Friday, March 08, 2013

Focusing the Violence

Israel's 2006 war with Hezbollah was a farce. Relying on air power that failed to stop the rockets or compel Lebanon to stop Hezbollah, Israel belatedly sent in ill-trained troops in shallow, small-scale attacks on prepared Hezbollah light infantry defenders. Israel screwed the pooch on that one. Israel is preparing for the next round and the army seems to be the force highlighted. The next round will be a different affair altogether.

Israel failed to defeat Hezbollah in 2006, notwithstanding the relative quiet of Hezbollah since then:

In 1973 the Israelis needed 18 days to mobilize and defeat the combined militaries of Syria and Egypt. This time the Israelis were unfocused, intent on winning with air power alone, then used minimal ground force in a shallow frontal assault that was just a low-level war of attrition, and then gathered forces for a big push that lasted all of half a day or so before pulling back. They could have had longer if they hadn't misused their air power in a misguided strategic campaign that compelled Sunni Arab states to cancel their support for Israel's fight against Shia terrorists.

Hezbollah was perhaps made more cautious, but they are still a combatant and determined to do better next time.

Fortunately, I believe Israel has learned what they did wrong in that war and have been preparing to do better, pushing deep into Lebanon to not only occupy the rocket-launching band of territory in southern Lebanon, but to tear up Hezbollah's rear area:

Drop paratroopers in Baalbek to hit and secure the Hezbollah rear area, drop troops by helicopters at key points between Baalbek and the Israeli border to facilitate movement north, and unleash mechanized units to advance around Hezbollah light infantry in the south to link up with the paratroopers (and smash up the isolated Hezbollah infantry left behind), and the next war will be very unlike the airpower-centric failure that 2006 was.

Israel's offensive will be more effective because Hezbollah can't run to Syria as a sanctuary of last resort. Run to Syria and the rebels will shoot at them, too.

Israel is highlighting preparations to hit Hezbollah. And funny enough, the story emphasizes the army's training:

During Thursday's exercise, near the Revivim collective farm, scores of Israeli reservists in full battle gear participated in a drill meant to simulate Israel's capture of a strategic hill overlooking a southern Lebanese village.

In the drill, three tanks kicked up dust as they charged forward and fired live rounds. In front of them, groups of soldiers lay flat on the ground and opened fire with propped-up guns as other soldiers stormed up the hill. Their targets were small cutout cartoon heads meant to represent Hezbollah fighters.

On a nearby Israeli army base, reservists have also been practicing urban warfare recently on a set made to resemble an Arab village, complete with concrete homes, narrow alleyways and mosque minarets.

Military officials say that while Hezbollah has upgraded its capabilities, Israel has also made important offensive and defensive changes since 2006, when it came under heavy criticism for its lack of preparedness and perceived sloppy performance.

They say the military now possesses sophisticated real-time intelligence and upgraded drones. For any potential land operation, it has fortified its armored personnel vehicles, activated a new tank defense that can shoot down anti-tank rockets and recently deployed "Iron Dome," a defense system that shot down hundreds of rockets during a recent round of fighting against Hamas militants in the Gaza Strip.

Israel was pretty shocked that organized Hezbollah fighters used anti-tank missiles to disable Israeli armor. I fault poor tactics more than anything, but active defenses on the tanks will help out, too, as long as the tactics are better (like remembering that an armored vehicle's main weapon is mobility and not its armament).

Remember, too, that although Israel's Iron Dome works, its weakness is ammunition supply. Israel will run out of Iron Dome rockets before Hezbollah runs out of rockets to shoot. Even against Hamas' smaller arsenal, Israel ran into that problem. But Iron Dome does work. So Israel has time bought by their Iron Dome rocket defense system to advance into southern Lebanon to occupy the ground from which the rockets are fired. An Israeli soldier standing on the launch site is the ultimate rocket defense.

While doing that, I'd push deep into the rear of Hezbollah rather than focusing on the rocket-launching band before moving north. Go deep early, and Hezbollah fighters will be looking over their shoulders with more interest than looking south to Israeli towns and cities.

Oh, and while Israel didn't use ground troops in the recent Gaza punitive mission, they did get a lovely practice mobilization of 40,000 troops. That might be useful experience for Hezbollah, no?

Israel may only want to frighten Hezbollah into passivity in a showdown with Iran, but I think that Israel will have to put their plans in motion. Any rationality Hezbollah displays is a thin covering over the nutballery under the surface. A chance to kill Jews is a chance to kill Jews, as far as they're concerned.

War on Women

What the Government giveth away free (funded by taxpayers, of course) because it is such an urgent health issue, the government taketh away:

Women In New York Are Getting Arrested For Carrying Condoms

That's funny. Rush Limbaugh got in trouble for saying Sandra Fluke was a "slut" for wanting free condoms from the government. Now the government assumes that if you have condoms on you and are a woman, you are worse than a slut--you're probably a prostitute. Really, this is quite humorous.

Tip to Instapundit.

I wonder if Slut Walkers will protest the nanny of New York City?

But, Hey, Rodman Likes The Un

As North Korea throws a hissy fit and threatens to nuke us, I want you to keep in mind that this has been prompted by our efforts to deny North Korean the means to build nukes and the ability to import luxury goods for the elites to enjoy while the population starves and otherwise suffers in poverty:

The proposed resolution would make it significantly harder for North Korea to move around the funds it needs to carry out its illicit programs and strengthen existing sanctions and the inspection of suspect cargo bound to and from the country. It would also ban countries from exporting specific luxury goods to the North, including yachts, luxury automobiles, racing cars, and jewelry with semi-precious and precious stones and precious metals.

It will be a good day when the North Korean regime collapses and angry subjects hunt down anyone with a BMI greater than 30 and string them up from lamp posts.

But I'm sure fools in the West will cry when Kim Jong Un meets an untimely death.

Thursday, March 07, 2013

Death Wish

North Korea's rulers shouldn't be trusted with sharp writing instruments let alone nuclear weapons.

North Korea is threatening to launch a nuclear first strike on us--after cancelling the armistice that has suspended the Korean War:

"Since the United States is about to ignite a nuclear war, we will be exercising our right to preemptive nuclear attack against the headquarters of the aggressor in order to protect our supreme interest," the North's foreign ministry spokesman said in a statement carried by the official KCNA news agency.

It will be interesting to see how these work out:

North Korea was conducting a series of military drills and getting ready for state-wide war practice of an unusual scale, South Korea's defense ministry said earlier on Thursday.

If the North Koreans have any brain cells to rub together, they'll recognize that the war practice shows that North Korea is completely unprepared for war. Their military is large but composed of near-antique weapons with soldiers ill-fed and not used to practicing with their weapons. Unless North Korea can dissolve the South Korean army with mass chemical strikes and some nukes thrown in so that North Korea only has to road march south without organized resistance, North Korea will die as a state by the end of the war they start.

Until North Korea gets nukes, they have one threat only: bombarding Seoul.

North Korea could do tremendous damage to the South Korean capital that lies very close to the DMZ. This article kind of cracks me up in that it refutes the idea that Seoul could be literally "flattened" by a North Korean bombardment. Good grief, people. Seriously? People really argue whether Seoul can be physically destroyed and wiped out? And if it can't be done except over many months of bombardment, it apparently doesn't count?

Even the above article concludes:

There's no doubt that North Korea's massive deployment of artillery, and potential deployment of roughly 300 ballistic missiles, could wreak havoc on Seoul and its population. What's clear, however, is that a sudden barrage of shells and missiles would only mark the beginning of a battle for the city, not an apocalyptic fait accomplit.

And it is laughable to speak of precision weapons making simple bombardment obsolete in the "real world." That's our real world. In North Korea's real world, they'll bombard Seoul to cause chaos and inflict as much punishment as possible. In the real world, people don't just bombard islands and sink ships out of the blue just to put on another performance of Dead South Korean Theater for the people back home to enjoy.

I have always assumed that the destruction of Seoul would be both from a bombardment and a battle if Seoul becomes the front line. Think Berlin 1945, at worst, which didn't literally erase Berlin. "Destruction" is not meant to be taken literally to mean the elimination of the city and its people. But over a thousand heavy artillery pieces will do a lot of damage and kill a lot of people.

People who insist that counter-battery fire will silence North Korean guns before they can do much damage over-state our ability to find and kill the guns. Even the South Koreans realize they might not be as good as they assume. I never forget that at the Battle of Dien Bien Phu, the French artillery commander promised that no Viet Minh artillery piece would fire more than a few times before his own guns destroyed it. He didn't even come close to fulfilling that promise.

I know, it is a long way from then and our precision is better, as is our recon. But the North Korean pieces are dug in with plenty of ammunition available. Assuming rapid counter-battery fire will work isn't just a matter of having precision weapons. We have to know where to aim the weapons. In 1999, our Air Force thought it crushed the Serbian army. But when the fighting ended, the Serbian army promptly marched out of Kosovo, showing no indication of being decimated. Our precision weapons did not destroy the Serb army, and during the war we over-stated what we destroyed. I still remember the picture of a success--which turned out to be a World War II-era American tank destroyer.

Even in the 2003 invasion of Iraq, where our air power was very effective in tracking and attacking moving Iraqi units, units that did not move were able to surprise us.

So do we really know where all the firing points are? Do we know which ones are dummies and which ones are real? Do we really assume we can destroy every weapon? Do we really assume the North Koreans can't replace those weapons that we do destroy and keep firing? Do we really think that we can erase this threat before the North Koreans inflict serious damage to the home of a quarter of South Korea's population?

Hey, didn't Israel assume they could quickly wipe out all of Hezbollah's rockets if it came to war? Yeah, they sure did assume that. And they failed to slow down the bombardment of northern Israel one bit during the 2006 war.

I sure don't assume we can cleanly knock out North Korea's guns and rocket launchers. Even if I assume the North Koreans will achieve far less than the total destruction of Seoul, tens of thousands of casualties and tens of billions of dollars in damage will be pretty bad. And what if North Korea throws in chemical weapons? Yes, it would be the biggest Dead South Koreans pageant, ever! Mission accomplished.

Who wants to assume that the nutballs in North Korea won't believe that with North Korea's superior will, they'd emerge victorious in an exchange of fire that relies on numerous North Korean artillery shooting at close Seoul versus the damage Pyongyang would suffer from long-range missiles and aircraft?

No, the only way to stop the bombardment is to occupy an arc of terrain north of the DMZ to control the territory that puts artillery in range of Seoul. Those exercises the North Koreans are conducting will demonstrate just how far the North Korean army has fallen. Reduce the threat to just long-range missiles and aircraft, and Seoul can be defended without too much damage.

And South Koreans are no longer so afraid of Pyongyang's threats that they quake in their boots when North Korea bellows:

"We have all preparations in place for strong and decisive punishment, not only against the source of the aggression and its support forces but also the commanding element," Major General Kim Yong-hyun of the South Korean army told a news conference in one of the clearest threats Seoul has made.

I suspect that the South Koreans will try to limit their own response to counter-battery fire and strikes on Pyongyang. But I also suspect that they over-estimate their ability to shut down North Korea's artillery. If North Korea doesn't voluntarily halt their bombardment, the South Korean army will need to roll north to protect their capital.

And one that happens, all bets are off on whether the fighting can be stopped before South Korean or Chinese troops are sitting in Pyongyang.

Your Thursday Dose of "We're Screwed"

Iran will go nuclear despite non-military means trying to low them down. Israel will try to use military means if we won't. But I wonder if it will even matter.

Our top general in CENTCOM doesn't see non-military means stopping Iran from going nuclear:

Mattis at one point was asked point blank whether he thought diplomatic efforts and sanctions were working to stop Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon.

"No sir," he said.

Later, when pressed, Mattis said he fully supported economic sanctions and diplomatic isolation.

"I believe they are trying to buy time with the negotiations but that should not be in any way construed as 'We should not try to negotiate,'" Mattis said, noting President Barack Obama's warning that military intervention was an option if all else were to fail.

He also thinks the Israelis would and could do the job:

Sen. Lindsey Graham ... asked him whether he believed Israel would strike at Iran if the regime “reached a critical point in terms of nuclear capability.”

Responded Mattis: “The Israelis have said so; I take them at their word.”

Graham followed up by asking whether Israel would need US assistance to carry out such an attack. Said Mattis, “They could conduct a strike without our help.”

Indeed. They can't do as good a job as we could, but this is a change from the assumption that Israel could not do the job. Whether Israel has increased their ability to do the job the way we would--by either focusing available resources on fewer critical targets or by expanding their capabilities--or by thinking outside the box with methods we wouldn't bother to use but which get the job done anyway, is the question. Or is it?

And this is separate from the question of whether even an effective strike that destroys every nuclear target in Iran would do the job. Iran knows there are red lines that will prompt Israel or America to strike. The Iranians might be smart enough to figure out how to cross the red line safely.

Yes, we are buying time, as General Mattis says. But so are the Iranians. We shall see what each side has used their time to achieve.

UPDATE: Thanks to Pseudo-Polymath for the link. No worries. I hear Unicorns have been modified to carry Standard anti-missile missiles.

Keep It Simple, Stupid

I don't actually worry that President Obama will order drone strikes on Americans inside America instead of arresting them.

But the administration has brought this worry on themselves by trying to make what is a simple war issue that allows us to kill even American citizens who wage war on us just like they are any other foreign person waging war on us, and trying to make overseas drone strikes on Americans who wage war on us justified under domestic law enforcement standards.

Call the administration on their stupidity. Don't raise the level of stupid.

UPDATE: This sounds about right (tip to Instapundit).

I don't worry that President Obama plans drone strikes instead of arrests on American soil. But Democrats who supposedly have such a higher moral plane (that they deployed during the Bush administration) couldn't back a resolution saying that the Senate didn't think the president could kill Americans on American soil? That was worth the price of admission to see.

Half a day later, the Justice Department released a letter saying that America did not have the power to simply kill Americans on American soil in a non-combat situation. I'm fine with that. Why was it so difficult to say quickly? The administration is overcomplicating war by conflating it with domestic law enforcement, and they shot themselves in the foot. They deserved it.

Really Missing the Point

In a counter-insurgency, money is ammunition. Let's keep audits of the Iraq War in perspective, here.

If there was fraud in Iraq construction aid, prosecute it. But otherwise, this is nothing to get worked up over:

Ten years and $60 billion in American taxpayer funds later, Iraq is still so unstable and broken that even its leaders question whether U.S. efforts to rebuild the war-torn nation were worth the cost.

In his final report to Congress, Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction Stuart Bowen's conclusion was all too clear: Since the invasion a decade ago this month, the U.S. has spent too much money in Iraq for too few results.

The reconstruction effort "grew to a size much larger than was ever anticipated," Bowen told The Associated Press in a preview of his last audit of U.S. funds spent in Iraq, to be released Wednesday. "Not enough was accomplished for the size of the funds expended."

You'll recall that the enemy kept blowing things up. So much of the money had to be used for security related expenditures. And rebuilding stuff again and again.

Recall, too, that we did not attack Iraqi infrastructure during our invasion to avoid having to immediately rebuild it, only to find that the infrastructure was so worn out that it had to be rebuilt from the ravages of Saddam's neglect. When sanctions "sequestered" his income, the palaces did not suffer--basic infrastructure used by the people--especially by Shia people--went without maintenance.

The most basic point this misses is that money is ammunition in a counter-insurgency fight, as I wrote four years ago when the head of the effort was just getting going:

Yet let's not get too carried away in this exercise [in auditing]. If there was fraud, by all means prosecute the guilty. But in a counter-insurgency, money is ammunition. We should not question it in terms of effect by examining efficiency. Do we examine whether expenditures of ammunition was necessary? No. And nobody raises a stink if an infantry platoon burns through ammunition and calls in fire support to nail a single sniper in a building. It was necessary to spend money in Iraq to undermine the insurgents' appeal and nullify terror damage. Slowing down that expenditure to rigorously account for the money before spending it would have hampered the war effort.

Really, we spent 14 times as much at the stroke of a pen in the 2009 stimulus. How's the audit on that going? And we spent far more on bullets and fighting-related expenses. Construction aid was a small fraction of the war spending (not quite as much as the stimulus act, if I recall). And it was well worth it. The objective of the spending was to win the war--not build a lovely mall for all to enjoy and turn a tidy profit in the end. We spent on civilian projects to win hearts and minds. This was simply not the same as civilian spending in a peacetime environment.

Again, this was a method of winning the war no different in its objective than shooting the enemy or collecting intelligence. Discussing the efficiency is just stupid. You want to discuss effectiveness? By all means. But do remember that we won the war, in the end, by defeating the armed enemies.

If you are worried about making the results in Iraq worth the cost, why aren't you screaming as loud as I have about remaining in Iraq to defend our gains during the post-war struggle to define the new Iraq that will arise from the ashes of the old Iraq of Saddam crushed in 2003 and the campaign to defeat Iranian and al Qaeda efforts from 2004 to 2008 to be the ones to define Iraq?

UPDATE: While reading another article on this, I caught this linked article from 2009 on a contractor problem uncovered by the investigation:

As soldiers exit the dining facility, run by KBR and its subcontractor Najlaa International Catering Services Iraq, they see signs along the emerald walkway urging those who "like to recycle" to follow the path and "Think Green." At the end of the path, soldiers sort aluminum cans and plastic silverware into separate bins.

But there's one problem: The recyclable goods are thrown into a pit with the rest of the trash and burned. While this is likely to disappoint soldiers who "like to recycle," it also is a breach of the government's contract with KBR to run the dining facility on FOB Warhorse, according to the US government's Defense Contract Management Agency (DCMA).

The chimerical recycling program is apparently a microcosmic example of the spotty accountability under which contractors have operated – at substantial expense to US taxpayers. A report issued Oct. 30 by the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction (SIGIR) said that audits of $6.4 billion worth of contracts revealed "internal weaknesses," including inadequate oversight of invoices and excessive change orders. The report also noted evidence of duplicate payments and payments sent to fictitious addresses and unapproved contractors.

Horrors! In a war effort, a contractor didn't recycle! Good grief. Like I said, by all means go after corruption and try to correct problems. But don't forget that the spending was an effort to win a war. I'm not nearly as shocked that KBR failed to recycle as much as I'm shocked that we put recycling into a war-support contract.

Robots Don't Blink

If the Chinese are trying to wear out the Japanese by provoking numerous sorties to block Chinese probes into waters around the Senkaku Islands, Japan just has to respond every time and not get tired out. Japan can do that.

This is an excellent article on the Senkaku Islands dispute.

China wants to wear out the Japanese ability and will to resist Chinese encroachment:

China's naval and paramilitary ships are churning up the ocean around islands it disputes with Tokyo in what experts say is a strategy to overwhelm the numerically inferior Japanese forces that must sail out to detect and track the flotillas.

A daily stream of bulletins announce ship deployments into the East China Sea, naval combat exercises, the launch of new warships and commentaries calling for resolute defense of Chinese territory.

"The operational goal in the East China Sea is to wear out the Japanese Maritime Self Defence Force and the Japan Coast Guard," said James Holmes, a maritime strategy expert at the Newport, Rhode Island U.S. Naval War College.

One problem is that the Chinese navy remains in the background while "civilian" agencies push the limits and throw elbows at the Chinese. One American naval officer put it well:

China's maritime surveillance agency, a civil proxy for the PLA, had become "a full-time maritime sovereignty harassment organization" with the goal of enforcing territorial claims.

If Japan uses their navy, it looks like "escalation."

If Japan stops reacting and resisting the Chinese moves, over time there will be a tipping point where Chinese authority is considered the status quo:

"If Beijing starts policing territory it claims as its own, and if rival claimants can't push back effectively, it will start looking like the rightful sovereign over that territory," said Holmes.

And until that happens, those bulletins trumpeting Chinese deployments have a nice secondary effect:

News of these missions also has domestic propaganda value for Beijing because it demonstrates the ruling Communist Party has the power and determination to defend what it insists has always been Chinese territory, political analysts said.

China also waves the bloody flag of World War II in order to pressure Japan and get other countries that have territorial disputes with Japan a reason to stay out of the way.

Japan needs to resist this pressure, unless they just want to give up. China is discovering that the Senkaku Islands are another "core interest" of China--an objective important enough to go to war over because China must have that objective:

Senior Chinese officials have strongly implied that Japan's claim over the islands is an attack on one of China's core interests, an important distinction to Beijing in defining its non-negotiable national priorities.

Which again raises the question of just what won't become a Chinese core interest? Because they keep mapping new claims. Increasingly, if China can reach it, they want it; and if they want it, it is a core interest.

So Japan can't fail to react or give China a toe hold. I say send in the robots to defend the Senkaku Islands.

Surface, sub-surface, aerial, and ground based robots (or remotely crewed devices, in the case of anything that can shoot) could be deployed around the Senkaku Islands. These robots would be defenders of Japanese control that will always be there, never tiring. And they could soak up every electronic and sound emission that the Chinese vessels release, for future reference.

Deploying coast guard or even navy vessels could be reserved for the most important messages.

Otherwise, let the Chinese play with the Roombas with attitude--they could transmit a message welcoming visitors to Japan and wishing them, "Have a nice visit!"

If the Japanese want to play a little rougher, like red-light camera systems, they could photograph intruding ships and planes and then send them a bill to the pilot or captain (sent to the unit) for the fee to visit Japan.

Armed robots for the really tough cases would be an option, too. With the Japanese Self Defense Forces in the background and the American armed forces on call, too.

China has already sent in robots (back to the article), after all:

There were signs that tension remained high last week when Tokyo protested that China had deployed a series of buoys around the islands to collect intelligence about Japanese operations.

China's Foreign Ministry said the buoys were in Chinese waters and positioned to collect weather information.

They just float and report, but they are robots. Japanese drones could destroy, disable, or retrieve those buoys. Japan could compete like this all day. Then the choice of destroying Japan's robot defenderss--while being filmed and recorded--would be a Chinese escalation choice.

Japan could also have export versions that would sell well to any nation within reach of China's military arm.

UPDATE: Obviously, I don't recommend the rock-shaped devices for any of the sea-based robots.

Wednesday, March 06, 2013

Once More, With Feeling

Egypt's military is trying to be a third force apart from protesters and the government's security forces. They maneuvered successfully between Mubarak and the protesters. Can the military pull it off again against Mursi's Islamists and the protesters who know that they were betrayed once already?

Port Said is the site of four days of army intervention trying to keep protesters and riot police apart:

Egyptian protesters demanding the release of prisoners battled police in Port Said for a fourth day on Wednesday, challenging state authority in the turbulent city at the northern end of the Suez Canal.

Unrest has plagued Egypt since Hosni Mubarak's overthrow two years ago, with Port Said a focus for violence since a football stadium riot in which more than 70 people died last year. ...

Army troops tried to separate police and protesters, and at one point a soldier was evacuated in an ambulance after choking on teargas, the witness said.

And once more, are the army conscripts reliable to take on either side in this without refusing orders to fire on people they identify with? This will be tough because Mursi is likely a tougher nut to crack than Mubarak. And protesters see how round one of protests didn't seem to do much good.

I'm not so sure the Egyptian army can navigate between the two sides who have much more intense feelings about the outcome of the protests.

Tuesday, March 05, 2013

He Smells Sulphur, Now

Rot in Hell, dirt bag.

UPDATE: Just to be sure, they's best poison him, shoot him four times, beat him, and drown him. Why take chances?

UPDATE: I'm torn between amused satisfaction over the gnashing of teeth and rending of garments evident now that so many so-called liberals are sad that Chavez is dead and depression that so many so-called liberals are sad that Chavez is dead. They do love despots who hate America. Tip to Instapundit.

UPDATE: No, I'm just depressed. No deparavity, aggression, and thuggery; and no amount of failure is too much for our left to support if it is just accompanied by a healthy dose of anti-Americanism. President Carter truly makes me sick to think that man held our highest office.

Life Itself Is a Series of Mistakes

Sowell takes exception to the notion that because people make mistakes they shouldn't be allowed to make decisions that can result in mistakes. The government, in its infinite wisdom, should make them. How that isn't totalitarianism is beyond me.

Instapundit recommends Sowell's essay, which begins:

John Stuart Mill's classic essay "On Liberty" gives reasons why some people should not be taking over other people's decisions about their own lives. But Professor Cass Sunstein of Harvard has given reasons to the contrary. He cites research showing "that people make a lot of mistakes, and that those mistakes can prove extremely damaging."

Professor Sunstein is undoubtedly correct that "people make a lot of mistakes." Most of us can look back over our own lives and see many mistakes, including some that were very damaging.

What Cass Sunstein does not tell us is what sort of creatures, other than people, are going to override our mistaken decisions for us. That is the key flaw in the theory and agenda of the left.

Implicit in the wide range of efforts on the left to get government to take over more of our decisions for us is the assumption that there is some superior class of people who are either wiser or nobler than the rest of us.

Yes, we all make mistakes. But do governments not make bigger and more catastrophic mistakes?

Yes they do. And unlike people, governments rarely have to take responsibility for those mistakes. They take credit if they work--or even partially work (or even if you can insist with a straight face that they work). You have to admit, that's a nice gig.

People do make mistakes. But that's ok. We learn. We live. We prosper. And you know what one of the best things about being free to make--and own--mistakes is? You know that when you succeed, you did that, too. Julia is fated to die of old age never able to believe she did something that she can be proud of.

Admittedly, the left has that covered, as well, insisting that "you didn't build that." That makes the Julias feel better about themselves, too.

Obviously, you have to train people to be this passive and dependent. Our schools try to do that (when they aren't terrorizing children over food that looks like a firearm):

A Florida high school student wrestled a loaded gun away from another teen on the bus ride home this week and was slapped with a suspension in return.

The 16-year-old Cypress Lake High student in Fort Myers, Fla. told WFTX-TV there was “no doubt” he saved a life after grappling for the loaded .22 caliber revolver being aimed point-blank at another student on Tuesday.

Again, tip to Instapundit. Imagine that. A student was suspended for taking action that quite likely saved a life. Stopping a shooting was being involved in a potential shooting incident.

Clearly, the school is trying to teach their students that it would be better to do nothing and hope the armed student doesn't do anything. And if he does start shooting? Well, hope that you live in a state where magazine size is limited. Or is passivity the rule while the shooter reloads, too?

And count on the police arriving twenty minutes later--long after the ammunition is expended--to identify the bodies and reunite survivors with frantic parents.

And the best part is, the government won't even have to admit it made any mistakes if everyone just followed procedures that require passivity! Heck, you can even use it to get more money in your budget the next fiscal year. Little Jenny (who wasn't going to go to college anyway) would probably even think her death was worth it if it adds a line item to the school budget that will benefit administrators students for years to come!

If these people are so eager to help, start or join a charity. And if I need their particular form of help, I'll ask. Don't compel me to avoid what you believe are mistakes. Helping means offering help--not insisting I do what you say. And saying "I am not a dictator" doesn't really change that distinction.

What the Hell, people. How many events in your life are things you can explain by saying "it seemed like a good idea at the time"? What? I'm the only one raising my hand, here?

But over time, I've had far fewer of those moments. It's almost as if I could learn from mistakes because I know that ultimately I am responsible for my own life. And I can even take some satisfaction over good decisions. Some of those good decisions weren't even apparent at the time.

Remember, if you owe too much money, you might go bankrupt. That's tough.

When the government encourages you to go to college by establishing policies that allow tuition to rise far more than inflation and make up for it by loaning you gobs of money, and get banks to loan money to people with no credit history by forbidding you to declare bankruptcy over those loans, your mistake just got much bigger didn't it?

And when the government has more spending investing programs just like that than stars in the night sky that it can't pay for, we just nationalized that debt problem. Is the government doing a good job of learning from its mistakes?

Even John Friggin' Kerry, in his ham-fisted way, recognizes that we have the right to be stupid. I just worry that he is thinking of the nation rather than the individual as the proper place for that right to be exercised

So to all those people who want to save me from myself--just bite me. My God, by failing to understand that life is a series of mistakes, you prove you have no idea how to design government programs for real people!

Screw up your own life--and just your own life, thank you very much.

A Floating Wreck Is Bad, Too

I've long thought our carriers are a platform-centric relic in an increasingly network-centric world. Their ability to remain afloat even when hit does not nullify that reality.

When I started to read this post, I thought I'd have to radically rethink my position on aircraft carriers:

It turns out that American “super carriers” are more resistant to combat damage that most people think. Because of their size (100,000 tons) it's been possible to protect these ships much better than potential foes realize. ...

Carrier experts in the navy have been gradually modifying the design and protection of the large carriers for decades, taking into account what new generations of large anti-ship missiles (“carrier killers”) could do. These design tweaks and damage control measures have been kept quiet, and often secret, to deny the anti-ship missile developers knowledge that they can use to improve their designs.

Carriers are rarely employed for [sinking exercises (SINKEX) analysis] but a 1996 SINKEX was conducted using the retired 82,000 ton carrier USS America. This classified exercise was a test of the vulnerability of such large ships to modern anti-ship missiles. While the exercise details were secret, it did get out that carriers this size were very hard to sink.

I can believe that our big carriers are very hard to actually put at the bottom of the sea. But so too were the big ships of the line back in the 19th century.

Pound them into splinters and they just floated there. But they were mission kills, to be sure.

So while it is a pleasant surprise to me that our big carriers can't be sunk as easily as I thought, that is a factor to celebrate for crew survival and not for mission purposes.

How much damage can one of our big carriers endure and still be capable of flight operations and self defense? And will it really matter if these ships can be towed back to dry dock and repaired in 6 months while the rest of the fleet--smaller than it might be because of the costs of the big carriers--loses the fight?

Even if physically difficult to sink, the cost of these costly platform-centric ships makes them an investment in the past.

Mind you, I'll not deny their enormous value in power projection missions against foes like Iraq and Afghanistan. They are quite valuable for that mission--even if network centric warfare means non-carriers could do the job cheaper. The biggest problem for our big carriers is changing their mission to sea control in the face of an enemy capable of fighting us for that control. Don't conflate arguments for the former for arguments in defense of the latter.

I've long worried that the mythology of our carriers and their symbolic stature as a proxy for our national power could be a severe psychological blow if a carrier or two is sunk in the early days of a war. A carrier burning but not sinking does not erase my worry.

You Keep Using That Word

President Biden vouched for President Obama on Iran:

Seeking to reassure anxious Israelis and their American supporters, Vice President Joe Biden vowed Monday that the United States won't back down from its pledge to use military action to thwart Iran's nuclear program should all other options fail.

"President Barack Obama is not bluffing," he said.

What? Is this an annual event?

I think that the Israeli government recognizes that, as president of the United States, I don’t bluff. I also don’t, as a matter of sound policy, go around advertising exactly what our intentions are. But I think both the Iranian and the Israeli governments recognize that when the United States says it is unacceptable for Iran to have a nuclear weapon, we mean what we say. Let describe very specifically why this is important to us.

The Iranians can be forgiven if they believe that President Obama is bluffing. If you have a reputation for resolve, you don't have to tell anyone you have resolve.

Monday, March 04, 2013

Feeling Inadequate

Now this is a rant:

It is getting harder and harder to write anything worthwhile about the domestic and international political scenes. Everywhere one looks, one sees mountebanks, liars, fools, evil doers, and just plain dopes at work--and all aided by a grotesquely incompetent, lazy, and leftist mass media.

Of course, once he gets going, he abandons restraint.

Provincial Capital Falls

Whoa:

Syrian opposition fighters captured the northeastern city of Raqqa on Monday and crowds toppled a statue of President Bashar al-Assad's father, opposition sources and a resident said. ...

Rebel fighters said loyalist forces were still dug in at the provincial airport 60 km (40 miles) from Raqqa and they remained a threat. A resident said that a Syrian military intelligence compound in the town was not in rebel hands but was surrounded by anti-Assad fighters.

It's a fairly large city at over 200,000.

Will Assad scrape up forces to head out there to try to eject the rebels?

UPDATE: Syria has so far just bombed the city. The article says the city has half a million people, too.

Best Sledding Ever!

The snow was icy this weekend. Truly the best sledding conditions ever.

Being a parent is truly a blessing.

Sadly, Lamb won't always want to race down safe hills with me cheering her on.


That's my girl. She bounced right up.

One day I'll have to dress like a scary survivalist the first time I meet any of Lamb's dates, refresh my memory of how Al Bundy dealt with boy suitors for his little girl, and hint at prison time that kind of hardened me.




I'll miss sledding.

We Won't Even See It Coming

Iran will go nuclear and we will be surprised when they do it.

I've long worried that Iran knows that it risks being attacked if it approaches red lines to nuclear weapons development. So Iran needs to be ambiguous about when they are about to become a nuclear-armed power. One method is to disperse key nuclear facilities abroad.

The other method is to go nuclear while everyone watches Iran approach the red lines that we believe are the only path to becoming a nuclear-armed state. With both a uranium and plutonium path to nuclear weapons, our problems are greater since Iran has the prospect of building weapons with both methods in a sprint. The problem for Iran is to deter attack while Iran builds home made bombs:

The problem from Iran's point of view is that they can't know if crossing one of these lines could trigger an American or Israeli preemptive strike out of fear that further delay in attacking would be too late to prevent Iran from getting nuclear weapons. And if I was an Iranian nutball, I wouldn't assume the Americans and Israelis couldn't knock out my infrastructure.

Were I an Iranian nutball, under those circumstances, I'd want at least a few atomic warhead on hand before I announce capabilities to produce atomic weapons-grade material. Which would mean I'd have had to have bought some from either North Korea or Pakistan--or possibly even from some broke custodian of Russia's arsenal.

If Iran can announce both the ability to make nuclear bomb material and the possession of actual nuclear weapons--perhaps by detonating one in a test on their own territory--Tehran would quite possibly deter an attack on Iran's nuclear infrastructure.

We're not dealing with idiots. If the Iranian mullahs believe there are red lines that trigger Israeli or American action, why wouldn't they take counter-actions rather than just blindly cross those lines and provide a pretext for military action against them?

And still we talk and hope, believing Iran is one pragmatic ruler away from a grand bargain that solves everything.

Or maybe Iran fulfills my fears and goes nuclear before we can react. Iran might be within range of deciding to race to nuclear capabilities and we'd lack the time to decide to do something about it.

What if the Iranian navy picks up a North Korean-designed bomb while they are touring the Pacific and then makes a good-will visit to Singapore or--better yet--Hong Kong, on the way home when the Iranian government announces that they are a nuclear power? And what if Tehran then quietly informs a number of relevant states that if anyone attacks Iran, loyal Iranians in custody of the nuclear bomb on that Iranian ship sitting in that harbor will detonate that bomb? Would we bomb Iran if we thought the Chinese would then blame us for losing Hong Kong? Would Israel?

But Iran would never anger China like that, you say! But if Iran can deter us with nukes, why wouldn't Iran be able to deter China with nukes? And if China can't be deterred by Iranian nukes, explain to me again why Iran can be deterred by American or Israeli nukes.

Iran has been preparing for decades to cross the nuclear threshold without drawing a violent response. They might think outside the box of ballistic missile-based nuclear deterrence for the first critical months of being a nuclear power. As I'm prone to saying, they're nutballs--not stupid.

Have a lovely day.

Total War

We're from the government, and we're here to help.

You know, if we transferred every federal employee whose job is to improve our economy into a department designed to sabotage our enemies, it would be so effective that it would constitute a war crime.

Survivability Is as Survivability Does

The Navy is defending the survivability of its new Littoral Combat Ship (LCS). I don't have a problem so much with the ability of the ship to take a hit as much as I have a problem with the ridiculous notion that we will send those ships into the littorals where they will face all manner of shore-based weapons capable of sinking the LCS. This is madness.

So the Littoral Combat Ship has survivability levels too low to take a major hit and continue the mission. The Navy says no big deal because this is what they intended. At survivability level 1+ it can take a hit, recover, and leave the area under its own power.

Navy leadership responded Wednesday to a Tuesday Pentagon report saying both variants of the littoral combat ship (LCS) are “not survivable in a combat environment.” ...

The Navy has three levels of survivability for the ships in the Fleet, according to an August 2012 report on the LCS from the Congressional Research Service that quotes Navy standards from 1988.

“The Navy decided to design the LCS to what it calls a Level 1+ survivability standard, which is greater than the Level I standard to which the Navy’s current patrol craft and mine warfare ships were designed, but less than the Level II standard to which the Navy’s current Oliver Hazard Perry (FFG-7)-class frigates were designed, ” the report says.

“Navy surface ships are designed to one of three survivability standards, called Level I (low), Level II (moderate), and Level III (high). Aircraft carriers, cruisers, and destroyers are designed to Level III. Frigates, amphibious ships, and certain underway replenishment (resupply) ships are designed to Level II. Other replenishment ships, as well as mine warfare ships, patrol craft, and support ships are designed to Level I.”

More in defense of the LCS here.

Our Perry class frigates were designed at level 2. They took quite a beating in the Persian Gulf in the 1980s (Roberts and Stark).

I find it amusing that one defense is that survivability is also not getting hit rather than just construction design. With physical survivability so low for the LCS, just what helps them avoid getting hit? Their speed? Get real. Going fast increases the likelihood of being spotted by some sensor or another. And the LCS isn't going to be faster than aircraft, missiles, or helicopters.

And deployed in green or--God forbid even more--brown waters, the LCS will face lots of land-based threats like aircraft, helicopters, missiles, mines, shore-based artillery, tanks with cannons far bigger than the LCS carries, plus small submarines and numerous armed small craft. It is insane to send the LCS into that environment.

If we want to operate in the littorals, send in small craft we can afford to build in large numbers and continue the mission even if we lose a bunch. Hey, we even built some of those. LCS are not expendable at the price we pay for them.

In an effort to deal with the real problem that our ships are too expensive (because they are so capable) to leave the expanse of the blue waters where we can see threats coming, we simply built another ship not quite as expensive but still too costly to build many of them. Whatever we say, we won't send them into the littorals, even if we say that is their mission and we have no alternatives.

Maybe we do have other affordable and more survivable options for at least the green waters of the littorals even if they don't look as cool as the unconventional version of the LCS.

The littorals are like a box of very lethal chocolates: you never know what threat you are going to get. Stupid is as stupid does, and our plans for employing the LCS in the littorals are plain stupid. I'll refrain from judging them quite yet for missions in blue waters.

The Safety Dance

The worry that the sequester will gut food inspections is kind of funny when you consider that many of the liberals who worry about that outcome insist that non-organic foods that are already inspected aren't safe enough for them to eat.



I say we can eat if we want to. Everything is under control. And if we can't, it's the government that's acting like an imbecile.

Sunday, March 03, 2013

Feedback Loop

The state of the economy is taking priority in the worry matrix over global warming. Which raises an interesting feedback loop that probably dooms the global warming agenda.

Global warmers want to cripple our economy to slow global warming. And the economic damage those policies inflict reduces the public support for economy-crippling global warming agendas.

Which is probably why the global warmers envision their role as reasonably enlightened despots to simply order us about.

Tip to Instapundit.

So That Was It?

The "pivot" to the Pacific that the president announced not even a year and a half ago was just a marketing thing. It simply reflected what had been going on as we adjusted to the demise of the Soviet Union which forced us to concentrate on the Atlantic. If it had a value, it was in reassuring Pacific allies worried about the rise of China and their ability to resist Chinese pressure. But is the pivot over already?

Via, Instapundit, is the pivot to the Pacific over? Here's a quote from Secretary of Defense State Kerry that bolsters Chinese confidence that Kerry will be good for China:

I’m not convinced that increased military ramp-up is critical yet. I’m not convinced of that. That’s something I’d want to look at very carefully when and if you folks confirm me and I can get in there and sort of dig into this a little deeper. But we have a lot more bases out there than any other nation in the world, including China today. We have a lot more forces out there than any other nation in the world, including China today. And we’ve just augmented the president’s announcement in Australia with additional Marines. You know, the Chinese take a look at that and say, what’s the United States doing? They trying to circle us? What’s going on? And so, you know, every action has its reaction. It’s the old — you know, it’s not just the law of physics; it’s the law of politics and diplomacy. I think we have to be thoughtful about, you know, sort of how we go forward.

So China reacts to others' actions? How do you explain China's military modernization given our retrenchment during our wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and the flat or falling (at least in inflation-adjusted terms) military budgets of South Korea, Taiwan, and Japan?

The idea that China will stop arming up if we just pull back is a disturbing thing for our chief diplomat to believe. And he is our chief diplomat--not our chief defense manager as he seems to want to be in that passage. Screwing with our military is now Chuck Hagel's job, remember.

Mead says that the optimism of believing we had won in the Middle East so could pivot to Asia is the best-case spin on this situation. Mead hopes that the administration will realize it must remain strong enough in both the Middle East and in Asia.

I worried that the "pivot to Asia" was simply an excuse to pivot from the Middle East. Now that the mission of retreating from the CENTCOM area is accomplished, there is no need for a pivot to Asia. And as I've said, with budget cuts, a pivot to Asia will be meaningless since even a higher proportion of less power will mean we grow weaker in the Pacific (just not as weaker relative to the rest of the planet).

So the pivot is over already. Well, both Hagel and Kerry have more important things to do now, I suppose.

Just Sayin'

Ponder that the all-powerful "Jewish lobby" was unable to derail the nomination of the least qualified candidate for Secretary of Defense that I can recall.

The Great Wall in the Skies

I'm confident that Japan could defeat China in a conflict over the Senkaku Islands, given Japanese naval and air strength, despite China's numerical advantage. Give China a decade if Japan stands still and I'll revise my estimate.

In a narrow fight over the Senkaku Islands, I think Japan has the advantage, mostly because I think their small but good quality air force can defeat the Chinese in all but the longest conflict where China can lose lots of older aircraft to wear down the Japanese through attrition.

But China won't have a quality deficit nearly as big if current trends continue:

American air power planners (air force and navy) are scrambling to adapt to the fact that China is creating a Western style air force, not just with modern aircraft, but with modern training methods and tactics as well. While China has only about 500 modern aircraft (comparable to the American F-15/16/18/22), it’s their improved training that is most worrisome. The U.S., Taiwan, Japan and South Korea have over five times as many such aircraft and well trained pilots. China, however, is rapidly closing the gap. In another decade or so, China will have at least two thousand modern warplanes and, if they keep at it, pilots close to the capability of their Western counterparts.

An effective air force is more than just good aircraft and trained pilots. You need a system of training, logistics, maintenance, aerial refueling, communications, command-and-control, planning, reconnaissance, and strike analysis--all meshed by experienced staffs--to wield air power effectively. But good planes and trained pilots are certainly the building blocks to create an effective air force.

Potential foes of China need to react now to the future Chinese air force that is being built right now to shield Chinese power projection forces and conduct power projection missions of its own.

Payback. Bitch-like: One Each

Remember how Syria sent suicide bombers into Iraq to help kill our soldiers in a desperate bid to start a civil war there by slaughtering Iraqis? So this is kind of satisfying--isolated from the horrible cost to ordinary Syrians:

Syria's foreign minister is accusing the United States of double standards and says the decision by the Obama administration to provide aid to rebels fighting to topple President Bashar Assad is prolonging the conflict.

Kind of sucks, huh?

Iran, too, is expressing outrage:

Iran's Salehi said the U.S. move would prolong the Syrian conflict, an uprising-turned-civil war in which 70,000 people have been killed.

"If you really feel sorry about the ongoing situation in Syria you should force the opposition to sit at the negotiation table with the Syrian government and put an end to bloodshed," he said.

"Why do you encourage the opposition to continue these acts of violence?"

To which our reasonable response must be, "kiss our buttocks."

The difference is that Syria and their leash-holders the Iranians were trying to support a minority in Iraq in a fight against the majority, while Assad is now fighting for the life of his minority against the majority in revolt.

Saturday, March 02, 2013

But Is It Good Enough?

Who knew that "don't get involved in a land war in Asia" is advice for the Chinese to take to heart?

A retired Chinese army officer (a general) has caused an unpleasant situation for the military leadership by going public with details of corruption in the army. ... [His]Internet posts provide details on how the thefts cripple the ability of the troops to fight, or even operate, effectively. Historically, this is old news, as is the usually very poor performance of the Chinese military in the opening stages of a war. China is a large country, so wars usually lasted long enough for the corruption to be quashed and more competent leadership to set things right. ... The navy and air force have a way to fight corruption that the army lacks. The government can provide more money to have ships at sea and aircraft in the air more often. You can’t fake that and the best training for sailors and pilots (and their maintenance crews) is constant use of their expensive equipment.

For Japan, which would not face the Chinese army if it came to a war over the Senkakus, this doesn't help.

But for Taiwan, it should offer some hope that even if the Chinese blow past their growing arsenal of missiles to throw an army ashore on their island, that invading army will have problems that will magnify the problems that afflict any army conducting an airborne and amphibious invasion. If Taiwan counter-attacks quickly while the invaders are still disordered, China could experience a defeat that will deter another invasion for a generation.

Taiwan could do that if the Taiwanese army is good enough to exploit the difficulties the Chinese will face invading with an army that is already degraded by corruption.

And assuming the troops China sends to invade aren't the least corrupt they have.

What bothers me most about our pivot to the Pacific and Air Sea Battle (yes, officially "Land" is now thrown in but it seems like a formality) is that it neglects the Army, which in the long run may be the service that has the best edge over their Chinese counterparts given China's army-centric corruption problems.

In the end, what really matters is, are the Chinese good enough to defeat the enemies they fight? Remember, the Soviet army beat the German army in World War II despite the Germans having arguably the best trained and led army in the war.

Food to Fear

Truly, somebody was beaten with a stupid stick to have suspended this kid (tip to Instapundit):

7-Year-Old Joshua was suspended this morning from Park Elementary School in Brooklyn Park. Joshua says he was eating a pastry during snack time and trying to shape it into a mountain, the teacher said it looked like a gun and took him to the principal's office. Joshua's parents were called, he has been suspended for two days.

To be fair, it probably did fall into the convoluted definition of an "assault weapon."

Teachers need to be aware of the lunch box threats.

Bullets:


Knife (or possibly bayonet):

Magazine (though thankfully not high capacity):


Hand gun:


Throwing stars:


And perhaps most ominously, the hand grenade!


Check those lunch boxes! Really, they're just ammo boxes with Disney princesses painted on, aren't they?


Idiots. We're really dealing with freaking idiots.

When Metrosexuals Ruled

European elite males once wore high heels. Until the Great Renunciation at the end of the 17th century:

It was the beginning of what has been called the Great Male Renunciation, which would see men abandon the wearing of jewellery, bright colours and ostentatious fabrics in favour of a dark, more sober, and homogeneous look. Men's clothing no longer operated so clearly as a signifier of social class, but while these boundaries were being blurred, the differences between the sexes became more pronounced.

Now that's more enlightened.

With a nod to Mad Minerva on the topic.

UPDATE: Ah, crud. Via Instapundit, we had a run of common sense for just a few centuries?

Designer fashion is no longer just for gay men and Europeans. Welcome to the age of sartorial enlightenment, in which the average male has shed schlumpiness for style.

Count me out.

Signs of Life

Assad's forces are still capable of local ground successes despite their overall decline in fortunes.

Assad's troops have opened a supply line to their forces holding out in Aleppo:

Syrian President Bashar al-Assad's forces seized a village southeast of the city of Aleppo on Friday, reopening a supply line to the country's biggest city where they have been battling rebels for eight months, a monitoring group said.

The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said the capture of Tel Shghaib marked the last step to creating a land supply route north into Aleppo from Hama province, crucial for Assad's forces who have lost control of part of the main north-south highway.

Even in the waning days of World War II, the Germans managed to scrape up a major counter-attack. But that wasn't the tide turning.

Assad still has potent combat power compared to the rebels. That doesn't mean he has reversed his losing trend with a local success near Aleppo.

UPDATE: Rebels took a police academy in Aleppo that had been under attack for quite some time:

The walled complex at Khan al-Asal was turned into an army barrack from where artillery and rocket launchers gave cover for Assad's forces holding around 40 percent of Aleppo, the opposition sources said.

Assad still holds 40% of the city.

All Your Coast Are Belong to Us

We christened a new type of amphibious warfare asset--the Mobile Landing Platform (MLP)--today.

Welcome Montford Point to the fleet:

The MLP is a highly flexible platform that will provide capability for large-scale logistics movements such as the transfer of vehicles and equipment from sea to shore. It will significantly reduce dependency on foreign ports and provide support in the absence of any port, making an MLP especially useful during disaster response and for supporting Marines once they are ashore.

The ship will leverage float-on/float-off technology, allowing Montford Point to partially submerge, facilitating easy movement of cargo and craft. Additionally, the ship’s size allows for 25,000 square feet of vehicle and equipment stowage space and 380,000 gallons of JP-5 fuel storage.

With this set of capabilities, the ship is able to easily transfer personnel and vehicles from other vessels such as the large, medium-speed, roll-on/roll-off ships (LMSRs) onto landing craft air cushioned (LCAC) vehicles and transport them ashore. The platform with its open, reconfigurable mission deck will serve as an important flexible and transformational asset to the Navy as it can be reconfigured to support a wide variety of future operations.

The nearly 800-foot, 80,000 ton displacement ship will be operational in 2015. It will provide the ability to project forces ashore in an area where there is no port. Non-amphibious warfare ships--like our maritime prepositioned ships (MPS), I assume--can transfer troops, equipment, and supplies to the MLP, which can then send them ashore without using port facilities to do so.

Or it could supplement a smaller port's facilities that normally would rule out that port as an objective.

This gives us much greater flexibility in choosing a landing site and complicates enemy defensive problems. If we are not limited to projecting power ashore in an area where we can quickly seize a major port, it will increase our chances of getting ashore with a sizable force intact and then building up forces to project power inland.

Obviously, the MLP will be a prime target if it is our logistics choke point. So if used against an enemy with significant anti-ship forces we'd still need to get a port fairly quickly.

Two others of the class are under construction.

Only the Troops Overseas Are at War

We're at war. Remember? You'd think that maybe the House, Senate, and president could at least agree to amend the current continuing resolution to provide the Department of Defense some budget management flexibility to cope with sequestration cuts. The cuts are made far worse by the need to cut every freaking budget category by the same amount.

If this is over in a matter of months, the military can recover from lost training and maintenance. If not, the authority to shift spending between accounts should be a no-brainer.

And as I've said before, I firmly believe that even the end of sequester would not save the Pentagon from a future round of budget cuts. Take it now to get some federal spending reductions to slow the budget's growth as a consolation prize, at least.

Although I should be relieved to at least see that President Obama didn't need to call out the military to control the sequester-caused zombie apocalypse that I thought was going to break out Friday morning. We're not at zombie war, so that's something.

Friday, March 01, 2013

Good Cop

We are going to send non-lethal--but valuable--assistance to Syrian rebels. Good.

I guess we aren't worried about making the situation worse given how bad it has gotten without us. We will send aid to rebels in Syria:

The United States plans to provide medical supplies and food to Syrian fighters, a policy shift to directly help those battling President Bashar al-Assad's forces on the ground, sources familiar with the matter said.

The sources, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the United States continues to oppose providing lethal assistance and said it also will not provide such items as bullet-proof vests, armored-personnel vehicles and military training for now.

One source said the United States was also expected to announce a large increase in assistance to the Syrian National Coalition, the main civilian opposition group.

I'm fine with this since I am reasonably sure that we are involved with the recent Croatian arms shipments that Saudi Arabia is funneling to non-jihadi rebels--after seeing jihadis getting more arms than the people more friendly to us. We can afford to formally not want to send in arms knowing that someone is arming the people we are sending assistance to.

The rebels are gnawing away at Assad's forces, and are even clinging to positions around Damascus that the government's forces haven't been able to eject them from:

Rebel forces have dug in to the north, east and south of Syria's capital, occupying stretches of suburban and rural terrain and threatening to break through to the heart of Damascus.

Government troops have largely pulled back to a well-defended core, including the city center and loyal bastions to the west.

Assad is begging for a collapse of his army by holding out in Aleppo and Damascus. Assad has too few troops to defend that much territory. If his army collapses, prospects for holding the Alawite core areas will diminish greatly.

And prospects for helping rebels less likely to be a threat to us win the post-Assad phase have gone up with our recent moves. I'll count this as actual smart diplomacy. So I give credit to the administration for this. No guarantees of success, of course. But at least we are trying to shape events to benefit us or at least avoid the worst. Even just being the good cop means we decided to be a police officer, so to speak.

Let's Think This Through, Eh?

Congo (the former Zaire) resists the best efforts of the United Nations to maintain peace. So obviously the UN will make the situation worse.

Fewer than 22,000 UN troops are failing to keep the peace in Congo. No big shock there given the regional interests, the large population, and the large amount of territory. There is precious little peace to keep, truth be told.

But the UN tired of failure, wants to compel success:

The UN has decided to change its peacekeeping policy and try the more aggressive and violent peacemaking approach in situations where the peacekeepers don’t seem to make much difference. The UN now wants to form such a peacemaking force in the Congo, to hunt down and forcibly disarm and disband militias that have resisted over a decade of peacekeeping efforts. This “intervention brigade” would have three infantry battalions, an artillery battery, a special operations company, a signals unit and other support units, lots of armored vehicles and some air support.

Let's contemplate what this means, in practice. After assuming that the UN can recruit nations into this intervention brigade.

In the vast Congo, with so many people, so much land, so many competing factions, and so many foreign interests to track, a single brigade will storm into trouble spots and compel peace by smashing up those who violate the peace the UN is supposed to keep.

So what do the many armed factions who are currently violating the peace that is supposed to prevail do when faced with that threat?

Assuming that the intervention brigade is fully capable of compelling peace on whatever piece of ground it stands; were I some warlord, I'd go somewhere else. Congo is big. Why fight for the piece of ground that the intervention force is standing on? It won't be able to stand there long. Some other location will scream for peace making. So just be patient if you really need to control that piece of land for your own interests.

And what happens to the rest of the UN force scattered around Congo when 3-4,000 combat-capable troops declare war on violent factions? Will those factions think of the UN forces as two separate entities--the sacred peacekeepers who wouldn't harm a fly and the violent intervention forces trying to make peace? Surely, those militias will possess the nuance to distinguish between dovish peacekeepers who shouldn't be attacked and the more aggressive peace makers, right?

I'm thinking that faction leaders will see all UN forces as targets--with most of the UN troops conveniently ill-prepared in equipment, training, and outlook to fight.

A little bit of peace making in a large peacekeeping mission is just asking for lots of dead UN troops.

Monsters, Inc.

The scariest thing as that Putin might actually belief his fantasy paranoid tales about America and NATO. It is probably too insulting to accept that we just don't think about Russia very much these days.

President Putin of Russia is calling for a stronger armed forces--very soon--to thwart the evil plots of America and NATO (!!!) to alter the strategic balance:

Russian President Vladimir Putin told the country’s top brass on Wednesday to drastically upgrade the armed forces in the next few years as part of response to attempts by the United States and NATO to “tip the strategic balance” in the world.

In his address to Russia’s defense ministry and top military officials, Putin said Russia is witnessing “insistent attempts” to change that balance and complained about U.S. plans to create a new missile defense system in Europe and the potential expansion of NATO to former Soviet republics.

Seriously. So all the fuss we make about North Korean and Iranian nuclear plans is just a diabolically clever ploy--which Russia helps out (damn, we're good) by bolstering Iran's and North Korea's ability to resist our efforts to stop them from going nuclear--to build missile defenses to stop Russia from having the ability to nuke Europe and America?

And to expand NATO into ex-Soviet states (which part of ex-Soviet state is unclear, anyway?)

One can only hope that Putin is lucid enough to understand that China is the real threat to Russia, but that it is simply far safer to scare children and aging generals with tales of the scary American plots to undermine Russia, knowing full well that unlike China we won't retaliate for the threatening rhetoric.

And it might hurt the ego to ponder that we don't get worked up about a good shoe-pounding from a Russian leader any more. Ah, glory days, eh comrade?

But he might actually be capable of believing that rubbish.

Still, good luck with that fast plan to revive the Red Army. Russia has problems.

Libya. Mali. Falklands?

British-French military integration is continuing as both countries attempt to afford real capabilities with diminishing money.

I am not pleased with British-French defense integration. Britain is kidding itself if it thinks that helping France in two military conflicts that Paris pursued (Libya and Mali) will get the French to help fight Argentina. Remember, the last time Britain fought Argentina, the Argentines fired French-made missiles at the British fleet.

This article paints a nice picture of French and British military cooperation, while making light of political differences:

"While the politicians may trade barbs, defense knows there's nowhere else to go other than working closely together," said James Arbuthnot, head of the British parliament's Defense Select Committee.

"At the defense level the cooperation and friendships are more than cordial, they are warm," he said, joking that he had forgiven France for killing an ancestor at Trafalgar.

That's lovely, and all, that their military personnel get along. No worries. I'm sure all the kinks of joint British-French operations have been worked out by now.

But to be sent to war requires the politicians to agree. And for quite some time, Britain will need France for sea-based air power. So what do the French think about that, given Arbuthnot's concerns about capabilities like naval aviation that Britain relies on France to provide?

"How can we be sure, and this is an existential question, that that capability would be available even after a change of government in our allied country and in circumstances where that ally profoundly disagreed with our policy?"

Paris sees the issue differently. "The Falklands is not a good question. What if? You have hundreds of cases with no answers," the French official said, adding the real question was whether a country could afford full military capability alone.

See? Nothing to worry about, Britain! The Falklands isn't a good question to ask when wondering about relying on the French. The French say so!

If I was a British planner, I'd watch French-Argentinian contracts very carefully. You never can tell what might be the tipping point that leads the French to let Argentina know when France's aircraft carrier will be unavailable for many months due to a major overhaul. Then, when the British ask France to borrow the carrier, the French can tell Britain it isn't a good question since the carrier isn't available even for France. So sorry.

And that's best case. The French politicians might not even worry about pretending to want to help. Is it really inconceivable to imagine the British asking France to expose their only carrier to Argentinian air power and submarines over the Falklands and the French telling the British to go to Hell? Britain can't imagine going anywhere else but to France, huh? Well there's one more, eh? The French politicians might even enjoy the look of surprise on the faces of the British, after the British mistook good military-to-military relations for a political willingness to help out Britain.

Look, I respect the French military. They have some good capabilities. But the French leadership has such a narrowly focused (and in my view warped, sometimes) view of their interests that Britain shouldn't count on the French sailing to the rescue.

Sequestration Now

The President loves the smell of sequestration in the morning. It smells like ... victory.



PRESIDENT OBAMA: You smell that? Do you smell that?

CHRIS MATTHEWS: What?

OBAMA: Sequestration, son. Nothing else in the media smells like that.

I love the smell of sequestration in the media. You know, one time we had Capitol Hill reported on for twelve hours...and when it was all over, I walked up. They didn't find one of them, not one stinking government program that wasn't gutted. The smell, you know that media smell? The whole federal government-smelled like-sequestration.

Someday this manufactured crisis's gonna end.

One can hope this is the end.

Apocalypse Not, indeed (tip to Instapundit).

Or in graph form:


I stand corrected, I guess. I've been noting a 2.3% figure. I recant! At 2.4%, Apocalypse descends!

Some will protest that the cuts are actually much bigger in the portions of the budget that the sequester applies to. They are correct. But they are not correct enough.

Remember, too, that statutes are not carved in stone. Congress can choose how to allocate that reduction in the spending increase without increasing taxes as long as the president doesn't veto it. Choosing to take the cuts in defense and certain non-defense programs is a choice the president and his Democratic allies have made in an effort to maximize the pain of the slowing of the spending increase.

Oh, and other critics of the sequester say it is too radical and that cuts should be gradually phased in. Huh? Check out that red sliver on the graph. Note how that the sequester is phased in over a decade? How much longer should the reductions in the planned increase be delayed? Until every politician involved has retired?

Honest to God, I am just stunned at this charade. I have low standards for our government. But this whole episode has crashed through the floor of my minimal standards for honesty and decency in our governing class. We should be embarrassed at the dog and pony show these clowns are putting on. They dare call it "leading" us.