Sunday, November 20, 2022

Weekend Data Dump

Sons of fire ships get air support.

Poland buys Reaper.

The Arab Middle East has been relatively quiet as wars in Libya, Syria, Iraq, and Yemen have returned to a simmer. Meanwhile in Jordan, the government feels the need to ratchet up the repression. What will that lead to? The 2011 Arab Spring largely failed. But the desire for something other than the traditional choice of autocratic or mullah rule persists. Change takes time. And I don't assume we live in that era.

Preventing China from taking Taiwan is forging an alliance between Australia, Japan, and America.

It is atrocious that it takes so long for America to count votes. We demand more from Third World countries. But don't nationalize election control to do that. States should still be in charge of their own elections. And states have cleaned up past poor performance. Like Florida. 

Terrorist explosion in Istanbul. Jihadis or Kurds? Former seems far more likely.

Space troopers? Nice name, Space Force. But until we have SMOD I won't be satisfied.

Germany practices reinforcing Estonia. That is useful, depending on the scenario. But don't let the Baltic states become a kill sack. I don't assume the Russians can't improve on their Ukraine performance.

I'll ask again, doesn't rank-choice-voting violate the principle of "one man, one vote"? Making something more complicated is the opposite of transparency. Could rank-choice-voting be challenged in court?

A Russian software company posed as an American company. Oops.

Japan, South Korea, and America basically tell North Korea that it can't nuke any of the three without all of them effing up North Korea really hard.

The Army announces Atlantic Resolve rotation to Europe of a division HQ, armored brigade, combat aviation brigade, and sustainment brigade.

Will military leadership "do the right thing"? It would be nice. Although obviously civilian control of the military complicates things. It would be better if a president would purge 'em all and let God sort them out.

I want to defeat Russia's invasion of Ukraine. But I'd rather have defeat lead to Russia flipping rather than secession or even Russia collapsing.

Democracy Dies in Dreckness.

The death of FTX. I don't trust crypto-currencies. I may be a fool for not jumping in. And maybe some are less risky than others. But I don't trust them. Tip to Instapundit.

I certainly wouldn't rule out yesterday's "wild conspiracy theory" becoming tomorrow's proven fact. 

The calls that threaten Russia's future are coming from inside the house. Tip to Instapundit.

Science! "Parents should 'avoid physical interaction with unvaccinated individuals' to keep their families safe from respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), according to NBC News, even though there is no RSV vaccine." And Journalism! Tip to Instapundit.

A tour of Russia's problems.

The KC-46A clusterfuck.

I'm starting to think that biological men winning in women's sports is a clever Republican ploy to get women and parents to abandon the cheering Democrats. What else makes sense?

China has problems. But there is a bright side! "Some of China’s investments in industry policy have paid off, in solar energy, wind turbines and electric vehicles, the supply chains of which are dominated by China." Funny how Western elites are so eager to rapidly adopt these technologies.

Pretending science justifies suppression of dissent. These wannabe prison camp guards can bugger off. Tip to Instapundit.

The Block 4 improved F-35 being planned.

The Navy intercepted 70 tons of  rocket fuel being smuggled from Iran to Yemen. The Houthi Iranian proxies seem to be waking from a ceasefire slumber.

Ethiopia and Tigray separatists agreed to move forward on talks, with humanitarian provisions during talks.

Worries about China: "The Philippines on Tuesday said defence ally the United States had agreed to spend $66.5 million to start building training and warehouse facilities at three of its military bases, under a 2014 joint security deal."

More from the climate "the end of the world is nigh" lunatics (via Instapundit): "Climate activists poured black liquid over a glass screen protecting Gustav Klimt's masterpiece 'Death and Life' in Vienna on Tuesday, in the latest protest at inaction over global heating." One day these proliferating freaks will go full Army of the Twelve Monkeys on humanity, won't they? These are the real white terrorist threats, eh?

DeSantis-Lake 2024?

Did the Biden-Xi meeting in Indonesia convince China that America doesn't want to destroy the Chinese economy; and convince America that China doesn't want to risk war with America?

Did Biden funnel money to Ukraine in order to launder taxpayer money back to the Democratic party via FTX? A lot of government expenditures are Democratic Party money laundering operations through pro-Democrat organizations. Ukraine needs to be careful not to appear as a part of the Democratic Party machine. But did the Biden administration give Ukraine a choice? Perhaps this isn't what it looks like. But given the record, I wouldn't bet that way.

Canada is experiencing an "unprecedented" military recruiting crisis. Call the most likely recruits unpleasant criminals, and that's what you get. To be fair, Trudeau and his party are way worse than Biden and his party.

That's not unreasonable to think: "Most voters believe cheating may have influenced this year’s elections, and think voting by mail makes it easier to cheat." In an evenly divided country, effective cheating in just 3 out of 435 House seats could be decisive. Securing elections doesn't mean keeping valid voters from voting. But it would increase confidence of those who lose elections. Tip to Instapundit.

Whither Trump? Democrats may salivate. But it would be hilarious if Republicans clearly reject Trump and greatly reduce Democrats' ability to use Trump for their constant two-minute hates.

To be fair, Warnock expected the media to hide his behavior and is a little stunned it hasn't. Via Instapundit.

North Korea continues to rot from within. But Kim Jong Un's missile test barrage brilliantly deterred America from invading that Pearl of Northeast Asia. An invasion America has been patiently preparing for nearly 70 years now.

The cannon fodder protests its role. When do they reject and run from their role?

Ukraine is playing up the Russian missile that hit Polish territory and killed two as a significant escalation. But Ukraine is eager for NATO intervention. Ukraine wants a NATO no-fly zone to defend Ukrainian air space. But I'm reasonably sure this was an accident that was bound to happen eventually as the war drags on. And even if an escalation, it is really a meaningless one NATO can safely ignore--other than with defensive measures and improving Ukraine's air defenses. This analyst reports it was a Ukrainian air defense missile that landed.

The Navy wants more ships and subs, but can't get its subs out of port when they are in for repair. No way letting these high value vessels wallow in port is a problem. 

Oh: "Disorganization and bureaucracy could hamper the US military's production of ammunition, according to a new report from a government watchdog." On the bright side, better to learn this now than during a big war with our troops on the line.

Good. But we spent more than enough on Artemis to expect it to fly successfully one day, no? God willing, it will get us back to the moon. But it is too expensive to sustain our presence.

Good: "U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris will visit the Philippine islands of Palawan on the edge of the disputed South China Sea, a senior administration official said on Tuesday, in a move that may be interpreted by Beijing as a rebuke." Better would be visiting an island China claims.

Sure, let's keep up our guard in the Arctic. But let's not push the argument that Russia's military sucks everywhere but in the Arctic. POLARCOM?

We see your fanatical willingness to die for your cause. And we raise you killer robots that mean we don't have to die to kill you. Now they are armed witn "non-lethal" weapons. Although that just seems to make it easier for attackers to destroy it. But the weapons mounted can change. I'd have more sympathy for the Palestinians if their corrupt leadership wasn't more concerned with personal benefits than the welfare of the people.

"Justice."

Iran's ethnic minorities seem to be joining Persian protesters. An apparent first. For a rump Persian empire with lots of regional minorities that seems important. Protests and resistance spiked up in mid-month.

The Biden administration was willing to spend a billion dollars for Taliban-controlled Afghanistan. But is unwilling to reveal how. Better to have spent that money over the last year+ to keep the Taliban from winning. But I disagree with the aside that America left an "advanced" arsenal to the Taliban. The error was abandoning the Afghanistan government--not the weapons the Taliban captured because of that error.

Why only the 2020 election is subject to ridicule for and fear of "election deniers" is a rhetorical question, I assume.

Ukraine's October attack on Sevastopol.

Russia's stumbling industrial mobilization. I'd gloat, but are Western countries doing better just manufacturing more 155mm shells?

Horrible. Criminal. But not "shocking": "An enormous mass grave dating back to the Russian Revolution has been discovered in the Transnistria region of Moldova, in which most of the dead bodies belonged to Jews who were accused of opposing the communist regime."

Yes, despite my vote, Michigan seemingly made it impossible to detect fraudulent voting.  I was horrified at the provisions. And at putting them in the state constitution. And pro side commercials hiding behind veterans. I was in the minority.

Remember when the "nuclear documents" Trump had at Mar-a-Lago were a danger to America? "Federal agents and prosecutors have come to believe former president Donald Trump’s motive for allegedly taking and keeping classified documents was largely his ego and a desire to hold on to the materials as trophies or mementos, according to people familiar with the matter." Ef the FBI. Ef the media. Nice clarification after the election.

The Ethiopians have another active armed struggle going on.

I've mentioned that America knits together countries in bilateral defense agreements with America to resits China. The Japan-Australia deepening defense cooperation cuts out the middle man as the only way to achieve cooperation.

Iran struck a tanker with a drone in the Gulf of Oman. The Israel-Iran quasi war continues. 

Speaking of a "barbed wire curtain" arising on NATO's border with Russia and Belarus is an awful implicit comparison to the "iron curtain" the USSR built early in the Cold War. The former is to keep people being used by Moscow out. The latter was to keep unwilling people in. Huge difference.

NATO states have pledged more air defense weapons for Ukraine.

Is China's rise taking us to an Asia Century short-circuiting? We've had indications. Not that Asia won't be important or even paramount in our concerns, of course.

If states got used to the federal government shoveling money into their budgets "because of Covid" got used to that "revenue" they are in for a world of hurt going forward.

The Black Sea food export deal was extended. Interesting that Russia isn't dragging feet. They may need income as much as Ukraine and fear being blamed for its end. Which is a far cry from hoping to blackmail the world into supporting Russia.

Enough? "China and India, after months of refusing to condemn Russia’s war in Ukraine, did not stand in the way of the release this week of a statement by the world’s leading economies that strongly criticizes Moscow." Hypocrisy is a compliment vice pays to virtue, I suppose. Although I'm more understanding of India's stance.

Is "integrated deterrence" just a buzz term to justify defense cuts? That's my worry. I'll be happy if this is meant to add all elements of national power to military power rather than substituting for military power.

That seems prudent: "U.S., Japanese, Australian and Canadian warships are currently staging extensive joint drills in Japanese and international waters, the U.S. Navy said Wednesday."

American aircraft readiness kind of sucks.

LOL:


Sweden will send its largest military aid package thus far to Ukraine.

Syria's Assad is getting even less support from Iran and Russia now. Israel is providing non-weapon support to Ukraine. And Iran stays pre-revolution. But is that changing? Will Iran's fear of civil war provoke one?

Russia can't offer much to Iran. 

What we know about the X-37B.  Four "possibles", a "potentially", and a bevy of "coulds" don't scream "know" to me. 

Another warning that negotiations to end the Winter War of 2022 are premature. A little more emphasis on winning that war, please. Getting ahead of ourselves is a good way to lose a war the good guys are winning.

Good! "The United States is now exporting over 60 percent of its liquid national gas (LNG) to Europe, up from 20 percent a year ago. U.S. LNG imports currently provide more gas to Europe than pipeline gas from Russia in an effort some have labeled the Berlin 'Gas Lift.'" Although why we aren't opening the spigots to all energy production here is beyond me.

Also: "Another ploy of Moscow is spreading propaganda that foreign aid has gone astray and that corrupt Ukrainian officials are siphoning off economic and military assistance." It is true that Ukraine is corrupt. I've worried about that. But it doesn't make Ukraine less of a victim of aggression worthy of support. Nor does it make the need to defeat Russia any less necessary.

Despite Western military production bottle necks exposed by the effort to supply Ukraine, Russia's military industry is seemingly in worse shape. I really want to know if Russia is able to produce enough artillery ammunition and what their stockpiles are.

Sh*t gets real when North Korea gets working ICBMs with working warheads. It's bad for America and bad for Japan and South Korea which rely on American nukes to deter North Korea from attacking them. Our allies will wonder if we'll trade Seattle for Tokyo or Seoul on their behalf.

Things the pro-Democrat media can talk about--for a while--only after the election. Until proven otherwise, I think rigging the media is the biggest way Democrats put their thumbs on the election scales.

Lab-grown meat safe to eat. If it's good and affordable, I'll try it. Will food fanatics call it "Frankenmeat" to undermine it the way they do for similarly safe GMO crops? Tip to Instapundit.

Oh? "If [student] loan dollars are to flow, borrowers should be made to understand the terms." What part of "you have to pay back loans" is unclear? When I was 17 entering college--the first in my family in Detroit to go, so I hardly had sophisticated understanding of finance--I knew that I didn't want the higher rate loans being offered on my financial aid! This isn't rocket science. Tip to Instapundit.

Vile police states kill off the crippled and other "undesirables." Compassionate, progressive states give those people the "option" of killing themselves. Way different, eh?

The Russian spy who came in from the cold.

Nine months into the war, the U.S. still hasn't addressed production of key weapons and ammunition to avoid draining American war reserve stocks too much. I really think Biden assumed Ukraine would have lost by now and would get credit for trying to save Ukraine. And avoiding the cost of actually saving Ukraine.

If we are warning China that invading Taiwan would face the same outcome as Russia invading Ukraine, we'd best make sure Russia loses. Decisively.

America should be expanding oil production rather than tapping the Strategic Petroleum Reserve now.

American defense spending is assuming China won't attack Taiwan within the next 5 years. Is that wise? We'd spend differently if we knew our assumption is wrong. We might be assuming too much from our shields' ability to buy us time. 

I'm less impressed with Google's all-knowing algorithm. A couple months ago I restored my YouTubeTV account and it wouldn't let me take advantage of an initial lower price deal because I'm a former customer. Oh well. And this week the service invites me to reactivate my TV service for World Cup. Their knowledge of me is clearly limited.

The X-37A, X-37B, X-37C, and China's version.

The Army sets its modernization objective and remained focused on it. And it is working. May this skill translate to warfighting.

A CRS report on the Ukrainian military at war: "To date, the UAF has sustained significant equipment losses. Some UAF units appear to be operating without mechanized or motorized vehicle support, likely due to losses and maintenance issues."

This seems significant: "The ongoing, anti-regime protests are likely creating fractures among senior regime officials within the Iranian security establishment."

And so Qatar hosts the first--and last--World Cup in a Arab Moslem country: "The FIFA World Cup has banned beer from stadiums days before the soccer tournament is set to begin in Qatar."

Nothing says restoring Russia's glory like needing Iran's help for weapons production: "Iran and Russia have finalized an agreement to build hundreds of weaponized drones in Russian territory[.]"

Justice?  

The mullah regime is ramping up the use of force against Iranian protesters. The mullah regime may need even more force: "The number and scale of ongoing, anti-regime protests have already intensified in recent days. ... Protests have also become increasingly violent--for protesters and security personnel alike—in recent days."

Europe has gotten over its worry about Chinese power and human rights and is rejecting American policy. Europe is now eager to sell China the rope advanced computer chips to hang the West. I was reassured by the nuanced class that the "trans-Atlantic rift" was all Trump's fault.

Trump didn't create the populist, conservative, blue collar parade. He jumped in front and led it for a while. Yes, Trump voters think Trump was screwed in 2020. Indeed, from 2015-2021. But "his" voters wanted his policies and haven't given up that hope. Their priority isn't his redemption. Most people are moving on. And the coalition is actually growing. Waiting for someone to replace Trump to achieve their hopes. And if Democrats continue to call this coalition "deplorable"--or whatever new term they come up with, the coalition will grow larger. Too large for the pro-Democrat media to overwhelm. Tip to Instapundit. 

If the Russians are big on omens, this is ominous: "Towering clouds of ash and glowing lava are spewing from two volcanoes on Russia's Kamchatka Peninsula and scientists say major eruptions could be on the way."

An "election" in Kazakhstan.  I have no idea if this reflects better or worse relations with Russia.

The new Democratic Party-backed "peculiar institution." Dressing up hate with compassion and "science" is nothing new. Tip to Instapundit.

Retaliation: "Turkey launched deadly airstrikes over northern regions of Syria and Iraq, the Turkish Defense Ministry said Sunday, targeting Kurdish groups that Ankara holds responsible for last week’s bomb attack in Istanbul." I didn't think Turkey's Kurdish separatists were the suicide-bomber type. I guess that's changed. Or maybe it wasn't a suicide bomber as I thought the news initially stated.

Poor countries manage to stage a shakedown from guilt-ridden Western leadership.

You go to war with the weapons you can use now; and not the superior weapons you wish you had.

Saturday, November 19, 2022

And Now For Something Completely Different

Mommy's alright, Daddy's alright. They just meme a little weird. Surrender, surrender. But don't give yourself away.

 

  

 


 


 


 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 









Friday, November 18, 2022

Does the European Union Defend Europe or the EU's Ambitions?

Will the European Union step up to defend Europe or is the Russian invasion of Ukraine just an opportunity to strengthen the EU's political power over the for-now sovereign states of the EU?

Americans are a little annoyed that Europe isn't stepping up to arm Ukraine despite its greater collective GDP:

In the key area of military aid, the gap is even wider: the US has pledged $24 billion, the Europeans only $12 billion. The actual difference may be greater, as key European donors have reportedly been slow to deliver on their pledges.

That was a month ago. The inability of our mostly European NATO allies to match American arms and ammunition supplies for Ukraine is a growing problem as the war drags on. Both for Ukraine's ability to fight--let alone liberate territory--and for America's willingness to spend money on Ukraine.

Yet America also worries about what Ukraine might do with more capable American weapons. We haven't sent tanks, fighter planes, and long-range missiles, for example. We don't want Ukraine to be able to take the war deep into Russian territory.

Both of these things reflect what has been a long-time American worry that allies will drag America into a war if they have too much ability to wage war:

We tend not to encourage allies to have large stocks of ammunition for US-designed weapons because we don't want allies to have the ability to wage a war for long that we disapprove of.

Will that change because of Putin's invasion? Would the European Union step up to bolster European weapons and ammunition stockpiles? That would be an actual useful program.

Or does the EU want its own military as part of its political project of stripping the prefix from its proto-imperial state, contrary to what proponents offer as reasons?

... The alternative to a EU military is not America standing alone. We have NATO. Which is the military alliance that has defended Europe and promoted European freedom since the Cold War started. Don't let the EU elites confuse the difference between geographic Europe which is the basis for NATO and political Europe which is the basis for an empire.

And any autonomous EU military will naturally subtract resources from the proven military alliance that has defended Europe. Nothing inherent to NATO prevents Europeans from building stronger military power.

Further, NATO does not prevent European countries from sharing weapon production to gain efficiency. So that is a BS reason to gut NATO to fund a EU military. 

As for the second reason, we're supposed to lie back and think of nuance as the inevitable EU military is formed? 

What Euro-elite apparatchiki want is the "autonomous" part and they don't care if the military they get is stronger than what European countries contribute through NATO now. The purpose of a EU military is to gut NATO and therefore eject American influence from the continent.

Although we have to be careful of even European military industry.

The EU pushes its most heartfelt goal even during this war: 

The European Union will train thousands of Ukrainian soldiers on its own soil [...]

Mind you, that's great. But the European Union does not have its own soil. That's the soil of sovereign member states. For now. The proto-imperial EU wants to strip away the prefix, so likes to confuse the terminology to pretend "Europe" is synonymous with the European Union.

The EU is a threat to European states from within Europe:

Are we going to let an egomaniac build an anti-American empire in Europe? Oh, I'm not talking about Putin. We're resisting him. I'm talking about France's Macron.

America has successfully prevented a Kaiser, Hitler, and Communists from taking all of Europe. We're nipping Putin's imperial bid for glory and territory in the bud.

Let's not forfeit this record of success by allowing EU bureaucrats--whether under Macron or someone else--exploit yet another crisis to control Europe and give anti-American forces the opportunity to organize the potential military power of the continent against America. 

NOTE: War updates continue here.

Thursday, November 17, 2022

The German Question

Can Germany take its rightful place in the West? Or does it still not understand what that place is?


Sigh: 

Germany has relinquished any aspirations of a leadership role in Europe. Its inadequate response to Russia’s attack on Ukraine has exposed Berlin more as an obstacle to European security rather than as a defender. German policy is also hypocritical by preaching anti-corruption to Balkan states seeking to join the European Union while enabling massive Russian penetration of its economy and political system. ...

 After months of pressure from its own public and NATO partners, Berlin finally began to supply Kyiv with desperately needed air-defense systems, multiple rocket launchers, and self-propelled howitzers.  

Yet Berlin has also been hesitant in imposing tough economic sanctions against Moscow. Again, it fears the impact on its own economy rather than taking the strategic high ground. Germany is also dragging its feet on providing economic support for Ukraine.

I hoped Germany had decided to join the West:

Putin's invasion of Ukraine was the clue bat Germany needed

Germany's 2014 pledge to NATO and even Trump's public hectoring failed to get Germany to rearm from the Holiday from History after NATO won the Cold War. 

Putin's invasion of Ukraine--built on his supposed fear of invasion from the West--has convinced Germany to rearm seriously. Strategery. Will none of Putin's advisors tell him he is effing up royally? 

The only bright spot for Russia is that Germany had sunk so low that the climb back up will be long. NATO must pray it is not too late.

Germany seems to be having second thoughts about being a defender of European security. The shock of the immediate crisis has passed. And now bad habits of fantasy world pacifism stir again.

Even after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, war crimes, and nuclear threats, Germany still needs a good whack with the Clue Bat:

I keep reading that the Germans hate their militaristic past so much that they don't want to fight.

Let's try applying the clue bat to Germany's collective skull on this issue.

Conquering and setting up death camps under the shield of a powerful military? That's bad. By all means, don't do that.

Having a military capable of fighting death cult enemies or stopping the Russians from moving west? Well, that's a good thing. Try doing that.

Amazingly (back to the article):

The one party that has learned practical lessons from Germany’s own imperial history is the Greens, who contend that a genocidal regime has to be stopped by military force as early as possible.

It would be nice if the Germans could display a little bit of that nuance I'm assured Europeans naturally have. Could Germany find a nice median between trying to brutally conquer Europe and self-destructive supine pacifism?

NOTE: War updates continue here.

Wednesday, November 16, 2022

The Mountains are High and the Emperor is Clueless

Fear is not always the beginning of wisdom. Can Chinese Communist Party rulers trust their trusted sources of domestic information? 


The Chinese Communist Party thinks it has a separate flow of accurate information separate from the propaganda for the masses: 

The reports are classified as state secrets, giving them an air of mystery in China. They are called “neican,” which is pronounced “NAY-tsahn” and means “internal reference.” ...

Newspapers, think tanks and universities across China each have their own classified reporting channel, sending intelligence up to local and provincial officials. They monitor air pollution in industrial Hebei province and guide the disposal of spoiled pickles in Hunan, a region famed for its cuisine. ...

The Communist Party calls internal reporting a secret weapon, acting as its “eyes and ears,” while propaganda acts as its “throat and tongue.”

Is it working?

But this internal system is struggling to give frank assessments as Chinese leader Xi Jinping consolidates his power, making it risky for anyone to directly question the party line even in confidential reports, a dozen Chinese academics, businesspeople and state journalists said in interviews with The Associated Press.

I've long read that lower level officials tell superiors what they want to hear, making the shit roll uphill. The example I recall reading was about economic statistics. Individually, officials might inflate statistics a bit upward as the information goes up. They'd even think that their own fiction that helped them and/or concealed their corruption was insignificant because the others were reporting good information. But the practice was common.

Apparently the leadership is starting to realize that they've been the victims of lower level officials' misleading-if sometimes inadvertent if merely passing on bad information rather than creating it--throats and tongues. 

The mountains are high and the emperor is far clueless.

The problem isn't just for the CCP, of course. Lack of information can--and has--harmed the rest of the world when the Covid-19 virus erupted in China:

In the early days of the virus outbreak in Wuhan, Xinhua’s Liao reported the arrest of eight “rumormongers” for spreading “false information.”

In fact, they were doctors warning each other about the emerging virus in online chats. Her story discouraged others from speaking up, leaving the central leadership blind to the virus’ spread.

I've been comforted to read that China's rulers know their military isn't as good as it appears. But what if the "neican" system means the CCP has no way to know how large the gap between reality and their reports is?

How can the CCP possibly use their genetically superior long-range planning abilities with bad information, eh?

And if the crisis is an international confrontation involving China, how can we possibly believe we can send those sacred, calibrated "signals" of restrained resolve that we think will cool off the crisis? What will our signal look like when it reaches the highest levels of the CCP?

The nuanced signal that our best and brightest craft might be twisted by the Chinese reporting system into a signal of retreat or a signal of intent to preemptively strike China. Delusion will be built on layers of delusions.

Can the CCP order the information flow to be honest? Can the lower level sources of information afford to admit they've been lying? 

Have a super sparkly day.

NOTE: War updates continue here.

Tuesday, November 15, 2022

How Much Money Will the Army Waste Failing to Design an Alternative to the Tank?

The Abrams is getting old. I've worried about it reaching the end of its life because of limits to what can be added or changed to the platform. But replacing the tank with a new model has failed repeatedly, leaving the Abrams--with another update--our primary main battle tank. Can a redesigned Abrams provide a proven platform and the ability to be updated decades more?


These authors thinks the Army should stick to what it knows and replace the Abrams tank with the Abrams X:

As the Army determines the future of the Abrams tank, it should remember that when it comes to purchasing new equipment, it’s often the easiest and cheapest to stick with what you know.

The Army is expected to make an initial determination on the Abrams’ successor next year. Rather than building an entirely new tank, like the Decisive Lethality Platform [PDF], the Army should continue along the Abrams’ iterative design route and purchase the Abrams X with the goal of the first production unit being in the hands of Army soldiers this decade.

The Abrams X is a technology demonstrator rather than a prototype. So it isn't meant to be put into production.

But the authors have a point about an iterative approach to replacing the current (updated) Abrams. The features of the Abrams X need to be examined to see which features are iterative and should be on the replacement model for introduction this decade. And which features need more work to make them affordable and reliable, and more appropriate for a future iterative update. 

I especially like the lighter frame--and I'm assuming this doesn't reduce protection--and new engine for better mileage and the ability to operate quietly while stationary. And if the platform's new software/AI package is built for future updates, that's great, too.

As I argued twenty years ago in Military Review (see pp. 28-33), the Army should not try to leapfrog technology attempting to build the FCS "wonder tank." As I wrote:

Barring successfully fielding exotic technologies to make the FCS work, the Army must consider how it will defeat future heavy systems if fighting actual enemies and not merely suppressing disorder becomes its mission once again. The tentative assumptions of 2001 will change by 2025. When they do, the Army will rue its failure today to accept that the wonder tank will not be built.
Although the Army will again be tempted to replace the Abrams tank with a non-tank, the Abrams may yet again be the wonder tank we refuse to appreciate in another Plan B.

Building the "unmanned wonder tank Decisive Lethality Platform" will be no easier than earlier revolutionary plans. But technological hope springs eternal, I fear.

NOTE: War updates continue here.

Monday, November 14, 2022

The Winter War of 2022 Prepares to Hibernate?

The war may slow down regardless of what Ukraine may want to do. Russia will rejoice. But the war doesn't need to slow down.


Ukraine has compelled Russia to withdraw from around Kiev and has mounted sizable offensives in the east and in Kherson province. But we are six weeks from those big attacks. Those big attacks grabbed chunks of territory but could not close the deal by sustaining a drive deeper than the first push. There were no Ukrainian reserves with the logistics to push into the fight and exploit the Russian retreats with even deeper advances.

Even the Russian retreat from the west bank of the Dnieper River in Kherson province this last week was apparently done mostly on Russia's terms and not compelled by Ukrainian ground advances. Yes, Ukrainian fires missions to muck up Russian supply lines across the river compelled the retreat. But that's different. Significant. But different.

If the fog of war dissipates enough to show that Ukraine captured significant numbers of Russian troops and equipment, I'll revise my thinking.

And the winter may preclude such deep advances. But the Ukrainians might be able to repeat the Kharkov and Kherson front drives if the Ukrainians have the winter clothing and gear, and other support to attack. I've been writing that I think a winter counteroffensive makes sense for Ukraine.

ISW thinks this is likely:

Some military equipment may need to be adapted for colder weather, and shortages of equipment or ammunition could slow advances due to logistical difficulties — not winter weather.[3] Winter weather could disproportionately harm poorly-equipped Russian forces in Ukraine, but well-supplied Ukrainian forces are unlikely to halt their counteroffensives due to the arrival of winter weather and may be able to take advantage of frozen terrain to move more easily than they could in the muddy autumn months. If fighting does halt this winter, it will be due to logistical challenges and the culmination of several campaigns on both sides.

And if Ukraine can do that, I can't rule out that a Ukrainian winter counteroffensive could drive Russians out of their front line shelter into the open, and crack the morale of the Russian army. It could be on that sector only. Or it might spread across the entire front.

That winter counteroffensive won't be an assault river crossing, I think. Unless Russian morale is already near the breaking point. I think it is far more likely that Ukraine would launch an offensive further east, aimed south from Zaporizhzhya with Melitopol as the objective. ISW believes Ukraine will thin out their lines in Kherson to reinforce the Donbas defenders; and to attack in Luhansk or some other unnamed location. Again, I'd go for the latter attack location and name it Melitopol.

On the other side, with Russia claiming that only half of the Russian troops on the west side of the Dnieper River will be used to hold the lines on the eastern bank, what will Russia do with the extra troops?

It would be smart to form a reserve. But I wouldn't be shocked if the Russians throw them into new attacks on entrenched Ukrainians in the Donbas. That's what ISW thinks.

There won't be much hibernating this winter.

UPDATE: I have long suspected that Ukraine will advance south toward Melitopol rather than try to assault the Russian line holding the Dnieper River in Kherson. But. Ukraine has river patrol boats. And we haven't seen Ukraine use any airmobile capability. 

We have also sent helicopters and 105mm howitzers to Ukraine. I had hoped an advance to the river in Kherson province might have used that capability to take a crossing on the run. Could Ukraine grab a bridgehead with a brigade moved by helicopter against the thinned out Russian defenders? Under cover of modern air defenses and Western rocket and and howitzer fire? And then the engineers go to work to span the river for reinforcements and supplies? 

And after brushing back the Russian navy and air power from Crimea, could the Ukrainian navy put in an appearance on the coast to land and support troops? 

Just trying to look at options.

UPDATE (Tuesday): Regarding my sea option musing, rumors of Ukrainian plans to take Kinburn Spit to outflank Russia's Dnieper River line. Plan or distraction from a Melitopol thrust? 

UPDATE: Rumors of Russian forces retreating from the east bank of the Dnieper River in Kherson. Big if true. And are ultra-nationalists going to push Putin to give a Hitlerian army-destroying "no retreat" order? Tips to PJ Media.

A while ago I wrote that the direction of the war would be on the knife's edge until it started to fall to one side. And then its movement could accelerate. Slowly and then rapidly. The cumulative losses on the Russian side might be reaching that accelerating point. If Ukraine can push the Russian ground forces over the edge.

UPDATE: Accident or shot across the bow? "Russian missiles flew over NATO territory and killed two people in Poland Tuesday, a senior U.S. intelligence official told The Associated Press." If deliberate, NATO's retaliation should be additional and more capable weapons for Ukraine. But with Russia's crappy weapons, it could be an accident.

Also, were no air defenses active in Poland?

UPDATE: Honestly, even if deliberate, why get too worked up? Russia can't handle Ukraine. It can't handle NATO, too. So it would be an empty deliberate threat. 

The NATO response if deliberate should be to activate air defenses that don't reach into Russian or Belarus territory to shoot down additional incoming missiles. And to help Ukraine more. Don't panic and don't think of this as an escalation that leads to general war. Calm down, people. Don't make this worse.

UPDATE (Wednesday): Per ISW, Russia scraped up precision missiles for a blitz on Ukraine's infrastructure. Likely timed for the G20 meeting, they say. Ukraine shot down a lot. One apparently hit Polish territory, killing two.

Also, it does not appear as if Ukrainian forces are operating on the eastern bank of the Dnieper River on the Kherson front. Although recon probes are possible.

UPDATE: It's even possible that the missile was a Ukrainian air defense missile coming down after missing incoming Russian missiles. What goes up must come down. Such air defense damage was common when America attacked Baghdad in two wars--with America getting wrongly blamed. But I recently read that Russian S-300s in their primary air defense role are designed to detonate if they miss to prevent ground impact explosions. Although that fail safe might have failed.

Would this incident advance the formation of the Flying Nightingales?

UPDATE: Apparently it was a Ukrainian air defense missile that struck Poland. 

UPDATE (Thursday): Fascinating: "Currently the Ukrainians have more operational tanks than the Russian forces do inside Ukraine." [UPDATE (Saturday): I meant to mention that in part this is misleading because long sections of the theoretical front line are now the border. So Russia no doubt has tanks inside Russia that are really on the front. All of Ukraine's tanks are in Ukraine.]

UPDATE: Interesting: "Ukrainian forces continued targeting Russian forces and logistics nodes in the rear areas of Zaporizhia Oblast and Kherson Oblast." Does this telegraph an offensive heading south in Zaporizhia with a supporting attack from Kherson across the Dnieper River? Or would Ukraine prefer to attack in Luhansk and potentially break the Luhansk Russian puppet and take out those forces from the front?

UPDATE (Friday): The Swedish investigation has found traces of explosives at the locations of the Nordstream pipeline blast. I assumed this was an accident from insufficient or non-existent Russian maintenance. Who did it? Not that I'm upset over it. Assuming the Swedes aren't giving inconclusive evidence more certainty than the evidence deserves.

UPDATE: Also, Russia continues to crawl forward in the east, taking small bites shoving troops into the teeth of Ukrainian defenses.

UPDATE (Saturday): This CRS short report on Ukraine's military has this:

The UAF still relies on a core of professional units to conduct combined arms operations and spearhead operations, supported by TDF and Reserve units. As mentioned, training new recruits to replace and expand these professional units could prove decisive in the coming months.

It sounds like a lot of Ukraine's ground units are suitable for somewhat static combat operations or lack the equipment to spearhead offensives. 

That's a problem in long static wars. Germans trained divisions in new tactics to spearhead late World War I offensives on the Western front to compensate for all the divisions useful for static trench fighting only. Saddam Hussein expanded his Republican Guards to two corps for the same reason later in the Iran-Iraq War.

When will the New Army being trained in the West be committed to battle? It seems like some were involved in Kherson but took significant losses early in that counteroffensive. They are clearly needed to put pressure on the Russian army and retake more territory.

UPDATE: Is it my imagination or are Russian attacks on the Donetsk front more intense now? Is this the result of reinforcements from the Kherson front?

UPDATE (Sunday): I guess it isn't my imagination:

Russian forces are reportedly beginning to reinforce their positions in occupied Luhansk, Donetsk, and eastern Zaporizhia oblasts with personnel from Kherson Oblast and mobilized servicemen. ...

Russian forces will likely continue to use mobilized and redeployed servicemen to reignite offensive operations in Donetsk Oblast and maintain defensive positions in Luhansk Oblast.

So Russia attacks in the east--again. Where will Ukraine launch a new counteroffensive?

NOTE: ISW updates continue here.

Sunday, November 13, 2022

Weekend Data Dump

We observed another Veterans Day. Thank you to those who have served and sacrificed throughout our history. I served in the military--Army Signal Corps. But it was minor service. Basic training was the toughest time I had. As I've noted, the closest I got to going to war was very nearly getting sent to the Persian Gulf in 1991. And even if sent, I would have been very safe. I was too young to be sent to Vietnam. And too old to be sent to Iraq or Afghanistan. I'll always feel a bit guilty about that. And I'll always feel more guilt about the first guilt as a cheap and easy emotion to feel.

I was listening to a George Friedman speech. I respect and like him. But he again said Ukraine's army had no center of gravity, allowing Ukraine to effectively wage irregular warfare with anti-tank weapons on the Russian invaders. But that was only true in the northeast. Ukraine had ten very good brigades in the Donbas. That was a center of gravity. Ukraine strongly held the capital, Kiev. That was a center of gravity.

Recalculating.

Space Force's X-37B has broken its record for time in orbit--and is still going after more than 900 days up there.

The Middle East is no longer the site for routine aircraft carrier deployments. We don't need the extra firepower for the threats we face. And other regions have higher priority. If the Air Force can't handle air power needs I don't know why the Navy couldn't do the job without carriers. 

More good jihadis in Somalia courtesy of the United States African Command.

The U.S. is committed to increasing the missile defense of Guam. 

Don't be suckers, infantry. A robotic mule to carry your stuff just means senior officers will add more stuff your units has to move around. And when the mule breaks down, gets stuck in the mud, or takes a crippling hit, all the stuff on the mule will be redistributed to your non-robotic backs. But I'm cynical that way. Does the Army like having leg infantry, or not?

The Victims of Communism Day is something we should all remember, as our young people just think Karl Marx is a black and white version of Santa Claus.

Ah, the joys of insufficient police power: "A powerful gang leader announced Sunday that he was lifting a blockade at a key fuel terminal that has strangled Haiti's capital for nearly two months."

Is it just me or am I hearing and reading the hitherto unused expression "top of mind" a lot since Karine Jean-Pierre used the term to excuse Biden's failure to remember a Congressional ally had recently passed away? 

Turkey and Ukraine called Russia's bluff to keep the food exports out of the Black Sea going. I did wonder last week if the Russians would dare attack the food ships.

The XQ-58A Valkyrie stealthy drone.

How powerful is Xi Jinping? "A tiger does not proclaim his tigritude," calls into question his power. What applies to military power perhaps applies to Xi. I have wondered how the rest of the CCP will react to Xi's gathering of power. And if Xi can hold power, this: "It is really hard to figure out what he’s after. It’s possible that we haven’t even begun to see what his real agenda is."

Don't let Leftists undermine the fact that 2016 Russia-Trump election collusion was a hoax by pointing out Russian 2016 election interference. Nobody doubts Russia interfered--we don't need a Russian to admit that to know that. But yes, Russia interfered. Ineffectively and on a small scale. As Russia and the Soviet Union before it have a long history of doing. Most people don't know that last part.

How Turkey overruled Russia's objection to Ukrainian food exports. Tip to Instapundit.

Trump should not have taken a jab at DeSantis when the mid-term elections are coming up. So much for Reagan's 11th Commandment. I'm also looking at you, Never Trumper "Republicans."

Inside Amy Schumer? I think I threw up a little bit in my mouth. Hard pass. Not even with somebody else's ... Paramount+.

Is America unready for the inevitable "big one"? I don't assume America will go to war with China. And while I think America could be much better prepared, I don't know if China is prepared. The outcome rests on the interplay between both sides. Although, yes, we need much better and faster weapons development processes.

The 2020 election was perfect. But the 2022 election is vulnerable to hacking. We have always been at war with Eastasia, amirite?

Pakistan quietly backed the Afghanistan Taliban. Now the Afghanistan Taliban agree with the Pakistan Taliban that the Pakistan government (the army with a UN seat) is an enemy. Strategery.

Russia can't replace its more modern battlefield air defense systems. And is replacing them with towed and truck-mounted 57mm AA guns--usually without radar.

If Iran supplies Russia with ballistic missiles, I assume ATACMS arrive in Ukraine the next day for use against Russian infrastructure from Belgorod through Russian-occupied Donbas, and over to Russian-occupied Crimea.

Tigray separatists agreed to lay down their arms for a ceasefire with the Ethiopian government. Will Eritrea withdraw its troops? We'll see how that goes.

North Korea's air force is its weakest conventional service. While the air force is the most vulnerable to lack of money (for maintenance and fuel for training), all of North Korea's conventional services are rotting away by policy, as the article notes.

The 1980s called, unfortunately, and Nicaragua picked up the phone. Banning the opposition party and jailing its leaders does wonders for electoral prospects. Democrats were right! The 2022 elections did result in the end of democracy!

21st century: "The US Navy for the first time has permanently installed a 3D printer capable of producing metal components onboard the amphibious ship Bataan (LHD-5), paving the way for the fleet to much more rapidly and effectively maintain vessels at sea."

Norway is ordering more South Korean K9 armored self-propelled 155mm howitzers and K10 ammunition resupply vehicles. 

I have no doubt that there was vote tampering in 2020. It has a long history. And the pandemic-era systems in some states were designed to be impossible to audit. Was it decisive? I doubt it. Four years of media propaganda was the decisive part. And while some things looked odd at the time, no fraud has been proven. The election wasn't proven to be honest, to be sure. But some of the odd things might have been what a normal election looks like--but we rarely looked closely. So Republicans need to move on. Strengthen election transparency and voter verification. But let the outcome of 2020 go. It's counter-productive to bring this up now.

The Russian navy in the Black Sea has backed away into force protection mode.

We had a Blood Moon early Tuesday morning. I forgot to wake up to see it. And Biden didn't use the backdrop for an election-day speech warning about the end of democracy.

The Army is upgrading its fleet. As in water.

The Biden administration has abandoned and demonized a lot of Americans. These Americans noticed and reacted. But it wasn't enough.

Oh? "The Pentagon says Russia and China appear to be “edging toward an alliance” at a time when Western nations are seeking to isolate Moscow over its war on Ukraine." I think the Pentagon should be using the word "vassal" to describe Russia more closely aligned with China.

Why did Republicans fail to match poll expectations? Maybe post-2020 census redistricting put a low limit on a wave gain now. Maybe gains in minority voters took place in cities that merely lowered Democrat margins of victory in House races. Maybe Trump (intensified by media depiction of him as Orange Hitler) motivates and scares Democrats too much for Trump to be useful. He was needed in 2016. He pushed the Republicans to make needed changes and he exposed the deep bias of the pro-Democrat media that had pretended to be objective. Yes, he was unjustly screwed over from 2017-2020 by the media and federal bureaucracy. But he may need to retire and let the Republicans move on. Even before this year I was worried about his age in a second term. Was abortion decisive despite pre-election polls that seemed to indicate it wasn't a major motivating factor? If so, time will dilute that as states define the parameters according to local values. And maybe polling is so bad that we have to go back to the days when candidates campaign in the dark with voting day providing the only poll that counts. Which means elections have to be beyond question valid so both sides accept the results. Both sides have been enthusiastic election deniers over the last quarter century.

A new 300-member Security Assistance Group Ukraine led by a lieutenant general and based in Germany will coordinate security assistance to Ukraine.

Iraqi corruption continues to thrive. Even before the Surge and Awakening, I warned that rule of law had to be achieved after battlefield enemies were defeated. Corruption has proven to be a more potent enemy than shooting jihadi enemies, who continue to decline in power. And Saudi Arabia is finally reaching out to invest in Iraq and cooperate militarily to keep the Iranians at bay.

Keeping Biden in office through the mid-term elections allowed Democrats to beat expectations. Biden seems as if he is taking the result as reason to run in 2024 (assuming the actuarial table cooperates with him). With the potential Congressional disaster averted, will Democrats 25th Amendment Biden in February to put someone in the White House who can beat a Republican not named Trump? Of course, Kamala Harris couldn't be allowed to move up. Democrats have seen her in action now. But if Democrats can't first get Harris to step down or accept an appointment to be Ambassador to the United Nations, the 25A route is dead.

Ukraine's partisans at war against the occupiers. Russia has fewer than 200,000 troops in Ukraine. With an active conventional war going on, not many can be spared for rear areas security. Partisan morale is bolstered by the belief that the Ukrainian army is coming.  

And conveniently across the border for maintenance: "Poland has donated 54 of its now locally produced KRAB self-propelled 155mm howitzers to Ukraine. Poland is manufacturing more and will soon deliver another 54 KRAB systems to Ukraine."

Distributed civilian air defense detection network. 

Fortifying Guam. I still want more baskets.

American forces in Syria are focused on building secure facilities to hold ISIL prisoners in Syria until they can be repatriated to their countries of origin over the next decade. Hopefully we are creating the ability to ambush ISIL rescue forces trying to recruit and replenish ranks from the prison.

This is nice. I suppose. But it's for small-scale missions: "U.S. special operations forces flying over the Arctic on Wednesday rolled a long-range missile out the back of a C-130 aircraft, dropping it by parachute before it blasted toward its target in the distance." And why can't a B-52 do this without diverting SOC from duties B-52s can't do?

Action: Xi Jinping is preparing China for war. Reaction: Japanese Prime Minister Kishida repeats his commitment to expanding Japan's military capabilities.

Oh FFS: "The Navy’s next-generation guided-missile destroyer could cost up to $3.4 billion a ship, while its next-generation SSN(X) attack boat could cost up to $7.2 billion – figures that are billions over the service’s own estimates, according to the Congressional Budget Office’s annual analysis of the Navy’s long-range shipbuilding plan."

France is in NATO but really isn't: "President Emmanuel Macron said Wednesday that France’s military strategy must strengthen the country as an independent, respected nuclear-armed power through the end of the decade[.]" Macron really wants to conquer Europe more than he wants to defend it from the Russians.

Saudi Arabia seems to be trying to help out America after our tiff.

Is the mullah regime about to attack and kill Iranian protesters on a large scale?

Cracks appear in the Russian ground forces.

Huh: "'Overall, 73% of [student loan 'forgiveness"] applicants say they are likely to spend their extra money on non-essential items,' the poll reports." Meanwhile, the blue collar people who have to pay off those loans will have to spend less on baby formula and gasoline. Tip to Instapundit.

Despite Democratic claims about the Republican threat to democracy, the Republicans either aren't very good at rigging elections, or--and I'm just spitballing here--not actually a threat to democracy.

Great timing: "In the south (the Niger River Delta) oil thieves and corruption among local politicians and security forces commanders are responsible for a dramatic and disastrous decline in oil production." Corruption kills.

Inspired by Belarusians, Ukrainian civilians behind enemy lines have been effective: "In Russian occupied Ukraine, there have been a growing number of disruptions in the railroads that carry most of the supplies from Russia to Russian forces inside Ukraine." And Ukrainian special forces joined the civilians.

Biden openly threatens African immigrant.

The Marine Corps doesn't want to be a "second Army" and is changing. But what the Army does--large-scale combat operations--is useful. Whatever the Marines uniquely become has to be useful. 

I will say that Putin isn't making a Hitler-level mistake of ordering his units to fight to the death to hold their conquests on the Eastern Front. The result was that Hitlers's troops died and lost the territory. Putin has ordered withdrawals from the Kiev region and now Kherson. So he's not oblivious to his problems.

If Russians are excusing their defeats in Ukraine by saying in reality Russia is fighting NATO, will anybody raise the issue that--while false, but this is what Russia is claiming--Putin decided to take on all of NATO in Ukraine? Isn't that damning of Putin's judgment? Will Russia's military accept being thrown under the bus for the Kherson retreat?

She's right. Trump was the means and not the end itself. I still want the end itself. Which means I'm done with Trump. Pity. I often disagreed with him. But he did some good at home and abroad. And he was unfairly undermined by the media/Dems/bureaucracy for 5 years. I defended him against the unfair attacks, despite getting exhausted by the amount of crap thrown at him. But I'm done with him.

China's subliminal offensive into India's territory. But you don't need a study to know this. India needs to admit it and fight it. Tip to Instapundit.

The worse they say climate change is, the more private jets they have to fly into conferences to fight it. Because Science!, denier,Via Instapundit.

It will be interesting to see what motivated Democratic voters. The instant consensus is that it was young single woman worried about abortion. But they trend heavily to Democrats anyway. Further, that is a tiny fraction of the voters. Can't you say any similarly sized bloc of voters with different motivation put Democrats over the top? 

LOL:


Russia and the U.N. are negotiating an extension of the Black Sea food and fertilizer export agreement.

Russia's military helicopter marketing department weeps.

China denies Japanese territorial sovereignty at a record pace.

A bold move into reality.

His "first gaffe" and not "a gaffe": "President Joe Biden committed the first gaffe of his trip to Asia Saturday within the first seconds of his opening remarks, when he mistakenly referred to his Cambodian host as the head of Colombia." Strap in. 

Republicans need to exploit mail-in votes as much as Democrats have. Only then will we restore election day to a single day. Otherwise, Democrats lock in their votes early, making them immune to late-breaking news. And make Republican votes vulnerable to late-breaking news or misinformation. That imbalance must not stand.

So government powers to "battle Covid" will last long after the virus is the common cold, eh? Tip to PJ Media.

The Turks develop a loitering munition.

The imaginary Democrat-claimed Red wave of election denier terror during the elections didn't happen. Well, it was insurrection porn, after all. Shame on Democrats for their divisive hate and fear-mongering.

The X-37B landed.