Tuesday, June 20, 2023

Jihadis and Russians and Turks, Oh My!

So how is Libya going 12 years after America helped overthrow the Libyan government but stayed out to let locals sort out their differences without a "destabilizing" American presence?

Thank God Libyans are being allowed to settle their differences without that destabilizing American influence! 

Libya remains divided and deadlocked. There are two main factions, one in the east based in Tobruk and another in Tripoli, in the west. The UN backs the Tripoli faction, as do local Islamic militias and Turkish troops and mercenaries. The eastern faction controls most of the oil and export ports. The Russian Wagner Group mercenaries are based in the east but now see themselves as peacekeepers and work with the Turks to maintain a ceasefire. This allows Russian oil firms to operate in Libya and do work for the Libyan national oil company. Both factions support national elections to unite the country but neither faction trusts the others enough to proceed with elections. Russia and the Turks refuse to withdraw their troops from Libya until they receive guarantees that their interests in Libya are respected.

Via Wagner forces, Russia has influence in Libya: 

While the US ponders whether to reopen its embassy in Libya, Vladimir Putin’s new ambassador is preparing to take up his post in the capital, extending Russian influence across an oil-producing nation on the doorstep of Europe.

It's a source of money, arms diversions, and migrants to aim at Europe. 

Also, "But the US is at a disadvantage in Libya, where it has no troops and no diplomatic presence." 

Remember when our drive-by intervention that killed Khadaffi was held up as big-brained Smart Diplomacy®, allowing locals to resolve their own problems post-dictator without America's "destabilizing" influence?  

It was bleeding from behind:

By simply overthrowing the dictator of Libya but keeping our troops out of the occupation business, locals would work out their differences because they'd be unable to rely on us to do it for them; our friends wouldn't be "tainted" by our association with them; and jihadis would have no reason to flock to Libya.

America "learned" from Iraq that we shouldn't try to overthrow Assad lest worse things happen. In Libya we tried the alternative to doing nothing or conquest. We just bombed the dictator's forces until locals could take over.

Too many here think America simply makes things worse. In reality, other people are perfectly capable of effing things up without us. And of the three test cases of Iraq, Syria, and Libya, Iraq has the best outcome so far--if we prevent Iraq War 3.0 by stopping Iran and jihadis. And let's not even go into Afghanistan where our "own goal" put the Taliban back in power, demonstrating that our imperfect local ally government was absolutely superior.

UPDATE: Is the door open for Russia to push migrants to Europe or is Tunisia just bargaining for a better price? "Tunisia’s president said Monday that his country doesn’t want to be Europe's border guard or a land of resettlement for migrants rejected elsewhere.

NOTE: The image was made with DALL-E. Although I had to add an American flag in the background with the meme generator. Often what I think is a clear instruction just doesn't make it into a picture. I wasted a couple of my limited allotment trying to get it right.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Monday, June 19, 2023

The Winter War of 2022 Expands to a Sideshow?

The war in Ukraine is heating up without any clear indications of where Ukraine will strike with its main effort. Is Russia trying to impose pain on America in Syria for supporting Ukraine? Or is Iran playing Russia for a fool?

Predictions of the outcome of Ukraine's slowly unfolding but still early counteroffensive run from crushing defeat to massive victory, depending on whether the analyst thinks Russian artillery and/or air power will batter the Ukrainians or thinks Russian troops will collapse under the stress of a sustained attacks.

Someone blew the Khakhovka dam on the Dnieper River. While I suspect Russia did in a combination of revenge for Belgorod raids and a probably mistaken fear the Kherson front could be a major offensive (I think it could be a supporting front if the Russians start retreating or collapsing further east), it is possible that Ukraine blew it to make sure the waters recede and the land dries before Ukraine plans to cross the river. If they know Russia will blow it during the crossing, blowing it now would be superior.

An interesting sideshow is the question of whether Russia wants to escalate beyond Ukraine in order to punish America for supporting Ukraine with such unexpected resolve.

Huh:

Iranian and Russian military officials met to discuss expelling the United States from Syria, which may indicate Russia’s intent to help facilitate Iranian-backed attacks against US forces. IRGC Quds Force and Russian military officials met in Deir ez Zor City to discuss coordinating attacks against US forces in Syria on June 6, according to local anti-Iranian outlet Eye of Euphrates.[1] CTP previously assessed that Iranian leaders are preparing to resume their campaign to expel US forces from the Middle East by attacking and killing US service members.[2] CTP cannot independently verify the details of the meeting in Deir ez Zor City. The reporting is, however, consistent with an article from the Washington Post that Iran and Russia formed a joint coordination center in Syria to expel US forces from Syria in November 2022.[3]

On the eve of Russia's first invasion of Ukraine, I noted that possession of Crimea enabled Russian intervention in Syria on Assad's side:

Pushing Russia away from the Black Sea--should Russia lose their bases in Crimea if Ukraine doesn't want them there any more--in the long run makes Russian operations in the Mediterranean much more difficult. That would make their help for Syria a bit more difficult and deprive Russia of some leverage in Egypt.

Russia did send in troops to bolster Assad not too long after taking all of Crimea in 2014. And now Russia will use its troop presence and influence in Syria to hang on to Crimea in the face of Ukraine's counteroffensive. 

Early in the year I noted my impression that Iranian attacks on American troops in Syria had increased:

Attacks in Syria seem to be happening more often: "Three suicide drones attacked a U.S. base in eastern Syria on Friday, wounding two Syrian opposition fighters, the U.S. military said. No Americans were hurt in the attack." Iran is likely behind the attack.

And I've wondered if this would lead to a new war for America. Perhaps Iran's strengthening military relationship with Russia leads to more than arms deals.

Syria may no longer be Ukraine's first line of defense, but Russia may think Syria is its first line of defense against America.

America has reacted, including sending A-10s to CENTCOM. More recently, America hopes F-22s will cool the jets of Russian pilots eager to intimidate U.S. forces in Syria: 

The Russians’ actions have included flying within 500 feet of U.S. aircraft, jamming U.S. aircraft electromagnetic systems, and flying over U.S. troops in Syria while armed with air-to-ground munitions[.]

If this is Russia's big plan I'm not sure it achieves. Yes, America might retreat if its troops in Syria endure significant casualties, which would be a problem for holding Iraq in that war--especially if it escalates to organized warfare. That would threaten the Arab effort to bring Assad's Syria back into the Arab League. And puts more pressure on Iraq to enter Iran's orbit. Those are wins for Iran.

But that doesn't automatically lead to America's retreat from Ukraine. It could backfire because America could respond by providing Ukraine with new capabilities--the theater most important to Russia.

And while it is an opportunity for Iran to get Russian support, there are dangers if Iran goes along and ejects America from Syria. America has counter moves in the sideshow. 

America could back Israeli strikes on Iran in Syria. Or America could move toward Israel in posing a threat to Iran's nuclear infrastructure.

America could repair relations with Saudi Arabia by recognizing Saudi security concerns in the region. Which would likely end early the well-publicized Iran-Saudi Arabia detente. Which would also embarrass China, which brokered the deal.

And Iran siding with Russia--who Democrats suddenly and oddly--given their history--decided was the source of all evil--could douse the burning love that Democrats have oddly had for mullah-run Iran. That could end Iranian and Democrats' hopes of reviving the awful Iran nuclear deal.

If Iranian support for hated Russia deepens, Democrats might reject Iran, too. And if that happens, America could decide that Syria is really a place to resist Russia--making my worries about resolve to resist Iran moot. Those A-10s could be busy against Russia's ally, Iran.

Which means a Russia horizontal escalation with Iran's help might fail, weakening Iran in Syria and at home with a stronger Israel-Saudi axis, and a splintered China shield.

But wait, there's more!

Republicans are warning the Biden administration against pursuing any agreement with Iran that would provide sanctions relief without approval from Congress, amid signs of progress in negotiations to contain Iran’s nuclear weapons program.

I'm sure a heaping helping of Biden administration Smart Diplomacy® will improve on the first shot in our own foot. Why do Democrats love the mullahs so much?

But more to the point, is Iran's flirtation with Russia's sideshow a ploy to get what they really want? Will Iran offer as a "concession" for a nuclear deal a promise to refrain from doing what it had no intention or riking?

I have to ask, is Iran playing Russia like Lucy plays Charlie Brown with the football? 

If this seems risky play for Russia, it is. And perhaps that indicates Western analysts who think Ukraine is set to stomp Russia are more correct in how the Ukrainian counteroffensive will unfold. I've worried that a Ukrainian failure to win big enough will discourage Western support for Ukraine. Russia may actually have a better idea of the real state of their military after living in a fantasy world for so long. 

So instead of concluding that because the Ukrainian counteroffensive hasn't defeated Russia yet means that Russia has defeated Ukraine's counteroffensive, let's have patience:

Several experts told Task & Purpose that the Ukrainian counteroffensive needs more time to unfold before it becomes clear whether the tide of war has shifted in Ukraine’s favor.

Maybe Russia is pounding Ukraine as they claim. But maybe Russia is throwing in the best troops they have and are using up ammo early to discourage the West by making support for Ukraine look futile. 

Ukraine hasn't won. But perhaps Ukraine isn't trying to go big yet. Could this be a combination of the Kherson and Kharkiv offensive approaches, with each a phase of the counteroffensive? Maybe Ukraine is slowly hollowing out the Russian defenders and at some point the Russian defenses will snap. And if Ukraine still has a sizable strategic reserve held back, the race to the Azov Sea will be off and running.

That's what I hope. Because I hoped--but didn't assume--the Russian defenders were fragile.

UPDATE (Monday): Ukraine seems to be pausing their probes to reevaluate their tactics. And Russian troop morale does seem fragile. Although fortifications, firepower, a stiffening with the best troops available, and the threat of being shot retreating could be holding the troops on the line so far.

If so, the sequence of probing and attrition followed by maneuver is still potentially on rather than this being a sign of Ukrainian failure. Remember, firepower can enable maneuver--it is not necessarily a signal that maneuver has failed.

Of course, the pause might not even be to reevaluate tactical failure. Maybe Ukraine has identified a weak point and needs time to deploy its units, establish air defenses and logistics, and begin the second phase of attempting to break through Russian lines and separate Russian troops from the factors enabling their resistance. We shall see.

UPDATE (Thursday): ISW doesn't think the slow progress is a sign of failure. But it isn't a sign of success: 

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky acknowledged that the progress of Ukrainian counteroffensives has been slower than expected, likely due to effective Russian defenses.

Not much of Ukraine's strategic reserve has been committed yet. If Russia is throwing in more of its reserves to keep the Ukrainians crawling, eventually the Russians may be so short of troops and supplies that the Ukrainians can commit a lot of the reserve.

UPDATE (Thursday): Ukraine blew a hole in one of the Chonhar bridges leading northeast out of Crimea.

FLASH OVERRIDE UPDATE (Friday): Geopolitical Futures alert:

Yevgeny Prigozhin, the head of Russia’s private military firm known as the Wagner Group, has accused the Russian military of attacking his forces and said he would answer with attacks of his own. Conflicting reports on social media suggest Russian military vehicles are on the streets of major Russian cities in anticipation of what Russia’s attorney general has called an “attempt to organize an armed rebellion.”

They don't know what is going on, but it seems dramatic.

News on the drama.

Hmmm. It's a long drive to Moscow for Prigozhin's troops.

UPDATE (Friday): What is Prigozhin's plan if this is an attempt to overthrow Putin? Does he expect his forces driving north to gather defections and supplies on the way?

That would reflect the Northern Expedition in China when the Nationalists defeated the warlords a hundred years ago to unify China. Those better trained Nationalist forces defeated enemies and gained supporters from that strength as they made their way north.

Or does he plan to hold an area in the south and hope to forge a "liberated zone."

Or will Russia gather enough forces to defeat and scatter the Wagner units?

I wonder if the Wagner forces are sufficiently loyal to Prigozhin?

While the Russian army is committed to fighting inside Ukraine, there are other forces available to Putin. We'll see if the National Guard is loyal to Putin.

What will the regions do? How ugly could this get?

Or will this resolved by the morning?

UPDATE (Friday): ISW doesn't think Prigozhin will win:

Wagner Group financier Yevgeny Prigozhin appears to have launched an armed rebellion on June 23 to force a leadership change within the Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) which is unlikely to succeed.

Prigozhin is striking the king in order to change the king's advisors? That seems foolish.

If Prigozhin knows he needs to kill the king, is he disguising his goals early on to buy time?

Or, as ISW suggests, did Prigozhin think he is acting on Putin's wishes to change military leadership? Especially in the Southern Military District?

UPDATE (Saturday): Wagner forces occupied a military headquarters in Rostov-on-Don; and a column of Wagner troops with a solitary tank on a flatbed truck were seen in Voronezh. 

It doesn't seem as if any Russian troops have defected to Prigozhin. But on the other hand, no Russian troops seem to have confronted his troops. Although Russian helicopters fired on the Wagner troops near Voronezh.

The Chechens are siding with Putin.

I'm not seeing people rallying to Prigozhin's side:

Officials across Russia have rallied behind President Vladimir Putin, publicly reiterating their allegiance to the Kremlin and urging mercenary leader Yevgeny Prigozhin to back down.

My guess is that this is basically over as a coup. How long will it take for Putin's loyalists to put them down? Will Wagner troops fight with defeat looming?

And how will this affect Russia's frontline troops? 

UPDATE (Saturday): Does Prigozhin have more support within Russia's military than is apparent?

Wagner Chief is shown casually meeting commander of the Southern Military District as well as the Deputy Defense Minister. 

This is a VERY serious development as is shows HIGHLY SENIOR members of the Russian Military collaborating with Wagner in this apparent coup.

Also:

In an audio recording , Prigozhin claimed that "where soldiers meet us, the Russian Guards and military police, they wave their hands cheerfully."

It may not be all over if behind-the-scenes negotiations for the loyalty of Russian military commanders is going on. 

Tip to Instapundit.

Prigozhin's success would not necessarily mean Russia will end the war. It may mean Russia tries harder to win.

Although once internal discord is unleashed, could any new Russian government do better than Kerensky in waging war more effectively than the Czar near the end of World War I before the Communists took over? And would whoever replaces Putin in effective control--if not formally--risk Kerensky's fate despite the intent to wage war more effectively?

UPDATE (Saturday): Will Putin use Prigozhin's Wagner uprising as an excuse to order full mobilization of Russia's people and economy? Putin doesn't need to admit his special military operation is really a war if the justification for mobilization is internal threats. 

UPDATE (Saturday): This post started wondering if Putin wanted to distract America from Ukraine with a sideshow in Syria. This week has ended with something that may be more than a sideshow for Russia inside Russia. 

UPDATE (Saturday): Wagner forces have advanced 200 miles toward Moscow already, 250 miles south of Moscow. Interesting that Putin's forces are hunkered down in Moscow that is being fortified. I don't assume the drive on Moscow is more than a token force reliant on defectors for mass. Am I wrong?

UPDATE (Saturday): A lot of the videos say this is very serious. I'm cautious about letting hope that internal divisions will undermine Russia's ability to wage war; and that a Prigozhin victory is necessarily a good thing. 

It is surely significant that Russian security forces haven't engaged Wagner forces already. And it is significant that Wagner forces seem to have a base of support in the south. But it is significant that Prigozhin is not getting open support, especially around Moscow. 

I wonder if some potential Prigozhin allies are waiting to see if the Wagner force marching on Moscow gets to within a certain distance of Moscow before coming out against Putin. We'll see.

UPDATE (Saturday): Will Putin get Lukashenko to send troops into Russia to resist Wagner?

UPDATE (Saturday): This is sheer extreme speculation, but would Putin use a tactical nuke on Wagner forces on the road to Moscow to demonstrate resolve while avoiding NATO response given the nuke is used on Russians rather than inside Ukraine? 

That might scare the Hell out of Russians to Putin's ultimate demise. And it might be a sign of Putin's weakness in having insufficient loyal security forces between him and Wagner. But is this a posssibility?

UPDATE (Saturday). Prigozhin said he is turning back his troops on the Moscow run; and Lukashenko claims to have brokered a deal.

UPDATE (Saturday): If this is the end of the insurrection, will Wagner troops get the choice of going to Africa to fight for Wagner in Russia's service or will they be put in penal battalions to die in frontal assaults at the front in Ukraine?

UPDATE (Saturday): It looks like the game is over for Prigozhin as Wagner is evacuating its positions in Rostov-on-Don in the south. What will the punishments be?

And what about the unlucky Russians who surrendered to Wagner or didn't resist its troops?

UPDATE (Saturday): Prigozhin will seek refuge in Belarus. Until he falls down a flight of stairs. It's not like he can flee to the West. Maybe he'll fly elsewhere and try his luck. Also: "Wagner Group rebels and their leader Yevgeny Prigozhin will not face criminal charges, the Kremlin has confirmed." We'll see what happens to Wagner troops outside of the criminal system. I see Africa or frontal assaults in their future.

UPDATE (Saturday): To bring this back to the original, the time in 2017 when Russia threatened an American base in Syria.

UPDATE (Sunday): What will the ripples from the Wagner insurrection look like?

Suggestions that Prigozhin’s rebellion, the Kremlin’s response, and Lukashenko’s mediation were all staged by the Kremlin are absurd. The imagery of Putin appearing on national television to call for the end of an armed rebellion and warning of a repeat of the 1917 revolution – and then requiring mediation from a foreign leader to resolve the rebellion – will have a lasting impact. The rebellion exposed the weakness of the Russian security forces and demonstrated Putin’s inability to use his forces in a timely manner to repel an internal threat and further eroded his monopoly on force. Prigozhin’s rapid drive towards Moscow ridiculed much of the Russian regular forces – and highlighted to any and all security figures, state-owned enterprises, and other key figures in the Russian government that private military forces separate from the central state can achieve impressive results. Wagner’s drive also showcased the degradation of Russia’s military reserves, which are almost entirely committed to fighting in Ukraine, as well as the dangers of reliance on inexperienced conscripts to defend Russia’s borders.

NOTE: ISW coverage of the war continues here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

Sunday, June 18, 2023

Weekend Data Dump

Keep out: "Poland has ordered 800 AGM-114R2 Hellfire missiles for its helicopters, which will arm the 96 AH-64E helicopter gunships Poland is purchasing from the United States." Poland doesn't want to tempt Russia with weakness. Will Ukraine follow Poland's path?

The Army's FBOH is now the M10 Booker. The only way the M10--the same designation as a World War II tank destroyer--makes sense is if it is mass produced to drive its cost down well below the Abrams, which I argued in Army magazine should have the role the Booker fills. And with a per-Booker cost of "$12.9 million, which includes spares, training and fielding", it isn't. Might have been better to restart production of the original M10. But wait, you say! The Booker can be airlifted! Your faith is almost cute. Anyway, burn baby, burn. Booker inferno. Hey, at least the Army made my sad mockery more alliterative.

Last week I noted the administration claim that reports about China setting up a spy base in Cuba were not accurate. I could have sworn this was old news but couldn't find a mention in TDR. I guess our denial of future Chinese plans was not technically a lie: "China has been operating a spy base in Cuba since at least 2019, part of a global effort by Beijing to upgrade its intelligence-gathering capabilities, according to a Biden administration official."

Oh. So close! One Republican presidential candidate wants to flip Russia against China by throwing Ukraine under the bus. That won't work. Russia will bank the concession and come back for more. Some are a short step from saying we should abandon Ukraine to save the planet, aren't they?  And it is immoral because goodness lessons won't change thugs. Remember, Russia needs America--not the other way around. Russian difficulties fighting Ukraine demonstrate what should have been obvious. We can demand a price from Russia. I'm just not swooning over this candidate.

Israel is not on the verge of striking Iran's nuclear infrastructure. But Israel can. When? "For years, Israel has been carefully watching as Iran makes headway toward nuclear capability." Yeah, and Iran knows Israel is watching carefully. The Iranians are fanatics--not stupid.

Climate change is a new form of a pagan religion (via Instapundit). Preaching to the TDR choir. And don't forget my song and poetry. Thankfully the urge for interpretive dance passed. Now go and emit no more.

Sometimes I worry that the Biden administration will appease Iran with a revived horrible nuclear deal and pretend it is Smart Diplomacy® because it gets Iran to pretend not to supply Russia with weapons and ammunition. In addition to pretending not to want nuclear weapons, of course. All we have to do is pretend to believe Iran. So that's totally going to be the reason given for a deal, isn't it?

Good God, she needs a vigorous beating with the clue bat. And now for something completely different:


Interesting: "The United States considers its alliance with the Philippines in the same category as the partnerships with Japan, Australia and South Korea, the Pentagon’s senior official overseeing the Indo-Pacific said Thursday." Is this assertion a sign that China is backing off as the Philippines stands up?

I recently heard the old "Rods from God" notion brought up. I never thought it was a good idea and now that you can put a warhead on a cheap drone I see no reason why anything to attack ground targets should be lofted into space on satellites. Also, cluster bombs are apparently bad even against a brutal invader. So, how about airborne bomb trucks with Lazy Dogs?

Ah, my fjords defense for protecting carriers may work for long-range anti-ship missiles but gravity bombs defeat that obstacle. Is the new concept just a repeat with nothing new to recommend it? So I retract my suggestion. Also from that initial post, the Navy has been reticent to admit carriers can even be damaged. I've never fallen for that delusion. I'm going to add this information to my "fjords" post.

Another indication that India is decoupling from Russian weapons: "Germany will build six submarines for the Indian Navy in its largest weapons deal with the South Asian country in 42 years. It makes Germany the latest Western nation to nibble at India's vast arms import market as supplies of Russian weapons dry up."

Hmmm. Have I been hasty in assuming recent accusations against Trump are more of the same BS? Perhaps Trump should face legal consequences for keeping classified nuclear documents. But if this accusation is true (big if?), there had best be an entire wing with Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden only the first high-level protected class people joining Trump in orange jumpsuits. Let a thousand investigations bloom?

I saw a story about Finland's new fence on its Russian border, with the question "A new Iron Curtain in Europe?" the title. The original Iron Curtain was a Soviet Russian highly defended obstacle to keep people in rather than let them flee the glories of communism to reach freedom. The Finnish fence is a flimsy speed bump to keep Russian out. A subtle, difference, I know. But surely 24 years haven't erased that basic knowledge, right?

And now for something completely different (I got the picture from The Week in Pictures):

 

Should we be afraid China would defeat America in a war? After the first couple days when China might execute a theater-wide Pearl Harbor, I'm not terribly worried about the first few months of a China-America war. As long as our local allies join us. Especially if we can build missile stockpiles before the war. But I am worried about repairing damaged warships--let alone building new ships--for a long war. And I worry that we over-estimate what China has to do to win in a Taiwan scenario. Say, what were the American flag officers doing all these years? But ideally China doesn't go to war to test whether their shiny military is as good as it looks in peacetime.

Oh, FFS: "The main goal against China, experts say, should be not to fight a war but to deter Beijing from starting one." Deterring China requires them to believe we will fight them effectively. Ah, "experts".

From the "Well, Duh" files: "Investigators who scrutinised top-secret intercepted communications and scientific research believe Chinese scientists were running a covert project of dangerous experiments, which caused a leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology and started the Covid-19 outbreak." Also: "China’s top naval scientist proposes a Star Wars-style ‘supership’ to convert nuclear energy to kinetic force weapons[.]" Am I astute, or what?


 

For a long time, it seemed as if only submarines could survive in a world of pervasive and persistent surveillance married to precision anti-ship weapons. Welp, sensors and computers may clear up the undersea murkiness: "No longer would submariners enjoy their seemingly everlasting advantage of being able to take advantage of the nature of water and hydrographic conditions—temperature, salinity, pressure—to hide from hostile subs, surface warships, and aircraft." And let's not overtax our pucker factor thinking about what happens to SSBN-based nuclear deterrence.

OPEC+ oil production cuts will likely be matched by non-OPEC production increases for the rest of this year. Tip to Instapundit. 

The Army met its retention goal early this fiscal year.

This level of violence would be considered a sign of defeat if an American ally experienced it: "There continues to be less fighting in Syria despite the continued presence of numerous mutually antagonistic groups in many parts of the country. So far this year there have only been a few hundred killed each month. This is a trend that has been continuing since the peak violence in 2014." But Russia intervened, so victory! We'll see if the volence ramps up.

Belarus is to get Russia-controlled tactical nukes from Russia much earlier than planned. This makes no sense to me. Russia has Kaliningrad further west. And longer-range nukes in Russia. Nukes in Belarus are pointless. Isn't this risking giving Belarus nukes to deter Russia if Belarus can bribe, blackmail, or intimidate the Russian controllers? Unless this is all a bluff and the warheads are inoperative. So just chest beating and flinging poo?

Those predictions of China's diplomatic victory with Iran and Saudi Arabia bringing peace in the Persian Gulf aren't unfolding: "so far, it looks like the Iranians are leveraging normalization to press their regional advantage rather than diminish tensions." Yeah: "Iran is using the China deal with Saudi Arabia as a shield for continued aggression rather than a means to bring peace to the region." The author says the deal is symbolizes that the Saudis lost their competition with Iran. Maybe. I think it was the Saudis telling America to take Saudi security concerns regarding Iran seriously--or the Saudis wouldn't resist Iran alone.

Syria: "A helicopter accident on Sunday in northeastern Syria injured 22 U.S. service members, according to U.S. Central Command."

I noted this before, but this article says Russia moved its best units from the Kherson front to meet the Ukrainian counteroffensive farther east. It is interesting that the Russians had to thin out that front to find reserves. It indicates the Russians are stretched even in the early stage of the counteroffensive. Also, at some point the Russian defenders will be too few to stop a Ukrainian river crossing on the Kherson front. When the flooding recedes and the land dries out, will Ukraine have that option?

I'm just getting ahead of the issue for March 2024. I wear green on St. Patrick's Day. It is a day of pride for Irish-American heritage. And an excuse to day drink. Which many Americans embrace to excess, passing out before noon. Amateurs. But if St. Patrick's Day becomes a day for pride for the most blatantly displayed sexual appetites of a minority of scantily clad Irish-Americans branded as representing all Irish-Americans--which all Americans must embrace even if there is kinky ball-gag line dancing in front of little children--I shall surely have harsh words for the Gaelic League. Not because I'm Irishphobic. But because I don't want sociopath fanatics to hijack a perfectly fine celebration of America's melting pot.

This is a problem because Artificial Intelligence writing is actually Simulated Intelligence that relies on plagiarizing. Human authors have the same problem when in their own ideological bubble of sources. Tip to Instapundit.

From the "Well, Duh" files: Schadentweet. And yes, both extremes have the problem. But only one side has the media and major institutions validating, supporting, and amplifying their cruel craziness. Tip to Instapundit.

Hmmm. Perhaps I was hasty in assuming Trump is guilty of the latest charges given court precedents. But if the point of prosecution is to gin up Democratic anger at Orange Hitler through another election cycle and influence swing voters, Democrats only need the case to fall apart after the 2024 election. Still, this article is about different documents than the ones that I referenced earlier in this post. We'll see.

What the Hell is Turkey's major malfunction? "Turkey is unlikely to signal it’s ready to approve Sweden’s bid to join NATO when both sides meet this week, despite the Nordic country’s hopes that a recent strict anti-terror law would persuade Ankara it’s cracking down on Kurdish militants." 

More European navies are deploying to the Asia-Pacific region. I've dismissed European states making the effort to deploy token naval forces there when I'd rather have them step up in Europe. I guess I've changed my mind because I accept this is not a warfighting effort but a tripwire that helps deter China. But I reject EU efforts to take charge of this effort. As you'd expect.

Ukrainian corruption is no reason to let Russia conquer Ukraine. Russia is far more corrupt, after all. We should reward Moscow? The farther east the line is held the less likely it is that American troops need to fight to hold the line. Fighting corruption in Ukraine is a long-term project. But Russia is the immediate problem.

America will send more military aid to Ukraine, including ammunition and some more Bradley Fighting Vehicles and Strykers (to replace losses?). 

Happy birthday to the United States Army. 

Will Iran invade Afghanistan, where Pushtuns and jihadis are consolidating control, to secure water supplies?

Making what little air power Ukraine has more effective: "Ukraine has received JDAMs and the new, longer (70 kilometers) range JDAM-ER. Ukrainians modified their Russian designed warplanes to use JDAM bombs."

Small Estonia at the tip of NATO's spear is arming up.

Germany has its first national defense strategy. That's nice. But without a military to carry out the strategy, it's just words.

Minimal ship manning as your starting point is a disaster waiting to happen. Ship's should plan to cope with minimal manning because of casualties to keep the ship in the fight--or just survive--in battle. Man your ship the way you want to fight because you'll fight the way you man your ship. Tip to Instapundit.

Be wary of the smart home. Early on I vowed never to go that way. It's bad enough when I want to throw my computer out the window when it gives me grief. Where do I throw my home when it does the same? But now people have another reason to avoid this. Will your very house be canceled for badthought?

Invading Ukraine in the first place is what caused the problem: "Russian President Vladimir Putin suggested Tuesday that he could order his troops to try to seize more land in Ukraine to protect bordering Russian territory[.]"

Putin will never agree to de-escalate the war he started? Sure, now. But eventually de-escalating the war may become his least-bad option among bad options if he is clearly losing. Let's focus on that rather than just falling for Putin's ploy that he will never stop until he's destroyed Ukraine.

The growing China-Russia axis? Oh, please.

A founding member of the Axis of Evil reaches out to the Axis of El Vil: "[Iranian] President Ebrahim Raisi’s visit to Nicaragua is his second stop, after Venezuela. He is also scheduled to visit Cuba, Iran's other ally in the region."

Decisive victory, marginal victory, or defeat. Alternative results for Ukraine's counteroffensive. 

The Army sees its aviation assets as key for Pacific operations. Shouldn't the Air Force be the primary force adapting its aviation assets for the region? I mean, what about the Army's core competencies? Are we really happy to simplify China's strategic problems?

Damn. More of that white supremacist violent tendencies in the Army. It's always in the last place you look.

Declare Mexican drug cartels terrorists? Personally, I think our non-military assets can fight the cartels if our federal leadership will use them. I think our military and intel assets have a big enough role fighting cartels. Are we to distract them from security dangers? Are we happy to risk drug-funded corruption in our national security entities?

Russia does what Obama (politely) and Trump (rudely) tried to achieve: NATO moves to make defense spending have a 2% of GDP floor.

Russia's invasion of Ukraine opened the money spigot for the M-1A2C which includes aiming improvements and an active protection system. Ten thousand Abrams have been built since the first models, judged half as capable as the latest.

China is slumping rather than bouncing back after its long Covid lockdowns (tip to Instapundit): "Chinese President Xi Jinping has instead been preparing his people for an era of lower growth, making it clear that's what the economy can achieve in its current state, and it's also the structure he likes. " Xi likes it because he values control over growth. If Xi starts ramping up xenophobia to maintain control in the absence of sufficient economic growth, neighbors should check ammo and double the guards. Especially if Xi finds the tiger he chose to ride isn't actually under his control.

Crap: "The USS Connecticut, a premier submarine that struck an underwater mountain in the South China Sea 19 months ago, won’t be back in service until early 2026 at the soonest, according to the US Navy, adding to a backlog of maintenance overhauls as the US faces a growing Chinese fleet." Houston, we have a problem. One more on top of the many that led to the collision.

Should the Navy set up its own "Area 51" in Lake Michigan to test unmanned vessels?

Think big! Biden: Hold my beer. He really is Obama's third term! And if he means the railroad will be across Asia, why does he want America to pay for something that is most useful to China?

Via Instapundit, is it possible China is sending agents or soldiers into America dressed as civilians? I have no idea. But I've long thought China would do that to Taiwan before invading. Sowing some chaos here might buy China some time to defeat Taiwan.

Assuming Russia doesn't conquer Ukraine, some NATO countries are looking at what kind of non-NATO membership security guarantees to Ukraine will help keep Russia as far east as possible.

Naval power: "India’s two aircraft carriers led their battle groups in a combined operation in the Arabian Sea earlier this week, showcasing what the service calls its 'formidable maritime capabilities' and ability to project power around the Indian Ocean and beyond." India should certainly be capable of cutting off China's sea trade through the Indian Ocean.

Perhaps we've been hasty, comrades. Tip to Instapundit.

The dream doesn't die: "Dubbed the ‘Warrior Suit,’ the idea of a brand new combat exoskeleton for soldiers is a “far-term” element of the Army’s robotics strategy[.]" Some day, our best special forces may have them. But I don't think this could ever be the mobile protected firepower that replaces tanks.

UN mission accomplished in Congo?

Oppression: "Internet security researchers found that some countries were using Chinese Huawei phone software to monitor and censor journalists of the government via a commonly used router accessory called middlebox hardware. Using special middlebox software supplied by Huawei, nations can quietly censor user access to certain subjects or identifying such users and secretly pass on offending messages to someone else." Also, Chinese parts with their origin disguised make it into American military systems.

The Army wants four Booker light tank battalions for four light infantry divisions; and wants "96 M10 Booker Combat Vehicles, with hopes to eventually produce over 500[.]" Huh. The Army certainly expects to lose a lot of Bookers if it needs 500 to sustain four battalions.

President Reagan's six assurances to Taiwan.

Who is doing it and was it effective? "A global cyberattack hit 'several' U.S. federal government agencies, exploiting a vulnerability in a commonly used software, according to the US Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA)."

Transnistria. I'd expect a Ukrainian operation to capture Russia's region bordering southwest Ukraine only if Ukraine's counteroffensive fails. 

One advantage America has over China is that everyone knows we will leave if asked: "The United States will be able to station troops and ships at military bases in Papua New Guinea (PNG) under a new security deal that could be pivotal in a clash with China over Taiwan."

Does this mean threats are greater or that Putin's paranoia is greater? "Mobile communications were severed Friday in Saint Petersburg in 'unprecedented' security measures as President Vladimir Putin attended a global economic forum amid growing Ukrainian attacks on Russian soil."

Because of China, mostly: "The national security advisers of the United States, Japan and the Philippines held their first joint talks Friday and agreed to strengthen their defense cooperation[.]"

Interesting: "The Washington Post reported on Thursday that the United States is giving tentative backing to a plan that would remove barriers to Ukraine's entry into NATO without setting a timeline for its admission." I'll guess that the biggest barrier is that Ukraine has a territorial dispute with Russia. Would NATO membership be the carrot to persuade Ukraine to make territorial concessions to Russia should Ukraine's counteroffensive fail to provide a substantial battlefield victory over the Russians?

Poland may buy a Swedish airborne early warning system: "Both Sweden and Poland want to monitor Russian operations over or on the Baltic Sea and a pair of GlobalEye aircraft would do that."

The federal government has made $3 trillion in improper payments since 2004. The sad thing is that on a per-year basis that's a rounding error in federal spending. Tip to Instapundit. 

And now for something completely different:



Some British Bank of England guy says that Brexit caused inflation in Britain. And apparently here and around the world, too! I guess he's pretty impressed that before Brexit he calculated the damage that he predicted Wuhan Flu spending sprees would inflict! Oh: "[Inflation] happened in coincidence with other factors[.]" You don't say? I think he's just an evil climate denier who says Brexit is the cause of all that is bad in Britain rather than the true villain, climate change. Best and brightest, indeed.

China's military budget is actually much larger than its published figures.

Germany's strategy looks great on paper, but: "In the face of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the gravest threat to European security since the end of the cold war, and in the unwonted light this has cast on the woeful state of Germany’s own army, the strategy paper does no more than restate the same promise. It hedges a bit, too, adding that 2% should be a multi-year average and that the government would strive to implement this 'at no additional cost to the federal budget'." After loudly waking up to the Russian threat to Europe, it would be embarrassing to Germany if it didn't at least pretend to follow up on it's beating with the clue bat that it so badly needed. But the weight of history remains a convenient excuse to only pretend.

The Biden administration's turns its war to erase women to flaming hot "11" level. 

Strategery: "There is an irony that the catalyst for [NATO's] new and bolder changes stem from Vladimir Putin’s attempt to fracture and weaken the alliance. The illegal invasion of Ukraine has pushed NATO to become stronger, not weaker." Meanwhile in Asia.

I mentioned this news before: " The U.S. Air Force and a MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) Artificial Intelligence project succeeded in developing a MagNav (Magnetic Navigation) application reliable enough to be used in air force aircraft to replace GPS for navigation." It has not been put on bombs or missiles. How long will it take to spread this through the military? And what will the countermeasures be? Notwithstanding that it can't be jammed.

Justifying hate. I had sort of a reverse education. Growing up in Detroit, I eventually figured out I was smart. But I never developed a sense of superiority, resentment, and hate for the family I loved, the friends I valued, or the fellow blue collar people I grew up with. Like everyone--including me--they had virtues and flaws. But when I went to college, I could see that the reputation of the educated class was way over-rated. I valued my unique opportunity at the University of Michigan. But I didn't learn to hate the credentialed. Professor Singer at Michigan (political science) was great. He was liberal. Professor Ober (history) was great. Professor Abbot at Eastern Michigan (military history) was great. And others at Michigan and Eastern I remember as really good and I respected them. These three stand out in my memory after all these decades, however. Most of my fellow students were great people, mind you. Yet I sure did learn to resent the sense of superiority with no obvious foundation that some developed. And here we are. With ugly hate justified and defended as progressive with rationale no less odious than the race-based superiority and hate of the past. 

Don't make the mistake of thinking this is analogous to our Supreme Court. Netanyahu's plan may not be the best. Out of my lane. But the opposition won't be blamed for not being willing to compromise on fixing an obviously broken system: "Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Sunday his government intends to move ahead on contentious plans to change the country's judicial system after talks aimed at finding a compromise solution appeared to be crumbling." 

Well I'm sure his defense will be he is trans-species and is just living the truth of his life. Although it isn't fair to link him to Senator Warren or leftists in general just because he donated to her. I know the left does this. But I just want to note my opposition to this line of attack. No individual is responsible for the the views of  any person who supports him or her. There is no transitive property of support. Tip to Instapundit.

While I suspect Russia blew the Kahkhovka dam, I question my judgment when the NYT agrees: "Evidence suggests this month's destruction of the huge Kakhovka dam in a Russian-controlled area of Ukraine resulted from an inside explosion set off by Russia, The New York Times said." This is the price our elite media pays for becoming political activists.

It seems odd that as of several days ago I'm getting a lot of hits from an Amazon account in Singapore to seemingly random old--like a decade or more old--posts. With no referring link so it is all just direct, apparently. Weird. And disturbing. Although obviously a different online behemoth and not the supervising one.

On Father's Day I remain grateful for having such wonderful children.

Happy Juneteenth! Tomorrow, June 19th, marks the day the armies of a Republican administration told the last slaves in Texas that they were freed from slavery under a finally defeated Democratic secessionist government that fought hard to keep them enslaved. That is a worthy celebration. I fly my American flag this day.

Saturday, June 17, 2023

Where Will the Dead Cat Bounce?

If China is weakening from its peak, it is still powerful and will be for decades or centuries. Even internal convulsions may only be a gap in China's global reach. How will China try to make the most of its power if it is declining? Projecting an image of continuing power will perhaps be key to keeping a lid on its people who are denied ever-expanding economic opportunities as the price of accepting the Chinese Communist Party monopoly on power.

 

China's population has peaked. That is perhaps a warning sign of broader problems. Have we passed Peak China's military and economic power, with suppressed discontent only hidden and impotent for now?

Probably. But that change will likely take time to have a noticeable effect. Even a relatively weakening China may be able to defeat smaller neighbors isolated long enough to avoid foreign intervention. 

And that discontent might take decades to harm China--if it erupts. And what comes after Xi's system? Do we have to choose?

The vast majority of attention remains on Taiwan as China's potential target, as a IISS report states:

China remains the "leading long-term challenge" to the existing international order and there is no evidence that Russia’s faltering invasion of Ukraine has changed Beijing’s thinking around "the timescale or methodology" for any potential attack on Taiwan[.]

That's my judgment. China's rulers just don't learn what we try to teach them. On the other hand, I have no idea if China is close to invading Taiwan or just wants to create that threat in the minds of Taiwan and its friends to demoralize and discourage them over time.

Perhaps China simply doesn't want to risk war with America and its allies and will look at targets more likely to be isolated at least in part from potential powerful allies. North Korea could be a target. Myanmar (Burma) could be a target. India could be a target. 

Or Russia. If China has peaked, I thought Russia makes a logical target:

If China tries to salvage something from their peak of power and strikes America, America needs to avoid giving China the option of crippling American power in the western Pacific to clear the decks for a war against a local target that might cement Chinese gains in a peace treaty before China's relative decline is clear.

Does a suddenly weakened Russia with its Potemkin military exposed in Ukraine create an opportunity for China? Or does a weakened Russia that has alienated the West give China more time to think about the Russia Question?

When Russia invaded Ukraine, China perhaps thought it could benefit by weakening NATO and the West with a display of raw power it could not stop. As Russia faceplants, China finds it can benefit from Russia's exposed and growing weakness. 

That's what I've been saying. And rather than wonder what China might demand from Russia to help it recover--which is one possibility--that author above wonders what I wonder--will China find it can benefit more from Russia as a target rather than as an ally or even a vassal?

That initial author judges the problems caused by Xi's tightened control are likely long-term issues:

However, for now, there seems little threat to the CCP. Despite its corruption and inefficiencies, the Party continues to rule largely unopposed — watchful and often vengeful, but not fearing for its immediate future. Such was the tsarist system of Nicholas I. His success in staving off change helped ensure cataclysmic transformation just over a half-century after his death. The lessons for Xi Jinping could not be clearer.

Does Xi know the true trajectory?  Or will he make decisions based on a mirage of power? And if Xi know the truth, can he leverage that purported long-term planning ability of Chinese rulers to correct the problem? Or will he be content to maintain the illusion of continued Chinese power so he can peacefully die in his bed after 40 years as emperor of a 21st Century Middle Kingdom?

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Friday, June 16, 2023

Blaming the Victim

Russia is responsible for its aggression and ambitions. That so many Westerners continue to defend Russia's aggression as justifiable because European states don't want Russia to reimpose control of large swathes of democratic Europe is repulsive. And as Russia's war crimes become more evident, the impulse to excuse the Russian actions is indefensible.

NATO "provoked" Russia's invasion of Ukraine by "expanding" NATO into former Soviet vassal regions. And Ukraine "provoked" the invasion by wanting NATO protection.  

His argument is BS. NATO must be capable of defending its member states. And that resistance must include:

not falling prey to narratives that seek to blame the victims of Russian threats, subversion, and aggression for said threats and aggression. Russia’s phony, self-serving narrative, like its overall information war, represents an assault on the very notion of objective truth. The integrity of the historical record is under attack, and defending it will help strengthen the foundations of European security. The false narrative peddled by Moscow and its supporters is not only factually wrong, it is morally and strategically corrosive. It is high time we defend that record and expose this deceitful narrative for the fraud it is.

Clearly, that author argues, ex-Soviet countries had no right to want protection from Russia. Any people who escaped Soviet/Russian control in Europe should have just patiently waited for the Russians to regain sufficient power to re-conquer them. That's certainly the Russian view, which rejects the sovereignty of every state that escaped Russian control. 

The initial author's idiocy is stunning--calling Ukrainians afraid of Russia "Russophobic" is merely the most glaring example. 

NATO did not "expand" into eastern Europe. Former Russian vassals eagerly requested membership in NATO. 

Mind you, this doesn't mean that NATO has an obligation to admit everyone who applies. The alliance is for the purpose of defending its members and not saving non-member states from Russian conquest. New members should be a provider of security and not only a consumer. I'm agnostic on whether Ukraine should be a member. 

Time has made admitting Ukraine to NATO more of a potential problem as Russia gained strength following its post-USSR nadir. It may have been better to admit Ukraine a decade or more ago if it was necessary to protect NATO.

On the other hand, Russia's clear willingness to lose lots of men in a long and brutal war may make membership a good idea now. And Russia's brutality has made Ukrainians--largely pro-West for a long time--far more broadly anti-Russian than they were a decade ago.

And Ukraine's willingness and ability to fight Russia shows they have the ability to be a provider of security to NATO.

It's possible that in another decade after this war ends that NATO will think it should have admitted Ukraine a decade earlier when Russia was temporarily weakened by this war.

Still, I'm conflicted on admitting Ukraine to NATO. What I'm not conflicted about is that Russia is a brutal aggressor and Ukraine does not deserve a fate of Russian control. And Russia should not control an unwilling Ukraine. I want Russia as far east as possible. An objective even more important by Russia's record in its invasion of Ukraine.

If Russia controlled Ukraine, could NATO prevent Russia from grabbing large chunks of territory from a member state bordering Russia and holding it against an eventual NATO counteroffensive?

And how many times could Russia carry out that kind of limited conquest before it added up to something significant?

Remember, no buffer will ever satisfy Russia. And it didn't matter how weak NATO was.

#WhyRussiaCan'tHaveNiceThings

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Thursday, June 15, 2023

Air Power Lesson Learned?

Is the lack of air power the reason the Winter War of 2022 has been largely static for more than half a year? Is that the lesson we should draw from the war so far? I don't think so.

Oh?

"What you are seeing particularly in Ukraine at the moment, is how essential it is to secure the necessary level of access to airspace. If you don't, standby for a bloody attritional slog with images that look like they have come out of World War One".
This view was echoed by Maj Gen James Kriesel, National Guard Assistant to the Commander, USAFE-A, later in the day, who said that "there are some out there that say that air dominance is not critical. And that what matters is owning key terrain, mashing of forces and logistics to really support an artillery slugfest. I disagree. If anything is conflict demonstrates that the protracted brutality of a conflict where neither side has gained air dominance".

That first quote was the deputy commander of the NATO air command. 

There is no evident cause-and-effect like that from the Winter War of 2022.

Russia advanced quite quickly in the south despite not using open Ukrainian skies early in the war.

And Russia advanced in Luhansk and Kharkiv provinces despite not using much air power.

Russia faltered not from lack of air power but because reliable Ukrainian ground forces finally arrived to bar the Russian advance in the south. And Russian logistics faltered too far from railroads.

On the other side, Ukraine managed to easily advance despite having little air power on the Kherson front and on the Kharkiv front. 

We shall see if the big Ukrainian counteroffensive takes ground. If it does, will we stop insisting that air power is necessary to advance and avoid static trench warfare?

Still, the air marshal did specify "necessary level of access to airspace". Notwithstanding what the American major general said in support of the crucial role of air power, perhaps we need to go to the Definitions section.

Because while I value close air support and ground attack, I think it is possible the Air Force mostly needs to deny the enemy use of the air to attack friendly ground targets. If ground forces have the necessary assets, ground-based fire support is enough to advance and maneuver. As long as enemy air power is nullified.

"Necessary level of access" to the airspace over a battlefield may be achieved with cheap drones that can be lost in large numbers and space assets that look down from relative safety.

I mean, the lack of Air Force interest in providing close air support to ground forces seemingly indicates the Air Force doesn't think maneuver is only possible if airplanes intervene in the ground fight. 

NOTE: The image was made with DALL-E.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.