Monday, May 22, 2017

The Hunt for Red October

Democrats continue to hunt for Russians wearing Make America Great Again hats during the October campaign period who rigged the election for Trump. If Democrats actually learned to stand up against Russia, this wouldn't be so bad. But we know that is not the case.

Well that's nice (tip to Instapundit):

Democrat leaders at the convention used their time to deride President Donald Trump and beat the familiar drum of tying him to Russia, the Associated Press reported.

Sen. Kamala Harris told the crowd that the president is putting “Russia first, America second.”

“The world, literally the world, is counting on all of you, counting on California to reject Trump’s deception and destructiveness,” Gavin Newsom, the California Lieutenant Governor, said.

The story focused on the leadership-led "F**k Trump" chant and deranged town hall protests, but I'm more interested in the faux outrage over Russia.

I've welcomed Democrats to the "oppose Russia" camp:

But hey, I'm an optimist. I welcome my Democratic brethren into the anti-Russian camp. You are late, but I welcome you. I bet if I still had that [anti-Soviet shirt I wore as a student] I could safely wear it again.

I'm sure Democrats will still be there when the going gets rough, right?

But we all know that Democratic embrace of putting Russia second is just a cudgel to beat Republicans that would be discarded in favor of cutting defense spending, appeasing the Russians, and excusing their actions as soon as (in their wet dreams) Trump is impeached and Elizabeth Warren takes the presidential oath of office under the approving gazes of Speaker Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Schumer.

Perhaps I'd believe the Democrats if they were chanting "F**k Russia" and organizing angry protests outside of Russia's embassy and consulates.

UPDATE: Wow! Who could imagine that telling the Russians to stop that wouldn't work?

Unclear on the Concept

It's like they never heard of the MOAB:

US intelligence believes ISIS is bringing together all of its experts on chemical weapons from Iraq and Syria into a new "chemical weapons cell," according to a US official.

The cell is comprised of chemical weapons specialists from Iraq and Syria who have not previously worked together, the official added. The new unit is being set up in an ISIS-controlled area in Syria within the Euphrates River Valley, between Mayadin, Syria and the town of al Qaim, just across the Iraqi border.

Really? You guys are concentrating? Because you can't dig deep enough. You know that, right?

Actually, I think we have different weapons designed to burn up chemical agents more than scatter them. And if the ISIL chemical cell is in a more desolate area, we might try those out.

Or I suppose we might try a different approach:

On May 16, the U.S. Army Second Infantry Division’s “Iron Rangers” regiment conducted a ship-to-shore assault and counter-weapons of mass destruction (WMD) exercise with the South Korean Navy.

Carrying out such a mission kind of requires a collapsing North Korean military, of course. But this is a skill set more broadly useful, eh? Even if done from land (like from Jordan?).

While that is a nice signal to North Korea, we have a global force so I don't assume a practice in one region means the experience is limited to that command.

That area the chemical cell has formed in is the new de facto ISIL capital as Raqqa gets closer to being assaulted by US-backed forces in Syria.

Like a China in a Bull Shop

China isn't cutting Japan any slack in the East China Sea as the North Korea nuclear issue advances toward a dangerous crisis. So now we know the ground rules.

Thanks China! Way to act like you care about resolving the North Korea issue as the most pressing security issue in the region!

Japan scrambled fighter jets on Thursday after four Chinese coastguard vessels entered what Japan considers its territorial waters near disputed East China Sea islets and a drone-like object flew near one ship, Japan said.

It was the first such flight near the islands witnessed by Japanese officials, although the incident took to 13 the number of intrusions this year by Chinese coastguard ships in the contested waters, Japan's coastguard said.

So let's get those freedom of navigation operations going in the South China Sea--real ones and not innocent passage dressed up like freedom of navigation operations.

And Japan should be prepared to emplace and use their own ground-based remotely manned weapons backed by aerial drones and smart mines to destroy Chinese unmanned drones trespassing in the Senkaku Islands.

Most importantly, because the North Korea nuclear issue isn't apparently a dire enough crisis to get China to pull back on pursuing other objectives in favor of a united front to stop North Korea, let's make the North Korea nuclear issue a problem China actually cares about:

So if China won't solve America's (and Japan's and South Korea's) North Korea problem because the problem isn't bad enough from China's point of view, perhaps we need to make a problem that China does care about.

We could quietly let it be known that America will be willing to help South Korea and Japan to each match North Korean nuclear weapons warhead for warhead to deter North Korea.

I suspect that the possibility that Japan and South Korea will have nuclear arms (and if they go nuclear, Vietnam and Taiwan and perhaps others will see a green light--or at least an opportunity to get lost in the outrage directed at Japan and South Korea--to go nuclear) would be important enough to get China interested in solving a nuclear proliferation problem among potential foes of China.

Or maybe less dramatically we can exploit this:

Levels of hunger not found in other parts of East Asia persist in North Korea, according to a report from two United Nations agencies.

The Food and Agricultural Organization and World Food Program's 2017 Global Report on Food Crisis states 17 percent of the North Korean population, or 4.4 million, are in a state of "crisis, emergency and famine," Voice of America reported Thursday.

Perhaps we should just blockade North Korea and let that hunger spread until North Koreans flood across the northern border into China looking for food.

What? Is that cold-hearted? Are we supposed to care more about North Koreans than Kim Jong-Un cares as he squeezes them to afford nukes? Maybe we care more about Americans, South Koreans, and Japanese who would be the targets of North Korean nuclear weapons.

China apparently feels it can throw its weight around as usual while counting on America, Japan, and South Korea to go along with whatever China does on the faint hope that China will deal with North Korea's nuclear threats.

But hey, at least now we know what China's priorities are.

UPDATE: China can just enjoy this:

Raytheon Co and Lockheed Martin Corp are working with Japanese partners on rival projects to develop new radars that will enhance Japan's shield against any North Korean missile strike, government and defense industry sources in Tokyo told Reuters.

As long as China won't stop North Korea, Japan has the perfect justification for building missile defenses. It is just a coincidence that it would be useful against China, too.

But what can China really say given that their little psycho pet nuclear threat really does justify missile defenses?

How much is China willing to endure to protect their little loose cannon on their border?

UPDATE: I see that it is clear that China and America have different objectives in Korea:

China said on Wednesday no one had the right to bring chaos to the Korean peninsula, a day after it pushed for full implementation of U.N. sanctions against neighboring North Korea for its missile and nuclear tests and called for dialogue.

China doesn't want chaos and America doesn't want North Korean nuclear weapons. That's quite a gap to bridge.

Sunday, May 21, 2017

Weekend Data Dump

Let's save this advice: "'I'm trying to keep this apolitical but I can't help myself ... the principle that no one, no one in this country is above the law and we need a Justice Department, not an obstruction of justice department,' [Senator Elizabeth] Warren said." I guess this principle didn't apply when Obama's attorney general met Bill Clinton on her plane at an airport and, they said, only chatted about family and grandkids and whatnot. Nobody ever asked them if written or digital information changed hands, I'll note. So if Hillary Clinton does get charged over her off-the-books email system and mass purge of emails from her secretary of state days, I'll haul that quote out.

Well sure, God sides with the big battalions, and all that. But leadership is not irrelevant unless you don't care how high the body count gets and if you think your people will tolerate any level of losses.

Strategypage looks at the situations in reviving Colombia and collapsing Venezuela. I worry that Maduro will try to cope with looming collapse by going to war with the Netherlands in an effort to rally the people around a foreign threat.

The apple doesn't kill far from the tree, apparently. Ah, family businesses. Just a reminder that ISIL is not the entire world of jihadis who need to be killed. Al Qaeda is also still out there.

North Korea fired what appears to be a long-range missile with an artificially short arc, but one that landed fairly close (60 miles) from Russian territory. Why did North Korea do that? Is Russia fine with that? I'm not sure whether it would be more worrying from Moscow's point of view if the impact site was deliberate or accidental.

Well that's not good: Four Montreal airport screeners were found to have become radicalized (of the Islamist variety). So the re-screening checked out. What about anybody allowed to bypass screening?

As an aid to Democrats let me say that many Republicans don't actually like Trump. He received a smaller percentage of the primary vote than Sanders got in your primary (although I admit that in large measure that reflects the mostly 2-candidate race that you guys had--how much of that was due to Hillary-DNC collaboration you might ask), so that shows you he wasn't that popular among Republicans. But when Democrats turn the "resistance" dial to 11 on every little damn thing Trump does or says, you make it difficult for Republicans to join you in criticizing Trump. If you force a choice between Trump and your spittle-flecked ravings and black-clad rioters, the choice is easy every single time. Related thoughts that seem about right. I'll never be happy that we had the choice of a clown or a crook in 2016. But I can't be unhappy that we dodged the long history of corruption.

A mass ransomware infection has hit the world. Last year I discovered some version on my computer. Lord knows how it got there because I do not click on attachments or links from unknown (and confirmed) senders. But it never triggered. Apparently I'm not ransom-worthy. I suspect this one is state-sponsored for some purpose. Crooks would want to remain low key to encourage payment rather than freaking out the world with the scale and mobilizing intelligence agency and software company collaboration to battle the attack. (In a pre-publication update, North Korea seems behind this.)

About a week ago Syrian forces moved "toward" the Iraqi and Jordanian borders at Sabaa Biyar. The Syrians and militia allies occupied an area abandoned by ISIL as they contract to hold positions at Raqqa and points east. But towards the border is not at the border. The town is over 50 miles from the borders, FYI. For a second there, until I looked at a map, I thought this was pretty provocative move regarding Iraq and Jordan. It will be big news if Syrian forces attack American-backed militias that eject ISIL from Syrian territory, not occupying abandoned territory. (And after I write this section, pro-Syrian forces did move toward the border where Americans are and got bombed for their troubles on Thursday.)

If you wonder why jihadis, Russians, North Koreans, and probably even Canadians think America is easy to defeat.

Huh.

Wow! Eight years of hope and change were surprisingly ineffective, it seems.

Disorganized and splintered hatred is better than hatred with a territory and people to command and plunder.

Azerbaijan destroyed an Armenian Osa air defense vehicle in a disputed region that Armenia holds. Armenia hosts Russian troops.

This is why I think Republicans need a sense of urgency on enacting legislation while they have a slender Senate majority along with the House and Oval Office. Accidents, actuarial facts of life, or deranged assassins can upset the best-laid 18-month plan for legislation.

The Democrats are an eye tic away from going on about their precious bodily fluids. I wish they had been this determined to confront the Russians in the Cold War--or even just before our last presidential election.

I'll withhold judgment on maintaining the Iran nuclear deal to see if we can make Iran howl within the horrible deal (Obama gave away too much up front, remember, making ending the deal problematic on that score). But I suspect that we'd be better off ending the pretense of a deal that relies on Iran pretending not to have nuclear weapons ambitions and relies on America pretending to believe the Iranians.

I'm just going to have to accept that Peak Stupid isn't going to arrive in my lifetime. I'm not even sure how to respond to that complaint. Please keep in mind that I spent many years at the University of Michigan and live in Ann Arbor without being absorbed by the Borg Stupid. Although as one friend said of me, living here has had remarkably little effect on me. Nobody has ever accused me of being a conformist, I guess.

I'm not fully on board the idea that geography is destiny. But I'm sympathetic. Stratfor looks at the Middle East. If you fear President Trump, you might want to sign on for the view, however. So you know, I assumed interests would shape Trump's policies more than the reverse. And I will say that our foreign policy is easier with a friendly Iraq that fights rather than supports terrorism. Remember what we would have chosen if we hadn't destroyed the Saddam regime.

From the "Advice it Would Have Been Good to Give Eight Years Ago" files. So put down the pen and phone? It is good advice, mind you. Just oddly belated.

If the media-political complex is making America ungovernable, is that a bad thing if it leads to states picking up the slack on all the things that aren't national that the federal government gathered to itself over the last 90 years? And perhaps when the federal government is more restricted to truly national (and foreign) affairs, it will be able to govern as the stakes for control go down. I like having a republic. Direct democracy threatens to undermine rule of law as far as I'm concerned and just become a tyranny of the majority.

Is the UN-recognized Libyan government bringing Haftar into the government or just trying to de-fang him?

Despite being a person of the left, the new South Korean president sees South Korea and America working closely to stop North Korea. Sometimes reality narrows your options, eh?

American artillery has so far fired 6,000 rounds of smart ammo in support of Iraqi operations to take Mosul.

The Baltic states have learned a lesson from Ukraine's dependence on Russian energy by tying their electric grid to the EU just in case Russia is less than reliable. Now if only the EU would make itself less reliant on Russian energy. On the bright side, Russia's Kaliningrad exclave has electricity supply lines going through NATO territory.

The fight against ISIL in Iraq still goes on in western Anbar notwithstanding the focus on Mosul.

I see the nutjob left doesn't even want me to be able to measure when we approach Peak Stupid. I don't want to hear one more Goddamn thing about liberals being uniquely pro-science.

What will they think of next?

Rouhani won reelection as Iranian Nutball in Chief. Remember, in Iran a "moderate" is the candidate pre-screened by the nutball mullahs who doesn't randomly yell "Death to America!" in English while discussing recent rain patterns. In America, liberals are still more upset that Trump won.

I noted an article on Russia's use of 600 bloggers/social media posters and $19 million to persuade Crimeans that the Russian invaders were the good guys: "To accomplish this, social cyber attackers appealed to the pro-Russian population of Crimea by spreading rumors of hate and fear." Funny enough, the Russians are amateurs compared to what the Democrats have done here since the Trump election.

New York, where voter suppression is just okey dokey with the courts and which doesn't upset any liberals.

The planetary defense shield is up! Tip to Instapundit.

That's Quite the Dilemma Iran Has Now

I've written that I think the Iran nuclear deal is horrible. And that despite the benefits to Iran being front-loaded (nice job Obama and Kerry!), I'd rather cancel the deal than let it exist to encourage the West to pretend it is working and that Iran is contained.

But President Trump's virtual declaration of war on Iran puts the deal in a new light:

Donald Trump slammed Iran during his Saudi Arabia speech in Riyadh on Sunday.

In an address to 50 leaders from Muslim-majority countries, the president, said countries must unite to isolate Iran until the regime committed to becoming a “partner of peace.”

“From Lebanon to Iraq and Yemen, Iran funds, arms and trains terrorists, militias and other extremist groups that spread destruction and chaos across the region,” Trump said.

"For decades Iran has fueled the fires of sectarian conflict and terror; it’s a government that speaks openly of mass murder, vowing the destruction of Israel, death to America, and ruin for many leaders and nations in this very room.

By rallying the Arab world (and to a far lesser degree, the broader Moslem world) to a fight to resist Iran, Iran has a problem with the deal existing--not the West.

If Iran abides by the deal, Iran gives Trump about a decade to defeat Iran during which Iran won't have nuclear weapons.

And if Iran cheats on the deal, we will presumably call Iran on that and justify harsher measures against Iran in the alliance against Iran.

Iran thought they'd shackled America with that nuclear deal. In one speech, Iran finds the handcuffs are on them.

Now that's Smart Diplomacy.

Keep the 2% NATO Measure

I don't buy the premise of this article criticizing the 2% of GDP defense spending goal for NATO states that the measure is the sole way of deciding whether NATO is capable of defending its borders and carrying out missions:

But for all its political appeal, the 2 percent figure is fatally flawed and does not accurately capture a state’s contributions to all of NATO’s core tasks. First, 2 percent is a rather arbitrary number. Before being first endorsed in 2006 by NATO’s defense ministers, the figure surfaced in response to declining defense spending after the end of the Cold War.

Oh come on! This is asking too much of the goal. It's just the freaking starting point.

NATO staffs surely look at what is purchased by that spending to see what it can do. No offense intended, but Britain spending 2% of GDP is going to have a far more effective military than Greece with 2%--even including Britain's nuclear forces. But just getting everyone to a floor of spending is a start to that analysis.

A new complicated measure that purports to encompass everything from spending to capabilities in one measure is pointless and will just invite further gaming of the system (as Germany would like to do) by states that don't want to meet the spending floor.

And such a measure would still be misleading. Greece, for example, meets the NATO minimum not because of a special commitment to NATO common defense but because their traditional enemy Turkey (a fellow NATO member) is their neighbor. Would a Greece that excels in the new proposed  measurement really be a more reliable NATO member or just digging in to face Turkey?

And if Greece failed in the new measure of NATO commitment, would Athens alter what they are doing one bit given their objective?

Sure, the spending floor is arbitrary. And flawed even. But it is a start. And if it seems necessary, NATO could suggest a 2.5% of GDP floor.

I don't think anybody argues that meeting the floor means NATO is good to go. It just means that everyone is meeting a minimum financial burden for collective defense.

Keep it simple. Keep the spending floor measure (and increase it when met--it isn't carved in stone). And let the NATO military staffs evaluate what their militaries can do with that spending without wasting time on PowerPoint presentations outlining a new and improved measure that reduces their analysis to a single number.

UPDATE: In a discussion of defense spending waste in Germany and their failure to appreciate a vital capability, there is this conclusion:

Germany is a modern, leading industrial power. There is no excuse for Germany not spending the political capital to allow for increased defense spending to the agreed upon 2% of GDP NATO spending goal.

Yes. Rather than look for reasons not to meet the goal or measures purported to more accurately achieve the objective of the goal, just meet the damn goal.

Saturday, May 20, 2017

Let's Avoid Iraq War 3.0, Shall We?

A think tank report calls for up to 20,000 American troops to remain in Iraq after ISIL is defeated as an organized state within Iraqi territory:

“My hope is the experience of 2014 may prove that … it may be worth paying a political price for keeping U.S. forces in the country,” Mr. Brands added, regarding acceptance of a prolonged American presence by Iraqis.

Iraqi Shia will likely remain split over support for the U.S. postwar mission, while Iraqi Sunnis and Kurds will embrace the deal, since they see American forces as a necessary “balance against Iranian influence,” Mr. Edelman added.

American forces will help the internal politics by helping to ensure that disagreements are resolved by politics and rule of law rather than by guns.

With American support for this, the leader of Iraq will feel far less pressure to fire effective military leaders and replace them with loyal leaders regardless of military competence.

Restraining Iranian influence and rolling it back will be important. If we are serious about opposing Iran's regional domination ambitions, we will retain a robust force to support Iraq.

And without our presence, will the Kurds and Sunnis of Anbar want to remain within Iraq? If they leave, natural allies to oppose Iran's influence in a portion of Iraq's Shia population will be lost.

Our continued military presence will also allow us to monitor the Iraqi officer corps to avoid the surprise of mid-2014 when we discovered that a politicized officer corps was unable to lead their troops to resist the ISIL uprising across the north (on top of the earlier failure to block the western uprising).

Remember, it can take a long time to reform the military of a defeated dictator:

The Bundeswehr has taken on a spring cleaning operation. Revelations that two soldiers had been planning a "false flag" terrorist attack in Germany - and to lay the blame on asylum seekers - led to wider questions firstly about the prevalence of neo-Nazis in the German military, and then about the way the Bundeswehr deals with connections to its Nazi-era forerunner: Adolf Hitler's Wehrmacht.

Let's remain in Iraq this time.

Or did we enjoy the Iraq War and Iraq War 2.0 so much that we are eager for Iraq War 3.0?

UPDATE: From Strategypage, after ISIL comes the Iranian threat.

Executive Summary: Just Shoot Them!

Make Russian invaders without unit insignia patches Little Green Dead Men and they'll be no problem at all.

Good grief:

The Pentagon is studying gray zone conflict — otherwise known as hybrid warfare — beginning with a focus on Russia and later moving on to study Iran and China, the acting assistant defense secretary for special operations and low-intensity conflict, told members of Congress.

What is to study? Russia got away with this tactic because Ukraine was in chaos with their military in no shape to respond and uncertain as to who was the lawful authority. Stop trying to make that very specific situation some grand theory that will run circles around us!

But you already know I think we are over-thinking this hybrid stuff.

It was obvious to me early on and far from the Crimea that Russia had invaded Ukraine.

It doesn't matter if an enemy denies invading as long as we don't go along with the fiction.

Just shoot the invaders.

Hell, enemy denial is a bonus! What will they do when we shoot the little green men? Complain we are killing their troops? Which they deny are there?

Talk about analysis paralysis.

Getting China's Attention

One of the problems with getting China to use their influence and power to solve our North Korea problem is that China has never minded rattling America, Japan, and South Korea by having their little pet psycho regime threaten us.

Chinese actors remain vital for North Korea's drive for  nuclear weapons:

A team of UN technical experts and sanctions investigators issued a report in early 2017 agreeing with South Korean allegations that North Korea was not only obtaining key components and manufacturing equipment via China but also prohibited raw materials and cooperation from Chinese banks and companies to pay suppliers and hide these activities from outside scrutiny. The Chinese government still denies knowledge of these activities but the latest evidence was so detailed and well documented that China did admit it must be acted on.

(China has had a role in keeping Iran's American-made F-14s in the air, too.)

Maybe offering trade concessions to China as the carrot to the threat to attack North Korea will work.

But I think we'd get China's more enthusiastic help if we make North Korea a problem China cares about:

So if China won't solve America's (and Japan's and South Korea's) North Korea problem because the problem isn't bad enough from China's point of view, perhaps we need to make a problem that China does care about.

We could quietly let it be known that America will be willing to help South Korea and Japan to each match North Korean nuclear weapons warhead for warhead to deter North Korea.

I suspect that the possibility that Japan and South Korea will have nuclear arms (and if they go nuclear, Vietnam and Taiwan and perhaps others will see a green light--or at least an opportunity to get lost in the outrage directed at Japan and South Korea--to go nuclear) would be important enough to get China interested in solving a nuclear proliferation problem among potential foes of China.

China doesn't think it is so bad to have North Korea pointing nukes at America, Japan, and South Korea?

Well maybe America won't think it is so bad to also have Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan pointing nukes at China.

Friday, May 19, 2017

Opa!

Greece is not in good shape financially. What are China's thoughts on that?

Athens truly has their gyros in a vice these days:

Thousands of Greeks walked off their jobs on Wednesday and marched through central Athens in an angry protest against continued austerity measures being demanded by international lenders in exchange for disbursing bailout funds.

There were isolated clashes with police, but the demonstration was generally peaceful.

The strike was called by the country's main public and private sector unions a day before Greece's parliament is due to vote on reforms that would help unlock the funds from the 86-billion-euro bailout, the country's third in seven years.

In light of China's large planned investments in trade routes that reach all the way to Europe (formerly the New Silk Road but now known as Belt and Road), I bet China would love to have a secure trading outpost and naval base in Greek territory to protect the far end of their long trade lines.

With a China wielding a check book, Greece has an alternative to austerity if China is willing to pay the price to buy Greece.

I'd worry about Russia doing this, but Russia has to sell their plasma to buy a pint of vodka these days.

Or maybe Greece is about to turn the corner and leave the crisis atmosphere behind. Let's hope so.

Turning Greece into a Chinese subsidiary (and thus leaving NATO) would singe our cheese, no doubt.

UPDATE: Related information on China's interests in Europe via the Belt and Road project, including the big projects to make Greece a port of destination.

Bonus: China's efforts undermine the European Union (although the analysis says China wants a unified Europe). I just hope NATO doesn't lose Greece as collateral damage in that impact.

The Faust and the Furious

I get the feeling that by the time Turkey quits NATO it will be a mere formality rather than a great change in actual policy at the time.

The Turks are angry with Germany but are acting like they are more powerful than their actual strength justifies:

Germany's defense minister says her office has drafted a list of eight locations where it could move aircraft supporting the anti-IS mission if Turkey continues to block German lawmakers from visiting troops at the Incirlik base.

Although to be fair, it might not be that Turkey fails to appreciate the benefits of NATO common defense as much as it is that Germany (as economically successful as it is, doesn't know what its role is believing the often-resented America will defend them) provides very little of that collective defense.

Although this is encouraging on the latter issue:

The German Air Force this month sent the U.S. military a written request for classified data on the Lockheed Martin Corp F-35 fighter jet as it gears up to replace its current fleet of fighter jets from 2025 to 2035.

I imagine the F-35 would be the smaller high end of a high-low mix with the European-made Typhoon.

Carriers are the Means and Not the End, Remember

Will the Navy adopt smaller carriers to supplement larger carriers?

“The Navy should also pursue a new “high/low mix” in its aircraft carrier fleet,” CSBA says in its report, CSBA “Restoring American Seapower, A New Fleet Architecture for The United States Navy,” released Feb. 9 of this year.

“Traditional nuclear-powered supercarriers remain necessary to deter and defeat near-peer competitors, but other day-to-day missions, such as power projection, sea lane control, close air support, or counterterrorism, can be achieved with a smaller, lower cost, conventionally powered aircraft carrier,” CSBA says “Over the next five years, the Navy should begin transitioning from large deck amphibious ships into smaller aircraft carriers with the goal of delivering the first such ship in the mid-2030s.”

The CSBA refers to the ships as light aircraft carrier (CVL), saying it “initially be a legacy LHA/LHD, but eventually replaced by a purpose-built 40,000- to 60,000-ton CVL with catapults and arresting gear.”

I don't think that makes a lot of sense on cost-effectiveness. Unless you can build and maintain multiple smaller carriers (and their escorts) instead of a single big carrier, is it really worth it?

Or are you telling me that Chinese (for a random example) anti-ship assets will be insufficient to take on 15 CVL battle groups rather than 10 supercarrier battle groups that are under high threat?

Further, unless sortie rates are no longer as important because of precision to generating carrier offensive and defensive air power, smaller carriers are at a severe disadvantage.

And while smaller drone aircraft could increase the number of aircraft that a smaller carrier can hold, don't smaller drone aircraft allow big carriers to carry more, too?

Further, describing a smaller alternative as "faster, more agile smaller carriers better able to maneuver away from enemy fire" is sheer marketing nonsense. A 40-60,000-ton ship is not agile in any meaningful sense of the word. And never will be. And adding a few more knots of speed will make how much of a difference against hyper-velocity missiles? How do you dodge that? We may find a way of shooting that missile down or misdirecting it, but the ship isn't going to get out of the way.

So just stop that.

Anyway, let me add some of my past posts on the subject:

"Decked" (January 2006).

"Hulk-21?" (November 2006).

"Let's Get Small?" (January 2011).

"Build More Ford Class Carriers" (January 2014).

"Not a Carrier" (February 2014).

"Another Carrier Debate?" (November 2015).

"A Floor Wax AND a Dessert Topping?" (October 2016).

"Size Matters" (February 2017).

These posts have a lot of other links to posts, of course.

The problem is that big carriers remain invaluable in power projection missions even as their survivability in sea control missions wanes. Carrier proponents and opponents tend to just argue their portion of the argument.

I think we should stop having carrier debates in order to have a sea power debate.

UPDATE: No ship type lasts forever as the dominant weapon.

Thursday, May 18, 2017

What Blue Water Missions Does Russia Need?

In another article on Russia's plan to rely on multi-mission frigates for their navy to have a "blue water" capability, one glaring omission stands. What blue water missions does Russia want to achieve?

I noted the frigate focus (in the most recent data dump):

Does Russia plan a frigate-centric fleet? That's closer to what Russia should have given that a major fleet investment is a source of weakness for the defense of Russia. (And given the land threats to NATO, I'd be content if Russia spent scarce money in a futile attempt to match NATO navies.) But even this frigate plan seems like an overreach for their high end warship given the trend in Russian shipbuilding that is leaving a smaller, older, and smaller tonnage navy (oh, and Ukraine won't sell the engines needed!) in contrast to the Chinese building program that has aimed for a newer and more balanced fleet with high-end blue water ships.

This article discusses it, too. But the only purpose given is for blue water--the deep waters of the oceans away from the shores--missions in the North Atlantic and eastern Mediterranean Sea.

The latter makes sense. It keeps Western ships from the southwest direction at bay from Russian territory. It builds on the conquest of Crimea as the launching pad for deployments in the eastern Mediterranean Sea that is bolstered by intervening in Syria to preserve a naval base option there.

Although countries in the eastern Mediterranean certainly make do with smaller ships tied to nearby bases. Does Russia have so little confidence in their Syria base to provide that resupply point for smaller ships that they want ships capable of longer deployments without resupply?

That leaves us with the North Atlantic as the location for Russian blue water capabilities.

What will they do in the North Atlantic? In the Cold War, the mission was clear: stop American and Canadian troops and supplies from crossing the Atlantic to reinforce NATO under assault by massed Soviet armor trying to conquer West Germany.

What is the point now? Does Russia really think that they need that capability again?

Russian blue water navy ambitions are a vanity item lingering from the glory days of the Soviet fleet that bear no relation to what Russia needs: coastal defense, ballistic missile subs for a nuclear deterrent, and the subs, ships, and aircraft to protect those SSBNs in bastions close to Russian shores.

Anything more is a wasteful drain on Russian resources needed for ground forces and the air power to support them to hold a very long land border that spans a distance from the Baltic Sea to the Bering Strait.

So I'm fine with Russia's plans to invest in their navy.

The Syria Front

According to television news, American aircraft fired at pro-Assad forces in southern Syria after warning shots failed to keep the pro-Assad forces out.

I assume this was for force protection purposes to keep American forces there safe from attack.

It also sounds like these are likely Iran-affiliated forces rather than actual Syrian troops.

Is this an effort by pro-Assad forces to fill a vacuum left by ISIL pulling east?

UPDATE: I guess my impressions are mostly right:

U.S.-led coalition jets hit a convoy of Syrian and Iranian-backed militias that were heading towards the Tanf base in southern Syria where U.S. special forces are based, a rebel official with a Pentagon-backed rebel group said on Thursday

Muzahem al Saloum, from the Maghawir al Thwra group, told Reuters that the jets struck after rebel forces clashed with advancing Syrian and Iranian militias that were about 27 kms away from the base along the Damascus-Baghdad highway.

There were Syrian troops with the group advancing toward the border where we support rebels.

Although this makes it sound like the Syrians were part of an Iranian-organized militia--so not really a "Syrian" government force.

UPDATE: This incident may be related to this Iranian initiative:

Iran has changed the course of a land corridor that it aims to carve to the Mediterranean coast after officials in Iraq and Tehran feared a growing US military presence in north-eastern Syria had made its original path unviable.

The new corridor has been moved 140 miles south to avoid a buildup of US forces that has been assembled to fight Islamic State (Isis). It will now use the Isis-occupied town of Mayadin as a hub in eastern Syria, avoiding the Kurdish north-east, which had earlier been mooted by Iranian leaders as a crucial access route.

But the more southern route risks running through territory that has been abandoned by ISIL to fight America-backed rebels or that those rebels could take from ISIL.

So was this clash the result of an effort by Iran to take over territory abandoned by ISIL in order to secure an Iranian supply line to Syria and Lebanon?

UPDATE: No, apparently there were no Syrian troops. Just militias that appear to be Iranian sponsored:

US jets have attacked a convoy of Iranian-backed militiamen in south-eastern Syria in the first clash between the American military and forces loyal to Tehran since the US military returned to the region almost three years ago.

The airstrikes occurred near the Syrian town of al-Tanf, where Syrian opposition forces backed by the US have been under recent attack by Syrian and Russian jets near the main road linking Damascus to Baghdad. The militias, made up mainly of Iraqi Shia fighters, had been advancing towards the base throughout the week.

This is more of a strike on Iran than on Assad. The article notes the supply line linkage I mentioned.

Although this is the logical development of the war that President Obama began in Syria. At some point the parallel wars that Syria waged on non-jihadi rebels and the war we wage on ISIL and other jihadis as a de facto Assad ally would lead to a conflict between Assad's forces and the Syrians we back to fight ISIL.

So is our policy that Assad has to go, as Obama said? Or do we just want the Iranians to go?

UPDATE: I don't think the Russian protests are totally sincere. While Russia surely doesn't want our intervention to conclude with Assad hanging from a lamp post, the Russians don't want Iran to build up their influence in Iran.

UPDATE: The strike certainly bolsters our seriousness about this diplomatic effort:

U.S Secretary of State Rex Tillerson says a centerpiece of President Donald Trump's visit to Saudi Arabia is to curb any threats to the region posed by Iran.

Iran was definitely the focus of the strike.

Let China Remain in Ignorance of Our Navy's Condition

I'm not a fan of our eagerness for military contacts with the Chinese that give the Chinese the opportunity to see our forces up close.

By now, won't we admit that we aren't frightening the Chinese military into passivity in the face of our awesome awesomeness?

If more evidence is needed of American dismissiveness mixed with a dose of hubris, consider the decision to invite China to the world’s largest international maritime warfare exercise, known as RIMPAC, in Hawaii in 2014 and 2016.

The People’s Liberation Army was invited despite well-understood intelligence risks (try ‘acoustic signatures’ for starters), and apparently in the belief that exposure to US awesomeness would convince China to behave. An invitation to China for RIMPAC 2018 is apparently still open.

Face it, the Chinese aren't learning what we keep trying to teach them:

We hope to teach them the big picture--don't mess with us; but the Chinese are just interested in learning how to do their job--fighting us--so they focus on details.

Face it, in a vacuum of information the Chinese will fear their own imagination about what our military can do more than from the Chinese seeing the reality of it.

Respect the Chinese navy enough to admit that the Chinese might use what we show them to hurt us and not go back home scared witless of our military.

I'm No Rocket Analyst, But I'm Calling Bullshit On This

No, this is not what would happen if North Korea launched a nuclear attack:

Speaking to the Associated Press about what would happen in the event of a nuclear strike from the North, scientist David Wright, of the UCS Global Security Program, and rocket analyst Markus Schiller, of ST Analytics in Germany, described how the drama would unfold.

“The timelines are short,” Wright explained. “Even for long-range missiles, there are a lot of steps that go into detecting the launch and figuring out what it is, leaving the president with maybe 10 minutes to decide whether to launch a retaliatory strike.” [emphasis added]

That statement is purely stupid. Why I don't drink more I have no idea.

America has a large and varied nuclear arsenal that includes the basic triad of land-based, submarine-based, and aircraft-carried strategic bombers. Plus we have a lot of tactical aircraft that can carry smaller nuclear weapons.

In what alternate world of stupid scientists pretending to offer analysis does North Korea's small arsenal pose such a threat to America's retaliatory capability that we are reduced to a "launch on warning" status of our nuclear weapons?

Because that's what the author is basically saying by asserting Trump would have 10 minutes to order a nuclear retaliatory strike. If 11 minutes pass without the order being given, the author apparently believes America's entire nuclear arsenal is gone, victim of a North Korean counter-force strike.

So here's how your host, an analyst of stupid with a MA in history sitting in his figurative pajamas in Ann Arbor, says a North Korean nuclear strike would unfold.

North Korea launches missiles. They impact on American soil--or don't if missile defenses work--and whether or not our missile defenses work, we ride out the assault with the loss of approximately 0.0% of our nuclear arsenal, and then we figure out what kind of retaliatory strike we need to order.

We would likely use nuclear gravity bombs to avoid any chance of a mishap with a nuclear missile going off course and hitting nearby China or Russia.

I think it would involve a nominal nuclear retaliation (to preserve deterrence--who would worry about us if we fail to respond to a nuclear attack with nukes?) against selected North Korean military targets (and we'd warn them so they could evacuate or run from the site); while the bulk of our retaliation would be a conventional campaign that strikes every leadership, missile, aircraft, ship, sub, artillery, chemical, biological, and nuclear target we can find in North Korea.

Ten minutes to order retaliation, indeed. Where do these "experts" come from?

UPDATE: Let me note that it could be that the reporter is the one that screwed up perfectly reasonable statements in the context given. I shouldn't be so quick to assume the reporting is fully accurate.

Wednesday, May 17, 2017

Yeah, That's the Job Description

I don't join in the belittling mockery of such things:

An Iraqi counter-terror official has told Al Arabiya.net that ISIS chief Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi has fled Mosul and abandoned his soldiers, “leaving them to die.”

Leaders take far longer to train than foot soldiers. Of course ISIL will pull out their chief people rather than let them go down with the ship.

Did MacArthur get left in the Philippines in 1942 to join his troops in Japanese captivity? No. We pulled him out. And we used him in the rest of the war and in the next war.

Really, sending (or leaving) men to die is the basic description of any fighting leader whether in a legitimate military force or a terrorist group.

For jihadis, of course, being sick murderous thugs is also in the job description:

Islamic State militants are planting bombs near front doors in Mosul to prevent civilians leaving, a federal police commander and witnesses said on Wednesday, as Iraqi forces make their final push against the jihadists after seven months of fighting.

We should kill them all, of course, even if mockery is inappropriate.

Loose Lips CINC Slips?

Is this a problem?

Trump shared ISIS-related information the US obtained from another country with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, as well as with Russia’s ambassador to Washington, when the two visited the Oval Office May 10.

At a White House press conference May 16, national security adviser H.R. McMaster deemed the information Trump shared as “wholly appropriate” and further stated that the president wasn’t even aware of the country that provided the information. The New York Times reported that the source was Israel.

What worries intelligence officials is that the information shared – which US officials say concerned ISIS methods of placing explosives inside electronic devices like laptops – could be “reverse-engineered” to pinpoint the source or sources of the information.

The issue of the laptop bomb threat has been out there for a while. So the knowledge of that can't be a problem for our sources.

As awful as Putin has been, does anybody really wish Russian civilians to die in planes struck by tablet bombs? I don't. And I'm not a member of the Russian-American Friendship League to say the least.

Not that I'd go all out to save the Russians while they harm us elsewhere (and I don't forgive this). But this piece of information should not have been a surprise to the Russians.

And I don't believe that the CIA told President Trump the source of the information. I don't think the CIA would telly anyone the actual source of the information if it was remotely critical.

The implication of the affair is that the CIA used a source within ISIL that ISIL's counter-intelligence people will reverse engineer to catch. And kill.

But McMaster said no sources or methods were revealed.

I find the idea that we or an ally might have an important human source within ISIL far fetched. I find it far more likely that we used overhead surveillance (drone, aircraft, or satellite) or signals intelligence.

Maybe we were told by a non-ISIL person in the region who is angry about occupation by ISIL.

But by acting as if Trump revealed a key source--totally plausible given the media narrative that is amazingly selective about what outrages it--won't ISIL start killing their own people to plug that "leak."

And you can't dangle a better internal spy threat to ISIL than this:

Israeli intelligence experts are gravely concerned that U.S. President Donald Trump's sharing of classified information with Russia may have compromised an Israeli agent, but don't expect any long-term consequences for intelligence cooperation.

I worry that this might be pushing it. An Israeli agent? Not a Jordanian or Turk? An agent of the Jews? Luckily, jihadis aren't big on nuance.

Note that witch hunts in Pakistan by the Taliban had little effect on sources of information that guided drone strikes.

Stand back and enjoy the mayhem.

This is my guess about the whole affair.

UPDATE: President Trump could have screwed up, I admit. That is the alternate explanation.

But I can't believe that standard operating procedures for either the allied nation with the asset or our intelligence people would include the source of the information in the intelligence product.

But I don't have an intelligence background. So I don't know. Perhaps my imagination of how things can be screwed up is insufficient.

UPDATE: The Russians say Trump revealed nothing:

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said on Thursday he saw 'no secrets' in U.S. media reports of apparent security threats by Islamic state and conveyed by President Donald Trump last week.

I assume this is right. In part because I assume the Russians assume (God, my head is spinning) that Democrats will not believe the Russian denial and so send Democrats looking under beds again with renewed determination.

UPDATE: Here's how we have been taking down ISIL. Yeah, getting ISIL chasing "spies" is a good thing.

Ruh Roh

The Russian annexation of the most Russified part of Ukraine isn't going as smoothly as Moscow would like:

Three years since annexation, many Crimeans find themselves disappointed by the results. Russian promises of higher living standards have not materialized. Few speak openly about their dissatisfaction, however; trials like Chiygoz’s have made it clear that dissent is not welcome. But even Lyubina, the human rights ombudsman, while denying there are any human rights violations post-annexation, complained about corruption and a lack of freedom.

I was astounded that Crimeans wanted to break into the prison three years ago.

I wonder how many people in Russian-occupied Donbas are truly happy with the life that Russia has given them?

But who would they tell? And what good would it do?

Tuesday, May 16, 2017

I Guess This Year We Find if President Obama Got His Decent Interval

Since early 2016 (at least), I've been worried about trends in Afghanistan. I figured the winter would be very important to reverse the trends in this year's campaign. Hold on tight, this will be rough:

Afghan army units are pulling back, and in some cases have been forced to abandon more scattered and rural bases, and the government can claim to control or influence only 57 percent of the country, according to U.S. military estimates from earlier this year.

"The intelligence community assesses that the political and security situation in Afghanistan will almost certainly deteriorate through 2018, even with a modest increase in (the)military assistance by the United States and its partners," Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats said in a Senate hearing.

President Obama escalated massively in Afghanistan (the "real" war); ended the military's staged offensive plan a year too early; and then left too few troops with too many restrictions to hold the limited gains made.

Will modest additions of American and allied troops reverse the trends allowed to develop?

And if American troops are allowed to routinely accompany Afghan forces on missions for advice and calling in fire support and medical evacuation, we really should deploy a brigade's worth of infantry with tanks and helicopters at various bases to be quick reaction forces in order to mount rescue missions for American advisors when necessary.

Did abandoning untenable outposts create sufficient Afghan reserves to take on the Taliban and deny the Taliban the initiative?

Does President Obama get a decent interval between his leaving office and the fall of Kabul?

If he does not get even that, what was the bloody point of all the additional American casualties that resulted from the president's 2009 escalation orders?

Or do we try to win?

Mattis and McMaster know it will take time, that simply withdrawing is not a viable alternative, and that the American people will accept low-level sustained engagement with strong leadership from the White House to persuade them on its necessity. This is the leadership that the United States showed under Truman, Eisenhower, and Kennedy with long-term strategies to improve places like South Korea and Germany as a means to defeat the ideology of communism. Many look forward to seeing the same from President Trump.

We do have a lot of Afghan allies who we can support to win this fight. Are we to abandon all that we created just because our enemies are persistent?

We keep bemoaning the need to take direct action against jihadis, but when we have local allies are we really in danger of walking away from them in Afghanistan to allow them to be defeated--and for Afghanistan to be a jihadi sanctuary again?

In Afghanistan, Trump Is Poised to Re-Escalate a Hopeless War

It's a Beinert article. He bemoans the idea that Trump would "escalate" the war--to all of about 14% of what Obama escalated to. Why would Trump do that, he asks?

Well, he might do that so we don't lose the "real" war. But then, I predicted long ago that Afghanistan had a short shelf life as the "good" war of the left:

If we are not fighting in Iraq, I've long held, the so-called "good war" in Afghanistan will become bad in the views of our anti-war side. Now the anti-war side protests Iraq and claims that they oppose Iraq in order to commit resources to the "real" fight in Afghanistan.

When Obama went back into Iraq in Iraq War 2.0 in 2014, even that didn't inspire the left to protest and elevate Afghanistan back to the "good" war. No, President Obama decided to stop fighting the Taliban and carry out a parallel war against international jihadis while leaving the Afghan security forces largely on their own.

That's why things went sour. It isn't because the war is inherently "hopeless."

Why we would accept defeat when our enemies are so persistent that they are still fighting and believe we can walk away without any problems at home? You really believe that?

And just because few Americans are paying attention to the country is no excuse. Darned few paid attention to the country on September 10, 2001, too.

Honestly, I wouldn't seek Beinert's advice on what color to paint tanks for the desert, let alone for operational or strategic advice.

One real problem is Pakistan which functions as a sanctuary for Afghan jihadis. I've long complained that this sanctuary limits what we can do in Afghanistan.

The article about trying to win above says we have to play hardball with Pakistan. But how? The best basic alternatives for supply are through Pakistan, through Iran, or through Russia. If we go to the mat to pressure Pakistan, is Russia a safe alternative? Is Iran? (And this is just one reason I've long wanted to support the overthrow of the mullah regime in Iran.)

Logistics to landlocked Afghanistan is a problem. Sure, in theory we could string together a route through Georgia, Azerbaijan, and Turkmenistan. But is that a real option?

And Pakistan is nuclear armed with way too many Islamist nutballs for my comfort. How much pressure do we want to put on Pakistan?

One option may be my old proposal for doing what we have done in Syria to fight ISIL: arm and support locals in the Pakistan tribal territories who will deny the use of the Afghan-Pakistan border area to jihadis in the absence of a Pakistani desire to truly control their border.

Hang on. The ride is beginning.

UPDATE: More. It's a long fight we can't afford to abandon and we should aim for de-centralization of governing to bolster support for resisting the Taliban. I'm on board those ideas.

I contest the author's notion that the concept of winning or losing is irrelevant because eventually--like many insurgencies--negotiations will end the war.

On the contrary, a lasting peace based on negotiations rests on defeating the Taliban so they admit defeat rather than using negotiations or deals as just another means of achieving victory.

So we should not make the mistake of suspending military offensive operations while we negotiate. That just gives the enemy the incentive to talk when they are weak in order to recover.

So we can talk. But the enemy negotiators should know that every day they talk is a day that Afghan forces backed by the American-led coalition go after them and kill them.

Victory is never obsolete.