Sunday, November 17, 2024

Weekend Data Dump

I post at The Dignified Rant: Evolved on Substack. Help me out by subscribing and by liking and sharing posts. I continue posting here on TDR seven days a week, including Weekend Data Dump and Winter War of 2022. I occasionally post short data dump items on my Substack "Notes" section. 

Could North Korea in 2025 follow the logic of a Kooks, Spooks, and Nukes strategy that downgrades the army to save money by selling to Russia a majority of their 3,500+ old tanks in order to keep Russia's tank force in action against Ukraine?

Ukraine likes their M777 155mm howitzers despite losing half to destruction or damage: "Despite these losses both sides find their howitzers extremely useful and effective doing jobs drones can’t handle."

Win-win: "Russia accepted the Chinese proposals for allowing Chinese farmers to enter the underused central Russian and far eastern farmlands. The large number of Chinese farmers would produce a lot more food, which the Chinese were willing to pay for." Food safe from blockade. And colonists in place.

I was informed it was a "peace dividend": "When looking at the maritime industrial base, it was post-Cold War budget cuts in the mid-1990s that led to reduced maritime production and left the once-robust industry fractured and fragile."

More on the pogrom in Amsterdam. The attackers are scum, of course. But where were the police both during and after the soccer match when the organized assaults on Jewish fans took place? Shame.

Putting the Indian in Indian Ocean: "As India eyes the prospect of more Chinese and Pakistani warships and submarines traversing the Indian Ocean, Delhi is boosting its nuclear-powered submarine fleet." 

Killing enemies is good: "US Central Command (CENTCOM) has conducted strikes against nine Iranian-backed militia targets in Syria since CTP-ISW's data cutoff on November 10."

Pre-boot camp training. School and play no longer routinely provide the raw material to turn into soldiers.

IFF fail.

This is unnecessary. Of course soldiers are required to disobey unlawful orders. I was taught that as an enlisted soldier. No, this is bizarre panic. And the president can fire any soldier. If this is going on I think Trump can justifiably say he has a "loss of confidence" in a lot of officers. As have I.

Okay, I link this not for politics but to ask how are we not living in a simulation? "A batty professor named Arlene Battishill came to represent the disappointed female voter demographic ..." Battishill? Batty shill?? At least the designers have a sense of humor, eh? I really wish I wasn't playing on the free version.

A provider--not only a consumer--of Western security: "South Korea is the 10th largest defense manufacturer in the world. That’s up from 13th a few years earlier. In 2024 South Korea was number 8 with a 2.8 percent share of defense exports." South Korea exports to allies.

The wild blue yonder: Ukraine has 20 of 100 F-16s promised. "These jets stay at least 40 kilometers from the Russian border because of the massive number of anti-aircraft missile systems stationed there." Ukraine doesn't have weapons to suppress air defenses. Or stealth planes.

Sure, fan the flames of my worries that the networked F-35 is vulnerable to hacking. 

Which is the bigger clue bat, ongoing Russian aggression or imminent Trump pressure? "A majority of Germans support significant defense spending increases, an outlook that coincides with the imminent return of Donald Trump to the White House[.]"

Explain to me again why we had to retreat from Afghanistan because it cost too much: "The U.S. has spent more than $14 billion to rescue and resettle Afghans in the U.S. over the last three years[.]" And $6.5 billion to subsidize the Taliban with "humanitarian" and banking aid! Other costs will come.

I've long thought China can't assume North Korea is a firm ally. I think that while China benefited from North Korea developing nukes that worry Japan, South Korea, and America, China should worry about actual North Korean nukes as much as the others. 

I heard a Times podcast guest call Russian soldiers "battle hardened." I think it is more like "battle shattered." I remember analysts calling the Iraqi army in 1990 "battle hardened" because of the long Iran-Iraq War. It was no such thing then and no such thing now for Russia.

Hopefully this is just Europhiles picking up on a European Union wet dream: "a Trump administration is likely to pull back and largely leave Europe to Europeans." We must resist "European" strategic autonomy. Euros want that regardless of the American president. 

Don't over-hype the Russia-China partnership: "Russia will not long tolerate its increasingly [vassal]-like status to China." Yes, they are frenemies with temporary benefits. But Germany and Japan weren't tight, integrated allies in World War II. So what exists isn't insignificant if China tolerates this relationship.

Navy support ships need to be armed for self defense. And perhaps supplement their defense with modularized auxiliary cruisers through higher threat areas. And such ships would be good escorts for equally slow cargo ships, no?

Sh*t got real: "The US Army will begin producing locally manufactured Trinitrotoluene (TNT), often regarded as the world’s most powerful non-nuclear explosive, for use in bombs, hand grenades, and 155 mm artillery shells after nearly 4 decades [of only importing it]."

Subliminal war: "China is stepping up pressure on the Philippines to concede its sovereign rights in the South China Sea, Manila's Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro said on Tuesday after meeting his Australian counterpart in Canberra."

The Philippines fights lawfare with lawfare: "Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. enacted on Friday two laws bolstering his nation’s maritime claims, drawing criticism from Beijing as South China Sea tensions persist."

The war on terror is not over: " On Nov. 4, CENTCOM announced that U.S. and partner forces in Iraq and Syria had conducted 95 missions against ISIS in the past 60 days, which led to 163 suspected terrorists being killed and another 33 captured." Will we really repeat the mistake of Obama's 2011 withdrawal?

Never mind? "The Qatari Foreign Ministry emphatically denied reports of Hamas’s expulsion from Doha, after U.S. officials said that Qatar demanded the Palestinian terrorist group depart." Tip to Instapundit.

I'm fine with U.S. military support for UN missions, as we've long done. But never put American troops on the ground in blue helmets between warring parties. Troops from other countries can be target practice if their governments decide it is in their interest. Our troops should win. Who else can defend the West?

Germany is effing up on a broad front: "All of these factors are responsible for Germany’s two consecutive years of recession. But even more significantly, its great manufacturing industries – chemical, engineering and automotive – are all in crisis at the same time." Can Britain avoid the same mistakes?

How brave to sail there during peacetime: "A Russian Navy warship equipped with hypersonic missiles has conducted drills in the English Channel, Russian state news agencies reported on Tuesday." That warship would lead a short but exciting life during war. 

To be fair, Iran is our active enemy: "Today, U.S. Central Command (CENTCOM) forces conducted strikes against an Iranian-backed militia group’s weapons storage and logistics headquarters facility [in Syria]. These strikes were in response to a rocket attack on U.S. personnel at Patrol Base Shaddadi."

Hmmm: "The Trump transition team is considering a draft executive order that establishes a 'warrior board' of retired senior military personnel with the power to review three- and four-star officers and to recommend removals of any deemed unfit for leadership." I never said all are worthy of dismissal. 

Familiarization is the first step: "The personal relationships soldiers are building in dozens of training exercises each year with partners throughout the Indo-Pacific are the true strength of U.S. Army Pacific[.]" Crawl, walk, run.

Hmmm: "Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has accused Israel of carrying out 'collective genocide' in Gaza, in some of his strongest criticism of the country since the war began last year." Is this a shift against Israel or a sign that war is nearly over, so just a verbal point to cover his base.

Interesting: "The FSB failure in opposing the Ukrainian [Kursk] incursion was caused by FSB preoccupation with investigating internal enemies and those suspected of opposing Vladimir Putin." When you already know what the threat is, contrary information is obviously disinformation.

Iran wages war on America: "The US Navy defeated a complex attack launched by the Houthis on Monday that saw the rebels fire several missiles and drones at two American warships off the coast of Yemen, a Pentagon spokesperson said on Tuesday."

This wasn't enough: "US forces carried out precision airstrikes against multiple Houthi weapons storage facilities in Yemen over the weekend. He said the operation involved F-35 stealth aircraft[.]"

Taiwan's decommissioned Hawk air defense missiles may somehow end up in Ukraine. 

China seized the shoal in 2012: "The Philippines has protested China’s baselines around the disputed Scarborough Shoal, as tensions between the two nations build up anew over their competing claims in the South China Sea." China's subliminal war continues under color of law.

Is the West emerging from its era of self-hatred to more confidently defend itself and its value?

It is true that the kill chain for destroying a carrier can go through the logistics vessels that keep it fighting. A logistics form of a mission kill still takes the carrier out of the fight. 

Interesting: "The MQ-25 Stingray aerial refueler will be joining the new MQ-4C Triton sensor aircraft later in 2025, Vice Adm. George Wikoff, commander of U.S. Navy Central Command and Fifth Fleet[.]"

I believe framing this as a "loyalty review board" is propaganda: "Senior officers in the U.S. military are preparing after reports of a potential new review process for top generals, a review they fear will vet personal loyalty to President-elect Donald Trump." We need leadership focused on fighting and winning.

I hope Trump doesn't issue orders via social media for communications security reasons alone. But if he does, I stand by my position that they are valid orders. A new medium doesn't change that aspect.

The long farewell nears the end: "The U.S. Air Force will start withdrawing its A-10 aircraft from Osan Air Base, South Korea, the Thunderbolt II’s last overseas location, starting in January."

The Air Force's "force design is focused on identifying the best mix of capabilities, systems, technologies, and personnel to achieve all of the Air Force’s five core functions[.]" 

Arming up: "The Latvian Ministry of Defence has selected the Ascod infantry fighting vehicle for the country’s armed forces[.]" ASCOD has many variants, including a "medium main battle tank," however that is defined.

Russia doesn't have control of the Black Sea and doesn't like that. Sure, Russia could use the sea more if it controlled it. But it has other means of conducting those missions. Ukraine is to be commended for sinking so many ships. But I suspect Russia decided no objective is worth further losses.

That's the $64,000 question: "Ukraine has a plan and so does Putin. When the plans collide, who will win?"

Russia's sledgehammer blows in the Donbas and Kursk--plus others?--could overwhelm Ukraine: "If Ukraine doesn’t find the solutions for these challenges, it seems that the war will enter into the dangerous stage of constant retreat of Ukraine." I worry about that. But I don't assume Russia can pay the price.

America's Aegis Ashore air defense system is online in Poland: "The Redzikowo base, 230 kilometers (143 miles) from the Russian border, has been operational since July but was officially inaugurated only on Wednesday." 

The East China Sea gets less attention than the South China Sea, but China has territorial ambitions there, too: "Warships and aircraft from the United States, Japan and South Korea gathered in the East China Sea on Wednesday to kick off their second large-scale exercise of the year." 

Looking North: "American, Canadian and [Finnish] officials committed to the joint development, construction and maintenance of polar icebreakers with the signing of the Icebreaker Collaborative Effort Pact in Washington today."

Israel believes its October strike on Iran reduced Iran's missile production capacity to 10% of pre-strike capacity. How long will that last? Can and will Russia make up for lost explosives production capacity? Tip to Instapundit.

Ukraine says it could build nuclear weapons if it has no other means to protect its security from Russia. But it cant' enrich to bomb levels any time soon. Maybe the better issue is whether Ukraine squirreled away some warheads--now inert, no doubt--from their old Soviet arsenal as a needed insurance policy.

From the "Well, duh" files: "Western sanctions and the war in Ukraine have deeply impacted Russia’s economy, as seen in the weakening ruble, increasing reliance on China, and signs of Russia potentially becoming a subordinate economic partner to China rather than an equal." China exploits Russia's need.

There will be a Block 8 Virginia SSN before a new sub: "SSN(X) is billed as a return to a prior generation of attack submarine optimized for blue water missions with a weapons room more in line with the Seawolf-class boats, USNI News previously reported.

Chinese-Russian Arctic cooperation. I don't see what China gains from strengthening Russia there. Sure, in peacetime China potentially gets a sea route to Europe. But that won't last during war. And if China fights Russia, Russian supply lines are better between west and east. Are they really more than frenemies?

Is this true? "The problem with [renting troops] is that Kim is probably not sending personnel from unreliable families to Russia, fearing that they would defect. Kim likely felt he could afford to send soldiers from politically elite families." I think Kim can't risk survivors coming home to "infect" others.

After Ukraine, Russia may need a less defended front to pressure: "The United States and its allies in the Arctic need to increase the number of sensors, patrols and intelligence sharing in the region to contain the expansion of Russian and Chinese forces in the far north, defense leaders said at the meeting this week."

France is wrapping up the training of an entire Ukrainian brigade "armed with France-supplied tanks, artillery canons and other heavy weaponry." Will France sustain the brigade with replacement equipment and trained troops?

What's "Tora! Tora! Tora!" in Chinese characters? "For over a year U.S. Marine Corps F-35B vertical takeoff (VTOL) fighters have operated from one of the two new Japanese aircraft carriers to test their flight decks for heat resistance to the F-35 B's engines." But don't call them aircraft carriers.

Unlike the mythical underground lair of Osama bin Laden in Afghanistan, Hamas built well: "Years of effort has produced hundreds of kilometers of tunnels. ... When the IDF recently set out to destroy the tunnel system they were shocked at how extensive it was and how resistant it was to attack."

Thunder in their minds: "In late October 2024, Russia conducted its normally annual large strategic nuclear exercise. Russia frequently calls it Grom (Thunder in Russian) although this latest exercise was unnamed." It's supposed to scare us. But it doesn't reflect reality. Precedent suggests Putin is oblivious.

Apparently North Korea has sent some of its long-range 170-mm M1989 “Koksan” self-propelled artillery to Russia.

American special forces are reverting from the War on Terror direct action mission to the prior one of training allied troops. China is a big focus on Taiwan and I assume special forces training involves preparing the Taiwanese for irregular and insurgent fighting should China invade Taiwanese territory.

Sh*t got real: "Norwegian defense firm Kongsberg won a five-year contract from the US Navy worth around US$900 million to supply anti-ship missiles, in what the company says is its biggest missile contract ever."

Appeasement? "Indonesia’s new president, Prabowo Subianto, needed only three weeks in office to make three big concessions to China. ... The shift is all the more demeaning for Indonesia because it closely followed a series of Chinese coast guard intrusions in late October[.]" He cashed China's check, it seems.

It is important to reduce corruption in Ukraine. It seemed like patriotism muted corruption in the emergency of Russia's 2022 invasion. Is the war so routine that corruption is making a comeback? On the bright side, it was never muted in Russia.

Well that's interesting: "Israel's Oct. 26 retaliatory strike on Iran 'destroyed an active top secret nuclear weapons research facility,' according to an Axios report." A warning of future strikes that Iran can't protest because officially it didn't exist.

China says the Philippines resupplied the Sierra Madre outpost ship at Second Thomas Shoal in the South China Sea and rotated the garrison with the permission of the Chinese. Has China established control with only the date of denial of permission to resupply the only question?

Sounds like an easy target in war: "China has achieved a milestone in renewable energy with the connection of its first 1-gigawatt offshore photovoltaic (PV) project to the power grid."

Russia intends to freeze Ukrainian civilians: "NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte has called on alliance members and other Western partners to provide more support for Ukraine as cold weather looms."

Good: "Israel's new defence minister, Israel Katz, has confirmed the conscription of thousands of ultra-Orthodox men planned by his predecessor." Relying on others to protect them from being massacred is immoral. And this will end an incentive to falsely claim to be ultra-Orthodox to avoid military service. 

India can calm things down but can't cope while India relies on China economically: "China and India have no desirable 'normal' status quo to return to. Challenges abound in the bilateral relationship, and China’s ambitions continue to circumscribe India’s ability to act at the regional and global levels." 

#YouInvadedUs: "The Ukrainian drone attacks are a form of psychological warfare against Russia and its people. Despite regular Russian pronouncements of victories in Ukraine, the drones keep coming and proving that Ukraine is not defeated and still very visibly fighting."

Good: "Vladimir Putin has ordered MSF or Médecins Sans Frontières/Doctors Without Borders to leave Russia." MSF has served to lessen the problem of Putin stripping medical personnel from the civilian world to cope with high war casualties. 

Plans on paper always work: "The Navy is refining its plan to create an 80 percent combat-ready surge force to meet the deployment goals included CNO Adm. Lisa Franchetti’s new navigation plan, the service’s second-highest officer said." A refined plan will be awesome. Still, it's nice to have a goal.

We win. He loses: "Washington must recognize that it would be negotiating from a significant position of strength. If there is to be any meaningful engagement with Turkey, Washington should be explicit in its expectations." We have an Erdogan problem.

Hypersonic missiles go to sea: "The Navy wants to start testing its Conventional Prompt Strike missile system aboard guided-missile destroyer USS Zumwalt (DG-1000) in 2027 or 2028, the admiral overseeing the effort said Thursday."

Tech. support for Ukraine: "NATO has moved its three decade-old reachback support operations to Poland. Reachback electronically connects troops in a combat zone with a large number of tech experts and other support personnel stationed anywhere else in the world, but generally in the US."

Has Israel developed the first working, mobile air defense laser?

Saturday, November 16, 2024

Nobody Ever Said There is No Substitute for Deterrence

Let's stop thinking that the price of defending our freedom can be lowered by building a military capable of denying an enemy a cheap victory rather than by smashing and defeating their military if they attack.

We commemorate Victory in Europe (VE) Day and Victory over Japan (VJ) Day. Enemies should fear those outcomes rather than being on the losing end of the theoretical calculation.

So I heartily endorse this advice for military capabilities:

Getting all of the partners and allies in the region involved in exercises and “demonstrating on a daily basis … that you’re prepared to fight and win a war should you need to is really the ultimate way to deter a war,” [Brig. Gen. Anthony Mastalir, commander of U.S. Space Forces Indo-Pacific] said.

Too often the quest for enough military power to deter an enemy attack focuses simply on making the cost too high for the enemy to bear. Sadly, this relies on accurately predicting how much the enemy is willing to lose to win.

I sure blew that one on Russia--although grant me credit on accurately judging Russia's military prior to the Winter War of 2022.

Deterring an enemy just seems like a quest for a cheap silver bullet weapon to lift the burden of being prepared to fight and win a war as the ultimate deterrence.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

Friday, November 15, 2024

Nuclear Deterrence ... Of Who?

Xi Jinping highlighted an inspection of a rocket forces brigade to highlight readiness. Readiness for what?

Okay:

This focus on the Rocket Force’s deterrence capabilities shows that Xi wants Beijing’s rivals to take China seriously. The key of nuclear weapons is not to launch a surprise attack, but instead to avoid any situation in which they are needed. These arms are all about deterrence, and if you want to deter an opponent they must know you are capable of fighting back, rather than thinking your rockets are filled with water. This is the crux of Xi’s deal with the Rocket Force.

But is that message using China's suddenly expanding nuclear force intended for America? 

But China has not felt much of a need for more nukes to deter America (or India) thus far. Suddenly having a lot more nukes is vitally important to China's rulers. Why?

Maybe China wants to deter someone else that sees nukes as its ultimate territorial defense. Which is more pronounced now that most of Russia's shattered army is fighting Ukraine.

Who is China really trying to deter? America which has no territorial claims on China? Or Russia which currently controls huge tracts of Chinese land taken in the 19th century in the largest land grab of the "Century of Humiliation"? Sure, Chinese nukes would be useful to deter America should China conquer Taiwan, which America considers free terrain notwithstanding China's claim to own it. But that's not quite the same, eh?

Not everything is about us.

And China recently reopened that 19th century issue with a seemingly small offer about gaining access to the Tumen River which leads to the Sea of Japan.

I can only wonder if Russia's closer defense ties with North Korea include a joint refusal to refuse that offer. Can they? 

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

Thursday, November 14, 2024

Breaking the Kill Chain From Space

Space Force is focused on Chinese ballistic missiles.

Chinese missiles threaten American ships and facilities in the western Pacific:

China has invested heavily in its long-range strike capabilities, and the U.S. Space Force is working to identify the vulnerabilities in China’s kill chains should conflict arise, the leader of the service’s Indo-Pacific component said Oct. 22.

The kill chain has links that can be broken. Although sadly, land facilities can't maneuver, reducing the links that can be broken. 

The focus on Earth is a good demonstration why I never thought Space Force should be based on the Navy. Save that for when our military moves beyond the Earth-Moon system.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Wednesday, November 13, 2024

Will Competing Alliances Light a Fire in the Horn of Africa?

America seems like an after-thought in the growing competition in the Horn of Africa.

Alliance: 

The presidents of Egypt, Eritrea, and Somalia formalized and deepened an anti-Ethiopian alliance during a trilateral summit on October 10. ...

Somalia has worked to deepen diplomatic relations and security cooperation with Eritrea and Egypt since Ethiopia signed a naval port deal with Somaliland. The January 2024 deal granted Ethiopia land in Somaliland for a naval base in return for recognizing Somaliland’s independence. The Somali Federal Government has strongly rejected the deal as unlawful and a violation of its territorial integrity, as it considers Somaliland to be part of its territory. The Somali and Eritrean presidents met days after the port deal announcement to discuss ways to “strengthen ties and foster cooperation.” Somali media said the two-day visit was “impromptu,” suggesting it was in response to the deal. Somalia’s cooperation with Egypt in particular has accelerated since January 2024. Egypt and Somalia signed a bilateral defense cooperation agreement in Cairo in August. Egyptian media said Egypt deployed 1,000 soldiers to Mogadishu between August 27 and 29, while international media has reported on two arms shipments including ammunition, arms, artillery, and other weaponry since August.

These countries don't like the Ethiopia-Somaliland port deal. Although Egypt is no doubt simply looking for ways to pressure Ethiopia on the GERD dam on the Nile River. Is Sudan in line to join this alliance?

Egypt will deploy more troops. And Egypt has a couple Mistral-class French amphibious warfare ships in its fleet.

I noted that regional powers are rushing to the Horn of Africa. And wonder where it might lead. 

I mean, does anybody expect America to settle the region down given its record the last year?

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

Tuesday, November 12, 2024

Fighting Drones

The Army recognizes the need to fight cheap drones with cheap ammunition.


Interesting:

The Army is in the initial stages of testing new, specialized bullets to shoot down small drones, Army officials said on Monday. The service is developing both 30mm and 25mm rounds to be carried by AH-64 Apache attack helicopters and Bradley Fighting Vehicles, both of which the Army views as a primary system for protecting troops from future drone threats.

I have questions. First, this sounds promising. But questions remain.

Does the Bradley round (BADGER) mean that in the future, the Bradley will be used exclusively for this mission as a new infantry fighting vehicle (IFV) enters the Army and replaces Bradleys in the IFV role? Or does this a means to test the ability to include this capability on the new IFV?

I'd guess the former because I'd think that modified active protection systems designed to cope with FPV drones attacking from above would provide vehicle protection. Unless a single future IFV in a platoon would have the longer-range capability the Bradley is testing; or perhaps a platoon of them at the company level parceled out.

Second, does the Apache round (APEX) reflect that the Army wants a safer mission over friendly forces as a combat air patrol because it is too dangerous for helicopters to carry out missions close to enemy air defenses--including suicide drones that target them? If so the already built helicopters could be seen as a bridge until fighter drones protect our troops from other drones are developed, as I called for some years ago in Army magazine.

Third, will directed-energy weapons end the drone mystique?

Small drones have an edge now. But counter-measures are coming. I think drones will simply become part of a complete combined arms operation.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: The image is drawn from my old DALL-E 3 stockpile.

Monday, November 11, 2024

The Winter War of 2022 Risks a Veterans Day Problem

Is Russia sowing the seeds of its own destruction? But would that do Ukraine any good in the short run?

Russia continues to target Ukrainian cities--at a substantially higher rate now--while Ukraine strikes deep in Russia against military targets and logistics. While the front as a whole only changes slowly, it worries me that Ukraine is losing ground in the western Donbas under the stress of Russian ground pressure:

Outmanned, outgunned, exhausted, Ukrainian troops are stretched to the breaking point by a Russian Army willing and able to throw more men and more weaponry to overrun Kyiv's defenses.

I worry that Ukraine can't stop the Russians and wonder how long can Ukraine endure this. Is Russia's advance limited more by their own shortcomings rather than Ukrainian resistance? ISW reports two things that seem to indicate the war is on the knife's edge. One, my worry as Russia grinds forward:

Russian forces will eventually make operationally significant gains if Ukrainian forces do not stop ongoing Russian offensive operations, but the Russian military cannot sustain such loss rates indefinitely, especially not for such limited gains.

And two, my hope that Russia can't continue as it is:

Russian forces reportedly lost almost 200 tanks, over 650 armored vehicles, and suffered an estimated 80,000 casualties in taking roughly 1,500 square kilometers during a period of intensified Russian offensive operations in September and October 2024.

Whose will to fight breaks first? For now the war drags on. Time alone pushes combatants to extreme measures to finally win and escape the drain of blood and treasure with no end in sight. It is most evident in the conduct of Russia's ground forces. Is Russia's brutality in war creating a fifth column inside Russia?

ISW has observed numerous instances of Russian military personnel, especially former Wagner Group fighters, committing gruesome acts against fellow Russian servicemen on the frontlines, Ukrainian forces and civilians, and Russian citizens upon their return from the frontlines. Russia is likely to see a significant rise of brutality and cruelty in its communities upon the arrival of more traumatized Russian servicemen home as long as it continues to brutalize its soldiers; refuses to provide the necessary psychological assistance to returning veterans; and militarizes its society, educational institutions, and government.

As I've long noted, I think an important reason to have rules of war is that it helps our citizen-soldiers fight what is inherently a brutal business come home with their heads held high. By fighting by means judged by superiors to be lawful, killing becomes less of a "thou shalt not kill" murder and more of a fighting for a good cause to defend our free nation.  

Russian soldiers are more at risk of coming home with the mindset of the former rather than the latter because they are expected to--and often ordered to--be brutal to their enemies, the people they've conquered, and even their fellow troops. 

And if that is a spark inside Russia, Putin is also scattering gasoline across Russia.

But Russian internal disorder may not matter to Ukraine if it loses this war first.

UPDATE (Monday): It is certainly true enough that "the Russo-Ukraine War is a secondary concern that needs to be concluded so that we can restore our focus on China."

But that doesn't mean Russia isn't a serious concern. And it doesn't mean that "concluded" can include "lost" unless we want the price of defending our national security interest in Europe to go up and dilute our ability to focus on China.

As the author notes, it doesn't seem like Trump will accept a serious defeat of Ukraine even if it involves losing territory. But I honestly don't know if Ukrainians are willing to pay the price to eject Russia from all the territory Russia has conquered since 2014, no matter how much the West arms and support Ukraine.

UPDATE (Tuesday): ISW sees more of a threat from Russia's offensive in the Vuhledar region:

ISW is revising its previous assessment that Russian forces would not likely be able to take advantage of the seizure of Vuhledar for further offensive operations in western Donetsk Oblast. That assessment was incorrect.

Yeah, in an update in this post I had my doubts about the previous comforting assessment:

This seems to be moving the goal posts quite a bit to minimize the significance of recent Russian advances around Vuhledar. Obviously nothing Russia has done matches their very early war advances into Ukraine.

The Russian advance may very well culminate before achieving anything of operational significance. But the advances are faster lately. Why?

Where are Ukraine's reserves? I've long hoped this year that Ukraine has reserves to give Russia a good counter-punch in the nose at one sector of the front where Russia is advancing. Hit them when they lack fortifications and are tired. I especially hoped for a counter-attack at the Avdiivka salient apparently aiming for Pokrovsk. But there has been nothing.

UPDATE (Friday): Sometimes I am astounded at how low the troop-to-front ratio in the war must be:

Russian forces recently advanced into Kupyansk during a likely roughly company-sized mechanized assault, although ISW does not assess that Russian forces control the area.

Russia is advancing with attacks this size or smaller. It's big news to read about a battalion-sized attack. 

And remember that Ukraine's incursion into Russia was initially a battalion-sized operation.

UPDATE (Sunday): Operation Die in the Cold continues against Ukraine's people:

Russia on Sunday launched a massive drone and missile attack on Ukraine, described by officials as the largest over the past months, targeting energy infrastructure and killing civilians.

The attack came as fears are mounting about Moscow’s intentions to devastate Ukraine’s power generation capacity ahead of the cold winter.

I guess Russia doesn't really think Ukrainians are Russians with a funny accent who need to be liberated. Ukrainians are just another independent people Russia wants to conquer.

NOTE: ISW updates continue here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Sunday, November 10, 2024

Weekend Data Dump

I post at The Dignified Rant: Evolved on Substack. Help me out by subscribing and by liking and sharing posts. I continue posting here on TDR seven days a week, including Weekend Data Dump and Winter War of 2022. I occasionally post short data dump items on my Substack "Notes" section. 

As we wait to see if Iran strikes Israel again and speculate about Israel's next retaliation, can we talk about Iran's path to nuclear missiles and whether we are too focused on the enrichment route?

North Korea embraces Russia: "The implications of a long-term alignment between Russia and North Korea extend far beyond the battlefield in Ukraine and may have long-term impacts on the stability of the Korean Peninsula and Asia-Pacific region." Is this alignment for resisting China?

Oh, BS: "'The entire Palestinian population in North Gaza is at imminent risk of dying from disease, famine and violence,' said the statement, published by the UN Inter-Agency Standing Committee." And if true, why doesn't Hamas surrender rather than continue to hide behind that doomed population? 

I just noticed that Bing doesn't seem to save my generated images, unlike DALL-E 3 which still holds everything I made despite not being allowed to make new images in that platform. I can't find anything to change the "recent" images list to "all"! I hope I'm missing something.

Iran expands its aggression against Saudi Arabia: "The Islamic Resistance in the Land of the Two Holy Mosques, an Iranian-backed militia claiming to operate in Saudi Arabia, claimed its second attack since announcing its existence. " 

Ukraine has converted a tank brigade (4 tank, 1 mechanized, and 2 rifle battalions) to a heavy mechanized brigade (2 tank, 2 mechanized, and 2 rifle battalions). America and Germany in World War II reduced the too-high tank-to-infantry ratio in their initial tank divisions as the war went on. 

I expect little: "Japan and the European Union announced a security and defense partnership on Friday as they seek to step up military ties, including joint exercises and exchanges between their defense industries, amid growing tensions with China, North Korea and Russia." The power to sign a deal is the EU goal.

I think our retired general and flag officers are outside their lane when they comment on politicians. I'd forbid officers from getting degrees in anything other than engineering and military history. Perhaps not literally, but directionally that should be the goal.

Ukraine's figurative Valley Forge looms. It's been a worry of mine.

I think European panic about America is all about claiming a crisis that the EU can exploit for its own power.

Bringing up "dormant NATO" again. So I'll repeat that I think it is a moronic idea. 

Yeah, I doubt the North Koreans sent to Ukraine are a game changer. We'll see if they are only the first wave, I suppose. But they aren't "special forces." Up to 12,000 Russians will see their death or wounding delayed by twelve days with this contingent. And the North Koreans will kill some number of Ukrainians. 

The Marines gave up their tanks. Are the Marines and Army ready to integrate Army tanks into Marine amphibious operations?

And now for something completely different:


Well, they sort of have a point: "A group of progressive House lawmakers is questioning the involvement of the U.S. military in the expanding conflict in the Middle East, arguing the deployment of American troops to Israel and other support violated constitutional law." But not really. It's complicated.

China pursues a blue water coast guard.

In case China escalates beyond its subliminal war: "The Philippine military opened two weeks of combat drills Monday that would include seizing an island in the disputed South China Sea and likely be frowned upon by China."

Courage and duty under fire. 

Stop obscuring it with a trendy term. Russia is waging war: "'Russia is conducting ... an intensifying campaign of hybrid attacks across our allied territories, interfering directly in our democracies, sabotaging industry and committing violence,' said [NATO chief] Rutte, speaking alongside Chancellor Olaf Scholz."

We've forgotten how to build weapons, it seems: "Like the Columbia-class submarines, Ford-class aircraft carriers and Constellation-class frigates, the new and improved Air Force bomber won’t reach initial operational capability until later than planned."

We will form a Naval Strategic Studies Group: "NSSG will be modelled on a similar group created in 1981 during the Cold War, which had a twofold mission to train future flag officers in strategic thinking and to conduct research on some of the department’s vexing strategic challenges."

OUT: Hybrid War! IN: Incremental War? I prefer to call age-old, sub-war aggression--or, in full-scale war, supporting measures that get obscured by the loud explosions--"subliminal war" so it doesn't seem like some new and novel form of warfare.

Well, Japan and Poland are both frontline states facing our common enemies: "Japan and Poland are set to gain access to the U.S. military’s Wideband Global Satcom (WGS) satellite network[.]"

A small but lengthy war in the Middle East is straining American Navy assets and munitions supplies.

Strategersky: "Russian leaders are dismayed that when Russia threatens the United States for one reason or another, the Americans ignore them. Russian leaders get the impression that the Americans don’t take them seriously. There are reasons for that and the most obvious one is the rampant corruption in Russia." 

Oopsky: "Putin yearned for the pre-war times when he could portray the Russian military as a mighty force that was not crippled by corruption and incompetent and corrupt leadership." I did warn him.

Ouchsky: "China wants its stolen territories back and Putin fears that while Russia is busy in Ukraine the Chinese might make a move." Putin's plan looked like a sure thing!

South Korea has a serious fleet: "The South Korean Navy has 17 frigates, all of which entered service between 1992 and 2024. There are thirteen destroyers, three corvettes and 34 patrol boats. There are also 22 submarines and 21 amphibious warfare ships."

Did Israel restrain its attack on Iran after Iranian air defense systems locked on to its F-35s? I'm skeptical given that Israel apparently knocked out the air defense radars. But I'll certainly watch for stories. Also, the headline about a F-35 "shot down" by Iranian radar is BS unrelated to the story text.

Sh*t got real: "The Department of the Navy plans to operate three Ticonderoga-class (CG 47) cruisers beyond their expected service life[.]" This extends their service past 2027 which seems to be the assumed year of China's decision to wage war.

Good: "The Extra Large Unmanned Underwater Vehicle (XLUUV,) fittingly known as Orca, is a fifty-one-foot autonomous submarine that can carry out clandestine missions like minelaying." Naval mines are under-appreciated because they aren't sexy. But if deployed by a sexy underwater drone ... funding!!

"Linger": "The Philippines has approved the purchase of 40 fast patrol craft worth 25.8 billion pesos ($441 million), seeking to bolster maritime security as tensions with Beijing in the South China Sea linger."

Germany wants to create a larger reserve force: "Germany's Cabinet approved legislation introducing a new form of military service on Wednesday, according to government sources." 

China unveiled its twin-engine J-35 stealth fighter that looks suspiciously like the Chinese stole everything about the F-35 except the "F". But is it really as stealthy as the F original?  

What will Trump's foreign policy be? It should mean a stronger military and ability to sustain war in case China goes to war; help for Ukraine and Israel to defeat their enemies to deter future aggression; defeating Iran inside Iraq; killing jihadis; missile defense at home; and a strong role in NATO to sideline the EU.

European training for Ukrainian troops is being compressed to meet Ukraine's desperate need for trained troops. I'll ask if real training is being shortchanged or are peacetime skills being junked to get speed.

A very large Chinese jet-powered drone is "at least depicted as being fitted with a modular payload section designed to launch swarms of smaller uncrewed aerial systems." Once again we see how China can use its mainland territory to employ what America needs large amphibious warfare ships to use.

Blowback: "South Korea plans to test-fire a domestically made, short-range ballistic missile in response to the North recently launching an intercontinental ballistic missile, according to a South Korean news report."

It will be interesting to see how many Americans flee abroad to seek asylum in the ten weeks before Trump's inauguration.

Huh: "France and Germany emphasized the need to keep up military spending and for unity on European security, including with the U.K., following a meeting between the two countries’ defense ministers in response to Donald Trump’s victory[.]" Ah, another faux "crisis" for the European Union to exploit.

Russia tries to throttle Ukraine's grain exports.

Russia's Black Sea Fleet has remained in port since 2023: "What keeps these Russian Navy ships from going to sea is a very real threat of attack by Ukrainian USVs (Unmanned Surface Vehicles), also known as sea drones." Sort of. Russia has few reasons to risk its fleet since it stopped trying to take Odessa.

Is artillery obsolete? "But to answer the question as to drones being the new artillery, the answer is no – at least for now." As counter-measures develop, drones will get more expensive to cope with them. Drones will just be a useful part of combined arms warfare. And I address the poor-man's air force aspect raised.

Interesting: "What neither side is doing in this war so far is delivering smart drones via missiles to hunt in wolfpacks, attacking high payoff targets (HPTs) without human control or oversight. This is the next evolution in drone warfare." About that. The First-Robot View "drone"?

BOOM: "the Israeli and U.S. strikes are a stark reminder that the most effective deterrent is a proven ability to devastate, not simply disrupt, targets at will." Pretty much preaching to my choir.

We defended our cities from Soviet bombers. The need is greater: "intelligent machines are going to take warfare to a whole new level. Enemies will aim to draw blood at each other’s industrial, agricultural, and energy underbelly – the center of gravity for any nation." Our home is the foundation of power projection.

The protection horizon expands: "The US has awarded Elbit Systems a $127-million follow-on contract to supply Iron Fist Active Protection Systems (APS) for its Bradley infantry fighting vehicles (IFVs)."

To the Shores of the Houthi?  There are limits to what can be done from the sea. Although the ability to destroy now goes beyond the range and power of smooth-bore cannons and mortars anchored offshore. Pity we knee-capped the Saudi campaign against the mostly peaceful Houthi. 

Oh, Canada: "Canada, once a primary supporter of NATO, now finds itself marginalized within the alliance, contributing little in resources or capacity to the North Atlantic and North American defense." I have thoughts.

But is EABO the answer? "Chinese naval forces and fishing fleets have engaged in activities near Australia’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), raising concerns about sovereignty and resource security. Australia has recognized the need to expand its naval capabilities to deter [China.]" I have thoughts.

Advice to the Army to learn from the Houthi to attack ships. Hmmm. I worry the Army is spending so much time trying to be a land-based navy that it is neglecting how to wage large-scale conventional land war in INDOPACOM.

There is a report that North Korean soldiers sent to Russia to fight Ukraine have discovered Internet porn. And like it a lot. One more reason Kim Jong Un wants every one of them to die in Russia. The "Hermit Kingdom" can't risk letting North Koreans exposed to the outside world come home to infect his subjects.

History is not the threat to these two: "Japan’ s Defense Minister Gen Nakatani was welcomed aboard a South Korean warship during its port call near Tokyo on Wednesday, a first for a Japanese defense chief, as the two countries step up security ties against a backdrop of growing tension in the region."

The Ukrainians repeatedly moved troops opposite Russia's Kursk province to dull Russian reactions prior to the assault in August.

American small drone development suffers from a peacetime development cycle that doesn't enable Ukraine's rapid wartime design adaptation. I assume one "problem" for America is that rather than being at war constantly using drones, we will stockpile them--which means they will be obsolete before needed.

The Biden administration plans to push appropriated aid for Ukraine out the door before the Trump administration is sworn in.  

The idea that Trump can end the Winter War of 2022 in a day is a threat to Ukraine is wrong: "The Kremlin has batted off Donald Trump's view he can end the war in Ukraine within a day as an 'exaggeration.'" Trump could well respond by saying the only way to end the war is to help Ukraine win.

Retired generals (and admirals) deserve a voice? Well sure. But define "voice." On policies? Absolutely they deserve a voice like anyone else. Especially on defense matters. On politics? Absolutely not. That partisan voice reflects on nonpartisan active duty officers, unfairly or not. 

I suspect this is part of China's two steps forward and one step back ratchet: "In late October 2024, India and China made a cautious but significant move to de-escalate their ongoing border dispute along the Line of Actual Control (LAC), their longstanding, loosely defined boundary." 

Reputation is the first line of defense: "A caravan of thousands of migrants traveling through Mexico with the hope of reaching the U.S. had shrunk to about half its original size on Thursday as many migrants grapple with their prospects following former U.S. President Donald Trump's victory[.]"

Is China's "gray zone" military pressure on Taiwan backfiring?  Or is China dulling Taiwanese reaction to military movements for an overt invasion?

European Union fanboys "complain" of the "end of Pax Americana" and ask if it is time for a European Union defense policy. Both are part of an EU wet dream to exploit anything to achieve longstanding objectives to eject America from Europe and remove the prefix from their proto-imperial project.

Reputation is the first line of defense: "Qatar has told the political leaders of the Hamas terror group that they were no longer welcome in the Gulf state, Israeli media reported on Friday. " Tip to Instapundit.

Traditionsky: "Russia [relies on muscles--not forklifts]. Clinging to archaic logistical practices means that supplies reach Russian troops more slowly, and often not at all, because of the shortage of trucks to move supplies the last fifty or hundred kilometers from the railroad to the front lines."

Ukraine is actually firing more artillery rounds than Russia now: "Russian forces in Ukraine have, over the last few months, been suffering ammunition shortages and increasingly unreliable railroad deliveries. Part of the reason for this was the August 2nd Ukrainian attack into Kursk province." Read the rest. 

A pogrom in modern Europe: "rampaging mobs of Muslim men targeted Israeli attendees of a soccer match featuring the Maccabi team." To be fair, a lot of people living in Europe now never vowed "never again." They're more into the "once more, with feeling" camp. Tip to Instapundit.

Caving to Putin was always highly unlikely. This makes it impossible: "Russian President Vladimir Putin appears to be assuming that US President-elect Donald Trump will defer to the Kremlin's interests and preferences without the Kremlin offering any concessions or benefits in return." 

North Korea sucks but endures under communism and sanctions. It makes money with troops that Russia dresses up as Russians: "The West knows that the North Korean soldiers are fighting for Russia, but the Russians would prefer to pretend otherwise."

Egypt remains powerful in its region: "Some things never change. Take Egypt and its continued domination of North Africa. For over 5,000 years, the Egyptian civilization has dominated North Africa." Can it extend its power to the Horn of Africa? 

China pretends defining Scarborough Shoal is an internal matter: "China has published baselines for a contested shoal in the South China Sea it had seized from the Philippines, a move that's likely to increase tensions over overlapping territorial claims." China took control in 2012, defying international law.

Honestly, this seems like a late move to be able to condemn Trump for revoking permission: "The Biden administration has lifted a de facto ban on American military contractors deploying to Ukraine to help the country’s military maintain and repair US-provided weapons systems[.]"

A consequence of America visibly trying to leave Iraq: "An amendment to Iraq’s 1959 Personal Status law was officially proposed in the Iraqi parliament on Aug. 4. The draft law could theoretically make it legal for girls as young as nine years old to get married." Will it pass? Also, Yahoo AI offered me "context."

Hmmm: "Just before Tuesday’s presidential election, the Biden-Harris administration quietly waived mandatory terrorism sanctions on the embattled Palestinian government—even as it determined that the government's leaders are paying imprisoned terrorists and fomenting violence in breach of U.S. law." Ugh.

Happy birthday to the Marine Corps.

The Taliban "will participate in the 29th United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP29)" for the first time. No doubt the Taliban hope this more than makes up for the whole repressing women and girls thing when it comes to the attitude of the sainted international community.

Saturday, November 09, 2024

Large-Scale Conventional Ground Combat Operations. What are They?

The United States Army in the Pacific is transforming into something that isn't primarily an army.

The Army in the Pacific is changing:

The U.S. Army command for the Indo-Pacific finds itself at the front of the service’s transformation initiative, incorporating new unit types created to facilitate rapid adaptation to adversary tactics, according to U.S. Army Pacific Command chief Gen. Charles Flynn.

Several units in the Pacific, from Hawaii to Alaska, were chosen as part of Army Chief of Staff Gen. Randy George’s initiative, dubbed “Transforming in Contact,” Flynn said in an interview ahead of the Association of the U.S. Army’s annual conference. 

Of all the units highlighted that operate across all domains--land, air, sea, space and cyberspace--one category stands out for its absence: ground combat brigades. Those legacy armored, infantry, Stryker, and airborne brigades are apparently so last century's fashion when fighting in contact was a thing. I had some hope of preparing for that, but Transforming in Contact seems to downgrade what is supposed to be an Army core capability.

It's clear that the Army in the Pacific is transforming into a non-army incapable of carrying out its core competency of large-scale ground combat operations, which as I argued in Military Review is absolutely needed in INDOPACOM to stretch China's resources. Even islands can require multiple divisions to secure. One island in particular is under threat, which could use American troops in large numbers, which I also addressed in Military Review.

The western Pacific Marines already checked out of the ground warfare mission. As the Army transforms, what service transforms to do that ground mission?

UPDATE: This essay on prioritizing preparing the Army for INDOPACOM is timely:

The complex formulae involving competition with China and assuring regional allies ultimately requires robust landpower capabilities on key terrain.

The author doesn't really address the Army's large-scale combat operations capability here, although he hints at it as the above quote indicates as does his comment that many regional allies have ground forces that dominate their military power.

The author focuses more on logistics. Which is totally fair. As I've noted, right now we are geared toward the narrow Japan-South Korea region. The logistics need to be much better to sustain a large Army operation across the broad theater. And of course the Navy and Air Force must be able to hold lines of supply to Army forces. That's a big concern of mine. For the Marines, too. And less known, other services rely on Army logistics. So crawl, walk, run, of course.

I don't think the Army should prioritize Asia. To prevent a new Bataan the Army needs the Navy and Air Force to be better first. But the Army in the Pacific certainly shouldn't be reliant on crumbs from the other theaters.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.