Thursday, December 15, 2022

The End of Westphalia?

If America is experiencing a government, social, and economic shift that is fueling our divisions and unrest, will our growing budget deficits be resolved by a major shift that decreases the size--and in time perhaps the scope--of our federal government?


America's big-government model of the federal government is unsustainable as it sucks in more resources and is less able to efficiently or effectively use those resources. World War II followed by the Cold War institutionalized this model. The rising national debt may be resolved by a major change in how our government is organized and staffed.

I can see future Republican presidents outsourcing some executive functions because they can't trust the left-leaning federal bureaucracy to do their jobs for a Republican. Is this how the bloated and unaffordable federal bureaucracy is ended in the long run? Now, think tanks function as shadow farm teams for the party out of power. Will there also be a constellation of private companies that get government contracts for carrying out government functions at the federal and state levels?

Or maybe a Democratic president would be desperate enough to maintain social spending to resort to this. Democrats would find that system a more direct--and more efficient--means of funding supporters than the indirect model of the so-called non-partisan civil service bureaucracy that tends to back the people who fund their jobs more enthusiastically.

This new model would extend to foreign policy. George Friedman wrote about these changes:

Consider foreign policy, an area that is the central responsibility of the federal government. As we have seen, the three prior institutional cycles emerged from war. The fourth one is now starting to emerge from both a war and a massive geopolitical shift. The war is the one that began on September 11, 2001. But the critical thing to remember is that since 2001 the United States has been in a constant state of war, even if not on the scale of World War II or the Civil War. But it is a war that has lasted far longer than any other in American history. And the inability of the government to frame the war in such a way that it might be won, the institutions of the United States revealed their fundamental weaknesses. War requires a simplification, an understanding of a desired end, clarity on strategy, and allocation of resources appropriate to both. The government proved incapable of the clarity needed for a war because it could not simplify. The complexity of the government was translated into a complicated plan for the war, and the complexity trapped the warriors in a confusion that undermined their mission. [The geopolitical shift was the collapse of the USSR.] ...

Except for Desert Storm, the United States has failed to win a war since World War II. Successful empires use as little military force as possible, depending on the regional tensions between nations to maintain their interests.

I have problems with his statement on America's failure to win since World War II. But I'll let that go for now. 

The key point is the inability of the government to focus on winning wars by mobilizing state assets, and the question of whether the government structure is the problem. I've touched on that as I struggled to see how America can afford to sustain a long struggle against jihadi terrorism:

I have come to more clearly agree with the idea that we need to minimize our effort. I was long against the idea that we could go in massively to Iraq or Afghanistan and expect results before the burden of that large sacrifice wore away our resolve to win. A slow win you can actually achieve is better than futilely trying for a quick win that can't be sustained. And at home I rejected calls for a needless draft or massive tax increases as just a means to get Americans tired of the Long War in order to admit defeat.

In posts here, here, here, and here I've addressed a role that defends America's position in the world affordably without routinely applying massive force in response to threats. Indeed, pre-blog just after 9/11 I wrote about pacing ourselves for a long struggle (longer than I anticipated, I admit).

This is difficult to accept. The Civil War and World War II set the template of massive mobilization efforts to decisively defeat an enemy that threatens our security at home. World War II especially established that "ideal" military response. 

The Cold War forced America to operate in an era without the shield of friends that could contain a threat abroad until America could mobilize massively and intervene decisively, if necessary. The collapse of the USSR changed things massively again and we need to adapt.

My posts on the Global Troubles outlook are perhaps the most on point about coping with military threats over long periods without exhausting ourselves with big (and futile) efforts, with the earlier posts addressing the benefits of defending the international system we built and an early guess at the big picture of that system developing.

A need to more affordably achieve foreign policy objectives could force America to further reduce its military and rely on other states as well as non-state actors to be the pointy end of the foreign policy stick. The non-state actors could be contracted for the period of time needed to achieve the result without creating a new bureaucracy that endures beyond its mission. Which is a feature of our dying big government model.

I'd long wondered if the trans-national jihadi terrorists and the resulting war on terror era signaled an end to the Westphalian system's dominance:

When nation-states no longer have the monopoly on the use of world-altering power and when states cannot control the threats from disease and terrorism that gestate inside their borders, we must not be hobbled by being chained to the capitals of the world.

The Treaty of Wesphalia has taken another and perhaps a decisive hit by our action. Not that national governments are irrelevant. They are still easily the major players. But when small groups can--possibly with the aid of nations--threaten to kill hundreds of thousands of us, national borders can no longer restrain our military or diplomatic actions.

I don't know if the State Department changes I noted lasted. But even a moment in time change could foreshadow eventual lasting change and significance.

Will America's foreign policy implementation follow this model with a greater revival of non-state military and coercive power to supplement a scaled-back American government national security infrastructure?

After reading Thomson's book and really thinking about how recently we ended pirate kingdoms, privateering, armed companies, private mercenary units, and cross-border recruiting of troops and officers on a large scale, the idea of revived private warfare by the West despite our laws and international system seems far more likely to me than it did when I speculated on that possible future. (And I looked to recruiting globally, too.)

There are glimmers of the organization to sustain such a privatized military power and the demand for these services (and here's one that is free).

Will civil war in Russia accelerate that trend?

Does the United Nations last as the stronghold of state dominance in its current form? I was on that long ago (in the pre-Blogger form, so scroll down to "Rules of Engagement" (Posted August 19, 2003):

In essence, the global community's rules of engagement are a crock. We cannot count on the international community to deal with genocidal and dangerous regimes. Did we not try this route with one of the more egregious violators of the world's peace and prosperity when we begged the UN to let us deal with Saddam's defiance of the UN?

 We need a new international organization of willing members who will fight with us. It doesn't even need to be a formal organization that explicitly abandons the UN. The UN should not, however, have a political role that limits our ability to defend our people in the absence of international resolve to protect our people. The UN should be restricted to UNESCO and WHO and the like.

We need rules of engagement that let us shoot the SOBs when we recognize them—not when they open fire. We're talking nukes here one day, people. The UN is not nearly enough.

If states are demoted in practice, the basis of the UN is undermined. It can't possibly last in its current bureaucratic bloat form for long under those conditions.

If America is lucky enough, America may be able to go back to the relative safety of  broad oceans and overseas allies buying America time to mobilize and gather forces. Add in the ability to use hired temporary allies and we have a new era arising from the unaffordable wreckage of our current national and international systems.

NOTE: Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Wednesday, December 14, 2022

Acceptable Collateral Damage

I await the proliferation of authors who argues that Ukraine should be honored to be sacrificed to the Russians' tender mercies for some greater good.

 

So, the West has to let Russia defeat Ukraine so [checks notes] China doesn't win? 

There’s a shrewd Chinese allegory that captures the essence of China’s thinking on this conflict: "As two tigers are fighting ferociously in the valley, a sage monkey is sitting on top of the mountain, looking down and waiting to see how it will end." 

The two tigers are Russia and the United States, both considered by China to be its top adversaries. China is the wise monkey patiently waiting as Moscow and Washington are eroding their respective combat power, fighting a proxy war over control of Ukraine.

What nonsense. While Russian combat power is eroding rapidly and Russia is being exposed as a paper tiger, American power is only taking a brief dip because of arms and ammo shipments to Ukraine. But that is temporary. America seems committed to increasing production capacity.

And the weapons shipped to Ukraine are less useful for an aero-naval war as any early period of a war with China would be. Further, Western weapons in general are getting a boost that should give future sage monkeys second thoughts about choosing war.

Oh, at some level the analyst has a point. But the only way out of the dilemma is abandoning Ukraine? Maybe Russia should be the one to get her message. 

And this gem from that analyst: 

On Wednesday, the Pentagon finally admitted what was clear to serious intelligence analysts from the start: Ukraine has no military path to victory against Russia.

The Pentagon also said Ukraine had no military path to avoiding being overrun by the Russian juggernaut in mere days. And to be precise, the Pentagon said the odds for Ukraine's victory going forward weren't high "anytime soon". Big difference. 

Never heard of the analyst. Have no need to hear from the analyst again. 

Not that the monstrous notion of abandoning Ukraine to Russia's tender mercies for some other "greater good" is new. I assume there will be a growing chorus that saving the planet from climate change requires the sacrifice of Ukraine. How dare we destroy the planet to save Ukraine, eh?

NOTE: Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Tuesday, December 13, 2022

The German Coup and the Ghost of Zimmerman

What's up with the Germans? And what are the Russians up to?  Is there a Zimmerman Email?

Not hearing a lot of news on the foiled coup plot in Germany:

Three alpaca stared bleakly at us as we rounded what seemed like the umpteenth sharp bend along the rural roads of the east German region of east Thuringia.

Looming behind the animals, perched on a hill, we finally saw what we'd travelled all this way for: the stone turreted towers of the neo-Gothic hunting lodge, Schloss Waldmannsheil.

HQ, to a large extent, until this Wednesday, for an eclectic group of plotters, hoping to take over the German parliament and destroy the structures of modern Germany, replacing them with a monarchical system, with a Prince at its head, whose family used to rule this region for hundreds of years before World War One.

And all this to be done and dusted by Christmas.

Sound incredible, almost unbelievable?

I had to search for that story. My normal feeds are really quiet since the initial stories on the arrests.

The thousands of potential coup supporters called "Reichsbürger" don't sound all that coup-like. We have such in America, called "sovereign citizens." There is an African-American centered version whose name escapes me now. There may be Hispanic and Asian groups for all I know. 

And some of the statistics trotted out in support of the threat seem very misleading. Could apply to any country. And even if true, so what? Lots of people could believe lots of dangerous things, no?

Further, how many of these people are from the former East Germany, and the result of that trauma for so many who miss communist authoritarianism? 

So are the Germans nuts or coup plotters? Could be both, of course. I don't mean to sound like I'm dismissing them. But the the tone of the news that is out there is odd for such a major plot, no? 

So yes, it does sound incredible. Including the tidbit that the 71-year-old German prince at the center of this plot has a "far younger Russian girlfriend who tried to get backing for the planned coup from the Kremlin[.]"

Huh.

Yet it is only almost unbelievable. Almost as unbelievable as the German effort to get Mexico to go to war with America to distract America and keep it from sending troops to Europe in World War I. 

Yet that happened.

Throwing Germany into chaos would really cripple the NATO effort to supply Ukraine given Germany's geography and NATO bases there. To say NATO would be distracted by such an event is a gross understatement.

Is the relative silence on this event the result of great care on Germany's part because of potential links to a desperate Russia? We saw how amateurish Russian interference in our 2016 election was. I can totally see Russians in the intelligence apparatus thinking a coup in Germany would solve Russia's problem in Ukraine. Putin didn't have to know or approve, I'd guess.

I have no evidence. Just a nagging suspicion based on the desperate need of Russia to throttle NATO's support for Ukraine to avoid getting totally defeated in Putin's failing war of conquest.

What's happening?

UPDATE: Some news:

Any attempts to get to the bottom of the problem will need to address German society’s deeply conflicted attitude toward the military. Due largely to Germany’s fraught past, today’s soldiers are sometimes regarded with disrespect or outright suspicion. Politicians often appear reluctant to view the army as anything more than a “necessary evil.” Those who die in conflicts are described as “victims,” not “heroes.” Military celebrations meet with controversy or neglect. Many soldiers hesitate to wear their uniforms in public for fear of being verbally or physically attacked.

Germany’s reluctance to embrace its military is understandable, given its history. But holding the Bundeswehr at arm’s length risks detaching it from society and politics, potentially breeding an us-against-them mentality.

But the news is still sketchy on the actual recruitment of troops and police for the plot. It is more heavy on potential.

And if the issue is German troops being susceptible to extremist propaganda, that attitude from the public and government contributes.

If the German military isn't busy preparing to defend Germany from external threats, it's troops have too much time to contemplate how the people and politicians mistrust them for putting on a uniform to defend Germany. That breeds resentment and vulnerability to those who can demonstrate simple respect for their service.

So let me pull out the clue bat one more time:

Germany pioneered mobile warfare backed by close air support. Now, both parts of that combination are atrophied.

I keep reading that the Germans hate their militaristic past so much that they don't want to fight.

Let's try applying the clue bat to Germany's collective skull on this issue.
Conquering and setting up death camps under the shield of a powerful military? That's bad. By all means, don't do that.
Having a military capable of fighting death cult enemies or stopping the Russians from moving west? Well, that's a good thing. Try doing that. 

Spend money on the military to show it is valued, and get it busy training to defeat the Russians and kill jihadis. That will take care of a lot of the extremism problem. 

UPDATE: Is my speculation really out of bounds, as we watch unrest in Kosovo?

Now there is a war involving Russia and the United States. It is not going well for Russia thus far. When fighting a war, forcing the enemy to divert his attention is critical, particularly when there is – at best for Russia – a stalemate. They have looked for other ways to distract the Ukrainians, but it is the Americans that must be distracted.

I did warn about this back in the summer:

Last October I noted Serb tensions with Kosovo. In February I noted that Serbia was arming up; and in April China delivered anti-aircraft missiles to the Serbs. Are the Serbs planning to revive the Kosovo war? Is Russia pushing this to distract NATO? Tip to Instapundit.

Germany in chaos would be the ultimate distraction in Europe.

NOTE: Winter War of 2022 coverage continues here.

Monday, December 12, 2022

The Winter War of 2022 Ponders Its Second Winter

We're approaching a second winter of war after Russia invaded Ukraine in late winter 2022. Who has the advantage in a longer war?

My preferred name for Russia's invasion, the Winter War of 2022, implies that the war would not drag on this long. I explicitly explained that like the Soviets in 1939 after faltering in their invasion of Finland I expected the Russians to recover from initial mistakes to wage war more effectively. In 1940 after 3 months of war, the USSR finally overwhelmed much smaller Finland.

Russia did change their methods since the initial failures of February and March 2022. The Russians contracted their offensive frontage to the Donbas region--and then to the Donetsk section eventually--and unleashed heavy firepower on the defending Ukrainians--and then on Ukraine's cities.

But Russia's adjustments have not allowed Russia to overwhelm smaller Ukraine. Russia does not have the conventional military resources of Stalin's USSR. Ukraine in 2022 isn't as tiny compared to 1940 Finland. And NATO and other Western states have sent large amounts of military and financial aid to Ukraine.

Ukraine has reoccupied territory as Russia has withdrawn and Ukraine has captured territory by defeating the Russian defenders. But Russia still holds territory it has taken since invading in 2022 and in 2014-2015 in Crimea and the Donbas.

And the Russian army still stands despite being decimated. So far it has not collapsed under the strains of defeat and casualties.

The Russians attacked in the late winter during the first winter. Will Ukraine return the favor this winter?

Ukrainian officials have indicated that Ukrainian forces plan to continue offensive operations over the coming winter to capitalize on recent battlefield successes and prevent Russian forces from regaining the battlefield initiative. Spokesperson of the Ukrainian Armed Forces Eastern Group Serhii Cherevatyi stated on December 4 that frozen ground enables heavy wheeled and tracked vehicles to advance and that Ukrainian forces are preparing such vehicles for winter operations.

But where will Ukraine attack? This is what I've been thinking:

The path to a Ukrainian victory — or at least the most obvious path — will probably cut south, through the muddy and flat fields of the Zaporizhzhia region. ...

But for all the logical speculation, the roads and military positions near the front line show little evidence of a buildup of troops, and there are no indications that the Ukrainians are trying to mount an offensive in Zaporizhzhia region anytime soon, Muzyka and other analysts said.

Originally I thought this offensive would be too risky with two open flanks as it drove south toward the Sea of Azov. I thought an offensive in Kherson that bounced the river after defeating the Russian ground forces on the west bank would be safer for the Ukrainians with flanks covered by the Black Sea and the wide Dnieper River. Logistics across the river would be tough. But I thought that price was worth the flank protection.

But now, and even before Ukraine compelled the Russians to withdraw across the river on the Kherson front, the level of Russian casualties in nearly ten months of war make the flank problem of a Zaporizhzhia offensive aimed south at Melitopol less of a constraint. 

And with Russian lines of supply north of the Sea of Azov cut, Ukrainian forces in that corridor would have interior lines, allowing Ukraine to rapidly focus on the east or west for subsequent drives. Ukrainian forces in the Donetsk or the Kherson front could support those follow-up drives east or west.

The winter seems like it will increase Ukraine's logistics advantage that Ukrainian and Russian decisions have already tilted toward Ukraine:

This has provided Ukrainian troops with a major advantage. Unlike Russian troops in Ukraine, Ukrainian soldiers suffer less from malnutrition, cold weather, and untreated wounds....

Ukrainian troops survive longer in combat and suffer fewer casualties, which means the average Ukrainian combat soldier is more experienced, trained, led and supported than their Russian counterparts. Ukrainian forces are prepared for a winter campaign and Russian forces are not.

I'll note that lack of indications near the front or otherwise is not proof such preparations aren't taking place. How obvious were the preparations prior to the Kharkov offensive? Further, the ground hasn't frozen yet, meaning moving forces closer to the front would simply telegraph the intention and provide targets for Russian artillery long before the Ukrainians can attack.

And even if the Ukrainians build on continuing operations to hammer the Russians on the Luhansk front first in order to avoid the most obvious path, Melitopol still looms large as the decisive front, in my mind.

And if such an offensive ends the war before reaching the first anniversary of the war, I guess my war name quandary is ended. It would be good for Ukraine, Europe, and the world if the war ends before this coming winter ends.

UPDATE: Huh:

Ukrainian forces blasted the Russian-occupied city of Melitopol with more than a dozen explosions lighting up the sky amid conflicting reports of casualties among Russian forces in the area.

UPDATE: "Ukrainian Defense Minister Oleksii Reznikov stated that Ukraine intends to continue counteroffensives in winter 2022–2023 after the hard freeze enables maneuver warfare, supporting an ISW assessment."

UPDATE (Tuesday): Fighting in the east is locally heavy despite the nearly static front. Russia's battering against Ukraine's defenders is costing Russia dearly with no clear significant objective at the end of their road. Unless keeping the Ukrainians engaged there is the point.

UPDATE: Russia can't simply bombard Ukraine's civilians into submission:

Pentagon officials are in the final stages of preparing a plan to send a Patriot air defense missile system to Ukraine to counter Russian aerial assaults, U.S. officials told CBS News.

UPDATE (Friday): We have a massive 24/7 news apparatus and the satellite photo information is news to me:

Commercial satellite photos do show Ukrainian forces assembling for what appears to be another offensive to seize all of Kherson province and cut off Crimea from vital supply lines from Russia. That could coincide with the Russian offensive out of Belarus, which the Ukrainians appear to be ready for.

Apparently the media is too busy looking up dirt on Elon Musk. 

UPDATE: Massive Russian missile attack on Ukraine's civilians today.

UPDATE (Sunday): My view is that while Russia's military was over-rated, it could have done better if it had been used properly. This seems to bolster my view:

ISW has long assessed that faulty Russian planning assumptions, campaign design decisions, and Russian violations of Russia’s own military doctrine undermined Russian operations. The NYT acquired and published logbooks, timetables, orders, and other documents of elements of the 76th Airborne Division and 1st Guards Tank Army related to the early days of the war on December 16.[11] The documents demonstrate that Russian military planners expected Russian units to be able to capture significant Ukrainian territory with little to no Ukrainian military opposition.

Do read it all.

The Russians lied so much they fooled themselves. The Chinese have a similar problem.

NOTE: ISW updates continue here.

Sunday, December 11, 2022

Weekend Data Dump

If we can't tell by looking at a person what that person's gender is, and if a person can change their gender at will by simply asserting it, how can anybody be punished for "misgendering" that person when even that person can't really be sure?

Bad racial science. Besides, nowadays you can make up your own unique gender just by making up pronouns. Changing your race is easy by comparison, no?

More on the GLSDB surface-to-surface America-Sweden missile that marries a 227mm rocket to a Small Diameter Bomb. This is the 98-mile range weapon I mentioned intended for Ukraine. It can hit moving targets on land or at sea in any weather.

Russia's defense and security budgets have climbed enormously. But Russia's defense industry can't maintain pre-war levels. Russia's GDP advantage over smaller Ukraine backed by Western production isn't the advantage you'd expect, in practice. 

LOL: "Russian troops are often using Cold War era maps [of Ukraine] that contain deliberate errors to confuse enemy troops who capture these maps."

My only question is whether this is collateral damage or deliberate: "The COVID-19 vaccine mandate is contributing to the military’s recruitment troubles, the top general in the Marine Corps said on Saturday." The general said the problem is vaccine "misinformation" rather than the policy. The military has the authority to require vaccines. Which would be useful for a really dangerous virus. But this isn't it, now.

Explosions at two Russian air bases deep inside Russia. Ukraine suggests it can do that. One or both could be accidents, of course. But Ukraine could have done one or both. No word of damage to aircraft, so I assume accidents at this point. Oh (tip to PJ Media), did drones damage two Russian Tu-95s? That's according to Ukrainian media, of course.

Global warming is "a quasi-religious movement predicated on an absurd ‘scientific’ narrative." Indeed. Now go and emit no more. There are real scientists doing real work. But the movement is led by activist true believers.

And now for something completely different:


Iran's weapons line of supply to the Houthis in Yemen: "Sailors from the sea mobile base USS Lewis B. Puller intercepted the stateless vessel in the Gulf of Oman on Thursday along a maritime route from Iran to Yemen, the Naval Forces Central Command said in a statement Saturday."

#WhyAmericaCan'tHaveNiceThings

Moron Supremacy in action. Her students will be crippled for life. But she'll feel morally superior. What would a racist do differently? Tip to Treacher.

Publicizing our SSBN in the Indian Ocean signals that enemies have to defend the entire globe to counter America's sea-based nuclear deterrent. And any enemy missile defenses have to be 360 degrees.

How fast? "Russia is burning through its munitions stockpiles at an 'extraordinary' rate as its invasion of Ukraine grinds on into its tenth month, the nation’s top intelligence official said Saturday." Will China fill the gap? Can China?

The Netherlands is supporting Ukraine: "the Dutch military has committed to donating Panzerhaubitze 2000 155 mm self-propelled howitzers, YPR-765 infantry vehicles, Panzerfaust 3 recoilless anti-tank weapons and Stinger anti-aircraft weapons."

The U.S. seems like it will have a policy to combat China's global over-fishing in other countries' EEZs. Some countries will have to overcome their submission to Chinese fishing paid for with China's bribes.

The power vacuum in Central Asia. I've noted that effect of Russia's invasion of Ukraine. China telegraphed their path a while ago. Turkey, Saudi Arabia, and Iran are players, too. But their capacity is small relative to China's. And they seem less interested in promoting stability, apparently.

Most people think that Trump running for the 2024 nomination would divide the Republican Party and benefit Democrats by reviving Trump as the Bad Orange Man leader of Republicans. But what if Republican primary voters reject Trump? Won't that settle the question and kill the Democrat-media fear narrative?

Is the logistics link repaired or is this just a publicity stunt? "Russian President Vladimir Putin tried to boost Russian morale Monday by driving a vehicle across a bridge to Crimea that a truck bomb had damaged in October."

"Better informed" is not necessarily "informed enough": "The U.S. director of national intelligence said on Saturday that Russian President Vladimir Putin has become 'better informed' about the challenges the military is facing." 

America modified HIMARS sent to Ukraine so they can't fire ammunition with ranges of more than 48 miles. Interesting. Is this a real limitation? Could Ukraine hack whatever physical or software changes made while shielding America from Russian accusations of giving Ukraine such capabilities? 

An invisibility cloak: "The InvisDefense coat can be seen by human eyes but is covered in a pattern that blinds cameras in the day and sends out unusual heat signals at night, according to the team." This is very familiar from an old sci fi book, The Light of Other Days, that explored reactions to loss of privacy in day-to-day life. Tip to Instapundit.

Stolen valor. As a rule they despise the military yet wear the cloak of battlefield service for their desk-bound jobs. Remember, troops can't click to block incoming actual fire.

What would have been prudent 6 month ago is WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU WAITING FOR? now: "As donations to Ukraine strain allied munitions stockpiles, the U.S. Army is seeking a “dramatic” ramp up in monthly production of 155mm artillery shells over the next three years, its chief weapons buyer said Saturday." Other ammunition supplies are targeted, too. Tip to Instapundit.

The lockstep left wing media dismissal of Musk's Twitter files (PR for the world's richest person) reminds me of the odd American media pivot to dismissing the nuclear threat when a CIA NIE on Iran's nuclear program was released. I read it and complimented one reporter who filed before the memo went out. And don't forget the Iran nuclear deal spin machine. Our media is largely a partisan joke. To Hell with them.

Pre-Musk Twitter spent its time suppressing Republicans while ignoring child porn purveyors. Ah, progressives.

Even hating murderous communists is racist. According to the murderous communists. The CCP knows their target. Tip to Instapundit.

Speaking of Democrats propping up the Chinese Communist Party with cash. And lied about it. To be fair, the administration might just have been ignorant. Tip to Instapundit.

Somaliland works. Most of Somalia does not. Successes always seem fleeting. Just keep mowing the grass until the parts that work expand into the parts that don't.

Taiwan's loitering anti-radar drone.

The Air Force limited what might be revealed when the B-21 was unveiled when it "was illuminated with blue light and some artificial fog. And this time, the B-21 didn’t come all the way out of the hangar."

Replacing the Black Hawk: "Textron’s Bell has won the U.S. Army’s competition to build the Future Long-Range Assault Aircraft, the service’s largest helicopter procurement decision in 40 years."

The Army's new landmine close terrain shaping obstacle. It seems more like a really short-range anti-tank rocket.

Russia deployed an anti-ship (or land attack) missile system in the Kurile islands off of the Kamchatka Peninsula. This helps guard Russian installations and the SSBN basion in the Sea of Okhotsk. The story says it is "near Japan." True enough, but I sometimes think Russia is hiding anti-China deployments with a Japan excuse. And demoting the Northern Fleet in favor of the Pacific Fleet makes me think Russia is carrying out a stealth pivot to face China.

The Army ramps up Pacific logistics: "The Army is moving equipment across the Pacific in support of its Operation Pathways exercise to be held in Australia in 2023 as it continues to define its changing role in the region." Logistics have to be ramped up a lot more if the Army is to carry out its primary large-scale combat operations mission in Asia generally and on Taiwan in particular (both Military Review articles).

A Congressional Research Report on China's navy modernization and America's response.

China's low-level balloon radar reflectors.

A Ukrainian drone attack just across the border near Kursk, Russia. Does this indicate the earlier explosions were Ukrainian drones? Or is this shallow attack designed to give the impression of Ukrainian long-range drone attacks. It seems the earlier explosions were drones. But are we sure?

If a legitimate free press existed, indeed. Tip to Instapundit.

Huh. On Facebook Meta, the ability to express hate freely has a price tag.

Iranian protests surged again.

Via Instapundit, is Germany's failure to stand up for European security in the face of Russian aggression the fault of Germany's leader, Olaf Scholz? Perhaps. The problem may be broader. But I hope it is the fault of one leader. That is easier to fix. To be fair, the 2% NATO defense spending target has until 2024 to be met. After promising immediate spending after Russia's invasion, Germany says it will meet it in 2025. Which is many years from their pre-war plan.

Warnock defeated Walker in the Georgia runoff election, giving Democrats 51 Senate seats. That means Democrats can completely control the committees. Unless Manchin switches parties ...

Russia convinced Ukrainians that the West was the source of their salvation. Russia continues to be NATO's best recruiter.

It's kind of funny that when confronted with the evidence that the FBI helped suppress the Hunter Biden laptop news before the 2020 election, Democrats ask, "Who was president, then?" as if the FBI was actually working for Trump rather than Biden.

Iranian Revolutionary Guard naval forces are harassing U.S. Navy ships in the Strait of Hormuz again. I think putting capital ships in the Persian Gulf is nuts.

All wars end.

Mobilized Russian men are arriving at the front with more training now.

The U.S. will increase rotational forces going to Australia, including bombers; and improved logistics and sustainment cooperation.

Strykers with friggin' lasers on them.

While the B-21 broadly looks like the B-2, there are significant differences.

Is Russia running low on artillery ammunition? We'll see if rate of fire goes down, with only priority targets hit. That's the standard response rather than firing as fast as you can until you are out.

The very length of this joint U.S.-Australian statement on military and diplomatic cooperation seems significant to me. Unless the inclusion of diplomats automatically ups the word count. LATER: If length is significant, last year's was longer. What does that mean? I'm skeptical of the author's take. But we'll see.

The Japanese will strengthen their ground forces on Okinawa. Which seems wise as American Marines move a regiment from Okinawa to Guam. Note that Japanese divisions are really small. Japanese pacifists have a particularly stupid take on the decision.

Anti-mullah labor strikes are taking place around Iran even as protests have abated.

Iran's proto-insurrection continues.

Irish need not apply. In Ireland. Tip to Instapundit.

Walmart says it may have to raise prices or close stores because government is not combating shoplifting at its stores (via Instapundit). Five years after the store closures, lefty researchers will note "shopping deserts" and blame racism, or whatever the usual suspect is then.

"The Babylon Bee is now redundant. You can’t parody this stuff. All you can do is quote it." Journalists have a greatly over-inflated view of their worth. Learn to code, you hacks.

Well that got my pucker factor redlining: "Authorities in Germany arrested 25 people on Wednesday who are suspected of planning to violently overthrow the government in a far-right extremist plot." The group hoped for Russian backing. I doubt this was a real threat. But even cosplay morons can kill people and cause damage before they fail.

We've seen news that Ukraine already needs to have its Western-supplied cannons re-barreled. Russia has fired massive numbers of artillery rounds. Has Russia had the same problem? Or has Russia just let its barrels deteriorate while using the guns, accepting crappy accuracy?

No offense to the British royal family, in general. But I'm starting to think we should take another look at that whole "regicide" thing. Via Instapundit.

Ban all the Chinese electronic things. I'm offended that we actually paid to have their SIGENT/cyberwar network installed here.

The Russian Gold rush.

Al Qaeda still uses Afghanistan as a sanctuary, despite what the Taliban claims.


I'd be more comfortable with Democratic charges that Republicans are exaggerating Democratic suppression of Republican views if Democrats didn't keep getting caught suppressing Republican views.

A "get out of jail free card" for illegal immigrants who commit crimes. This is an outrage. And it shouldn't be allowed. But more and more I think that if far-left municipalities want to get their own people killed and cripple their economies, who am I to object? Via Instapundit.

Bernie Sanders runs interference for Iran's war in Yemen.

And if Ukraine's dispersed ground warfare against Russian invaders as across water and not land for movement and resupply, I'd totally buy this convenient justfication. 

The A-10 will get retired more quickly. But the Air Force is lying. The A-10 no longer needs to fly low and slow to provide close air support. The Air Force has a long history of wanting to kill the plane. They have some points. But it's about more than the plane. It's about trusting the Air Force.

China may have more nuclear warheads on ICBMs than America does. It was relatively straightforward when it was mostly a US-Russia balance. With small assists to America from Britain and France that didn't really affect the big picture. But with China thrown in, we all need extra nukes to deal with two potential nuclear-armed enemies. Russia and China can use shorter-range missiles to deal with each other. America got rid of its shorter-range sea-based nukes. So now we rely on the long-range weapons.

Okay: "Domestic extremism is rare in the military, ‘but it is an issue’[.]" Deal with it. Absolutely. But don't rip apart the military rooting out a rare problem.


Your terms are acceptable: New York Times staffers went on 24-hour strike and urged us not to read NYT in solidarity. I say stay out as long as possible to teach the fascists a lesson.

Democrats seem to be setting the stage for resisting a House inquiry into Biden's business practices by claiming Republicans aren't interested in "governing." As if the Republican House can pass anything the Democratic Senate will pass or that Biden would sign. How stupid do they think people are? Or maybe the question is how hard do they think the media will regurgitate that nonsense?

America got a women's professional basketball player back from Russia. But not a former Marine, Paul Whelan who was essentially kidnapped by Russia, who still sits in a Russian cell. And we gave up a prolific Russian terrorist, arms dealer, and smuggler. Which might be useful for Russia under sanctions. More Ukrainians will die because of this trade. Our diplomats are morons who no doubt made it clear they were desperate to get someone out.

"Disinformation Down 92% As NYT Writers Go On Strike[.]" I don't mind them going away. I mind them not staying away. Via Instapundit.

Deep Twitter. Via Instapundit.

I caught a cold. If two negative Covid tests are to be believed. I haven't had a cold since the pandemic. I think this is a sign the pandemic is over. And note, this cold is worse than the Covid I had in almost every way. The one way is why I suspected it was not Covid.

I always assumed No Labels was about peeling off progressive stickers to trick independents into moving away from Republicans. Also: "Two former staffers said they witnessed one of the organization’s few Black employees being singled out to discuss race issues at a staff meeting." Wait. What? Don't progressives tell us only minority voices can discuss minority issues? Also, a #MeToo issue. Tip to Instapundit.

Not getting hopes up. Bernie Sanders is "Independent".

Well that's quite the pro-Biden spin on the Griner-Merchant of Death trade. Let's correct that: "Yes, it is a win for Putin, but one that comes at the cost of exposing his weakness and his need to keep the military elite he relies upon content."

Let's just marvel that Chinese protesters had more impact on China reversing harsh Covid policies than Canadian protesters had. Kudos for the title.

The Kraken Regiment and Cyborgs.

Will Harry and Meghan please go away. If Netflix raises their price after paying these twits so much money I'll cancel the service.

The New Extraterritoriality. Hey, could private businesses do this to protect their stores?

The Rising Sun reaches the Philippines. China will regret what it awakened. A peace constitution is not a suicide pact.

The pact was good. But implementation needs high-level follow through to work: "Australia’s defense minister said that his country’s nuclear-powered submarine pact with the U.K. and the U.S. still faces regulatory hurdles that hinder defense industrial cooperation."

The United States is rotating an infantry company reinforced with HIMARS into Estonia to enhance reassurance. Or HIMARS with infantry local security, as I prefer to think of such groupings. 

"Twitter worked closely with like-minded government bureaucrats to squelch legitimate news, information, and discussion. They did so to protect favored candidates (Democrats) and political positions (progressive)." Note that so far we're seeing how the bureaucracy operated on its own--so much for democracy--within the Trump administration. What will we find out when we move into the Biden administration that supports such actions? Assuming "former" FBI guy James Baker didn't successfully destroy evidence before he was fired from Twitter. Democracy Dies in Wokeness.

Indeed: "The Navy needs to work out how to repair and rearm warships faster to get them back into a fight, the service’s secretary said Thursday." I'm grateful the Navy recognizes the reload and repair problems.

Oh, I'm afraid of a Russian collapse. Loose nukes. A massive internal war. And China filling vacuums. But I think that fear is a reason to think about how Ukraine defeats Russia--not letting Russia win this war.

If I was  in charge of Russia, I'd prioritize rebuilding Far East military forces. Russia has had two conscript classes and a mobilization/stealth draft since invading and denuding the Far East frontiers.

China's official statistics don't seem reliable. Via Instapundit.

No. They're just mentally ill, pampered barbarians.

Government censorship with an extra step: "US law enforcement and intelligence agencies knew the New York Post was about to publish that story. Knowing that, they told social media giants, including Twitter, that the Russians were about to dump some disinformation. When the Post story appeared immediately after that FBI warning, Twitter connected the two. The link was even clearer when 51 former high-ranking intelligence agents publicly stated that the Hunter Biden story had 'all the earmarks of a classic Russian disinformation operation.'" Or, if you prefer, fascism.

Russia still aspires to operational sortakinda stealth Su-27s.

Oh? "Russian President Vladimir Putin said Friday that Moscow could adopt what he described as a U.S. concept of using preemptive military strikes, noting it has the weapons to do the job,[.]" Give it a rest, Ivan.

From the "No Shit, Sherlockovich" files.

LOL:


And a Heh:


One problem with trying to draw lessons about the future of war from the Winter War of 2022 is that it is not a great power war. Some lessons are possible about battle. But ultimately, Russia knows it solely has the ability to escalate the war. Even though Russia is right across the border, Ukraine is deterred from significant strikes into Russia. No matter what Russia does to Ukraine. Two great powers fighting have a different dynamic entirely. 

Go Army! Beat Navy!  It's nice to have a rivalry where I respect the other team.

Putin claims that Russia is open to negotiating an end to the war, but those Ukrainians just won't. Fortunately, Russian leaders have a "tell" for when they are lying. They speak.

Where are Russia's wonder weapons? LOL!

China's espionage against American military technology was amazingly successful for a long time, no? I sure as Hell hope we succeeded in letting the Chinese scoop up a lot of crap that they wasted their time on exploiting. 

Japan, Britain, and Italy will cooperate on building an advanced fighter plane.

Making good jihadis: "American forces on Sunday killed two Islamic State militants in eastern Syria in a helicopter raid, U.S. Central Command said in a statement."

We are losing the war against Iran in Iraq--Phase IX of the Iraq War. FFS, the Iraqi people mostly don't want Iran's influence.

Seriously, how many ballistic missiles does Iran have stockpiled? "Russia is trying to obtain 'hundreds of ballistic missiles' from Iran [per British intelligence.]"

Are we finally reaching peak climate hysteria? Dunno. But I don't underestimate the panic-prone nuts. Who can just ef off, of course. Via Instapundit.

Orion works. It sure cost enough. But good. I guess it's ready to carry people, now. We're way behind where we should be in working and living in space. Via Instapundit.

And yes, yesterday's And Now For Something Completely Different post was my last. But I did put a new one I authored earlier in this post. So you're not completely safe.

Saturday, December 10, 2022

And Now For Something Completely Different

Here on my blog. Where the image breaks down. Will you visit me, please. If I publish my meme in blogs?


This is a rerun.







 







 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 
This is a rerun.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

NOTE: I ended this category of posts. As I mentioned in a Weekend Data Dump, it was getting to be more of a chore than fun to come up with a bunch, on top of others I put in regular posts and in the Weekend Data Dump. Going forward I'm just meming for post illustrations with extras in Weekend Data Dump when I feel like it.