The Middle East is Still a Military Problem

Don't pretend we can walk away from the Middle East just because we have bigger problems in Europe and Asia.

Obama tried and failed to pivot away: 

The Middle East problem is not going away. The region has become a proverbial Hotel California; the United States can check out anytime it likes, but it can never leave.

With a rising China and a major land war in Europe, many analysts have called for the United States to move on from the Middle East, penning articles like “The Middle East Isn’t Worth It Anymore,” “The Middle East Just Doesn’t Matter as Much Any Longer,” and “The End of America’s Middle East.” While the United States has recently shifted its efforts to the Indo-Pacific region and increased its military presence in Europe, the Middle East continues to demand attention.

And we do have fewer assets routinely in the Middle East now after we ramped up to defeat immediate threats and then scaled our forces back after reducing the threats.

The demand to evacuate the Middle East to focus on Europe and Asia makes as little sense as claiming we should evacuate Europe to focus on Asia. Notwithstanding some reinforcements to Europe in response to Russian aggression, we already did reduce our presence in Europe dramatically.

And just as Africa still requires some attention notwithstanding its role as an economy-of-force front, the Middle East still requires our military attention. Luckily, we have allies to support against common enemies--if we admit they are enemies--rather than having to carry the primary load.

Ignoring the region won't work now. Especially now. But one thing would reduce the explosions to a dull roar. 

NOTE: The image was made from DALL-E.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Monday, May 20, 2024

The Winter War of 2022 Becomes a Long War

As we see the war flow from failed initial Russian invasion and successful local Ukrainian counter-attacks in 2022, the big failed Ukrainian counteroffensive of 2023, and Russia regaining the initiative in 2024 to plow forward using mass and firepower to overwhelm smaller Ukraine, a path to even more stages across more years must be found if Ukraine is to win. 

The war goes on.

Russia expanded their frontage to areas north of Kharkiv, advancing into Ukrainian areas that Russia's invaders retreated from in the latter part of 2022. On the rest of the front, especially in the Donbas closer to Russian sources of supply, Russia claws forward at a slow but worrisome rate. And Russia continues to bombard Ukrainian critical infrastructure.  

Ukraine expands its own strategic warfare with long-range but low-payload suicide drones deep in Russia; and strikes Crimea with new weapons from America and Europeans in addition to using their own surface and aerial drones.

So the war continues as American aid starts to fill the gap left by America's failure to authorize more aid. European aid continued, but does not yet have the ability to produce the volume that America can generate. As insufficient as America's production still is, it is significantly better than allies.

This is a good starting point for planning in the West for support to Ukraine:

For Ukraine, the ideal end state appears clear: (1) restore its sovereign territory (i.e., the 1991 borders), (2) rebuild the country in a manner that promotes deeper Western integration, and (3) hold Russia accountable for war crimes.

The war might not end on those terms, but it's a good objective to base planning on.

And of course, Ukrainians will ultimately decide what they are willing to die for. Just as Russians ultimately must decide what conquests they are willing to die for. For Ukraine, my guess is that liberating areas of the Donbas occupied by Russia since 2014-2015 will not be worth it since those guys are clearly willing to kill Ukrainians. I have no idea what the pain level is for Russia. I once thought I did. Nor do I know if the pain level is at the level of soldiers, military-age recruits and their families, Putin, or the amorphous wealthy supporters and senior security apparatus leadership.

Strategypage says Russians are increasingly anti-war as news of the reality spreads. It is said that desertion from the Russian military is increasing. Whether this all leads to difficulties scooping up enough even unwilling recruits is beyond my ability to judge. 

But Strategypage includes casualty statistics that are just odd. Nearly 180,000 dead Russian troops and 34,000 dead Ukrainian troops (with another 11,000 dead Ukrainian civilians); with the wounded twice those numbers. I'd like to believe the killed ratio is that lopsided for Ukraine. But I can't believe a 2:1 killed-to-wounded ratio when based on history it should be at least 3:1. It seems that medical advances should have improved even for the Russians with their horrible medical corps.

But I have no idea. And those who know aren't talking.

Anyway.

The planning for more years of war requires a path to something that will break the territorial stalemate where significant advances have not taken place since 2022.

If Ukraine endures the rest of this year (and if Russia can continue flinging men at their military problems), Ukraine needs to be able to emerge victorious over a larger enemy with a number of long-range efforts. Otherwise the war could fade into a simmering stalemate that some will wrongly call peace. This will allow Putin to reload and resume the offensive under better conditions from territory deeper inside Ukraine. Do this enough and Ukraine falls.

CSIS calls the long-range efforts "five strategic problems" to be solved to achieve the ideal end state of Ukrainian victory. The broad picture makes sense to me. This may break the stalemate by increasing Ukraine's relative defense capacity compared to Russia's.

The U.S. is working to increase Ukraine's own defense production: 

Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Wednesday announced a $2 billion aid package for Ukraine largely intended to help the embattled country grow its indigenous defense capabilities and move away from Soviet-era equipment.

This is good. And as I've long said, Ukraine must reduce its corruption to compete with the even more corrupt but much larger Russia.

We do pay attention to this issue. The fact that we do does not mean Ukraine forfeits the right to exist free of Russian control. It just means Ukraine has to succeed to be better capable of remaining free of Russian control without the current level of Western assistance. Western assistance will always be vulnerable to changes in Western policy whether from strategic, fiscal, or Russian disinformation and influence reasons.

Tip to Instapundit.

UPDATE (Monday): Russia's Kharkiv attacks are petering out. Will Russia waste more ground power attacking than Ukraine does reacting to the Russian attacks?

If Russia truly has numerical superiority it makes sense to stretch the Ukrainian defenders. But if stretching the Ukrainians uses Russian reserves that might be used where a real effort could capture something significant, Russia is stretched, too. I've expressed my surprise that people were shocked that Russia could make initial rapid advances against weak defenses on a quiet sector of the front.

As I've observed, I'm starting to get the impression that the Russians are following the pattern of Germany's 1918 offensive. The Germans had a series of dramatic advances on the Western front. But the attacks seemed opportunistic without having any real operational focus to achieve victory. In the end, Germany failed to break the Allied line. The most significant result was that Germany depleted their army and wrecked their army's morale. 

UPDATE (Monday): I don't quite agree with this:

If time is on Ukraine’s side, then it should avoid negotiations and drag out the war for as long as possible. If time is on Russia’s side, then it should act the same way. 

Time is also a gift to the enemy if it is losing. Because you never know what an enemy will do with time to erase your edge.

Further, it is perfectly rational to want to win a war faster to reduce the price of victory. 

And as the author notes, the judgment that one side has the edge could be wrong. Belief is not reality. Also, even if there is a long-term advantage for one side, if the side with that edge loses in the short term, the long-term edge is moot.

I don't know who has the long-term advantage. But I've never assumed Russia has the edge because of its size.

UPDATE (Wednesday): Interesting ISW special report on Russia's offensives the last six months.

My commentary in the first Monday update on the apparently aimlessness of Russia's attacks is answered by ISW's portrayal of the offensives as means to demoralize Ukraine and the West by making Russian victory seem inevitable.

Putin believed America would falter in aiding Ukraine. And Ukraine would lose hope. Leading to a Russian summer offensive to break Ukraine's army.

But America did resume aid. And Russian losses combined with a revived Ukrainian military will make Russia's plans for a summer offensive obsolete. So their plan must change.

That angle at least explains the apparent lack of a larger battlefield purpose to Russia's attacks that I saw. 

UPDATE (Thursday): TDI wonders if there will be any big Russian offensive. Perhaps Russia will work on that buffer zone north of Kharkiv, then sit on the defensive and pound Ukraine from the air to drive them to the negotiating table.

Plausible. 

But can Putin tolerate sitting on the defensive for long? A tiger-riding reincarnation of Peter the Great doesn't want to be Vladimir the Perfectly Adequate.

Or maybe that ISW report I linked Wednesday is correct that Russia will keep trying to grind forward under the limits of its recruiting efforts to replace casualties.

UPDATE (Saturday): Ukraine knocked out an important Russian radar in Crimea:

According to The War Zone blog, the station is part of Russia’s nuclear ballistic missile early warning system.

The blog said the station may have been targeted because it is capable of tracking U.S.-made ATACMS long-range missiles, which were recently approved for distribution to Ukraine by Washington.

A bit of caution is in order so we don't get the paranoid Russians worried about a Western nuclear first strike.

NOTE: ISW updates continue here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Sunday, May 19, 2024

Weekend Data Dump

Huh: "German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius used a Thursday speech in Washington to call for both Berlin and Washington to hit 3 percent GDP spending on defense, while also stating his support for reintroducing conscription to the German armed forces." Maybe this sticks.

State Partnership Program: "Finland is the latest country to join the U.S. National Guard’s state partnership program, an initiative that aims to strengthen allied forces by connecting them to American reserve forces for long-term collaboration." Virginia is the state.

The Russians will fan the flames of jihadi terrorism: "The Pentagon this week formally ordered all 1,000 U.S. combat troops to withdraw from Niger, a blow to the Biden administration’s effort to counterterrorism and Russian influence in West Africa."

Mexico is awash in violence (tip to Instapundit). Remember when Mexico thought drug traffic was an American "demand" problem and that they'd just enjoy the American money flowing into Mexico?

Oops: "One side effect of Russian corruption plus sloppy manufacturing is that 21 Russian guided bombs and SAMs landed on the Russian side of the Ukrainian border and caused some damage and an undisclosed number of casualties."

And now for something completely different:

 

Ukraine would like a lot more because they work well: "Ukraine currently has three Patriot Air Defense Batteries and one more is about to arrive."

I don't believe this claim is true: "Russian troops are furthering their advances, and Moscow now controls more of Ukraine than it has at any point since its Feb. 2022 invasion." Ukraine forced Russia back a great deal from northern Ukraine, across the Dnieper River in Kherson, and in the Donbas in 2022.

Shoigu is out as defense minister. Pity. He seemed to suck. I never do victory dances when Putin replaces poor leadership. 

China is attempting to turn another land feature into an island: "Signs of #Chinese land reclamation in Sabina (Escoda) Shoal just 75 nautical miles (140 Km) from Palawan Island, #Philippines " Doing that does not make it an island for legally claiming territorial waters. The Philippines is opposing China.

America kind of supports Ukraine and Israel: "Policy whiplash gives Biden’s positions a Janus-faced quality. He tries to hold opposing positions at once to keep all sides at bay, always speaking with the fervor of someone who can’t understand why no one else understands his logic." It's Smart Diplomacy.®

China has much more capacity to build ships than we have: "Foreign capital and technology are flowing into Chinese dual-use shipyards, which is accelerating Beijing’s ongoing naval buildup." We have shipbuilding allies. But are they a replacement?

Is this too pessimistic (for China)? "China’s slowing growth, real estate crisis, high youth unemployment, and U.S. restrictions on key technologies have led to predictions of a so-called lost decade of stagnation." Tip to Instapundit.

NATO can't exist without America. True. And I want a robust NATO. But ignore the author's Trump bashing and review his actual record which looks darned good after his predecessor. NATO has two threats: Russia, which is obvious. And the European Union, which is oddly overlooked. 

Hungary under Orban is no friend of America. I gave him the benefit of the doubt for years because the media cries wolf fascist when anyone right of left-of-center is elected. I have doubts he is really fascist. But I'm sure he's no friend of America.

I read that Russia's attacks into Ukraine on the long-dormant front north of Kharkiv are enabled by the inability of Ukraine to use Western weapons on targets inside Russia itself. If Russia's attacks push inside Ukraine, that solves that restriction, no?

German Eastern Front experience was that depleted infantry with good artillery support could hold their ground. If ammo arrives soon, this is bad but not disastrous: "Ukraine’s brigades are currently operating at just 40 percent of their original capacity, in terms of personnel and vehicles[.]" More troops are coming.

Huh: "The U.S. and Taiwan navies conducted joint drills in the Pacific in April that, officially, did not take place, four people briefed on the matter said, as the two militaries boost cooperation amid rising Chinese military threats."

We should sink the supply vessels: "The United States called on Iran on Monday to halt its transfer of an 'unprecedented' amount of weaponry to Yemen’s Houthi rebels, enabling their fighters to carry out 'reckless attacks' on ships in the Red Sea and elsewhere." But we all know why that's ruled out.

Good luck with that: "Civilian contractors have arrived in Haiti to build living quarters for a Kenyan-led international security force meant to counter gang violence in the Caribbean nation, the U.S. military's Southern Command said."

China wants Taiwan and expects an American blockade in response: "According to Chinese plans, that blockade would last a few years and would then be lifted because so many nations want to end their economic suffering because trade with China was blocked."

But if Ukrainian ground forces don't attack through Kherson into Crimea, this will have been pointless: "Ukraine has been regularly attacking Russian land and naval bases in Crimea and usually destroying them. Ukraine also attacked Russian radars and SAM (Surface to Air Missile) installations."

A proposal for a new stealthy aerial refueling tanker. Some years ago I read that China's plan to defeat our air power was to charge in to overwhelm our fighters to get at the critical tankers and support planes. So Good. I have an additional thought.

A call for America to outpace China as the source of lots of quality small aerial drones.

Marines may get anti-drone capabilities on their service weapon: "[The officer in charge] insisted the ultimate solution would not add to any Marine's duties or take them away from other tasks." How can it not interfere with closing with and destroying the enemy? I want fighter drones in the brown skies.

A 23rd branch? "The Army would gain a drone branch under proposed language in the 2025 defense authorization bill, a move intended to further professionalize the field and put it on par with the service’s other disciplines." The branch would also do counter-drone operations. Fighter drones?

Well, this is the theory for the 2,100-strong Marine Littoral Regiments. I have concerns about the practice. I'd rather have answers to concerns.

Via Instapundit, I think that's right: "One could argue - in spite of some problem areas in the island nations west of Wake - that in aggregate our friendships and alliances in the Western Pacific are stronger now than they were 10 years ago." We have friends. Japan is a recent bright spot. But we still have work to do.

Short version: Let Russia win in Georgia: "[The pro-Russian government remembers the 2008 war with Russia but] also remembered that despite profuse statements of friendship, support and partnership, the U.S. refused to intervene to save Georgia." That's major history re-writing. Why do I bother reading RS?

Alternatives to an Asian NATO for Asia-Pacific security relations. The widely dispersed countries threatened by China lack a common battlefield that NATO had in West Germany.

Can South Korea reverse its birth collapse? Seems like the main three options in the world are robots, immigration, and cloning. Unless societies start valuing larger families again. Interesting that the chart ignores reports that China already peaked.

China might undermine Taiwanese will to remain free with "a PRC coercion campaign that remains far short of invasion but nevertheless brings Taiwan under Beijing’s control." I worry Taiwan's will to remain free could collapse if the PLA gets ashore in strength. So this conjecture isn't a big leap to make.

Russia's Kharkiv front sanctuary.

De-Baathification was necessary for Iraq rather than an error. One thing I forgot to mention was that Shias had reason to be suspicious of American motives after America let Saddam brutally suppress post-Desert Storm Shia uprisings in the south in 1991. We had reason to oppose a pro-Iran uprising. But it left a mark.

Palestinian civilian casualty tally was dramatically reduced. It's still too high given the "children" category goes up to 20 and fighters could be 16. And don't assume women aren't involved. Fighting for a city is a decision to destroy it. Hamas chose to fight for urbanized Gaza--behind civilians. Israel is fighting clean.

I'm so old I remember when America decided it didn't want to help allies in Afghanistan keep the Taliban out of power. Now, Taliban-run Afghanistan is a host for terrorists. And since we retreated from Afghanistan we've given over $17 billion dollars to Afghanistan and for refugee support. We're that stupid.

Putin demoted a close ally and powerful siloviki, Nikolai Patrushev, "the individual personally responsible for the assassination of Wagner Group financier Yevgeny Prigozhin[.]" Sure. Powerful, willing to murder, and able to murder? Useful to Putin. But not too close. Best to mow that tall grass down to size, eh?

As Russia gears up for a long war, NATO signals it will match that effort: "Blinken stated during a speech in Kyiv that more than 32 NATO states are negotiating 10-year bilateral security commitments with Ukraine, including nine states with completed agreements." Will Ukrainians and Russians fight that long?

China-occupied Scarborough Shoal: "China has sent dozens of coast guard and maritime militia vessels toward a disputed atoll in the South China Sea, a large show of force aimed at blocking a civilian protest flotilla from the Philippines, as tensions between the countries have flared."

Making new Purple Heart medals as the World War II stock runs out. 

FFS, hardened aircraft shelters should be Aircraft Protection 101. The most advanced plane in the air is just a shrapnel magnet on the ground.

To be clear, the protection for aid to Gazans is from Hamas threats: "two [Navy] ships will join the thousands of Israeli Defense Forces soldiers -- plus Israeli navy ships and Israeli air force planes -- that are dedicated to protecting the effort to move food and supplies into Gaza[.]" Hamas will not be not grateful.

Reactive armor and active protection would be a good start: "As the US Army prepares to field its new light tank next year, the M10 Booker, it is gearing up for a testing series that will help determine just what modifications may be needed[.]" Because, burn, baby burn. APS isn't a silver bullet, however.

The drones got a good head start: "Ukrainian and Russian forces are scrambling to field countermeasures for protecting tanks against one-way attack drones, which experts say are a growing challenge even for vehicles traveling at speed."

Hungary's Orban doesn't act like an authoritarian ruler. I still don't like his dalliance with Putin.

How did a pro-Russian government get elected there? "Crucially, this anti-Western trajectory of the government cuts directly against the will of the Georgian people. They overwhelmingly lean towards Europe, with polling suggesting that over 80 per cent want Georgia to join the EU." Can Russia intervene?

Yeah, a Taiwanese president resisting Chinese intent to conquer Taiwan is not the problem here. FFS. 

China is providing crucial help to Russia to get around war-motivated sanctions. But so far has not provided weapons. Russia doesn't like the limits on Chinese help. Is China willing to provide more help despite Western opposition?

Their own worst enemy: "[Putin's] long-serving and intensely loyal foreign minister Sergei Lavrov earlier this week challenged what Russia calls the 'collective West', declaring Moscow's troops are ready to meet NATO on the battlefield." Even Europe (!) is rearming in response. Effing chimps with effing nukes.

A "great game" against China should not include losing two games in the Middle East and Europe. We have in fact greatly reduced military power in Europe and the Middle East to focus on China! FFS. You want a great game against China? Here it is.

Only a B-2 can drop it: "An Army ammunition plant in southeast Oklahoma is being expanded to at least triple monthly production of the US’s biggest non-nuclear bomb, a weapon often invoked in debates about a potential attack on deeply buried nuclear facilities in Iran or North Korea." And the future B-21, right?

Fragment of empire. 

Good Lord: "Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico was being treated for 'life-threatening' injuries after being shot in what the nation’s Interior Ministry described as an assassination attempt." He's pro-Russia. But this is not a good means of settling political questions. The apparent shooter was arrested.

Countering jihadis in AFRICOM: "Flintlock 24, which began Monday and runs through May 24, features nearly 30 countries and approximately 1,300 personnel. For the second year in a row, Ghana and Ivory Coast are hosting."

Nobody wants to be Pearl Harbored: "The United States and Japan signed a cooperative agreement Wednesday to co-develop a hypersonic missile defense capability designed to neutralize hypersonic threats in the glide phase of flight[.]"

Cuba cooperated just enough for us to pretend they're okay: "In a policy step to ease pressure on Cuba, the Biden administration removed the communist island from the roster of countries "not cooperating fully" with anti-terrorist efforts, a list the U.S. State Department issues every year." Bust out the "Che" shirts!

Strategic warfare: "[Ukrainian] attacks were carried out at night by low flying non-metallic UAVs that, because of their altitude and non-metallic composition, were difficult for Russian air surveillance radars to detect."

Hamas made a post-war plan after occupying Israel: "The plan included details on which Israelis would be killed, expelled, or forced to remain because they were educated Jews and experts in the areas of medicine, engineering, technology, and civilian and military industry."

Those Filipino civilians at Scarborough Shoal called their sea operation a victory over the Chinese occupiers. 

France upped its efforts to quell unrest in New Caledonia.

China has apparently built a small drone carrier. To carry small suicide drones close to Taiwan?

This author says it would be a geopolitical coup for Russia to get China to agree to an energy pipeline from Russia to China. I suspect that such a pipeline would put weak Russia in more danger of Chinese dominance. America reacted to reliance on Middle East energy with CENTCOM. Putin plays with fire.

The Philippines is growing into a sizable country with economic heft; and is ending their holiday from history after the Cold War to reclaim friendship with America for our mutual security benefit. Tip to Instapundit.

The half-year gap in aid is taking longer to bridge than I thought: "US officials have expressed confidence that the arrival of US security assistance to Ukrainian forces at scale by July 2024 will likely allow Ukrainian forces to reverse many of the tactical gains that Russian forces have achieved in recent weeks."

How the proto-imperial European Union compelled Poland to take another step away from sovereign state and toward imperial province. All part of the EU plan to strip away that pesky prefix. Because smaller states are just the easier first targets.

Russia has a history of failing to effectively reform its military. This may be true and too difficult to overcome given Russia's institutional flaws. But Russia can still have a military good enough for Russian government work. 

Oh good Lord: "in the middle of the largest land war since World War II and a substantial conflict in the Middle East, the United States is running low on modern gunpowder." And Russia is getting plenty of nitrocellulose for gunpowder from China.

Marine small-unit exercise in the Philippines. The South China Sea is a place where a few will do.

Guns and butter: "Putin stated that even as Russian defense spending grows, the Russian state must fulfill all its social obligations to Russian citizens and develop Russian social spheres, such as education, healthcare, support for veterans, and pensions." America tried that in the Vietnam War and got stagflation.

Corruption? Or disloyalty to Putin? "Russian sources speculated that the May 13 detention of Russian Deputy Defense Minister Lieutenant General Yuri Kuznetsov is only the beginning of a wider effort to root out corruption within the Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD)."

Israel is the result of post-World War II anti-colonial trends. Tip to Instapundit.

Huh. India test-fired a 3D-printed engine. Tip to Instapundit.

I’ve speculated about a potential Ukrainian offensive across the Dnieper River. A lot of conditions would have to be met. But I’ve seen no signs of this option. I must conclude my speculation is unlikely.

No weapons were reported in this attempt--which included an illegal immigrant on the terror watch list--to drive a truck into the Marines' Quantico base. Was it a dry run to test security in action? 

Who says the LCS has low lethality? "A northern Michigan marine dock is suing the defense contractor Lockheed Martin, alleging that a 388-foot combat ship caused more than $2.5 million in damages to the facility’s seawall, dock and the surrounding lakebed."

Troops issued a laser air defense Stryker aren't impressed with it. The field is different than a static industry site. 

Still not up to large-scale combat operations: "The U.S. Army and its allies and partners in the theater are finding more ways to come together and build relationships, Flynn said, some of which have endured since the end of World War II." Crawl, walk, run (in Military Review).

This is reassuring? "The Russian military lacks enough troops for a major breakthrough in Ukraine despite recent battlefield gains, the top U.S. military commander in Europe said this week." I'd feel better if the military hadn't said the Afghan government could last two years and that Kiev would fall in a few days.

Russia has "ramped up deployment of electronic warfare systems, which, to the surprise of NATO leaders, was absent at the outset of the fighting[.]" I know I mentioned that early war lack of what I thought was a strong part of their military.

Headlines about nukes in space mask the dramatic decline of Russia's space capabilities: "Russia is way behind and not likely to catch up to the west, or even China, any time soon."

Interesting: "Armed UAVs cause more casualties in Ukraine than mortar, artillery, or missile attacks." That's not an "and" but still impressive since the last thing I read is that artillery kills a clear majority. Is this an artificial result of the artillery shell shortage?

Delivering supplies and votes for compassion and calculation. American troops could pay a price for that.

Biden is eager for Israel to have a "day after" plan for Gaza. Let's not get distracted by a post-war that assumes victory before Hamas is crushed on the battlefield. Israel needs a rebuilt hate-free Gaza with a coexisting counter-example. Could America's objective be achieved with a virtual Pal-E-stine state?

The Army is looking for a new cannon: "The U.S. is planning on a competition between various mobile artillery systems this summer to select a new self-propelled howitzer." Wheeled systems are not ruled out.

Russia's offensive around Kharkiv has "jolted" Europeans? Why? It was a secondary front with lower quality defenders. Defending on the border was difficult given limits on using Western weapons on Russian territory. I expected Ukraine to trade a bit of terrain for time. Why is this a jolt?

This view of what happens if Russia defeats Ukraine over-states Ukraine's ability to fight an insurgency and under-estimates Russia's ability to crush resistance with mercenaries, collaborators, brutality, and population transfers. "Dormant" NATO? How much more dormant can the U.S. get in NATO?

Russian women are protesting the war that sends their men to die. Huh. It's easier to see war weariness in Ukraine. That doesn't mean Russians are eagerly marching to their deaths for Putin.

Good: "The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said on Saturday that it killed an Islamic jihad commander, who is said to have been the logistics head in Rafah for the pro-Iranian militia allied with the Palestinian Islamist Hamas group." I usually use "Hamas" as an umbrella term for all the jihadis in Gaza.

This seems prudent: "Donald Tusk said work on the Shield-East project which includes building proper military fortifications has already begun." 

Good luck: "Trucks carrying badly needed aid for the Gaza Strip rolled across a newly built U.S. pier and into the besieged enclave for the first time Friday[.]" Hamas will not be not grateful. More specifically, probably one of the smaller satellite jihadi groups will get the job of striking.

Huh: "French security forces worked Sunday to retake control of the highway to the international airport in violence-scorched New Caledonia, shuttered because of deadly unrest wracking the French Pacific archipelago where indigenous people have long sought independence from France."

That's impressive DOD spin on Niger's flip to Russia and ejection of our troops: "The withdrawal of U.S. forces from Niger does not affect the continuation of U.S.-Niger development relations. The United States and Niger are committed to ongoing diplomatic dialogue to define the future of their bilateral relations." 

Probably an accident: "Rescuers are trying to locate the helicopter on which President Ebrahim Raisi and Foreign Minister Hossein Amir Abdollahian were traveling, state media reported. Their status is unknown." But in tense times, accidents, solar storm blackouts, and meteor impacts can appear hostile.

Saturday, May 18, 2024

Russia, Never Ever Let the Chinese See Your Fleet Up Close!

Putin may dream of his own Red Storm Rising at sea. But his fleet is not up to battling for sea control against a serious naval enemy. Perhaps China isn't up to challenging the American and Japanese fleets. But Russia's Pacific Fleet is just waiting for an ass-kicking by someone.

Russia is foolish to allow China any view of Russia's navy: 

The Russian and Chinese navies signed a memorandum of understanding and cooperation on April 21 amid recent reports of China’s increased support for Russia’s war in Ukraine.

Putin should not believe his own BS about his naval prowess:

The Russian navy can detect any enemy and launch an "unpreventable strike" if needed, President Vladimir Putin said on Sunday, weeks after a UK warship angered Moscow by passing the Crimea peninsula.

"We are capable of detecting any underwater, above-water, airborne enemy and, if required, carry out an unpreventable strike against it," Putin said speaking at a navy day parade in St Petersburg.

Putin thought his army was pretty hot stuff, too, back in 2022. 

Oops.

I think China will certainly learn to understand Russia's navy during that new, glorious cooperation. Which should not be something Russia wants no matter how much Putin concocts futile plans to restore Soviet naval glory.

Which could be a problem for Russia one day:

Could China hit Russia's fleet and air bases in the Far East and combine that with a quick, overwhelming hit on some Russian border post that provides the image of land dominance, too? ...

If the Chinese could actually inflict a quick defeat on Russia, ended the fighting before it could escalate, could they use the leverage of that victory to get the Russians to make a small adjustment on the common border that would at least set the precedent for more later (to undo that 1858 unequal treaty)? Or what if there was no territory change, but the Chinese get the Russians to concede Chinese economic interests in the Far East as a step back to establishing claims to the land much the way Russia eased their way into the territory?

As I concluded in that old post:

When we think of China's rising power, we naturally think of how it might be directed at us. But from China's point of view, there are safer targets than America. So if we think about whether China might use their growing military power, don't fixate on America and our allies. 

Putin should not assume he is special in Xi's eyes.

America may be China's pacing threat. But that just makes lesser targets easier to take on. 

UPDATE: Russia needs help in its invasion of Ukraine and China has helped with "non-military" exports that help Russia produce weapons:

China suggested, and Russia accepted, that long-standing Chinese claims on a quarter of the Russian Far East and most of its prime coastal areas be considered as a form of payment.  

Huh. I haven't seen that news.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post. 

Friday, May 17, 2024

The Air Defense Queen?

Could America put air defense auxiliary cruisers into service to support access through critical waterways or access to important ports? They would supplement warships and free some warships for offensive action.

The Navy would like directed-energy weapons for air defense:

Downing Iranian-supplied missiles and drones with multi-million dollar SM-2 missiles to protect shipping in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden is a bad exchange that must change, the vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff said Wednesday.

“It has been an air-defense fight” in which the Navy and Air Force, along with allies and partners in Operation Prosperity Guardian, have largely prevailed in demonstrating “how we bring defense in depth,” Adm. Christopher Grady said during a U.S. Naval Institute-CSIS Maritime Security Dialogue.

To change the cost-benefit equation, he wants more directed energy systems deployed “where a drop of fuel becomes a weapon” to destroy attacking unmanned systems.

A problem is making sure ships have the energy to power the weapons--or even the armor.

Navy warships in the near term could have weaker directed energy weapons installed. But the ships have power limits on what they can handle. And limits on space to mount them without reducing VLS cells for offensive and defensive missiles, I imagine. Volume is needed that the current generation of surface ships can't provide in intense threat environments.

Could there be a role for modularized air defense auxiliary cruisers in getting that volume of fire? I addressed Navy use in this post (originally submitted as an article many years ago) along with Army missions (calling the ship The AFRICOM Queen for its intended area of operations) in this Military Review article.

The container ship could be modified with plentiful generators to power as many directed-energy weapons as are needed. The directed-energy weapons and generators could be installed in standard shipping containers to make it easier to configure the modularized auxiliary cruiser. Other weapons might be appropriate as well for limited attack capabilities against surface targets and close-in-weapons systems.

In shipping containers, the systems would also be easier to remove from a damaged modularized auxiliary cruiser to rapidly equip another hull.

And the ship itself might be the source of systems put ashore for a long-term mission before the ship retires to reload with systems for other missions at sea.

Mind you, these aren't for protecting a carrier strike group or any other fast-sailing Navy group.

But for protecting a vital piece of sea estate in a sea bastion or escorting merchant ships through danger zones like the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden, they might be great.

Or they might be useful to reinforce port defenses until land defenses can be established. 

In larger numbers to create a thick air defense bubble, they might even be useful off the east coast of Taiwan to help keep the line of supply open and protect American and allied warships operating there. Apparently our air defense systems don't have a problem with ground clutter (noted in an update).

NOTE: The base image was made from DALL-E.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post. 

Thursday, May 16, 2024

Europe Needs and Resents America

Europeans are worried that Trump will abandon Europe. Europe keeps rebooting this sad movie to turn the proto-imperial EU into a full empire.

Trump didn't walk away from NATO in his first term despite bluntly telling European NATO states that they must spend more on defense--as they promised Obama they'd do by this year. Seriously, while Europe has proven it is not prepared to face Russia, how much worse would its war-generated defense crisis be without Trump?

Remember, Europeans didn't take comfort from Biden announcing America "is back." And they said his defeat in Afghanistan was reason to worry about him. 

And don't forget that NATO was in a "mid-life crisis" in the Obama administration with European allies worried about American commitment. 

It's almost as if Europeans want to worry about America. We're too distant or we're too overwhelming in power--say, speaking of the European view of the Clinton presidency.

And the most European of Europeans are the European Union apparatchiki, who need a reason to kick America-led NATO out of Europe.

So when you see Macron basically ignoring the American military role in deterring the Russians and the recent large military aid package, wonder why:

With the zeal of a convert, Macron argues that the stakes in Ukraine include not only Ukrainians’ future but also the future of Europe: “The condition sine qua non for our security is that Russia does not win the war of aggression it is waging against Ukraine. This is imperative.” Even though the US Congress has finally passed a supplemental aid bill for Ukraine (as well as Israel and Taiwan), Europeans must recognise that the US has only two priorities: “America first, which is legitimate, and China.”

Macron denies America has an interest in keeping Europe from being hostile as strongly as some isolationist conservatives here. 

And Macron--in his so-called "Macron moment"--is trying to ride that to a more powerful European Union that strips away the prefix from the EU proto-imperial project. The zeal of a convert is just the tactical expression of whatever new crisis there is to exploit for that end. Gaining EU-wide support for France on something--anything--is the goal. Macron would sell out Ukraine to Russia--which he also tried to do before the war--or risk war with Russia in defense of Ukraine to get that. Or suck up to China.

Who knows how long this reason to make the EU an empire under French leadership will last until the next reason.

With Macron the emperor--even if he wears a suit rather than flowing robes and a bejeweled crown.

Seriously people, it's not us that's the problem in trans-Atlantic relations. It's them.

NOTE: The base image was made from DALL-E.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post. 

Wednesday, May 15, 2024

Are Marine "Stand-In" Forces a Threat to or Opportunity for China?

I have nightmares over how the Marine Corps is changing. Helping the Navy is fine. But don't be bait that the Navy will lose men and ships to supply or rescue. At least there is a silver lining to what they're being equipped with that might help the Navy.

The Marines get a weapon for littoral operations: 

The Corps has established special “littoral” units for the specific purpose of refining an ability to conduct warfare operations in coastal and island areas throughout the Pacific such as the island chains in the South China Sea. As part of this, the Corps’ Marine Corps Force Design 2030 document calls for specific “stand-in” ready forces capable to conducting offensive operations in close proximity to enemy areas within the larger perimeter reach of longer-range weapons. ...

Northrop Grumman’s Modular Payload System is a 26,000-pound four-pack missile system designed for forward, highly-mobile fires from warships and land-locations as needed.

I have many worries about the Marine plans. 

In many ways the Marines could be setting the stage for a fight like the Guadalcanal campaign of World War II (in a Land Warfare Paper) when the Japanese expended a huge amount of men and ships to sustain a garrison on Guadalcanal.

The Marines could well be isolated bait that draws in the Navy to try to rescue them while the Chinese use their missiles and planes to hammer the would-be rescuers who don't want to leave any man behind. 

Taking on the Japanese 1942 role doesn't seem wise.

Or maybe the Navy prudently but regrettably lets the Marines wither on the vine the way the Navy had to let the defenders of Bataan be marched off the the deadly prison camps in 1942.

But missiles in a box have potential for other uses (in Military Review). Although the concept may have more direct effect on Navy sea control and sea denial missions by equipping and using them as Modularized Auxiliary Cruisers, which was the genesis of my Military Review proposal:

Our Navy defends our nation within the incompatible and unforgiving boundaries formed by the tyrannies of distance and numbers. We struggle to build enough ships both capable of deploying globally and powerful enough for fighting first-rate opponents. Operating within a network-centric Navy, auxiliary cruisers could once again play a valuable role in projecting naval power. Using modular systems installed on civilian hulls, auxiliary cruisers could handle many peacetime roles; free scarce warships for more demanding environments; add combat power within a networked force; and promote the global maritime partnership.

I just hope the price of getting that capability isn't a lot of dead or captured Marines.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Tuesday, May 14, 2024

The Never-Ending Pivot to Nowhere

I've long noted that the Left has a history of opposing the current threat we are resisting in order to focus like a laser beam on the "next" vitally important threat. Obviously, when the current threat defeats us, that "next" threat becomes the current threat. Lather, rinse, repeat. The "bad war" versus "good war" dance of two decades ago is the most obvious example of this process.

The right has adopted this "we need to focus on the real threat" approach to advocate a pivot to Asia in order to abandon Europe and/or the Middle East to their fates. It'll be fine, they say.

This author's denial that America has pivoted to Asia ignores the departure of hundreds of thousands of American troops from Europe since the Cold War. The denial of a pivot ignores the massive reduction in American military power in the Middle East after winning in Iraq and losing in Afghanistan. As I observed in this post:

Clearly, we've been pivoting to focus on China ever since the collapse of the Soviet Union. We have very few forces committed to Europe, the Middle East, Latin America, or Africa. I think it is ridiculous to argue we are distracted by the rest of the world. How much more should we withdraw? We're damned close to the point in those areas where the only thing left to pack up and take home are the cemeteries of our troops who died in combat overseas to protect America.

And pray tell, just how do we pack even more forces into limited bases in the western Pacific? I fear we would just put our best military assets in easy reach of an initial theater-wide Pearl Harbor by China.

And become I'm such a nice guy I won't mention that the Middle East is in Asia.

America didn't put a lot more power in the Pacific. But we prioritized that region for quality. And we certainly didn't reduce it the way Europe and the Middle East got the "bring them home" treatment. Forces in the Pacific clearly represent a higher percentage of the forces that exist. The remainder of American military power is more concentrated at home where it can reinforce the western Pacific more easily.

And I'll ask again, where do we put more units in Asia? We shouldn't jam them into ill-defended bases close to China and leave them open to a theater-wide Pearl Harbor. We need more bases with the air defenses to keep them from being convenient targets for China. 

And simple things like aircraft shelters:

U.S. military bases in the Indo-Pacific region are sorely lacking hardened aircraft shelters, leaving them vulnerable to devastating airstrikes in a potential conflict with China, lawmakers warned.

Recent war games show the U.S. would lose 90% of its aircraft on the ground, rather than in air combat, due to insufficient base protection ...
How is it possible to develop advanced planes yet put them where they can be easily knocked out on the ground?

But even as the call to pivot to Asia continues, some in that camp are setting the stage for the next dance steps to minimize the fierce urgency of that "next" threat so it too can be current threat that isn't really America's main concern. As the saying goes, nice work if you can get it:

America is willing to sacrifice for uninhabited rocks and reefs in the East and South China Seas. This is one of the main messages from Japanese prime minister Kishida Fumio and Philippines president Ferdinand Marcos’ official visits to the United States. The Biden administration’s doubling down on advancing Indo-Pacific countries’ interests vis-à-vis China represents a reckless strategy in a region where Washington should be especially shrewd and savvy. Instead of fighting others’ battles and setting itself up to fail, Washington should adopt a restrained regional policy to secure its interests. [emphasis added]

Oh, restraining our military deployments and alliances will settle the western Pacific? Huh! It sounds so simple! The problem is that China won't restrain its policies or its objectives. The author even admits this, which means in practice we are supposed to simply accept China's demands. Which seem to grow every couple years.

The author says we should not risk nuclear war over the Sudetenland Pacific "rocks". Wait. What? Nobody has ever said America should initiate a nuclear war over them. So the author must believe China thinks mere rocks are important enough to start a nuclear war. Really? That's what the author is going with? So no other lower level of resistance to China is possible?

Oh, with the author's policy of "restraint" we'll get the false peace of retreat. For a while.

And then we lose allies who decide to "restrain" their own regional policies knowing they are on their own.

But that's okay! Some in the chorus line are already dismissing the very idea that China is a threat that justifies a pivot! The mind boggles at what will be chosen as the "real" threat.

A policy of "restraint" means allies get isolated and defeated. Lather, rinse, repeat. How America's security interests are secured this way is beyond my nuance-free simple mind to grok.

It is depressing to see conservatives embarking on the quest for Mr. Good War. Sadly, America gets effed up every time with that approach.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.