Thursday, June 06, 2024

Will a PLA "Sushi Wave" Flood Taiwan?

China may believe mass works to overwhelm a smaller enemy. And while Ukraine has the territory to give up to buy time without losing the war so far, Taiwan is geographically small enough to be vulnerable to the brutal mass and firepower methods Russia uses.

China has a lot of civilian ships built for a wartime role to invade Taiwan:

While the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) lacks the numbers of amphibious landing craft needed to stage the sort of invasion seen during the D-Day landings, it could bridge the gap with civilian vessels, including dozens of gigantic roll-on, roll-off ferries that can each carry hundreds of armoured vehicles.

I've noted this capability. While they are more vulnerable than military ships, there are a lot. Just as Russia is willing to sacrifice men in "meat wave" assaults to grind away at Ukraine, China may be willing to expend a "sushi wave" assault to make sure enough of the troops carried across the Taiwan Strait make it ashore.

And if the Chinese intend to use their air and missile power to suppress Taiwanese air defenses and anti-ship assets, the invasion will mostly come by air and not across beaches. Remember, America needs amphibious warfare ships for airmobile assaults because we aren't 100 miles from any likely targets. China itself is a giant amphibious warfare platform if Taiwan is the target.

And if the air mobile and airborne forces--supplemented by infiltrated spies and special forces, marine assaults, and even light infantry smuggled into Taiwanese ports as I speculated long ago in a scenario I think holds up pretty well as a basic outline--sow chaos in Taipei, cripple Taiwan's ability to strike ships, and delay Taiwanese ground force deployments, the civilian ships may be able to sail into Taiwanese ports to disembark behind a thin shield of Chinese light infantry without crippling losses. 

While I used the Norway 1940 template, this author makes a case for Crete 1941. I'll say as the initial phase it has a lot of merit. At Crete the airborne forces did the heavy lifting. Seaborne reinforcements were stopped. But if Taiwan fights, China will need seaborne reinforcements as the Germans did in Norway.

If Taiwanese morale collapses, China wins quickly. Or China may find it has to stand fast and hold its bridgeheads (and airheads) to await reinforcements of troops and supplies. That's a lesson China identified from the World War II Guadalcanal campaign:

In a future amphibious invasion against Taiwan, just as the Marines fought off the initial Japanese counteroffensives, the PLA must anticipate stiff resistance once its forces had landed on the enemy’s beachheads. It must vigorously defend its footholds along the coast before pushing farther inland.

China may be able to build up quickly to overwhelm Taiwan's small ground forces with a relatively shallow advance before Taiwan's allies can deploy significant force to stop the Chinese offensive to take Taipei.

Or China may dig in and prepare for round two years later after building up more forces, supplies, and infrastructure ashore agree to a ceasefire, as I explored in Military Review.

People keep noting the Pentagon's appraisal that amphibious warfare is the hardest type of operation to conduct and concluding that it is impossible for China to invade Taiwan. I don't think that leap of logic is sound.

Ultimately, Taiwan needs to go to the source to eliminate the Chinese threat to Taiwan. But unless that happens, Taiwan will need to fight like Hell every step of the PLA's way in--and drive the PLA into the sea.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Wednesday, June 05, 2024

Is Iran's Long Drive for Nuclear Weapons Finally Here?

Will Iran get nuclear weapons in Obama's third term of office? Mission accomplished!

The Biden administration is pressuring allies not to confront Iran on their dash to nuclear weapons:

But what is it that the U.S. fears? That Iran unbound could arm Hamas and Hezbollah to launch genocidal attacks on Israel, or could launch its first-ever direct missile strike against that American ally? That Tehran could arm the Houthi fighters in Yemen as they disrupt global shipping through the Red Sea? Or that the mullahs could send missiles and drones to Russia for use in Ukraine? Or give Shiite militias the green light to attack U.S. troops in Syria, Iraq and Jordan?

I'd say that this is another example of the "Let the Wookie win" school of dealing with our enemies.

But it is much simpler than that twisted view of foreign policy. The Biden administration loooves mullah-run Iran. The mullahs don't love America back--famously wishing death to the "Great Satan" for many decades now. But that's no obstacle to courting the mullahs and expecting peace. 

How else do you explain this? 

The United States expresses its official condolences for the death of Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi, Foreign Minister Amir-Abdollahian, and other members of their delegation in a helicopter crash in northwest Iran.

We expressed condolences for the death of a murderous thug whose record is exceptional even for a regime of murderous thugs in religious garb. That's true devotion.

Recall the brilliance of their policy they once boasted about in those innocent days of August 2023:

The Biden administration is maneuvering to pretend it has forcefully compelled Iran to back down from regional mayhem and agree to a nuclear deal that we will insist keeps Iran from going nuclear. In reality it will be worse than the original.

And now Iran helps Hamas and Hezbollah wage war on Israel; helps the Houthi wage war on international trade; helps its Iraqi and Syrian pawns wage war on American troops in the Middle East; helps Russia wage war on Ukraine; and still works with North Korea on nuclear missile technology.

Bravo.

The most dangerous aspect of our renewed Smart Diplomacy® is our policy toward Iran's nuclear ambition:

Sadly, the basis of the original deal seemed doomed to be repeated:

Well of course a deal is possible! Duh. All Iran has to do is pretend to end their drive for nuclear weapons and all we have to do is pretend to believe Iran. Simple, no?

Unfortunately, the original deal may have worked all too well. By giving up to 15 years of shielding Iran from attack, it enabled Iranian cheating by giving Iran benefits up front and encouraging Western caving in to Iranian threats to leave the deal if called on their cheating. The incentives to ignore cheating were clear. 

And the deal actually helped Iran with basic nuclear technology, as I noted when I first looked at the nuclear deal. God help us, but Obama expected a nuclear-armed, mullah-run Iran to become a responsible regional power. It's a miracle Iran doesn't have nukes yet. They don't have nukes now, right??!!

And my fear that Iran may already have nukes has only grown. 

The only thing keeping Iran quiet for the moment--except for occasional hints that seem more frequent lately, with "repeated statements in April and May from senior Iranian officials, including a top foreign policy adviser to the Supreme Leader, that have begun to normalize discussions about Iran’s ability to procure a nuclear weapon"--may have been the complete failure of their missile and drone barrage directed at Israel. Without missiles that can penetrate Israeli missile defenses carrying a nuclear warhead, the mullahs only invite fatal nuclear retaliation. 

Say, I wonder what Russia is paying Iran with for all the military support Iran sends to Russia?

Have a super sparkly day.

UPDATE: None of this should shock anybody who pays attention to the news:

Washington’s de facto alliance with Iran, which began under the Obama administration and was revived by Biden, is the central fact of US foreign policy today. Iran is the decisive factor in most decisions the US makes in the region, including in relation to Israel. Yet White House officials know that stating this directly would create a public-relations disaster.

But do read it all. I don't stand with everything the writer sets out, but on our Iran policy he's spot on.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Tuesday, June 04, 2024

The Hamas War Taps Out--For Now

We have a new stage in the Last Hamas War. The stage that rescues Hamas and makes sure there will eventually be Last Hamas War II. We're at the point where Israel needs to dig a moat around Gaza and stock it with alligators.

An offer Israel couldn't refuse? 

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government begrudgingly accepted President Biden's plan for a cease-fire in Gaza on Sunday.

Netanyahu's office initially appeared to contradict Biden's plan in a statement on Saturday, saying Israel’s conditions for ending the war – the destruction of Hamas's military and governing capabilities, the freeing of all hostages and ensuring that Gaza no longer poses a threat to Israel – had not changed.

"The notion that Israel will agree to a permanent ceasefire before these conditions are fulfilled is a non-starter," his office wrote.

Biden's plan appears to allow for Hamas to continue to exist and play some role in Gaza, however.

Hamas says it likes the part about a permanent ceasefire. Kind of like the one that existed on October 6, 2023, I assume. Before Hamas and its sick little allies went on a murder, torture, rape, and kidnapping spree across Israel.

Smart Diplomacy® is a wonder to behold. We'll be lucky if it isn't much worse.

We'll see if Hamas makes Israel's acceptance moot by refusing the offer. After all, contrary to the American administration assertion, not all hostages can be released. Because you don't "release" murdered hostages.

Or maybe Israel intends to turn its attention north in one form or another.

But perhaps I'm too cynical. Maybe Israel sincerely sees the occupation of the Philadelphia corridor on the Gaza-Egypt border as the last piece of the puzzle on the table before shifting to a quieter intelligence-based campaign to hunt down Hamas leadership. That may even be accurate. 

Perhaps a publicly reluctant Israeli acceptance is designed to get Hamas to believe this is actually a rescue when in reality the Mossad and special forces hit teams are already poring over intelligence reports on Hamas leadership movements.

But I'm rarely too cynical. I fear that "ending" the war is just a period to let Hamas reload. Because Hell, Hamas won't even have to rebuild Gaza! The West will do that for them. And Hamas will skim weapons money off the top of that scheme.

UPDATE: If Israel accepts a ceasefire in Gaza to go after Hezbollah, the Biden administration may with to review the curse of "beware of what you wish for because you just might get it":

Israel’s war cabinet is set to discuss Tuesday evening the escalation on the border with Lebanon after rocket fire caused dozens of fires in the north of Israel.

That would be a serious new phase of the war--a broader war to pull Iran's fangs biting into Israel. 

UPDATE: To be fair, this crosses no red lines at Rafah:

The Israeli military launched a new ground and air assault in central Gaza on Tuesday, as its forces ramp up attacks amid a deepening humanitarian crisis.

Also, Hamas could end the humanitarian crisis any time by surrendering. 

UPDATE: Israel doesn't have to reject the plan:

A senior Hamas official responded negatively on June 4 to the latest Israeli ceasefire proposal for the Gaza Strip. Hamas appears unlikely to accept a proposal that does not meet the maximalist demands that Hamas has maintained since December 2023.

Hamas is committed to killing Jews no matter how many Gazan human shields have to die to do that. And no matter how hungry those Gazans get.

UPDATE: Chances of success go up when Hamas remembers that it only has to pretend to want peace:

The Biden administration has launched an intense drive to persuade Hamas and Israel to accept a new cease-fire proposal in the nearly eight-month-old war in Gaza while it also presses Arab nations to get the militant group to go along with the terms.

UPDATE: Shifting phases is still in progress:

With a renewed ceasefire push in the eight-month-old Gaza war stalled, Israel bombarded central and southern areas again on Friday, killing at least 28 Palestinians, and tank forces advanced to the western edges of Rafah.

Who were the Palestinians killed? Fighters? Civilians? If the latter, who is responsible for them being in the line of fire? Israelis or the known human shield-holders, Hamas? 

UPDATE: Good:

Four Israeli hostages kidnapped by Hamas from the Nova music festival during the 7 October attacks have been rescued in a daylight raid deep in central Gaza.

Even better is destroying Hamas so it can't capture, rape, torture, and murder more Israelis. 

UPDATE: In some ways the fighting in Hamas now seems like an inter-war period:

Israeli officials are continuing to discuss an offensive into Lebanon amid an increase in Hezbollah drone attacks targeting northern Israel.

Seemingly, Israel would try to force Hezbollah north of the Litani River which is supposed to be their southern limit since 2006.

This article looks at Israeli options.

I looked at options, too. I'm torn. As the Hamas War winds down--hopefully to an intelligence-driven raid form of warfare against Hamas leaders and assets--the odds of military action against Hezbollah may rise if Hezbollah persists in shooting. Trying diplomacy first makes sense because Israel is busy with Hamas and to satisfy American desire for "war is the last resort" status. 

If Hezbollah persists in attacking, Israel has incentive to attack while their military is geared up for war. And if war is the option, advancing to the Litani River with ground forces to clear out Hezbollah is the minimum level of war.

That might be enough if Lebanon and the UN actually fill the vacuum, allowing Israel to withdraw without allowing Hezbollah to flow south to the Israeli border.

If Israel can't get a friendly force into the south that is willing to keep Hezbollah out, Israel will need to drive all the way to the Bekaa Valley to seriously rip apart Hezbollah's rear areas to set back Hezbollah capabilities for years.

Or maybe this is a bluff to convince Hezbollah to stand down or face the power that devastated Gaza.

UPDATE: This is BS: 

Hamas gambled on the suffering of civilians in Gaza. Netanyahu played right into it[.]

Played right into it, indeed. What world does that author live in?

Hamas didn't gamble on suffering. Hamas ensured it by using their own civilians as human shields to protect themselves from Israel's justifiable wrath following the Hamas October 7, 2023 mass rape, torture, murder, and kidnapping invasion. 

And no matter how few Gazans died because Israel could have restrained its lawful use of force even more, Hamas would have worked harder to use human shields and simply lied--and those who hate Jews would have believed it.

UPDATE: America's push for a ceasefire is dangerous:

Hamas issued new demands on June 11 in response to the latest Israeli ceasefire proposal. US Secretary of State Antony Blinken described the new demands as going beyond Hamas’ previous negotiating position and questioned whether Hamas is acting in good faith in the talks.

Whaaat?? Hamas might not be acting in good faith? Whatchu talkin' about, Antony?

What would we do without the insights of top diplomats?

Blinken is trying to get a compromise number between Israel's demand that Hamas kill no more Jews. And Hamas wants to kill all the Jews--no matter how many involuntary martyrs are created from Gazan human shields to do that.

I shudder to think what number Blinken has in mind. 

Ah, Smart Diplomacy®. 

UPDATE: You'd think Israel's good record and our own experience with the brutality of jihadis would have led us to trust Israel more:

As Israel celebrates the rare return of some of their hostages, Western media for the most part focuses on the tragic death toll at the end of the extraction operation.

Implicit in their coverage is that Israel is responsible, and perhaps careless, for killing 200+ people in the raid. But what is not said is that the extraction itself killed very few people, and probably almost all terrorists. The deadly fight was started afterwards, and pointlessly, by Hamas.

This is really just symbolic of how Hamas bears the responsibility for the vast majority of Gazan civilian casualties in this war. Tip to Instapundit.

UPDATE: Israel taps out during daylight hours, it seems:

The Israeli military announced it will conduct a daily "tactical pause" in its activities in the south of the Gaza Strip to allow more aid deliveries.

UPDATE: The new stage will begin soon. What will it be?

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Sunday that the conflict is about to enter a new stage.  

In part, it means the war on Hamas in Gaza will get less intensely kinetic. But no ceasefire. Selective firepower use and raids to kill Hamas leaders or rescue hostages; as well as likely increased Hamas attacks within Gaza and into Israel, will punctuate a quieter war.  And this is what the ground control will look like:

Israel is expected to retain control of Gaza’s border with Egypt, to deter arms smuggling there. It is also expected to continue to occupy a strip of land that separates northern and southern Gaza, preventing free movement between the two areas.

What it means for governance is unclear. I have a suggestion.

The larger question is whether Israel goes to war with Hezbollah to take care of all business while its military is mobilized and while its people see the need to prevent threats:

After drawing down troops in Gaza, [Netanyahu] said, “We will be able to move part of our forces to the north.”

I doubt Hezbollah wants to take on Israel while Israelis are pissed as Hell. I don't know what Israel wants or is capable of doing after the long, intense war with Hamas.

Of course, the question of whether that becomes a war between Israel and Iran is an issue, too. I doubt either really wants that now. But you never know how "events" will influence courses of action.

UPDATE: Palestinian Islamic Jihad attacked:

Israel’s military says Palestinian armed groups in Gaza have launched about 20 rockets towards Israeli border communities - the heaviest such attack in months.

A number of the projectiles were intercepted and others landed inside southern Israel, but no injuries were reported. The military said it responded with artillery fire.

That was fast. The war may be different in Gaza. But it will remain a war.

UPDATE: And a response:

The Israeli army said it had attacked rocket launch pads in the south of Gaza during the night following rocket fire from the coastal strip.

In order to avoid civilian casualties, residents of eastern neighbourhoods of the city of Khan Younis were asked to leave the affected area, the army said.

UPDATE: This will need to be ongoing:

Israeli forces have located and destroyed the largest long-range rocket manufacturing site utilized by the Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) terrorist organization in the Gaza Strip[.]

UPDATE: When does Hamas tap out for Hezbollah?

The pro-Iranian Lebanese Shiite movement Hezbollah has fired some 200 missiles and drones into areas in northern Israel, it said on Thursday, to avenge the previous day's killing of one of their commanders.

The Biden administration wants Israel to end its wholly righteous war on the Hamas barbarians. Be careful what you wish for. 

UPDATE: Hmmm. Israel has re-escalated on the ground after many months of low-level commitment to ground fighting. Hamas seems like it wants the war to end rather than thinking it can exploit a continuing war.

UPDATE: Will Israel have to move to a new phase of the war without really completing this phase?

Hamas likely retains the institutional knowledge and skilled commanders required to reconstitute despite the loss of several high-ranking Hamas commanders in the Gaza Strip since October 2023.

UPDATE: Has Israel's Rafah operation finally isolated Hamas in Gaza and made Hamas eager to end the war?

UPDATE: Victory or Smart Diplomacy®?

The U.S., Israel and the United Arab Emirates held a meeting in Abu Dhabi last Thursday to discuss plans for Gaza after the war ends, two Israeli officials said.

Again, I have a suggestion.   

UPDATE: Hamas has a suggestion, too, along with Fatah and other unnamed factions:

The agreement stipulates that a government partly influenced by Hamas would rule the Gaza Strip and West Bank until elections could be held at an unspecified future date.

That doesn't seem like anything Israel could--or should--accept. 

UPDATE: Definitely feeling like the war is going to tap out after trending that way for nearly two months now:

US, Israeli, and Arab officials are reportedly considering former Fatah leader Mohammad Dahlan as an interim leader of Palestinian security forces in the post-war Gaza Strip. Dahlan is a former Fatah official who was a close advisor to former Palestinian Authority (PA) leader Yasser Arafat. The Wall Street Journal reported on July 25 that under the plan, Dahlan would oversee an interim security force of 2,500 Palestinians in the Gaza Strip after Israeli troops withdraw, citing Arab officials. The United States, Israel, and Egypt would vet the Palestinian personnel, who would work in coordination with unspecified international forces and even private Western security firms.

The interim security forces will be compromised. Perhaps the personnel vetting the recruits would be intimidated, bribed, or secretly loyal to Hamas. Or the personnel recruited will be intimidated, bribed, or secretly loyal to Hamas. Or they'll simply turn actively anti-Israel if Israel continues to fight the war in Gaza in a new, lower intensity war in the shadows.

And as ISW notes, the force is too small to suppress Hamas trying to rebuild in Gaza. So Israel will still need to fight Hamas if Israel doesn't want to just pretend to win by losing the so-called peace.

We need Palestinians who hate Hamas and its jihadi allies more than they hate Israel. That is more effective than vetting which is just an attitude check at a moment in time.

NOTE: This seems like a new phase of the war, so I'll be updating this going forward.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Monday, June 03, 2024

The Winter War of 2022 Gets the American Spigot Turned Back On

Ukraine's war effort was crippled by the 6-month gap in American military aid authority. As the aid flows again, don't get expectations up too high. This isn't a silver bullet. Ukraine has lost ground and even restored aid will only reclaim lost capabilities for a while before increasing Ukraine's military capabilities beyond what they were when aid halted.

Is resumed American aid building up a head of steam to help Ukraine rock Russia back on its heels?

Advisor to the Head of the Ukrainian President's Office Mykhaylo Podolyak stated that US-provided military aid has started arriving on the frontline but that it will take "weeks" for the gradual increase in US-provided military aid to reach "critical volumes."

As more aid comes in, Ukraine is also working on their personnel shortage:

Ukrainian field commanders' decisions to train newly-deployed personnel on the front before committing them to combat indicates that the overall quality of Ukrainian forces will likely remain higher than that of Russian forces in the near- to mid-term.

This author thinks Russia has seriously hurt Ukraine by attacking all along the front:

The outlook in Ukraine is bleak. However, if Ukraine’s allies engage now to replenish Ukrainian munitions stockpiles, help to establish a robust training pipeline, and make the industrial investments to sustain the effort, then Russia’s summer offensive can be blunted, and Ukraine will receive the breathing space it needs to regain the initiative.

But he has some hope of Ukraine stemming the tide. We'll see if Russia's telegraphed summer offensive was based on America not resuming aid. If so, the small nibbling attacks may be all we see of the Big Push. TDI is skeptical that Russia will make that kind of effort. 

UPDATE (Monday): Air defense is needed:

Ukraine imposed emergency power shutdowns in most of the country on Sunday, a day after Russia unleashed large-scale attacks on energy infrastructure and claimed it made gains in the eastern Donetsk province.

And Ukraine won't train their troops as much as they should be:

As Ukraine prepares to mobilize tens of thousands of men to address a critical shortage of soldiers amid intensified Russian attacks, Ukrainian commanders in the field say they are bracing for most of the new troops to arrive with poor training.

The article also mentions the issue I noted in the main body about training existing soldiers transferred to combat units.

I've commented that after Army basic training, I was just a rough-stamped cog only ready to be finished and put in the Green Machine. 

UPDATE (Thursday): The pig is finally reaching the end of the ammo python:

Western-provided artillery ammunition has reportedly started arriving to Ukrainian forces on the frontline, although not at a scale that would allow Ukrainian forces to fully challenge the Russian military's current artillery shell advantage.

Will this deter Putin from carrying out the suspected summer Big Push?

UPDATE (Thursday): FFS:

Ukrainian officials are pressing the U.S. and other countries to ramp up their F-16 pilot training, saying the current pipeline isn’t producing enough aviators to fly the jets that will be soon donated to Kyiv.

Hey, instead of ignoring the urgency, how about acting like there's a war on and expand the capacity to train?

Maybe jump start the whole thing with contract pilots, trainers, and maintainers, eh? 

UPDATE (Sunday): Are Russians growing tired of dying for Putin?

Chechen Akhmat Spetsnaz Commander Apty Alaudinov claimed in an interview with Russian state media outlet RT on June 8 that Russian authorities decided to transfer elements of the Akhmat Spetsnaz to the Kharkiv direction from unspecified areas at the end of May 2024. Alaudinov claimed that the "Kashtan" detachment, formerly known as Akhmat "Kamerton" detachment and renamed after its new commander, is operating in the Kharkiv direction. Ukrainian Khortytsia Group of Forces Spokesperson Lieutenant Colonel Nazar Voloshyn stated on June 8 that Akhmat forces are serving as blocking units – specialized disciplinary units that fire upon friendly forces if they engage in an unauthorized retreat – in the international border area, and it is possible that the Russian military command transferred Akhmat forces to the area solely for this purpose and not to conduct offensive operations.

One would think that's overdue. But the question is whether that reluctance matters in the face of Putin's determination to send them to die and make sure they die from Ukrainian bullets or the bullets of his Chechen enforcers.

NOTE: ISW updates continue here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.

Sunday, June 02, 2024

Weekend Data Dump

China massacred its subjects at Tiananmen Square 35 years ago. I observed that if China had unmanned ground vehicles that "Tank Man" would have been quickly murdered. In unrelated news: "China has showcased robot dogs capable of firing machine guns in the latest display of its military prowess."

 

The Palestinians continue to be their own worst enemy. Why the Biden administration wants to re-crown them as Queen of the Victim Prom is beyond my powers of comprehension. Rewarding Hamas for their rape and murder invasion of Israel is no way to pound sanity into their collective skull.

We need it: "Despite these continued successes, U.S. opinion polls indicate that 81 percent of Americans have confidence in their military. This is down from 90 percent twenty years earlier." The Afghanistan debacle broke my confidence in our flag officers. Below them, the military is still good. Will the rot stop?

I've posted on the American X-37 space plane. China has one, too: "China’s experimental reusable spacecraft has released an unknown object into orbit while conducting its third mission." Tip to Instapundit.

The front line: "Defense officials in NATO member Poland presented plans on Monday for fortifying its eastern border with Moscow ally Belarus." That seems prudent. Add that to the Baltic states digging in.

U.S.-Australia Defense Policy and Strategy Talks: "The DPST is the premier defense policy dialogue for the U.S.-Australia alliance to address shared challenges in the Indo-Pacific region and beyond by ensuring close coordination and promoting the alignment of strategic guidance."

Deterrence requires it: "A Polish official said the US told Russia it would strike Russian targets in Ukraine if Putin used a nuke." We'd use conventional weapons--not nukes. Tactical nukes were the pre-precision weapons means of hitting important battlefield targets. We don't need nukes to inflict that damage now.

Detecting and defeating the threat: "The Baltic states announced plans alongside Norway, Finland and Poland to construct a 'drone wall' along their shared borders with Russia on Sunday."

China likes to act as it this is an internal law enforcement issue and not subliminal conquest: "The Philippines has protested China's imposition of a unilateral four-month long fishing ban in the South China Sea, its foreign ministry said on Monday." China wins if we accept their internal issue claim.

Huh: "North Korea condemned China, Japan and South Korea on Monday for committing to denuclearise the Korean peninsula, describing their joint declaration after a rare summit in Seoul as a "grave political provocation" that violates its sovereignty." I guess China no longer considers their little pet psycho useful.

So, how stable is the Mosul Dam these days? I remember our special forces moving in to secure it 2003 to prevent it from being blown by enemies. Since the Islamic State period, I haven't heard much.

More than two decades of wartime blogging has made me wary of trying to connect dots. Especially in a huge country like America. But man, if this isn't a pattern to worry about it sure looks like one. It's a vulnerability an enemy should try to exploit. But again, scattered dots don't really form pictures. Do they?

But he's such a polite proto-fascist! "Justin Trudeau is running out of time." I don't want to visit Canada while his policies rule the country. Still, the charge of "Conservatives pounce!" might save the man.

Britain's return to the Indo-Pacific "east of Suez" is folly? Maybe. Britain's military was redesigned so it would have influence in a post-Brexit global trading network. Russia's invasion of Ukraine may have invalidated that strategy. But Europe's need for Britain's military may negate continental EU hostility.

Well, yeah: "the Biden Administration’s goal is to have Hamas survive this war victorious and to achieve the lost-but-now-found two-state solution in the post-war period." That's what I've been saying. It's Smart Diplomacy® to help our enemies win!

This article denies that the Baltic Sea is a NATO lake since Sweden and Finland joined NATO. Hogwash. Just because Russia still has bases on the sea only means Russia can contest the sea. For a while. Their naval forces will survive no better than NATO troops in West Berlin would have survived war in 1987. 

Smart Diplomacy®: "The Biden administration is pressing European allies to back off plans to rebuke Iran for advances in its nuclear program, even as it expands its stockpile of near-weapons-grade fissile material to a record level ... ." Of course Biden did that. I bet our allies could use mean tweets about now.

Escalation: "Western intelligence officials stated that the Russian General Staff's Main Directorate (GRU) are behind a series of low-level sabotage operations throughout Europe that aim to disrupt Western arms supplies to Ukraine and create the appearance of a European movement opposing support for Ukraine."

Explain to me again why we shouldn't support a "color" revolution movement in Russia: "Russian officials are considering delisting the Taliban as a prohibited organization in Russia and will likely do so in the near term."

The sanctuary in the air: "Belgium’s pledge on Tuesday to send the first batch of F-16 fighter jets to Ukraine this year comes with a clear warning to Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy: Don’t fly them in Russian territory." Still, it's a good donation--30 aircraft.

Good Lord ...: "A Papua New Guinea government official has told the United Nations that more than 2,000 people are believed to have been buried alive by last Friday's landslide and has formally asked for international help."

China's submarine force: "Their submarines are poorly designed and built. The crews are often poorly trained and supervised." That apparently remains an important advantage for us. But China keeps pushing and we see their subs in the central Pacific more often. Eventually the subs will be dangerous.

Sucks to be North Korea: "North Korea continues its economic decline and risk of political collapse. More North Koreans are malnourished and starvation deaths are increasing. " Draft evasion is rampant. How long can Kim Jong Un rely on spooks and nukes to keep his ruling kooks in power? Surely there's a limit.

I don't overlook Russia's strategy of out-bleeding Ukraine. It's that I don't think Russia can continue that long enough to win if we supply Ukraine. I think a Russia willing to bleed makes it more important to keep it as far east as possible. Sure, Democrats' sudden Russia conversion is ... odd. Gratefully accept it!

Instapundit said our war logistics look shaky because of this: "A floating pier on the shores of the Gaza Strip, set up to provide a lifeline to the Palestinian territory, has faced a rocky start, with one report claiming that it was 'sinking.'" FFS. This doesn't reflect war logistics. It's a Michigan GOTV operation.

Does Iran already have nuclear weapons? That's my worry: "I've long wondered if Iran would exploit the intense focus on its enrichment status to hide its acquisition of nuclear weapons from North Korea. Iran's rulers are nutballs--not stupid--I argued." North Korea could have shipped nukes through Russia to Iran.

Putin wants to partition Ukraine because his military is too weak, his people too weary, and China isn't coming to the rescue with a second front: "In short, he is now looking for an exit from a war he started but can’t afford to see through." Putin would use the time gained to reload. Russia must retreat for peace.

Proto-despots wage war on proto-subjects: "This is a war against ‘hate speech’ and ‘disinformation’, which the EU claims pose an existential threat to democracy. In truth, it is the Eurocrats’ censorious designs that are the real danger to Europeans’ liberties." The EU wants all the prefixes stripped. Kill it.

I wish I trusted the investigators: "The Afghanistan War Commission’s probe is getting very real." We screwed the pooch in 2009, 2016, and 2021. I'm not sure which was key. But only the last one was fatal. And I don't know if the state of denial of those responsible will ever end. That's as real as this gets.

Replicating the CRAF air transport reserve: "A new program called the Commercial Augmentation Space Reserve, or CASR, will ensure the Space Force can rely on commercial vendors’ space systems throughout a 'spectrum of conflict.'"

The Army wants to replace its Shadow tactical drone with a new basic airframe "to be runway independent, have on-the-move command and control and soldier-led field level maintenance"; and that can be reconfigured easily with software and payloads as future requirements and capabilities arise.

The rockets of Israel.

The rockets of Elon.

Putin lies about Ukraine's constitution to claim Zelensky's presidency is illegitimate. But this is perfectly legal under martial law which was invoked after Putin invaded Ukraine. Putin is the last man who should lecture us about limits on terms of office.

NATO exercises in Lithuania: "Just as the allies stood up for us during the Cold War, we are standing up for the security and freedom of our partners today - on every square centimetre of the alliance's territory," Carsten Breuer, the Bundeswehr's highest-ranking officer, told dpa while visiting Vilnius."

Russian cruelty misses no targets: "Russian authorities are preparing to intensify the deportation of Ukrainian children to Russia throughout Summer 2024, further consolidating another component of Russia's genocidal campaign in Ukraine." 

Huh: "Iranian production models for Shahed drones and Iranian drone technologies are at the center of the entire [Russian] Alabuga enterprise. ... Iran has also likely supplied Russia with Qaem-5 television-guided air-to-ground bombs, which Iran started producing as recently as 2019." Biden still can't quit the mullahs.

So what? "European Union defence ministers meeting in Brussels on Tuesday were unable to reach a consensus on whether Ukraine should be allowed to use the weapons they supply to strike targets on Russian territory." Are we pretending the EU has power over sovereign member states on this issue?

So there was a night blood-red sky in a region in China: "The Dinghai District Meteorological Bureau debunked speculations of the sighting as being of supernatural origin." Interesting response. Well, let's hope people start thinking the Mandate of Heaven was withdrawn from Xi Jinping.

I'm surprised global warming wasn't blamed: "The U.S. military will remove the temporary pier that operated for less than two weeks off the coast of Gaza after suffering damages from rough seas and bad weather, the Pentagon announced Tuesday."

Sure: "Iran keeps making substantial progress in its brisk walk to an atomic weapon, a United Nations report leaked Monday suggests, and what are they going to tell us next—that there’s gambling at Rick’s? Yet the Biden Administration wants to hide this scary truth from the world in this election year." Ah, love.

North Korea released a flock of balloons to float over the DMZ into South Korea: "Witnesses told local media that some of the bags, apart from containing pro-North Korea propaganda, produced an odorous smell and likely contained animal feces." What is their major malfunction? 

Sadr is our enemy: "Nationalist Iraqi Shia cleric Moqtada al Sadr demanded that the Iraqi government expel US Ambassador to Iraq Alina Romanowski and close the US Embassy in Baghdad in retaliation for US support for Israel." I've warned for twenty years we'd rue the day we let that insurrectionist live.

Meanwhile off the coast of Yemen: "The Houthis damaged a Marshall Islands-flagged merchant vessel in the Red Sea on May 28." Iran is pleased.

Too many of our flag officers suck at being military leaders. Can't disagree with that. 

And yet the dread "Arab street" doesn't rise up: "Arab media does not cover the Gaza war in an objective manner, but instead sells its consumers illusions that are far removed from reality and even echoes Hamas' claim that it is defeating the Israeli army." Tip to Instapundit.

China says the South China Sea is its territorial water: "Philippines President Ferdinand Marcos Jr said on Wednesday new rules outlined by China's coast guard that could result in the detention of foreigners in the South China Sea were an escalation and 'worrisome'." If nobody resists, China's claim will be correct.

Waving nukes around: "A senior member of a Russian think tank whose ideas sometimes become government policy has suggested Moscow consider a 'demonstrative' nuclear explosion to cow the West into refusing to allow Ukraine to use its arms against targets inside Russia." But what will it demonstrate?

CRS report: "Russia remains the U.S. rival with the most capable and diverse nuclear forces. Today it is unique in the combination of strategic and non-strategic nuclear forces it fields[.]" Sometimes I wonder if we go along with Russia's Potemkin nuclear force to help Russia deter China. 

I don't understand why Palestinians get to be the Queen of the Victim Prom. Syrians killed by Assad, Kurds or Iranians killed by Saddam, Iraqis killed by Iran's mullahs or jihadis, Sudanese killed by Sudanese, and Afghans killed by jihadis--all in large numbers--never inspired moral outrage. Odd, no?

Meanwhile in and around Yemen: "Another U.S. MQ-9 Reaper drone went down in Yemen, images online purported to show Wednesday, as Yemen’s Houthi rebels continued attacks on shipping around the Red Sea over the Israel-Hamas war." We shrug at what Iran is doing. It seems odd. It is odds.

Working on restoring the Arsenal of Democracy: "A plant still under construction in Mesquite, Texas, will soon turn out 30,000 artillery shells each month, roughly doubling current U.S. output." It's flexible on shell size.

Putin has more territorial ambitions: "U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Wednesday pledged $135 million in aid to Moldova for energy security and to counter Russian disinformation[.]"

Hmmm: "Israel is examining the M61 Vulcan cannon to counter drones, according to the Israel Defense Forces, with local media reporting the weapon would go atop armored personnel carriers deployed along the northern border." Do we have any of those Cold War vehicles in desert storage somewhere?

Poland buys JASSM-ER cruise missiles: "The ministry said the contract is connected to Poland’s recent purchase of four aerostat-based early warning radar systems from the United States for $1 billion as well as its acquisition of F-35 combat jets, also made by Lockheed." Balloons still go to war. Without feces.

Reuters is concerned that cargo ships avoiding Iran's Houth proxy anti-shipping war in the Red Sea are increasing carbon dioxide emissions when they reroute around southern Africa. Yeah, that's the problem.

Putin often sends out his screeching vodka-addled nuke monkey Medvedev to fling nuclear poo and pound his chest. America speaks softly and flies a big stick: "Two B-52 Stratofortresses from a U.S. Air Force bomber task force flew over the Baltics and Eastern Europe on May 28, U.S. Air Forces in Europe said."

Ukrainian partisan attacks behind Russian lines and inside Russia; plus Ukraine's strategic warfare drone attacks inside Russia. Apparently, Ukraine has rounded up most of the Russian agents inside Ukraine.

China goes big: "During the first week of May this year, China’s first modern aircraft carrier, Fujian, carried out its initial sea trials. The sea trials and time in port for needed modifications means that Fujian will not enter service until 2026." Hey, their carriers will burn, too.

China's new Type 76 amphibious warfare ship is about the size of the America-class ship, but wider. I've long observed that China doesn't need them to invade Taiwan. I think these are primarily intended for peacetime power projection. Or small-scale assaults on islands in the East China Sea or South China Sea.

Russia greatly outnumbers America in short-range nukes: "Russia may take extra steps in the area of nuclear deterrence if the United States deploys intermediate and short-range missiles in Europe and Asia, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov told the state RIA news agency in an interview." Also, really?

Oh, FFS: "The US Navy mishandled oversight of a $22 billion frigate program to replace the much-criticized and more vulnerable Littoral Combat Ship, according to a new congressional audit." We couldn't sustain a long blockade of China with our crappy shipbuilding. What happened to our Navy?

Democrats and foreigners are in a hysterical panic over a Trump presidency. I guess they can cherry pick statements and extrapolate. Or they could look at his record when actually the president. That's what I do.

Democracy dies in kangaroo courts (via Instapundit): "Today, the Hong Kong courts convicted 14 pro-democracy activists in the city’s largest national security trial. The Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation unequivocally condemns these sentences and calls for the immediate release of the 47 ... ."

Some Iraqi militia or terror group fired the cruise missile: "Israeli air defenses shot down a projectile fired at the southern Golan Heights 'from the east,' the Israel Defense Forces said Thursday." States that can't control their territory shouldn't get Westphalian benefits. Declare the Lexington Rule to be our policy.

Without wisdom, you're just a DIK. Okay, the article is outside my lane. But my summary seemed too obvious not to use.

Robot wars: "Video has emerged showing what is claimed to be a Russian First Person-View (FPV) drone attacking a Ukrainian uncrewed surface vessel (USV). It is the first time we have seen this kind of engagement." Now do aerial drones, as I advocated in Army magazine.

China prefers not to have competition for its huge land-based missile arsenal: "China's defence ministry on Thursday strongly condemned the deployment of a U.S. intermediate range missile system in the northern Philippines during military drills in April, saying it 'brought huge risks of war into the region'."

Maybe: "The head of the U.S. military in Africa vigorously defended the country’s counterterrorism strategy on the continent and vowed to press forward with it despite a wave of criticism and a drift among African nations toward seeking security help from Russia instead." But we're losing right now.

Pity: "The U.S. Navy’s much-touted goal of a regional fleet of 100 unmanned surface vessels in the Middle East fell so short of expectations that the service has scrapped the notion of a numerical target for the program[.]" I anticipated battling Iranian suicide and small attack boats with robots--not our big ships.

Our post-Cold War holiday from history is over and the credit card bill is due: "The U.S. Navy is unable to build enough new ships to replace the fleet it currently has." Meanwhile, China mass produces warships. Is our failure the result of our Ten Year Medium Term Rule?

Electronic warfare. 

Where are the nuclear wessels? "A high-ranking US Navy official has warned that China and Russia have intensified attempts to infiltrate American military bases, potentially jeopardizing national security." As we know from Fort Hood Cavazos, our bases are soft target weapons-free zones.

Aiding Taiwan: "'The whole idea is for these guys [Taiwan] to … deter, and if deterrence is not an option, to be able to hold their own for a period of time,' a senior American defense official said." Taiwan relies on allies coming to help. China only needs to delay America to defeat Taiwan. But China might beat us.

So a right-wing majority may win the European Union "parliament"? Meh. Winners will just play the game of using money funneled through the EU to their own constituencies. The EU wins. Unless the majority cuts the tentacles of the proto-imperial EU, the EU will erase the prefix and strangle freedom.

If Smart Diplomacy® has anything to say about it, we won't seriously try to defeat an unstable Peking ally on its border: "By any measure, it would be a stretch to say that the United States is currently engaged in a New Cold War proxy war with China and Russia in Myanmar."

China looked at Guadalcanal for lessons: "According to one study, Japan fell into a 'vicious cycle (恶性循环)' after it lost the airfield on Guadalcanal." This reflects my analysis in this 2017 Land Warfare Paper of the synergy of each American service winning their own domain in the campaign.

The Chinese noted this problem of Japan's two-front war: "Between 1942 and 1943, the mainland soaked up 64 percent of the Japanese army while it absorbed 45 percent of the air force." Our war would have been harder if Japan hadn't been tied down on the continent. That's why I want China focused inland.

The mostly peaceful Attacker community waits in fright for the backlash: "A knife-wielding attacker injured several people on the square in Mannheim, located in south-western Germany, before being shot by police. The attacker was wounded."

They replaced an odious government and then became an odious government: "With most of the results now in from South Africa's election, the long-ruling African National Congress (ANC), will have to contend with sharing power after a historic loss of its parliamentary majority." Still has a vote plurality.

If sustaining American power abroad is your main concern for next year, skip to the part on Afghanistan and keep going for a while. It does mix foreign and domestic policy, but it is valuable for the allied panic setting in abroad about potential American policy that disregards actual experience. Tip to Instapundit.

The F-16 and its F-35 replacement. Neither Russia nor China have anything to match. The F-35 is good--but can be hacked because it is networked. The F-16 continues production with the F-16V. After long worry I'm settled down about the F-35 plane. The hacking issue still worries me. 

The DARPA (Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency) UUV (Unmanned Underwater Vessel), Manta Ray, can autonomously travel long distances carrying supplies--among other options. Is this really the answer to supplying Marines on forward islands inside China's A2/AD envelope? 

Poland in the shadow of Russia decides to dig in. 

Russia won't attack now. But mischief might subtract NATO aid to Ukraine. So: "Russia is up to so much mischief around the Baltic Sea that even the things that it ends up not doing cause Western alarm bells to ring." The Baltics are on the list. And the mischief proves Russia doesn't actually fear NATO will attack.

China's reach for the Antarctic.

Russia wants to portray Ukraine as uninterested in "peace" but wants to "present Kyiv with terms of surrender that involve de facto acceptance of Russia’s territorial gains" that include a demilitarized zone on the Ukraine side of the border. Unlike America, Russia understands that peace follows victory.

I should pay more attention to China's Moon advances: "A craft launched from China in May is preparing to land on the far side of the Moon - an unexplored place almost no-one tries to go." The plan is to retrieve rocks and regolith (not "soil" as the article says, but we know what they mean).

Adding to the Houthi tanker war? "Russia is planning to build a logistical support center on Sudan’s Red Sea coast, which it likely intends to use to advance its efforts to secure a Russian naval base in Sudan. Russia’s backing of the SAF aligns Iranian and Russian policies and strategies in the region." Iran tries.

Strategic warfare: "Russian forces conducted a large-scale drone and missile strike mainly targeting Ukrainian energy infrastructure on the night of May 31 to June 1." 

Strategery: "The current lack of clarity about US restrictions on Ukraine's use of US-provided weapons to strike military targets in Russian territory misses an opportunity to deter further Russian offensive efforts across the border into northern Ukraine."

More on Myanmar: "China is playing both sides of the civil war, supporting anti-junta ethnic militias in order to extract ever-greater economic and political concessions from the very regime that it supports militarily."  Man, China seriously screws with even the thug regimes it supports. We can't exploit that?

Um, stop panicking, review his first term for lessons of actual policy, and treat him like the lawfully elected leader of your major ally? Just spitballing.

ATACMS goes to Ukraine and its replacement, Deepstrike, gets a test there. The headline says ATACMS production is revived but the body doesn't mention that.

Remote weapons stations reduce casualties for gunners. And a side trip into FPV drones. I assume one day they'll be viewed as the quaint forerunner of the fully robotic weapons.

North Korea sent another wave of garbage balloons across the DMZ: "The balloons, which are carrying 'filth,' flew across the border on Saturday, again, and into multiple provinces, including areas of Seoul, South Korea’s capital." North Korea doesn't like the private South Korean balloons showing freedom.

Hamas will accept the American rescue that will let Hamas rearm and resume efforts to kill Jews at a later date. Or maybe seizing the Philadelphia Corridor, as I noted in an update to this post, is the key.

America, Japan, and South Korea are tightening their security relationship. In addition, Japan and South Korea are also strengthening bilateral security ties without needing an American buffer.

I wonder what "unbearable" response South Korea intends to counter North Korea's aerial garbage attacks.

Russia said it was from negligence: "Fire broke out at an oil refinery in northwestern Russia on Sunday, resulting in deaths and injuries, local officials said." But who knows?

Some weeks are more difficult than others to stay in my lane.

Saturday, June 01, 2024

Army Fires Corps?

How should drones be integrated into the United States Army?

As part of a number of UAV recommendations, RUSI advocates separate drone battalions in armies:

[The] effectiveness of UAVs is largely determined by their layered employment, by crew skill, and by the capacity to plan flights. The latter requires access to electromagnetic surveys, meteorological data, intelligence on enemy air defences, and awareness of other UAV activity. The need to scale effect, and to have access to a support structure that must often draw on highly classified capabilities, means that while some UAVs may be widely distributed as tactical tools, most classes of UAV are better grouped into a specialist formation that is able to use different kinds of UAV in combination, and that has the in-house capacity to update and reconfigure its UAVs.

They'd fit nicely in a Army Air Corps--or better yet a Army Fires Corps for the synergy of different systems RUSI notes. 

The Army doesn't want drone operators in their own branch:

A Virginia Congressman is asking the Army to create a drone corps as a formal training branch, on par with traditional specialties like artillery and intelligence. But Army leaders aren’t buying it.

But that shouldn't mean that certain larger classes of drones not part of maneuver units can't be organized in battalions or companies as part of a Fires Corps that integrates artillery, rockets, missiles, and drones in fires brigades or battalions to maximize timely fire support to the Army.

One thing RUSI does not include is a fighter drone capability, which I advocated in this Army article. I think that is inevitable. 

But I have notions rather than firm opinions--let alone a solid position. So I'm following the debate with interest. 

UPDATE: To fight suicide drones, should air defenses and fires assets be combined in the "'air littorals,' meaning contested airspace closer to the ground"? That is, shooting at the operator on the ground or shooting down the drone is all part of the same mission.

In that Army article about fighter drones cited in the main post I used the same variation of the "littorals" that the Navy has used for a long time distinguishing between deep "blue waters" versus coastal "green waters" or even "brown waters" that are so close to the land it is muddy. But I called that space just above the ground troops the dusty "brown skies" distinct from the "blue skies" where expensive warplanes roam.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War in this post.