Wednesday, July 19, 2023

God Save America from Another Iraq War Lesson

I don't worry about America failing to learn lessons from the Iraq War as much as I worry we'll learn complete BS that masquerades as lessons. Behold the lesson that we should have reshaped Iraq's tribal- and kin-based society.


 God help us but somebody else wants us to learn a lesson from the Iraq War: 

The campaign pacified the insurgents, but the U.S. military paid too little heed to Iraq’s many sectarian divisions as it tried to suppress violence. It made no durable attempt to work or reshape the country’s system of tribes and kin-based relationships beyond making transactions with them. As a result, it was easy for violence to flare back up once the United States withdrew.

Is that all we needed to do before leaving? Reshape Iraq's system of tribes and kin-based relationships? 

After that morning task we could fix the religious and ethnic divisions in the afternoon, eh? 

Corruption could be dealt with over a working lunch, I assume.

Face it, we won the war. Some people expect too much from America for counting it as a win. Reshape Iraqi society, indeed. 

Mind you, I think leaving Iraq in 2011 was a mistake no matter how much the administration wanted to hang the "Mission Accomplished" banner and walk away. We had more to do to hold the lid on the place. And deal with Iranian intrigue.

Maybe some sheer nonsense* in the article leads me to overlook that we agree on the major point of the need to defend the win by remaining in Iraq.

The military is a blunt instrument. Saying it failed because it couldn't cut up and stitch together a better Iraq is ridiculous. The West took centuries to make that kind of progres. All we could do was hold the line and assist Iraqis in making something better than Saddam's abattoir of lives and hope. The future might see the kind of progress that we should all want Iraq to make.

Sigh. The nonsense just never stops, does it?

[*Seriously, the author says "hundreds of thousands of armed men began protesting across the country"? If America faced that many armed Iraqis resisting us that early, the author could never have even written his "The campaign pacified the insurgents" preamble to his major complaint.

But don't get me started on the "Washington disbanded the Iraqi military" nonsense. So letting the pro-Iran Iraqi militias that helped stop ISIL in 2014 remain intact rather than disbanding them after defeating ISIL in Iraq has been a source of stability rather than a mistake? Letting the bad guys remain armed is a bad idea.

No nonsense would be complete without repeating this oracle: "When asked by Congress before the invasion what it would take to defeat and occupy Iraq, U.S. Army Chief of Staff General Eric Shinseki said that the armed forces would need several hundred thousand soldiers, more than the 130,000 they were given." We never had 300,000 American troops in Iraq. Not even during the surge. Yet as the author admits, we "pacified the insurgents." Fancy that.

Further, I reject the charge we had no post-war plans. Heck, the New York Times said we did. But plans never survive contact with the enemy. Our post-war plans had assumptions that didn't pan out in large measure because rather than having a post-war situation we had a different-war situation as Iran and its western satrapy, Syria, invaded Iraq.

And the American military is supposed to predict the long-term costs of a war as a warning to civilian leaders? When two decades later it couldn't predict four days of Russia's invasion of Ukraine? 

I almost digressed. A huge footnote avoids that, right?]

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Tuesday, July 18, 2023

Somebody Will Pay the Cost of Defending America

We are a wealthy country. I'd rather spend money than blood to protect America.

Holding off our most serious security problems "over there" makes this necessary: 

The United States has always been enthusiastic about spending enormous amounts on weapons, ammunition, supplies and equipment for the troops, with the idea of keeping U.S. casualties down while still winning the war. During World War II, U.S. combat deaths were 300,000 plus 100,000 non-combat dead. The Soviet Union, on the other end of this scale, lost 10.7 million dead in combat (including 4.4 million captured and missing), and nearly 20 million civilians killed as well. Of all the major combatants in World War II, the U.S. had the lowest casualty rate (about 2 percent). Russia lost about 15 percent of its entire population during the war. For every American killed during World War II, 75 Russians died. 

It's easier to motivate soldiers directly defending their homeland under direct attack. The Civil War was our most bloody war. 

So compassion and practicality intersect to encourage America to spend money rather than blood to sustain our soldiers' will to fight and die far from home on alien shores. 

Consider our experience in the Atlantic. We don't want that threat revived. And we don't want a similar threat from across the Pacific.

And our troops may need a higher cause to justify extended sacrifice far from home. The Civil War provided the model by requiring a crusade to end the evil of slavery here. And Americans certainly fought and died in Korea and Vietnam to defeat global communism. And Americans fought and died in Afghanistan and Iraq to fight global jihad.

Is there waste in our defense spending? Sure. And if we can reform how we spend we could reduce spending without reducing capabilities. But the same can be said for the rest of the budget. We clearly can't do that. And if we can't do that, when we cut spending the first thing to go is military capability. I don't have to like that reality to recognize it.

So when you want to cut American defense spending--which is a small portion of our GDP--you may need to decide whether we should spend more blood instead of money. You may need to decide whether we should abandon a forward defense and focus on a cheaper--but more dangerous because it abandons allies and turns them into enemy assets--Fortress America. And you may need to decide that none of our enemies are evil enough or dangerous enough to require our sacrifice in either money or blood.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Monday, July 17, 2023

The Winter War of 2022 Looks Static

The war looks static. Is it?

The Russians are holding firm with Ukraine only making relatively shallow gains since early June. Westerners are eager to see something positive on the ground but have been disappointed.

Ukraine appears to be weakening Russian forces holding the line with offensive action designed to use firepower to destroy Russian military power while minimizing Ukrainian losses. I suspect the Russians have few reserves beyond local reserves. So the stout defense may be a crust that relies on bluff to get the Ukrainians to give up even as they get close to winning.

I'm hoping that eventually Ukraine's efforts to erode Russia's ground forces without suffering too many losses of their own will lead to a crack in Russia's line and an opening for Ukraine to commit a good portion of their reserves to push through and advance. And I'm hoping that Russian morale and command and control will not be able to adapt to a fast-moving situation, leading to a collapse of Russian defensive cohesion as units try to escape.

In completely unrelated news, what's going on with the arrest or dismissal of various Russian commanders in some of the most effective ground forces in the war? Insubordination is in the air.

This well-known author thinks slow progress is no reason to declare failure. He sees this slow-moving Ukrainian assault as a phase to stretch the Russian defenders and undermine their logistics, with the hope Ukraine can commit their uncommitted reserves to quickly drive through the Russian lines:

Some units are now close to Russia’s main defence line, though most are not. We can note evidence of poor coordination between Russian units and how they often, but not always, lose out in small-scale engagements, but also that Russian defences have not yet buckled. This remains a tough and costly fight for Ukraine. During this attritional phase we can see the potential for progress but it has yet to be realised. Only when and if the strike phase is reached will we be able to measure Ukrainian progress on the map.

The Allies did this after landing at Normandy in 1944.* I can't say this pattern will hold true today. After all, the Allies had much more materiel superiority--including air superiority--to grind away despite suffering higher losses until the Allies could break out with speed.

On the other hand, the Germans were more skilled than the Russians are today. And maybe Ukraine's ground-based precision rockets can replace air power as long as Russia's aircraft are kept off of Ukraine's advancing armored forces.

Fingers crossed. I try very hard not to let my hopes exceed the facts. But the facts seem open to success or failure at this point. As war all too often is. And too many seem to be letting their hopes for proving their long-held positions that Russia can't lose (and that America is responsible for the war and not Russia) exceed the facts so far known.

What I can say is that Ukraine's tactics could work. Russia has suffered heavy losses already and I don't know what their breaking point is. On the other hand, Russia is buying time with their troops' lives. Eventually, Russia might buy enough time for the Ukrainians to run out of campaigning weather. And buy time for Russia to restore their army. 

If Ukraine can't get their "Saratoga" victory in the next few months, the West might scale back help to pressure Ukraine into accepting a ceasefire leaving Russia in control of Ukrainian territory.

*After I wrote this, an American general cited the D-Day experience.

UPDATE (Monday): Ukraine apparently damaged the Kerch Strait bridge linking Crimea to Russian territory in new attacks. Does this mean Ukraine's counteroffensive is getting ready to scale up?

NOTE: ISW coverage of the war continues here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

Sunday, July 16, 2023

Weekend Data Dump

Fareed Zakaria fluffed President Biden something fierce. I haven't commented on Zakaria in ages. But it is still true that he couldn't find his own buttocks with both hands and a GPS signal.

Mistakes like this happen when Supreme Court justices forget they are judging laws for constitutionality and think they are quasi-legislative actors who need statistics to back their favored policies. Judges, legislators, and executives should stay in their lanes and do their actual jobs. Tip to Instapundit.

Sure: "Ukraine deserves to be in NATO, Turkish Recep Tayyip Erdogan said Friday as he met with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky ahead of the alliance's upcoming summit in Lithuania." Getting something for their approval is one thing. But the bottom line is that Turkey gained great freedom of action when the Soviet Union collapsed and the Russians were pushed back from Turkey's borders in Europe, Asia, and the Black Sea. Turkey doesn't want Russia to again dominate the Black Sea. Ukraine holds that line. Delusions of Ottoman Empire 2.0 grandeur have cleared a bit with the realization that NATO is still useful in a dangerous region.

Strategypage discusses NASAMS and IRIS-T in Ukraine.

Sanctions are no silver bullet: "Russia found that nearby Iran, which has been under varying degrees of sanctions for decades, was a good source of advice on evading sanctions. Even before Russia went total outlaw in Ukraine, they had been cooperating with Iran, North Korea and several other heavily sanctioned nations." But they still hurt the sanctioned state.

Despite Russian aircraft harassing our drones, a drones managed to make a good jihadi in Syria. 

I object to the notion that Germany sending troops to exercise in Australia represents a shift in focus to Asia. Doesn't that imply that Germany had a focus elsewhere? I'd be happier if Germany had a vague image of European security. To be fair, sending 240 ground troops probably is a major fraction of Germany's effective ground power.

Finally: "Turkey agreed Monday to allow Sweden to join the NATO alliance[.]" Hungary had tied its opposition to Turkey's.

China needs to know that even if they quickly conquer Taiwan that the war is far from over. But making sure Taiwan can build whatever advanced defense equipment is flawed if Taiwanese troops lack the will to fight hard. And if we don't intervene quickly. That might just result in China capturing a lot of high-tech defense industry and equipment.

Good grief, this seriously over-states the effects of recent Russian aircraft losses. Russia has lost a tiny fraction of its planes. The real problem is training and how they are used.

This is odd on the surface. I don't think this is proof of a conspiracy with Prigozhin to weed out the disloyal: "The mercenary chief had a three-hour meeting with Putin on June 29, five days after his short-lived rebellion, Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said." I think it probably has more to do with stretching out the demise of Prigozhin so Putin can salvage as much of Wagner's combat capabilities as he can for his war effort.

Plausible: "Nearly 50,000 Russian men have died in the war in Ukraine, according to the first independent statistical analysis of Russia’s war dead." Based on inheritance records and excess mortality during war. And given the fractured nature of its forces fighting, Russia might not even know the full tally.

I'm not worried that Biden said we are short of artillery ammunition. That means we've reached a floor below which we won't go. Not that we are out. And that issue is well discussed in our media. This is no big reveal to the Russians or Chinese.

I'm calling BS on "bed rotting" as a "trend". A few social media morons showcased it and it is supposedly a trend justifying an article? Not buying it. Via Instapundit.

It is bizarre that Russia is refusing to admit that Crimea is a potential war front: "Russian officials continue to struggle with traffic and logistics issues at the Kerch Strait Bridge associated with the continued tourist season in occupied Crimea." That could bite Russia in the ass if Ukrainian special forces or partisans exploit the needless civilian traffic. Or if panicked Russian civilians knot up ground lines of communication in the event of a Ukrainian offensive or missile attacks that frighten them.

Last week I suspected Hamas-Palestinian Authority disputes; and wondered if Iran and their Hezbollah proxy had a hand in that Jenin situation. Iran has been busy: "Hezbollah appears to be establishing another front behind Israeli lines—both within the country’s official boundaries and the West Bank." Iran wants another rocket arsenal in the West Bank. Maybe Iran is angling to back Hamas and others in a civil war over control of Palestinians in the West Bank. They've already gained ground: "The PA has lost control of the cities of Jenin, Nablus and Tulkram to Iranian allies Palestinian Islamic Jihad, Lion’s Den and Hamas." Would Israel fight where Hezbollah want the fight? Or respond by going to the home base of Hezbollah's power? Or, as that article's author advises, Netanyahu can offer concessions to people who want to kill Jews--to make Biden happy.

Russia has about 2,000 small-payload Iranian Shahed-136 suicide drones/cruise missiles apparently being held in reserve for something. Perhaps that's Russia's main weapon to strike Ukrainian troops if they break through Russian lines. I've wondered if Russia's air force would do that. Maybe Russia knows its conventional air force can't do the job at an acceptable cost.

I salute him for aiming high: "On July 13, retired Air Force Lt. Col. James Harvey III will celebrate his 100th birthday, the latest milestone for an original Tuskegee Airman who also won the first ever ‘Top Gun’ trophy and was one of the first African American fighter jet pilots."

It's help for Ukraine and real-world training for the Australians: "Australia will send a Royal Australian Air Force surveillance aircraft to Germany to help support Ukraine by protecting vital humanitarian and military supply lines."

Chutzpah.

So strange that they risk so much to get to the so-called racist West. Get back to me when they risk that much trying to leave.

Huh: "A U.S. intelligence assessment says Iran is not pursuing nuclear weapons at the moment but has ramped up activities that could help it develop them." Two things. One: "At the moment". Funny no assessment was publicized in "another moment". Two: "Ramping up activities" to help build nuclear weapons is Iran's nuclear weapons program. Okay, three.

After Russia's first invasion of Ukraine in 2014, "the U.S. Army realized that it had a major deficit in both capabilities and capacity to conduct long-range fires. The U.S. Army was both outranged and outnumbered by Russia’s long-range fires systems." Also, the Army realized the Air Force isn't highly interested in providing close air support. Naturally, the God of War needs an offering.

Island hopping campaign continues: "China and the Solomon Islands on Monday signed a deal on police cooperation as part of an upgrade of their relations to a 'comprehensive strategic partnership[.]'"

Mowing the jihadi grass in Somalia. Pretending Somalia is a country that can be reformed is clearly insane at this point, isn't it? 

Totally non-shocking news after Erdogan backs Sweden's membership in NATO: "US President Joe Biden's administration has backed Turkey's desire to purchase 40 new Lockheed Martin Corp F-16 fighter jets along with modernization kits for its existing warplanes from the US."

So our media is going with "Biden yells at all his staff for being incompetent because he's a strong alpha male"? That would be quite the late-stage development after merely being a mean, bullying, braggart all his adult life. But if true, doesn't that say little about his ability to hire quality staff? On the other hand, in that video Biden is clearly--if perhaps inappropriately--speaking to the British soldier. Biden isn't vacantly staring off at God knows what. There's enough to point out without assuming everything is proof of dementia.

My F**k Off reflex is getting a workout this year: "A constitutional law professor at Georgia State University recently said it’s 'unfortunate' that the Michigan 'pronouns' bill making its way through the state legislature is likely unconstitutional." Right, "constitutional law" professor. Tip to Instapundit. 

Why did Finland and Sweden join NATO now? Really? Because Russia invaded Ukraine. Which demonstrated their need to join NATO and also took advantage of Russia being too busy fighting Ukraine to do much about Finland and Sweden. I imagine Ukraine could join NATO while Russia is busy holding off a Chinese security force expedition taking control of portions of Russia's Far East taken from China in the 19th century. The compensation would be NATO military supplies to hold off the Chinese.

After buying 36 of the French land-based planes in 2015, India will buy more: "Nearly three dozen Rafale-Marine fighters will be sold to the Indian Navy for use on its locally manufactured aircraft carrier, the INS Vikrant, according to senior officials familiar with the developments." The most important Indian defense decision of the decade enters its second decade with little progress.

Ukraine may have converted ancient S-200 air defense missiles to short-range surface-to-surface ballistic missiles.

Yeah, it angers me that organizations needlessly enter politics. Back in the 1980s I remember being annoyed that a group advocating protecting rain forests spoiled their message by taking a position on the presidential election. I wasn't pro-burn-down-rain forests, after all. Of course they hated Reagan. Why push away potential supporters of your narrow mission? 

FFS: "U.S. Special Presidential Envoy for Climate John Kerry was blasted on social media Monday after worrying about how Russia's invasion of Ukraine will affect climate change." I expect nothing less from the worst secretary of state in living memory. And how prescient was I at the end of that post?

NATO agreed to stand by Ukraine and to eventually let Ukraine in the alliance. The Definitions Section is noticeably absent.

Take your time. No rush at all: "A coalition of 11 NATO countries agreed to begin an F-16 training program in Europe this August to train Ukrainian pilots on the warplanes, ending speculation about when the long-awaited training would begin." Tick tock, people.

I believe Russia's decision to invade Ukraine is the source of any problems we have: "Former President Trump ripped President Biden for his decision to send Ukraine cluster bombs and claimed Biden was 'dragging' the United States 'into World War III' by making the controversial decision." Yet another adherent to the "Let the Wookie win" school of strategy.

Support: "As NATO debates the future for Ukraine, Germany has vowed to surge weapons supplies to Kyiv after signing off on a €700 million ($769 million) military aid package covering air defense equipment, infantry fighting vehicles, main battle tanks and artillery ammunition." Also, Germany will sell Australia infantry fighting vehicles.

But on the other hand it is infested with jihadis and has nuclear weapons: "Pakistan turned out to be a slow-motion trainwreck which took decades to devastate Pakistan economically, politically and militarily."

Yeah: "It is unclear if North Korea even has reliable nuclear warheads because they only recently developed working nuclear weapons. Turning these nukes into reliable weapons for ballistic missiles is another chore and it is unclear how effective the North Korean nuclear warheads are."

That's not a lot: "Iran continues to deplete its artillery ammunition inventory in order to supply Russia. The latest deal involves 14,000 152mm shells for D20 towed howitzers, 10,000 high-explosive shells for T-72 tank guns as well as two replacement barrels for the T-72 tank and two replacement barrels for the 122mm D30 towed howitzers." And full price. I wonder if the ammo and barrels are just testing for quality before buying more. Or maybe Iran doesn't have much to sell.

Is Air Force General Brown waving too many red flags to be Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff? "General Brown has not resisted the temptation to opine boldly in public about controversial political issues. The public's trust in the military has been trending downward for the past 20 years and is approaching historic lows. High ranking officers have become openly political, eschewed impartiality, quibbled, or openly lied to the public." To be fair, I'm not sure who I trust these days.

That's about twice the rate it should be for normal maintenance and updates: "As of this year, 18 of the US Navy’s 49 attack submarines — 37% — were out of commission, according to previously undisclosed Navy data published by the Congressional Research Service."

A warning to Iran? "The United States and Israel on Sunday kicked off the second iteration of a new series of war games designed to enable the Israeli air force to partake in long-range strikes on strategic targets hundreds of miles away from the country’s own airspace." I don't believe this administration would support Israel striking Iran's nuclear infrastructure. I imagine this is for the purpose of figuring out how to hinder Israel.

The Army develops HADES, its new ISR plane.

Putin's yappy purse puppy growls: "Dmitry Medvedev, the deputy secretary of Russia's powerful Security Council chaired by President Vladimir Putin, said late on Tuesday that the increase in military assistance to Ukraine by the NATO alliance brings World War Three closer." Putin surely respects Prigozhin more than his court eunuch Medvedev.

I say they need to suck it up and accept we won't replace our freedom of speech with Islam's blasphemy enforcement rules: "Muslim states including Iran and Pakistan on Tuesday said desecration of the Koran amounted to inciting religious hatred and called for accountability, as the U.N. rights body debated a contentious motion in the wake of a Koran burning in Sweden." I say you guys stop the murder of Christians and others first. Then we'll ponder your demand. Who am I kidding? Too many westerners are eager to have excuses to erode freedom of speech.

Before Russia invaded Ukraine, I warned against a Ukrainian "porcupine" military strategy because "if Ukraine tries to focus on killing Russian soldiers without stopping them, the flaw is that if the enemy decides it is willing to accept the casualties it will invade and win." And here we are about 50,000 dead Russian soldiers later and Russia shows no sign of willingness to stop. And if it does, it still has a lot of Ukrainian territory.

Doing "for" America what Gavin Newsom did to California is a threat and not a campaign slogan. To be fair, a majority of Californians cheered him on. Will the rest of the country?

Is the biggest part of Turkey's agreement to let Sweden into NATO an apparent Turkish reversal of its flirtation with Russia? Well, Russia forced Turkey to make that choice rather than any NATO diplomacy. Siding with a pariah and being reminded that Russia wants to restore its imperial reach that once bordered Turkey surely did the heavy lifting of this deal. If Turkey wants leverage, I'd expect outreach to distant China. They could cooperate in replacing Russian influence in Central Asia, for example.

Is Germany through its new national security strategy backing NATO in the NATO-EU defense split? "The Federal Government wants to further strengthen the European pillar of the transatlantic defence community. The more our European allies contribute militarily and politically to NATO, the more solid the transatlantic Alliance will be. Europe’s ability to act on its own is increasingly a prerequisite for German and European security." Or is Germany hedging and keeping its options open? Still, in the near term this is a defeat for Macron.

Good grief, how long before Europeans are complaining America doesn't meet the NATO minimum of spending 2% of GDP on defense?

If China thought that inflicting a pandemic on the world would be a net advantage to them, the results won't encourage them. And I don't think China released Covid-19 on purpose. But it is possible that it decided to share it to avoid suffering alone. And that some saw it as an interesting experiment in bio warfare. Tip to Instapundit.

To repeat, I have no moral qualms about providing cluster "bombs" to Ukraine. Peace will come with more Russian body bags going home, as I said the day Russia invaded. And as I called for long before the current invasion. Since 2014, in fact. No Russian soldiers will die from cluster warheads if Russia leaves Ukraine.

The universe is taunting us, right? The Navy is set to implement "Brandon Act" access to mental health service reforms. The Brandon act, indeed.

Remember when the Law of the Sea Treaty would make signers obey international law? "China accused the United States of 'ganging up' and forcing it to accept a 2016 arbitration ruling over claims in the South China Sea, as Washington urged Beijing to halt what it called its routine harassment of vessels of other countries in the region." China signed it. 

Putin's handling of the Wagner Revolt has not quieted apparent discontent within the military and the Russian parliament over the poor command of the war effort. Huh. Interesting.

Remember when you hear that American artillery ammunition can't be sent to Ukraine. That doesn't mean we are low. I assume it means we have a minimum level we don't want to drop below. Also, we would use more air power rather than rely on artillery. And I haven't seen anything that makes me worry NATO air power can't deal with Russian air defenses.

Focus on the latter two tasks: "The US Army National Guard conducted a Special Forces exercise in West Virginia to upskill in counterinsurgency operations, irregular warfare, and interoperability with foreign forces." This is about working as stay-behind forces (or infiltrated after) working with local irregulars and partisans in the NATO Baltic states invaded by Russia. Although my theory is weakened by the fact that the unit in the story is focused on Southwest Asia and the Pacific. Could be Taiwan-related, I suppose. If so, other Special Forces groups are working on the Baltic states.

Russia has taken some Ukrainian territory. Russia has more territorial ambitions. Some Russians talk about part of Alaska. Which one of Putin's failed, expensive ambitions will be too much for Russians?

America's budget deficit is over one trillion dollars already this year. Does anybody really think Air Force complaints that they lack sufficient money were caused by spending less than 10% of that in aid to Ukraine over the last year and a half? In what world do our leaders ever make choices on what to spend money on rather than just borrow/print more of it? Let's have some perspective here.

Is there any clearer proof that an organization is failing at its main task when it branches out into areas it should not go? Teach them the difference between adverbs and adjectives. Tip to Instapundit.

Is Russia running out of the ability to hide the decline in its economy and finances? I did not believe Putin's bravado and statistics. Tip to Instapundit.

The Popov Affair.

So I read that military veterans are supposedly the reason for poor recruiting. I guess that was last week's excuse: "Depending too much on military families could create a 'warrior caste,' [Army Secretary Christine] Wormuth said. Her plans seek to draw in people who have no real connection to the military and to broaden the appeal of service."

Italy will revive its tank force.

This includes replenishing its arsenal after supplying Ukraine: "Britain’s Ministry of Defence is next week expected to lay out what the military will look like in the future in a new review aimed at reshaping the armed forces." Britain will muddle through.

Apparently, Popov was known as spending his soldiers' lives frugally: "Many military bloggers argued that Popov’s dismissal eroded troop morale at a time of relentless Ukrainian attacks. One blogger, Vladislav Shurygin, said it has dealt a 'terrible blow to the entire army,” while another, Roman Saponkov, described it as a 'monstrous terror attack against the army’s morale.'"'

If China wants to exercise their forces around Taiwan, China should expect America to record every electronic signal they emit: "China’s military protested a U.S. Navy P-8A flight through the Taiwan Strait on Thursday, as the PLA continues operating near the island."

Lovely little alliance you have there. It would be a shame if something was to happen to it.

Lovely little empire we had there. It would be a shame if you stood in our way.

Admit it, if a Republican president ordered this, the media would call this a "back door draft": "President Joe Biden signed an executive order Thursday that will allow the Pentagon to tap into reserve forces for deployment to Europe as part of its long-standing NATO mission on the continent."

Huh:"A former Russian commander who has not been seen in public since the Wagner mutiny in June is 'resting', according to a senior MP in Moscow's parliament." And now for something completely different:


I've wondered if the Wagner Revolt was a one-off or a sign of systemic problems: "The most striking consequence of the June revolt is that even some pro-Kremlin media outlets admit that it has exposed the incompetence of the entire state system established under Putin." I was trying not to draw a too-convenient conclusion from what appears to be true.

Oh, FFS: "The House Oversight Committee is finally planning to hold a long-teased hearing on UFOs." It's a target-rich environment for oversight of Biden administration policies, personnel, and programs. And this will take up valuable committee bandwidth. Republicans don't even want to win elections, do they?

Huh. Did the clue bat shake some sense into California? We'll see if that wears off before the bill gets signed.

Serves you right, a-holes: "Pakistan's army said on Friday it was seriously concerned that militants had found safe havens in neighbouring Afghanistan and threatened to take an 'effective response' two days after 12 of its soldiers died in two attacks." Brilliant plan to engineer America's defeat there (admittedly with great American cooperation--as I warned about and feared we were screwing up as time passed).

So what the Netherlands tourism bureau is telling us is that no Dutch woman could be found prettier than a man? Well that's awkward. Smells like woke spirit.

Okay: "Russian tanks simply continue to get decimated by Ukrainian forces in the ongoing war, and the current counteroffensive may well be accelerating the pace at which Russian tanks are destroyed." Or: "Russia has a near endless supply of Soviet tanks in storage, military experts say[.]" Do you wonder why I don't offer certain predictions about the course of the war? 

Not that the proto-empire will give up: "In a prolonged cold war, then, we shouldn’t be surprised if the European Union plays an increasingly subordinate role to Nato." The nations of Europe value NATO's defense orientation in an era of Russian threats. The EU is focused on cheese regulations to entangle the nations of Europe in a proto-empire that keeps the bloody peasants from making European leaders again go to war against each other. In time, the Brussels elites will strip away the prefix.

The battle between Egypt and Ethiopia over control over the Nile River. Can this move beyond battle for control to cooperation?

Uh oh: "One of the positive legacies of the US occupation of Iraq was the introduction of federalism in the country. That legacy is now being dismantled, as Baghdad whittles down the autonomy of the Kurdistan region and, above all, deprives it of its major independent revenue sources."

Hey, good luck with that: "A Reuters article from April of 2023 specifically says Russia has “begun using its T-14 Armata” to fire on Ukrainian positions." Oooh, scary. Seriously, stop flinging panties at Armata. 

Ground-based drone defenses. I've suggested (in Army magazine) that the best way to defend forward combat units from drone swarms is a combat air patrol drone. 

Ultimately, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police at the Battle of the Bouncy House was a Pyrrhic victory over the Canadian trucker protests. Good. The government's behavior toward the protesters was criminal, however. Tip to Instapundit.

North Korea says the Korean peninsula is on the "brink of nuclear war" because of America. I see the North Koreans took the Medvedev Diplomatic Charm class. Yawn. Also, remember when Trump's harsh words were leading to nuclear war, according to critics? North Korea really isn't our fault regardless of who is president.

China probes Palau waters.

Maybe TikTok isn't the problem: "The Chinese government is being called upon to take action to stimulate the economy and create jobs at a time when young people in substantial numbers have adopted an attitude that’s termed the 'four nos': no interest in dating, getting married, buying a home or having a child." China has a positive version of the app, after all.

Using America-class amphibious warships as light carriers fail on survivability and flight operations in heavy seas. I've long warned that the ship is not a carrier. It is an amphibious warship with a secondary light carrier mission.

The number is unknown: "Ukraine's border guard service has confirmed that Wagner mercenaries have now arrived in Belarus from neighbouring Russia."

Wagner troops are not apparently significantly  participating in any combat operations following the Wagner Revolt per the DOD: "we do not see Wagner forces participating in any significant capacity in support of combat operations in Ukraine."

LOL!

 

Every time I worry that Russia is holding back a significant number of recruits to build a reserve army using good equipment, leaders, and supplies being ruthlessly held back from the front, I read something that says I shouldn't worry about that. I would like the universe to ease my worries that are growing again. If I was in charge of the Russian war effort that's exactly what I'd do, taking risks at the front in order to build a force to inflict a military defeat on Ukraine. But I'm to assume Russia wouldn't do this? And I'm to assume we'd detect this if it was happening?

Is Ukraine converting S-200 (SAM-5) air defense missiles for ground attack roles? This is not uncommon. And I'll note that Saddam Hussein smuggled in obsolete SAM-2 air defense missiles to convert them to banned--by the Persian Gulf War ceasefire--ground attack missiles, prior to the Iraq War. If converted, the S-200 would have a ground attack range of 250 to 310 miles, depending on the model of the missile.

Ukraine has built a 155mm truck-mounted howitzer. It's debut was bombarding Russian troops on Snake Island. So far these may be hand-crafted prototypes pressed into service. Let me know when they can be built at scale. The production equipment was moved to western Ukraine. So maybe. Producing the ammunition would be helpful, too.

Let me note that mobilizing 3,000 American reservists for military activities in Europe isn't a sign we are going to war. The trend for using reserves as an operational rather than a strategic reserve increased a lot after the Cold War. Note that the Geocities and AUSA links don't work. Link rot. But that Guard division article I cited is online now.

Well that was a depressing read. Tip to Instapundit.

The replacements keep coming in: "The Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) announced the completion of Russia’s spring 2023 conscription cycle on July 15." Although I assume this is for replacing troops that are leaving military service after their term of service is complete. as well as replacing losses. This is still a "special military operation" without troops "in for the duration", I think.

Ukraine seems to have a toe hold on the eastern bank of the Dnieper River on the Kherson front. I keep wondering if Ukraine could be building an underwater bridge to exploit Russian diversion of troops to other fronts.

So, Iran? In Syrian territory against someone? Yemen territory? "An unmanned aerial system from U.S. Air Forces Central’s newly formed Task Force 99 was deployed to conduct intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance missions against a U.S. adversary in the Middle East — and its performance was 'very effective,' according to a senior Department of Defense official."

The proto-imperial EU is persistent in acting against real threats to it: "David Livingstone, Citigroup’s chief executive for Europe, Middle East and Africa, told The Telegraph that the City has 'not been diminished' by Brexit, adding that efforts by Brussels to create a rival financial centre to London have so far failed to yield meaningful results."

Russia has already used them--with their usual care around civilians. So whatever: "President Vladimir Putin said Russia had a "sufficient stockpile" of cluster bombs and reserved the right to use them if such munitions, the use of which he said he regarded as a crime, were deployed against Russian forces in Ukraine."

The media gets military matters wrong so often than I worry when I see more stories like this: "'I would describe it as a policy of starve, stretch and strike,' [British admiral] Radakin told a British parliamentary committee." What worries me most is the talk of how the Ukrainian counteroffensive isn't designed to defeat Russia's ground forces, but to get an edge at the negotiating table. To me that's a slippery slope to being defeated. Fight to win. The enemy sure is.

Hmmm: "Iraq’s prime minister held talks Sunday with Syrian President Bashar Assad in Damascus during the first trip of its kind to the war-torn country since the 12-year conflict began." Assad was Iran's agent in funneling jihadis into Iraq to bolster Saddam Hussein and then suicide bombers during the Iraq War. Is this meeting a sign that the Arab world is trying to pry Syria from Iran's orbit? Or a sign Iran is pulling Iraq into its orbit, too?

Saturday, July 15, 2023

Sacrificial Lamb

China needs to delay America's effective intervention if China starts a war in the western Pacific. Cuba will be sacrificed to achieve that goal.

To defeat America, China can focus on defeating one of our many allies in our web of bilateral alliances that we knit into a coherent whole to deter and defeat China.

And defeating one of those allies, like Taiwan, doesn't require China to defeat America--just to delay American intervention until China achieves victory. And then dares America to pay the price to reverse China's victory.

China wants an outpost in Cuba: (via Instapundit):

China and Cuba are in active conversations about creating a new joint military training facility on the island nation 100 miles from the American homeland.

Sure, a Chinese military outpost would lead a short but exciting life if China goes to war with America. But that's not the point.

The USSR liked having an outpost in Cuba to slow down potential American reinforcements sent to Europe from Gulf Coast ports or from the Pacific through the Panama Canal. China sees value in that threat for traffic going west. 

Depending on how you define what a Chinese victory in the western Pacific would be, China might not need to buy as much time as you think.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Friday, July 14, 2023

Is Russia a Target Without Limits for China?

China has to reconsider what its partnership with Russia means even if in the short run nothing visibly changes. 

China has discovered that Russia is much weaker than they assumed:

Yurii Poita, the head of the Asia-Pacific section at Ukraine’s Center for Army, Conversion and Disarmament Studies, agrees the partnership is expected to continue in the short term.

But he said Beijing might be making more contingency plans based on a revised understanding about the weaknesses in Russian security and defence.

Both the war and the Wagner Mutiny call into question Russia's value as an ally to China.

Indeed, Russia might be a liability without limits for China. China certainly sees limits on its help for its so-called partner Russia embroiled in a war with Ukraine who is backed by NATO.

I'd imagine that China might consider a contingency plan based on Russia being too weak to be an ally but weak enough to be a victim. 

Maybe China wants a signal military victory against Russia which has few friends for China to worry about.

Maybe China goes big for the prime remaining land grab from the Century of Humiliation. 

Or China could play it safe and seek gains at Russia's expense outside of Russia.

Or China might play a long game beginning with undermining Russia, gaining more and broader concessions from Russia, and preparing to pick up the pieces.

It's been a big change since Russia believed it would crush Ukraine in days, break NATO's will, frighten former Soviet states into passive compliance, and turn to face China with confidence and demonstrated power.

The Fuck-Up Fairy has been super busy in Moscow.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Thursday, July 13, 2023

Russia's Great Power Status Revoked?

Does Russia's failure in Ukraine mean that the entire concept of a "great power" is invalid? I don't think so.

Russia's failure in its invasion of Ukraine proves there is no real thing as a "great power"? 

In the last 150 years, there have been only a handful full-spectrum powers. One is obviously the United States, which became the largest economy in the world sometime in the 1890s and had few security concerns compared with most countries. The United Kingdom was certainly a full-spectrum power from the late nineteenth century until 1943, when it had to subordinate its preferred grand strategy to accommodate U.S. interests. Before then, the United Kingdom was capable of creating and deploying advanced and well-prepared forces almost anywhere in the world and maintaining a war economy that hardly any other state could match. Other countries that probably fit the full-spectrum bill were Germany from around 1900 to 1942, the Soviet Union from 1949 to the 1970s, and China from approximately 2010 to today. All three could compete in every strategic domain and produce high-quality military equipment. They did not always have true global reach, but they exercised great influence in a large part of the world.

Sure, defining a great power is difficult. 

As for Russia, one, I knew Russia was weaker than it projected. I actually chuckled at Obama's description of Russia as a regional power. The truth hurts.

Indeed, in some ways the more powerful USSR was a "only" a regional power obscured by its continents-spanning size and nukes. But the Soviets had the advantage that an advance of about 100 miles on the ground to reach the Rhine River would have shattered NATO and had global consequences. 

And while the author calls China a great power akin to America, I think it is more accurate at the moment to say China is a capable great power with strategic-level targets nearby--just like the Soviets had. Sure, China has the economic, technological, and financial power the Soviets lacked to have more reach in those areas. But if projecting significant military power is key, China doesn't have that.

Yet in some ways, using the America standard of deploying power globally (add in imperial Britain, too) is an unfair standard. America (and Britain in its imperial days) had to have a long reach to deploy significant power to a strategic target in Eurasia. Russia and China didn't have to do that because they are already in Eurasia. Being in Eurasia means they face other great and lesser powers in contrast to America's current situation of having no Western Hemisphere threats to tie down our power here.

That geographic reality applies to early twentieth century Germany, for that matter. Both for opportunities to conquer and in regard to powerful threats able to reach them. And that is what is important. Can you threaten something of global significance that would push power toward you? America has that. China has that. Russia for the moment only sort of has that from Estonia to Poland, in my opinion. And that is a far cry from the scale of the threat the USSR had when the Rhine River was so close.

Really, I think Russia's experience just shows that we shouldn't fall for propaganda and rely on untested assumptions--or the data most easily quantified--for who is a great power. Russia is weaker than most of us--not me--thought until Russia invaded and stumbled. Just as Italy in 1940 was over-rated and Austria-Hungary was over-rated in 1914. Toss in the Ottoman Empire in 1914. Toss in China now? Heck, I wonder if America is over-rated now.

Also, to put a little cold water on the cause and effect relationship between Russia's failure and the denial of great power status in general, Russia hasn't actually been defeated in Ukraine yet. Would a Russian ugly victory nullify the basis for denying great powers exist?

Anyway, it is an interesting question for definitions and accurate data to measure countries for great power status. I think that should be the real point of Russia's overblown reputation being exposed.

NOTE: The image was made with DALL-E.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Wednesday, July 12, 2023

The Twenty-First Anniversary of TDR

Well, The Dignified Rant is 21 years old today. No. Please. Stop. Your cheering is embarrassing me.

Since last year I ended my weekly post of memes, And Now For Something Completely Different, that for awhile I enjoyed. It got tedious. This was the last post. I still do them for the daily posts and sometimes I make them for the Weekend Data Dump. I do miss altering song lyrics for the introductions.

And the Winter War of 2022 was regularized as a weekly post with updates as necessary. Although I will also put war information in the Weekend Data Dump if it isn't really breaking news. And sometimes in separate related posts not labeled for the war. I confess the distinction is hazy in my mind for what I put where.

I also resumed occasional non-security issue posts, such as this and this. Hey, it's my blog.

Last year I highlighted 20 years of posts for the big 2-0.

So how about a dozen defense and foreign affairs posts from the last twelve months to celebrate reaching 21 years?

I worry that the continental United States is no longer a sanctuary to project power overseas.

I really don't like the European Union.

Do we need a drone combat air patrol to defend forward troops from drone swarm attacks?

The Russian threat to the NATO Baltic states.

Does Xi Jinping actually know what is going on inside China?

I don't think we are simulating a Chinese invasion of Taiwan with the right definition of victory and defeat.

Will precision offensive and defensive firepower, persistent surveillance, and artificial intelligence create static high-speed battles of attrition?

Is the Marine Littoral Regiment the right way to support the Navy?

Stop flinging your panties at unmanned surface vessels.

The Air Force finally wins its long struggle to rid itself of the A-10.

America's efforts to defeat Russia in Ukraine are part of a long American struggle to keep the Atlantic Ocean from being our first line of defense for the east coast.

Ukraine's big counteroffensive doesn't seem to be doing much.

Anyway. I'm trying to write more for publication. And this year I have finally felt somewhat motivated to do so. I scored an initial success in the July issue of Army magazine. Hopefully I'll have more. So far it isn't interfering with my intended reduced blogging output. But 21 years is a long time for solo blogging.

Heck, technically I have two blogs if you include this one.

Admittedly I'm often distracted from formal writing by the lack of need to publish to make my mortgage payment or eat. So far I keep my cat in the lifestyle she's become accustomed to without that kind of effort.

I imagine I have another year in me. I still enjoy it and think I contribute useful perspectives. And it helps me organize my thoughts and keep up on national security issues. 

It at least keeps my day drinking down to socially acceptable levels.

Thanks to my readers for hanging in there when shiny new Twitter (Now with freedom of speech!) beckons.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Tuesday, July 11, 2023

Relying On the EU for American Security is Insane

Should we reimagine NATO as a force without America that will hold Europe against Russia's threats and send military forces to help us fight China if it comes to war? That must be a wonder planet of cotton candy and unicorns one author lives on.

This is a strange argument against my preference that we keep Russia as far east as possible: 

But this argument can only be taken seriously if the events of the last year are ignored: Russia, which cannot get troops to Kyiv, will not get past Poland, much less France.

One, Russia hasn't lost the war and been forced to give up its territorial gains yet. Does conquest not count for the victims if the cost to Russia is high? 

Two, if Poland is the frontline, that means Belarus is controlled by Russia. 

Three, in time Russia will rebuild its power. It may even learn from the beating with the clue bat it is enduring.

Four, if Poland is the frontline, the Baltic states are at risk. 

And FFS at five, if your fallback position is that France will hold, Russia already won. 

Fine. I accept that last one is hyperbole. But as long as France is being brought up as a road block to Russian expansion, let's talk about France: six brigades. That's a speed bump and not a road block.

But at least the author didn't rely on Germany to hold the line west of Poland. 

Finally, this is the author's foundation for arguing America should rely on Europe to hold Europe:

This is not to say that such a shift would be easy. While the EU has some defense mechanisms, the creation of some sort of EU—or, if the UK and Norway were to join, European—Army would require sustained effort. But if America were to make clear that it was shifting its focus to Asia, pulling out a significant number of troops, and had a president willing to make good on such a declaration, Europe could be jump-started into getting the process done.

The nonsense of arguing the EU would allow America to pull out a significant number of American troops is obvious when you consider America has already removed the vast majority of our troops to take into account the reduced Russian threat to NATO Europe and to focus on China as the pacing threat!

What more should we do, dig up our dead soldiers in European cemeteries and bring them home? 

Europeans can increase their defense effort within the existing NATO structure built to defend Europe. If abandoning NATO in favor of creating a new EU structure is the answer, you don't really value defending Europe. You value the proto-imperial EU removing the prefix.

America should not want "Europe"--that is the EU--to be capable of defending Europe without America-led NATO keeping the primary role. Face it, we'd be replacing the USSR with the EU--but with all of Europe under its control. 

I don't trust the EU to hold our wall.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Monday, July 10, 2023

The Winter War of 2022 Gets a Problematic Model

Maybe a ceasefire in Ukraine will be necessary because it is the least-bad option. But don't delude yourself that this is a good option we should pursue now.

Ever since Ukraine survived the initial invasion and it became clear Russia could not conquer Ukraine, Westerners have sought to get Ukraine to give up trying to liberate their territory. Ukraine's slow counteroffensive is reviving those calls:

It is a truism that wars are not won in a day, but critics of aid to Ukraine are using the current offensive’s slow progress to once again demand that Ukraine give up in order to end the war. The argument now is that Ukraine’s current struggles mean the war is in a deadlock. It will grind on, World War I-style, until the U.S. defunds Ukraine and forces it to make concessions. Variations of this argument have been floating around since last summer when longtime U.S. foreign policy observer Henry Kissinger counseled the same thing. 

Is a ceasefire and partition of Ukraine between Russian-occupied and pro-West free Ukraine the solution to the Winter War of 2022? 

Yet if pursuing negotiations is a gamble, it is one with low risks and high potential rewards. Failure would merely yield the same result as doing nothing. Success, however, could preserve Ukraine, allay wider fears for democracy, deter further Russian aggression, and put fears of escalation to rest. The kind of stable, durable peace the Korean armistice produced would be a victory not just for Ukraine and its supporters but for the entire world, as well.

Before the war I said I wouldn't be shocked at this outcome: 

Sometimes I wonder if the end point of the Ukraine crisis is an East Ukraine under Russian control and a West Ukraine admitted to NATO and the EU.

But I would not make this Plan A. I don't see the low risk aspect of this model. The risk is that the chance for victory is forfeited to show "sincerity" for negotiations by halting Ukrainian offensive action.

And potential rewards--assuming the above flaw doesn't simply cause Ukraine to lose the war--require a lot from America and our allies and a lot of time to potentially see those benefits. 

The Korea model the author proposes and spends a lot of time describing its background and path, is only somewhat attractive after 70 years of fragile semi-war with major war hanging over us all that time. And it required a lot of American troops to hold that line. And nukes now cloud that model. 

I don't know if we can yet conclude the Korea model worked for South Korea. Although I'm optimistic after all this time.

The ceasefire and partition model failed in Vietnam. 

Also, how's Cyprus working out? 

Heck, how did partition in Ukraine work since 2014-2015? 

Sure, partition worked in Germany in 1945. After a long and expensive Cold War struggle with nuclear war hanging over it. And the victory is somewhat tarnished given united Germany's refusal to stand up for the West. 

The record of partition to hold off an aggressive state that wants to conquer all of the partitioned state isn't terribly appealing to me. 

Although I concede that for NATO, that partition option might work out as long as NATO uses the time Ukraine has purchased to arm up rather than revert to sticking our head in a hole. But that isn't obviously beneficial to Ukraine. And that path risks a feeling of  Ukrainian betrayal by NATO gives Russia an opening to subvert Ukraine's current pro-Western leanings and divide its people, making them vulnerable to Russian attack.

Also, I find this amusing in a frightening sort of way from the partition article:

Washington should bear in mind that its stakes in Ukraine are lower than its stakes were in Korea. It is hard to imagine that any American president would commit U.S. forces to fight alongside Ukrainian ones. 

Wait. What?

The Korea model is one of America standing shoulder-to-shoulder with South Korea against the North Korea threat. Now the author says Ukraine won't get that major feature of the ceasefire--American troops on the DMZ--that gave us the success the author seeks in Ukraine?

How would partition of Ukraine be more than temporary to allow Russia time to rearm if we go into this proclaiming Ukraine is outside of the NATO defensive perimeter? Wasn't the author's long description of the Korea ceasefire based on China accepting it could not outlast America's commitment to fight?

And don't be so sure washing our hands of Ukraine after a ceasefire will keep NATO out of a new Russo-Ukraine war because our stakes are allegedly so low. America committed hundreds of thousands of troops and suffered tens of thousands of casualties to defend South Korea, a new country America had declared outside our defensive perimeter before North Korea invaded.

I reject the Korea model for Ukraine. It would give Putin a badly needed win despite his dismal record of protecting Russia. Until the Korea model is the least-bad option, anyway.

And for a bonus reason to reject the proposal, if you think a partition despite Russia's heavy casualties will discourage China from invading Taiwan, you aren't correctly judging the question of what a Chinese victory is. 

UPDATE (Wednesday): Another appeal for partition. This time using the post-World War II Germany model. To be fair, the author says it would not be "ideal." As I said, I'll only consider it when it is the least-bad option.

But I worry that a new cold war centered on a divided Ukraine will lock Russia into actin as if NATO is an enemy. And China might decide subsidizing Russia to lock that in might be worthwhile.

I'd rather have Russia defeated so that perhaps a big whack with the clue bat will help Russia admit China is the real threat to Russia.

NOTE: Thanks to that Canadian NATO delegation who made the model for my meme.

NOTE: ISW coverage of the war continues here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.