Monday, March 25, 2013

Seriously, This is Madness

Okay, I have to keep going after taking one shot at this piece of shoddy analysis.

What planet does this guy live on?

Ignatius, Webb and many other tenth-anniversary war critics base their judgments on the outcome of Bush’s war decision, not on speculations of what the outcome might have been. Consider: Before the war, America was flush with cash. It had Iraq’s Saddam Hussein at bay, a brutal but broken dictator who could be—and was—rather easily contained in his own space. And yet, even in his reduced state, Saddam posed an important counterweight to the ambitions of neighboring Iran, thus helping maintain a valuable balance of power in the region. Al Qaeda didn’t have a presence in Iraq, as the secular thug Saddam had no intention of allowing any such threat to undermine his rule. True, he maintained Sunni dominance over the majority Shia, but this had been the political reality in Iraq for centuries—under the Ottomans, the British, the British-installed kings and the succeeding dictators. And while this wasn’t pluralism, it did breed stability.

Now America is broke, in part because of the estimated $2.2 trillion invested in Iraq. Iran, unchecked by Iraqi power, is on the prowl in the region as never before. Al Qaeda is pursuing openings there that didn’t exist during the Saddam days. Sectarian strife is rampant and on the rise. The entire region has been destabilized, in part because of the Iraqi invasion, and Islamic fundamentalism is more thoroughly entrenched in the region than ever. China, as Webb and others predicted, has exploited America’s Middle East preoccupation to flex its muscles in Asia. And all this represents the strategic cost, leaving aside the 190,000 people killed by the war, including 4,488 U.S. service members, 3,400 U.S. contractors, and 134,000 Iraqi civilians.

This is laughable. It has nothing to do with being a critic based on the outcome.

America was "flush with cash" prior to the war? Really? We were less in debt but still in debt. Many conservatives were rather upset with Bush over spending. I wasn't happy about it but winning the war was my priority, and at least Bush didn't falter in trying to do that despite growing cries to lose (ahem, Obama, Pelosi, Kerry, Biden, and Hagel). We had budget surpluses based on bubbles that burst near the end of that run and we did have that 9/11 thing. Remember that budget deficits were declining until the financial crisis of 2008 hit us. Absent that, as the wars wound down we would have reached that "flush" state again--albeit with a higher debt because of deficit spending. And the Iraq War cost less than the 2009 stimulus spent at the stroke of a pen. Citing $2.2 trillion as an Iraq War cost requires you to count all indirect costs decades into the future--which is obviously not money we've spent already. Saying Iraq is the reason we are broke is plain wrong. At one trillion dollars in deficit spending now without a single American soldier in combat in Iraq seems like the obvious rejoinder to this cause and effect claim.

Further, Saddam was sort of held at bay, but he was fostering terrorism in the region, training and hosting terrorists and funding suicide bombers in Israel.

Saddam may have been bluffing about having WMD, but based on his need to bluff (he was willing to endure even weakening sanctions to maintain that bluff, recall) he'd obviously try to get WMD before his bluff was called, no? And North Korea shows us that even being broke, you can get nukes. Iraq--with oil money--could have gotten nukes if he'd remained in power. Chemical weapons--which he produced for the Iran-Iraq War--would have been easy. And sanctions were breaking down in early 2001 as Saddam staged dead baby parades to successfully weaken support in the Arab world and the left wing in the West for sanctions. Recall that in early 2001 our then-Secretary of State Powell was already talking about a fall back position of "smart sanctions" that focused on rulers in place of the collapsing general sanctions on Iraq that Saddam was evading by exploiting the "oil for food" loop hole to get resources for his own regime at the expense of the people of Iraq whose suffering was a lovely chorus for his propaganda shows.

And Saddam did make and carry out threats against the Kurds or against Kuwait even as he was "contained." And as we practiced dual containment of Iran and Iraq, there was always the danger of a new Nazi-Soviet pact that would align Iran and Iraq against their common enemies in the Gulf and America.

Oh, and you have to love the dismissal of Saddam's minority dictatorship. I mean, as long as its been done a long time, that's just dandy. That wasn't stability. It was just the illusion of stability made easy for Westerners to believe because the quiet suffering didn't make our evening news to disturb our suppers.

Was al Qaeda in Iraq? Well, al Qaeda had Afghanistan for their base. So why bother going to a place where they could be bombed by American no-fly patrols? And plenty of supporters were in Saudi Arabia before that government recognized al Qaeda as a threat to their own rule. Why base in Iraq?

Saddam did welcome al Qaeda refugees from Afghanistan after we routed the Taliban to remote portions of Iraq where they could draw supplies from Saddam-controlled territory (and from Iran). As for al Qaeda exploring openings in Iraq that weren't there before we invaded, why would al Qaeda do that when Saddam shared an enemy with al Qaeda? Al Qaeda invaded Iraq precisely because it was no longer a friend and because they had been crushed in Afghanistan. But rather than being a jihadi conquest to create a new al Qaeda base, Iraq was where we slaughtered jihadis and put them in openings in the ground about 6 feet deep. We devastated al Qaeda in Iraq.

Further, although it is commonly claimed, Saddam was hardly secular by the time we invaded. Saddam increasingly relied on appeals to Islam for his legitimacy during the 1990s. Or have we forgotten the jihadis that Saddam imported prior to the 2003 war known as Saddam's Fedayeen? They arrived via the same pipeline that funneled suicide bombers into Iraq during the war.

As for causing Islamic fundamentalism in the region, that is farcical. Both regimes and opponents of those same regimes stoked different versions of Islamist fundamentalism as pillars of support. The Iraq War discredited the jihadi versions of those Islamist factions as the Arab world saw jihadis gleefully killing other Moslems. So when the Arab Spring hit, the first protests called for democracy and not Islamism. And even though Islamists have gained influence and power, they have been unable to make a flat appeal to the joys of jihad as they exploited prior to the Iraq War--and which fueled a bloody war in Algeria during the 1990s, recall. That jihadi option was not a popular one any more after the images of jihadi depravity were broadcast. The Islamist leaders may yet trick their people into getting jihadi-friendly Islamist governments, but the leaders can't openly promise that outcome. Not after the Iraq War.

Finally, the idea that China needed us to fight in the Middle East to exploit their growing power in Asia is nonsense. Our ground forces weren't in Asia and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were ground-centric. And if you want some more fun with this, China did worry about our forces in Afghanistan (which actually borders China). And American ships in CENTCOM are as well placed to interdict China's trade with the Middle East and Africa as any ship in the western Pacific. They're better placed, in fact, since they are out of range of Chinese power.

The man has a lot of nerve pretending his side has the monopoly on cold calculation of outcomes.

Two posts on one piece of idiocy. Maybe I am a masochist with fantasies of pain.

UPDATE: Here's a better analysis. Funny, I forgot about shutting down the Pakistani nuclear market and Khadaffi's abandonment of his nuclear programs. I wrote about them, to be sure. But they escaped my recall for the ten-year anniversary. Yeah, the war looks better the more you analyze it.

UPDATE: Here's Strategypage on Iraq. Oh, and let's add another success to the Iraq War ledger: the war required Saudi Arabia to wage a war against al Qaeda's sanctuary within Saudi Arabia. Many opponents of the Iraq War argued we took on Saddam without dealing with the home of the majority of the 9/11 hijackers. Well, the Iraq War did that. It may not have been as satisfying as invading Saudi Arabia and destroying their energy industry in the invasion and chaos that would follow (and American troops owning the cities of Mecca and Medina wouldn't be a problem in the Moslem world, eh? Talk about "the street" rising up! That would have united all factions within Islam, no?), but the Iraq War certainly directly led to our success in curbing Saudi tolerance and overt support for jihadis when the jihadis proved to be a threat to the royal family's rule.

Yeah, biggest strategic error we've ever made. Whatever.

Fifty Shades of Iraq

I think of myself as conservative. But after the Cold War, a lot of conservatives reverted to isolationism and I don't go with that at all. A recent piece on Iraq is just a masochistic piece of junk that can't even admit we achieved anything in Iraq.

I mean, seriously?

Ignatius, Webb and many other tenth-anniversary war critics base their judgments on the outcome of Bush’s war decision, not on speculations of what the outcome might have been.

Webb's confusion cited in the article about defeating terrorism and worries about occupying Iraq forever would seem to be self-evidently wrong rather than a sign of far-sighted wisdom considering we are almost completely out of Iraq and we crushed al Qaeda thoroughly in Iraq, breaking their momentum and putting lots of jihadis who might otherwise have killed us here in the ground over there.

Indeed, Vice President Biden could say that Iraq might be the biggest victory of the Obama administration. Assuming that isn't damning our president with faint praise, that might still be the case.

I base my support for the war on actual accomplishments and examination of what we'd have had to accept if we hadn't gone into Iraq and overthrown Saddam.

Further, by quoting Ignatius without noting that the article cited was a complete mush of incoherent ritual confessions of guilt, the analytical ability of the author arguing that supporters are basing their opinions on speculation is just ridiculous.

I am judging my support on the outcome. We achieve much, even if we haven't achieved (yet) as much as I'd like. Even if you want to argue that the cost we paid has been too high for what we achieved, it is hard to argue that what we did was immoral. Think of it as a really tough case of Responsibility to Protect if that makes you feel better.

I'm not sure what the opponents of the war are doing. It seems more like penance than analysis to me.

It Makes a Certain Amount of Sense

Russia sees the hand of the West in the NGOs working for rule of law in Russia. I guess if you want to name and enemy, naming one that actually has no interest in crushing you is safer.

Russia has moved against rights groups in Russia:

Russian prosecutors and tax police searched the Moscow headquarters of Amnesty International and several other rights groups Monday, continuing a wave of pressure that activists say is part of President Vladimir Putin's attempt to stifle dissent. ...

Putin has long been suspicious of NGOs, especially those with American funding, which he has accused of being fronts for U.S. meddling in Russian politics.

We barely think about Russia let alone have the time to plot against them. Good grief, you can read stuff here just about begging Americans to remember that Russia still matters. They could nuke us and otherwise make trouble for us, but practically speaking they aren't going to smash up Europe or Japan. And without that, we really can afford not to think about Russia too much if they don't want to be our friend. Have fun with 1.2 billion Chinese on your border and angry Moslems within them.

But Russia really does think we are plotting against them. Or at least enough in power think that way:

Westerners are puzzled at the way Russian politicians are growing increasingly hostile to foreigners in general and the West in particular. ...

Scrounging up details from Russian media, discussions on the Internet and statements by the many members of the Duma (parliament) with access to the inner circle reveals a rather bizarre (to Westerners, and some Russians) state of affairs. Put simply, most of those currently running Russia really believe that the United States has formed an anti-Russian coalition that is surrounding Russia in preparation for an invasion. The motive behind this plot is the Western need for Russia’s many natural resources. The U.S. has been using pro-democracy and reform minded NGOs (Non-Governmental Organizations) within Russia to cause turmoil and weaken the government and military.

In a way I'm flattered. Some like to complain that we can't sustain a long-range plan for anything under our system. Yet the Russians think we have a deep (and secret) plan to surround them and crush them. Oh sure, we did that to the Soviet Union. I'll grant them that. But Russia isn't the Soviet Union.

And the Russians shouldn't want to be the Soviet Union again. We could be friends if the Russians would get over their nostalgia for the Soviet era when fear of them gave them power and influence.

But who knows if the Russians really believe this stuff. After all, it is safe to rail against a NATO conspiracy when European NATO would have trouble rounding up stray cats let alone invading Russia. So if I was going to make up a threat, I'd pick someone to demonize with no interest or capability to make the fantasies real.

But I go for the simple explanation. I suspect that this is a sincere belief among Russian leaders rather than just a story to justify their increasingly dictatorial rule. But I'm not sure if it is better or worse if the Russian leaders do believe this stuff or don't.

Still, I much prefer a Russia frustratingly annoying over the Soviet era when they were a major threat to us around the globe.

Sunday, March 24, 2013

Did We Just Stick It to the Iranians?

The formal ceasefire between Kurdish rebels in Turkey will surely make it more likely that Iraqi Kurds will accept autonomy within Iraq rather than seek independence. This follows Israel's "apology" to Turkey. Should Iran be worried?

This is good news. A 29-year fight has been ended (except for die hards who will simply extend the death toll):

The Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) militant group declared a "formal and clear ceasefire" with Turkey on Saturday after the rebels' jailed leader this week ordered a halt to the decades-long armed campaign for autonomy.

"Since March 21 and from now on, we as a movement, as the PKK ... officially and clearly declare a ceasefire," said Murat Karayilan, the PKK's field commander, in a video message apparently taped at a rebel holdout in northern Iraq.

Iraqi Kurds surely understand that Turkey is hardly going to be fine with Iraqi Kurdish independence if it might reignite their own Turkish population. So Iraq's Kurds have limits to how much they can play off the central Iraqi government against the Turks.

Which is good. I'd rather the Kurds enjoy their prosperity and autonomy within a unified Iraq.

A unified Iraq is also a tougher nut for Iran to deal with. Not only have the Kurds proven to be the most effective troops in the Iraqi military, Iraq keeps the option of undermining Iranian control of their Kurdish population.

Further, since the Kurds are Sunni (although not Arab), it helps with Iraq's outreach to Sunni Arab countries to accept Iraq as one of them in opposition to Persian Iran.

Indirectly, it helps with outreach to the Sunni Arab world by denying Sunni Arabs of Iraq an excuse to secede from Iraq. Within Iraq, Iraq as a whole could benefit from Arab world acceptance of Iraq as long as the perception is that the Sunnis are treated fairly within Iraq.

And by avoiding a rump Iraq that is mostly Shia Arab, Iran's influence in Iraq is diluted.

Since this took place right after the Israeli "apology" to Turkey, I wonder if the timing was related? Could the glow of the apology be an effort to obscure the ceasefire? Or is it the reverse and the ceasefire is timed to take the attention away from Israel's apology?

The two events do seem related, after all. A Turkey that has made up with Israel and its own Kurdish population is more likely to have the inclination to cooperate against Syria and/or Iran.

I've said that I have a gut feeling that President Obama really is prepared to strike Iran to keep them from going nuclear (assuming that Iran doesn't surprise us--a big "if"). Am I too naive to believe that while President Obama may give every indication that he has a noodle for a backbone, that on this issue perhaps he has a spine?

Perhaps four years of Iran's failure to grasp his extended hand has caused our president to learn--or just be terribly offended. Maybe this is why Netanyahu was willing to appear to apologize to Turkey for the Palestinian faux-tilla incident. Sure, it is unfair. But Israel lives in the world that it has and not the world it would like to have. The issue is at least put to rest.

Heck, as long as I'm looking for dots to connect, if America, Israel, and Turkey are gathering to confront Iran, wouldn't that make this diplmomatic effort more than an exercise in futility?

Secretary of State John Kerry made an unannounced visit to Iraq on Sunday and will urge Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki to make sure Iranian flights over Iraq do not carry arms and fighters to Syria, a U.S. official said.

Without us nearby, Iraq fears mullah-run Iran. That leads them to do things for Iran that we don't like. This doesn't mean Iraq is controlled by Iran or even friendly to Iran, although it is a pain. While I've focused on returning America to Iraq to resist the Iranian threat, simply removing or defanging the Iranian threat is an acceptable alternative for securing Iraq. (Russia should take notes on this part given their worry about our Europe-based missile defenses designed to stop future Iranian missiles.)

Kerry will also speak to leaders from the Kurdish and Sunni Arab communities. Which hopefully keeps them calmed down.

I keep hearing we have smart diplomacy now. Was this some of it?

UPDATE: Of course, gathering a coalition to face Iran--if that is what we are doing--might be related to a push on Syria to get Assad out. Note the president's visit to Jordan with promises of aid to cope with the refugees and note Israel leaning forward a bit more on their Syria border.

Again, just because they are dots doesn't mean that they should be connected. But you never know.

UPDATE: Without bringing up Turkish-Israeli relations, this author wonders if something is up, too. Although he wonders about Syria, I consider that a shot at Iran, too.

Trade First. Then Flag

A land war in Asia requires a supply line. China wants to build that supply line.

Russia is a little nervous that Chinese railway building to Central Asia might pose a threat under different conditions:

China is offering to build new railroads into Central Asia. This is part of a $300 billion plan to upgrade and expand Chinese railways over the next two decades. Chinese businesses are investing more billions to create new businesses in Central Asia and the cheapest way to get goods in or out of this landlocked area is via rail. ...

Something Russia does not like to discuss openly is the fact that Chinese railroads extending into Central Asia would make it easier for China to carry out major military operations in the area.

Like I've said, I want China to pivot to Asia.

In Related Green News

I keep forgetting to mention a local green fail that amuses me every evening.

I long thought it was kind of funny that the light bulb over my car in the car port is the only incandescent bulb left in said car port. The other two were replaced with twisty, green CFL bulbs. How fitting that I got the 20th century technology.

But now, it is just funny. The two twisty bulbs have burned out while my bulb remains glowing in its lovely soft light.

It should be unnecessary to add that the twisty bulbs are obviously newer than my old bulb. I guess they don't necessarily last longer, after all. Perhaps cold Michigan winters aren't the same as laboratory conditions.

But at least the CFLs cost much more. Of that we're sure.

The government said the science that says compact fluorescents bulbs arebetter than incandescents is so solid that you can't have the latter. Are they? (tip to Instapundit)

Maybe the new LEDs are better than both. But I'd really rather have the choice of buying a bulb that in some forms might be as cheap as $10 when I might outlive it. Honestly, having my lightbulbs outlive me isn't my highest priority.

Red and Green and Dark All Over

Earth Hour kind of snuck up on me this year.

I didn't read anything at all about that annual act of public ritual penance where we are supposed to turn off our lights for an hour. I only knew because Canadian TV hockey announcers mentioned it during a game last night.

Somehow, that just seemed wrong. Like a bikini-centric beer commercial suddenly mentioning liver failure. Or reminding men that beer guts are more likely than attracting young babes.

I guess the lack of fawning wall-to-wall coverage that I couldn't avoid in the past is progress. But fear not! Our glorious comrades in North Korea carried the ball for those of you too busy with your electrified lives to participate in this 60-minute hate of human progress:


Oh wait. That's every hour of every day in North Korea. They're just livin' the dream, I guess.

Saturday, March 23, 2013

A Small Dose of Sanity

Japan is willing to offer Taiwan fishing rights around the Senkaku Islands to keep Taiwan from agitating over the issue of ownership in a manner that favors China, which is aggressively claiming the islands:

Japan is ready to open a contested tract of the East China Sea to fishing boats from Taiwan, officials in Taipei say, a rare concession in a bitter territorial dispute that involves heavyweight China and has the United States on guard.

Good. It is absolutely nuts for Taiwan to allow the island issue to alienate Japan. Taiwan needs Japan if Taiwan wants to keep China at bay. Even if Japan doesn't fight (and Japan is edging that way), America needs to use bases in Japan to help Taiwan. Stoking hostility between Japan and Taiwan over the islands only benefits China.

We All Have Our Fantasies

North Korea released a video showing them winning a three-day war against South Korean and American forces:

The four-minute video, titled "A Short, Three-Day War", begins with images of a massive artillery and rocket barrage, followed by a large-scale land and air assault with North Korean troops streaming over the border.

A male narrator then describes how "crack stormtroops will occupy Seoul and other cities and take 150,000 US citizens as hostages."

The video was posted on the North's official website, Uriminzokkiri, which distributes news and propaganda from the state media.

That's nice. Whatever gets them through winter nights until the next harvest, I suppose.

Even if the North Koreans can get their rickety army on the road, I'm reasonably sure the whole thing breaks down when the spearheads hit the first mall or supermarket south of the DMZ. The North Koreans will be too busy looting and eating to reach Seoul.

Personally, I have a fantasy where I'm in a long three-day sex marathon with Sarah Michelle Gellar, Summer Glau, and Maggie Q, who---

--Sorry. I'm back. I was in my happy place.

Anyway. My fantasy has more chance of happening than North Korea's.

 Of course, I don't have a film of it. So Pyongyang has the edge on me there.

Maybe It's Fine, Then

I'm on record as not liking the military-to-military contacts that we believe teach the Chinese not to mess with us. But perhaps restrictions make them okay

I've opposed contacts with the Chinese military, figuring they'd learn far more about us than we'd learn about them, considering our open nature and their closed nature.

China is sending ships to the next RIMPAC exercise we host. But there are limits on what we can do with the Chinese military:

China's People's Liberation Army has accepted an invitation to participate for the first time in a major U.S.-hosted naval drill, but legal restrictions will limit its role to less sensitive exercises, like disaster relief, U.S. officials say. ...

U.S. law prohibits the Pentagon from any military contacts with the PLA if it could "create a national security risk due to an inappropriate exposure" to activities including joint combat operations. ...

"The U.S. Navy has operational security safeguards to protect U.S. technology and tactics, techniques and procedures from disclosure," Wilkinson said.

Still, just having them around means the Chinese will learn--and we will learn nothing from them:

"If they have a frigate, or even a hospital ship, in the middle of that exercise, the hospital ship is going to be staffed by intelligence officers," Cheng said.

Hopefully, we let them see only what we want them to see--whether it is true, or not.

I'd never heard of those statutory restrictions on Chinese participation. Perhaps they are new. Perhaps just new to me. But at least the situation is better than I feared. Whether it is better enough? That I don't know.

Some Damn Fool Thing Near the Balkans

Our responses to economic issues aren't rational. Why do we expect decisions on matters of war to be decided rationally?

I keep harping on the need to consider what is rational from the point of view of other nations making decisions. Even if I can't really do that because I don't have their point of view, I'm aware that it should be done.

But what if leaders and their citizens are incapable of making rational decisions even from their own frame of reference? People have trouble making decisions rationally on economic matters (tip to Instapundit):

Ten years ago, watching Argentina implode, I used to spend a lot of time asking analysts and other financial journalists why they couldn't do the obviously necessary things to stabilize their economy and maintain access to world markets. Ten years later, as Argentina continues to actively maintain its pariah status with unnecessarily aggressive negotiating tactics, this seems entirely normal. The technocratically obvious solution is rarely politically possible, except maybe in a few tiny and very homogenous countries in Northern Europe.

How much worse is it when matters of state up to decisions for war are being made?

And good grief, just figuring out what is rational from their point of view isn't even the end of the problem. They might not choose what is rational from their point of view, in the end.

That's why crises between foes who are in proximity and over issues of importance are so dangerous and can escalate to war. Each side can think it is being rational and each side can read the other side completely wrong--or decide they can't respond rationally to survive the crisis, rationally preferring to risk war based on their narrow interests rather than national interests (perhaps even convincing themselves their narrow interests are the same the national interest).

I remain grateful that even if America and China develop into rivals, we don't face each other across the Fulda Gap over control of the most concentrated collection of economic, financial, and military power potential on the planet.

Friday, March 22, 2013

The Enemy of My Enemy

While I imagine the usefulness of Israel in resolving the Assad issue was the underlying cause of Turkey's willingness to work with Israel again, I'll count this announcement by President Obama as a foreign policy success:

Israel apologized to Turkey on Friday for killing nine Turkish citizens in a 2010 naval raid on a Gaza-bound flotilla and the two feuding U.S. allies agreed to normalize relations in a surprise breakthrough announced by U.S. President Barack Obama.

Mind you, the Israelis only apologized for the deaths as the result of identifiable operational errors, but we got Turkey to accept it as an apology for the incident.

Which grates, mind you. This was an incident provoked by those sailing from Turkey as an ambush, so Turkey should be the one apologizing, in my view.

But diplomacy is honorable men sent abroad to lie for their country, eh? Israel took one for the larger goal of re-engaging Turkey. We want Turkey and Israel on the same page over Syria and Iran as much as possible.

UPDATE: This writer is more than a little grated by the apology and our role in getting it done. I concede that Turkey should have done the apologizing. But I'll repeat that in my reading of the press report of the "apology" it was a non-apology apology where Netanyahu apologized for operational errors in the mission to stop the vessels rather than an apology for the mission. And Israel did make errors by falling for the ambush. So if we got Turkey to accept that as an apology? I think it is fine.

If this gets Turkey back to cooperating with Israel, I'm fine with this. If, of course.

Holding the Reins More Tightly

If China doesn't want war with Japan or others based on rival maritime claims, China's unification of naval agencies should be a good sign.

I've worried that multiple Chinese naval agencies could trigger a war that draws in the Chinese armed forces. The Chinese are unifying a number of those "dragons" for greater efficiency:

China is combining four of its five maritime police organizations into one new outfit; the Coast Guard Bureau.

I assume this will lessen the chance of a war being started by an aggressive agency trying to be more Chinese than a rival agency.

On the down side, it makes it easier to do what China's leaders intend. If they wish to provoke an incident or war, they'll be able to do that better:

This reorganization reflects the Chinese tactic of asserting its claims to control most of the South China Sea by avoiding the use of military vessels. Instead it sends out these “police” ships to harass and threaten foreign ships operating in what international law considers the high seas but that China considers its territorial waters. If any of these intruders call in warships, that China will defend itself by calling its own warships and aircraft.

But at least accidental wars should be a lower ranked threat after this.

They Invaded From the Sky. They Died the Usual Way

Russian Orthodox Christianist death squad ethnically cleansed the Родина of Snowy Russians (or Russians of Snow?). Mother Russia is safe. For now. This war never ends ...

Let's Encourage China to Pivot to Asia

While I would rather defeat China in war than lose; and while I'd rather deter a hostile China from initiating a war against us or our allies than win a war; I'd much rather have China's attention focused on the interior of Asia where we lack significant interests to defend.

Is China getting more militaristic in orientation as their military capacity grows?

Has a quiet military coup taken over China’s foreign policy? Is China’s new president, Xi Jinping, leading the militarization of policy or submitting to it? The questions are not frivolous or far-fetched given recent actions and statements emanating from China’s new leader and other influential establishment figures.

China's neighbors on the edge of Asia are reacting to China's growing capabilities made more alarming by aggressive talk and claims from Peking.

Our pivot to Asia, as slow and gradual as it is, is one response. Another response is part of the "rebalancing" of our military following major counter-insurgency campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan. No longer required to put conventional war fighting skills on the back burner, we are preparing our military for conventional fights again. And China is the most difficult conventional challenge out there:

With the heavy fighting over in Iraq and Afghanistan, the U.S. Air Force (along with the navy, marines and army) are all moving away from using air power against terrorists and irregular troops, towards what they all refer to as “The Big One.” Less discreet air power planners describe their current work directed at developing winning techniques for “Bombing Beijing.”

Bombing irregulars and terrorists who lack air defenses was a challenge, but not the same challenge as fighting a peer competitor or even a regional peer competitor that fields advanced weapons in reasonable numbers. Now we have to consider loss rates and whether we can get through to the targets with acceptable losses. Aircraft will be attacked, as will the bases and carriers that launch them. Bomb damage assessment will be difficult and persistent aerial surveillance is not likely to be possible. Even our satellites will be at risk.

So we need to prepare for this type of fight even as we don't want to have to use these skills. I'd rather beat China than lose if if comes to war. And while we hope that our capabilities will deter China, I'd much rather have China's interests pivot away from the western Pacific and the states on the edge of Asia or off shore.

We did deter the Soviets from overt aggression against NATO Europe during the Cold War. But I'm not eager to try a repeat of that hair-trigger confrontation with China. While the geography is better since Western Europe was a tremendous objective to fight the USSR over and nothing of critical value like Europe is at risk right now.

Sorry South Korea, you are important and a friend, so I would want us to fight at your side to defend your country, but the loss of your country to the West would not be in the same league as losing Western Europe would have been during the Cold War. But just in case, Seoul should be thinking of nukes and being friendlier with Japan.

Given China's growing capabilities and more aggressive stance against our interests and our allies, we have no choice but to ponder the problems of "bombing Beijing."

But preparing ourselves and our allies to fight China is not ideal, to say the least. I've said it before and I'll say it again, I'd rather have China focused on the interior of Asia:

While all this looks good for building an alliance to fight and defeat China, this is not playing the Great Game. This is making the best of a worst case scenario--war with China. Sure, if we must fight I'd rather win, but just going to war is going to cost us in lives and money.

One can say that we hope that by becoming strong enough we deter the Chinese but this is still only second best. A deterred China will always be on the verge of attacking, just waiting for the moment when we cannot stop them for one reason or another and so cannot deter them for even a short window of opportunity.

No, defeating China makes the best of the worst case and deterring China makes the best of the second worst case. We need to shovel the Snow back north. We need to play the Great Game in Asia to achieve our best case--a China pointed away from the south--Taiwan and the United States and our other allies--and pointed toward the north and the interior of Asia.

Yes, Russia would bear the brunt of China, then. But so what? They think we are plotting against them already. And it would be nice payback for Russia's massive shipments of air and naval weapons and technology that allowed China to face America and our allies in the western Pacific, much as Moscow's Operation Snow before World War II helped focus Japan's attention on the sea and away from the USSR. Can we get China to pivot to the interior of Asia?

UPDATE: The state of Russian-Chinese relations is highly relevant, of course. I can assume that Russia and China will eventually face off against each other, but even if I am right one can't know how long the period of cooperation will last until friction dominates the relationship. And I've assumed that Russia's military power needs to recover to allow Moscow to stop essentially appeasing China to keep China at bay. Putin has a lot in common with Maliki of Iraq, I say, who has to cope with a potentially hostile Iran next door without the means to hold off an Iranian attack.

And so (back to the article on Russian-Chinese relations) Russia has an incentive to do all it can to keep this strategic situation intact:

[Although] China’s military modernization is being closely watched in Moscow, it so far has concentrated on projecting power outwardly by sea. This is in contrast to its traditional focus on land-based threats, and indeed is only made possible by China’s secure land borders. In other words, Beijing’s military modernization suggests Chinese policymakers believe that tensions on their northern and western borders with Russia can be mitigated indefinitely, and conflict avoided.

Now that's smart diplomacy, comrades.

Russia is annoying and needlessly paranoid when it comes to us. And their military might is not a threat to Western Europe any more.

But they are the only country in the world that can nuke us until the rubble bounces (however unlikely that is). And their relations with China matter a great deal. So yeah, Russia still matters. Hopefully, Russia's own pivot to Asia involves beefing up their air and ground power in Central Asia and the Far East.

We Won in Iraq. Get Over It

Ignatius seems like a smart guy, but his analysis of the Iraq War seems far more like penance than analysis.

Really, what's the point of that article?

Invading Iraq to topple Saddam Hussein a decade ago was one of the biggest strategic errors in modern American history.

That's pretty big talk, strategery-wise, isn't it? No "we made mistakes" or no "the price was too high" or "it was an error"? None of those more pedestrian claims? He goes right for "one of the biggest strategic errors" in modern American history? Pray tell, why?

One, he claims we didn't have enough power to impose a settlement on Iraq, so the war was a failure:

America’s military power, awesome as it was, turned out to be insufficient to impose a settlement in Iraq; and in a grinding war of occupation, all our might could not turn on the electricity in Baghdad or frighten Sunnis and Shiites into cooperating with each other. Rome was also weak at home, politically: The United States didn’t have the stomach for a protracted war that President George W. Bush couldn’t explain and the public didn’t understand.

Excuse me? We did have enough power to win the war, impose a settlement that got the Sunni Arabs to largely abandon violence; convinced the Kurds to remain within Iraq; and got the Shias to adopt democracy--as shaky as it is (but is that a problem of the war or our failure to stay after the war?)--rather than just become the new brutal dictator to sit in the palace.

As for not having the stomach to fight a protracted war, we did fight through a number of stages in the war from spring 2003 to spring 2008 that broke the backs of many forces trying to defeat us. If that isn't stomach for the fight, what is?

Yet while this justification for his claim is just obviously wrong, his next one is so mystifying that I fear I simply lack the nuance to appreciate what he is getting at:

My [Syrian] friend took me aside after the fighting had been raging for several months. I am still haunted by what he said: “I am sorry for America. You are stuck. You have become a country of the Middle East. America will never change Iraq, but Iraq will change America.”

What does that even mean? My brain may not strain the seams of my cap, but I think I'm a pretty smart guy. But Iraq changed America in such a way that Ignatius is "haunted" by it? Dude. Seriously? Give me a scrap to work with! Nothing? No clue what you mean? Just a grimace, a thoughtful shake of the head, and then you move on?

But there is no explanation for his claim. Just that haunting worry. This isn't analysis. This isn't even penance. It's in therapy territory.

Then he says a reason for his claim is that a vacuum of power was created by crushing Saddam's regime. Well, duh. Is that really a reason to keep dictator's in power? Do you really want to stake that claim?

Of course not. So Ignatius trots out the notion that we could have prevented the vacuum and prevented sectarian interests from arising to replace the firm hand of Saddam:

[When] we disbanded the nonsectarian army and most of the secular government, Iraqis had nowhere to turn but their most basic ethnic and tribal identities as Sunnis or Shiites, Kurds or Arabs.

Many in the CIA understood the need to keep the Iraqi army and civil service together.

While an interesting notion, I think it is dead wrong. One, the Iraqi army was not "nonsectarian." It was a tool of the Sunni Arab Baathists. Two, arguing we failed to keep the army together by "disbanding" it is rot. The Iraqi army dissolved in the major combat operations. I was simply gone by April 2003. Indeed, that was our intent because we did not want our spearheads slowed down by the need under international law to take care of a flood of captured enemy POWs.

The "secular" government claim ignores that Saddam increasingly relied on Sunni Islam to justify his rule. Remember that "Saddam's Fedayeen" were not local chapters of the League of Women Voters. They were imported jihadis under the control of the Baath Party. And Sunni Arabs hated Shia Arabs and Kurds (gassing the Kurds infamously in 1988). Shias were second-class citizens--on a good day.

I'm open to the question of whether de-Baathification went too deep. But given the suspicion that the majority Shias had of us after we encouraged them to revolt in 1991 and then refused to help them when they did revolt against Saddam, a decision to keep Sunni Arab-dominated army units and civil servants in power would have been a huge strategic error by giving the Shias the idea that the new boss was the same as the old boss. The twin Sadrist and al Qaeda/Baathist offensives in spring 2004 could have been a disaster of Sepoy Mutiny dimensions if we had followed the advice that Ignatius now says justifies his claim of massive strategic error.

And without the Shias mostly on our side because the Shias could see the alternative to fighting with us was a return of the Sunni Arabs to power, we truly would have faced a national resistance to our presence. Even if the Shias didn't side with the Sunni Arabs, they might have remained neutral and we would have flailed away alone (the Kurds would have withdrawn to the relative safety of their mountains) without a population to protect. We would have lost that war.

And since we did impose an American occupation government (and I use that as a legal term rather than as a moral condemnation) to try to impose order, it is funny that some today say that we should have thrown together an Iraqi government faster despite the lack of experience or credibility of any Iraqis not tainted by Saddam.

As for the dignity issue. To Hell with that. For all our talk of democracy, we actually left Iraqis a democracy, no? And it isn't that we harmed their sense of honor and independence as much as it is we fought and bled by their side until they could do it on their own. If Saddam's strutting evil stroked Arab ego, that's a problem for them and not our fault. It is surely no excuse to have left Saddam in power.

Ignatius' final evidence for strategic error has a point, but misses the target:

A final lesson is the benefit of persistence. Bush made a disastrous mistake invading Iraq in 2003. But having busted up the country, he tried his best to clean up the mess. By checking the spiraling sectarian killing, the surge of U.S. troops led by Bush and Gen. David Petraeus saved thousands of Iraqi lives. It’s one thing Americans did right in this painful story.

One, we busted up Saddam's regime--not Iraq. Aside from Saddam himself during his reign of terror and war, Iran, Syria, and al Qaeda did the real busting up from summer 2003 to spring 2008 (and continue to do so at much reduced levels).

More importantly, if the desire of Ignatius for persistence is sincere, do remember that President Bush did persist over the protests of many here until victory--as Ignatius concedes Bush did. But what about President Obama? Where is his persistence to spend the relatively small effort to defend what we achieved in Iraq by deciding to destroy the Saddam regime (as our Clinton-era policy codified our objective for Iraq)?

If Ignatius wants to seriously talk about modern American strategic error, he needs to ask the White House today why they set Iraq adrift in a sea of hostility. Iraq may turn out well even without us, but we are taking a greater risk of failure in the power vacuum that President Obama accepted in Iraq at the end of 2011.

UPDATE: Mark Steyn is less sure of what we achieved in Iraq, but he still thinks it was worth it. But he absolutely doesn't like the way those who supported the war have melted away over the last ten years:

The war dead of America and its few real allies died in an honorable cause. But armies don’t wage wars, nations do. And, back on the home front, a vast percentage of fair-weather hawks who decided that it was all too complicated, or a bit of a downer, or Bush lied, or where’s the remote, revealed America as profoundly unserious. A senator who votes for war and then decides he’d rather it had never started is also engaging in “alternative history” — albeit of the kind in which Pam Ewing steps into the shower at Southfork and writes off the previous season of Dallas as a bad dream. In non-alternative history, in the only reality there is, once you’ve started a war, you have two choices: to win it or to lose it. Withdrawing one’s “support” for a war you’re already in advertises nothing more than a kind of geopolitical ADHD.

Back in 2005, I was disgusted by the sight of war supporters melting away:

Our leaders have been keen on getting the support of the American people for war. The military especially has been gun shy after Vietnam unless the American people clearly support the decision to wage war. The resulting Abrams Doctrine of relying on our reserves to ensure public debate prior to going to war surely worked for the Iraq War. There was mobilization, debate, and a Congressional authorization for war that reflected public polling in support of war. Pretty much the Gold standard, wouldn't you say?

But now elements of our population and political parties are abandoning their earlier pledge of support while the war is not yet won. We are winning but the war is not yet won.

So the question is, when giving consent to wage war, don't those who give that consent have an obligation to maintain that consent until victory? Was there a clause in the Congressional declaration that said it sunsets in 2006 or is there a subsection that allows for a reversal at the 2,000th casualty? And the American people whose support for winning is dropping, the same criticism holds. If our enemies ever believe our people have a particular threshold where we retreat, we guarantee resistance to reach that threshold.

But we did stay long enough to win. Public support held and we achieved battlefield victory. Yet still we might blow it because people who hate George W. Bush were charged with defending what he allowed our troops to win.

Well That Didn't Work Out As Planned

It was George W. Bush's fault that the Middle East stopped liking us, according to our liberal brethren. Whether we should blame ourselves for being unpopular for doing good things like deposing awful regimes and liberating 50 million people was my obvious response to that.

But regardless, the conventional wisdom was an expansion of that awful post-9/11 reaction by some, "why do they hate us?" And the answer predictably was that it was our fault.

So we embarked on a new course with a new president--the first African American to win that office (which as a milestone was good for us, no doubt)--raised in the Third World with the middle name "Hussein" and who proclaimed an outreach to the Islamic world in Cairo.

Naturally, the Middle East would forgive us for sacrificing thousands of our own sons and daughters and hundreds of billions of dollars to liberate 50 million people in two Moslem countries.

Nice plan. The outcome isn't so tidy (tip to Instapundit):

According to the latest survey by the Pew Research Center's Global Attitudes Project, confidence in Obama in Muslim countries dropped from 33% to 24% in his first term. Approval of Obama's policies declined even further, from 34% to 15%. And support for the United States in Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon and Pakistan is lower today than it was in 2008 in the closing year of George W. Bush's administration.

Huh. I wonder if this factor is in play?

Or maybe our role is just to be blamed for what goes wrong. Damned if you're Bush, damned if you're anti-Bush.

Ideological Menage a Trois

One crime and two anti-right memes! The left must be very happy to hear this news:

The man who shot up an Aurora, Colo., movie theater during a screening of “The Dark Knight Rises” last summer has reportedly converted to Islam and prays up to five times a day.

Not only did they get a good run with the "white man with guns" stories, now they get to go with "Moslem man mistreated by American justice system" stories!

I must say, it is a brilliant defense strategy. But when the hot babe defense is ruled out, you go with what you've got.

They probably won't even examine the deeper theological question involved: does the Aurora murderer get his virgins in paradise since he killed Infidels before converting? Jihadi purists will object to giving credit, no doubt.

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Quite the New Year's Resolution

Iran says it is against Islam to have nuclear weapons. Yet somehow if Israel attacks Iran, Iran will raze a couple Israeli cities. One can be forgiven for wondering how you reconcile those statements.

Unless they're counting on Mohammed's fist to do the deed, this seems to raise more questions:

"At times the officials of the Zionist regime (Israel) threaten to launch a military invasion but they themselves know that if they make the slightest mistake the Islamic Republic will raze Tel Aviv and Haifa to the ground," Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said in an address to mark the Iranian new year.

I'm no expert, but I didn't really think that cheap, clean, nuclear-generated electricity was capable of being weaponized.

Pity he didn't resolve to exercise more or cut back on pastries.

From the Institute for the Bleeding Obvious

Can we draw conclusions from North Korea's nuclear test? Why, yes.

North Korea's nuclear test last month wasn't just a show of defiance and national pride; it also is advertising. The target audience, analysts say, is anyone in the world looking to buy nuclear material.

Ya think?

UPDATE: Thanks to Pseudo-Polymath for the link.

Defining How We'll Have Their 6

China is upset that we will discuss ways we can help our ally Japan defend the Senkaku Islands.

I've figured that Japan is currently capable of defeating China in a conflict over the Senkakus without our direct intervention on the shooting side of things, but that we could assist in ways that make the Japanese more effective.

We will discuss the actual measures we can take and that Japan would like. China is unhappy:

Shigeru Iwasaki, head of the Japanese Self-Defence Forces' joint staff, and Samuel Locklear, commander of U.S. forces in the Asia-Pacific, are expected to agree that the allies will accelerate the drafting of the plans when they meet in Hawaii on Thursday and Friday, Kyodo news agency said.

They will likely review several scenarios including one under which Japanese and U.S. armed forces conduct joint operations in case China invades the islands, Kyodo said. The Nikkei business daily carried a similar report on Wednesday.

"China is extremely concerned by these reports ... The Chinese government has the determination and ability to maintain the nation's territorial sovereignty," Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei said.

This doesn't reach the level of "extreme concern." Save that level of alarm for the day we decide we need to help Japan develop their own nuclear deterrent.

Because that's the way China is pushing events. You'll notice how South Korea is reacting to decades of North Korean threats (tip to Defense Industry Daily)

Analysis or Penance?

Much of the hand wringing over the Iraq War on the tenth anniversary of its beginning strikes me as attempts to be fashionable far more than analysis. It just isn't good for your career in journalism to say anything but bad things about the Iraq War. And you might not get invited to the right parties.

We won on the battlefield with acceptable levels of mistakes, for a good cause, achieved a number of objectives (including the gutting of al Qaeda notwithstanding incorrect statements that Iraq "distracted" us from fighting al Qaeda in Afghanistan), and even now have a Middle East Arab example--however imperfect--of democracy for those who hope the Arab Spring can offer alternatives to Islamism and autocracy as a way to live their lives.

It was a good war. I say that without hesitation. But I'm not interested in being fashionable.

We Meant To Do That

It is kind of funny that despite our mis-steps, the Russians believe our actions around the globe are part of a deep plan to (of course) screw them over.

Russia's paranoia is our best defense these days (tip to Instapundit):

Moscow is certain that if continued crushing of secular authoritarian regimes is allowed because America and the West support “democracy,” it will lead to such destabilization that will overwhelm all, including Russia. It’s therefore necessary for Russia to resist, especially as the West and the United States themselves experience increasing doubts.

This way of looking at us is surely good for Russians' egos, too. It's all about them. It would be too crushing to believe that not only aren't we orchestrating a vast plan to collapse Russia, we honestly don't even think about them very much since 1991:

The Russians can't accept that we just don't think about them much any more the way we used to when Soviets roamed the planet. We've got bigger issues to face on a daily basis, and only when the Russians act like this do we dust off the phone number for the 3rd under-secretary of defense who still speaks Russian to give him a task to do.

I keep mentioning that when we discuss what an enemy might rationally do, we must not make the mistake of thinking what is rational for us is also rational for them. And Russians are sort of Europeans, from our general heritage. How much worse is it to try to think like North Koreans, Iranians, or Chinese?

Was That a Blink?

So after all that rhetoric about smashing up South Korea, the North Koreans disrupted ATM usage in South Korea?

North Korea has been issuing threats again. And it seems to have upped their talk game. In the past, threats or a little Dead South Koreans Theater would prompt talks and aid. But no more.

North Korea's military has deteriorated and the South Koreans are determined not to just take another round of North Korean attacks without striking back very hard.

So is this North Korea's attempt to make good on threats without being exposed as too weak to stop a South Korean retaliation?

A cyberattack caused computer networks at major South Korean banks and top TV broadcasters to crash simultaneously Wednesday, paralyzing bank machines across the country and prompting speculation of North Korean involvement.

Screens went blank at 2 p.m. (0500 GMT), the state-run Korea Information Security Agency said, and more than seven hours later some systems were still down.

Cyber-war is new and nobody accepts that gunfire is the accepted response. But cyber-weapons used are cyber-weapons that probably can't be used again as targets adapt their systems to repel the attacks. You'd really want to save a big cyber-attack to coincide with a conventional attack to sow confusion in the ranks of the defenders. A solo attack is just a pointless bombardment, really.

Nothing critical was struck, with the major impact being South Koreans forced to use cash to buy coffee. So perhaps no really important cyber-weapon was used in this attack. I assume we'll learn something about North Korean capabilities by analyzing the attacks, even if the North Koreans held back their best viruses.

But I call this progress. Dead ATM Theater doesn't have the same impact.

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Who's Cares?

If you are some poor oppressed person in some murderous Third World Hell Hole hoping that America might intervene to save you under the doctrine of Responsibility to Protect, who would you hope is in the Oval Office? George W. Bush, who took his responsibility to protect Iraqis when the going got tough? Or President Obama, who could barely be roused to protect (Libya) when the odds looked totally in his favor?

A Little Hope, Anyway

I have to say that I am starting to think that President Obama is serious about being willing to strike Iran to keep them from going nuclear.

If presented with a clear alternative of Iran going nuclear unless we strike, I think President Obama would give the order to go. My question is what it would take for the president to believe the alternative is clear and the point of decision is now.

What I worry about is that deep down, the president would rather not make that choice and would be relieved if Iran went nuclear in a development that surprises us, allowing him to say it is too late to do anything without greater risk of nuclear launches.

And Israel certainly thinks it got a qualified green light, in case Israel sees striking Iran as necessary. If we think it is too late to act, the president may feel Israel will save the day by taking the risk of things going badly.

What really scares me is that I actually doubt that Iran is affected by whether they perceive President Obama as willing or not willing to use force to stop Iran. I think Iran's rulers are too far gone to believe anything but that God is on their side and wants them to have nuclear weapons, Great Satan be damned.

Beware the Idiots of March

In 2009, President Obama cancelled the deployment of 10 Bush-era anti-missile missiles. In 2013, President Obama orders the deployment of 14 Bush-era anti-missile missiles. Huh.

Apparently, I was one of the few to note the Obama decision to put 14 more missile interceptors in Alaska. Austin Bay comments on the missiles and the supine press corps:

In 2013, the Ides of March fell on a Friday. In Washington, D.C., 21st century America's version of a gaudy Roman circus, Friday is the day for dumping on our mute national press corps those large and inconvenient truths that embarrass the Obama administration.

Make haste, loyal White House press corps! Assassinate this story, and let the dark soil of weekend celebrity chatter and sensationalism bury its foul corpse. To quote our former secretary of state, Lady Macbeth, "Out damn Benghazi spot."

On Friday, the Ides of March, 2013, recently confirmed Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel quietly announced that the Obama administration would deploy an additional 14 Ground Based Interceptors (GBIs) long-range anti-ballistic missiles (ABMs). GBIs are the "long arrow" in the prophetic U.S. Missile Defense Agency's (MDA) very limited ABM system.

Given the left's history of opposing missile defense and President Obama's position as both the most leftist president we've had and his decision in 2009 to cancel Europe-based missiles (which was leaked on the anniversary of Stalin's invasion of Poland), you'd think this is a big deal. You'd be wrong if you assumed that's how our press rolls:

If you think 14 missiles simply wasn't a big enough number for today's trillion-dollar press corps, recall that in September 2009, 10 GBIs was an earthshaking bigfoot deal. That's when the Obama administration cancelled the Bush administration's carefully structured deployment of 10 GBIs to Poland. Those missiles were a critical part of a layered NATO ABM system designed to defend Western Europe against an Iranian missile.

And of course, our Left no longer derides missile defense as "Star Wars" science fiction. They may not like it, but The One will face little criticism from his base for spending money on missile defense. I guess I should be comforted that even the Obama administration can learn. But I can be appropriately disgusted with our press corps and our Left for gliding over the lessons learned.

Opening Pandora's Safety Deposit Box

Why Cyrpus won't be viewed by other Europeans as the tip of the iceberg after authorizing state seizure of bank accounts--even the bank accounts of Russian crooks--was an obvious oversight by the EU planners. It is finally obvious. But it is too late. The Euros crossed the banking Rubicon.

It was obvious to me that the price of saving the huge banks of tiny Cyprus would be too high:

Everybody in Europe is on notice, now. Where do the bank runs start on Monday? Surely, some people are going to think that if Cyprus has gone this route, their country is the logical next country that will confiscate money. This is Willie Sutton territory (When asked why he robbed banks, he said "because that's where the money is." At least according to urban legend, anyway.).

And this was a plan by the smart guys and gals of the EU. In what world are they living? In their centrally planned world, an exception for tiny Cyprus is just that--an exception that proves the rule that your bank accounts are safe. In the real world, fear for what little you've accumulated as a reserve against bad times will motivate your actions.

Now it is obvious to more:

The Cypriot economy is tiny -- less than half a percent of the euro area’s gross domestic product. Even if worse comes to worst, the direct fallout for the rest of Europe will be minimal. Perhaps that accounts for this weekend’s absurdity. Nonetheless, the readiness to repudiate the principle of deposit insurance is knowledge that can’t be unlearned or confined to one “special case,” and it will make managing the next EU banking crisis more difficult.

I'll hold my breath when the banks reopen on Cyprus. The fear of losing your money even in "safe" banks where your money is insured against theft by Suttons or loss by poor bank managers--but not by Eurocrats--is now on the loose in Europe. Try getting that back in the box.

Opportunity

Russia doesn't have much of a naval base in Syria, but it is all they have. Would Cyprus be their Plan B and make letting Assad fall be an easier pill to swallow?

I heard on the news this morning--noted here as well--that Russia is offering to bail out Cyprus' banks in exchange for advantages, including a naval base.

Russia offered that deal a few months ago, when I was wondering whether Russia would seek alternatives to Syria for a naval base in the Mediterranean Sea.

UPDATE: Huh. Russia doesn't want to buy an island, after all:

"The talks have ended as far as the Russian side is concerned," Russian Finance Minister Anton Siluanov told reporters after two days of crisis talks with his Cypriot counterpart, Michael Sarris.

Are they that confident that their Syria base is secure? Or do they have another port in mind? Or do they simply think they have time to get a better bargain for Cyprus?

Russia is planning to reform a Mediterranean naval squadron. Does Russia believe that they don't need a secure place to refuel, rearm, and repair? Could they simply stage logistics vessels in international waters to replicate these base functions?

Watching the Iraq Alternative Play Out

As we watch Syria--a Baathist-run, minority dictatorship who we suspect has WMD--burn in revolution, remember that some anti-war advocates here in 2002 thought that supporting a revolt against Saddam was the proper response rather than invading Iraq.

It is difficult to keep up with the latest numbers, but an estimated 80,000 have died in Syria after two years of fighting. The pace of fighting is under-estimated by noting that has taken place over two years when you recall that in the first year, casualties weren't anywhere near half that level. So the death rate is astounding.

In Iraq, we wouldn't have faced the casualties that resulted (total of about 120,000 Iraqis during our fight there) if we had been able to prevent Syria and Iran from supporting Shia death squads, al Qaeda, and Baathists who tried to ignite a sectarian civil war. The initial invasion largely spared civilians because of our precision weapons, training, and rapid victory. And the worst of the sectarian fighting promoted by Iran and Syria took place in a single year from about mid-2006 to mid-2007 when the surge broke the back of Sunni Arab resistance.

So in Syria we have the alternate model of popular revolt on display as a Baathist minority government with WMD capabilities fights the long-oppressed majority. Already in just 2 years of fighting the casualties are two-thirds of the casualties endured in 8 years of fighting in Iraq.

And al Qaeda has found a front and recruiting tool even though we aren't there to "provoke" that outcome as so many alleged about Iraq. Sadly, nobody is in Syria to break al Qaeda as we did in Iraq.

Further, we are already worrying about the sectarian conflict that might extend out decades because of the brutality and intensity of the current fighting. We even have reports of possible chemical weapons use (I'm holding off on commenting on the initial reports since they may be wrong). And of course, we worry about Assad's chemical arsenal leaking out of Syria because of the fighting.

And we worry about Syria destabilizing the region.

Is the alternate model working out as planned?

God help us, once Assad falls, we may see another alternate model play out since our administration apparently believes that "disbanding" Saddam's army and de-Baathification was a mistake in Iraq.

Let's see how the Sunnis of Syria like enduring the casualties they've endured at the hand's of Assad's thugs and then being told that they have to shake hands and work with the thugs in a new Syria where "kumbaya" (in Arabic) is required singing.

Look, My Liege! Hockey Stick!

It's 26.3 degrees (F) outside and it feels like 16.

I know that global warming is a "global" thing, but on the first day of spring I hoped my part of the globe might experience some of that warming. Yes, I know, this is weather and not climate (remember that the next warm day in November, okay?), so all I have to say is that it must be bloody hot in the rest of the globe to make up for Michigan.

Oh wait, it isn't? Huh. Tip to Stones Cry Out.

Remember:


St. Patrick's Own

Here's an interesting piece on the New York Army National Guard's 1-69 infantry battalion, the "Fighting 69th."

Troops of the New York Army National Guard's 1st Battalion, 69th Infantry, marched at the lead of the New York's St. Patrick's Day Parade this year, just as they have since 1851.

The march up Manhattan's 5th Avenue marked the highlight of a tradition suffused in the history of one of the National Guard's most storied units.

Each Soldier in the 750-person formation marched with the stories of the past -- the tales of valor in the Civil War, World War I, World War II, and current overseas contingency operations -- living on in each tradition kept.

It's a little late for St. Patrick's Day, but I'll drink to the unit anyway.

Setting the Standard

This article on the big lesson of the Iraq War is quite possibly the most stupid thing I will read this year.

Rejoice, for the Iraq War was the last conventional war we will ever fight. It was the war to end all wars, it seems, according to the cited article via Real Clear Politics:

The old style of war was discredited in Iraq. Even if it hadn’t been, there’s no one left in the West who can afford to wage it. Another conflict on the scale of Iraq is unthinkable in the current climate. We might bomb Libyan air defences and (possibly) send guns to Syrian good(ish) guys, but major ground operations just aren’t on the table.

Iraq was the last big war the West is likely to ever fight. And, unfortunately for us, the rest of the world knows it.

He says that mechanized forces are obsolete, since the Iraq War proved that mechanized forces aren't suited to fighting insurgencies.

God, give me strength.

This is right after he lauds the ability of our conventional mechanized forces to crush Saddam's army. Pray tell, how were we to get to the insurgency phase without crushing the conventional foe?

And is the author truly so poorly informed about the military that he doesn't understand that different parts of the military have different uses? We have a full spectrum military that must face many threats. Funny enough, counter-insurgency forces aren't very good at hunting and killing submarines. They are also deficient in deterring nuclear attacks, let alone shooting down ballistic missiles.

Just because some parts of our military aren't the primary tool for a particular problem doesn't make them obsolete. After all, remember that armor actually is very useful in counter-insurgencies. Our Abrams were not useless once the major combat operations were over. They just need to be used differently. We even modified our heavy tanks to be more useful in supporting infantry in counter-insurgencies.

It's kind of funny, actually. After the Persian Gulf War of 1991, a number of so-called deep thinkers believed the Abrams was obsolete. Here's something I wrote about that for the tenth anniversary of Desert Storm:

It seems safe to emphasize rapid deployment, abandon heavy forces, and discount mere numbers of troops because of the most unfortunate lesson. We learned we are unbeatable. Braced for thousands of casualties to break an Iraqi army hardened by its long war with Iran in the 1980s, we were stunned by the apparent ease of victory. Although few would admit this if pressed on the point, the very fact that we are seeking a smaller, lighter Army and are willing to thrust it into combat piecemeal upon arrival in the theater is unassailable proof that we do assume victory.

And we assume other countries know this too and so will never challenge the Army on the battlefield. All threats are asymmetric now. This is wishful thinking. Victory in Desert Storm will not give us credit toward the next war. We have to fight each one individually because every future enemy will have chosen to fight despite our last victory. They aren't scared of us. They may respect our power, but they think they can win. We must respect that determination. The proper lesson is that a military equipped and trained for the fiercest foe is ready to win decisively against lesser foes; and that decisive victory can lower casualties if it ends the war quickly.

And then we fought the Iraq War. And ten years after that we have a National Post writer who believes the war means conventional warfare with heavy forces is over.

The Iraq War was not the last big war the West will fight. But if enough Westerners believe it was the conventional land war to end all conventional land wars, unfortunately for us, the rest of the world will attempt to exploit that belief.

Perhaps, if this thinking spreads, the Iraq War will just be the last big war the West will handily win. But that's different.

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Who Knew OIF Was About Freedom for Iraqis?

Operation Iraqi Freedom provided Iraqis with freedom and the opportunity to build a democracy:

The invasion was not about the United States setting up bases or stealing Iraq’s oil or using Iraq for an invasion of Iran, as Saddam’s apologists claimed. Nor was it about imposing democracy by force. It was about two things: stopping a time bomb that was ticking in the heart of the region and removing the impediment to democratization that was Saddam's regime.

More than a million Americans fought and worked in Iraq. They share part of the credit for the fact that Iraqis today are able to run their own lives without fear. They can be proud that, once again, American power was used to free a nation from tyranny.

Yes, the Iraq War was not a typical war for conquest or advantage, though we had vital interests involved in fighting in Iraq:

In many ways, contrary to the charge that we fight in Iraq for oil or Halliburton, our fight in Iraq is highly idealistic. Rather than settling for putting "our sonofabitch" in charge of Iraq, we are attempting to give the Iraqis the chance to live in a free country where ballots decide who sits in the government's offices.

We did a good thing by helping Iraqis achieve what they have. Let's help them achieve more. We worry that the Arab Spring will betray hopes of freedom for Arabs getting a first taste of life without corrupt autocrats. Why not help a people who have made more progress down that path than any who stood their ground on the streets in the Arab Spring?

Yeah, That Does Suck

Assad is upset that a neighboring country isn't controlling its territory, allowing terrorists to wage war against his government.

Assad is angry at Lebanon:

"Syria expects the Lebanese side to prevent these armed terrorist groups from using the borders as a crossing point, because they target Syrian people and are violating Syrian sovereignty," it said in a message to the Lebanese government, according to state media.

Syria threatens to strike inside Lebanon more if it doesn't stop.

I have to agree with Assad, having a neighbor send in terrorists is an outrage.

Mind you, Assad has a point. He's an evil maniac killing his people as fast as he can. But he has a point. Lebanon does have an obligation to control its territory and prevent it from being used to attack another country. And failure to do so invites foreign action against elements using their territory.

Which is why I see nothing wrong with Israel hitting Hezbollah inside Lebanon. Which is why I see no problem hitting jihadis in Pakistan. Which is why I wanted to pound Syria and Iran for helping insurgents and terrorists inside Iraq while we fought there.

So if it is sympathy Assad seeks, he should look elsewhere. Although it would be funny as Hell if Israel endorsed Assad's view on Lebanon's responsibilities.

Not So Difficult to Understand

Other than running contrary to the facts and assurances of Thomas Friedman, why is it difficult to understand that arguments the Arab Spring was caused by global-warming induced wheat shortages is pure bunk?

It is difficult to understand how anyone can make the claim that the Arab revolts of 2011 could have been caused by a wheat shortage caused by global warming when, in fact, there was no wheat shortage and there was no warming.

Anyone who is a true believer can make the claim. And those who aren't true believers can burn in Hell.

Now go and emit no more.

The Obama-Centric Universe

We have rules of war. Why on Earth do we need rules of drones? They are simply another weapon used in wars.

This is just ridiculous:

President Barack Obama, who vastly expanded U.S. drone strikes against terrorism suspects overseas under the cloak of secrecy, is now openly seeking to influence global guidelines for their use as China and other countries pursue their own drone programs.

What's the point? If using an artillery piece, or missile or aircraft to kill enemies is legal, it is no more or less legal to kill those enemies using drones.

And if we aren't using the drones consistent with the rules of war, isn't that really the big deal rather than the new weapon we are using?

Does this administration think everything about it and what it does is a new thing in the universe?

A Decade After OIF

Ten years ago, we invaded Iraq after Saddam Hussein refused to prove he'd dismantled his WMD programs as the 1991 ceasefire required him to do. Iraq is a bright spot in the Middle East and the Axis of Evil history. If we lose Iraq, it won't be because we lost the actual war.

I stand by my reasons for going to war with Saddam's Iraq, set forth here and here. They did not rely exclusively on the "slam dunk" assessment that we'd find WMD when we invaded.

Claims it was a mistake require you to explain what reason to destroy Saddam's regime was invalid, of course. Few will go that far.

And given that Iraq isn't in as good a shape as I'd hoped, you have to explain why it is because Saddam is gone rather than because we are gone from Iraq now.

Of course, many will say we made mistakes in the conduct of the war that made the war itself a mistake, notwithstanding what we did achieve. And we did achieve a number of objectives by winning the war. We won despite some smart guys and gals telling us we could not win on the battlefield. People with no clue about Vietnam have no business comparing Iraq to that war.

And you know what we didn't get from the war? Oil. Yeah, all the smart guys and gals said it was a war for oil. You'd think they'd be more supportive of the Canadian pipeline and fracking to keep us from grabbing Iraqi oil, but I digress. We didn't seize Iraq's oil as a spoils of war.

But while we should learn from errors, errors are part of war. In the end, we won. Talking about what we could have done is a parlor game at this point. Interesting but besides the point. Let's focus on defending what we gained, OK? [Oopsy. That was a completely wrong link that is now fixed.]

Some of the suggestions for what we could have done better could have turned out really badly. It is really common to say we shouldn't have disbanded the Iraqi army (aside from the fact that "disbanding" the army was a legal formality that recognized the army was simply gone) or de-Baathified the Iraqi government. Hogwash. Does anyone really believe the Sunni Arab Baathists would have decided that it was OK to be ruled by the hated Shias if they kept their jobs? Would Syria and Iran have not viewed those steps as opportunities to exploit?

Imagine what might have happened in the spring 2004 dual Sunni and Shia uprisings if the security services had been filled with "former" Baathists and even entire units of "former" Saddam's army. As it was, half of the Iraqi security forces dissolved in the onslaught. Under the alternate, "better" scenario of retaining the army under Baathist leadership, units and even parts of the government would have switched sides to fight us. Shias might have decided that the new boss was the same as the old boss since we had again betrayed them by keeping Baathists in leadership positions (still remembering our failure to help them in 1991 after we encouraged them to revolt). The Kurds might have declared independence.

God help us, I'm worried that our Syria policy is being guided by wrong lessons like this from the Iraq War.

Any "error" we might "correct" in hindsight might change the course of the war that we did end up winning.

On the bright side (tip to Instapundit), without admitting a mistake by returning US troops to Iraq, we are at least trying to help Iraq more than the Obama administration anticipated when it "responsibly" withdrew from Iraq, according to information cited in the Wall Street Journal:

[The] CIA has stepped up its assistance to the Iraqi Counterterrorism Service which includes Iraqi Special Operations units that were trained and mentored in the past by U.S. Special Operations forces? Iraqi forces are now working with American clandestine operatives to target al-Qaeda in Iraq and its Syrian offshoot, the al-Nusra Front. ...

This is, in essence, a second-best solution–better than nothing but not as good as keeping an American military contingent after 2011 as America’s military commanders on the ground had argued for. Does President Obama now regret, one wonders, not trying harder to secure a Status of Forces Agreement?

I guess the original Obama post-war plan wasn't so good. Which isn't too shocking considering Benghazi.

In an era when North Korea is threatening to nuke us and Iran is on the verge of nuclear-armed nutballery; and when Egypt could collapse Syria is in bloody open revolution, and Libya is a playground for jihadis, the relative stability of a weak but still democratic Iraq is a bright spot in the Middle East and in the fates of the Axis of Evil.

Imagine what we might be facing if Saddam or one of his evil spawns was running Iraq today? Would Iraq be in bloody sectarian revolt like Syria or look more like Iran in pursuit of WMD backed by oil income?

It was a good war, fought for good reasons, and waged by good troops.

Our troops brought us victory when lots of smart guys and gals said it was impossible to win there. It's up to us to defend that victory and exploit it to achieve more by establishing an alternative to the old choice of autocracy or Islamism to rule Moslems.

We certainly paid more than we hoped to achieve this victory. You'd think this fact would encourage us to expend the relatively trifling additional effort in Iraq to defend the victory. Fascinating articles about mistakes we could have avoided or about paying too high a price for victory are irrelevant since we did fight and win despite the mistakes and despite the added casualties and money. Are you really willing to argue that we should abandon Iraq now because you believe the price we paid was too high?

I bet that a lot of Americans would have decided that World War II was not worth the cost if you told them the price we'd pay to win. I bet a lot of Union war supporters would have decided that defeating the South and ending slavery were not objectives worth the price we paid if we could know the price beforehand. Once we have paid the price, why would you decide to reverse the gains or allow the gains to be reversed by failing to defend them?

I'll commend the Obama adminsitration for taking the step reported in that cited WSJ story. I'll really thank them if it is enough.

Are we doing enough to achieve that a decade after we smashed Saddam's armed forces?

UPDATE: Thanks to Mad Minerva for the link. She recommends Eric's Learning Curve to watch. It's nice to see people still willing to defend the war despite the "cool" kids bailing on it.

Monday, March 18, 2013

An Idea So Crazy It Might Just Work

We watch Syria burn and worry that it will explode across the region if it keeps burning. Logically, we refuse to try to have one side or the other win more quickly.

We don't have a Syria strategy. We have Syria talking points. Seriously, what's with this?

The Obama administration lent its support Monday to British and French plans to arm Syria's rebels, saying it wouldn't stand in the way of any country seeking to rebalance the fight against an Assad regime supported by Russia, Iran and Hezbollah.

Secretary of State John Kerry said the longer Syria's two-year civil war goes on, the greater the danger of its institutions collapsing and extremists getting their hands on the Arab country's vast chemical weapons arsenal. With some 450,000 Syrians living in neighboring countries as refugees already, he said the conflict is becoming a "global catastrophe."

We won't stand in the way of Britain or France arming the rebels? What would we do otherwise? Invade France? And isn't the notion of "rebalancing" the fight just another way to keep the fight going longer--which we say creates a greater danger of bad things happening?

But if you think we are just wringing our hands and watching this war drag on into a third year, think again!

President Barack Obama and other officials [have in the past said] more weapons in Syria would only make peace harder. As the violence has worsened over the last year, Washington has tempered that message somewhat. It is now promising nonlethal aid to the anti-Assad militias in the form of meals and medical kits, and refusing to rule out further escalation.

Yes, we might escalate to providing desserts in addition to those meals.

And there's a bonus Kerry gaffe when he appears not to be completely clear about who is fighting on what side. No worries. He's a Democrat, so no conclusions about his brain are justified.

If we want to end the war faster, help one side win the war. Otherwise, we're just backing a balance of terror.

I Suggest Doubling the Nuance Dosage

Once again, the Obama administration must reassure Poland on changes that reduce our planned missile defense capabilities to be based in eastern Europe.

Here we go with that smart diplomacy again:

U.S. officials visiting Warsaw tried to reassure Poland on Monday that the cancellation of the final stage of a European missile defense system will not sideline the country and was not made to appease Russia.

U.S. Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel announced last week that plans to place long-range missile interceptors in Poland in the next decade are being abandoned. As part of the announced changes, the U.S wants to place other interceptors in Alaska due to the threat from North Korea.

Well, at least this time the change wasn't done on the 70th anniversary of the Soviet invasion of Poland. So this is progress of sorts.

And recall that in 2009, the Obama administration claimed it was getting rid of a Bush-era missile planned for Europe in favor of proven Navy missiles. I didn't understand how these missiles could effectively cover all of Europe let alone defend America. Only later did I find out that the new plan relied on the Navy missiles only for a faster deployment of limited capabilities to defend Europe, and that longer-ranged missiles capable of defending America had to be developed.

So we didn't replace a new system with a proven system, after all. And now we are cancelling the new system for Europe because we are having problems developing it in order to pay for more Bush-era missiles in Alaska.

And we get to worry the Poles again. Bravo, Obama administration. Smart diplomacy and smart weapons acquisition! The nuance! It burns!

UPDATE: Thanks to Stones Cry Out for the link.

Talk to the Toasters

The Chinese want to wear out the Japanese by making it too hard to respond to continuous Chinese incursions around the Senkaku Islands. Keep doing this until Japan is too tired or too worn out to respond, and China is the only force around the islands. So Japan can't get too tired.

Strategypage writes about the Senkaku confrontations:

The new Chinese tactic of sending more and more boats and aircraft takes advantage of the fact that while Japan has better ships and crews, China has more patrol boats and men. In combat Japan would have an edge, but in this endurance contest the advantage shifts to China. In response Japan is building more patrol boats, bringing retired ships back into service and devising new tactics of its own that rely on technological advantages.

Oh, and Japan has to win this low level cold war while also making sure that Japan retains an edge in an actual fight for the islands. If Japan wins the cold war by not tiring but China then decides it has the option of going hot and winning, Japan still loses.

If Japan wants to rely on technological advantages that could negate China's strategy of tiring out the Japanese, I say send in the robots. They don't blink.

Blank Check

We promised to nuke North Korea if they strike South Korea.

South Korea is understandably worried about the unstable kooks with nukes up north. We want to reassure them:

US Deputy Defence Secretary Ashton Carter on Monday promised to provide South Korea with every military resource under the US nuclear umbrella at a time of heightened tensions with North Korea.

Carter was in Seoul on the second leg of a four-nation tour of US allies and partners in Asia including Japan, the Philippines and Indonesia.

"We remain steadfast to our commitment to extended deterrence offered by the US nuclear umbrella," Carter said after talks with South Korean Defence Minister Kim Kwan-Jin.

We really have to nuke North Korea if North Korea uses a nuke on South Korea. If we don't, extended deterrence dies and no ally of ours will want to be without nukes of their own for primary deterrence.

Not that this means we have to incinerate a city if North Korea strikes a South Korean city. I think we could incinerate military bases with nukes and avoid mass murder, yet still maintain our credibility in extended deterrence.

But this just puts off the major problem of extended deterrence. The problem is that it only really works when we aren't vulnerable to nuclear strikes. Any Ally of ours has to worry whether an Enemy nuclear attack on our Ally will prompt us to use nukes on the Enemy if the Enemy can then threaten to fire a nuke at one of our cities.

That was always a worry of our allies during the Cold War. They worried if we would trade New York City for Bonn, Paris, or London, and worried we'd share interests with Russia in restricting a nuclear war to European territory. So Britain and France had enough nukes to rubble up Russia, which would prompt Russia to strike America, which would make America know we could not avoid general nuclear war by fighting just a limited nuclear war.

Really, at some point if nuclear proliferation among our enemies continues, it is in our interest to promote proliferation among our trusted allies so that they can deter--or fight--local nuclear wars without involving us. A blank nuclear check isn't something we want cashed when nutballs can fire nukes at us, too.