Thursday, March 16, 2017

If a City is the Battlefield

I dismissed the idea of creating a class of Army units geared for urban warfare in megacities. I prefer good soldiers in general purpose brigades even though I recognize the need for that urban combat skill set if needed. The author of that proposal discusses the organization for his proposed unit.

I will say, the author makes sense in this article. I will concede that a special unit would be useful to test concepts of operating in a city.

Since the author admits that this would be the spearhead  unit rather than the first of many, he clearly understands that the Army can't have enough of these units to do the job. Other general purpose units must be capable of learning and adapting for urban warfare on a large scale.

So let me concede this much: a test unit outside of our force pool would be useful to try out weapons, organization, and tactics.

But I would still rather have officers educated in this mission, with weapons stockpiled, and portions of our engineer units including urban operations skills in their core training in order to help general purpose Army (or Marine) units committed to urban combat.

One thing I wonder about is the author's view that Stryker and Bradley Fighting Vehicles would be sufficient for urban warfare in the brigade organization he outlines.

While these vehicles worked against irregulars and light infantry in Iraq, I have deep reservations about relying on those vehicles---especially the Strykers--for urban combat against a conventional enemy force with far better levels of support from heavy weaponry.

Perhaps we should adapt Israeli practice and make Abrams Fighting Vehicles to provide better protection in an urban environment.

And virtual infantry, of course.

Wednesday, March 15, 2017

Caring About War and Warring About Care

I am amused by Democrats saying that Republicans shouldn't undo Obamacare because it is a fact of life and despite its shortcomings, undoing it will cause great harm to people who now count on that act for health insurance.

I wish that these Democrats had the same view about the Iraq War we won but which Democrats came to oppose when President Obama undid that 2008 victory by leaving Iraq in 2011, even though the undoing of that victory caused great harm to many people who counted on our victory for their personal safety.

At least the Iraq War started out with bipartisan support.

And don't even talk to me about lying us into insurance war.

Responsibly Transforming War

The Boko Haram caliphate has been defeated. But the next war against Boko Haram will be lost and revive that caliphate if Nigeria's government doesn't battle corruption and strengthen rule of law.

The war is won. And the war continues:

Boko Haram is done as an organization that can control territory but as a persistent Islamic terrorist threat it is still around and spreading to other parts of the Moslem north. Now the government has to deal with the fact that the continued corruption and bad government (especially when it comes to security and courts) are keeping enough people angry to sustain some Islamic terrorism along with all manner of violent protest. This can be seen in the Niger River Delta, where most of the oil is and the local tribes have become increasingly violent about the corruption, pollution and obvious lack of benefit to living in the midst of all that wealth.

Nigeria is already at the stage that I wrote Iraq would be when ISIL is finally defeated. That war is critical to preventing jihadis from rising again in Iraq:

It is of course important for the American military to remain in Iraq after the Islamic state caliphate is broken in order to help the Iraqis hunt down ISIL remnants; and to keep an eye on training standards in the Iraqi security forces.

But that is not the only thing that should be on the 30-day review of the fight against ISIL (and jihadis in general, including al Qaeda that is rebuilding).

It is also important to have a surge of FBI and court advisors to help the Iraqis build a law enforcement system with rule of law that does not leave so many holes for the jihadis to enter Iraqi life and kill Iraqis.

And advisors on how to run government agencies as something other than personal enrichment fiefdoms.

This must be a government-wide effort and not just a military effort.

This will be the next Iraq War. We need to win that too.

We did learn that lesson from our premature departure from Iraq in 2011 that emphasized "ending" a war but which allowed the rise of ISIL in the absence of an America-backed battle against corruption and for the strengthening of rule of law, right?

If not, see Nigeria.

UPDATE: ISIL resistance in Mosul is faltering:

Islamic State fighters are in disarray and struggling to fend off a rapid offensive by Iraqi forces to recapture Mosul and expel the militants from their last major stronghold in the country, a top U.S. military official said.

"They’re lacking purpose motivation and direction,” Army Maj. Gen. Joseph Martin said in a phone interview from Baghdad. “I’ve never seen them so disorganized.”

There have been reports of ISIL leadership leaving Mosul. Yes, some left behind will fight to the death. But without leadership to direct the resistance, that willingness to die rather than trying to live to fight another day is a favor to the Iraqis who are more than willing to kill the jihadis.

So the transition to new fights will begin rather sooner than later.

All Your Stuff are Belong to the CCP

The Chinese are punishing the South Koreans for accepting THAAD anti-missile defenses by denying cruise ship and airline links to South Korea. Everything in China is a potential asset for China's foreign policy goals as set by the Chinese Communist Party which suffers your existence on their whim.

The Chinese discovered that having an apparently crazed little friend with nukes isn't as fun as they thought.

Wait. What? The Chinese aren't masters of looking ahead with a long view based on their ancient civilization somehow translating into strategic farsighted thinking?

But I digress (as I can!).

The Chinese are upset that the South Koreans prefer not to be nuked:

Pressure in China on travel firms forced airlines and cruise operators to cut routes to South Korea, as the fallout spread on Friday from a diplomatic row over Seoul's plans to deploy a U.S. missile defense system against Beijing's objections. ...

An internal South Korean government document seen by Reuters said Chinese authorities gave a "7-point" verbal instruction to travel firms to curtail or ban trips to South Korea.

These included a ban on tour groups visiting South Korea from March 15, cruise ships not being allowed to dock in South Korea ports and a warning that those who violated the guidance would face "severe punishment".

Of course, when cruise ships can help gain control of territory, the Chinese are eager for the PLAN Boat to make another run.

Signs of Hope

Other than the militias looming in the Iraqi background, this is refreshingly normal, eh?

While Iraqi forces are fighting to retake the western half of Mosul from Islamic State fighters, internal divisions regarding the future of Iraq’s political process are escalating ahead of provincial elections scheduled for September, especially within the country’s largest Shiite political bloc, the Shiite National Alliance.

Iraqi militias, especially those with ties to Iran, in the Popular Mobilization Force units are a potential weapon to use bullets and not ballots to determine the future of the political process.

As I saw it, keeping American combat troops in Iraq after 2011 would have had one mission of reassuring Iraqis that nobody could afford to resort to violence to settle political divisions without running into American troops--who would kill them.

So retiring the militias or regulating them enough to defang them as Iranian tools would help a lot.

Further, arresting and charging that Iranian hand puppet and all-around walking piece of breathing garbage and three-time insurrectionist Moqtada al-Sadr before he can wreck Iraq would help. Sadr needs to rot in prison or die for his crimes.

And this political maneuvering is why I want Iraq to remain a single state, even if the center is weakened. I want the Kurds and Sunni Arabs to be additional factions within Iraq to help counter the pro-Iran elements of the Shia factions.

The pro-Iran elements are a minority of Iraqi Shias, but as Saddam proved, even a minority with the guns can run a country. So I'd really like the pro-Iran Shias to be heavily outnumbered.

The participation of the Kurds and Arab Sunnis as allies of Shias will also help normalize these parts of Iraqi society to the Shia majority and help them use politics and not weapons to negotiate for resources.

Also, I seriously worry how long Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani will live. He is old and a calming influence on the Shia. When he passes, I assume Sadr will try to take his place as the leading Shia within Iraq.

Still, the political divisions are encouraging. It may not look pretty, but as America endures a losing faction continuing to reject the outcome of our last election and taking to the streets with so-far minor levels of violence--with some of them even hoping for a military coup, for Pete's sake--can we really say that the Iraqis aren't learning the ropes?

Iraq has voting. We have to help them remove the threat of violence to influence or override voting. And we have to help Iraqis develop rule of law by combating corruption.

Do those things in the next Iraq War which with our participation will be a peacetime struggle, and Iraq will get an actual democracy.

We won't abandon Iraq again after ISIL is dispersed and Iraqi authority is restored, will we?

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

An Intercontinental Nuclear Delivery System Already Exists

One of these days, this is how a cargo ship run by an enemy will pick up a nuclear device and deliver it to a port city to detonate:

Hundreds of ships are sailing into European waters after suspicious manoeuvres near terrorist hotspots, prompting fears that they are smuggling people and weapons with impunity.

An investigation by The Times has uncovered how cargo ships and other large vessels routinely switch off GPS tracking so they can disappear, falsify their identification or veer off their usual course.

Is that a problem in American waters, too?

Have a super sparkly day.

Game of Tweets

I see that the cut-throat and bloody world of Game of Thrones was insufficiently ruthless to prepare one actor for the Hell that is a Red Tweeting:

A debate over whether it’s racist for white actor Finn Jones to play a martial arts character became so furious that the Game of Thrones actor decided to drop off Twitter to avoid further attack.

Jones came under fire for defending his role in Marvel’s Iron Fist, an upcoming TV series on Netflix. He was accused of insensitivity towards Asians for playing a white man proficient in martial arts.

Jones, a straight actor best known for his role as the gay character Loras Tyrell in Game of Thrones, is headlining the comic book-based show Iron Fist. Its detractors claim that Jones’ role takes away opportunities for non-white actors.

This whole cultural appropriation business is one of the most unintentionally hilarious aspects of politically correct modern liberalism.

Back in "white man's burden" days when the bloody wogs had nothing of value worthy of emulation or use to a proper Westerner, such a refusal to adopt or adapt foreign traditions, foods, or customs would have been based on racist condescending dismissal of the value of foreign cultures.

Now the refusal to adopt or adapt foreign traditions, foods, or customs is the height of respect for other cultures.



Truly, the stupid is spreading like wildfire.

One Europe, One Government, One People

The European Union is what American liberals elevate to cherished status?

The origin of that proto-imperial body is fascinating:

Scorning the universal values of the Enlightenment that underpin the EU, these thinkers instead propose a united Europe bound together by what, in their eyes, are the irrefutable and irresistible claims of race and ethnicity.

So there was a racist (and anti-American) DNA in the united Europe camp?

Was?



To be fair to American liberals, hippie Oregon shares similar origins.

UPDATE: And do note that the EU brain trust thinks setting up a circular firing squad around the threats is the way to be stronger together.

From the Damned If You Do and Damned If You Don't Files

Saudi Arabia's effort to bankrupt American oil producers is failing. Will this really help defund jihadis?

I don't know whether Saudi motives for reducing oil prices prioritized harming Iran or American frackers, but the latter target is doing okay. So Saudi Arabia is losing money:

The twilight of Saudi oil dominance has arrived, a point underscored by the announcement of a giant onshore oil find in Alaska. ...

[The] frackers may have bankrupted the Sunni Jihad. But in doing so, the oilmen have created a potential power vacuum even bigger than which resulted from the Arab Spring. Technology often creates new power relationships which officials only belatedly respond to. The consequences of American oil power have not yet been fully assimilated by the political system. Turmoil in the Kingdom and the Gulf might trigger a tragedy that would make events in Syria and Libya seem trivial by comparison. [emphasis added]

There could very well be turmoil in Saudi Arabia as the government scales back spending to cope with a drop in income. But I don't think that hurts the jihad. Bankrolling jihadis isn't nearly as expensive as paying for a massive and generous welfare state and advanced weapons.

And the jihadi bankrolling comes from private individuals rather than the state. Yes, Saudi Arabia subsidizes the most aggressive form of Islam around the world. But that is cheap by comparison, too.

And if government payments to individuals are cut back, pointing to support for "pure" Islam abroad might be the natural response of the government to retain legitimacy.

Further, as I've asked before, if Islamists rail against the West for "stealing" Arab oil, what will the Islamists do when the West buys less of that oil?

Buy their oil and we're hated. Stop buying their oil and we'll be hated. Oil is not the reason jihadis hate us. As I ask repeatedly, what doesn't anger jihadis?

Monday, March 13, 2017

The Post-Caliphate ISIL Era Looms

Iraqi forces say ISIL resistance in Mosul is weakening and the fight for Raqqa is approaching. Meanwhile Assad pretends that ISIL is his primary concern.

In Iraq, ISIL's major conquest is being lost:

Speaking to AFP on Sunday, Staff Major General Maan al-Saadi of the elite Counter-Terrorism Service said "more than a third" of west Mosul was now under the control of security forces. ...

"The battle is not easy... we are fighting an irregular enemy who hides among the citizens and uses tactics of booby-trapping, explosions and suicide bombers, and the operation is taking place with precision to preserve the lives of the citizens," Brigadier General Yahya Rasool, the spokesman for the JOC, told AFP.

Still, he said, IS resistance "has begun to weaken in a big way".

Rasool appears to be speaking of ISIL resistance in a specific area rather than all of Mosul, but it seems like the comment does reflect the bigger picture.

Meanwhile on the Syria front, American-supported forces reinforced by American troops are nearing an assault on Raqqa:

Defence officials told the Washington Post that a Marine artillery unit had been deployed with large field guns that can fire 155mm shells about 32km (20 miles).

A coalition spokesman, Col John Dorrian, told Reuters news agency they would help "expedite the defeat" of IS in Raqqa.

These American forces are part of a temporary deployment not counted in our ceiling for troops levels. So the assault must be imminent. And as the article notes, we'd like to kill off the leadership in the battle to cripple ISIL's ability to adapt to loss of the caliphate.

Which means we will likely see the commitment of that reserve force we decided to put in place in Kuwait.

Remember in the initial 2001 Afghanistan campaign, we relied too much on local Afghan allies on the ground, which seems to have allowed Osama bin Laden and other leaders to escape the Battle of Tora Bora.

Another sign of an imminent battle is that ISIL has evacuated the families of their troops:

The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said "300 families of foreign fighters of IS have left the city of Raqa since dawn Friday to take refuge in the province of Deir Ezzor to the east and Hama to the west".

Syria's dictator Assad is a latecomer to the battle against ISIL, having let others fight them while he slaughtered non-jihadi rebels in the west. Now he is trying to get in on the act to exploit the American-led effort:

Assad said that "in theory" he still saw scope for cooperation with Trump, though practically nothing had happened in this regard. He dismissed the U.S.-backed military campaign against Islamic State in Syria as "only a few raids", and said a more comprehensive approach was needed. ...

Assad noted that the Russian-backed Syrian army was now "very close" to Raqqa city after advancing to the western banks of the Euphrates River this week - a rapid gain that has brought it to the frontier of areas held by the U.S.-backed forces.

He said Raqqa was "a priority for us", but indicated that there could also be a parallel army attack towards Deir al-Zor in the east, near the Iraqi border. Deir al-Zor province is almost completely controlled by Islamic State, also known as ISIS.

It is funny that ISIL is being defeated because of America with no help from Assad or his friends, yet he claims America has carried out "only a few raids." This fights nicely with recent Russian claims to have killed about 1,600 ISIL forces in a couple of air raids recently. So on paper Russia is prominent in that fight.

Note that at Deir al-Zor (Deir Ezzor) city Assad forces are under siege. I haven't heard of any recent ISIL efforts there, which at one point seemed like a target to create an alternate capital once Raqqa falls.

I suspect that Assad's forces poised west of Raqqa (which is likely mostly non-Syrian), notwithstanding his sudden "priority" of fighting ISIL, will hang back to let the American-supported forces bleed to take Raqqa--which has been the strategy all along--and then wait for the temporary flux of American troops to leave before sending in his forces to take Raqqa from the Syrian militias we back and then move on to Deir al-Zor province.

Assad is our enemy. Do we take that into account as the post-caliphate era we've striven to achieve looms?

UPDATE: Yes, the Iraq front morale problem appears to be Mosul-wide.

ISIL resistance in Mosul is faltering:

Islamic State fighters are in disarray and struggling to fend off a rapid offensive by Iraqi forces to recapture Mosul and expel the militants from their last major stronghold in the country, a top U.S. military official said.

"They’re lacking purpose motivation and direction,” Army Maj. Gen. Joseph Martin said in a phone interview from Baghdad. “I’ve never seen them so disorganized.”

There have been reports of ISIL leadership leaving Mosul. Yes, some left behind will fight to the death. But without leadership to direct the resistance, that willingness to die rather than trying to live to fight another day is a favor to the Iraqis who are more than willing to kill the jihadis.

The Germans Should Put Their Money Where Their Mouth Is

If the Germans are so worried about Russian missiles in Kaliningrad, I suggest the Germans create two divisions with the mission of overrunning that Russian exclave.

Do tell?

A decision by Russia to permanently station Iskander missiles in Kaliningrad, its enclave on the Baltic Sea, would mark a setback for European security, German Foreign Minister Sigmar Gabriel told Russian news agency Interfax on Wednesday. ...

"If Iskander missiles were stationed in Kaliningrad permanently, that would be a cause for great concern and a blow to European security," Gabriel said. "That is why we are watching what's happening in Kaliningrad very carefully."

Germany is weak militarily.

But if Germany is truly worried about the missiles, the Germans should step up to accomplish what I believe should be the first NATO offensive action in a war initiated by Russia.

So what do you say Germany? Will you build a new two-division corps dedicated to crushing that exclave as rapidly as possible to end the threat to European security?

Post-Miracle China

Stratfor discusses China's faltering economy after an impressive growth spurt:

Japan turned into a low-growth, but stable, country. But Japan did not have a billion impoverished people to deal with, nor did it have a history of social unrest and revolution. China’s problem is no longer economic – its economic reality has been set. It now has a political problem: how to manage massive disappointment in an economy that is now simply ordinary. It also must determine how to manage international forces, particularly the United States, that are challenging China and its core interests.

Do read it all.

I never panicked over China's rise. I expected their growth spurt would expire rather than go on forever the way some portrayed China. I could remember similar claims about the Soviet Union, Germany, Japan, and even the European Union surpassing America.

I'd like to add two things to the article.

One, the impressive Chinese rise was in part due to urbanization. As I wrote many times on this blog, take the most efficient peasant and put him in the most inefficient factory, and GDP goes up a lot. China has run out of that option to get a cheap input for easy gains. What follows is harder.

And two, the very size of China made the export-dependent route to economic growth a problem. China is so huge that the world ran out of customers before China ran out of rural peasants to plug into factories.

Taiwan, Singapore, and even Japan were small enough to urbanize and modernize without exhausting the world's ability to absorb their exports.

But China is huge, obviously. How could the world ever absorb the scale of exports that would allow China to replicate Japan's path?

So China has achieved a lot. But it was no miracle. And now the task of coping with the reality of China's limits rather than seeing a fantasy vision of never-ending growth is China's job.

Which has lessons for India, too, which also desperately needs economic growth to reduce massive poverty in large segments of their population that aren't plugged into the global information economy.

Sunday, March 12, 2017

Road Warr-e-ors

During the Iraq War, one of the major "fronts" of the war was enemy attacks on our supply convoys. While the supplies never stopped, the casualties to keep the supplies moving were a potentially decisive pressure point to undermining support for the war. The Army is making advances in autonomous vehicles that would nullify that threat.

Interesting changes in the Army's Robotics and Autonomous Systems (RAS) strategy:

Through 2020 the army plans to mature concepts and initiate or continue programmes that would increase situational awareness for dismounted forces at lower echelons, lighten carried loads for dismounted forces, improve sustainment via automated ground resupply, improve route clearance systems, and improve explosive ordinance disposal (EOD) platforms and payloads, the army said. [emphasis added]

Automating ground supply convoys and the route clearance missions needed to clear roads of IEDs and other threats to the supply runs would end the vulnerability of having troops in poorly protected convoys.

Yes, we did an amazing job of getting the supplies through this major enemy effort to inflict casualties with roadside IEDs. But casualties were always a potential threat.

In addition to the methods described above, we replaced military drivers with civilian contract drivers in the supply vehicles, which lowered official military casualty tolls. But those are still dead men.

And a small proportion of supply runs were transferred to aerial means.

So autonomous supply runs would eliminate that source of casualties along lines of supply.

But the supplies still need to get through and unless we want fully automated defenses--and a ruthless enemy would quickly react by using women and children as shields filmed to show American robot-killers in action--the supplies won't get through.

If we pair virtual soldiers that use a battlefield internet to man remote weapons stations on the convoy vehicles, we could have the ability to have both direct fire in defense of the convoy and eyes on targets to call in fires strikes against attackers. But without actual human friendlies in the convoy who can be killed.

Note that the long-term portion of the Army strategy includes "tele-operated" weapons. Which fits nicely with my proposal.

Plentiful supplies and few casualties sounds like a good combination to me.

Oh, and here's the Army report.

The Dangerously Alien Sanity of North Korea

Stratfor discusses North Korean rationality:

The attribution of rationality to North Korea’s leadership is not a justification for its actions, nor does it argue that the North has only one path to pursue. Rather, it seeks to understand the behavior of the country's rulers — a vital step toward predicting both action and reaction.

Do read it, of course.

Our UN ambassador should read it. Kim Jong-Un is not irrational except if you put him in an American context. His rationality comes from his environment. So we need to understand them.

I've never claimed the North Koreans are nuts, despite I'm sure calling him a "nutball" on occasion. But that is hyperbole.

That's why I've been more inclined to try to contain North Korea rather than risk a war to destroy North Korea.

Although I do worry that rationality in North Korean terms can include welcoming a 95% chance of defeat and destruction by launching a war when the alternative may seem to the North Korean elite as a 100% chance of regime collapse.

Nor do I go into panic mode over every short-range Scud missile launch into the sea that gains headlines. These are often just aging missiles that provide a chance to yank our chain and train their military with a live-fire event.

Long-range tests are more of a problem, of course.

The rationality of opponents (and allies) within their own parameters is key to avoiding mirror-imaging another actor's motivations.

When You Assume, Sometimes You Get it Right

This article argues that Iran is seeking nukes via North Korea.

It offers no hard evidence, unfortunately. Just noting ties and making assumptions. Do read it all, of course. But it is speculation.

Not that I disagree. I too have long thought that the ties and logic make it likely that Iran has subcontracted nuclear weapons work to North Korea.

Indeed, taking the logic further, I wonder if North Korea will sell the entire nuclear deterrent force to Iran that will shield Iran until the mullahs can build their own at home.

The North Korea angle is the big lacuna in thinking that Trump could vigorously enforce the Iran deal and make the best of it. The deal just might not matter all that much--other than the time, cash, and conventional weapons that Iran has gotten because of that misbegotten monster of a deal.

But I do wish our intelligence assets would really look for cooperation. Perhaps they know. Perhaps just we don't know.

Have a super sparkly day.

Saturday, March 11, 2017

Weekend Data Dump

This article on Russia in the Far East is interesting. But the side statement that "The future of Ukraine, whose existence as a buffer state is essential to Russia’s survival, is in flux" (emphasis added) is bewildering. Who is Ukraine a potential buffer against? Are the Swedes, Poles, Germans, or French going to invade Russia from the west? Will Austria and Hungary reunite and be a threat? Is America really interested in driving on Moscow? Will Turkey push north to again control the entire Black Sea? Just who poses a military threat against Russia through Ukraine? Times change. Truly, let's have a reality check. Russia doesn't need a buffer state in the west in the modern world--unless they drive the West to hostile relations again with Moscow's unrelenting aggression and belligerence. Or is the author saying that the logic of a Russian-German partition of Poland still applies today?

President Obama launched a cyber assault on North Korea's nuclear program. It is unclear if the effort slowed down the North Koreans or if internal deficiencies were the cause of until recently some failures. Such a measure can only delay the effort, of course. Funny that liberals say that air attacks should be ruled out because they won't do more than delay the effort. I guess delaying, as I've long said, is worth it. Especially when you consider you can lather, rinse, repeat. Also,  how did we get the North Koreans to use the punch cards with the hacking code? [rimshot] (I'm old enough to remember paper tape.)

It would be awesome if we unleash a lunar "gold rush." When I saw 2001: A Space Odyssey as a child, it seemed that the 21st century was so far away, but it would be awesome. I guess in the ways that personally affect me, it is awesome in many ways. But I'm still disappointed that our space presence consists of a mobile home up on blocks with less internal space than my own home. Admittedly my view isn't as good. Tip to Instapundit.

A Syrian Mig-23 pilot who was rescued a week ago said his plane was shot down. By who is not said. What really got me is that the pilot is 56 years old! Good grief, the man is old enough to have fought against Maverick in Top Gun! Assad really has to be scraping the barrel for pilots if they have 56-year-old pilots.

I don't know why some news outlets bother to cover defense issues: "The Air Force sent 14 Super Hercules fighter planes to western Tokyo ..." The rest of the sentence doesn't matter. The article is about C-130J transport planes--not fighter planes. For a bonus, the title calls them "jets." For God's sake, Google?

Swedes and their allies in America indignantly deny that there are"no-go zones" in Sweden's immigrant neighborhoods where government employees stay out from fear. Technically, that denial is correct. They are "go only with armed escort zones."

A Strategypage tour of China and their military loyalty, corruption, economic, ethnic minority, and North Korea problems.

If "right-wing" hate is so widespread, why do leftists have to fake crimes so much?

The liberal world (including their university and city authorities) had best get their communist and anarchist storm troopers off the streets before conservatives form their own militias to defend their rallies. As long as the Left attacks--and the authorities don't defend conservatives legally gathering--conservatives would be justified in taking this step. But it is a very dangerous step that leads to street battles and real civil strife. Nobody should have street enforcers. The Left needs to stop accepting these far left street thugs as their own in a bizarre fantasy that Trump is a fascist who is bringing a dictatorship to America. Remember, we have had active leftist terrorists in living memory.

Grant me that this is funny. Behind every great women's event ... ?

ISIL is a bunch of pikers when it comes to destroying historical landmarks. The Saudis paved paradise and they put up a parking lot.

A Navy report on Iran's navies. They have their regular navy, which has more of a tendency to act professionally; and the Republican Guard (Pasdaran) navy that is run by the mullah nutballs. In any clash, focus on sinking the latter, of course.

I don't mean to be the skunk at the anti-Russian garden party, but doesn't saying a new Russian cruise missile violates the "spirit and intent" of the INF Treaty mean it is legal under the terms of the treaty? What gives? Is the Russian missile illegal or not?

So this week America had a Day Without Women. Ah yes, I remember the last time we had that day--June 6, 1944, wasn't it? Around the world, women could use help to achieve equal rights against actual oppression. And of course, women tend not to have rights where nobody has them. But in free America, the women's auxiliary of upper middle class liberalism took a day off to ... whatever it was they did. Bravo. Hear them roar. Hear me yawn. Truly, Al Bundy was ahead of his time. As was Bill Clinton.

The LCS Detroit successfully tested a Longbow version of the Army Hellfire surface-to-surface missile module. Good, that's another building block for The AFRICOM Queen (see page 50).

In reality, putting a little girl in front of charging bulls is a dangerously stupid idea. I mean, you go, girl! Which perhaps explains why a democratically elected president was impeached--not Trump!--yet she has refused so far to leave office. You go, girl. Because with equality you get punished equally.

Iraq agreed to better information sharing with America and other concessions in order to get off the revised executive order temporarily halting certain immigration. So that's good.

For those convinced that Trump has wrecked longstanding American-Australian relations, we have this news that would otherwise be ordinary: "A C-band space surveillance radar system jointly operated by the United States and Australia has reached Full Operational Capability, the Australian Department of Defense reports." The system used to be in the Caribbean Sea. So there you go.

China is not the only target of our freedom of navigation concerns, as this short Navy summary shows.

I don't know nearly enough about the issue to judge whether the House approach to repealing and replacing Obamacare is good or bad. But given the media biases, I'm not inclined to assume it is bad.

This last week, Michigan got hammered with record weather-caused power outages from wind damage. Luckily, I had a power outage from wind a couple weeks before that and with no great demand on repair crews, the cause of that outage was good enough to spare me this time. Whew. But this comment about the damage really just makes me want to pound my head into a wall in frustration: "Just think, if we were actually using wind power, no one would be without power." So if I understand this obvious engineering major, that source of the electricity would have made the means of transmitting it to our homes invulnerable to wind damage? God help us from the "pro-science" people.

Just a note on Army readiness to be fair. Just because only 3 of 58 active and reserve combat brigades are ready to "fight tonight" does not mean that the other brigades are combat ineffective. We have high standards for readiness. So our "unready" brigades would outmatch a lot of enemy units considered ready. These units would not be as effective and would endure more casualties, but they could fight. I made this observation during the Bush 43 era when the media was outraged at readiness levels affected by war rotations; and I will repeat this context now that the media couldn't care less about the effects of spending reductions on readiness during the Obama administration.

Yes, I hope President Trump settles down. He'll be better than I hoped (and is surely better than Hillary could ever have been), but he has to make a better transition from celebrity to president to excel. He can do a better job of that than Obama did, can't he?

Yes, the Russians are back in action to harm America with their WikiLeaks hand puppets. So much for Putin welcoming a Trump presidency. In his quieter moments, at night, in his underground bunker where he gently pets a white tiger kitten, I'm sure he weeps for the lost opportunities of a Clinton presidency. "My God! The FSB told me she couldn't lose ... "

A robotic burger fry cook has been built. Somebody please break the news to SpongeBob. Say, what's the minimum wage in California, anyway?

My dad liked to say "an idle mind is the devil's workshop." So true (in Swedish). Can the West stop financing those who seek to kill us (Google translation to English of one page)? Just a thought. RT highlighted this. I don't care to send traffic to Russia's propaganda arm.

American Abrams tanks newly back in Europe are getting reactive armor. Which is a problem for infantry dismounts supporting the tanks, of course. And it should just be another layer that eventually includes active protection systems because I don't believe reactive armor has any effect on top-attack missiles that bypass heavy passive armor and reactive armor that work against threats from direct fire.

Yet another reason that I am totally opposed to forgiving student loan debt: "[Nearly] one-third (30.6 percent) of those polled said they did plan to apply at least some of their student loan funds toward their spring break vacation." I worked my way through college--at the University of Michigan, which wasn't cheap. If students want to booze it up on beaches with borrowed money, then I damn well shouldn't have to pay for it with tax money. And I saved money for my own children to go to college, yet for parents who don't do that, I share the burden of paying for their spring break? Screw that. Those young people can pay for their hangovers the rest of their lives, for all I care.

I'm fairly surprised that President Obama's half brother would pull this kind of stunt given the recent half-brother VX agent troubles we've seen.

Any minute now that pro-Russian policy will kick in. Any minute. Seriously, you don't still believe that Putin wanted Trump to be president, do you?

Did Iran really successfully test an anti-ship ballistic missile recently? The way so many of Iranian weapons developments are fraudulent (no, Iran does not have a stealth fighter), was this test a fake with perhaps a homing beacon on the target barge? Or was the impact point simply a GPS coordinate that means the fact that the target could have been any stationary target at sea or on land? Of course, even without that missile, I think it is insane for our Navy to put big ships in the Persian Gulf.

Siri let me down. I thought this weekend was daylight saving switch time. My son asked me if it was so I asked Siri when daylight saving time in Michigan was. Siri said it was in early April. My son said he thought I was right about this weekend, after he thought about it. So I Googled it. It seems Siri--who I have set with a female Australian accent (hey, don't judge)--gave me the Australian date for the shift! Lord knows what my phone would be doing if I had it set as a Russian accent. It would probably answer my questions before I even formally ask, eh?

Canada said they'd welcome "refugees" that America doesn't want. They're coming. Enjoying it yet? That was fast. I guess Trudeau didn't learn any lessons from Merkel's virtue signaling that tragically backfired for all of Europe. How long before Canadians build a beautiful wall?

"Her vagina is her moral compass?" Let's hope Cate Blanchett was just joking. Of course, if true, it means that the guidance system for the heat-seeking moisture missile has an easier time finding its target. Hey, don't hate me for the juvenile joke. She raised the issue, you know. Seriously, men are accused of thinking with "our pants"--and not in a good way. But what Ms. Blanchett said was edgy and/or feminist affirming? I mean, you go girl! Tip to Instapundit.

The Yemen raid was not a debacle as so many on the left have been eager to claim, says the CENTCOM commander. Sometimes shit just happens. The enemy is trying to win, too, remember.

Apparently, Senator Warren has been participating in a Day Without a Woman at work for quite some time now.

Am I guilty of cultural appropriation because I really like poutine? Mind you, not that I care if I am ...

Unbeelievable

The notion of a “beepocalypse” or “beemageddon” just isn't true. Or at least not new.

I apparently haven't written about this issue except as part of a mockery of the crisis du jour that the bee issue was.

And keep your eye on New Zealand. When I wrote that post above they just had a couple islands. Now they have most of the land of an entire continent! Tomorrow? The world?

Remember, it isn't that I don't care. It's that I don't care about what fake crisis mongers care about.

Between Iraq and a Scarred Place

Germany's situation under threat by jihadis must be very puzzling to the nuanced crowd.

You'd think that refusing to participate in the Iraq War (which the left long said motivated jihadis) and welcoming Moslem refugees and migrants mostly fleeing Syria's civil war (to disprove "Islamophobia") would eliminate any motivation whatsoever for jihadis to target Germany--or to even exist there.

Shockingly, that is not the case according to the head of Germany's domestic security agency:

“Germany became significantly more prioritized as a target of Isis over the course of 2016,” said BfV President Hans-Georg Maaßen, adding that the level of danger continues to be high. ...

Maaßen further said that the number of people believed to be potentially violent Islamists in the country has steadily risen. There are currently an estimated 1,600 living in Germany.

Clearly, there's no pleasing some people. As I often ask, what doesn't enrage jihadis?

UPDATE: They hate the shopping?

Police in the western German city of Essen sealed off a shopping center in the center of town and ordered it to remain closed on Saturday due to concrete indications of a possible attack.

The article doesn't say it is a jihadi threat, but the context given is that the Germans are nervous since jihadi attacks in Belgium and France and their own Christmas weaponized truck attack.

Well, maybe my memory fails me. Perhaps Germany contributed a panzer division to the invasion of Iraq and perhaps Germany built a big beautiful wall to keep out refugees and migrants.

I mean, that would earn the Germans jihadi wrath, right?

UPDATE: Yes, the threat is from ISIL:

Germany's domestic intelligence service had tipped police off about the threat, interior minister Thomas de Maiziere told public broadcaster ARD.

"There exists a link to the so-called Islamic State terror organisation," he said, adding that "some indications or orders" were given by someone who had travelled from Germany to the conflict zone in the Middle East.

You try to be so careful not to offend. And this is what the Germans get for their effort.

Friday, March 10, 2017

When a War of Choice Becomes a War of Necessity

Many ISIL fighters will likely disperse back to their home countries following the defeat of their caliphate across Iraq and Syria. While some analysts like to say this is a bad thing, the alternative is to let them keep their territory which terrorizes and indoctrinates those under their control and provides greater resources to the terrorists to launch attacks abroad. So this is good. And there is another benefit to jihadi dispersal.

Yes, jihadis will go underground in Iraq and Syria to function as more traditional Islamist terrorists following the defeat of the caliphate.

And some jihadis will go back home or disperse to new targets for the jihad. Some of those will become terrorists in those countries.

Others who disperse will be discouraged and will drop out of the jihad. Some of those can be turned to fight those who continue to fight, whether in Iraq or Syria, or elsewhere.

And while one can find analysts who claim that dispersal is a bad thing, it is a better thing than to have them with their own proto-state. Sure, I'd rather kill them all where they stand while they try to hold their caliphate, but life is imperfect.

And there is one more advantage to jihadi dispersal.

While many countries don't cooperate that much in a coalition of the willing to fight jihadi terrorists "over there," when the jihadis come to them, these less enthusiastic defenders of  civilization against the jihadis find they must join the fight as jihadis come to them.

Yes, that anti-ISIL meeting will have more attentive participants now:

The Trump administration is to host a meeting of minister from 68 countries focussed on taking forward the battle against Isis.

And don't forget that these really are barbarians deserving of no quarter in this fight:

Islamic State fighters dressed as doctors stormed a military hospital in Kabul, killing at least 49 people and wounding dozens more during an attack in the diplomatic heart of the Afghan capital.

Am I really the heartless one when I say the only good jihadi is a dead jihadi?

Anyway, to avoid things like that, reluctant allies will be in the fight.

I'm not saying I welcome the new threats to countries and their people. But I am saying that they will become new allies in the fight against jihadi terrorists out of necessity.

Never Embrace the Bear

America-backed rebels have turned over territory that Turkey wanted under their control to the Syrian government. Is Turkey enjoying their new Russian friend yet?

Well, that's gonna leave a mark:

Syrian government forces have taken over positions from a U.S.-backed militia in the northern city of Manbij on part of a frontline with Turkish-backed rebel forces, in line with a deal brokered by Russia, the militia's spokesman said on Monday.

The Russians are making it clear that the Russian-Turkish deal on Syria is only on Russian terms:

Putin was making a point — loud and clear — that this was now history, and that the Russians are now working openly with the Kurds to obstruct Erdogan’s buffer-zone, reminding him that it was the Kremlin, rather than Ankara, that was calling the shots in Syria, and that no scheme would ever pass in this war-torn country if not approved by Moscow.

Turkey stiff-armed America in 2003 by denying permission for America's most advanced division, 4th Infantry Division (heavy) to strike Saddam's forces from the north.

And despite President Obama's decision to embrace Turkey's Erdogan as a safe and tame Islamist, Obama never backed Trukey's desire for a buffer zone.

So Turkey--which should have embraced their NATO membership that some states to the north would kill to have--turned to Russia's fellow autocrat (as Erdogan is rapidly becoming) while alienating America.

How'd that work out?

In Space Nobody Can Hear Your Budget Request?

An author advocates for a new Space Corps as an independent service because the Air Force has done a poor job of exploiting space. As a first step, the author wants the Space Corps as a separate entity within the Department of the Air Force. Perhaps.

The Air Force started out as the Army Air Corps, so there is a little irony in the fact that a part of the Air Force might break off because the Air Force wants the space elements to support the primary missions of the Air Force.

Added bureaucratic study value is that the Army is still unhappy with Air Force efforts to support the Army which is why the Air Force was once created as the Army Air Corps.

And I got over the loss of this force which started out in the Army Signal Corps.

Anyway:

Space operations are becoming ever more critical to American and global economic interests and military power projection to a degree that warrants a devoted service. The expertise required to operate in space is so fundamentally different and specialized, and the space-minded perspective so altogether different, that it will never serve the nation to have this expertise and perspective under-resourced and buried under another service.

I'm not sure about the idea of a Space Corps as a separate service. But I can travel at least part of the way with this proposal given that I have long called for the Air Force to "aim high" for space (and I refined the missions in subsequent posts), becoming an Aerospace Force (and that's my most recent post on this).

If that Aerospace Force has two components--an Air Force and a Space Corps--I'd be content to see how that works out. Remember, The Army Air Corps didn't have a problem becoming the Army Air Force that grew powerful under the Army.

When the Air Force has trouble supporting ground forces as it focuses--when it is allowed--on control of the air, will a separate Space Corps just be a separate service that ignores the ground to control its environment?

I continue to think that the Air Force should aim higher by moving into space while giving the ground support function (and budget) back to the Army, so the Army has its own air support like the Marines have now.

While I wondered what the Army would do with this authority in that Aerospace Force post above, by surveys the troops like the helicopters, so the force structure might not change much.

And that Space Corps--whether part of the Air Force for a while or as part of a newly focused Aerospace Force--should have a "ground" force component trained to operate in space or on the moon.

But right now I prefer to have the Aerospace Force include space rather than calve that off for a separate service.

The only way, right now, that I support a Space Corps as a separate service is for a service that has responsibility for space outside of the Earth-Moon system.

Once the focus of the service isn't to support missions on the ground, it will need to separate off non Earth-Moon system assets into a separate true space service.

Then we can have a really fun debate on whether it should be modeled on the Air Force or Navy. Science fiction traditionally calls such a force a space navy, with large ships and large crews. But if automation and cost means that space ships have only a small crew running automated onboard systems and unmanned space vehicles sent off for missions, couldn't the Air Force be the model?

Thursday, March 09, 2017

The Subliminal Long War

If early April will mark the end of the Mosul assault as ISIL defenses crumble, it will have been about 34 months from fall of Mosul to ISIL in mid-June 2014 to liberation from thousands of defenders.

The Iraqis think Mosul will be wrapped up in about a month:

"Despite the tough fighting... we are moving ahead in persistence to finish the battle for the western side within a month," Lieutenant General Talib Shaghati told Reuters at a conference in Sulaimaniya.

Not that Mosul will be cleansed of jihadi presence in a month, but the Iraqi government could have control of the city again. After about 34 months of ISIL control.

From the Pearl Harbor attack that brought America into World War II through the D-Day invasion of Nazi-occupied France and then to the beginning of the Operation Cobra breakout, following the creation of American armies, navies, and air forces to conduct the operations, was nearly 32 months.

Compare and contrast war efforts.

The Russians are amateurs compared to us for subliminal war.

Laughing Turns to Crying

Oh how China laughed and laughed as their little rogue pet North Korea pursued nukes and gave America, Japan, and South Korea fits! Good times. Good times.

But now America, Japan, and South Korea are forging closer military and intelligence ties in the face of the North Korean nuclear threat.

The three are building missile defenses that work against Chinese as well as North Korean missiles.

And we build offensive forces like long-range missiles, ground forces, and air power capable of striking and invading North Korea, a capability that could be used against Chinese forces if China tries to maintain their North Korean buffer territory.

With North Korea raging against these three and going postal on real and imagined enemies of the state, North Korea could start or provoke war.

So all of a sudden, the North Korean antics aren't so funny:

The [Chinese] government openly asked North Korea to stop its nuclear and ballistic missile tests and implied that if North Korea complied China would persuade the United States and South Korea to halt their military preparations to deal with a North Korean attack. North Korea was apparently not impressed. ...

China offers North Korea a choice; cooperate and be rewarded or continue to offend their “elder brother” and suffer the consequences. North Korea has not cooperated and China is reluctant to deliver consequences (the removal of Kim Kong Un) that will work.

The post also notes that since 2014, China has told North Korea that Chinese cavalry won't ride to the rescue if North Korea either attacks South Korea or if the Pyongyang government collapses.

But I sincerely doubt that this means China would stay out of North Korea in a crisis. I suspect China would move into part of North Korea to keep a buffer zone away from Chinese territory, even if it no longer will defend or prop up the North Korean regime.

There could be a partition of North Korea yet, although it seems more likely now that it could be either two (divided between China and South Korea) or maybe three (throwing in a small Russian zone in the northeast) if China is willing.

Let's hope that deals are cut. If it is a race, accidents can happen if each side sets their own finish line.

These Violent Storm Troopers Need to Be Arrested and Convicted

I see the Angry Nutball Totalitarian Intolerant Fascist Activists ("antifa," as they style themselves) are out in force again.

These are almost quite literally communist storm troopers. Some are anarchists, which is close enough for anti-government work.

Why the media doesn't call these "antifa" violent thugs the real fascist-like totalitarian threat rather than anti-fascists is beyond me.

Tip to Instapundit.

UPDATE: Local authorities--or states if local authorities won't do it--need to defend freedom of speech.

Defending the Baltic States is a Potential Kill Sack

We can't defend the Baltic NATO states from invasion. The best we should do is position tripwire NATO ground units to deter invasion and pull in all of NATO if Russia invades; and prepare for the counter-attack that first secures Russia's Kaliningrad exclave and then drives the Russians from the Baltic states.

No!

David Shlapak, senior international research analyst at RAND Arroyo Center, said its war games show a collapse of NATO defenses in 36 to 60 hours of a Russian invasion of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania without new steps being taken to deter Moscow.

The war games projected a seven- to 10-day warning of possible attack.

“Deterrence would be enhanced” if the three armored brigades and four other brigades of lighter forces from a number of NATO countries coupled with necessary artillery and logistics support were equipped and positioned to respond.

We can't possibly deploy enough troops to actually defend the Baltic states and defeat a serious Russian invasion force.

Worse, the only way such a NATO force in the Baltic states that is insufficient to stop the Russians makes any sense at all is to be the vanguard of an invasion force that preempts a Russian invasion by driving on St. Petersburg.

Believe me, that is exactly how the Russians will interpret it even though NATO would have no intention of doing that. Which will encourage the Russians to plan an invasion that hits NATO hard.

Rather than trying to hold in a forward defense, the objective must be for NATO forces to survive and counterattack:

These NATO states are small and weak; Russia is close and much stronger than them; and NATO's capabilities are divided, far away, and mostly unable to deploy away from home countries.

So of course we lose control of the Baltics to a determined Russian offensive to take the Baltic states. At best we could hold a corner of Lithuania.

But the key consideration isn't whether we can hold these NATO allies. It is whether we will fight to win the war and liberate them. West Berlin during the Cold War could never have been held if the Soviets had invaded. Large chunks of Norway, West Germany, and Denmark would have fallen, too. And perhaps the Netherlands and Belgium, depending on the success of Soviet armies in the northern part of a thrust into West Germany.

So I'd focus on the "near" rather than the "in" the Baltic states part of the RAND recommendation.

Personally, I'd permanently station a couple heavy American brigades in Poland (and supporting units like fires, engineer, and helicopter), with a pseudo armored cavalry regiment formed by adding a tank battalion (and also helicopter battalion) to an upgunned (with 30mm guns) Stryker brigade trained to operate as a screen in the Suwalki Gap in combined arms task forces.

The heavied-up Stryker unit could be a transitional unit before restoring heavy armored cavalry regiments to the Army for European missions focused on delaying and attriting a heavy armor offensive.

Add in REFORPOL depots in Poland for both American and other NATO forces; the restoration of an American corps in Europe controlling at least 5 brigades (we have a Stryker, a parachute, and now a rotational heavy brigade committed); plus a Marine ability to operate in the Baltic Sea using existing prepositioned stocks in Norway.

If Baltic state militaries in Estonia and Latvia especially can work with NATO special forces as irregulars and guerillas to complicate the Russian occupation until liberation, that would be great.

Of course, build logistics capability to deliver and support forces in eastern NATO.

Seriously, building up enough forces in the Baltic states to stop a Russian invasion begs the Russians to stage a coup in and drive through at-risk Belarus (which should be a key diplomatic objective) to hit Poland, link up with Russia's garrison in Kaliningrad, and leave the NATO troops in the Baltic states to wither on the vine isolated from the main battle in Poland and Lithuania.

The RAND people admit this:

When asked how long the seven brigades could hold out against a Russian attack in the war games, he said 28 days, “sort of Bastogne-like,” referring to the World War II Battle of the Bulge that slowed a German advance until American reinforcements could arrive.

The article misses the point that the key part of admitting that the forces in and rushed to the Baltics would be isolated by the Russians. That's what the Battle for Bastogne was--a siege with the American force isolated by the attacking Germans.

At best, we could try to hold Riga with a smaller force (a reinforced US Marine brigade plus NATO trip-wire battalions falling back and Baltic state units that survive) in a Tobruk-like siege sustained and supported from the sea and ground forces on off-shore islands to help keep Russian units fixed and to support irregulars deeper inland.

Could we really react and counter-attack to rescue 7 critically needed forward-deployed brigades in 28 days? When the key NATO counter-attack force resides in Fort Hood?

Oh Hell no, we couldn't.

So don't put those forward-deployed NATO brigades in a Russian kill sack in the Baltic states. (And I swear I will slap you if you try to tell me that the Russians need a 3:1 ratio to beat us.*) Those brigades need to survive to hold the line further south until we have a counter-attack force.

We were warned prior to Russia's invasions of Ukraine that we had to prepare. We did not prepare. Do we really need more warnings from Russia?

Oh, and while we worry about our new NATO allies on Russia's border, don't forget that Norway has always been on the front line. They are working on their revised defense needs, too.
____________

*If NATO deploys a third of the number plus one of brigade-equivalent units that Russia sends into the Baltic states, that does not mean NATO will win as a too literal interpretation of the "3:1 rule" holds.

As I explained prior to the American withdrawal from Iraq when I did a back-of-the-envelope calculation of force needs for defending Iraq from an Iranian invasion:

I know that a lot of writers would look at those numbers and chant the "3:1 rule" and say Iraq is safe, but that ratio applies to lower levels of analysis (and then considers the benefits of terrain and other factors on the "points" of the basic units). One side in a campaign with even a 1:1 equality overall could strip forces along the front to reduce local balances to 2:3 while massing combat power at the point of attack up to 6:1 or higher. Recall that the German blitzkrieg of France in 1940 had the Germans on the short end of tank numbers by a considerable margin and were pretty equal in troop strength. Yet the Germans concentrated the bulk of their tanks at the allied weak point and overwhelmed the spread-out Allied tank strength which could not mass to respond to the breakthrough. Campaign over.

I can't believe those people testifying raised this misinformation.

Wednesday, March 08, 2017

This Man Will Be Dangerous As Long as He Lives

Moqtada al-Sadr is a dangerous man and he would destroy everything we are trying to achieve in Iraq since the 1990s under President Clinton when America decided that Saddam had to go in favor of democracy.

Tell me nobody is surprised at this problem:

On Feb. 28, hundreds of pro-Sadrist university students in Kut attacked Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi's procession with stones and water bottles. Abadi's security forces fired tear gas and live bullets at the protesters, injuring three. Subsequently, Sadrist leader Muqtada al-Sadr apologized to Abadi for the breaches. Though he called on his followers to stop the protests in Kut until further notice, he accused former Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki of being behind the breaches to try to distort the Sadrist movement's image.

The incident reflects the intense competition among Iraq's Shiite leaders. There are currently three main Shiite figures competing for power: head of the Islamic Supreme Council Ammar al-Hakim, head of the State of Law Coalition Maliki, and Sadr himself. Each has his own plan to remain in power and remove the others or limit their influence.

Sadr is dangerous.

He is one path for Iran to control Iraq, which is a real threat we must defeat:

The U.S. is not happy with how Iraq has quietly disbanded the “Iran Section” in the Iraqi equivalent of the CIA. This organization was set up after 2004 with $3 billion in American cash and CIA trainers and advisors. Since the American troops left in 2011 Iran has pressured Iraqi officials to shut down the Iran Section and in early 2017 that was quietly done as the last few hundred personnel assigned to the Iran Section were fired or transferred. This has many Iraqis worried. While about 60 percent of Iraqis are Shia most of them do not want Iraq dominated by Iran. The security forces are now dominated by Shia but many of those generals do not want any of the 80-100,000 or so Iran backed Shia militia fighters involved in retaking Mosul. The Iraqi Shia that control the Iraqi government and military do not trust Iran and believe the Iran controlled Shia militias are being prepared to support an armed takeover of the current Shia controlled government. Many of the Shia militia are from Baghdad and there are growing fears that Shia cleric Ayatollah Muqtada al Sadr, an open fan of the Shia religious dictatorship in Iran, is planning to use his anti-corruption campaign in Baghdad as justification for an armed takeover of the government.

I've warned about Sadr again and again, given his violence and ties to Iran.

Indeed, I've warned about Sadr since summer 2004 (and enjoy the primitive nature of my pre-Blogger site. I shudder ...).

Why we or our Iraqi allies let him live is beyond me.

UPDATE: Eric at Learning Curve corrects me via email that the policies go back to Bush 41 following the Persian Gulf War.

I knew we hoped that in the aftermath of his crushing military defeat in the 1991 war that someone would overthrow Saddam, but I either forgot or did not know that the Clinton-era legislation traced roots a bit earlier. Thanks!

The End of the Beginning.

Iraqi forces are making good progress in western Mosul. As I've mentioned, I don't see the harder ISIL resistance that was supposed to greet the Iraqi forces in this phase of the battle. On the contrary, ISIL seems to be trying to escape with a rearguard buying time.

Iraqi progress is coming quickly:

Iraqi forces said Tuesday they had seized the main government offices in Mosul and its famed museum as they made steady progress in their battle to retake the city's west from jihadists.

The advances, which also included the recapture of three neighbourhoods, were announced on the third day of a renewed offensive against the Islamic State group in west Mosul -- the largest remaining urban stronghold in the "caliphate" IS declared in 2014.

I've been perplexed that the pre-battle buzz was that the battle for the western part of Mosul would be harder. It seemed more likely that ISIL shot its bolt in the fight for the east side of the city.

And the details of the battle didn't seem to indicate hard resistance at a main line of resistance. ISIL is running out of territory to have a main line of resistance.

Unless ISIL has been sucking the Iraqis into a kill sack in the interior of the city where massive house bombs will be used to slaughter troops and civilians alike in a final suicidal and homicidal gesture, Mosul is being liberated.

Terrorists can of course remain. Mosul has been a problem city for a long time, in that regard. But ISIL is being defeated.

And Strategypage confirms my impression of the battle despite the press reports that claim resistance will be harder even as the stories themselves indicate weaker resistance.

They say:

Intel analysts, taking all available data (refugee reports, prisoner interrogations, Internet chatter, aerial surveillance and captured documents) are pretty certain that ISIL has shifted most of its personnel into or towards Syria and the ISIL capital Raqqa. From there ISIL is trying to get a lot of their veteran operatives out of Syria. ISIL leaders are telling their followers to prepare for setbacks and a shift to clandestine operations (and lots of terror attacks) rather than administering territory. ...

For the troops and militia seeking to liberate Mosul this could be very good news because it means the current rapid advances (especially in the southern portion of west Mosul) are not part of a deception (to lead complacent attackers into a trap) but confirmation that ISIL is not going to use a lot of their dwindling fighters to make a bloody last stand in Mosul.

Iraqi commanders have apparently accepted this new assessment and are making the most of it. Foreign advisors (especially the Americans who call in air and artillery strikes) have been allowed, since the end of 2016, to operate as close to the fighting as they thought practical. As a result the guys calling in the smart bombs and artillery are delivering this firepower as quickly as they would for American troops and the Iraqi special operations personnel (many of them trained by Americans) are taking advantage of that to use all that firepower like the Americans do.

The Iraqis will still face ISIL terrorists even though the caliphate in Iraq is being dismantled.

Do read it all. There is more on Anbar where Iraqi forces are gaining the upper hand over dwindling ISIL numbers; and on Iran, who we will need to resist--in part by promoting rule of law--as Iran tries to dominate the Iraqi government. Iran had a free lane after we left Iraq in 2011 and with the Obama administration that was determined to be Iran's friend regardless of what Iran did to harm us and our friends.

We shall see how that goes. Mosul isn't the end of the road.

UPDATE: So long, and thanks for all the Daesh:

U.S. and Iraqi officials believe the leader of Islamic State, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, has left operational commanders behind with diehard followers to fight the battle of Mosul, and is now hiding out in the desert, focusing mainly on his own survival.

That has to suck to know you weren't one of the few deemed to be worthy of evacuation as the smart bombs get closer.

UPDATE: Perhaps it is official:

In the [Iraqi] command centre responsible for the eastern half of the city, which was liberated in December, Brigadier Qais Yaaqoub was jubilant. “They are in full collapse now,” he said. “When an army breaks it happens very quickly. Within a week or two, this will all be over.” He may be speaking prematurely, but probably not by much. The liberation of west Mosul, started only last month, has proceeded much faster than expected.

American officers think there are fewer than 500 ISIL defenders left. They may yet fight to the death in parts of the old city, but they are defeated.

Unless the Iranians launch a coup in Baghdad, the Iraqi forces aren't going to be distracted enough to fail to finish off the ISIL defenders.

UPDATE: Without a major target to fight for in Iraq like Mosul, more American power will be available for the Syria front.

Marines with 155mm artillery assets are now in Syria to support the offensive to take Raqqa:

A U.S. Marines artillery unit has deployed to Syria in recent days to help local forces speed up efforts to defeat Islamic State at Raqqa and the campaign to isolate the city is going "very, very well", the U.S.-led coalition said on Thursday. ...

The additional deployment comprises a total of 400 U.S. forces - both Marines and Army Rangers. It adds to around 500 U.S. military personnel already in Syria, Dorrian said.

Four hundred men would probably be a battalion, possibly stripped down for its temporary nature and possibly augmented with a rifle company for local security. But I'm guessing on that.

In addition, we may augment the theater reserve force with a reserve force that local commanders can commit quickly:

U.S. President Donald Trump's administration is weighing a deployment of up to 1,000 American soldiers to Kuwait to serve as a reserve force in the fight against Islamic State as U.S.-backed fighters accelerate the offensive in Syria and Iraq, U.S. officials told Reuters.

Proponents of the option, which has not been previously reported, said it would provide U.S. commanders on the ground greater flexibility to quickly respond to unforeseen opportunities and challenges on the battlefield.

So we'd have a reinforced battalion task force as an immediate reserve, if implemented.

But as we accelerate the fight against ISIL in Syria, what do we do about Assad? Forces backing him, including Russians, are heading east toward Raqqa to finally join that fight.

Will the militias we support in the fight against ISIL be fine with submitting to Assad after defeating ISIL? Will we walk away from them when ISIL is defeated?

Our objective for the end game in Syria has always perplexed me. If Assad isn't the final enemy, what is the point of our effort, really?

If Assad isn't the ultimate objective, we should have left ISIL in Syria alone--except for interdicting traffic to Iraq and other missions to support the Iraq front--and let Assad enjoy the fight against ISIL.

UPDATE: The Marine unit temporarily deployed to Syria is part of the 11th MEU currently deployed in CENTCOM.

UPDATE: Strategypage writes that the Marine unit is an artillery battery of artillery; also we have a Ranger company up near the Turkish border, with supporting HIMARS, to support the offensive on Raqqa and to keep the Turks from hammering the Kurds. Much more, too, including the part about Trump wanting to defeat Assad as well as ISIL.

UPDATE: Yes, Syria is complicated with lots of bad guys. But ISIL and Assad are two bad guys with American blood on their hands and the potential to kill more of us, so defeating them is as good a place to start as any.

UPDATE: I guess I'm unclear if the 400 new American troop increment is just the Marines or includes the Rangers.

UPDATE: The balance of a brigade of the 82nd Airborne Division already supporting Iraqi forces is going to Kuwait as a reserve force:

The U.S. military is sending an additional 2,500 ground combat troops to a staging base in Kuwait from which they could be called upon to back up coalition forces battling the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria.

We need to beat ISIL. And it is taking an amazing amount of time to break apart their caliphate. More troops to support our allies will help.

But this will result in more American casualties in the short run. While it is true that a war won sooner means troops won't be dying in a longer war, the unseen non-casualties never make up for the seen casualties.

What's the Difference Between the European Union and the Russian Empire?

In an article about the problem of Belarus under the shadow of Russia (which I addressed) is this gem that supports my poor opinion of the European Union:

At the same time, the Eurasian Economic Union, an international organization in the post-Soviet space, initiated and advanced by Russia, has been maturing. The main difference between the union and previous Russian projects is that the union is more structured. Additionally, it has clear plans and benchmarks for integration that are similar to those of the European Union. [emphasis added]

The Russians at least are clear for their end state of integration--autocracy under the Russian empire run from Moscow.

The European Union pretends that it isn't an anti-democratic proto-imperial project to be run from Brussels by a transnational Euro elite class.

UPDATE: Here comes the Praetorian Guard:

European Union states agreed on Monday to open a small command center to run military training missions abroad, a step France and Italy hope is a precursor to an EU defense headquarters.

A thousand-mile journey begins with the first boot step, though the EU denies what France and Italy hope for:

The EU is seeking to match its economic might with an ability to deter militant or Russian threats, as well as using peacekeepers to stabilize failing states on EU borders.

If the EU wanted Europe to have military might to match their economic might, European states would already have a stronger military within NATO, the organization set up to defend Europe.

Europe's elites in Brussels are starting on the path to a separate military structure--that weakens NATO in the hope of replacing it, thus ejecting America from Europe--in order to prop up the proto-imperial state of the European Union.

Britain may have gotten out in time--I assume nothing until the deed is done. Will other states take their opportunity to escape before it is too late?

With a military, Brussels will have an empire to prevent future exits from the ever closer union.

UPDATE: So the EU is causing an anti-democratic reaction in European states?

Sure. And I figure that works for the EU just fine. If Europeans lose democracy, will they care if they lost it to their local lords or to the imperial capital in Brussels?