Sunday, July 09, 2023

Weekend Data Dump

Does the U.S. need to rethink our Cold War and post-Cold War security system: "Today’s world is defined by China’s return to global importance. The United States is not only the largest destination for Chinese exports, but almost every country in the world is one of its major trading partners. China has used this revenue to modernize its military, fund a global development program, and position itself as a competitor to US power." Is the assumption in that argument wrong?

I don't blame Ukraine for trying to drag NATO into the war: "Ukraine has invited NATO countries to join it in a program to demine the Black Sea." They're desperate for something that could end the war. But that doesn't mean we should fall for it. Better to organize African and Middle Eastern countries that rely on Black Sea grain exports to do the actual mine sweeping.

It's come to this: Liberals are enraged that upper middle class college students who will have cushy careers will have to pay back the loans they decided to take out in order to get their degrees. Is it okay to tell them to "f**k off"? I mean, really f**k off. Via Instapundit.

North Korea: Quantity has a target quality all its own.

South Korea is designing a new tank called the K3, which in concept reflects the failed Russian T-14 Armata. The K3 prototype is anticipated in 2030.

Israel will buy 25 more F-35s. Israel has 50 already. For those who still wonder if the plane is any good that should be convincing.

So universities can put thumbs on the scale for socio-economic handicaps even if they can't use race? Surely that's better than using race and ethnicity. But thank God I didn't have to start a career under a cloud of wondering if I really earned a place in the University of Michigan. I made it in on grades and standardized test scores. I'm biased, but I think those should be the only criteria. That would prevent the wealthy and connected from getting points on all the other BS that orbits academic abilities for admissions purposes. I came stupidly close to blowing my opportunity. But I digress.

Because he already wrapped up that dystopian present of global truly terrifying human rights violations, he has time to think about other things: "Climate change threatens to deliver a 'truly terrifying' dystopian future of hunger and suffering, the United Nations' human rights chief warned Monday." I'm getting a lot of use for my "eff off" reflex this week.

Collateral damage from Putin's invasion of Ukraine: Companies invested in China worry about being caught on the wrong side of a Western sanctions wall if China invades Taiwan.

It is established that "just following orders" is no defense for committing crimes. Also, if you try to do the right thing you might be accused of committing a crime. When you strike a king, kill him. But who will kill the bureaucracy that has become a powerful fourth branch of government? We need a bureaucracy that isn't a fourth branch. How deep should the purges go? And with civil service protections, simply eliminating the budgets of entire agencies might be the only way to go. Then hire a fraction of the laid off willing to honestly do their jobs somewhere else.

If slavery is an original sin in America (ignoring the global history and present of that abomination) that can never be erased, how did the Democratic Party avoid responsibility for defending slavery for so long, up to and including armed insurrection--and then a century of segregation enforced by its armed wing of the KKK designed to continue the practice without technical ownership? I mean, putting the guilt on America, which waged a long and bloody war to end slavery in portions of America to finally enforce the promise of our Constitution, was truly an epic propaganda effort of Russian proportions. And let's not even go into the BS of blaming the other party ... I mean, come on! Not that I think most Democrats are racist. The vast majority are fine people. But if an institution can be guilty, let's hit the right target.

This seems futile: "The International Monetary Fund has agreed to provide $3 billion to Pakistan in badly needed relief to help bail out the impoverished country’s ailing economy." But Pakistan has nukes and jihadis that for the moment are separate. So the check gets signed. 

Yeah: "The United States Navy helped secure victory in two world wars and the Cold War. Today the Navy remains a formidable fighting force, but even officers within the service have questioned its readiness." I know I'm worried.

I have admitted that the F-35 can provide close air support and that the low-level A-10 mission is probably futile in high-intensity combat. The plane carrying out the mission was never the issue. The Air Force is replacing the A-10 in two units, with one continuing the close air support mission. Just one. We'll see if my trust issues are addressed.

The Army's navy: "A U.S. Army watercraft unit equipped with more than a dozen transport vessels will be homeported in Japan, the commander of U.S. Army Pacific told soldiers during a recent visit to this base in Kanagawa prefecture."

West Point graduates concerned about the direction of the institution have founded an alternative graduate organization, the MacArthur Society: "West Point’s reason for existing is to train Army officers to win our nation’s wars. Period. Instead of winning wars, debacles like Kabul 2021 continue to happen. Many of the generals responsible for that debacle were unfortunately West Point graduates. Instead of focusing on duty, honor, country, USMA is focusing on identity issues, tribalism, pronouns, and the football team’s record." We already saw the commie in the coal mine there. Although I disagree with the notion that since 1945 we lose our wars--Afghanistan excepted. But I like the focus on winning wars above all else. Nobody responsible for the debacle in Afghanistan was fired or resigned.

The extended riots in France by Moslems--although obviously a minority of them: "This is largely an insurrection without aims: a scream of fury, an anarchic rejection of government; an act of gang-warfare writ large; a competition in performative destruction." That's nice. No worries, then! But as I mentioned last week, what if a nuclear-armed Iran gave those rioters direction and a goal? Things can always get worse.

As France burns, the far right rises there. Well, duh. If the respectable mainstream politicians and elites don't address the concerns of growing numbers of people because those concerns are viewed as "phobic" or an "ist", less reputable leaders who accept the concerns are valid will gain influence.

Is Xi's call for college graduates to go to the farms to appreciate their struggles and value really the same as Mao's order to go to the countryside and toil alongside them? Some things are ominous, I admit. And it could get out of hand. If Xi effs up Chinese agriculture, things could get ugly.

China hosted the leaders of Central Asian former-Soviet countries: "The pomp, and the praise that Xi and his guests from Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan heaped on one another, led some observers to proclaim a Sino-Russian scramble for Central Asia in which Beijing had just notched a victory at the Kremlin’s expense." China has a way to go. But China is going.

Hmmm: "Explosive devices and Molotov cocktails were used to target multiple [Washington, D.C.] businesses early Sunday morning, according to authorities."

Are Russian minefields the main problem slowing Ukraine's troops?

College applicant makes his case for a high Disadvantage Score to gain admission:


Learning: "'The Chinese and Russian navies have close exchanges and frequent interactions,' the [Chinese Ministry of Defense] quoted [Minister Li Shangfu] as saying." China has an incentive to observe Russia's navy closely. I kid, I kid! They're best friends. There's no way Russia should worry. 

 

 

Can any encryption not based on a similar computer constantly changing the defenses futile? "Google has developed a quantum computer that instantly makes calculations that would take the best existing supercomputers 47 years[.]"Tip to Instapundit.

Israel is going in big with its military into the occupied West Bank city of Jenin on the apparent belief it is a terrorist sanctuary. It seems like a bunch of jihadi groups are there. My question is whether this is ultimately a Fatah sanctuary or a Hamas sanctuary. Heck, could it be a direct Iran project?

Good bye A-10.

Danger zone: "US Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Mike Gilday said mid-June that Ukrainian have been very effective in terms of pushing the Russian navy back in the Black Sea. He said: 'When you take a look at the numbers of Russian ships that are operating in the Black Sea now, it's at a much lower rate than we've seen in the past.'" Crimea may be a nice power projection platform in peacetime. But with enemies around the Black Sea coast, Crimea doesn't prevent those enemies from turning the sea into a turkey shoot. If Russia has to pull back with the Ukrainian threat, it has no chance against NATO assets.

Happy Independence Day! I love my country independent of who is in the White House.
I've got complaints. But our politicians aren't our country. If you only love America when your party controls the federal government, you don't love America. You have a transactional relationship with America. You actually love your party. Still, we'll get through this. We've gotten through bigger divisions than we mostly seem to experience on social media these days:




So we could block out the sun to save us from the sun? Interesting. But how many times can we set fire to Canada to do that?



Climate Change is the real problem: "During the last ten years, over 78,000 Nigerians were killed by Islamic terrorists, bandits, fighting between farmers and herders, and local unrest. Most of the deaths were due to Islamic terrorism, especially against Christians, banditry and clashes between farmers and herders."

Cloaks of invisibility. The fight against drone eyes in the sky continues.

I find it astounding that after the debates about whether the AMX-10 is a tank or not--it's not, it's an armored car--people are shocked that it is vulnerable to explody things nearby.

This is absofreakinguseless: "The global chemical weapons watchdog said Tuesday it found no evidence to support a claim by Syria that its forces were attacked using toxic gas in 2017." Six years later. Why bother? "Watchdog", indeed.

Mid-Week July 4th memes.

America is only an Arsenalish of Democracy rather than the Arsenal of Democracy as some boast: "But this lofty rhetoric does not match the reality on the ground. Shortages in production, inadequate labor pools, and interruptions in supply chains have hamstrung the United States’ ability to deliver weapons to Ukraine and enhance the country’s defense capabilities more broadly." Indeed. But we should be.

The British never really felt European. Sadly, whatever grey apparatchiki rule in Brussels are only the latest continentals who have wanted to drag Britain into Europe.

With Finland and Sweden in NATO, Russia is all alone in the Arctic. I mentioned that value. 

China's top diplomat revived the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere, telling the Japanese and South Koreans: "'No matter how blonde you dye your hair, how sharp you shape your nose, you can never become a European or American, you can never become a Westerner,' Wang said. 'We must know where our roots lie.'"

Second Thomas Shoal: "The Philippines on Wednesday accused China's coast guard of harassment, obstruction and 'dangerous manoeuvres' against its vessels, after another incident near a strategic feature of the South China Sea that has become a flashpoint between them." You may recall that shoal.

Continuity during a European war: "NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg will stay in office for another year, the 31-nation military alliance decided on Tuesday."

Just. Stop: "In a June 30 solicitation, the Defense Innovation Unit is seeking 'novel commercial solutions that enable responsive and precise point-to-point delivery of cargo to, from, and through space.'" It's so much more fun to push this futuristic notion than to just build more f**king transport planes, eh? At least putting Marines on one of those rockets is dead. It is dead, right? Right?!

African Union peacekeepers will leave Somalia. The question is how long will it take to be reminded why they were needed. 

Training Ukrainian soldiers. Also: "most of the [Russian] troops have little training or advanced tech and suffer from low morale and poor leadership." But they're holding the line as Ukraine counter-attacks. Maybe a combination of fear of being shot and lots of Russian fire support is compensating. But low morale isn't apparent so far.

Boom: "Russia’s giant 240mm self-propelled mortars are appearing in increasing numbers on the battlefield in Ukraine – and getting destroyed just as fast." Sending the cumbersome mortars was a response to shortages of gun ammunition. I've read Ukraine has been successfully hitting Russian artillery, so this isn't a shock. But the absolute numbers of the mortars destroyed isn't high.

Signs of Russian poor morale? As long as this is isolated, it doesn't matter. As long as they keep fighting, it doesn't matter. As long as the front is mostly static, troops with poor morale will defend themselves even if not enthusiastically. They are vulnerable to cracking only if the Ukrainians force the Russians to retreat on a large scale. Which is what I've been saying for a while. I worry Ukraine gave Russia too much time.

We are not on the brink of a climate disaster. Claims we are on the brink are meant to frighten us into giving them the power to fine tune the climate--as if that is possible. These loons should be mocked. We'll be fine as we learn to cope and address the problems that arise over time.

Will the Supreme Court dismantle the federal administrative state? It certainly needs to be curbed. I worked on this at the state level. Rules for technical things to implement policy statutes are good. Rules that make policy are bad. Legislative oversight is essential to prevent the agencies from doing the latter. Sadly in Michigan the state supreme court ruled that oversight was an unconstitutional legislative veto. The only solution is to deny agencies the authority to write rules. But addressing this is fighting the symptoms. The cure is to reduce the scope of federal actions and let states do them.

Why did I not know that China owes American bondholders about $1 trillion? This is more than the $850 billion in American government bonds that China holds. We pay the interest. China does not. This really undermines the long-held argument that China has America on a leash because they can call in their loans if we act against them, doesn't it? Or will we just erase the debt? Unlike Britain. Tip to Instapundit.

Republicans shouldn't make so much of Biden's refusal to recognize his grandchild by Hunter. All Biden has to do is have the friendly media at some family event where Biden embraces (but not in a creepy, hair-sniffing way--which is a risk) a cute little girl. Ka-ching! The little girl will be stiff-armed quietly after, but the video and media adulation will linger on. Reelection assured. 

Iran works on blackmailing America into another nuclear deal--with a benefit of pushing oil prices up for its close friend Russia: "Iran tried to seize two oil tankers near the strategic Strait of Hormuz early Wednesday, firing shots at one of them, the U.S. Navy said." The U.S. blocked Iran.

I know I'd never visit China: "On June 30, citing Chinese detentions of US citizens under vague anti-espionage laws, the Department of State website advised American citizens to 'reconsider travel to Mainland China', 'to the Hong Kong SAR', and 'to the Macau SAR' due to 'the arbitrary enforcement of local laws'."

From the "Well, Duh" files: "Ukraine's war with Russia is giving NATO countries the chance to test their advanced weaponry on an actual battlefield, and they're gaining valuable insight as a result, the Financial Times reported."

Wait. What? "Joe Biden is pushing for Ursula von der Leyen to be installed as the next Nato secretary general after Ben Wallace’s candidacy was blocked, The Telegraph can disclose." Is Biden insane? Or do you think she did such a great job for Germany? She's just a Trojan horse for the proto-imperial EU to undermine NATO and eject America. 

Sadly true: "The country today is run by politicians who spend all their time telling us freedom is dangerous, and the press won’t go near the word unless it can wedge it into an act of self-flagellation[.]" Tip to Instapundit.

Huh: "Among other findings, the veteran community, as a whole, did not manifest higher support [for extremists groups] than the general population. Interestingly, the majority of those who supported political violence were not also supporters of specific groups." There was a lot of unfair media claiming higher support. Also, Antifa had much more support than white nationalists.

The Ukrainians don't believe Russia has moved tactical nuclear weapons to Belarus yet.

Sh*t got real: "China imposed restrictions on exporting two metals that are crucial to parts of the semiconductor, telecommunications and electric-vehicle industries in an escalation of the country’s tit-for-tat trade war on technology with the US and Europe." Everyone else seems to be able to get stuff despite sanctions, via smugglers and front companies. I bet we can get gallium, germanium, and the other stuff. Tip to Instapundit.

Good if true: "'At this stage of active hostilities, Ukraine's Defense Forces are fulfilling the number one task – the maximum destruction of manpower, equipment, fuel depots, military vehicles, command posts, artillery and air defense forces of the Russian army,' Danilov, head of Ukraine's National Security and Defence Council, wrote on Twitter."

Useful ancient tanks: "In Ukraine the T-55s were used by both sides to support infantry attacks or as defensive pillboxes." LOL! Right? At least Ukraine's are modernized! Stupid Russians. Meanwhile, we will spend $13 million per copy (including spares, training, and fielding--and don't forget the undercoating!) for the Booker light tank to do the same thing. Who's looking stupid? I wish we had old M-48s to refurbish for our infantry.

America's Air Mobility Command conducts logistics exercises with allies in INDOPACOM. It's tough to prepare for a fight away from the Japan-South Korea corner of the command.

Russia is beginning to upgrade its minesweeper ships: "Currently only four more are under construction but it is uncertain if money will be available to build more any time soon because of the cuts to the naval budget. This is a side-effect of the unexpected high costs of the Ukraine War effort." Ukraine may have sunk some of the current Russian navy, but Putin is sinking the future Russian navy.

Russia tried to knock down American drones over Syria without shooting at it.

America is working on AI for fighter aircraft. It's here to stay, the Air Force says. Our pilot skill has been a major advantage. Will we have to rely on our programming and AI for that edge in the future?

Where is Prigozhin, anyway? Did he ever go to Belarus (as if even that is safe for him)? Or was that just a story to get his loyalist troops out of Russia where they can essentially be imprisoned in camps surrounded by Belarusian troops whose job doesn't require Putin to divert any troops from the war.

We've seen this problem developing a long time: "America desperately needs more ships, but maintenance delays result in, as one retired admiral put it, 'the equivalent of losing half an aircraft carrier and three submarines each year.'" Yeah.  I'm sure our Navy leadership is right on it.

It's like calling Al Capone an "expert" on banks: "Columbia ‘First Amendment’ expert defends feds working with Big Tech on ‘content moderation’[.]" Also, "content moderation" is government censorship. You can name it something lovely like a "rose", but the point of it all is still the thorns. Tip to Instapundit.

This sounds like hope as an alternative to a counteroffensive that succeeds: "The head of Ukraine's main intelligence directorate (GUR) has said that Russia is on the brink of civil war that could tear the country apart."

India makes a gesture to American concerns: "India revised its position on the 2016 South China Sea Arbitration last week in a meeting between Indian and Filipino diplomats that supports Manila’s territorial claims over China." How long before India can "Fight East"?

They aren't called missile magnets for nothing: "Ukraine's success in destroying Russian command posts has raised a troubling question for the US military: If Ukraine can do this to Russian headquarters, can other militaries, especially China's, do it to American HQs?" Soft vehicles, expensive equipment, highly trained officers and NCOs, parked close together, and emitting in every possible way you can imagine. What could go wrong?

Fascinating. I never really thought about that.

While the left drones on about defending "our democracy", Biden and his allies threaten our "rule of law." Which is the real foundation of our democracy--not counting votes until you win. I try not to get all dark about this. I assume we'll bounce back. But it's hard to maintain that confidence these days.

Is Russia's defense line brittle because Russia has no reserves to rotate into the line? Are the troops enduring the fight for so long capable of continuing to fight when the going gets tough? Also, are Russian troops attacking already destroyed equipment to inflate body equipment counts? These are allegations by Russian milbloggers--not ISW's assessment.

Germany does build weapons: "German arms manufacturer Rheinmetall plans to begin production at a new facility in 2025 to build 'at least 400' F-35A center fuselages[.]" Turkey used to have that job until they got too close to Russia.

Is federal control of the National Guard illegal and only possible if the state accepts federal funding? Could be, apparently. But the Army Reserve and Air Force Reserve might get much bigger if the feds have to cope by cutting funding to state Guard forces. States are not going to pay for that kind of firepower.

And now for something completely different:


Mali's corrupt government decided corruption profit is worth letting jihadis take over the north. Foreign peacekeepers tried to stop that. Wagner, hired by Mali, is content to participate in the profit.

Is lack of air power the reason Ukraine hasn't broken through Russian lines? "Tanks, armored infantry and self-propelled artillery need air cover to maneuver. Air interdiction of enemy reserve forces and close air support (CAS, i.e., airstrikes on adjacent enemy forces) 'soften' the enemy so mobile forces can breakthrough and achieve a decisive victory." That's a theory for air power. I have another.

I'm so old I remember when global sea-based supply chains were the priority to keep our economies from tanking. Never mind: "Maritime nations agreed Friday to slash emissions from the shipping industry to net zero by about 2050 in a deal that several experts and nations say falls short of what's needed to curb warming to agreed temperature limits."

Prigozhin never made it to Belarus, it seems. Is this a sign there are deeper problems inside Russia than just a one-off revolt? Or is it a sign that Prigozhin is destined for torture by the Russians and eventual death? I don't follow this closely enough, but has the man been sighted despite "news" about his activities?

The Somalia of the Western Hemisphere: "The United States remains active in its search for a country to head a multinational force in troubled Haiti, Secretary of State Antony Blinken said Thursday, without offering Washington's lead." But without jihadis. So we've got that going for us. Which is nice.

Arleigh Burke destroyers since 1991 have been a tremendous success. But new weapons and systems exceed the capacity of the hull to incorporate. But a successor won't happen: "DDG(X) probably is not going to happen. It costs too much." FFS. In completely unrelated news, "China now has the largest ship building industry in the world."

Sadly, Erdogan won reelection and he continues to block Sweden's admission to NATO. Hungary has pegged its position to Turkey's. Still, the NATO bribe might be big enough. And maybe only Nixon can go to China. Damn, I really am an optimist.

Russia's four possible futures after the Wagner Revolt: Bad, Worse, Pucker Factor Redlines, and LOL!

Is Iran preparing to go to war with America? Russia would certainly like that. Ideally from the mullah perspective, Iran just threatens such a war, throws Russia under the bus, and gives Biden an excuse to give Iran a Nuclear Deal 2.0 that grants Iran all its wishes. While pretending this represents Smart Diplomacy® that preserved peace.

No more inland halls. Just all the shores: "The U.S. Marine Corps is undergoing its biggest reorganization in decades, slimming down and chopping weapon systems, such as tanks and howitzers, in an effort to become quicker, more agile, and more lethal, while specializing in operating in island chains and coastal areas." Tip to Instapundit.

After disaster strikes, government: "We're here to help kill off more of you." Oops. I figured the government saved lives from Covid, but that the lockdown effects might make the total more harm than good. It notes more traffic accidents, among other causes of increased deaths. Which raised my memory of early Covid driving that seemed to trend toward Mad Max rules as many seemed to disregard traffic regulations. But don't worry, governments and WHO have learned their lesson. Just kidding. They want even more power for the next disaster. Tip to Instapundit.

Calm down. Now go and emit no more.

Related, I recently heard that the vaccines originally did stop Covid; which prevented it from being spread by the vaccinated. But the engineered virus mutated and nullified that benefit very rapidly, making the vaccine an increasingly less effective treatment for reducing the impact of getting Covid. The vaccines just didn't keep up. I did not know that.

Interesting: "But the Stinger missile design is so old, and the stockpiles of the missiles being expended so quickly, that Stinger-maker Raytheon is asking for its retired missile makers to teach current workers how to restart production[.]" 

Prigozhin may not have gone to Belarus. Seriously, what is going on? Is he even alive? Does Putin have a Prigozhin double running around?? I think I'm joking.

Honestly, this story about cheap, garage AI that Ukraine is using to fight Russia sounds like propaganda. I'm sure Ukraine is doing stuff with computers and software automation. But I bet calling it "AI" is a stretch.

Might do the Nordic Luddite some good.

Of course, NATO members were supposed to meet the 2014 pledge to spend 2% next year: "NATO allies have agreed to a new pledge to spend at least 2% of GDP on defense, firming up the alliance’s previous goal to 'move toward the 2% guideline.'" The new pledge has no deadline. How convenient for some.

Threads, a competitor to Twitter, went live. With a convenient warning to users for specific posts: "This account has repeatedly posted false information that was reviewed by independent fact checkers or went against our Community Guidelines." So, the user lies OR says things Zuckerberg disagrees with. Pairing a bad thing with a mere point-of-view dispute is rather slimy. Like justifying exiling Mark Zuckerberg by explaining "He has repeatedly tortured and eaten puppies. Or, he doesn't label his food container with the date in the lunch room refrigerator." 

Is civil war looming in France? It depends. As I asked early in this post, will Iran help turn riots into insurrection? Things can always get worse.

Republicans "pounce". Democrats clam up and hope the media makes it all go away. Coke in the White House. Cluster munitions for an ally. Can you imagine how the media would howl in outrage if a Republican was president?

I've certainly recognized the potential for further loss of Russian imperial territory after 1989 and 1991. So this is plausible: "Vladimir Putin and Moscow’s central power have been weakened by Yevgeny Prigozhin’s mutiny. The fact that Prigozhin and his rebellious troops have not been punished will embolden others to challenge Putin’s authority." But this depends on whether the Wagner Revolt is a symptom of a broader internal problem that could generate more resistance; or a one-off threat that Putin defeated.

Yeah, reading a "9-dash line" illegal territorial claim into that "map" with its 8-dash line seems like a stretch to me. Hollywood has surely bowed to China many times. Oddly enough this time it seems innocent. Although I'd expect Chinese propaganda to portray it as endorsement.

Biden is apparently well past his Democratic Party USE BY date. Tip by Instapundit.

I noted a story that this was approaching. America's chemical weapons are gone: "Today, U.S. officials announced that the final munition in the nation's obsolete stockpile of chemical weapons has been safely destroyed — a disarmament milestone decades in the making."

The Marines are trying to change their manpower to long-term service as much as possible. This makes for more effective Marines. But makes for a more brittle force that cannot endure significant casualties and retain its effectiveness. 

Russia's outward show of economic strength in the face of war and Western sanctions is Russian bluster. Russia would want the West to think resistance is futile.

America, Britain, and Germany are the biggest laggards: "Only around half of the heavy weapons that Ukraine's allies have promised to send it have actually been delivered, according to a new report compiled by the Kiel Institute for the World Economy."

More on the US deal with India to service American warships. Strategypage thinks the Indians need our help. Hmmm. "Need" or "want"? I figured India could handle a Chinese thrust into the Indian Ocean at the end of a long supply line through the Malacca choke point. But I could be wrong. 

Iran wants to control eastern Syria along their ground supply line? "Iran instructed the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps Quds Force (IRGC QF) to achieve total hegemony in Deir ez Zor Province, Syria in May 2023." Would America fight or fold? Or is this an Iranian ploy--a pretend threat with only performance art of some dead or wounded Americans--to give America a plausible victory of stopping Iran and getting them to agree to another awful Iran nuclear deal? Syria is seemingly back in play.

He's been dangerously partisan: "Attorney General Merrick Garland is facing a potential impeachment inquiry for what appears to be lying to Congress about the independence of the Justice Department’s investigations into Hunter Biden." I imagine operatives whispered in his ear about how political Republicans allegedly were when he was nominated by Obama for the Supreme Court as a reason for him to get revenge. Tip to Instapundit.

Inflation and the inability to move money around to maintain priorities is harming American defenses under the budget. Add in procurement process bloat and cost overruns in general. And the now-obvious need to expand our defense-industrial base.

Some are getting their panties in a twist over America sending cluster bomb shells to Ukraine. I don't recall outrage over Russia's use of more dud-prone versions. Also, we didn't sign that treaty. Nor did Ukraine. Or Russia for that matter. Although war crimes can exist even with perfectly legal weapons used improperly. But I'm sure we can all heave a sign of relief that Saint Kitt and Nevis vowed never to use them. And Ukraine is willing to use them on their own territory to fight the invaders. Finally, the West can't yet produce enough regular shells. The bottom line is that you go to war with the ammo you have--not with the ammo you wish you had. They are great against soft spread-out targets like exposed infantry, towed or otherwise unarmored artillery, air defense systems, supply trucks, and tents--which might house headquarters or supplies.

That wistful "being China for a day" crap has had an effect in America. While China has a vast "Firewall of China" to censor information the Communist Party doesn't like, plus more direct methods to keep subjects in line, Democrats outsourced their firewall to the private sector: "There are 40,000 people at Google and Meta pulling stuff down. They’ve pulled over a billion things down. I don’t really trust Big Tech to be in charge of this, and I don’t, frankly, trust government in cahoots with Big Tech in private to be in charge of this." Add in a compliant Department of Justice and we have a "kinder and gentler" proto-police state in place. Tip to Instapundit. 

Mostly I'm amused that Democrats lapped up similar Soviet misinformation in the Cold War yet now find it horrifying. Also, only Twitter is singled out for political reasons. My view is that this crap mostly reinforces the beliefs of people who already believe the crap category and persuades few who don't. By all means, combat it. But censorship is not the answer. Also, I'd be curious how many of the "shares" of fake news are by bots or Russians.

Saturday, July 08, 2023

Will Russia Pay Any Price and Bear Any Burden?

Russia does not have limitless endurance in blood and treasure to remain fighting in Ukraine without victory.  

I think Russia will accept defeat in Ukraine when the price of continuing to fight Ukraine is higher than the price of admitting defeat:

People like to say Russia can't afford to end the war without victory. So we should just let Ukraine die. At the moment Russia can't admit defeat. But at some point if Russia continues screwing the pooch, ending the war with retreat may seem like the best outcome Russia can get.

Being bigger than Ukraine is certainly a Russian advantage. But being larger is not a guarantee of victory in general or in the direct case of Russia versus Western-supported Ukraine.

So obviously I agree with this author:

The war is a quagmire, and at some point, the costs of fighting endlessly just make it easier and cheaper to give up and go home. In other words, Ukraine probably will not win so much as Russia will lose, and Russia will choose to lose because it is cheaper.  

Exactly. Before Russia invaded I was in favor of killing Russians and imposing a price on Russia:

Why doesn't the West make Russia's tolerable "forever war" against Ukraine an actual quagmire that hurts Russia enough until it leaves?

That was my advice early on. Make Ukraine Putin's bleeding ulcer, I said. 

Russia is bleeding now. Even as Russia mostly holds the line during Ukraine's tentative counteroffensive, are events taking place behind the line that will cripple Russia's war effort? 

The high casualty rates in Russian combat units has led to increasing protests from wives and mothers of men conscripted or “mobilized” (persuaded or forced to join) into the army.

The home front might be shaky. Or: 

The new recruits are more aware of poor preparation (training and equipment) and combat leadership that is common in Ukraine. All this led to severe morale problems.

Units in combat are often too busy surviving to revolt unless things get really bad. But the guys behind the lines have more time to think and worry--and opportunity to act out.

Just as Russia did in Afghanistan, Russia can turn around and exit Ukraine when the price of remaining inside Ukraine to fight Ukraine's army is too high. 

Nobody will be pursuing the Russian army back to Moscow. Except maybe the mothers of Russia's dead seeking revenge on the government.

NOTE: TDR coverage of the Winter War of 2022 continues here.

Friday, July 07, 2023

Iran's Mullah Rulers are Nutballs--Not Stupid

So Iran is about to test a nuclear device? If true, we may have already lost the opportunity to prevent Iran from deploying nuclear weapons.


This might not be the start of an Iranian nuclear threat:

Iran continues to pursue illicit nuclear weapons technology across Europe and is on the cusp of testing its first nuclear warhead, according to intelligence estimates from three separate countries.  

An Iranian nuclear test might be the sign than Iran already has a nuclear missile force.

I've worried that much of Iran's nuclear infrastructure is long-term in nature and not the driving force of getting a nuclear weapon. I've worried Iran subcontracted nuclear weapons work to North Korea, safely out of range of Israel and sort of under China's protection:

Iran's rulers may be nuts but they're not stupid. They know we can attack them. So they take precautions to minimize our strikes, like digging deep or siting near civilian targets. Outsourcing weapons programs to trusted rogues is another way to do that.

North Korea is broke and could make a lot of money from Iran. As I asked long ago:

If Iran can announce both the ability to make nuclear bomb material and the possession of actual nuclear weapons--perhaps by detonating one in a test on their own territory--Tehran would quite possibly deter an attack on Iran's nuclear infrastructure.

We're not dealing with idiots. If the Iranian mullahs believe there are red lines that trigger Israeli or American action, why wouldn't they take counter-actions rather than just blindly cross those lines and provide a pretext for military action against them?

But we keep watching the nuclear enrichment status. Or now, anticipating a nuclear test as if that's the signal we should seriously begin to worry rather than the signal it is too late. 

Have a super sparkly day.

NOTE: TDR coverage of the Winter War of 2022 continues here.

Thursday, July 06, 2023

What Could Possibly Go Wrong in Putin's Greater Russia Plan?

One can almost see the outline of Putin's plan for imperial glory in his failure to rapidly stomp Ukraine.

Russia was forced to admit that it simply wants to take Ukraine "back" after demonstrating that Ukrainians do not in fact yearn to be rescued by Russia's army:

Russia eventually named portions of Poland as one of its future targets for absorption into “Greater Russia”, otherwise known as the Russian empire. Belarus, the Baltic States and some former Soviet territories in Central Asia are also on the acquisition list. None of these targets for Russian aggression are willing to go peacefully. As the largest and wealthiest East European NATO member, Poland is leading the way by rearming to confront any future threat. After Russia invaded Ukraine, Poland decided to increase the size of the armed forces to 300,000 personnel and spend at least three percent of GDP on defense.

This isn't how it was supposed to go.

I can imagine Putin thinking the invasion of Georgia in 2008 was a wake up call to rebuild the Russian military.

Putin had limited time after signing an agreement with China to buy time to build up defenses in the Far East where China's "century of humiliation" continues.

By 2014, the little green men took over Crimea in a brilliant and nearly bloodless campaign. "Hybrid war" was the new buzz in the West and Putin was its master. Never mind the peculiar circumstances that should have been a warning sign that panties were being flung.

By 2015, Ukraine showed that it could fight back, holding off the hand puppet "rebels" who only partially took the Donbas for Russia.

Still, everyone in the West swooned over magical hybrid war and the simply amazing battalion tactical groups. 

Sure, China still loomed over Russia's Far East and made inroads into Central Asia. And NATO wasn't broken yet. Despite nuclear threats and obvious military power, NATO was even rearming after its long slide into combat impotence. And that ceasefire with China was about to expire.

So Russia got five more years of a truce with China. This would be enough time to complete his long-term plan of restoring Russia to greatness.

Ukraine had surely collapsed into a puddle of Soviet nostalgia and fear of Russian power. It was ripe for the taking. So in 2022, Putin took the finely tuned instrument of the military he built and sent it in to Ukraine for a parade ground march into Ukraine's cities where appreciative Ukrainians would greet them as liberators.

NATO would be helpless to stop Russia and would collapse into a puddle of appeasers competing to see who could gain Russia's temporary favor; or simply avert their eyes and hope distance would save them from Russia's expanding empire that would claw back lost Soviet territory--and perhaps more?

With the NATO threat neutralized, Russia could then finally pivot to Asia to protect its Far Eastern territory taken from China in the 19th century; and bolster its Central Asian influence to bring them back into the fold in time.

Indeed, before Putin invaded Ukraine to establish the penultimate portion of his plan, it seemed like Putin had established the ground for the major pivot for the last step.

It was a great plan. Until Ukraine resisted. And the West rallied to Ukraine's defense. And NATO got serious about rearming and rebuilding its military industry. And NATO even expanded as Finland and Sweden abandoned long neutrality--but Russia-wary--policies.

And it gets worse for Russia. Sure, despite the Wagner Revolt, China said it supports Russia: 

But the mutiny has probably also forced Beijing to consider how its own geopolitical, economic and territorial interests would be affected if Putin were to suddenly be toppled. That could lead China to distance itself from Russia to some degree.

Said Yan Xuetong, a senior international relations scholar at China’s prestigious Tsinghua University, "From a security perspective, this war has not enhanced China’s security but has subjected China to more security threats[.]" 

Indeed.

Truly, Putin invited the Fuck-Up Fairy to live in Russia full time. Will the Russian people and elites decide Putin should pay the price for his record of epic failure?

#WhyRussiaCan'tHaveNiceThings

NOTE: TDR coverage of the Winter War of 2022 continues here.

Wednesday, July 05, 2023

The Year of the Monkey For China Data

We debate the direction of China's policy and government. But we haven't really settled on what China is right now. What is China's population? What is China's GDP? Shouldn't that be kind of important before we peer into the future?

New demographic data on China is rather stunning (tip to Instapundit):

China aged past the point of demographic no return over 20 years, ago and it wasn’t just this year that India became the world’s most populous country, that probably happened roughly a decade ago. And it wasn’t in 2018 that the average Chinese aged past the average American, that was probably roughly in 2007 or 2008.

Huh. I keep reading stuff like this, including that China's economy is grossly overrated: 

Is China's GDP overstated by 60%? Big if true. Their defense spending is a much bigger burden, for example. Tip to Instapundit. I've been a skeptic of China's rise to surpass America as many posts show. A decade ago I wondered about the quality of China's growth. Four years ago I mentioned the light metric. And three years ago I noted skepticism of official stats. But I never would have guessed by this much.

Doesn't this throw a monkey wrench into the machinery of our China analysis? Yet nobody seems to adjust the official statistics and everybody just keeps pretending nothing has changed. 

And if we can't easily adjust our views for data contrary to what we've long assumed to be true, can the Chinese Communist Party adjust? China's senior leadership may be even more isolated from reality inside China. Even if China's rulers have special long-term planning instincts, bad data undermines that magical skill, no?

Perhaps the Chinese people are feeling these changes on the ground despite the stasis in analyst and leadership views on China. This author speaks of the end of optimism in China:

Taken together, the statistics paint a picture of a society that is reluctant to invest in an uncertain future—one where many Chinese appear to be protesting with their wallets, wombs, and feet, and where the best and brightest see themselves in a literary character meant to symbolize irrelevancy.

Not to get all mystical, but is the Mandate of Heaven being withdrawn from Emperor Xi Jinping?  And what would Xi try to restore it (back to the end of optimism author)? 

If the public mood continues to sour, the Communist Party will likely resort to greater repression to assert its will and enforce its unpopular policies. Xi could also continue to turn to nationalist causes, such as unification with Taiwan or control of the South China Sea, to rally the public behind him, potentially making his regime a greater danger to regional stability.

That said, I'm not sure how to evaluate Zeihan's credibility. I mean, I want to believe him. As much as I don't want the economic dislocation of a failed China I want an aggressive China even less. Maybe he's Gordon Chang with better timing. Or just fresher timing.  

We certainly are living in interesting times. With complex global supply chains. And nukes.

Have a super sparkly day. 

UPDATE: Related thoughts:

China is probably at or near its peak global influence before it begins a long, slow descent in its relevance to the rest of the world. In this and following pieces, I will lay out some statistics that show this will likely be the case.

That article focuses on demographics. 

UPDATE: Via Instapundit, is the word spreading?

Conditions in the Chinese economy are worse than the world thinks, a self-exiled property entrepreneur told The New York Times. 

NOTE: TDR coverage of the Winter War of 2022 continues here.

Tuesday, July 04, 2023

Mutiny in Russia

Is the Russian Wagner Mutiny played out in its effects yet?

In many ways--at least how it turned out--it is accurate to say the Wagner Insurrection was a military mutiny:

Prigozhin's actions fit the definition of a mutiny almost perfectly, military experts say. In his televised statement, Putin himself described what was happening as a mutiny, or a rebellion.

In other words, though Prigozhin threw down the biggest gauntlet Putin had faced since catapulting to prominence in 1999, it's not clear Prigozhin wanted to oust the Russian leader. However, he may have been seeking the heads of other top officials: Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu and the country's top military officer, General Valery Gerasimov.

The stated purpose of the Wagner mutiny was to end the pointless slaughter of Russian soldiers ordered by the government. That Prigozhin willingly carried out those orders for so long to batter his way through Bakhmut with his prison-recruited cannon fodder was to be ignored, I suppose. 

I can't rule out that this truly was intended by Prigozhin as a coup:

Putin called the failed Wagner Group march on Moscow treason. Yet many senior Russian generals quietly agreed with Prigozhin and some were secretly in touch with him and ready to openly back Wagner Group forces against Putin, but only if Prigozhin marched into Moscow.

But as it ended, it looks like a mutiny.

In World War I both French and Russian troops mutinied in response to their heavy casualties, too. The Russian example led to the collapse of the state. 

The French example, however, was kept quiet and led to the French being much more careful using their troops to get them to fight again. Albeit with possible fatal repercussions in 1940. 

I've hoped we'd see a mutiny in Russia's own ground forces in response to their own casualties. I didn't expect Wagner to mutiny, even if I wondered if it would be part of general chaos. 

General troop mutiny was not triggered by the Wagner Mutiny. But will the apparent lack of punishment for Wagner troops encourage Russian army, paratrooper, or other security force troops in Ukraine to mutiny, too? I mean, I was wrong about Putin's sensitivity to casualties. Although to be fair, Putin started the war expecting it to be a short and glorious near-parade. 

But maybe the troops are reaching their limit. Escaping to Belarus might be looking like a pretty good deal right now.

Anyway, NATO wants to figure out what, if any, weaknesses this reveals about Putin.

UPDATE: Oh, FFS. The mutiny was not a Putin ploy to reveal traitors: "The coup was staged, and completely faked false flag operation." In what alternate world would Putin need to do that to fin and punish traitors? It isn't like he needs proof! And he'd needlessly tarnish his image of power to do something he doesn't need to do?

As for the "proof" that Putin didn't send ground forces to stop Wagner's march? Did you not notice that the security forces Wagner ran into stood aside or surrendered? Putin couldn't risk adding troops to Prigozhin's army. That's why only aircraft were sent. Please note in regard to the reliability issue that Putin is sending elite Spetsnaz to secure the Belgorod border because even before the Wagner Revolt the security forces sent to stop anti-Putin Russians from raiding Russia were unreliable against that tiny threat.

God. I felt brain cells committing suicide reading that ploy article. Get back to me when there is evidence and not just fanciful motivations ascribed to events with more sensible explanations.

UPDATE: Interesting:

The reported reorganization of Russian internal security organs suggests that the Kremlin has not yet concluded that it has effectively neutralized the threats of future armed rebellions following the Wagner Group’s June 23-24 rebellion.

NOTE: The image was created with DALL-E.

NOTE: TDR coverage of the Winter War of 2022 continues here.

Monday, July 03, 2023

The Winter War of 2022 Just Lies There Being Indecisive

Ukraine is attacking along the front and making small gains. But without committing more than a few of the new and rebuilt brigades. So far the Russians are holding the line. But they have had to strip troops from Kherson. And Russia had a distraction at home. So ... we wait for something significant to happen.

Nothing decisive has visibly happened on the front despite the start of the Big Push counteroffensive. But Ukraine is moving and destroying:

The Ukrainian counteroffensive in southern Ukraine continues to advance. There are a growing number of armed Ukrainian partisans operating in Russian occupied territory. The partisans are concentrating on destroying or damaging rail and road transportation networks as well as destroying Russian supplies. Sometimes this is done by revealing to Ukraine where key Russian supplies are stored.

Long-range Ukrainian weapons can hit those revealed targets behind Russian lines. And perhaps Ukraine is hollowing out the Russian defenders by advancing to identify targets for firepower to destroy. But the Russians are only being pushed back slowly. 

But rather than being deliberate attrition, maybe this is just an example of what happens when you give your enemy time. Ukraine may have had no choice but to delay its counteroffensive for so long given the slow pace of Western arms deliveries. But regardless of the reason, Russia was given the precious gift of time to prepare.

Ukraine is attacking around Bakhmut in the east, which Wagner mercenaries captured after a long bloody offensive. Wagner turned over defensive duties to the Russian military. It would look bad for the Russian military to lose the city. So Russia will send reinforcement to hold it. I assume Ukraine's attacks here are diversionary.

The southern front is probably going to be the site of the main effort for the counteroffensive when Ukrainian probes find a weak point. I assume the ideal objective is Melitopol. 

I further assume the western Kherson front is a supporting effort. That may kick off once Russia pulls more forces from the Kherson front to stabilize the southern front in the face of a Ukrainian main effort. Unless Ukraine has figured out how to use boats and helicopters to get a significant force across the Dnieper River before that trigger. And then supply it and defend the supply line with air defense assets. That seems unlikely. But Ukraine has also had a lot of time to prepare. So I'm unwilling to rule it out.

Meanwhile, Russia's home front is simmering:

The economy (GDP) shrank by two percent in 2022 and is headed for a 3.8 percent decline in 2023. The deficit spending has caused high inflation and a growing number of Russians can’t afford to buy essential items. The percentage of Russians living below the poverty line is now more than 60 percent.

The Wagner Revolt raised the pot to a boil for a day. What happens next inside Russia or on the battlefields in Ukraine? 

I know we're supposed to be patient. Ukraine's troops are the ones dying--not us. They have their own timetable and plan. But patience exercised long enough can become indistinguishable from stalemate. That's not good for Ukraine, either.

UPDATE (Tuesday): I continue to worry that Russian shortages on the front are deliberate as Russia scrapes together equipment, ammo, officers, and NCOs to build a new offensive force. The longer it takes Ukraine to inflict a major defeat on Russia's ground forces, the more likely it is that such a force can be completed and sent to renew the Russian offensive.

UPDATE (Tuesday): As long as this is accurate and Ukraine is successfully doing it, that's fine for now:

Ukrainian forces appear to be focusing on creating an asymmetrical attrition gradient that conserves Ukrainian manpower at the cost of a slower rate of territorial gains, while gradually wearing down Russian manpower and equipment.

If Ukraine hollows out Russia's defenders, eventually the line will be thin enough to crack open.

But if that takes too much time, what will Russia have done with that time?

UPDATE (Thursday): Has Russia lost half of its combat capability during the war? Is it incapable of launching a counteroffensive against Ukraine's offensive? Interesting.

If Russia has lost half of its combat capability, the vast majority of the loss is from the ground forces. So the counteroffensive capability assessment is plausible. Am I worrying for nothing about Russia scraping together a major counteroffensive force? 

Further, is Russia's apparent stout defense a Potemkin defense that is essentially a crust with little behind it? If so, the apparent stalemate could end dramatically if Ukraine keeps pushing. 

Or maybe Ukraine's offensive is failing. I just can't tell from the news. 

Sorry I can't make a prediction.

UPDATE (Thursday): This author thinks Ukraine can win but there will be nothing dramatic:

Even if Ukraine’s progress this summer is only moderate, Russia is still tied down in an expensive ‘forever war’ that will gradually exhaust it. In time, the constant strain will make withdrawal ever more attractive. This is how the Afghans defeated the Soviet army in the 1980s and is likely what will happen in this war.

I admit I've hoped for a rapid advance following a Russian troop morale collapse. But I've hoped that since September 2022 even as I warned that failure of Ukraine to attack gives Russia time to recover and prepare.

UPDATE (Thursday): Are 180,000 Russian troops really massing in the Donbas, ready to resume an offensive if Ukraine commits its reserves to the south? That certainly feeds my longstanding worry that Russia has starved the front of resources to build a reserve, gambling the frontline will mostly hold. 

If so, the authors think it is unlikely they are trained or equipped. They may be there to draw Ukrainian forces there for a fight. That puts Russia close to lines of supply--as I've noted. And it diverts Ukraine from the key Crimea objective that Russia has more trouble supplying.

It bears repeating this quote I've used before:

Man cannot tell but Allah knows
How much the other side was hurt.

Although I remember the secondary source I read used "is hurt". But the point remains.

UPDATE (Friday): Just as I'm wondering if Russia's front line is brittle notwithstanding Ukraine's slow progress, ISW writes: 

The deployment of almost the entirety of the Russian Eastern Grouping of Forces and extensive SMD elements to the frontline in southern Ukraine suggests that Russian defenses in southern Ukraine may be brittle.

The only reserve may be a single brigade that has been damaged in battle.

UPDATE (Sunday): Just going to say it seems as if Ukrainian troops are pushing the Russians back a little more lately. Still slow. But Ukraine also hasn't really committed its reserve, it seems. Is a thin Russian crust getting too thin to hold? Or is this a false dawn of Russian troops being between prepared fortified lines?

NOTE: ISW coverage of the war continues here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

Sunday, July 02, 2023

Weekend Data Dump

UK MOD: "Ukrainian forces are using the experiences from the first two weeks of the counter-offensive to refine tactics for assaulting the deep, well prepared Russian defences. Ukrainian units are making gradual but steady tactical progress in key areas." We'll see what this looks like on the ground by the time this is published.

Huh: "The US Naval Criminal Investigative Service is investigating after multiple Navy personnel reported receiving unsolicited smartwatches in the mail that could be installed with data-stealing malicious software, an NCIS spokesperson told CNN on Friday." The Army, too. What did I say?

Did the Wagner Insurrection damage the Russian political system despite failing? Or merely reveal its schisms? And if the latter, I assume Putin will inflict more damage on this system as he roots out all the people he thinks are out to get him. Winning doesn't make the paranoid feel secure. Winning just proves one of their many enemies almost won.

LOL (via Instapundit):


The 1990s called and they want their Balkan hatreds back. I have to wonder if Russia is involved. It would distract NATO. But I don't assume locals aren't capable of reviving violence all on their own.

This is a problem: "An old American problem, defense projects that are completed over budget and late, has proved impossible to eliminate. A recent assessment of 36 defense acquisition projects revealed that their costs had increased over the last two years by $37 billion and most were late as well." To be fair, U.S.S. Constitution and her famous sister frigates were over budget and late. I guess I mostly hope our enemies are worse off rather than count on fixing it. But it would be nice to reduce the problem to a dull roar.

Russia's claimed motive for invading Ukraine collapsed--Ukraine did not need to be saved from Nazis and by their fierce resistance demonstrated they were not oppressed Russians waiting for Russia's help. Russia's high casualties and economic and diplomatic costs have led Russia's leaders to escalate their war goal to justify the casualties--restoring the glorious Russian/Soviet Empire. Putin might be at risk if that goal is accepted but Putin is deemed unable to achieve it. And what happens when Russia's casualties and other costs are too high to justify that goal? A bigger insurrection or coup to end the war?

Australia will provide more help to Ukraine, including 70 military vehicles.

Questions about China's economic prospects right now. Via Instapundit. Will India pass China by? Hmmm. Don't replace irrational exuberance over China with India. 

Friends: "The US is seeking to assist India in developing its naval and maritime infrastructure to create an Indo-Pacific regional hub for ship repair and maintenance[.]" The hub would assist America in shifting naval power from CENTCOM to the South China Sea.

While I have wondered if Russian war failures might lead to civil unrest on the scale of 1905 or 1917, I don't think the Wagner Insurrection indicates one is near. Putin may have endured the worst of the divisions within Russia. After all, it was a one-day threat that didn't attract any elite support. That doesn't obviously weaken Putin. I'm reticent to let my hopes drive my conclusions that this episode dooms Russia's invasion. Civil unrest on a scale that threatens Putin may depend on whether Ukraine's counteroffensive can inflict a substantial defeat on Russia's military--not "mere" stubborn resistance to Russia's military. And if Russia does experience a coup, who knows what leader will step forward from that wretched hive of scum and villainy that Russia's political class creates? Also, I don't think this was a Putin conspiracy.

Thoughts on the Wagner Insurrection. Big question is what happens to Wagner units. I don't think it is safe for Putin to disband them and send them home. The best thing for Putin is that the men die fighting in Ukraine (in separate penal battalions dressed up as "assault" units?) or in Africa to spare some Russian soldier less prone to insurrection from dying. Keep them separate from regular formations to keep the Wagner units from infecting the other troops--or provoking battles between Wagner insurrectionists and angry regular troops. Fun fact: China sent a lot of the losing Nationalist troops from the civil war to die in the Korean War.

Oh, our government is effective all right. Effective in rewarding supporters and punishing the opposition. But seriously, do check it out. I agree 2-4 are problems. I have mixed views on 5, but I'm sympathetic. I reject 1. We've had 1 for a long time without having ineffective government. As Victor Hanson has said, when government officials spend their time spouting off on issues unrelated to their official duties, expect the official duties to be done ineptly. Tip to Instapundit. 

I'm so old I have a game where the yet-to-be-made M-2/3 Bradley was called the MICV. American Rheinmetall Vehicles and General Dynamics Land Systems will compete for the Bradley replacement that the Army is now calling the XM30 Mechanized Infantry Combat Vehicle. One day it will be the M-30. I had thoughts on a replacement in Infantry magazine (I thought the link was gone until I realized I needed to change part of the address for the new base name).

Welp, let's see if those leaner Marine infantry battalions of the future are just as mean without tanks and tube artillery. I've got a bad feeling about a lot of infantry on a modern battlefield trying to survive--let alone win--without armor and firepower volume. Fingers crossed.

The splintered rebels are tough to negotiate with, however: "Iranian influence on the Shia rebels is fading and many rebel factions call for some kind of peace deal and an end to a civil war that the rebels were losing."

Russia is using anti-tank mines to help slow down the Ukrainian counter-attacks. Those mines wreck the tracks and wheels. But remember, as long as Ukraine controls the ground where the loss occurred, the tank can be repaired for the surviving crew. Controlling the battlefield is important to reviving those "mobility kills". 

ISW discussion of the Wagner Insurrection and the aftermath. Also: "The Telegraph, citing British special services, reported that Russian special forces threatened to harm the families of Wagner commanders during the armed rebellion, which may further trigger tensions and low morale."

I've noted this lateral movement of forces because of an apparent lack of reserves: "The UK MoD indicated on June 26 that Russian forces likely lack operational-level reserves that could reinforce against simultaneous Ukrainian threats on multiple areas of the front hundreds of kilometers from each other, chiefly Bakhmut and southern Ukraine." And subtract most of Wagner from Russia's force pool until Putin decides whether to imprison them, execute them, throw them at the Ukrainians to let their enemy kill them, or send them overseas to die for Russia.

Liability without limits? "'Chinese leaders must be concerned that China’s strategic alignment with a weakened Russia may turn out to be a net burden rather than a plus to China’s strategic interests,' [Brookings Institition's Patricia M.] Kim said." Indeed.

Drug war scam 2.0: "The Taliban have launched an impressive new war on drugs[.]" In the 1990s the Taliban engineered a temporary drop in Poppy production to get Western aid. The revenue and drug industry supporters were too important to the Taliban to stomp out. What the heck. This time we can totally trust Taliban 2.0!

After voting for Brexit in 2016, Britain still isn't completely out of the EU's grasp. Yet Remainers blame Brexit for everything going wrong in their zeal to rejoin the proto-empire. And Conservatives find it convenient to excuse their policy failures. Putin must be kicking himself over the superior power of 10,000 entangling EU cheese regulations over tanks and secret police to bind a subject state to its master.

Germany doesn't have much of a military, but it will deploy more forward: "Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said Berlin’s decision to station an army brigade in Lithuania will enhance allied security along the eastern flank."

The military's recruiting crisis. 

Is the wording imprecise or indicative of my major issue with retiring the A-10? "Moody isn’t the only base set to get a new mission to replace departing A-10s—the Air Force also announced that Gowen Field Air National Guard Base, Idaho, will transition to F-16s in spring 2027." A new mission?  Not a new plane? My trust issues are not being addressed.

LOL: "Reuters determined that President Joe Biden and every living former U.S. president — except Donald Trump — are direct descendants of slaveholders[.]" Tip to Instapundit.

Obviously charges will be dropped only until the weapons are handed over: "Preparations are under way for the group to hand over its heavy weapons and equipment to the Russian army, the defence ministry said." Or perhaps lots of Wagner troops will subsequently end up falling out of windows or down flights of stairs.

Bulgaria will provide Ukraine with military aid. 

America will provide Ukraine with more ammunition, anti-aircraft and anti-tank missiles, mine- and obstacle-clearing equipment, and additional Bradley Fighting Vehicles and Stryker armored personnel carriers, among other things in the latest arms package.

Right now the goal is to get Sweden in before the July 11th NATO summit commences: "NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said Monday that he will call an urgent meeting in the coming days to try to overcome Turkish objections to Sweden joining the military organization."

Belarus may attempt to use Wagner forces that choose to move to Belarus plus nuclear weapons as means to push back against Russian control by portraying Belarus as capable of halting NATO. Lukashenko is awful. But we really want him to be awfully independent from Russian control.

Russia seems to be stripping Wagner of heavy weapons in order to give them to Russia's National Guard. Which pulls needed equipment away from the war for internal security purposes.

United Arab Emirates.

Can Yemen become less clusterf*ckish?

Arguing for a thicker red line: "The British Army’s most senior leader has hailed the need for combat mass as one of the major lessons to be drawn from the Ukraine war and strongly advised against any further cuts to UK land capabilities."

Prigozhin is purportedly in Belarus. But is he alive? And will Putin really let Wagner fighters go to Belarus? 

And now for something completely different:

 

The bill would also push the Coast Guard to work more closely with INDOPACOM: "A $91.5 billion bill making its way through Congress funding programs under the U.S. Department of Homeland Security includes provisions to continue supporting an increased U.S. Coast Guard presence in the Pacific."

Increasing price is making it more difficult to fulfill this requirement: "Muslims are required to make the journey to Mecca at least once in their lifetime, if they are physically and financially capable of doing so." Over time, one would think this trend could break this pillar of Islam.

If states can't sue the federal government to enforce immigration laws (tip to Instapundit), who can? The majority makes a good point on the need for priorities (so maybe have fewer federal crimes and laws to compete with this?). But if this is something that is supposed to be resolved by politics, doesn't the 17th Amendment make that more difficult?

Ukraine says the countdown to the end of Putin has begun. I'm sure Ukraine hopes that saying that is so will make it so. And it encourages their own troops to keep fighting.

Railroad sabotage in Crime and a failed drone attack on Moscow.

Conservatives mocked liberals for constantly saying they had the evidence on the latest alleged Trump crime. It never turned up. Are conservatives making the same mistake that the walls are closing in on Biden before there is something that rises to levels of evidence that is decisive in a court?

Should America be more active in Central Asia rather than let China and Russia dominate them? We can't be strong everywhere. It was hard enough to sustain efforts in Afghanistan. But we'll expend effort in landlocked Central Asia? I'm thinking this is a low priority. I want Russia and China to clash in Central Asia. At most, we could help Russia resist China there if Russia retreats from Ukraine--and stops promoting chaos in Europe, Africa, and the Middle East. That would be Smart Diplomacy.

And I thought I was an optimist. To be fair, "moving toward" stability is agnostic on velocity.

Russia sends a message to China: "Taiwan scrambled aircraft and dispatched ships late Tuesday to monitor the passage of two Russian warships off its eastern coast[.]" The message is, "I swear to God we're still useful! Please don't invade us!"

Well that's unfortunate: "Switzerland blocked arms maker Ruag AG from selling almost 100 tanks in a deal that would have seen them used by Ukraine in its war with Russia."

We decided to build more because we couldn't manage to design a new destroyer: "The Navy on Tuesday formally took delivery of the first Flight III Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer from HII’s Ingalls Shipbuilding." With the new AN/SPY-6 radar and updated Aegis, it will have better air defense capabilities and will take over the carrier air defense role retiring missile cruisers have had.

And now for something completely different:


Friends in a dangerous neighborhood: "Australian and Japanese forces conducted exercise Trident 2023 over the weekend in the South China Sea."

To be fair, he did help create a doozy in Wuhan: "Georgetown hires Anthony Fauci as ‘distinguished professor’ of infectious diseases [.]" Tip to Instapundit.

Ukraine will get American AMRAAM air-to-air missiles. Right now this is for surface-to-air missile systems. I assume this will eventually be for F-16s or some other Western fighter.

Shortly before the Wagner Revolt, I wondered if fear of internal chaos would push Russia to end their failed attempt to conquer Ukraine. Does Putin have that fear now that Wagner revolted? Or does Putin think he weathered the worst of the threat because he defeated Wagner quickly?

It's very weird. Blogger stats indicate 60,000+ hits in June. Which is nuts. And I don't believe that. And while my other stats show a noticeable increase, it is nothing at all like that. And to make it weirder, that usually more accurate stat count's counter at the bottom of the page shows many more hits than the actual stats report it is based on. Very weird.

Hard to dispute this take: "At this point, lefties are basically in a contest with one another to see what they can get people to give up in the name of their Earth cult." Now go and emit no more.

Guard the skies: "The U.S. State Department has approved a possible $15 billion sale of an Integrated Air and Missile Defense (IAMD) Battle Command System (IBCS) and related equipment to Poland as it upgrades its air defenses[.]" America needs a secure location to send reinforcements to its new European center of gravity safe from Russian missile attacks.

Estonia arms ups and why countries want American troops.

Helping the ground attack missiles get past defenders.

At this point I assume Russia is behind the burnings to get Turkey to keep Sweden out of NATO: "Several Muslim-majority countries have condemned the burning of a copy of the Quran in Sweden at a protest." As long as governments are issuing protests rather than seeing mobs of enraged Moslems killing Infidels and rampaging through their neighborhoods, I call this progress.

Why can't Americans be as science-based on medical treatment as Europeans? Tip to Instapundit.

The Claymore directional mine. I'm sort of fond of this weapon. In basic training I had to carry one around and provide the platoon with lessons on its emplacement and use during gaps in training. And really, "Front Toward Enemy" is kind of funny, no?

Is the Army's plan to get a Bradley replacement lacking in validity and reliability for the basis of the competition to build it?

The Marines want smaller prepositioned equipment ships for disaggregated operations in the Western Pacific. Hmmm. So how do they operate in the shadow of China's anti-ship missiles? If the idea is to have more targets than China can hit, just how many are planned? 

Ukraine will get the vehicle-mounted, 124-mile range Naval Strike Missile.

NATO plans to revive once-downgraded and lightened ground forces. Plans are cheap.

How to lie like a professional (via Instapundit): "The former spies and Biden campaign aides who smeared Hunter Biden's laptop as Russian "disinformation" have remained silent following revelations that the FBI authenticated the computer nearly a year before it was released." The former spies said that the laptop looked consistent with Russian disinformation. Later, at least one farcically said nobody claimed the laptop actually was disinformation. Yet none stood up to correct the impression they gave when the media ran with their statement and assumed the laptop was disinformation. But hey, it worked, didn't it?

There is renewed talk that Biden will revive the awful Iran nuclear deal. Recall my prediction of what the deal would be before the first one: "The Iranians will pretend not to have a nuclear weapons program; and we will pretend to believe them." I've only slightly altered that prediction:



Okay, I may lose some readers (and won't gain any). But I try to provide perspective. I have partisan views but I try not to let that interfere with analysis. I suspect the Pride slogan "We're coming for your children" wasn't meant literally by 99.8% of the chanters. It's like murder mystery shows where the initial suspect is someone overheard before the body is found saying, "I'm so mad, I could kill him!" I think the problem is that everyone excuses hyperbole from friends because we know they don't really mean it. But think foes are actually revealing their deep dark intent they usually hide. I complained about the left's fear of a conservative "insurrection" for the same reason. So you can't say I'm not consistent, at least. Words aren't violence. Mind you, this is a separate issue than child mutilation in search of the right pronoun match.

Yeah, I remember the good old days. They sucked compared to today. We had deeper political divisions and more political violence. Tip to Instapundit.

Interesting: "Labor strikes are rising in China as weak demand sees factories shutter and workers’ pay cut." Let me know when they get angry at the Chinese Communist Party for that. Also, let me know when the police stop being willing to arrest, beat, or shoot them.

Does the Russian record since the Crimean War defeat indicate Russia will experience a societal shake up after the Winter War of 2022? One, four examples is a small sample size. Two, the Russian empire is shrunken now, with fewer centrifugal forces at the periphery. And three, Russia hasn't lost this war yet. Russia has performed poorly. But that's different. So I don't know.

Three potential outcomes for the Winter War and implications for Taiwan, mostly regarding Western aid for Taiwan. I think a stalemated partial Russian win's implications for Taiwan are most dire because it would encourage China to believe an invasion could be a multi-step process to conquer Taiwan.

The Pentagon says no decision on providing ATACMs to Ukraine is imminent. Which means Ukraine will get them. 

Practice: "The U.S. and its allies intercepted American B-1 bombers coming across the Atlantic toward North America, in a NORAD-led exercise simulating an enemy attack on June 26." That seems prudent.

Some so-called peace group said putting American forces in Somalia was based on an exaggerated threat to America. Well let's just wait until they hit us? I say make more good jihadis.

Australia really should lock down friendly relations with the Solomon Islands.

Good: "The US Supreme Court shot down the Biden administration’s controversial plan to forgive billions of dollars in federally-backed student loan debt, a decision that means millions will have to start making repayments later this year." As a 17-year-old newly admitted college student, I knew enough not to take more than the smallest interest rate loans. And few of them. I understood I'd have to pay them back. And as a father I put away money for my children for college. Paying the loans with my taxes of moron college graduates who took too many loans would have been a killing blow against good citizenship for me others who didn't spend our money on luxuries and then claim victimhood to get other taxpayers to bail out their poor decisions. [LATER: Damn them to Hell. It's a bailout for the liberal upper middle class, pure and simple.]

It would be nice if this is true and it pressures Russia to withdraw from Ukraine: "Russian forces are losing ground in Ukraine and facing possible civil war at home." My judgment is that the frontline troops are focused on immediate problems: "So unless Russian leadership effs things up behind the lines, I think there is a good chance Russian troops still holding the front are unaffected by the Wagner coup attempt. At least in the short run." I'm working hard not to let my hopes lead me too much.

I speculated that Wagner forces had to reach a certain distance from Moscow to get open Russian military support. Well, "zero" is a number: "many senior Russian generals quietly agreed with Prigozhin and some were secretly in touch with him and ready to openly back Wagner Group forces against Putin, but only if Prigozhin marched into Moscow."

The Marine infantry battalion evolves. Of course it has drones. Also, Switchblade suicide drones couldn't handle Russian countermeasures and are no longer produced. Better to know now.

Biden's brain dies in darkness. "Journalists." If only we had those. Tip to Instapundit.

The SR-72 approaches. Maybe. I wonder if it can actually reach or operate in space in unmanned mode?

ABC: It would be a shame if something happened to your little opinion polling company. "Journalism." Tip to Instapundit.

The game of thrones inside Russia. Maybe the leadership shake up will make things worse. I worry that Putin might stumble upon somebody who is effective to take charge of the war. 

Higher education is taking a beating in America as it has expanded and provided too little value for too much money to too many people. There should be a well-deserved contraction and reform for the survivors. But what do we do with all the over-educated morons who believe they should be running things despite their farcical degrees? An oversupply of such people is a recipe for unrest.

Oh FFS: "Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy met Thursday with Swedish environmental activist Greta Thunberg and prominent European figures who are forming a working group to address ecological damage from the 16-month-old Russian invasion." Yeah, that's the biggest problem with Russia's brutal invasion of Ukraine. Greta can go to Hell.

Also, HRW can go to Hell: "Human Rights Watch (HRW) has urged Ukraine's government to follow through on its recent pledge to avoid using banned antipersonnel land mines and investigate and punish their use so far in the war with Russia." How about punishing Russia for invading?

But other than that, how was the play Mrs. Lincoln? How would a cabal of our enemies inflict more damage on us? Tip to Instapundit.

You spelled "to help encourage migrants to go north to Europe" wrong: "The U.N. Security Council voted unanimously Friday to immediately end its peacekeeping mission in Mali as demanded by the country’s military junta, which has brought in mercenaries from Russia’s Wagner Group to help fight an Islamic insurgency."

My impression is this is a Plan B to reassure Ukraine to accept less than a complete ejection of Russia from Ukrainian territory in a peace treaty or ceasefire if the counteroffensive does not make a good start on that objective: "NATO members are closing in on a compromise on Ukraine's membership aspirations that may set out how Kyiv could join the military alliance, the U.S. ambassador to NATO said on Thursday."

Riots in France over the police killing of a 17-year-old of North African origin. I assume the rioters are Moslem. One day the riots could have a bigger purpose than just reactive rage. They're certainly big enough. Imagine what Iran might do to make a claim to be the protector of all Islam and not just Shias if it gets nuclear missiles. Not saying Iran would nuke France. But Iran might be far more vocal and might extend aid to those growing "no-go zones" knowing their own nukes limit France's reaction. Jihadi lives matter, Iran will say. Say, here's a vocal reaction to Sweden's freedom of speech. And that would certainly distract Iranians from protesting the Iranian government. And earn Iran some points with new friend Russia for destabilizing a NATO state.

Bravo:

 

More than a decade ago I worried that failing to win the war on terror would threaten civil rights at home in an increasingly intrusive battle against terrorists here. What I didn't suspect was that our security apparatus would shift from looking for foreign-inspired jihadi terrorists to defining lawful dissent as terrorism. That was inconceivable to me. It was a failure of imagination. Can we dismantle what our post-9/11 security laws have led to?

Oh? "On the surface, the turmoil in Russia would seem like something for the U.S. to celebrate[.]" It is standard operating procedure to quietly stand out of the way while your enemy is busy fighting itself.

How's that restoring our trans-Atlantic relations that Trump "wrecked" going? Oh: "A week ago we learned that US President Joe Biden, the leader of the free world, appeared to have blocked Defence Secretary Ben Wallace’s candidacy for Nato Secretary General. British officials were understandably furious[.]" Our closest ally. This is shameful. But Biden will call it Smart Diplomacy®. FFS.

Michigan didn't really propose to make it illegal to "misgender" someone. House Bill No. 4474 would add misgendering to statutes about "ethnic intimidation" against defined protected classes, enhancing penalties for the base crime. Much more is required than merely using the "wrong" pronoun to be guilty of ethnic intimidation. For example, stalking someone and repeatedly using the "wrong" pronoun might fit the definitions. Or beating up someone while yelling "You are not a girl!" or some such thing. Although I imagine if passed this law will be mis-used against someone, as this author (tip to Instapundit) writes, "it might not be abused today. But it will almost certainly be abused at some point." I'd expect a challenge in the courts for that. I think this change is stupid. And I have problems with the underlying hate crime law that allows only some victims to get the benefits of harsher sentences for their attackers. But as written it shouldn't require specific pronoun use. The bill narrowly passed the House and is in a Senate committee.

Shit getting real: "Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki says his country wants to join NATO's nuclear weapon sharing program."

Interesting: "During a secret visit to Ukraine by CIA Director William J. Burns earlier this month, Ukrainian officials revealed an ambitious strategy to retake Russian-occupied territory and open cease-fire negotiations with Moscow by the end of the year, according to officials familiar with the visit." Ukraine hopes by the fall to have retaken some territory in the Donbas; take substantial territory in the south; and put Crimea within range of long-range weapons.

The Chief of Space Operations wants Space Force to focus on protecting assets down on Earth rather than just satellite protection. I'm sure that's a problem. Remember who spun them off.

The Pentagon can claim they aren't woke. But saying veterans are wrong to discourage enlistment isn't going to cut it: "Pentagon scrambles to retain the main pipeline for new service members as disillusioned families steer young people away[.]" Thank you for your service. But FFS, your pronoun is "major". The Pentagon needs to demonstrate it isn't too woke to be entrusted with our young men and women. Because the woke sure aren't enlisting.

Ah, a sense of urgency: "The Navy has not developed a full cost and schedule estimate for its Shipyard Infrastructure Optimization Program (SIOP)—an effort to improve its dry docks, facilities, and equipment—and reports that it will not be able to do so until fiscal year 2025." I'm sure the Navy will get around to it.

Russia has so few reliable security forces available that it is sending Spetsnaz troops to secure parts of the border.

Science! Put up that "IN THIS HOUSE WE BELIEVE ..." sign, stat! Tip to Instapundit.

Progressive tolerance: Stay away but send a gift, you deplorable monster. Yes (and bravo), a candidate for the "Bridezilla Hall of Infamy." Tip to Instapundit.

NATO and Western allies are continuing to train Ukrainian recruits. Is the pipeline enough to replace Ukrainian losses on offense?

Saturday, July 01, 2023

Putin's Empire of Dirt

Putin could survive in the wake of the destruction he is causing Russia itself. He charged into Ukraine looking for threats from Nazis, NATO, and the Devil himself to his rule. But ended up creating an actual threat at home. Putin is surely paranoid. But he may be paranoid enough to endure this mess of his own making.

Putin made it through the brief Wagner Revolt. As a perceptive man observed:

What have I become?
My sweetest friend
Everyone I know
Goes away in the end
You could have it all
My empire of dirt
I will let you down
I will make you hurt

I wear this crown of shit
Upon my liar's chair
Full of broken thoughts
I cannot repair
Beneath the stains of time
The feelings disappear
You are someone else
I am still right here

What did Putin endure?

Prigozhin thus demonstrated that he is less a threat to Putin’s rule than he is a symptom of its inherent fragility.

That's a question I've had. One-off or symptom? If the latter, is it significant any time soon? 

Saddam Hussein kept his throne in Iraq despite presiding over a deadly musical chairs game of competing religions, ethnic groups, interests, and factions. He endured a bloody war against Iran, which he invaded, from 1980 to 1980. He survived another war he lost badly against an American-led, UN-blessed coalition from 1990-1991. And then sanctions. Yet he remained atop his empire of dirt.

It took another campaign in 2003 to chase him from his palace--and then a hunt to pull him from a hole. 

This is a strong argument, however, that Putin might not die peacefully in bed: 

Putin’s reign has been characterized by the privatization of national sovereignty. Private armies such as Wagner, which received $1 billion a year from the state’s budget, have been integral to the Putin system, and the war in Ukraine has spurred the formation of additional mercenary forces.

And then you have to consider the splintered government military ground forces that add to the mosaic of a potential bloody internal war if Putin--or the system, if it replaces Putin--loses control.

It took an invasion that went for the throat to finish off Saddam. NATO won't do that to Putin. Someone else might.

NOTE: I used DALL-E for the illustration.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.