Saturday, December 21, 2024

Marine Force Design: To the Shores of Taiwan?

Is ripping apart the Marine Corps a distraction that hides 3rd Marine Division's plan to fight the Chinese navy from outposts on Taiwan?

Western Pacific Marines prepare to sink ships:

Marines with 3d Marine Littoral Regiment, 3d Marine Division have an expanded arsenal. This week the regiment received the Navy-Marine Expeditionary Ship Interdiction System, also known as the NMESIS weapons system.

Beyond the ominous name, the NMESIS is designed to boost the Marine Corps’ anti-ship capabilities, particularly for potential conflicts in the Pacific theater, where Marine units would be expected to deploy to several islands throughout the ocean.

The weapon only has a range of 115 miles. This seems like a fatal flaw in the regiment. 

But what if the plan is to put the unit on Taiwan and we just can't say that part out loud?  That anti-ship missile's range which seems so small in the vast Pacific theater is enough in the narrow Taiwan Strait, no?

This doesn't reverse my criticism of Force Design. Indeed, even if hiding its intended mission is the purpose of FD, it makes ripping apart 3rd Marine Division and crippling the rest of the Marine Corps for one task within INDOPACOM seem even more ridiculous. That change would be done for defending one island. A large and important island, but still only one.

Especially when the Navy Expeditionary Combat Command could have been assigned the anti-ship job and prevented the neutering of the ground combat capability of the Marine Corps.

UPDATE: Doubts that Marines ashore on Taiwan could survive let alone contribute more than more traditional anti-ship assets can. 

That issue has been a major worry of mine, in general. But I thought perhaps resupply to Taiwan would be more plausible. Perhaps even that is too optimistic.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

Friday, December 20, 2024

The Logistics of Defending NATO

For all the talk of NATO "expanding" through the former Soviet satraps in their freed imperial holdings, NATO didn't emplace troops or the infrastructure and plans to actually move military power into or through the new NATO states. Russian aggression changed that.


Sh*t got real: 

Secret documents revealed Wednesday that Berlin has begun making plans for how it could help deploy as many as 800,000 NATO troops — including Americans — into Ukraine as Russia’s nuclear saber-rattling reaches new heights.

“Operation Deutschland” is a 1,000-page plan to prepare Germany for the possibility of a World War III scenario.

The top-secret papers reportedly detail specific buildings and infrastructure to protect so they can be utilized by the military, and how businesses and civilians should prepare in case of increased threats, according to the German newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung.

Putin claimed to fear the phantom military threat from NATO until he created it, perhaps finally believing his own BD. And invading Ukraine which would not submit in the fortnight he planned has bought NATO additional time. NATO has bought even more time by arming Ukraine to gut Russia's army and deplete its ammunition and equipment reserves.

Plans to move and sustain NATO troops to its eastern front are a warning to Putin that he has lost his window of opportunity to pounce on an unprepared NATO. Much has improved since Putin displayed his suicidal imperial ambitions in Europe:

[For] years after the Cold War, NATO expansion east was in name only. NATO did not add forces to new NATO members and NATO didn't build up the logistics infrastructure to sustain a defense of those new members, let alone to attack Russia from there. And NATO didn't even have war plans to defend new members. Russia changed all that with its serial aggression against Ukraine.

Really, you can't simultaneously argue that NATO provoked Russian aggression and that it is perfectly natural for Russia to want buffer territory in the west. Would Russia have attacked west if NATO never admitted former Soviet-controlled territory, or not?

Will Russia--with or without Putin--learn from this massive whack with the clue bat to face the real threat to Russia?

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Thursday, December 19, 2024

Fighter Drones!

Fighter drones have arrived in Ukraine.

Screw asymmetric weapons--fight fire with fire:

In the contested skies above Ukraine, a new kind of warfare is rapidly emerging as drones are increasingly sent on new attack missions. Their targets aren't armored vehicles or fighting positions — they are other drones.

I won't claim to be a prophet. But I did recognize the growing problem. To counter that problem, in 2018 in Army magazine I called for fighter drones--unmanned aerial systems (UASs) to protect our forward troops from enemy drone swarms in the "brown skies" just above them:

Clearly, units at the company level and below need a better means of controlling their own brown skies airspace. Yet rather than burdening lower-level units with additional ground-based air defense gun and missile systems, air-to-air combat UASs would provide better air defense than either high-flying advanced fighter aircraft or distant higher-echelon air defense weapons that will have difficulty identifying and tracking small aerial threats--let alone engaging them--before the threats strike and return to enemy positions. ...

Much as Army units carry out their operations unaware of the battles taking place in the blue skies that keep enemy aircraft away from the battlefield, units maneuvering and engaging in direct fire can't afford to be distracted by fighting for the brown skies above them.

I thought that forcing the bleeding edge to lug around and use anti-drone weapons sufficient to protect themselves would fatally distract them from their primary mission of closing with and destroying the enemy. Perhaps the Replicator phase 2 addressing counter-drone technology will see a role for this type of weapon. Maybe phase 2 is what we're seeing in the skies over New Jersey, eh?

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Wednesday, December 18, 2024

China Gets a Reality Check

As much as I worry about China's rise, I always try to keep in mind that the facade of their shiny new weaponry conceals problems. This is no reason to assume China can't fix their problems. But it means we should not panic. Work the problems we have the power to correct.

The hollowness of China's modern, expanded military:

Chinese President Xi Jinping has devoted billions of dollars to his aim of transforming the military into a modern force by 2027. His government has also launched sweeping purges in the upper echelons of the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) in response to what US intelligence believes to be widespread corruption undermining Xi’s ambitions.

A major concern for Beijing appears to be graft that has eroded the quality of the weapons and capabilities of units such as the Rocket Force, which oversees the country’s missiles and nuclear arsenal, and would be instrumental should Beijing invade Taiwan.

China doesn't need to advance far to have strategic results. Although now I'm more worried about a long war, too. So I worry about China. But I have long recognized that China isn't as strong as it looks.

On the bright side, discovering the effects of corruption should mean China's rulers aren't going to decide to go to war based on a mistaken view of their military prowess. At least for a while, that lesson from Russia's invasion of Ukraine will shake Xi's confidence.

Which also means it is strategic malpractice to abandon the rest of the world where active fights are ongoing in order to focus on China in case it becomes an active enemy in the near future. 

UPDATE: Timely addition from the DOD--the 2024 annual report to Congress on China's military power. And from the fact sheet, a new section in the report:

In 2023, the PLA experienced revelations of a new wave of senior leader corruption, which may have disrupted the PLA’s progress toward its stated modernization goals. This wave of corruption touches every service in the PLA, and it may have shaken Beijing’s confidence in high-ranking PLA officials. Rooting out corruption in the military had been a major focus for Xi Jinping since 2012.
NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Tuesday, December 17, 2024

Strategersky: Central Asia Edition

Russia once figured its former imperial holdings in Central Asia could be next on the agenda. Instead, as Ukraine keeps fighting Russia is losing influence. China will inevitably fill the growing vacuum.

Stand in awe of Putin's 4D chess skills!

Facing increasing Russian hostility to Central Asian immigrants, Central Asian countries are instead encouraging their nationals to go to other Asian countries to ensure transfer payments and prevent domestic explosions.

Remember when Kazakhstan seemed next for Russia after a quick march into Kyiv? Not that I thought Russia could pull that off that first conquest. And Kazakhstan may want to keep its enemy closer:

Russian President Vladimir Putin and Kazakh President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev met in Astana on November 27 and signed a joint statement deepening the Russian-Kazakh strategic partnership within the framework of Russia's efforts to establish a "new world order."

Or perhaps Kazakhstan fears China more right now.

But under the circumstances of Putin's faceplant in Europe and failure to defend Assad in Syria, we might want to instead talk about China's first target in the region. As the initial article does:

Russia’s ally, will not save Russia in Central Asia. Instead, Beijing is likely to exploit this new set of Russian losses. Beijing itself, however, will also find itself in competition with South Korea and other Pacific Rim countries because, unlike them, it is unlikely to be able to arrange for the dispatch of Central Asian workers to China. 

China can hardly decide not fill the vacuum as a favor to Russia because others--perhaps unfriendly to China--will do so.

The autopsy on Russia's imperial ambitions and who destroyed Russia could be fascinating.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with DALL-E 3 before it shut down.

Monday, December 16, 2024

The Winter War of 2022 Pretends Russia Can Be Satisfied

The Winter War of 2022 rages. In a sense it is frozen in expectations. Russia claws forward on the front--with Pokrovsk now threatened--and bombs Ukrainian civilians. Ukraine suffers grievous human losses while inflicting even more casualties on the invaders; and bombs Russian logistics. Occasionally we are reminded that Ukraine uses unmanned surface drones in the Black Sea. But nobody really expects much to change on the battlefield. How will American policy change next year and what will it do to the surface battlefield stasis?

Russia continues to advance in the Donbas. This worries me despite my advice since 2014 that preserving their army is the highest priority over holding random terrain. Ukraine falls back while inflicting disproportional casualties on the Russians. Part of my brain says this is good. Another part sees the loss of territory. Because I can't see if Russia's losses are reaching a point of affecting Russia's will to keep waging war. I can see the slow loss of territory and wonder if this reflects critical problems in the Ukrainian army. And worry that eventually Russia will take critical territory if this continues.

And firing the Ukrainian commander of the Donetsk front where Russia has been advancing (at high cost) inspires both fear of problems and hope of better performance over whatever factor led to his firing.

Evaluating the war is difficult. And so whether diplomacy saves Russia or Ukraine is hard to figure out. Depends on the form of diplomacy.

Zelensky (a couple weeks ago) is correct if the West is to avoid creating a "peace' deal that is merely cover to let Russia reload:

An offer of NATO membership to territory under Kyiv’s control would end “the hot stage of the war” in Ukraine, but any proposal to join the military alliance should be extended to all parts of the country that fall under internationally recognized borders, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said in a broadcast interview.

If the West isn't going to help Ukraine win (if Ukrainians have the stomach for the losses needed to do that), any deal should simply accept the reality that Russia occupies the territory--not that Russia lawfully owns it as a result of its wars against Ukraine. Kind of like putting West Germany in NATO without accepting East Germany was forever lost. And without seeking to unify Germany.

If instead a ceasefire-in place is negotiated as a precondition for diplomatic talks, locking in Russia's conquests, Ukraine may naturally feel betrayed or they may feel relieved that they won't have to pay the price to drive Russia back. Although relief could be followed by resentment unless NATO membership is offered.

As for Russia? The naturally paranoid Russians will see an American plot and feel betrayed no matter how good a final deal is for Russia, as I've long predicted:

Any Western deal that gives Russia a partial win will eventually be portrayed by Russia as a stab in the back denying Russia their deserved complete victory.

That will guarantee another war. Perhaps directly against the West to take away Ukraine's source of weapons and support before turning against Ukraine again.

If you want an "off ramp" for Russia in a policy of defeating Russia's aggression, be prepared to offer phased ending of economic sanctions of Russia as they restore peace with Ukraine. Outside of weapons-related sanctions as long as Russia chooses to be run by the paranoid hostile nutballs that plunged Europe into war.

And in that area, as I've suggested for some time since the 2014 invasion, I'd even explore the idea of leasing Crimea to Russia on a long-term basis. I'm not sure Ukraine wants its pro-Russia (and often actual Russians) people back inside Ukraine. Why not lease the peninsula to Russia, which concedes Ukraine owns it and the mineral rights in the waters off its shores?

As dangerous as defeating Russia may seem, that is the safest outcome in the long run.

Russians will forget their losses, how badly their military performed, and how bad their economy became. All they will see is that they were denied the fruits of their heavy sacrifice by the crafty Americans. And NATO, Nazis, and the Devil himself just to cover all their bases. Russian leaders will hate us even more for saving them from the worst consequences of their own folly. 

And if you think the "end" of this war scratches Russia's territorial itch, forget that comforting notion:

NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte warned on Thursday that Russian President Vladimir Putin wants to “wipe Ukraine off the map” and could come after other parts of Europe next, as he urged Europeans to press their governments to ramp up defense spending.
Russia decided a disarming NATO that barely paid attention to Russia and made excuses for Russian aggression is Russia's mortal enemy. Now that NATO is alerted, Russians will simply say "See! We were right!" More aggression of some sort will follow. It will reach NATO.

Or the conflict unexpectedly unfreezes with dramatic changes. I'd guess it takes place on the Russian side. But who knows?

Have a super sparkly diplomatic day.

UPDATE (Monday): Here we go (tip to Instapundit). Partitioning Ukraine with a ceasefire "would help Ukraine by allowing the country to focus on its domestic problems[.]" This sure sounds like a massive amount of confusion that assumes "ceasefire" means "peace".

More likely a Ukrainian focus on domestic problems while Russia focuses on rearming would simply make it easier for Russia to complete their conquest of Ukraine. I believe the best way for partition to work is after Russia is clearly defeated. And I've long said that might be the way the war could end.

Maybe partition is inevitable if Ukraine is unable or unwilling to drive the Russians back or to simply keep fighting hoping Russian morale cracks first from casualties and economic collapse. But let the Ukrainians decide that. If NATO makes the decision for Ukraine, Ukrainian morale might take a big hit, believing they've been betrayed. Will they trust NATO to defend them the next time for sure? This could make the next Russian invasion as easy as Putin thought it would be in 2022. Or perhaps, like in Georgia today, Russia can undermine Ukraine from within by funding pro-Russian politicians. Far from being seen as a fiasco, the war will be seen as a victory for Russia.

Who in NATO mans the very long DMZ to make it work? And that will need to include Ukraine's border with Belarus. Reagan said of the Soviets, "trust but verify." For the Russians with a proven track record of brutality to crush Ukraine, this will very much need to be "don't trust and enforce."

And I'm assuming this partition doesn't mean the Russian version where Poland and Hungary absorb parts of Ukraine, too. 

UPDATE (Monday): Russia strikes to freeze Ukrainians into submission:

Russia launched a massive air-strike against western Ukraine on Friday in what Kyiv described as one of the largest attacks on its power infrastructure since the war started.

UPDATE: Russia lost a couple river tankers to rough seas when they were ordered into the Black Sea. Russia is seemingly desperate to keep the fuel moving to the front.

NOTE: ISW updates continue here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War and the related Syria events in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved.

Sunday, December 15, 2024

Weekend Data Dump

I post at The Dignified Rant: Evolved on Substack. Help me out by subscribing and by liking and sharing posts. I continue posting here on TDR seven days a week, including Weekend Data Dump and Winter War of 2022. I occasionally post short data dump-type items on my Substack "Notes" section.  

Red storm writhing: "The Russian navy has not been mentioned much during the last year. The reason is that there is not much of a navy left. Case in point is the nuclear-powered Nakhimov, a 28,000-ton battlecruiser that entered service in 1988." It is doubtful it will ever sail this century. Pity.

Canada's Arctic front: "Ottawa envisions the deployment of new patrol ships and navy destroyers, ice breakers and submarines capable of operating beneath ice sheets, as well as more aircraft and drones."

Drones. They provide needed capabilities but I don't think they've replaced air and artillery fires as the post claims. Russian air attacks have escalated. And Ukraine never had much. Because artillery and rocket shells don't have cameras for posting videos, I think the relative effect of FPV drones is exaggerated.

The alliance firms up: "Simulated missile strikes and dispersed military operations are the focus of a nine-day exercise involving forces from the United States, Japan and Australia."

I always wonder if these are FONOPs or just puffed-up "innocent passage": "A U.S. Navy warship on Friday sailed close to disputed islands militarized by Beijing and other nations in the South China Sea, the service announced soon after the freedom-of-navigation operation." Did it conduct warship operations?

In October, USS Carney used its 5" gun in an anti-aircraft role.

Russia gave Assad a ride and not help. Syria is what probably would have happened to Ukraine if Zelensky had accepted America's offer of a ride out in February 2022 when Russia invaded.

Is amphibious warfare dead? Broadly speaking, I'd say no. But assault landings against dug-in peer opponents is certainly very difficult to the point of being suicidal. During a long war it may be possible to build the assets and shape the battlefield as was done at Normandy on June 6, 1944. But now? Egad.

Does China's increased crossing of Taiwan's air defense identification zone within a plateau of military effort around Taiwan's ADIZ suggest China is at peak military capacity there? Maybe. Or it may just suggest China has reached the level needed for the H Hour strikes as well as dulling Taiwanese reactions.

The term is cheapened, but fully valid for China: "Under Xi Jinping, China meets all four hallmarks of what constitutes fascism – cult-like worship, hyper-nationalism, a merciless surveillance apparatus and the glorification of military strength." Feudalism, communism, fascism, ... democracy? One day, maybe.

I'm not against using race as a factor in the military. As long as all leaders meet standards high enough to be effective as a military asset and as long as trust in leaders benefiting from that factor is not undermined by wokeness. Quality and diversity make the military stronger, I say.

Never say the Russians don't have a sense of humor: "The Russian Foreign Ministry issued an appeal on Sunday for all parties involved in the toppling of Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad to refrain from the use of force."

Keep out: "Australia has signed a treaty with the Pacific nation of Nauru which gives Canberra a veto over security and infrastructure partners, dealing another blow to China’s efforts to expand its strategic presence in the region." 

I heard a British The Telegraph podcast highlight how some American conservatives admire despots. The guest highlighted admiration starting with Germany's Kaiser before World War I. He noted that leftists are more known for despot worship! No host comment on the fact that Europeans followed actual despots.

Will Saudi Arabia exploit Iran's new weakness to go after the Houthi who in the past were happy to fire missiles at Saudi oil infrastructure on Iran's orders?

Huh: "A study by Chinese rocket scientists has uncovered a critical issue with the solid fuel used in intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs). ... significant changes can occur in missile fuel columns within just 30 years[.]" I'm sure Russian quality control is much better. That said, this applies to America, too.

Huh: "Plagued by mass migration, economic decay, political turmoil, and an existential crisis of identity, Europe is a civilisation in freefall. Trump’s ambitious vision – with its focus on strength, sovereignty, and economic dynamism – may well be the West’s last best hope." I usually see panic in European media.

Will Syria fragment? Well, that path has long been evident. If Syria does split apart, don't expect the UN to recognize the results from below. Ask Somaliland and Puntland if they've been rewarded for providing some stability in a fractured state's territory. 

Reach out and touch someone: "Australia has become just the third country to launch a Tomahawk land-attack cruise missile (TLAM) after the Royal Australian Navy’s (RAN) Hobart class destroyer HMAS Brisbane (DDG-41) successfully test fired the long-range weapon for the first time[.]"

Targets of opportunity: "Pentagon officials say that the massive strikes against more than 75 Islamic State terrorist group targets in Syria over the weekend were the result of an opportunity created by the withdrawal of Russian forces amid the collapse of the regime of Bashar Assad." Their shield disappeared.

Drones are a big factor in the Winter War of 2022: "[FPV] small drones are difficult to shoot down until they get close to the ground and the shooter is close enough, as in less than a few hundred meters, away to successfully target a drone with a bullet or two and bring it down." Could APS be modified to do that?

Russia wants its own gated Internet.

It's farcical for the Biden administration to claim any credit for the fall of Assad. Syria's Assad basked in the glow of Democratic love for its patron, mullah-run Iran. And be careful taking credit because those words will haunt them should jihadis come out on top in the next months or years in Damascus.

With Iran weakened by losing wars over the last year, I look forward to Trump resuming sanctions on Iran. Which is our enemy. Will it seriously harm the mullah-run regime? Hopefully. But at worst it forces China to pay for their new friend rather than relying on the West to sustain it. Tip to Instapundit.

ISW has thoughts on putting pressure on Iran to exploit its loss of Syria and the inability to rebuild Hamas and Hezbollah hammered by Israel; and to weaken Iran's remaining proxies in Iraq and Yemen.

The Philippines is absolutely at war. And China is the aggressor: "Marcos told reporters on Tuesday when asked if the government plans to send Navy warships. 'We are not at war, we don’t need Navy warships.'" He'd best send something effective or China will win its subliminal war.

Shameful: "The Biden-Harris administration waived sanctions on Iran three days after the November election, providing Tehran access upward of $10 billion in once-frozen funds, according to a copy of the non-public order[.]" Trump was wrong, too. But Biden still looves the mullahs. Tip to Instapundit.

Good: "The Missile Defense Agency intercepted an incoming ballistic missile threat target in a test from Guam, according to a Tuesday agency announcement." But I think we've been building up Guam as a major base for as long as I've been blogging.

They were escorting American merchant ships past Yemen: "U.S. destroyers USS Stockdale (DDG-106) and USS O’Kane (DDG-77) shot down a number of Houthi weapons in the Gulf of Aden between Monday and Tuesday, according to US Central Command."

Hmmm: "The Russian and Ukrainian militaries are moving to transform their soldiers’ rifles into weapons capable of countering exploding drones, experimenting with different ammunition types to determine the best shot[.]" That makes sense for troops on a static front. But it's a distraction during close combat.

LOL: "The Biden administration said Tuesday it will recognize and support a new Syrian government that renounces terrorism, destroys chemical weapons stocks and protects the rights of minorities and women." The Taliban promised to protect women and when they resumed oppression we kept the cash flowing.

The new car smell hides rust: "Chinese President Xi Jinping hasn’t come up with a workable solution for the Chinese military’s serious problems. The main one is corruption, which is pervasive and crippling." Are we exploiting or squandering the time that problem gives us? Long ago I noted the issue.

The Western Hemisphere outpost of the F**k-Up Fairy: "A recent surge in gang violence has led international aid organizations to get their personnel out of [Haiti] as soon as possible." The gangs are rising up and cooperating. The government-on-paper can't deal with this.

Chain guns go to sea in INDOPACOM: "At least four A-10 Thunderbolt II aircraft, commonly known as Warthogs, have arrived at Clark Air Base in the Philippines, photos published on Friday by the U.S. Air Force showed. They will conduct integrated training with the Philippine air force through December 15."

The Chinese national was arrested while waiting to board a flight to China: "Federal police arrested Yinpiao Zhou on Monday after he was allegedly caught flying a drone over the Vandenberg Space Force Base, in California."

The Philippines is building up its laws, security assets, and foreign defense ties to defend itself against China's subliminal war on its South China Sea territory.

If Russia already thinks it is at war with the West, it's because Russians started believing their own BS.

Stop celebrating the victory of HTS over the admittedly evil Assad regime. It's sort of like welcoming Stalin's defeat of Hitler in World War II, no? Relief should be immediately followed by dread and a full weapons check.

China prefers to win its subliminal war: "Diplomats and representatives from the militaries and coast guards of the United States, Japan and the Philippines agreed this week they prefer a peaceful settlement of ongoing Chinese aggression in the South China Sea."

I believe more information enables maneuver rather than inhibit it. But mobile units need the communications to exploit information: "With several network modernization efforts in the works, the program office is seeking to examine the right mix of radios for units."

Will Chad reconsider if Russian help falters? "France flew out the two Mirage fighter jets it had stationed in Chad on Tuesday, signaling the beginning of its withdrawal of military forces from the former French colony in central Africa that last month broke off its defense cooperation agreement with Paris."

I suspect the potential crisis was solved with a parallel agreement with Somalia that "allows" the deal with Somaliland to proceed: "Ethiopia and Somalia have agreed to end their bitter dispute over Addis Ababa's plans to build a port in the breakaway republic of Somaliland following talks in Turkey." But I'm guessing.

Taiwan's objections are the point of the deployment: "Taiwan demanded Wednesday that China end its ongoing military activity in nearby waters, which it said is unilaterally undermining peace and stability and disrupting international shipping and trade."

Morons with cumberbunds: "Tony Blinken Tells Congress ‘No One Anticipated’ Taliban Takeover of Afghanistan[.]" He was warned of the risk by his diplomats before the collapse. I could see the risk before that. Why there wasn't a culling of the leadership herd for this failure--and defeat--is beyond me.

Is Russia one major shock from a collapse? I never assumed Russia was done breaking apart. If Russia is lucky, it will experience regime collapse rather than state collapse. Will Russia's generals see getting rid of Putin and ending the invasion of Ukraine a means of making sure it isn't the state that collapses?

Will the West stop Turkey: "Syrians fear their country now faces an Islamic regime under the Turkey-backed conquerors, and military intervention may be necessary[.]" Help isn't coming. Nobody wants to "further militarize" the conflict. Let Erdogan enjoy victory. Don't subsidize his imperial ambition.

The leader of HTS in Syria learned from history by keeping Assad loyalists in the bureaucracy? Ah, the false conventional wisdom that de-Baathification in Iraq was a mistake. HTS has learned from the victorious Taliban and the Iranian Islamists before them to appear moderate at their weakest moment.

Oh? "President-elect Donald Trump’s choice to be NASA’s next administrator, Jared Isaacman, said Wednesday that as the U.S. establishes more of human presence in space, it will eventually need Space Force guardians stationed in the domain to protect its economic interests." Here comes SMOD! 

LOL: "A high-ranking official from the United Aircraft Corporation (UAC), Russia’s state-owned aircraft manufacturer, has disclosed that the country’s fifth-generation Su-57 stealth aircraft is being equipped with sixth-generation fighter technology." Russians "disclose" a lot of things. 

Can we command and control without emitting? "A handful of operational U.S. Army brigades now have a tool to “see” how they and enemy forces look in the otherwise invisible electromagnetic spectrum."

With spare air-to-air missiles, Ukraine has a "9K33 Osa (SA-8 Gecko) mobile short-range air defense system (SHORADS) armed with the Soviet-era R-73 (AA-11 Archer) infrared-guided air-to-air missile."

Individual NATO states may offer Ukraine defense guarantees: "In a so-called Berlin Declaration, the foreign ministers of Germany, France, Poland, Italy, Spain and the UK, as well as the EU's foreign affairs chief, Kaja Kallas, outlined their continued support for Kiev." We all know why the EU is involved.

What are the drones flying over the New Jersey region? The Department of Defense says they aren't military or Iranian. Which doesn't mean they aren't controlled by another part of the government or a contractor. If foreign, could denial of a threat be for the purpose of gathering forces to take them down?

Are we really this stupid?! "Any plans the Air Force might have for new hardened aircraft shelters or other physical defenses at bases are prominently absent from a new infrastructure modernization strategy."

The U.S. wants Russians to know what is happening: "The information provided by soldiers who have been there, or parents seeking to find out what happened to their sons in the army, has caused growing reluctance to support the Russian operations in Ukraine." Russians are resisting service in Ukraine.

Another American military aid package for Ukraine.

Falling star: "President Vladimir Putin’s disdain for the Russian space program has doomed the Russian space agency Roscosmos. Escalating incompetence among Roscosmos managers and staff crimped efforts to make Roscosmos effective and relevant again."

Should Nimitz-class carriers be updated to remain in service rather than retire them as Ford-class carriers enter service? The author notes questions of survivability in the face of kill webs. But says carriers are useful. Sadly, usefulness always ends up as an apples and oranges debate. You know my thoughts.

China is outraged that their subliminal offensive faces resistance: "China accused the Philippines on Friday of having 'provoked trouble' in the South China Sea with U.S. backing, a week after Beijing and Manila traded accusations over a new confrontation in the disputed waters."

Apparently the Somalia-Ethiopia deal brokered by Turkey cancels the Ethiopian naval base deal with Somaliland with the promise of a Somalia-Ethiopia deal to be negotiated. We'll see. But my initial guess was wrong. Still, Turkey is making a play to fill the power vacuum in the Horn of Africa.

We'll lose expensive planes to sheer stupidity: "Chinese strikes on airfields will stymie U.S. military aircraft in the Indo-Pacific region if there is a conflict, a new study says, recommending that the United States invest in cheap, uncrewed aircraft and runway repair capabilities." How is repair not Airfield 101?

Saying "maximum pressure" on Iran won't work ignores that helping Iran since 2021 strengthened Iran. So reversing that again will undo Iranian resilience. Also, Iran has lost much over the last year. And will a better U.S. reputation as a strong horse have no effect? At the very least, we'll force China to pay for Iran.

Has the rapid fall of Assad to Sunni Arab rebels put the fear of Allah into Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman and other Arab monarchs and autocrats? The enemy of their Iranian enemy is absolutely not their friend. And a facade of stability is not necessarily actual stability.

America needs Europe in friendly hands. And American military power through NATO knits together the separate strands of European power (and we should do more of that as I argued in Army magazine). And not to offend our European friends, but remember how things were when Europeans could wage war.

Russia wages a covert war on NATO: "In Poland civilian military police and intelligence services have been hunting down Russian operatives based in Belarus responsible for trying to organize a sabotage campaign in NATO nations in Eastern Europe, notably Poland."

How long before China has this? "European defense manufacturer Thales has an autonomous [sea] mine clearing system. The French Navy will be the first to use this system and, if it works, other NATO nations will probably adopt it." But it would be useful against Iranian mines laid around the Arabian Peninsula.

Upgrade: "The U.S. Army’s XM250 light machine gun replaces the M249 SAW, enhancing firepower and range with the new 6.8mm round, designed to penetrate next-gen body armor." Initial introduction will be focused on INDOPACOM, including Rangers and the 101st Airborne. They're Asia-focused? Really?

The American secretary of state made an unannounced visit to Iraq. Is it for the purpose of exploiting Iran's defeats in Syria, Lebanon, and Gaza to fight Iranian power within Iraq? Or to orchestrate another skedaddle?

Bye? "A second motion submitted by the largest opposition party in South Korea to impeach President Yoon Suk Yeol secured the required two-thirds majority in the country's parliament on Saturday." Their Constitutional Court will eventually rule on this.

Claiming America provoked Russia by "expanding" NATO ignores that the first Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2014 followed NATO disarmament and massive American withdrawal from Europe, including pulling out all its tanks. The accusation conflicts with the claim that Russia needs a buffer in Europe.

Does Taiwan count on this to overcome its own weaknesses? "In the absence of proper civil monitoring and an independent judicial system, it is very difficult for the CCP to monitor itself. Therefore corruption is certain to persist in the PLA, affecting the level of its overall combat readiness and military power."

With an eye on China, India decides to build two nuclear-powered attack submarines and purchase 31 Predator drones from America.

Undoing the artificial borders drawn by colonial masters--by creating South Sudan--didn't solve the region's problem: "Once more war has broken out in the northeast African nations of Sudan and South Sudan." I think the border problem is over-stated. Most borders are artificial. And time gives them meaning.

Compare and contrast on the Korean peninsula.

I remember the Cold War. So yeah: "defeat in Ukraine would require the United States to spend $808 billion more on defense over the next five years than it has budgeted. Since 2022, by contrast, Congress has appropriated $112 billion to the Defense Department to assist Kyiv." Distance from Russia is good.

WTAF? "More than half of the Army's senior officers are turning down opportunities to command, choosing instead the stability of staff roles over the high-stakes demands of leadership, or retiring, according to internal service data." FFS, order them to command! How is this a choice? Via Instapundit.

A fair summary: "Biden administration officials have claimed credit this week for the ongoing collapse of the Iranian axis, seeking to recast their role in a series of Israeli victories that they worked to thwart." Tip to Instapundit.

The foundation of America's war on ISIL is crumbling: "Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) Commander General Mazloum Abdi is attempting to preserve and unify the SDF’s Kurdish base as the group faces two existential threats (Turkey and Sunni Arab defection to HTS) in the wake of the fall of the Assad regime."

Elements of the Syrian rebels are displaying sectarian hate despite the HTS claim of unity and moderation. This pushes HTS to match the extremists or risk holier-than-thou factions to take over. This should push minorities--especially Alawites--to seek foreign protection. Is this Russia's opportunity to keep key bases?

Russia's influence expands in Georgia's government. They are deeply bought to ignore Russia's defeat in Syria and loss of influence in nearby Armenia. Many Georgians are protesting the push to return to the gulag.

Saturday, December 14, 2024

Protect the Sea Lines of Communication

The Navy must restore its ability to protect sea lines of communication for trade and power protection against the threat of enemies to break those SLOCS.

America will fight with the Navy it has rather than the Navy it wants: 

The U.S. must carefully consider how to provide logistical support to a besieged island deep within an adversary’s weapon engagement zone and with little enabling sea control.

Indeed. It's a need for every theater. 

The island in question is Taiwan, which China's expanding naval power with ships, subs, land-based long-range anti-ship missiles, and modernized aircraft could envelop to cut it off from the outside world to drive it into surrender.

But I suspect China prefers a fast win--not through a long blockade. Every week that Taiwan stands is a gift of time to America and its allies to gather forces to defeat China.

But if China does blockade? How about making modularized auxiliary cruiser escorts for the ships challenging the blockade to keep allied navy ships free to focus on the PLA Navy.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: Photo from the U.S. Navy.

Friday, December 13, 2024

Making Rotary Wing Lemonade or Growing More Lemons?

Life--and an agreement with the Air Force on apportioning aircraft--gave the Army attack helicopters. Can attack helicopters fight only if they attack while far from the battlefield?

Sounds good to me!

The U.S. Army wants to test an active electronically scanned array (AESA) radar on its AH-64 Apache attack helicopter, using a standard Apache weapons pylon. A radar of this kind would be a very valuable tool for spotting, tracking, and engaging targets, especially in bad weather and at extended ranges, including airborne threats, but it would also be able to perform more general intelligence-gathering and provide improved situational awareness, along with other functions. If successful, the radar could find its way onto other Army platforms, both rotary and fixed-wing, the service has said.

I have doubts about the ability of attack helicopters to survive over a modern battlefield. So keeping them back and still able to carry out their missions is great. But I wonder if the Army would choose to operate attack helicopters if it wasn't the only heavy option for ground support.

Tell me if this AESA upgrade is just a means to make existing helicopters effective rather than battlefield scrap; or if this means we'll continue building and fielding expensive attack helicopters in the future when other air assets might do the same job if equipped with AESA, too.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post [link fixed].

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Thursday, December 12, 2024

War Can Get Close Faster Than You Think

War between great powers is unlikely to be short, even if an enemy achieves surprise and wins an early victory against you. But that doesn't mean it isn't cheaper and safer in the long run to keep your enemy as far away as possible.


Good advice against relying on a presumed industrial advantage that no longer exists:

The democracies must not pattern the traditional Western complacent practice of allowing the enemy to conduct a surprise attack in order to mobilize its domestic population, like the 1940 Fall of France or the 1941 strike on Pearl Harbor. During the Cold War, NATO was faced with the dreaded choice of triggering a tactical nuclear war either at the commencement of hostilities along the East German border before most of NATO’s divisions were overrun, or in a last-ditch desperate defense on the Rhine, and it was this uncertainty that held the USSR at bay. 

The sudden rebel offensive that collapsed the Assad regime's security forces in Syria in less than two weeks certainly is a cautionary tale of ceding the initiative to your enemy on the assumption you can absorb the first blow.

I've long advised that it is best to keep enemies far from America to reduce the risks of an enemy jumping on us. Indeed, I warn against dangling our best military assets in tightly packed bases too close to enemies, fearing that will tempt them to start a war with a surprise offensive to take out our best units early. Like the Japanese in the original, that enemy may be wrong about how much they can exploit that. But the war will be longer and more costly for America because of it.

The solution is to support allies who keep enemies at a distance, whether in the Pacific or Atlantic. With Russia the current active threat, I've noted that distance from Russia is our friend. I'd much rather have the line in Ukraine than in central Europe.

When we bow to hollow Russian nuclear threats, we essentially let the Wookie win. Do that once and we'll face that threat again and again. The closer our front line gets to the Rhine the higher the cost of defending, the bigger the risk of losing a conventional war, and the higher the risk of nuclear war. And the risk of re-establishing deterrence against a nuclear power will be high.

And if we lose that European barrier? Well, we have centuries of experience with that problem in the Atlantic, don't we?

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing. 

Wednesday, December 11, 2024

The Return of Nukes at Sea

I'm not happy that our nukes are spreading throughout the fleet rather than being concentrated in our small fleet of nuclear-powered, nuclear ballistic missile submarines (SSBN).

Here we go:

In a surprising development, the US Navy has released a Request for Information (RFI) regarding the development of a Nuclear-Armed Sea-Launched Cruise Missile (SLCM-N).  

The initiative aims to establish a modular and resilient cruise missile system that delivers a proportional response while ensuring essential adversary targets remain vulnerable.  

It may be necessary to spread elements of our nuclear deterrent beyond our dedicated SSBNs to our Virginia-class submarines used for conventional war. America may need to make sure its nuclear arsenal is survivable in a world of expanding nuclear threats--mostly increased numbers of Chinese nukes and increased Russian hostility with their existing nuclear arsenal. Mostly China because who knows how many of Russia's long-range nukes work.

But I don't like that when a submarine launches conventional cruise missiles, enemies won't know if it is conventionally armed or nuclear. If their nuclear posture is "launch-on-warning" to avoid losing their arsenal in an enemy first strike--which would apply to smaller states in particular--it could be a very bad day.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: The picture is from the article.

Tuesday, December 10, 2024

Will Crimea Rise and Fall in Syria?

Is Russia going to be forced to abandon its bases in Syria? Because Russia's Syria adventure helped justify the prior conquest of Crimea, this is interesting.

As we digest the scale of rebel victory in Syria and any regional resistance, this is something to consider:

A scenario in which the rebels toppled [Syrian ruler] Assad would harm the Kremlin’s strategic objectives involving Africa and surrounding waterways, such as projecting power in the Mediterranean and Red Seas and threatening NATO’s southern flank. Russia’s activity in Libya and the Sahel supports its objectives of securing access in the Mediterranean and Red Sea, an undertaking that is heavily dependent upon Russia maintaining its naval base in Tartus [in Syria]. Tartus is Russia’s only formal overseas naval base, which it uses to project power into the Mediterranean for various purposes including ostensibly to counter NATO. 

That scenario took place. Will losing its Syria bases be a significant factor in Russian decisions in Ukraine? 

I noted that there is probably a link between Russia's 2014 conquest of Crimea and Russia's subsequent intervention in Syria. The combination of bases in Crimea and Syria gave Russia opportunities in the Mediterranean Sea and beyond:

Russia's moves in Crimea and Syria are complementary. Crimea is a staging area to support Russian forces based in Syria--where Russia will build a permanent naval base at their Tartus facility--which can exert control over the eastern Mediterranean, which is also bolstered by Russia's announcement (in the same article) that 5,000 paratroopers will exercise in Egypt this month (is Russia angling to re-flip Egypt, which was our Cold War coup?)

Egypt no longer seems ripe for a flipping now. Also, Russia has expanded its reach to Africa. And the war against Ukraine has limited Crimea's ability to be a staging area for its Syria bases both from Ukrainian military action and the closing of the Turkish Straits for the duration of the Winter War of 2022. A major Russian setback in Syria reduces the importance of keeping Crimea. After all, Ukraine demonstrates one can carry out an anti-access/area denial in the Black Sea without Crimea. 

And that's aside from the fact that a Russian Mediterranean flotilla would lead a short but exciting life if at war with NATO.

Still, Russia may have an alternative to Syria in Libya, although the fall of the Assad government will at least improve Libyan bargaining power--or make eastern Libyans wary of counting on Russia. Or will the new Syrian rulers make a deal with Russia despite its past bloody support for Assad? The Russians are certainly hoping a deal can be reached.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

Monday, December 09, 2024

The Winter War of 2022 Fears the New Year

The Winter War of 2022 waits for winter to settle in and fears what a new American president will do about the war. As a supporter of Ukraine's fight against Russia, I'm not pessimistic. But given the stakes, those who would risk Ukraine losing because of lack of American support should remember cutting military aid would be counter-productive and increase the risk of general war in Europe. Further complicating the new year, Russia has suddenly lost an asset as Assad's security forces collapsed in the face of a rebel offensive. How will that affect Russian alliances and internal politics?

The war goes on. Different week. Same death and destruction. And another war revived in Syria less than two weeks ago, leading to the fall of Assad, briefly distracted world attention. Will there be repercussions felt in Moscow over losing their client and prized power projection asset in the eastern Mediterranean Sea? Will Russia's other allies reconsider the value of Russian support?

Conservatives are divided on aiding Ukraine and those who oppose it seem to focus on Russia's threats to escalate up to nuclear war if we don't stop the aid: 

Escalation is not a one-way street, yet these critics ignore the bigger half of the issue – constant Russian aggression – to focus narrowly and unfairly on Ukraine.

Do read it all. Critics on the right agree on escalation fear with Democrats who have limited our help to Ukraine. Acting on that escalation fear is a huge mistake. It is essentially adopting a "let the Wookie win" strategy.

If America cuts aid to Ukraine, a number of European NATO states will continue to supply Ukraine because they know they are on Putin's list of former vassals to bring back into Holy Mother Russia. So NATO states will continue to aid Ukraine on their own.

The problem is that it won't be as effective in quantity or quality, and so gives Russia more of a chance to win. Indeed, Russia's chance could be much higher if Ukrainian troops get discouraged and believe they are doomed with only European support. Unless Europe replaces much of American aid by purchasing American weapons and munitions for Ukraine, those European NATO states may escalate their role in the war in ways that push Putin to escalate in reality rather than in rhetoric and sabotage. 

Once Russia is clashing with European NATO states overtly, you can be sure Russia will believe America is the puppet master behind the European effort despite American protests that it is trying to stay out and negotiate peace. And with that stage set, general war actually could break out.

If you think America can sit that out, you're fooling yourself. Heck, much as Hitler declared war on America after Japan attacked Pearl Harbor--pushing America into war with Germany months earlier than Congress would have decided to do so--Putin might declare war on America and attack us, feeling America will inevitably join its allies in the war.

I firmly believe keeping Russia as far east as possible reduces the cost of achieving America's long-standing objective of preventing Europe from being a platform for directly attacking America.

Again, I think Trump will find a way to sustain Ukraine without it looking like a waste of American money being given to Ukraine for no visible gain as the foundation of its policy. Helping Ukraine is vital. But so is being able to afford providing that aid. The fall of Russia's client Assad should weaken Russia's reputation in at least the short run. 

I wonder if Ukraine could replicate the Syrian rebels' outreach to Christians and Druze to split them from Assad. Could Ukraine appeal to Putin's puppets in the Donbas who have bled and suffered so much attacking Ukraine? Those Donbas puppets are integrated to some extent within the Russian army. But how solid is that control?

UPDATE (Wednesday): On Substack I ask whether the Russian army will break.

UPDATE (Thursday): By 2020 the Syria multi-war had settled down in the west. Assad had endured near-defeat to win the war. But at a high cost that wrecked his military. By this month, Syria's military and people were so shaken by their costly victory that they didn't have the will to fight even against enemies with reason to be brutal in victory.

Early in the Winter War of 2022 I speculated that after Russia won a partial victory by weight of numbers, the cost of winning might deter Russia from renewing the war later. I looked to the brief  Winter War of 1939-1940 when Russia invaded Finland as a potential model. Does Assad's fate give Putin cause to worry about the effects of even a declared victory at high cost in Ukraine?

UPDATE (Thursday) What is Russia going to do? Invade Ukraine and kidnap and brainwash Ukrainian children?

Russia said on Wednesday that Ukraine had struck a military airfield on the Azov Sea with six U.S.-made ATACMS ballistic missiles, a move that could prompt Moscow to launch another experimental intermediate-range hypersonic missile at Ukraine.

Nearly three years after Russia marched into Ukraine expecting little resistance, the Russians are still apparently shocked that Ukraine fights back.

NOTE: ISW updates continue here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.