An online journal of commentary, analysis, and dignified rants on national security issues. Other posts on home life, annoying things, and a vast 'other' are clearly marked.
I live and write in Ann Arbor, Michigan. University of Michigan AB and MA from Eastern Michigan University. One term in the Michigan Army National Guard. Former American history instructor and retired nonpartisan research analyst. I write on Blogger and Substack. Various military and private journals have published my occasional articles on military subjects. See "My Published Works" on the TDR web version or under the mobile version drop-down menu for citations and links.
I have finally salvaged my pre-Blogger TDR archives and added them into Blogger. They are almost totally in the form of one giant post for each month. And the formatting strayed from the originals. Sorry.
But historians everywhere can rejoice that this treasure trove of my thoughts is restored to the world.
And for your own safety, don't click on any old Geocities links or any of their similar variations in my posts. Those sites have been taken over by bad and/or dangerous sites. Hover over links first!
I don't think we can avoid additional waves of Wuhan Flu patients after we start to reopen our economy. All we can do with our shutdown is buy some time. We can't buy perfect safety.
Avoiding new waves can't be the standard for reopening the economy and our country. Surely you can't possibly believe we can mostly shut down the world until a safe vaccine is developed, mass produced, and used on us, can you?
The point of a shorter shutdown is to buy some time to help us be better able to treat new cases and contain outbreaks in an opened economy--no matter what the terms of an "opened" economy are (good luck with having Michigan Stadium seating post-Wuhan Flu so closely packed that not only can I tell if my neighbor has coins in her pocket, I can tell if they are heads or tails facing outward).
I know there is a media theme that there is a partisan divide over the Wuhan Flu with conservatives dismissing the pandemic's seriousness while the left practices SCIENCE and concern (well, they only became concerned weeks after complaining that Trump throttled back air travel from China).
But I suspect that media narrative is built 90% on conservatives recognizing that there is more than one threat with the Wuhan Flu while liberals see nothing but the Wuhan virus (and they refuse to call it that and you have to know they are mere weeks from calling it the Trump Virus).
I won't pretend to know what pace we should reopen. And I haven't been shy about saying much of the issue is way outside my lanes. But don't pretend staying closed is an option.
It’s a foundational premise of macroeconomics that the only way in which this machine can malfunction is to be either under-fueled or over-fueled. Studying the details of the economy’s inner workings is the province of microeconomists. The best microeconomists have learned that the economy isn’t a machine. It is, instead, a complex and ever-evolving process of billions of human actions, each adjusting in real time to the signals—market prices—generated by the actions of consumers and entrepreneurs across the globe. Though the outcomes of this process can be tallied up in monetary terms and reported as GDP figures, to focus on only these aggregate outcomes is to miss the all-important details of the economic process.
This will be hard, I think. I hope I'm wrong.
UPDATE: When the pandemic crisis is serious and global, I'd have hoped that the Democrats would abandon their standard false charge that Republicans just want people to die because Republicans want to slow the rate of growth of budget item X. But no:
No, those who want to reopen the economy don’t want to kill old people. And those who want to maintain a rigorous COVID-19 lockdown don’t want to kill jobs. Sane people on both sides want to ensure our physical health along with our economic health.
It’s not either/or; it’s both/and.
If we could just start with that premise, it would be great. Okay? The virus is not the only variable to consider. Tip to Instapundit.
The U.S. Army is again reorganizing its combat units. The last major reorganization was after 2003 when the independent combined arms brigade became the basic combat unit, replacing the combined arms division that had become the standard before and during World War II. The latest effort seeks to create combined arms battalions. China recently announced that it was making such combined arms battalions the standard combat organization for ground forces. Russia has already moved in this direction and the United States is experimenting with it.
We've done this before. During the Cold War combined arms task forces (battalions) and teams (companies) were commonly formed from the pure tank and mechanized infantry battalions.
Our current "heavy" brigade combat teams have two maneuver battalions with 4 companies each, split evenly between tank and mechanized infantry companies. I liked this balance because I've read that experience going back to World War II showed that a balance between infantry and tanks works better than having too many tanks and too few infantrymen.
Keep in mind that it is possible that our leadership will suffer without pure tank battalions to produce leaders who understand tank warfare, as an article advocating pure tank battalions I linked to in this post argued.
I suspect that we can push down combined arms to the battalion and company levels--because we have in the past with great success. But it should be the common practice in the field rather than the organizational standard which should be combined arms no lower than the brigade level.
Although I'd be fine with separate combined arms heavy battalions to loan to infantry brigades (or to the Marines these days), as I included in this Army article.
The infantry community has a problem. The centerpiece of the Army’s operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, the infantry brigade combat team, is in danger of becoming obsolete in the face of near-peer opponents. This formation of three infantry battalions, an engineer battalion, an artillery battalion, a cavalry squadron, and a support battalion needs to be restructured to maximize an infantry brigade’s chances of success in an era of fast-paced and rapidly evolving multidomain operations.
The author wants a new infantry brigade with just two infantry brigades to make room for more supporting weapons and systems to fight in high-intensity combat. [I guess the new term for conventional battle is "multidomain operations." Bad TDR.]
This is all fine. Although more infantry than a two-battalion brigade has would be needed in urban warfare. And despite my firmly held view that we should minimize the need to fight in cities rather than embrace it, sometimes we will need to fight in cities because we need to and not just because we can. We could attach infantry battalions from the National Guard to the brigade tasked with urban warfare if it comes to that.
Or we'll need infantry if we need to fight COIN again despite our clear desire not to do that again. Even in the Cold War the Army had a pretty consistent even balance between infantry and heavy units.
The arguments for light tanks to reinforce Army infantry brigades will get our infantry brigades destroyed. ...
As I argued in my article in the April 2018 issue of Army ("Look to Abrams Tanks to Support the Infantry," pp. 42-45--sorry, not online [NOTE--yes it is]), the Army should attach tank companies or battalions (or tank-mechanized teams or task forces) to infantry brigades to give them a chance to survive a mechanized fight.
Because I don't know what obscure niche scenarios the Army has in mind for these light tank-equipped infantry brigades, but I think the most worrisome conventional land war scenario we will face is massed Russian heavy brigades storming through the Baltic states heading to link up with Russia's Kaliningrad exclave.
If we throw infantry brigades with light tanks designed to outmatch Russian light tanks into that fight, those infantry brigades will be slaughtered and likely nothing more than a speed bump.
Give our infantry brigades intended for high intensity combat the Abrams tanks and/or Bradley Fighting Vehicles they need to slug it out with Russian tanks.
I'd rather just convert more infantry brigades to armored brigades. But some infantry brigades are needed for some missions. Yet if the infantry brigades are to have a chance of surviving if thrown into the fight against heavy enemy forces, they do need more firepower and capabilities than leg infantry can bring to the field.
Drop the infantry battalions to two without reducing the battalions ATGM total, by all means. Add other supporting elements as the author offers, including reinforcing the cavalry element.
But stop mucking around the edges and just give the new infantry brigade intended for a European fight a tank battalion or a heavy task force. For God's sake, look up the old studies on Light Infantry from the Cold War when some believed they could be equipped and trained to be more than speed bumps against heavy forces.
When you start to heavy up the infantry brigade, heavy up the infantry brigade.
“It is not strategically prudent, nor operationally viable to physically concentrate on large, close-in bases that are highly vulnerable to a potential adversary’s strike capability,” Indopacom’s commander, Adm. Philip Davidson, wrote in his report. “Distributed operations increase mobility and agility to ensure our ability to ‘Fight and Win.’”
Under the multiyear Indopacom proposal, $5.8 billion would be for offensive missiles and multiple radars, including a space-based radar; another $5.8 billion would be used to distribute forces around the region; and $5.1 billion would be for “logistics and security enablers”—a broad array that includes counterpropaganda operations, fuel storage, battle-damage repair facilities, as well as military aid for forces in Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand, and Vietnam.
Since we left the Philippines after the Cold War, our military in the western Pacific has been concentrated in the Japan-South Korea area.
We are moving Marines out of Okinawa back out of easy reach of Chinese missiles and aircraft to Guam and Australia.
And our Navy is still working on operating out of Singapore with a small contingents of LCS.
But still we need more bases, as Davidson said. I agree.
And improving the logistics for moving around the theater is necessary if the Army is to expand its horizon's from the DMZ in South Korea, which I advocated in Military Review.
Our secretary of defense also spoke of the need for more efforts to support our diplomacy:
Esper has warned that Beijing’s expanding military threatens U.S. influence, and he’s called China his “No. 1 priority,” traveling to Asia last August to shore up U.S. alliances. But critics charge the Defense Department’s budget process is better organized to address the procurement priorities of the armed services than regional war-fighting priorities—except when it comes to Europe and the European Deterrence Initiative.
[Neighbors of China] have to be confident that we have the power and determination to use it against China and to be confident that other potential partners won't stop absorbing some of China's power by making deals with China to ally with Peking. If these countries don't have confidence that we will help them, they'll cut a deal with China to protect themselves and turn away from us.
So we have to be careful about maintaining our power in the Pacific and maintaining our reputation for supporting allies and fighting until we win. If any nation, like Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Australia, or Vietnam think that they can't count on us for effective military support, they'll withdraw from the potential balancing coalition against China. And once one country defects, the power potential arrayed against China will drop enough to perhaps push another country to defect and align with China rather than with us.
China is a threat, and we need the allies and infrastructure to resist Chinese expansion at our expense.
Because they’re only getting about 60 percent of the new recruits into the system, they’re also taking an increasing retention. What I have recommended to the services is that they take a real hard look at extensions of enlistment periods, or delaying dates of separation or retirements for folks who are eligible to do that, in order to keep that side of the equation up.
The extension of enlistment periods (stop-loss) is absolutely allowed even though it is not apparently the first thing the military is thinking of, and I mentioned that possibility last week:
Military recruiting is naturally suffering during the Wuhan Flu. Although at some point you'd think some young people will see a military job as better than no military job. But basic training is a group project with little in the way of social distancing possible. So even if recruiting was fine, how do you bring the new people in and turn them into troops? I wonder if stop-loss will be used in the short run to maintain numbers. Or maybe troops will be persuaded to stay in a bit longer to make up for lower intake because of the lack of job opportunities in the civilian economy. And the morning after I wrote this I see that the Army has stopped moving recruits to basic training. This is just for two weeks to put policies in place. Perhaps every recruit is isolated for two weeks before basic training. Even if this works, there is going to be a recruit shortfall. Let's see if stop-loss action is next. A lot of troops may be shocked that their contract with their last years of service in the reserve component gives the Army the option of making that active duty service. If memory serves me. [emphasis added]
Still, I think there is a decent chance that stop-loss won't need to be used because enough troops will extend their service voluntarily rather than try their luck in a lockdown economy. Which could be enough to get through the slump in recruiting.
Although at some point won't recruiting go back up as people decide the military is a good option to get through our lockdown economy and get out when our economy is running again?
If stoploss is used, I assume the Left will more easily go berserk in today's Resistance environment.
Africa could become the next epicentre of the coronavirus outbreak, the World Health Organization (WHO) has warned.
UN officials also say it is likely the pandemic will kill at least 300,000 people in Africa and push nearly 30 million into poverty.
The past week in Africa has seen a sharp rise in coronavirus cases.
I guess a slight genetic resistance among Africans and warmer climates may not be the protective shields that once seemed plausible. I hope we are prepared to get our now excess ventilators to Africa in a hurry to meet the hospitalization surges.
Africa was supposed to be China’s new stomping grounds. Instead, the novel coronavirus has spawned a growing backlash that threatens to unwind the ties Beijing has carefully cultivated over decades.
The trigger for the burgeoning diplomatic crisis: Anger over the treatment of African citizens living in China and frustration at Beijing’s position on granting debt relief to fight against the outbreak. ...
[China's] decadeslong quest for influence in Africa was gravely challenged last week when a group of disgruntled African ambassadors in Beijing wrote to Foreign Affairs Minister Wang Yi to complain that citizens from Togo, Nigeria and Benin living in Guangzhou, southern China, were evicted from their homes and made to undergo obligatory testing for Covid-19.
A lot of poor countries have accepted China's offer of loans and construction to be part of China's ambitious project to build Chinese-controlled trade routes. They are extremely vulnerable to the virus raging out of control once it hits them. Will China be the one to help them cope with this epidemic?
I hope this is contained--and soon. But if it isn't how many countries will be eager to invite China into their country going forward? Or even allow them to stay? This would be a convenient excuse for countries having second thoughts about the wisdom of the debt trap they signed up for.
Although I did not suspect the open displays of Chinese racism that would bounce the rubble in Africa.
Will the money that China can spread around be quite as appealing after the Wuhan Flu passes?
Probably. The article's author certainly concludes that. But some damage will likely endure.
I suppose virtual NATO meetings could make alliance decisions faster. But face-to-face meetings are still very useful and the fact that they are preferred in general may not just be inertia. Also, virtual meetings are easier for Russia to hack and potentially interfere with them.
Better raped than rude. To be fair, the people making the insane policy can continue to feel virtuous even as the proles pay the price of that luxury belief. Tip to Instapundit.
Interesting. But it is self-reporting. And for many on the left, reporting a mental health issue may be more about claiming victim status than anything else, I imagine. Still, it's nice to see the BS science going after the left instead of the right for once. Tip to Instapundit.
California seems to have done a good job of handling the Wuhan Flu. But this crime policy in San Francisco just seems to be begging for blowback. Tip to Instapundit.
So a Wuhan lab escape isn't so far-fetched, after all? This doesn't mean it is a bio-weapon, which analysis says it is not. Perhaps China's propaganda effort to blame America was meant to get people to defiantly push back by pointing to the wet markets in order to shield the laboratory. More here.
Another faked campus hate crime. This isn't proof that racism doesn't exist. But it is clearly an indication that the demand for racist campus incidents far exceeds the supply of racists. And it is why I yawn when I read about one. At this point I assume that in months a much quieter debunking of the claim will take place. And amusingly, Newsweek redacted the racist and ethnic slurs but not B*TCHES. I assume feminists will attack this editorial decision in 3 ... 2... 1 ... Tip to Instapundit.
Just like I refuse to jump on Trump for not acting sooner given the facts known at the time (and given the state of mind of the loyal opposition), I am not going to jump on Whitmer for Michigan's response. Sure, some aspects of the governor are likely overboard. But that is a matter of fine tuning, I think. And note that Metro Airport was not affected by Trump's early travel restriction for China. That hurt. There is no mention of brisk traffic with bordering Canada as a contributor to the sudden and big spread here. Which seems odd, eh?
Howard Zinn was a partisan hack with undeserved influence. But based on my experience with the American Historical Association, it is not shocking that historians haven't trashed the man's eminently trashable trash history of America. Somebody has finally trashed it. But it is too late, for the damage was done. And besides, the anti-American Left has the 1619 Project to replace Zinn.
I expect our FBI--our counter-intelligence outfit--to be able to resist being useful idiots for our enemies. Sadly, the FBI's role enabled a much broader Russian recruitment of useful idiots here. Tell me that anybody in Russia imagined what their amateurish low-budget effort would achieve.
I have to believe this is satire. Because if I think it isn't for just a moment, my despair over the state of higher education in America will consume my soul. It would make great satire, you must admit.
Like all other information coming out of China, China's defense spending numbers can't be trusted. Remember, everything there supports the Chinese Communist Party monopoly of power. The methodology seems sound and puts China's defense effort not far beyond America's. And America spends to deploy and sustain forces globally in contrast to China's more China-centric deployment.
Contrary to this author, I think the nation-state will be just fine after the Wuhan Flu passes. I'll pay attention to notions the nation-state is taking second place to some other basis when the United Nations--which legitimizes the nation-state as the basic organizing basis of governance--is renamed the United Entities.
April 15th in Ann Arbor:
I don't like living in a snow globe. The lack of spring is the only thing keeping me from having a fully obsessive hate going on about the Chinese Communist Party's role in the Wuhan Flu lockdown I'm living through.
Within this post they mention that Ethiopia will begin filling their not-quite-completed dam on the Nile River on July 1st despite lack of an agreement with Egypt and Sudan on how fast the reservoir will be filled. Egypt wants a 7-year fill period to avoid water shortages. Ethiopia says 4 is fine.
I don't know what to make of Trump's assertion that he--and not the states--has the final say in opening up the economy. Perhaps in some ways there is a way that the federal government can assert emergency powers (but I don't know what that is and don't pretend to be knowledgeable about that), but my first reaction was that of course this is a state responsibility. Much like my defense of state powers in imposing restrictions and lockdowns under federalism, I think states are the place for that decision. And after outrage in the media the states said they'd do it, and announced plans in regional groupings, and the president quickly backed down, it seems. Did Trump bait them into doing what he wanted them to do? Did he back down? Very odd.
And again, why I don't trust our media. They might be that stupid to make such mistakes. But the pattern indicates they feel reporting news is beneath them when they can make the news.
I think this praise for Germany's meticulous and orderly handling of the Wuhan Flu rests on stereotypes of grim German efficiency rather than the actual statisticscompared to other countries. And I honestly don't think we have uniform standards of deaths due to the epidemic or even infections for valid comparison by country. Not that Germany seems to be doing poorly. But hold off on the heel-clicking and saluting. But have no doubt I have my fingers crossed that the Germans can ease out of lockdown successfully. Will their reputation shape reporting of this, too?
While I think the captain of Theodore Roosevelt had a good motive for sending a letter up the chain of command regarding the Wuhan Flu outbreak on his ship, the details seem inappropriate. I'm not so sure that possibly putting him back in the mix of command officers at sea is a good idea. But my knowledge is obviously very limited. And experience. Still, it is possible that reinstatement is simply for his formal record which will be followed by his retirement. Even with reinstatement I find it hard to believe that his path for promotion is dead.
Seriously, what the heck happened to Jennifer Rubin? The blinding hatred she displays should embarrass her, but apparently doesn't. I would never argue that Trump should be free from criticism on the Wuhan Flu response or in general. But she makes it easy for Trump loyalists to ignore valid criticism by pointing to idiocy like Rubin peddled there.
The Chinese are bullying the Malaysians in the South China Sea as if any law at all allows China to claim the region as their own. America's position has long been that the claimants can negotiate what they want but that China should not simply take what the want; and that the South China Sea is an international waterway.
I'm just going to note that the short-lived faux scandal fanned by media and partisan hyperventilating that states had too few ventilators and that Trump was a war criminal for failing to provide all that the states asked for has ended with no state apparently ever short of ventilators to deal with their surges of Wuhan Flu patients.
California appears to want to exploit the Wuhan Flu to open up a more socialist economy. Well, the Wuhan Flu at least gave them a head start on reaching the poverty that socialism always produces if left running long enough. And no, Scandinavia no longer has socialism. They have free market systems with extensive welfare systems. Which has its own problems but is not socialism. Tip to Instapundit.
I think we really need to look into whether the Wuhan Flu--just its existence--causes stupidity and paranoia. Yes, people with advanced degrees can be dumb as rocks.
To be fair, increasing prosperity in China may yet one day lead to a more free China--over the objections of the Chinese Communist Party. And if countries fall into China's debt trap with their Belt and Road project (New Silk Road), why wouldn't those countries consider simply nationalizing (seizing) Chinese assets the way countries did with Western assets decades ago? Are those countries more willing to be colonies now than then?
China's nuclear arsenal and missiles. We think their nuclear arsenal is pretty small, but is it? It just seems odd to me that with all their extensive missile testing and building plus their general massive military modernization that they seem to have fewer nukes than credited in the not so recent past. On the bright side, most of their missiles are shorter range missiles aimed at Russia or India (or at least intended for them, if not technically targeting them as they sit there).
Once again, the story is not about the new information that makes Democrats look bad and possibly criminal, but about the fact that Republican Party "seizes on" that information to attack the Democrats for what they did. Amazing. This is how it works. If a Republican does something wrong the story is about what the Republican did wrong. With bonus stories about how that reflects badly on all Republicans. When you have Democrats to defend, this is how CNN goes. And the way they write it up is fascinating. Yes, the initiation of the probe into Trump and Russia was probably (barely) justified. The story seems to make that the key point. What was not justified was the ... overly enthusiastic ... continuation of the probe long after the so-called evidence justified the probe. That is the potential crime if the probe went on and on just to get a domestic political opponent. You wonder why I don't trust the media at face value? And every decade during my adult life time they've gotten worse. Tip to Instapundit.
As China continues to be a bunch of lying SOBs about the Wuhan Flu--which started in China and then spread because the Chinese lied about the spread along with WHO--the Chinese are looking the other way (if not cooperating with) at the North Korea regime in evading sanctions over Rocket Man's nuclear ambitions. And that's on top of their East China Sea and South China Sea shenanigans and Hong Kong repression noted earlier. The Chinese really want to erase all doubt in the world about the desirability and wisdom of decoupling from the Chinese Communist Party's police state.
I really want to know how the shutdown of our economy ends. People need to work. And few can just work from home.
Checks paid for with borrowed money will help bridge the unemployment gap but cannot be a replacement for an economy based on work. We're not at the point where the robots can do the work for us, regardless of whether that is good or bad. And I hate to break it to you, but just printing money or minting super-expensive coins is not the answer for long.
So again, what are the conditions that let us re-start the economy? And can we just "re-start" the economy at our choice, like it is a mere machine under our control? What can the government do to make sure too many businesses don't hang back and risk going broke by starting up before there are customers?
There needs to be confidence in local hospital capacity. "We have to arrest the spread of the virus," said [U.S. Representative Tom] Cotton, "and we have to give people confidence that if they do get out of their homes, go back to work, or go back to their normal economic life of shopping and going to restaurants and so forth, that 1) they're probably not going to get the virus, and 2) if they do, the healthcare system will be up and functioning and able to treat them."
That involves defeating the flu by containing and nullifying it through policies, personal behaviors, treatments, and vaccines.
But that's not the only part. In a vast country with economic transactions spanning our country and entire planet, how do we rebuild all those links suddenly ruptured globally be the Wuhan Flu? It isn't just a problem for China trying to open up first.
And for God's sake, the debate over whether the president or the governors have the power to restart the economy is completely misplaced. I side with governors on this but the power of the federal government to print money gives the federal government leverage that makes the state powers largely irrelevant as a practical matter. Both must cooperate and the states can decide but not make things work on their own.
I'd love a spontaneous V-shaped crash and recovery. But the damage is too deep and too wide around the planet to get that, I think. I'd really love to be wrong.
The reason for this is not primarily the poor performance of EU countries in using integrated EU tools to fight the virus and its economic impact - although that plays an important role as well.
The main reason is that Europe could end up being too broke to still be resilient, let alone be a shaper of foreign policy outcomes on its own continent, let alone the world.
Still, despite reporting on that silver lining to a dark Wuhan Flu cloud over Europe, the author seems to conflate political "Europe" with geographic Europe, assuming the decline of the former means the decline of Europe in general. I disagree. The EU should be a trading bloc without the stifling hand of an imperial state on top of the countries of Europe.
Nor do I agree with the author's notion that American ties to Europe have weakened since the Obama "pivot" and Trump's election. And I find additional humor in the fact that Bush 43 and Europe's popular opposition to the Iraq War--which we won without their help, in the end--used to be the defining moment in the American-European divide. Never mind, I guess.
American military strategy in the Asia-Pacific region needs to include the Army, and not simply as a naval auxiliary with anti-ship and air defense capabilities. The Army must be prepared to carry out its core capability of large-scale conventional ground operations for better deterrence and better war-winning options in INDOPACOM's area of responsibility.
Such conditions might be a Chinese civil war, collapse of central authority, or when China's ground forces are too occupied to prevent a large-scale Army "Thunder Run" raid or a temporary enclave on the mainland to establish air bases to allow air operations deeper into China.
Short of such events, America would need full mobilization at World War II levels to raise scores of ground divisions to invade China, of course.
Not that a major land operation in INDOPACOM is necessarily a good idea. But failure to have that option simplifies China's military problems. What, I have asked, is the point of our Navy penetrating Chinese anti-access/area denial weapons (A2/AD)? To sail around off the coast of China waiting for China to offer terms of surrender?
I have been reading Donald Kagan's On the Origins of War and the Preservation of Peace, and the conclusion about the Peloponnesian War of 431 to 404 B.C. stated:
When Pericles's moderate policy failed to deter Corinth, however, deterrence of Sparta was no longer possible. The Athenians simply did not have enough manpower to offer a credible offensive threat. Talk of seaborne raids and fortified bases on the Peloponnesus would not work. Most Spartans did not have the imagination to understand the threat the skillful use of such devices could pose to them and their alliances. Only the challenge of a superior army could have held them back, and the Athenians had no way to produce that. Their policy, therefore, was not consistent with their strategic capacity. Had they understood that better they might have refrained from the Megarian Decree and taken a more conciliatory approach, since their capacity for deterrence was inadequate and since no strategy was available to them that guaranteed victory in war. Pericles and the majority of Athenians, however, had great confidence in the promise of the new, untried, strategy that their navy, walls, and empire allowed them alone to pursue. They counted on it to deter their enemies from fighting and, when that failed, to bring victory. So the war came. [emphasis added]
Remember, if we cease attempts to make sure we can penetrate China's anti-access forces to operate near China, a reliance on exploiting the Malacca Dilemma means that we must immediately escalate to the total war measure of blockade should China seize some territory in the East China or South China Seas, perhaps Taiwan itself--or do nothing.
Is that what we want to do? Have a pre-war 1914 German strategy that assumes total two-front war with the initial offensive aimed at France even if France is not involved in the war-threatening crisis?
I don't want to rely on air and naval power to take on China if it--God forbid--comes to confronting China. Will the Chinese think anything short of a ground option is a real threat to Chinese Communist Party control of China? China will have a tremendous advantage knowing that they are immune to American ground power.
We have that knowledge regarding Chinese threats to American territory. Let's keep that edge and make China worried about what we might do to them on the land.
I mentioned losses Nigeria and Chad endured at the hands of jihadis and the announced counter-offensive. This is big if true: "The Chadian army said Thursday it had wound up an offensive against Boko Haram jihadists in the Lake Chad border region in which 52 troops and 1,000 jihadists were killed." I do worry that Chad defines any running local resident as a jihadi--and any local resident standing still is a well-disciplined jihadi.
When enough ISWAP groups have made themselves comfortable and secure in their assigned area they can contribute mobile (using trucks and motorcycles) fighters that can become part of a larger attack force that can inflict a major defeat on the military. That’s what happened on March 23rd to the Chad army base on Bohoma Island. The Chad forces got sloppy and ISWAP took advantage of that. The Chad Army is usually more professional and effective than that and the Bohoma [defeat] will motivate commanders to do better. This may backfire on ISWAP but at the moment ISWAP is ignoring the recent losses on the Lake Chad coast and Abubakar Sheka, the ISWAP declared a victory. He also sent out a second video message urging his followers to remain firm and defeat enemy attacks. This message was an acknowledgement of recent heavy ISWAP losses in southern Chad.
So it seems as if there was some atypical troop sloppiness and yes, the counteroffensive did hammer the jihadis.
The Long War goes on. But you have to admit that Nigeria, Niger, and Chad have certainly earned jihadi hatred for their invasion of Iraq in 2003. I hear that is what causes the jihadis to hate us, after all.
It seems like we may finally be getting to peak epidemic in America. I worry that even if we could turn on our economy like a machine simply idling for the time being during the Wuhan Flu, will enough other parts of the world go live at the same time to provide customers?
Does America have enough economic heft to drag the rest of the world into recovery after the Wuhan Flu the way we did after World War II? We may see a hint of our problems as China starts to reopen their economy even as their best customers in the West are still shut down. And China has a greater reliance on trade than America.
This issue argues for America to work with our Western allies--and not just with Europe--on economic revival.
In the bad scenario, a snag that BRI is likely to hit is a funding shortfall. So far, President Xi Jinping’s signature project has been powered primarily by China, whose growth rates were decreasing even before the outbreak. The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) leadership is facing a daunting task revitalizing an economy that is up against serious structural challenges. Three months after disaster struck in Wuhan, the country appears to be coming round, but a V-shaped rebound is not a given and analysts continue to slash their forecasts. With the United States and Europe reeling from the pandemic, Chinese exports will take a big hit. At home, Beijing is faced with limited room to stimulate the country’s highly leveraged economy, with persistently bad news coming in.
The Wuhan Flu coronavirus could really destroy any hope of expanding China's soft power via their so-called New Silk Road infrastructure project. China hoped that trade will follow their flag, but trade will not follow the flu.
And there were issues before the Wuhan Flu hit Chinese finances and credibility.
This part of that initial article cracks me up: Could Xi have "jumped the gun with an overly ambitious and assertive foreign policy agenda, including the BRI."
A Chinese leader jumped the gun and didn't anticipate the future even without considering the Wuhan Flu? Say it ain't so!
The market mechanism does not function comprehensively to allocate resources, most notably for land, energy, and financial capital. ... Gao [Shangquan, Director of the China Society for Economic Reform] notes that local government officeholders will be in power for only a few years but will auction off land to be used over many decades. The incumbent government will want to see results from land auctions now, even if this means the land will be abused or polluted and therefore lose future value. The same is true for minerals, whose artificially low prices encourage overexploitation. At the same time, the shortsighted governments refuse to make investments in education, public health, or sustainable agriculture because the payoffs from such projects can come only many years into the future, by which time today's officeholders will have moved onto other jobs, in other locales.
This. is. awesome.
Chinese rulers unable to think about the long term and simply focused on the short run? Say it ain't so! The culture! The history! The vaguely worded fortune cookie pronouncements! Patience and perspective are in their effing genes, aren't they?
Apparently not.
The Chinese are people, like anyone else. What a radical idea.
Anyway, we should watch China's reopening for clues about potential problems we will face with as much urgency as we should have watched the Chinese epidemic back in December and questioned WHO's cheerleading of China's efforts.
UPDATE: The guidelines for moving forward. Are they good? Dunno. Out of my lane, as I have freely admitted. But we have to start trying. I'm pretty darned sure about that.
As a force for good in the nation and as Iraq’s closest friend, the United States has proposed a Strategic Dialogue with the Government of Iraq to be held in middle of June.
With the global COVID-19 pandemic raging and plummeting oil revenues, threatening an Iraqi economic collapse, it’s important that our two governments work together to stop any reversal of the gains we’ve made in our efforts to defeat ISIS and stabilize the country.
The Strategic Dialogue will be led by my Under Secretary for Political Affairs David Hale. And all strategic issues between our two countries will be on the agenda, including the future presence of the United States forces in that country, and how best to support an independent and sovereign Iraq.
This sounds like an effort to figure out how to fight Phase IX of the Iraq War in the face of Iranian pressure on Iraq (and against American forces supporting Iraq).
The more Iraq works with America, the more the effort can be non-military, I think, because Iranian assets inside Iraq will be less able to attack American and Coalition forces as Iraqi security elements arrest them. I'd much rather have Phase IX be one focused on rule of law. Outlaw the Iranian-controlled militias, arrest the pro-Iran Iraqis, expel the Iranian agents, reduce corruption that Iran exploits and that rightly inspires popular anger at the government's ineffectiveness in general.
The U.S. State Department’s Rewards For Justice program has offered a $10 million bounty for information on Muhammad Kawtharani, one of Hezbollah’s senior operations commanders inside Iraq. Hezbollah operates in Iraq closely alongside Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps to prop up and support Shia militias hostile to the U.S. and the West.
Iraq has incentive to want this type of non-military war to avoid Iraq being a battlefield for American and Iranian forces.
If Iraqi forces can take the lead inside Iraq, America will be better poised to deter or fight Iran outside of Iraq with its military forces in the CENTCOM region.
I'm hoping we and the Iraqis have the power to define this phase of the war.
*As an aside, the author describes the American consolidation of troops at two bases as being part of a "winding down" operations in Iraq. Is that true? Or is it to simplify Patriot defense against a new Iranian ballistic missile barrage?
Amidst Beijing’s increasingly aggressive actions, Taiwan’s President Tsai Ing-wen called on like-minded countries around the world to start pushing back against China and other “anti-democratic forces” across economic, political, and military fronts.
“Historical trends do not always favor the forward march of democracy. But in Taiwan, moving backward is not an option,” Tsai said on June 25.
“In the 21st century, democracy is in retreat,” she said, citing a report by Freedom House that found global freedom has been in decline for 12 consecutive years.
Tsai should encourage the establishment of a League of Democracies on Taiwan designed to promote democracy and rule of law at the national, state/provincial, and local levels. It would be made up of representatives from democracies around the world and NGOs. Which I've noted before:
But why couldn't Taiwan host a League of Democracies on Taiwan to discuss the mechanics of democracy promotion and democracy practice?
It could be composed of nations, provinces/states, and cities that want to discuss these issues.
As a body discussing the concept of democracy in both state and sub-state actors, it would not run afoul of Chinese red lines about independence. China has offered one state with two systems to Hong Kong--although it really doesn't--and to Taiwan to ease resistance to Peking absorbing Taiwan. How could China oppose democracy as a concept apart from independence when it formally agrees?
Yet it would be a powerful symbol of resistance to Chinese efforts to deny Taiwan democracy.
Taiwan would invite specific qualifying countries, states or provinces, and cities--including Hong Kong--to join the body. Taiwan could invite non-governmental bodies that address democracy and rule of law, including the Carter Center. Perhaps those NGOs could help define a rule of law democracy for membership qualification. Neither China, Iran, nor Chicago, for example, would qualify if the definitions are real.
How would the Chinese people react over time to such a body in their backyard discussing how to create and improve democracy--something China does not have and which Xi Jinping will never grant the people voluntarily?
At some point Taiwan needs to go on offense to get off the treadmill of a losing arms race with the far larger China. Hitting China at their weak point of legitimacy of Chinese Communist Party rule by highlighting democracy and rule of law is the way to go. Perhaps after decades of being a KMT authoritarian state that could only compete militarily with the communist autocrats on the mainland, thinking of an ideological struggle is too new for the rule-of-law democracy that Taiwan has become.
But it is a new and valid arena to compete with China.
Or Taiwan could go the Israel route and build a bigger and more effective military with a really good reserve system, backing it with nuclear weapons.
Recent reports that Moscow is deploying Cossack groups along the Russian-Ukrainian border near the Kharkiv, Sumy and Chernihiy regions of Ukraine are extremely worrisome, as the Kremlin ostensibly used similar units in its initial invasion of southeastern Ukraine in 2014. Such revelations may presage a new Russian move against Ukraine and be intended as an attempt to muddy the waters about who is behind any aggression. But at the same time, they are the latest sign that the Kremlin wants to have groups with which it can maintain a certain plausible deniability when engaging in destabilizing or aggressive operations both internationally and within the Russian Federation.
And the Russians are bringing the Cossacks--now augmented by units simply called "Cossack" because it sounds bad ass rather than being ethnic Cossacks--into the regular armed forces rather than treating them as paramilitary irregulars.
But it seems odd that Russia would risk something like this against a Ukraine far more prepared than it was in early 2014. Isn't Russia broke enough?
And wouldn't Ukrainian troops just slaughter any paramilitary Cossacks who cross the border? Would Russia support them with firepower and troops, greatly reducing the implausible deniability of another invasion of Ukraine?
And wouldn't an expansion of the war just give Ukraine an excuse to hit Sevastopol (missiles and sea mines would be my weapons of choice) and inflict damage on the only gain from Russia's 6-year-old stalemated war with Ukraine?
As the author notes, they might be intended to reinforce the Donbas front. Or the Cossacks may just be appearing as a force designed to cope with the inability to bring enough warm bodies into the ground forces.
This problem gets worse, especially for the Islamic government Turkey has had for the last two decades. This government became allies with Russia and Iran, two traditional enemies. To no one’s surprise, these alliances did not work out. In order to please these new friends, Turkey risked being expelled from NATO. Worst of all, expulsion from NATO would mean the West would regard Turkey as just another poorly managed, Islamic terrorists-tolerating and unreliable Middle Eastern nation. One thing most Turks can agree on is NOT wanting to turn away from the West. The policy of being closer to Arab nations and tolerant of some Islamic terrorist or radical groups has also lost any popularity it once held.
Turkey used to have close relations with Israel, too, until Erdogan ended that.
In addition to fighting a war inside Syria (with 10,000 Turkish troops and a lot more local allies) against Assad, Iran, and Russia (so much for Erdogan's brief fling with Putin, and to a lesser extent with the Shia mullahs), Turkey is fighting a "war" with fellow NATO member Greece by pushing a human wave of refugees toward Greece, which involves some low-level--so far--armed elbow throwing.
Turkey is trying the "lovely little continent you got there, it would be a terrible thing if something bad happened to it" ploy to get European money and support for their Syria war. The EU has kind of abandoned Greece after promising support for dealing with refugees coming through Turkey.
And Turkey decided to get involved in the Libyan civil war. Turkey has sent about 500 Turkish troops and 4,500 Syrian mercenaries there.
Turkey has a problem with the Syrian multi-war south of them. But I fail to see how Erdogan is solving the problem rather than just adding to Turkey's woes by trying to establish a virtual Ottoman Empire to the south and attempting a virtual march on Vienna to the northwest, which has alienated actual allies.
The Marines are evolving to support the Navy. How much should they evolve away from sustained large-scale ground combat?
This author thinks that the amphibious ready group and its Marine Expeditionary Unit (MEU, reinforced Marine battalion) should abandon forcible entry missions to focus on "strike (as a light carrier), raiding, humanitarian assistance/disaster relief (HA/DR) operations, and special operations support."
He thinks the battalion should be slimmed down and split between the three ships of the amphibious ready group (ARG). This matches my raiding and advance base employment of Marine Expeditionary Companies (MEC) in this Proceedings article (membership required):
MECs also could carry out A2/AD missions. Prior to 1921, the Marines prepared “for the defense of advance bases and not for offensive landing operations.” Citing World War II experience, EF21 holds that the Marines must be capable of establishing and defending advanced bases while working with other services to “project power and control the sea.” This will allow the United States to “turn the A2/AD table” on an enemy by deploying weapons and sensors in a “network of numerous austere bases—by occupation or seizure—as a means of dispersing aircraft, missiles, and intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance assets” that deny an enemy the ability to operate in those waters and in that air space. Such advance expeditionary bases equipped with long-range strike, antiship, and antiair systems would function as “sea denial outposts.”
Such outposts—quickly established and abandoned as needed—could be used for forward arming and refueling points to support dispersed air operations ashore, making a transition between sea-based and land-based Marine air power truly seamless.
The author wants some offensive power with the ARG too, so the Marines can fight through opposition to reach the objective on the shore.
My graphics didn't make it into the published article. My notional MEBF had a surface action group (SAG) to provide firepower along with the ARG and MEU. SPS with the equipment for the balance of a Marine Expeditionary Brigade whose troops remained at their home station would allow for more rapid reinforcement of the MEU after it lands.
Although obviously in the early stage of the war when the struggle for control of the seas is in doubt, you can hardly sail the prepositioning ships with the ARG. I expanded on the SPS concept in this post.
As necessary as the Marine evolution is to support the Navy to gain control of the sea is, the Army will miss the Marines in land campaigns as the Marines lighten up and evolve to directly support the fleet. The Marines had been the most significant expeditionary force to accompany the Army overseas since the Korean War. No more.