Sunday, January 12, 2025

Weekend Data Dump

I post at The Dignified Rant: Evolved on Substack. Help me out by subscribing and by liking and sharing posts. I continue posting here on TDR seven days a week, including Weekend Data Dump and Winter War of 2022. I occasionally post short data dump-type items on my Substack "Notes" section.  

Nobody there is even nominated for Queen of the Victim Prom: "Rebel forces backed by Rwanda have captured the town of Masisi in the east of the Democratic Republic of Congo, according to various reports." So the sainted international community won't bestow Palestinian-level focus and aid upon them.

Good: "A major Ukrainian metal and mining company that makes so-called cope cages for the country’s tanks and fighting vehicles says it has installed a new armor protection system on at least one of Ukraine’s operational high-end air defense systems[.]" In Vietnam we used vehicle- and ground-based RPG screens.

Sea power: "The Turkish navy has begun the new year by announcing the construction of three warships based on domestic designs: a submarine, an aircraft carrier and the lead ship of the highly anticipated TF-2000 air-defense destroyer series." A quasi-empire needs a fleet.

They sure do try: "Russia has abandoned its 29-ton twin engine Su-57 Felon project after only 32 prototype and pre-production aircraft were built. This was another effort to build a stealth fighter to match the American F-22 and F-35." The Su-75 Plan B isn't likely to move into production.

Ukraine's aerial drones extend their reach: "The longer range drones enable Ukraine to strike targets deep inside Russia. These attacks now include drones dropping guided bombs from one kilometer altitude. This way the bombs can glide for long distances and strike Russian targets unexpectedly."

Trump must avoid getting sucked into the Winter War of 2022. Fair enough. But Trump must also avoid getting sucked into enabling--by excusing or even welcoming it--Russia's conquest of Ukraine. 

Where the Air Force fears to tread: "The primary role of the MDACS is to defend stationary and semi-stationary positions [using hypersonic shells] from attacks by drones, cruise missiles, aircraft, and helicopters."

Sadly, Britain is only deploying the division headquarters for a NATO exercise. My dream of the British Army of the Vistula remains just that. 

Britain counts on distance from Russia and allies in the way: "Britain’s government is gambling that allies care more about its defence than it does. An odd definition of leadership." I feel your pain, buddy. Dress it up as "leading from behind" but you only fool yourself.

CDR Salamander highlights China's D+0 cyber capabilities against the West. I noted this 20 years ago: "The Chinese should also initiate cyberwarfare against Taiwan on a massive and continuing scale and small attacks against the US, Japan, and European countries that end within a few hours [as a warning]."

Trudeau has resigned as leader of his party, but because of the parliamentary system will remain prime minister until a replacement is chosen. He is a special sort of awful. Best wishes to our neighbor and ally going forward.

Yeah: "Some seem to think that Trump’s return is the spur Europe needs to finally stand on its own two feet. But they need to recognise, as was the case during the Second World War and the Cold War, that only a strong alliance between Europe and the US offers any hope of resisting [a rising China-centric axis.]"

The last tango at sea: "For years, A-10s have been patrolling over the Persian Gulf as part of a multinational maritime security initiative." Last month I noted a similar deployment to the Philippines. While I'm a fan of the A-10, my real concern is the loss of the skill set that made the A-10 effective.

This is weird and disturbing: "A standoff between rival government forces outside the presidential compound in South Korea has been startling even for those used to the country’s famously rough and tumble politics."

New York Army National Guard troops are heading to Djibouti; and Pennsylvania Army National Guard troops are heading to Iraq. The use of the National Guard as an operational reserve rather than a strategic reserve continues.

How many Americans still believe Russia had nothing to do with starting the Korean War? "[In] the 1990s, the Russian government released telegrams sent before 1960, by Russian and North Korean leaders, making it clear that Russia wanted the invasion, and that North Korea duly carried it out."

If the campaign against the Houthi is testing the ability of the systems and crews in Navy Combat Information Centers that wield a ship's combat capabilities, how will they fight a war against China? But perhaps then the first line of ship defense would be destroying the enemy missile launchers.

They should have been executed as unlawful combatants long ago: "The Pentagon said Monday it had transferred 11 Yemeni men to Oman this week after holding them for more than two decades without charge at the U.S. naval base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba."

The war on [Islamist] terror is not over: "F-16s and F-15s carried out airstrikes against ISIS fighters operating in Iraq’s Hamrin Mountains. U.S. Air Force A-10s, which were called in to support ground forces, were successful in killing Islamic State militants fighting in the cave, the command said."

China wages war on Taiwan: "A Chinese-owned cargo ship suspected of damaging a subsea telecoms cable off Taiwan has stopped transmitting its location on the high seas, Taiwan's coast guard said Tuesday." It's not the explodey sort, but it's war. 

I let my membership lapse after seeing how left-wing it was at the 1991 AHA national convention. Skip forward to today: "The American Historical Association passed a resolution condemning Israel and proceeded to break out in chants of 'free, free Palestine' over the weekend." Tip to Instapundit. 

Why couldn't America reduce its military "aid" to Ukraine by having Europeans unable to produce the needed equipment purchase a portion of American military equipment, ammunition, and assistance for Ukraine? Total military assistance from America wouldn't change--just the burden of paying for it.

North Korea test fired an intermediate range ballistic missile.

Just going to note that the Persian Gulf is also called the Arabian Gulf; part of the South China Sea is also called the West Philippine Sea; and the Sea of Japan is also called the East Sea. Disputes are not uncommon. Also, a name does not convey ownership. Calm down.

To resist Russia's invasion, America and its allies have given Ukraine "more than $126 billion in weapons and military training and assistance." America has provided $66 billion of that.

The war on terror continues: "U.S. forces helped evacuate Somali troops from harm’s way during a recent operation against insurgents that resulted in the deaths of 10 militants from al-Shabab, U.S. Africa Command said Tuesday."

Drones firing drones: "Ukraine has claimed that it’s successfully used uncrewed surface vessels (USV), better known as drone boats, to launch aerial drones against Russian targets for the first time." 

Perhaps Hezbollah is weakened enough to make this not futile: "The Biden administration in its final days is shifting more than $100 million in military aid from Israel and Egypt to Lebanon as it tries to bolster a ceasefire agreement it helped mediate between Israel and Hezbollah."

A line in the sea: "The United Kingdom is leading a Joint Expeditionary Force (JEF) and NATO effort to track Russian 'Shadow Fleet' vessels in Northern European waters, in real time, to protect critical undersea infrastructure, the United Kingdom’s defense minister announced Monday." 

That seems less than optimal: "Taiwan began three days of military drills on Tuesday as concerns rose over potential cuts to the defense budget due to legislative wrangling between the island’s two major political parties." The article highlights criticism of Taiwan's new Abrams tanks. I vigorously dissent.

The Australian Roadrunner suicide drone designed to take down aircraft, helicopters, and other drones. American special forces have purchased it. Huh.

Why isn't Britain being condemned by global human rights groups and pursued by the International Criminal Court for this failure to protect so many victims? I remain dumbfounded that feminists aren't the most committed anti-Islamist warriors. Tip to Instapundit.

If you can't put boots on the islands China wants, China will take them: "Navies across the Asia-Pacific region are boosting amphibious capabilities in an effort to protect their complex coastlines, as China continues its flex its military muscle in the region."

Your moment of cat zen:


Service in the Army did not radicalize Shamsud-Din Jabbar, the New Orleans terrorist. But that belief marinating in anti-military circles surfaces so easily. How fun! Now do Islam, about which the default view here is always "why do they hate us", as if we did something to provoke the murderous hate. 

China's recent attacks around Taiwan and in the Baltic Sea to destroy underwater conduits either indicates China is not as vulnerable to losing use of the seas or indicates the Chinese fear no retaliation, or indicates the Chinese are just being self-destructive. Perhaps an Alignment of Upheaval right now.

Buh bye: "Moscow no longer appears to have any attack submarines in the Mediterranean Sea after NATO forces spotted its last known submarine leaving the region last week." That's for the best, really. Russia's flotilla would lead a short but exciting life in a war with NATO.

Milley authorized the use of directed-energy weapons against rioters in June 2020 Washington, D.C. unrest. This is not a scandal. I may not like Milley much, but these less-lethal weapons (don't call them non-lethal) can send rioters running for home without the casualties of rifle fire or batons. Via Instapundit.

Blowback: "Finnish President Alexander Stubb will host a summit in Helsinki of the NATO countries that border the Baltic Sea together with Estonian Prime Minister Kristen Michal next Tuesday." Putin is Russia's worst enemy.

Turkey wants official United Nations recognition of the portion of Cyprus that Turkey took over in 1974, and which declared its independence in 1983.

Ah, a quarter century of the F**k-Up Fairy dragging Russia into the abyss! 

Ef that: "The objective should not be the total defeat of Russia—a nuclear-armed state—but its transformation into a pivot power that seeks to balance its interests between Washington and Beijing." Beat Russia down with the Clue Bat until it accepts it's smarter to defend their Far East than attack NATO.

Turkey may invade Syria: "Turkish efforts to interdict SDF supplies may be a precursor to a wider operation, especially if these interdiction strikes attempt to strike deeper behind the front line." The Turkish foreign minister said Turkey would attack Kurdish units if they don't let HTS absorb them.

Security: "Since the 1940s, the Pentagon has valued Greenland, which serves as a gateway to the Arctic. During the Cold War, the military had more than 10,000 troops in its territory, which hosts Pituffik Space Base, formerly known as Thule Air Base." China claims the fake status of a "near-Arctic" state.

How China's Great Firewall cracked during the Covid-19 lockdowns. Also, Russian and Chinese propaganda efforts.

But counter-measures are still weak: "Starting in 2023 the proportion of casualties inflicted by drones in the Ukraine war soared to more than those inflicted by artillery, and in 2024 an outright majority of all casualties have been inflicted by drones." Am I wrong about how FPV drones will eventually fit in?'

The cheese-eating surrender monkeys go all Patton on a fake threat: "French foreign minister Jean-Noel Barrot suggested moves on [Greenland] would be an attack on the European Union." Guess what threat the French ignore? And FFS there will be no American Anschluss with any unwilling party.

The Burke is a mature and successful design--but of course: "The U.S. Navy’s Flight III Arleigh Burke (DDG-51) class destroyers are facing cost increases and delays, jumping from an average of $2.1 billion per ship to $2.5 billion per hull, with even steeper cost increases coming in the future[.]" Eh, it'll be fine! 

For no particular reason, let's review who can wage war under our Constitution. Remember that prior to Hitler declaring war on America that America waged an undeclared "gray zone" naval war on Germany in the Atlantic. So it isn't as clear as you may believe.

True: "The year 2027 is just a year. We should remain watchful as it approaches, lest the prophets of automatic warfare prove correct, but we should neither relax our guard in the meantime nor resign ourselves to a certain clash of arms." And timely.

Europeans are our friends. The European Union is not: "Rattled by the rise of populism, and their authority rotting from within, Europe’s supposedly ‘sensible’, self-described ‘centrist’ leaders have resorted to ever-more authoritarian means to keep their grip on power." A reason for America to lead.

Where's the global human rights "community" that cares so much more than you or I do? #MeToo #NotYou. Tip to Instapundit.

Defending freedom of navigation: "[Navy] forces, which were not identified, struck two Houthi underground Advanced Conventional Weapon storage facilities in Yemen, according to the Wednesday news release."

I have little doubt these are intended to help Finland if Russia invades Sweden's ally: "Sweden is purchasing 44 new German Leopard 2 A8 main battle tanks and plans to modernize its existing fleet of 66 Leopard 2 tanks as well as other combat vehicles in its military arsenal[.]" 

In harm's way: "Taiwan on Thursday demonstrated its sea defenses against a potential Chinese attack as tensions rise with Beijing, part of a multitiered strategy to deter an invasion from the mainland." 

Don't pretend the war on terror is over because we "ended" the Afghanistan campaign (by losing it, to be clear): "The Islamic State has evolved and expanded globally since the territorial defeat of IS in Iraq and Syria in 2019, enabling the organization to continue to orchestrate and inspire attacks on the West."

Fingers crossed: "As Côte d’Ivoire’s relations with its former colonial master have continued to deteriorate, culminating with last week’s decision to expel the 600 French troops in the country, the United States has increasingly stepped into the breach." The region needs resilience to kill jihadis.

Isn't this a big Chinese middle finger to Russia? "Serbian defense authorities announced that the Chinese-made FK-3 air defense systems are now in service with the Serbian Air Force, marking a success for Beijing[.]" Serbia should be cautious lest China declare it is a "near-Balkans" state.

We focus on a boat-load of cruise missiles, but the class has always has a special operations capability: "The U.S. Navy’s Ohio class guided missile submarine USS Michigan made notable use of uncrewed underwater vehicles (UUV) in the course of operations between October 2022 and January 2024[.]"

This seems like a no-brainer. Why is it delayed? "The U.S. Navy has long eyed a return to a cavernous former Royal Norwegian Navy base that could serve as a convenient support point for submarine operations in the Arctic." 

Well that's fun! "Several European leaders have cautioned Donald Trump against violating the sovereignty of other NATO allies across the continent, following comments by the U.S. president-elect that did not rule out using military force to annex Greenland’s territory." Now do Islamist fanatics. But that's not safe.

The race between Chinese anti-ship ballistic missiles and hypersonics on one side, and American SM-3 and ship-mounted Army Patriots on the other. China works hard to target our ships. Don't forget that breaking China's kill chain starts with destroying the missiles on the ground before they launch. 

Fingers crossed: "Donald Trump's media genius strikes again, this time calling national and international attention to two slowly developing but strategically treacherous threats to North America's military and economic security: [defending the Arctic and maintaining use of the Panama Canal.]" It sure got attention!

This is needed: "The U.S. Air Force’s F-15E Strike Eagle and F-15EX Eagle IIs are now set to be armed with the AGM-158C-1 LRASM (Long Range Anti-Ship Missile), allowing the Air Force’s assets to engage surface targets at sea." That gets TDR stamp of approval!

Corruption is a weapon: "The recent, high-profile case of Alice Guo—a former mayor accused of graft, money laundering, and espionage—shows how domestic corruption leaves the Philippines vulnerable to Chinese infiltration and subterfuge." 

Per the Pentagon, America is exploiting the sudden east Syria power vacuum: "When you saw the fall of Assad, you saw Russian assets further consolidate, which allowed U.S. Central Command to take actions in the Badiya desert and elsewhere where we hadn't previously done a significant amount of strikes[.]" 

A Taylor Swift super fan lacks resolve? "While Trudeau has made some noteworthy pronouncements about Canada’s role in the world, his actual record reveals a profound failure to safeguard Canadian sovereignty and support the Canadian Armed Forces." No! Way! There is a way forward. 

Putin said that if America takes over Greenland that it justifies Russian expansionism. LOL. Putin should worry about the precedent he is setting for Chinese claims on Russia's Far East. Putin is a moron clearly being guided by the F**k-Up Fairy.

Afghanistan faces a complex set up challenges in 2025? No, the challenge is pretty simple: the Taliban. And FFS, America shouldn't subsidize the Taliban rule. Let their new friends in Pakistan and China fund them.

Shut up, the European Union said: "Will the EU sacrifice the American market and estrange itself from its military defender for the sake of content moderation?" Of course it will. I firmly believe that without American influence--whether NATO or Musk--continental Europe will drift back to its autocratic history.

Good grief people, being not-Assad doesn't make the new Islamist rulers good guys. I suspect Europeans will reward HTS and the other jihadis as long as refugees don't flow from Syria into Europe.

Interesting: "Iran is increasing its military presence in Venezuela, with officials and personnel, with some members of the country's elite acquiring properties in the Latin American country and being offered political asylum should they eventually need it." If Iran goes down, will the open door for exile close?

Britain's Labor government sent volunteers to help Harris in the recent campaign. And I guess bad habits from impressing American sailors live on: "The UK government has tasked its 'Counter-Extremism' unit with investigating billionaire Elon Musk following his sharp criticism of Prime Minister Keir Starmer."

Stopping NATO, Nazis, and Satan himself wasn't enough reason to end business as usual: "The 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine failed as a military effort but was successful at creating many new opportunities for corruption. This included Russians of all types." The cogs notice.

Cogs with doubts: "The war in Ukraine has cost the Russian military over a million soldiers dead, disabled or fled the country. Several million more military age men have left the country or gone into hiding while still in Russia. There are labor shortages everywhere." Employers help employees evade military service.

Trump's hyperbolic language certainly raised this vital issue: "Denmark acknowledged on Thursday it had long neglected the defence of Greenland, a vast and strategically important Arctic island, after President-elect Donald Trump said acquiring the Danish sovereign territory was vital for U.S. security."

The sainted international community doesn't care about those people because they aren't Palestinian terrorists: "More than 100,000 people have been displaced since the start of the year in eastern Congo as a result of a new rebel offensive, according to a United Nations report released Friday." 

Sh*t got real: "Germany's Bundeswehr will establish a major new land forces unit dedicated to securing critical infrastructure and key military facilities across the country, an army spokesman said on Saturday." It's a blend of active and reserve troops. 

The Philippines is upgrading two ports and an airfield in the Spratly Islands. Hopefully the Philippines defends them lest it is just upgrading a future conquest by China. 

Notwithstanding closer ties to China, China is the biggest sovereignty threat: "Indonesia will expand its existing defence partnerships and step up its handling of strategic issues impacting its sovereignty, including maritime security and the safety of sea passage and fisheries, its foreign minister said[.]"

I'm starting to think America should grant any family in Great Britain that includes young girls immediate refugee status based on a fear of imminent harm. Tip to Instapundit.

America's presence helps keep disputes limited to ballots and not bullets: "There are early indications that some Iraqi Sunni and Kurdish politicians are trying to build an alliance ahead of the Iraqi parliamentary elections in October 2025. Such an alliance would challenge the Iranian-backed Shia parties[.]"

I never trust the media when it calls a European party "fascist" or "neo-Nazi" because a major success of the left has been to hide the fact that Hitler was a socialist. Remember, communism is the last stage of socialism building toward that withering away of the state and its gulags. A stage we've never seen. 

New French suicide drones to Ukraine and a review of how Ukraine uses French Caesar artillery pieces.

Combat fatigue (PTSD), desertions, and temporary AWOL in the Winter War of 2022 affect Ukrainians and Russians. Political fatigue affects nations supporting Ukraine. I will note that Russia might have more combat fatigue problems if more of their troops survived their tour of duty invading Ukraine.

Iraq still fights ISIL: "The Iraqi Army and Popular Mobilization Forces (PMF) launched an operation targeting the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) in the Hamrin Mountains, Diyala Province. The Iraqi Air Force conducted an airstrike on January 10 that killed four ISIS members."

Iraq reinforces border defenses: "Iraqi security forces have extended the border wall between Iraq and Syria by 83 kilometers, increasing the total length of the wall to around 400 kilometers. Iraq seeks to extend the wall by another 215 kilometers." ISIL's revival could pave the way for Iranian influence.

If North Koreans knew, that will hurt Kim Jong Un: "The [North Korean] POW told Ukrainian authorities that he had undergone coordination training with Russian forces for only one week before deploying to combat and that he thought he was going to a training exercise in Russia, not to the war in Ukraine."

Human waves: "The Washington Post reported on January 11 that North Koreans fighting in Kursk Oblast are attacking in large groups with support from Russian artillery and drones, unlike Russian forces who usually move in smaller groups." To be fair, they aren't intended to return home.

Saturday, January 11, 2025

For Want of a Nail, the Kingdom Was Lost

Advanced aircraft are worthless if peppered with shrapnel by much cheaper weapons. Why are cheaper counter-measures neglected?

We got used to having a sanctuary even that close to China: 

Chinese missile attacks on Air Force runways at bases in the Indo-Pacific region would severely limit U.S. military power in a future regional conflict, according to a report by military researchers made public Thursday.

Key U.S. air bases in Japan and elsewhere in the region until recently were safe havens from enemy attack and provided rapid power projection with airstrikes for more than three decades, the report by the Stimson Center said.

Rapid advances in Chinese missiles and aircraft put these bases in danger. But we haven't reacted. 

We need hardened aircraft shelters, air defenses, and rapid runway repair capabilities. And we need more bases rather than jamming units into few vulnerable bases to check that "pivot to Asia" box.

And as long as we're in the western Pacific neighborhood, I worry about strategic tunnel vision and our forward-deployed ships, too. 

UPDATE: More on the issue:

Pouring concrete to make hardened shelters for aircraft on the ground may not be as sexy as building next-generation fighter jets, but it may be just as important for the U.S. in a potential conflict with China, according to airpower scholars.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Friday, January 10, 2025

"Robot Man" Won't Be a Thing

"Tank Man" who briefly slowed down the slaughter of pro-democracy protesters in Tienanmen Square by PLA troops in 1989 wouldn't stand a chance against robotic enforcers. The tank crews hesitated to kill an unarmed man. Would any man simply choose to stand in the way of robots without souls to trouble?

China has robot police prototypes out in the streets (tip to Instapundit):

Chinese robotics company Logon Technology unveiled the RT-G autonomous spherical robot in a "technological breakthrough" the other month.

And despite people believing it was all a bizarre marketing stunt, RT-G bots have actually been spotted the streets of China alongside human cops.

Footage shows one of the beast balls rolling round a city, carefully patrolling for any potential crime that could occur.

The spheres are designed to assist - and eventually replace humans - in dangerous environments and situations involving crime.

It is designed to be armed and to withstand blunt force blows.

There will be no "tank man" willing to stand up to killer robots programmed to maintain the Chinese Communist Party's monopoly of political power in China.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Thursday, January 09, 2025

Where Are the Carriers?

As much as I think we rely too much on carriers for sea control, they remain a massive part of our naval power. Losing them would hurt our sea war. And perhaps shake our morale seeing them burn. Could an enemy neutralize them before they even get to sea.*

 

America's carriers are concentrated in home ports much more than I'm comfortable with. 

Nimitz                    Kitsap-Bremerton.
Reagan                   Kitsap-Bremerton.

Vinson                    South China Sea (San Diego)
Roosevelt               San Diego
Lincoln                   San Diego

Washington            Yokosuka

Eisenhower            Norfolk.
Stennis                   Norfolk
Truman                  Red Sea (Norfolk)
Bush                       Norfolk
Ford                       Norfolk

[Eisenhower is to retire in 2028. Nimitz is scheduled for decommissioning in 2026]

My worry about a Pearl Harbor isn't solely about new, expensive high-tech weapons. Although at least this attack option seems to be more widely appreciated today.

Even low-tech numbers using suicide drones from within are a potential threat. 

Just as formerly safe forward bases are at risk, CONUS is no longer a sanctuary during war. Or during the minutes of "peace" before we realize we're at war. Perhaps it is time to spread our carriers out one per home port to complicate enemy attack plans and to mitigate the damage done in a surprise attack. More facilities would be useful in a war, too.

We seem to have forgotten Pearl Harbor. Oh sure, we remember the attack. But we treat it as tragic history rather than a relevant lesson. We act like it can't possibly happen again. But enemies find a way despite our assumptions.

*Optimist that I am, perhaps like the 1941 Pearl Harbor attack that crippled our battleship fleet--and prevented them from being sunk at sea with the total loss of ships and crews--putting our super carriers at the bottom of a port with minimal loss of life might be a blessing in disguise. Their air wings would at least survive to fight from land bases.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Wednesday, January 08, 2025

My Appreciation of French "Sophistication" Continues to Elude Me

I'm no expert on French domestic politics. And I freely admit I lack a proper appreciation of nuance. But France seems to have a huge problem that it studiously ignores.

Ah, those sophisticated French and their New Year's Eve traditions to welcome the birth of 2025: 

Despite nearly 1,000 cars being set ablaze, hundreds of thousands of people in France welcomed the New Year with largely peaceful celebrations, according to Interior Minister Bruno Retailleau.

Retailleau announced late on Wednesday that 984 cars went up in flames across the country. Some 420 people were arrested, 310 of whom were taken into police custody.

It's largely peaceful! Barely literally fiery at all! 

Pay no attention to those people of unknown origin and belief setting cars ablaze in the suburbs! All is well in central Paris! The threat is nowhere near the the Champs-Élysées!

Details on the likely culprits are revealingly sparse in that article about the mysterious motivation of the people setting cars ablaze. But we do know they sure do hate the cars!

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Tuesday, January 07, 2025

Georgia Not On Our Mind

America stymied Russia's attempt to recapture Georgia in 2008, which it lost in the collapse of the Soviet Union. Russia has been patiently working to reverse that defeat and complete the conquest with internal allies rather than military invasion. Is the West going to let Russia succeed without doing anything?

Georgia is sliding back into Russia's orbit: 

There is now little doubt that the October election was fraudulent. Yet the response of Western governments has been strangely muted. ... 

The reasons for Georgia’s authoritarian turn have a lot to do with domestic politics—and specifically the rise of Georgian Dream, a vehicle for the political ambitions of the billionaire Ivanishvili, who made his fortune in Russia. Since it came to power in 2012, Georgian Dream has slowly but steadily pursued a course toward authoritarian rule that now appears on the verge of culmination. Yet the West, once so eager to champion Georgia’s struggling democracy, has retreated into passivity.

Russia practiced its invasion before the well-telegraphed invasion. And we are blowing our under-appreciated efforts during Russia's 2008 invasion to keep Russia out.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: Image from here.

Monday, January 06, 2025

The Winter War of 2022 Staggers Across the 2024 Line

Ukraine still stands in 2025. That is an achievement despite the loss of lives and territory and despite the disappointing but much-heralded summer 2023 counteroffensive. One thing the lengthy Russian war to conquer Ukraine despite its own massive casualties should teach the West is that Russia wants land and people more than it wants Western friendship. Stop pretending the right deal will satisfy Russia's imperial ambitions and make Russia our friend.

The war goes on in Ukraine as 2025 begins. The basic story hasn't changed much for many months. Russia bombards Ukraine's cities while on the ground it grinds forward at the cost of huge casualties and equipment losses while its economic machine is also leaking fluids and popping rivets; while troop-starved Ukraine attacks Russian logistics from the air (mostly drones) and at sea (mostly with sea drones). 

Ukraine's brief admittedly impressive counteroffensive into Kursk in the latter part of 2024 evolved into one more part of Russia's costly ground grind. Ukraine seems to have renewed their attack, but so far the scale, objective, and intended duration are unclear:

Ukraine has launched a fresh offensive in Russia's Kursk region, the Russian defence ministry says.

As the completion of three years of war nears, war weariness is growing. It is most evident in NATO and Ukraine, but have no doubt it exists in Russia, too. The West should seek to increase the weariness in Russia to gain victory to stop Russia in Ukraine before it moves further west. Stop Russia hard enough, now, and maybe Russians will be willing to face up to the real threat to Russia's survival as a great power rather than conceal its appeasement of China by threatening NATO, which was no military threat until Russian aggression provoked a response.

NATO did not provoke Russia's centuries-old imperial ambitions: 

The Russian Federation is a top-down imperialist power.  In its current form, the systemic nature of this empire offers no path forward for the West to reach a lasting modus vivendi with Moscow.  Russia can be blocked and contained, as it was during the half-century of the Cold War, but until a fundamental systemic change occurs inside Russia that would begin to transform its political culture, the idea of turning Russia into a responsible stakeholder in the international system by satisfying its current demands will remain a pipedream.

Exactly. 

And remember there is no logical limit to Russia's ambitions in the west. Let's focus on America's need for a buffer in Europe. A buffer built not on conquest but on the willing cooperation of partner countries who fear Russia's brand of a buffer of crushed vassals.

Russia's armed forces were once parked on the Elbe River within striking distance of the Rhine. It may seem crazy to think Russia could advance that far through NATO when its first step could be very small. But Russia's empire was built over centuries. Just because much of Russia's empire was lost in only two years doesn't mean the revival of that threat can only be measured in that short time frame.

For some parting advice, this author states it well:

For now, we must kill the idea that Putin is “winning” the war. It has been a colossal failure. The tragedy is the West may be about to reward Putin with enough territory for him to claim otherwise, turning defeat into victory.

Who will decide--whether by choice or events--it is not up to another lap of war into 2026?

UPDATE (Monday): I'm not sure of the scale of Ukraine's attacks in the Kursk salient. The initial August 2024 attack seemed much smaller than it was. But that may have been disinformation based on counting just the initial assault elements of a much larger force poised to join the attack.

UPDATE (Monday): Minds greater than mine have no idea what Ukraine is doing in the Kursk salient, what the objective is, or what else is planned.

UPDATE (Tuesday): Thoughts on ending the war and preparing for when Russia resumes its invasion.

UPDATE (Wednesday): ISW shows more Russian initiative in the Kursk salient than Ukraine. Ukraine's attacks (recon?) in the Kursk salient seem to have petered out or achieved its objective--whatever that was.

UPDATE (Wednesday): Looking ahead to 2025 potential developments. Which rely on this assessment:

Putin understands that Russian citizens and the Russian government continue to support his war on Ukraine, and they are fully committed to the Russian war machine.

The cogs continue to show up to replace the shattered cogs that have been chewed up in that war machine--until they don't. And Trump's decisions will matter a lot.

UPDATE (Wednesday): Hmmm:

Dozens of clashes had been reported earlier in the Kursk region. The General Staff said at least 94 battles had taken place in over the previous 24 hours in an operation it said was aimed at "preventing an enemy offensive in the Sumy region" on the Ukrainian side of the border with Kursk.

Is this a spoiling attack to interrupt a new Russian offensive?

NOTE: ISW updates continue here. Also, I put war-related links and commentary in the Weekend Data Dump.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War and the related Syria events in this post.

NOTE: You may also read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing, after rewording the request to get around whatever "unsafe" image they thought I was asking for. God save us from the algorithms.

Sunday, January 05, 2025

Weekend Data Dump

I post at The Dignified Rant: Evolved on Substack. Help me out by subscribing and by liking and sharing posts. I continue posting here on TDR seven days a week, including Weekend Data Dump and Winter War of 2022. I occasionally post short data dump-type items on my Substack "Notes" section.  

This too shall pass. Tip to Instapundit.

Rising tensions with China are fueling American interest in revising issues around the Panama Canal.

Former President Carter passed away last Sunday. His death at a ripe old age is to be mourned, of course. I am disappointed he was our president and relieved he served only one term. His post-presidency charity efforts obscured his quiet help for enemies of America. He was an awful man and president.

Rising sun: "The Japanese Cabinet on Friday approved a record [$55 billion]) defense budget for 2025 as Japan accelerates building up its strike-back capability with long-range cruise missiles and starts deploying Tomahawks to fortify itself against growing threats from China, North Korea and Russia."

That's 3.3% of GDP: "Finland’s conservative-led government has unveiled a broad plan to lift defense spending from $6.8 billion in 2025 to $11.5 billion in 2032." 

Old Air Force proposals to base offensive nukes on the Moon. To be fair, having nukes 2-1/2 days from American soil rather than 20 minutes would complicate an enemy first strike. 

To maintain the pace of strikes on Hamas that used accumulated pre-war intelligence on targets, Israel had to use artificial intelligence to generate new targets fast enough. You'd need AI for a high-tech phalanx.

That can't be good: "Chinese hackers that gained access to U.S. telecommunications networks in a sweeping cybersecurity breach were able to use their positioning to geolocate millions of individuals and record phone calls at will[.]" Via Instapundit.

But China believes we'll defend our allies? "[Censorship suggests] despite [Covid 19] ultimately killing more than 1.2 million Americans and over 7 million people worldwide, there was still an overriding interest in the administration to downplay the Chinese responsibility for the pandemic." Via Instapundit.

Not pining to renew the bro-mance: "North Korean leader Kim Jong Un vowed to implement the “toughest” anti-U.S. policy, state media reported Sunday, less than a month before Donald Trump takes office as U.S. president." His new friend Putin would be jealous.

China's massive military build up and aggressive psychological warfare.

Rule of law: "Law enforcement authorities in South Korea requested an arrest warrant for President Yoon Suk Yeol after being impeached two weeks ago for his martial law decree on Dec. 3 that shook the nation."

More American security assistance to Ukraine, mostly ammunition. 

I'm skeptical when I read that European parties or politicians are fascists. I experienced too much of our media accusing normal Americans of that (your gentle host was called a "fascist" for wearing an Army uniform) to accept this without more proof. That same media praises the autocratic European Union.

Please define: "A delegation led by Ukrainian Foreign Affairs Minister Andrii Sybiha met with Syrian Foreign Affairs Minister Assad al Shaibani and Intelligence Chief Anas Khattab. Shaibani said that there will be a 'strategic partnership' between Ukraine and Syria during a press conference after the meeting."

The Arakan of Myanmar (Burma) can only dream of being crowned Queen of the Victim Prom by the sainted international community.

Russia is waging a war of sabotage against Finland and the Baltic States, especially Estonia (tip to Instapundit). You can call it "hybrid war" to avoid calling it war, but that's what it is. And if we insist on court levels of proof before treating it as a form of war, it could get much worse for Estonia and NATO.

Can American, Japanese, and South Korean submarines strangle China by blocking China's trade routes? My gut feeling is that we under-estimate China's ability to cope well enough to cope under wartime conditions.

The U.S. seeks AI to "empower decision-makers to better understand and engage with potential adversaries, optimizing strategies for deterrence and incentive-based actions." We were successful with pattern recognition to predict terrorist activity locations in the Iraq War. Can it really be scaled up?

Drones: "Despite all the remarkable innovations above, drones are not as destructively effective on the battlefield as artillery, missiles and landmines. However, drones are what captures the public imagination." Agreed. Useful? Absolutely. Silver bullets? Nope. Stop throwing panties.

"End the Cold War in Cuba"? By ending it, the author means rescuing the cruel communist dictatorship from its own incompetence. Ef that. Let the communists flee in disgrace and fear to Venezuela first. But what do you expect from a publication drawing on "social-democratic" tradition? Just proto-communists.

Basically, just how effed is Germany? Is it the fault of voters demanding this clusterf**k or leadership ignoring voters to implement the clusterf**k? And can Germany pull out of its suicide dive into the mountains? Or is the cockpit just too cozy--for now--to bother?

A Ukrainian sea drone apparently shot down a Russian helicopter. Could future warships be disaggregated in numerous manned and unmanned hulls? Damaged or destroyed components could be quickly replaced with new components. You might not reload them at sea--just replace it and send the empty one to port.

The retreat from quasi-empire continues: "Ivory Coast announced on Tuesday that French troops will leave the country after a decadeslong military presence, the latest African nation to downscale military ties with its former colonial power."

Well, Michigan defeated Alabama in their bowl game despite our depleted team. Broadly speaking, Michigan did to Alabama what it did to Ohio State with a defense-centric game plan that exploited early Alabama turnovers. Best 8-5 season ever!

The war on terror is not over: "A man intentionally drove a pickup truck into a crowd of revelers on Bourbon Street in New Orleans' French Quarter early on New Year's Day, killing 10 people and injuring dozens of others, officials said. The FBI said the driver was killed in a firefight with police."

The Strategypage annual wars update for 2024."Thanks to modern technology, especially ubiquitous access to cell phones and the Internet, any mayhem anywhere on the planet easily becomes another news item for a global audience." Still, numerous old empires try to revive their past glory.

Former imperial subjects--including Ukrainians--strenuously disagree: "While rebuilding the empire is popular inside Russia it has terrified and united the rest of Europe and led to a growing militarization effort." And Russians are suffering to restore bits of the empire in Ukraine.

Hmm: "For historical analogy, think of Russia as the equivalent to World War II Japan while China is the wealthier and more powerful Nazi Germany." I see Russia as World War II Italy because of its nostalgic obsession with imperial glory that threatens to be a drain on Chinese resources to sustain. 

China's shrinking and aging population affects the PLA: "There's also a shortage of skilled people in the armed forces. Plenty of low skilled or inept volunteers, but not the ones that are most needed, and in demand." Can China effectively use its new, shiny weapons? That's long been my question.

Is this old-school mass assaults or Russia's version of repeated small-scale waves? "North Korean troops deployed to Russia’s western border with Ukraine are conducting 'human wave tactics' on the battlefield, leading to more than 1,000 casualties within their ranks last week, a White House spokesman said[.]"

When I first heard the NOLA police chief describe the 1/1 terror attack, she seemed ... off. Seemingly perplexed that the killer would ignore clearly evident prohibitions about entering certain areas. Per Instapundit, she clearly has no business wearing a police uniform. The actual police responded bravely.

Being invaded--and some needed purges--has made Ukraine's counter-spies more effective.

Strategerski: Effing with NATO just provokes its member states to spend more to resist Russia, as Norway's experience shows. Russia invited this problem.

Link between Las Vegas and New Orleans attacks. And of course the ISIL link. That link may make it difficult to justify withdrawing American troops from eastern Syria. Tip to Instapundit.

China has illegally exerted control since 2012: "Chinese air and naval forces staged 'combat readiness patrols' around Scarborough Shoal last Sunday, marking Beijing’s final major show of strength against Manila over the disputed South China Sea maritime feature in 2024."

I hope these Navy plans to build up "joint all-domain operations" capabilities in INDOPACOM bring real capabilities soon rather than spectacular PowerPoint presentations. 

The odd situation of Ukraine subsidizing Russia's war on Ukraine by allowing natural gas to flow across Ukraine to European customers has ended with the expiration of the contract period. With this advance notice, Europe should be prepared to cope.

What could possibly go wrong? "[The] South-North Water Transfer Project" ... "aims to redistribute billions of cubic meters of water annually across one of the world's largest countries, spanning 2,700 miles." I'll go out on a limb and predict that this will "unexpectedly" create huge problems.

So-called bomb planters thought to be working with the New Orleans terrorist were curious bystanders. That makes more sense given than none of the bombs were detonated. Clearly the terrorist expected to survive longer to detonate them. Thank you police officers who rushed to the sound of the attack.

I'm assuming Russia can still build effective subs given their strategic importance: "The Russian Navy accepted the fifth in a class of advanced nuclear attack submarines that is set to be based near Norway, Moscow announced last week." They are needed to protect a SSBN bastion.

I won't joke about France. Those desertions highlight that Ukraine should have sent new soldiers to experienced brigades where they are a minority able to learn from veterans. Veteran cadres should have staffed the core of new brigades. The narrow problem of this brigade is a failure of its leadership.

Wait. What? Is ProPublica suggesting American shipyards hire illegal immigrants? Unless that is true, Trump's policy to stop illegal immigration will have no effect on Navy expansion. I never trust ProPublica and it is disturbing that Defense News uses them in their Early Bird Brief.

FPV drones had the field to themselves for a while: "An Estonian tech startup has developed a miniature missile designed to counter low-flying drones that it plans to test in Ukraine this month, as Russian drone attacks continue to cause havoc across the war-torn country." That is changing.

A bold raid to destroy an Iranian underground missile-production facility in Syria: "The raid, codenamed Operation Many Ways, was deemed an outstanding success, with the facility destroyed and none of the 120 Israeli special forces troops involved being injured."

VDH likens Germany's de-industrialization from green policies to the punitive Morgenthau Plan that was considered but never implemented by the Allies to make sure Germany was never a threat again. I made that comparison several times in 2024 data dumps. FFS, where is the clue bat?!

No! Way! "US officials were briefed on Iran's oil smuggling scheme—and mostly ignored the intel" which allowed Iran to earn billions to sponsor terrorists. But of course they did. Tip to Instapundit. 

America's challenges in 2025: "The big problems are so pervasive, complex and entwined, they are at best mitigated, navigated or reduced." This fits well with my observation that we need to pace ourselves using military power when we go to war.

Iran's mullahs sought Allah-approved foreign glory to bolster domestic support in the face of economic problems and dissent against mullah rule. Absolute defeat in Syria and the broader defeats at the hands of Israel which is dismantling Iran's proxies has broken that glory leg of legitimacy from under the mullahs.

Can Israel exploit its victories to take persistent enemy pawns off the board for quite some time? We must let Palestinians face defeat without a foreign safety net. Decades of that net is false compassion. Defeat that forces them to accept a deal that abandons their desire to kill all the Jews is real compassion. 

What the heck is going on in South Korea? Is this resisting rule of law or upholding it?

But the EU is not "Europe": "The European reality is one of a sprawling bureaucracy held together by a series of tenuous compromises, lurching from one crisis to another. Despite the grand rhetoric, it seems Europe’s main goal has become to avoid falling apart long enough to issue another press release." Just die.

Ukraine highlights the next generation of FPV drones. It's a deja vu feeling, no?

Is the U.S. building a small base at Kobani in northeast Syria to shield the Kurds from the Turks? And is it for our troops, coalition forces, or both? Based on the way the DOD spokeswoman answered questions, I suspect we are building a base for coalition forces.

Hard target: "The Australian Defence Force (ADF) has received the final nine F-35A Lightning II aircraft, rounding out the planned fleet of 72." Australia is definitely lunge worthy.

They led an army in Europe in World War II: "Canada’s Army suffers from a severe recruitment and retention shortfall, outdated equipment, and inadequate training—crises that erode its ability to defend the nation and support NATO." I don't expect Canada to field two corps. But please don't stink on ice.

The A-10 is old: "The Air Force sent at least 39 retired A-10 Thunderbolt IIs to the boneyard in 2024, a significant increase as the service moves toward removing the aircraft from its inventory even as it recently used the planes in training exercises and in combat overseas." But it's really a matter of trust.

Preparing F-22 crews for shooting down Iranian long-range Iranian drone-style cruise missiles.

Bomb the food supply? "Strategic bombing is still difficult to carry out effectively, especially due to the lack of accurate [bomb damage assessment]. That’s why finding key targets that are few in number and difficult to repair, like power plants and Ammonium production facilities, is so important."

The end of history is over: "The USN/U.S. Navy is the most powerful in the world and has been that way for eighty years. That primacy is now threatened by the American inability to maintain an adequate number of supply and support ships for the fleet at sea." That's a problem. 

Near the end of this DOD news conference, a reporter asked if the military is doing enough to track extremism in the military given the two New Year's Day bombings by veterans. How fun! Now do Islam, which even Moslem leaders understand has an extremism problem. 

Risking war during a presidential transition is difficult to justify, as I've noted. Biden certainly has the authority to strike Iran's nuclear facilities before exiting. The transition shouldn't be safe zone. But it would have to be done with the full approval of and coordination with Trump who is coming in.

In my view Slovakia deliberately created this vulnerability by refusing to seek alternatives as a favor to Putin: "Slovakia could substantially cut its support for Ukrainian refugees in response to Kyiv's recent decision to shut off a Russian pipeline supplying natural gas to central Europe."

Sh*t got real: "Poland’s Interior Ministry is drawing up rules and regulations for evacuating civilians and national culture treasures in the event of a natural disaster or military threat." Clearly hateful "Russophobia" unrelated to history or current events.

Huh: "Russia-appointed officials in Moscow-occupied Crimea announced a regional emergency on Saturday, as oil was detected on the shores of Sevastopol, the peninsula’s largest city." Does oil protect Russia from sea drones? Can Ukraine ignite it? Can fire be focused on military target or is it a war crime?

Eye in the sky: "China has been spotted testing a new early warning and control aircraft, reportedly the KJ-3000, based on the Y-20 platform."

A Ukrainian pilot's view of the air-to-ground war. 

The drone went rogue over Ukraine so the Russians shot it down and bounced the rubble with a missile strike: "In late 2024 Russia sent one of their new Su-57 stealth fighters into Ukraine accompanied by an S-70 Okhotnik-B stealth drone." Ukraine still collected the debris.

Teetering: "Three years after invading Ukraine, the Russian defense budget has turned into a monster devastating the economy." Corruption was accelerated by war rather than reducing corruption. Note Strategypage adds information to older posts. So saying Russia is on the defensive is clearly old prose.

I'm calling BS: "The European Union will closely watch the political process developing in Syria and stand by the country if it moves toward a peaceful and open future but it will not back Syria's Islamization, Germany's foreign minister said on Friday." If the jihadis wear suits on camera, the EU will sign deals.

Just lie back and think of virtue signaling. What happens when you import invaders. National security starts at your border.

Saturday, January 04, 2025

Is Belarus Plotting to Escape Russia's Grasp?

Since the collapse of the Soviet Union, Belarus under Lukashenko has tried to balance relations between the West and Russia to preserve its independence. Since the creeping Anschluss was carried out by Russia prior to the Winter War of 2022, balance has been impossible. Will Belarus try to reverse Russia's pull and try to crawl to the West despite Russia's grip?

Last month ISW wrote that Belarus seemingly agreed to become even more deeply controlled by Russia:

The Kremlin continues to advance its strategic effort to de facto annex Belarus and further expand the Russian military’s presence in Belarus through the Union State framework. Russian President Vladimir Putin and Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko signed a new Union State treaty on security guarantees at a meeting of the Supreme State Council of the Union State in Minsk, Belarus on December 6. Lukashenko made a public appeal to Putin that Russia deploy Oreshnik ballistic missiles to Belarus under the condition that the Belarusian military-political leadership would determine the Oreshnik's targets should the missile ever launch from Belarusian territory. Putin responded to Lukashenko's request by stating that Russia could deploy Oreshnik systems to Belarus by mid-2025 on the grounds of the new Union State agreement on security guarantees and as Russia scales up the production of Oreshnik ballistic missiles. Putin noted that the new security treaty allows Russia and Belarus to use "all available forces and means" as part of Russia’s and Belarus’ mutual defense obligations.

I've long noted the creeping Anschluss, which accelerated before Putin ordered his troops to invade Ukraine in 2022.

I've also wondered if Lukashenko really is willing to submit to Russia. Could Belarus be trying to get nuclear missiles into Belarus in order to capture them? ISW certainly sees such motivation in play:

Lukashenko is likely trying to preserve Belarusian sovereignty against Moscow by advocating that Belarus control Russian weapons deployed in Belarus – an endeavor Lukashenko has historically failed at.

If Lukashenko can disarm and eject the Russians from Belarus, he could claim to have a nuclear deterrent to prevent a Russian invasion. Russia won't know for sure that his officers controlling the nuclear warheads didn't take bribes to give Belarus control.

Unless Russia knows it placed inert nuclear warheads in Belarus to avoid such a ploy, of course.

I wonder about the path Belarus is taking because it doesn't make sense that Lukashenko would volunteer Belarus to be a target for NATO nuclear weapons as a favor to Russia. And after Russia failed to decisively support Assad, how does Lukashenko judge Russia's ability to hold Belarus?

What else is going on behind the facade of brotherly solidarity?

UPDATE: Huh:

Belarusian ruler Alyaksandr Lukashenka did not apologize to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy in the days following Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, a spokeswoman for the authoritarian leader said, disputing recent comments made by Zelenskiy.

Is Lukashenko simply unwilling to openly admit this? Or is Zelensky trying to create friction between Belarus and Russia?

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Friday, January 03, 2025

Will a Short-Term Navy Plan Drive a Long-Term Decline of Super Carriers?

Commercial off-the-shelf unmanned surface vessels (USVs) will be a thousand stakes in the heart of the platform-centric sea control Navy.

The Navy's Navigation Plan seeks salvation in unmanned surface ships:

The U.S. Navy’s commitment to develop, test and field uncrewed surface vessels at an accelerated pace has profound implications for the maritime community. The need to field a hybrid fleet not at some distant time, but this decade, will likely mean that the Navy can’t wait for uncrewed surface vessels that are developed via the DoD’s often tortuous acquisition process.

What this means for industry is that commercial-off-the-shelf uncrewed surface vessels will likely receive a favorable hearing from Navy officials who increasingly recognize that the need for a hybrid fleet to emerge as soon as possible is compelling.

The Navy needs numbers in the short run, assuming this works. This would address my worry about how large surface ships survive in a kill web environment. In the long run, enemies will be able to respond in kind. And have the advantage of not worrying about ocean-spanning range. So shipyards still matter to crank out USVs like sausages.

And massing effort from many smaller unmanned ships requires a networked Navy using something like the Integrated Combat System that has a certain logical path to follow that has profound implications, indeed:

You may say that ICS-equipped escorts will be able to mass defensive missiles and systems to protect the carrier. But I doubt that the defenses could stop all the inbound missiles. Enough will evade defenses to get at least a mission-kill. Is it really worth it to use networks to defend the big platform-centric offensive carrier instead of focusing on networked offense?

How many Ford-class carriers--the pinnacle hull of a platform-centric Navy to mass effort--will be built on this path? I think far fewer will be needed for both power projection and sea control missions because sea control will be dominated by semi-expendable sea-going USVs--along with larger, more conventional ships with smaller AI-assisted crew supplemented by shore-based crew working remotely--and because power projection requirements need fewer big carriers.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.

Thursday, January 02, 2025

Long-Range Torpedoes

Missiles have longer range than torpedoes. But the ability to detect and shoot down missiles is much better. What to do? Combine their features.

The Navy has new air-launched torpedoes that keep the launching aircraft safe from fire:

The Navy has also developed accessories for its air-launched torpedoes, the lightweight Mk 54 which enables the torpedo to glide long distances before entering the water. The new accessory enables a maritime patrol aircraft to launch the torpedo from high altitude. The modified Mk 54 has pop-out wings, so the high-altitude torpedo can still be stored inside the aircraft bomb bay. When dropped, the wings pop out, an onboard computer uses GPS and tiny electric motors, to operate the wings and fins to guide the torpedo to a preprogrammed location, at which point the glide kit falls away as the torpedo enters the water and starts searching for the submarine. 

The system can also be used for naval mines. But what about anti-ship torpedoes like my suggestion for ASuROC anti-ship torpedoes fired closer to the target through the air to avoid far stronger ship air defenses.

I thought mounting them on surface-hugging missiles would achieve that by being too low for air defenses to react before the torpedo goes in the water. The Tomahawk would be a good candidate given the "U.S. Navy is aware of the fact that the Tomahawk is not the ideal anti-ship missile."

But gliding from high altitude outside of missile defenses should work against surface targets as long as the torpedo payload has a long enough range once in its element, no?

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: The image is from Boeing.

Wednesday, January 01, 2025

Land-Based Aircraft Replace Carrier Aviation in Some Locations

Have we forgotten that aircraft carriers needed for air power far from land air bases aren't as necessary where land bases exist?


Will land-based F-35s be just as much of a deterrent and combat force as carrier-based F-35s? 

The aircraft carrier remains a potent signal of American intentions — but it is not the only asset at the United States’ disposal to project hard power, should it be called on.

Recent events in the Middle East demonstrate that the F-35s deployed abroad are arguably just as, if not more important, than the capital ships on which they deploy.

And given the F-35’s capabilities, the aircraft’s presence alone should be interpreted as a signal of American fixity of purpose on par with that of the aircraft carrier.

The article is more about spreading out and sustaining the F-35 for a long struggle with the above observation almost made in passing, but the observation is one I've made well before F-35Bs and F-35Cs went to sea:

Land-based air power has always been an important part of naval aviation. Even with our total carrier dominance by the end of World War II in the Pacific, we needed to plan for an amphibious landing on Kyushu Island to establish air bases prior to the main assault on the Tokyo region.

In the context of our needing land-based air when we had fleets of carriers roaming the seas, the idea that even two carriers in CENTCOM is enough naval air power is kind of ridiculous. Why not put Navy (or Marine Corps) planes ashore in the Gulf region?

Carrier-based aircraft do have the advantage of not needing host nation permission. For punitive missions against a minor enemy, a carrier or two is enough. 

But in a major operation in CENTCOM against enemy forces ashore, carriers would need local allies for diplomatic and military support in addition to permission to use their land facilities and bases to support carrier operations. Carrier aviation would only be able to assist land-based aircraft, which would do the heavy lifting.

As long as we have that kind of host nation support in peacetime, I don't know why land-based aircraft can't be used for punitive missions. We could deploy a portion of a carrier air wing ashore even if the carrier is available.

NOTE: TDR Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

NOTE: I'm adding updates on the Last Hamas War, including the revived Syria multi-war, in this post.

NOTE: You may also like to read my posts on Substack, at The Dignified Rant: Evolved. Go ahead and subscribe to it.

NOTE: I made the image with Bing.