Saturday, February 23, 2013

Steady, Lads

Well, if this isn't wrist-slitting depressing, I don't know what is.

Work the problems. What's the alternative?

And really, can you say our problems are worse than in the 1970s when MAD ruled our lives, the Soviet Union was apparently on a roll, our economy was faltering in the face of rising foreign competition, and all the smart guys and gals were talking about the "convergence" of our system with the Soviet system and only hoped to manage our decline gracefully? And when people spoke of the American century ending in 1975 (well short of 100 years), with the Soviet century just beginning?

Even tough problems can be solved. And all things considered, perhaps our problems aren't even in the "tough" league.

Friday, February 22, 2013

Working on Tin Foil Hat Block 50

You thought I was joking? The Russians have serious issues to work through:

A survey published today by the fairly staid Moscow daily Noviye Izvestia found that barely half its readers believe the official report that the blast was caused by a meteor.

According to the newspaper, the other half prefer to believe in an assortment of bizarre explanations, including that the blast was a secret US weapon test, an off-course ballistic missile, a message from God, a crashing alien spaceship, or even an extraterrestrial trojan horse carrying a deadly space virus to wipe out the Earth.

Sure, we have plenty of nuts with nutso theories here. But nothing like this.

Although our nuts don't have the excuse of having lived under Communism and Putinism, which waged war on facts and twisted the people's perception.

Shrewder Than We Imagine?

So Iran is messing with us to disguise their nuclear progress? These authors are on to something, but they under-estimate the problem.

Iran keeps raiding their stockpile of 20% enriched Uranium to delay the estimated time it will be before Iran has enough to further enrich for a bomb. Iran is doing this to buy time to increase their ability to break out of the talks and denial farce and race to nuclear capabilities:

Together, the new IR-1 and IR-2m centrifuges would more than double the current output of the Natanz facility. This would translate into a nearly 50 percent reduction – from 99 days to 52 – in the time it would take Iran to produce 20 kilograms of HEU, the minimum for a nuclear weapon.

Thus, Iran might be delaying the day when it is ready to make the dash to a nuclear weapon, but is ensuring that the dash will be as short as possible. In effect, Iran is shrewdly sidestepping Israel’s red line while raising the stakes for the next round of international negotiations.

I think the author has the right idea, but if I was an Iranian nutball, I'd worry that 52 days was way too long to race to the security that they believe atomic weapons will provide them. Sure, there could be a couple weeks of not being sure if they passed the threshold and a couple more weeks to decide to strike. But that would still leave more than three weeks to attack Iran and keep Iran from crossing that red line.

If I was chief nutball of Iran, I'd want some nukes before I start racing to produce as much HEU as I can:

The problem from Iran's point of view is that they can't know if crossing one of these lines could trigger an American or Israeli preemptive strike out of fear that further delay in attacking would be too late to prevent Iran from getting nuclear weapons. And if I was an Iranian nutball, I wouldn't assume the Americans and Israelis couldn't knock out my infrastructure.

Were I an Iranian nutball, under those circumstances, I'd want at least a few atomic warhead on hand before I announce capabilities to produce atomic weapons-grade material. Which would mean I'd have had to have bought some from either North Korea or Pakistan--or possibly even from some broke custodian of Russia's arsenal.

If Iran can announce both the ability to make nuclear bomb material and the possession of actual nuclear weapons--perhaps by detonating one in a test on their own territory--Tehran would quite possibly deter an attack on Iran's nuclear infrastructure.

We're not dealing with idiots. If the Iranian mullahs believe there are red lines that trigger Israeli or American action, why wouldn't they take counter-actions rather than just blindly cross those lines and provide a pretext for military action against them?

The Iranians are nuts. But they aren't stupid. If I was the chief Iranian nutball, I'd buy nukes from impoverished North Korea--which seems to have perfected their design--or at least buy the design blueprints from North Korea while bringing in the HEU for the warhead from sources that don't have the same level of attention as those centrifuges receive, and which we seem to be defining as the red line for action.

Sequestration Panic

Sequestration panic is starting to tick me off. Let the sequestration arrows fly.

We should be insulted by the president's dire predictions of reducing the rate of growth of our government by a very small amount this year under sequestration. The president and his supporters always trot out huge numbers to describe "cuts" that reflect a decade of reducing spending below planned increases. This is ridiculous:

If the sequester goes into effect, the federal budget for this year will still be larger than last year’s ($3.553 trillion in 2013 vs. $3.538 trillion in 2012). With the sequester in effect, federal non-defense spending will still be 10 percent higher than it was in 2008. But Washington, led by Obama but with GOP help, is telling the American people that unless government gets an even bigger raise (with money borrowed from China, by the way), civilization will unravel, 911 calls will go unanswered, and Bane shall irrevocably seize control of Gotham.

The federal government has grown inexorably for decades. Our president casts himself as a Solomonic manager, and yet he is saying that absent a few extra pennies on every dollar, there’s no way he can maintain government’s core functions? A manager in any other field of human endeavor would be fired on the spot for making such an argument. But in Washington, this passes for leadership.

If the administration can't handle this trifling reduction in the growth of spending without letting people die, then their whole strutting boast about their competence to govern is a farce.

The Defense Department seems to be participating in this blackmail, too:

There's no doubt President Obama is using the so-called Washington Monument maneuver in the fight with Republicans over sequestration budget cuts. It's a time-honored tactic of bureaucratic warfare: When faced with cuts, pick the best-known and most revered symbol of government and threaten to shut it down. Close the Washington Monument and say, "See? This is what happens when you cut the budget." Meanwhile, all sorts of other eminently cuttable government expenditures go untouched.

So now Obama is warning of drastic cuts in food safety, air traffic control, police and fire protection -- in all sorts of services that will allegedly be slashed if the rate of growth of some parts of the federal budget is slowed.

But perhaps the biggest example of the Washington Monument maneuver is coming from the Defense Department, where it goes by another name. Over many decades of defense budget battles, the Pentagon has often used a tactic known as a "gold watch." It means to answer a budget cut proposal by selecting for elimination a program so important and valued -- a gold watch -- that Pentagon chiefs know political leaders will restore funding rather than go through with the cut.

I expect better from the Department of Defense when we are at war.

The idea that we won't send an aircraft carrier battle group to CENTCOM's area to watch Iran because of these relatively small cuts is an insult. Yes, I know that part of the problem is that the department was basically told not to plan ahead for sequestration. And I know that the department probably has little authority to pick which areas of the large budget qualify for sequestration. And the White House is their boss. So they play ball the way the administration is fighting these puny cuts. But I don't have to like it.

Are we forgetting that the massive bureaucracy of our defense infrastructure is for the purpose of sending an aircraft carrier out to be the pointy end of our spear? The carrier is not a life-support system for 50,000 desks and those who sit behind them. If the Pentagon can't cut spending in ways that keep a carrier forward, I want to know who is stopping them? If the Pentagon is refusing to make those choices even though it has the authority, I want courts martial convened. We are at war.

If civilians tell the Pentagon that budget cuts will blot out the sun, the Pentagon should reply, "then we will fight in the shade."



It really pisses me off. Cut the budget a little, and the government reduces funding for first responders to make us feel the pain when the government knows damned well that similar cuts that furloughed (for a few days a month of unpaid days off) a larger number of employees with large oak desks, real leather chairs, and job titles that require four lines on their business cards yet are still unclear about what they do, nobody would notice or care if they weren't doing their job.

I've written that I'm conflicted about defense reductions under sequestration. If enacted with some planning to make choices about priorities, it shouldn't be a big hit in the long run. But the Department of Defense seems to be structuring those cuts to maximize damage to the military in order to frighten us into reversing those cuts. If that isn't dereliction of duty, I don't know what is.

This is an evolving process of trying to grasp what is going on and what real effects are. So I remain conflicted. But now I'm just pissed off.

At this point, just because of the obvious political nature of the cuts that the Department of Defense is proposing, I say let the defense sequester go through. We'll see if duty finally calls and the cuts are done intelligently after the Pentagon knows it will lose that budget fight.

Besides, the way I see it, this administration is going to cut defense spending anyway. So even reversing these proposed cuts at the price of losing the only chance of reducing domestic spending increases even a little will be futile. Whatever spending is retained this spring will be lost by the fall.

UPDATE: George Will makes a more high-browed reference than mine to urge our "leaders" to "Cry 'Havoc!' and let slip the hamsters of sequestration":

At his unintentionally hilarious hysteria session Tuesday, Obama said: The sequester’s “meat-cleaver approach” of “severe,” “arbitrary” and “brutal” cuts will “eviscerate” education, energy and medical research spending. “And already, the threat of these cuts has forced the Navy to delay an aircraft carrier that was supposed to deploy to the Persian Gulf.”

“Forced”? The Navy did indeed cite the sequester when delaying deployment of the USS Truman. In the high-stakes pressure campaign against Iran’s nuclear weapons program, U.S. policy has been to have two carriers in nearby waters. Yet the Navy is saying it cannot find cuts to programs or deployments less essential than the Truman deployment. The Navy’s participation in the political campaign to pressure Congress into unraveling the sequester is crude, obvious and shameful, and it should earn the Navy’s budget especially skeptical scrutiny by Congress.

With a bonus slam on global warming hysteria. Do read it all.

Be the Strong Horse

NATO may agree that something must be done to persuade Afghans that NATO maintains resolve to win despite the pending departure of NATO forces.

Given my concerns, this is a positive development:

U.S. and NATO officials are considering a plan to maintain the size of Afghanistan's national security forces at 352,000 for another five years.

U.S. Defense Secretary Leon Panetta joined his NATO counterparts for the Thursday meeting in Brussels where they discussed the move, which is meant to boost confidence among Afghans who are worried that their country may descend into chaos after most foreign troops depart at the end of next year.

I guess it depends on whether we want to win in Afghanistan or want to leave Afghanistan. Remember, war isn't receding--just our military power is receding.

The Nuance. She is Overrated

Wow, I thought we were supposed to be bad at post-major combat operations planning. What are the French doing in Mali?

Paris has said it plans to start withdrawing some of its 4,000 troops from Mali next month but the rebel fightback comes as Mali's army remains weak and divided and African forces due to take over the French role are not yet in place.

Islamists abandoned the main towns they held but French and Malian forces have said there are pockets of Islamist resistance across the north, which is about the size of France.

The French advance was suitably impressive and fast. And they appear to have killed a good number of jihadis with their air power as their blitzkrieg forced the jihadis to move.

But the French are going to turn over responsibility for stabilization to troops that will alienate the people they need to cooperate with (the Tuaregs) in order to hunt down and kill the remaining jihadis?

I'm starting to think European nuance with a French accent is overrated.

UPDATE: Strategypage has more about the situation.

UPDATE: The jihadis paid the price for massing:

Chadian troops killed 65 al Qaeda-linked fighters in the clashes that began before midday in the Adrar des Ifoghas mountains near Mali's northern border with Algeria.

Chad lost 13 of their own trooops.

Eventually, persistent surveillance, aerial firepower, and effective ground troops could force the jihadis to spread out to avoid getting hammered like this. That will help isolated government and ECOWAS and foriegn African outposts survive by making it less likely that the jihadis can mass enough troops to overrun those outposts.

If the French leave too soon, the jihadis won't be atomized. Then the foreign African forces will bear the brunt and will tire of the casualties and go home, leaving the Mali troops more eager for revenge against the Tuaregs than in fighting jihadis in the lead. If that happens, the Tuaregs will again align with the jihadis and eject the demonstrably crappy Mali army from the north, and we'll be right back where we started last spring--but worse since the Tuaregs may not be tempted to turn on the jihadis again.

France needs to rethink that whole declare victory and go home nonsense. At the very least, Western special forces, drones, and firepower are needed to keep the jihadis at bay while the Mali army is made ready for the fight. Foreign African forces will only take so many casualties before they say, "screw you guys, I'm going home."

And good God, cut a deal with the Tuaregs, or the French effort will have been wasted.

Failing to Appreciate the American Dream

Huh. I never heard of this story of the self-exile of Chheng Guan (David) Lim, who spent four years in hiding in Ann Arbor after going on academic probation in the engineering program he discovered he did not like at the University of Michigan.

Do read it all. You can skip the rest of this post since it will be self-referencing reflection based on my own life in Ann Arbor and familiarity with academic probation. The story is fascinating enough without my additions!

I've mentioned before that I started out higher education as a computer science major. I had taken every math course in high school and loved my programming classes. Yet after two semesters of being a math major, I found myself on academic probation with a GPA of 1.993 (if I remember the thousandth place correctly). On such thin margins, life paths are determined. Remember that when it comes to deflecting asteroids on a collision course with Earth.

In my own defense, I did have a great time.

I assume now that a student would whine to a professor to get a small bump to avoid that plight. It didn't occur to me even though I thought I'd calculated my programming course (ALGOL-W, I think) as being better than my final grade.

But rather than focus on getting that 0.007 GPA to get off academic probation, I doubled down and took even more math in the fall after summer break. My GPA went into free fall and I was out. In the nick of too late, I accepted that since I did well in my political science and history courses, that was probably the route I should have taken. I had taken every history class available in high school, too, after all. I registered for classes, somehow hoping that I'd escape the consequences of a GPA as low as I'd gotten it. The paperwork caught up with me, but not before I had attended courses for some weeks and figured that was the life for me. So I had that going for me.

My first course of action was to get a job. Which I'm sure was a relief to three apartment mates who kind of needed me to pay rent--aside from the value of my friendship and company, of course. So in a very bad economy, I finally found a job washing dishes at a seafood restaurant. Stray cats followed me home at night when I walked across the Diag.

I owed it to my friends, of course, not to let them down. And I worried my parents would despair. But I never had any doubt that I'd work the problem. I briefly considered the Army option (I would not go that route for 7 more years). I had failed. I was not a failure. That distinction was never unclear. I never considered going home in failure to live in my old room at my parents. And I never forgot my ultimate goal was to graduate from the University of Michigan.

I applied for readmission, citing my flash of insight about my proper path. The University would have none of that. Heck, I even remember spending a good half hour (as in amount of time--not the experience) with the head of academic affairs at the university on the way out. I even remember his name to this day (or think I remember it, anyway). But he had his own theories about why I flunked out that didn't involve alcohol and a disinterest in math that was crippling.

(Indeed, a good friend in college and a room mate who loved math--yet scored less than me on math SATs--could not bear to start the weekend if he was in the middle of a math problem he had not solved. That was the difference. I was already heading for happy hour and 25 cent hot dogs.)

A friend, who I will always be grateful for, drove me down to register when I told him what I needed to do. He didn't even ask. He just said, "Well, let's go," and he got up and headed for the door. I fully intended to register, but without my own car you can never tell if I would have carried out my intention in time for that term. Luckily, I grabbed my check book and never had to find out.

In a fortuitous event, we even had a guest lecture by a state representative in my political science class. Perhaps that turned on my radar for that career path when I got an opportunity to work for the state legislature a decade later--working in part for him, funny enough.

So I went to the local community college and took a full load of history and political science. With that under my belt, I reapplied and was accepted back in to Michigan.

I returned to the University of Michigan. Without my state scholarship, of course, due to the aforementioned GPA difficulties. So I continued to work. I worked the dorm cafeteria to provide access to food as much as for the pay. And I eventually got a job at an arcade (several arcades, actually), where I eventually became an assistant manager and then manager. Work the problem, as I always say. Whining says you gave up.

In perhaps what was a foolish gesture, rather than take easy classes to get off of academic probation, I took introductory physics my first term back. It was a course I flunked in my last term in, so it seemed like a statement about my resolve to do well this time. I got a B- in that. And hey, in seven years of helping my children in their grade school science fair projects, Mister earned two first places (only one trophy since the first year there was only a ribbon) and Lamb has earned 3 trophies. So my physics education was not totally wasted.

After that first term back, I lifted my GPA above 2.0 and never looked back. Working 20-30 hours a week, it did take me longer to graduate. At one point I had to stop taking classes until I paid off my tuition debt. But I made it. I may have every mark it is possible to get on a college transcript, but I graduated. Double majored, even. As I like to joke, "I loved being a college sophomore--the best three years of my life!"

Then I went on to graduate school, the Army National Guard, and then a good job and family (and divorce, in time) and all that. It's been a good life so far, and I look forward to much more.

The Lim story hits home because it is just beyond my comprehension that he would have fled the world in shame after faltering in college. Perhaps where he came from, that was a stumble that you could not recover from. But not here. If you stumble, you get up. I had only limited financial help from my family--those were rough times in Michigan. I was grateful for what I did get, and didn't use that as an excuse to stop piling up credits even if it seemed like it was painfully slow at times.

I hope the Life of Julia that our government is trying to impose on us doesn't take that attitude away from us. If you eff things up, face it, learn from it, and try again. A safety net too comfortable and certain is really just a burial shroud.

Anyway. Lim eventually graduated with a bachelor's degree in history, and returned to Singapore to live a normal life, dying too young at 55 in 1986--the year I graduated with my own BA in history and political science, coincidentally.

This is a great country. I hope Mr. Lim's hope, failure, and recovery gave him an insight into why America is great. We certainly reward success. But we forgive mistakes as long as you forgive yourself, learn, and keep moving. For every person, you are the biggest obstacle to your own success.

This is America, damn it. That's what we do.

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Pulling in the Outposts

Taiwan is wisely pulling their troops in from islands close to China where they could just be bypassed while the main battle on Taiwan is decided. But the islands should still be defended.

I've been happy that the Taiwanese government has reacted to the loss of superiority in the Taiwan Strait by withdrawing troops from futile missions to defend those islands that lie close to China. The garrisons would not contribute to the decisive battle on the main island and just risked giving other Chinese forces not needed for the invasion something useful to do to gain an early victory and demoralize other Taiwanese troops.

More troops are leaving their exposed positions:

Taiwan plans to withdraw troops from two islets near the Chinese mainland and will turn the former battleground into a tourist attraction as relations improve, officials said today.

The islands are Tatan and Ertan, which are part of the Kinmen islands.

Rather than turn them into tourist attractions, I'd fortify them with robotic defenders.

Brain-Free Zones

When guns are outlawed, criminals will still have guns while even the children of law-abiding parents will be arrested for having toy guns (tip to Instapundit):

Just one day after her fifth-grader’s toy gun was discovered on a school bus leaving Douglas MacArthur Elementary School in Alexandria, Virginia, his mom says he was arrested, dragged to court and questioned, photographed and fingerprinted. “Any time we get a call like this, we take it very seriously until we can determine the extent of the weapon, if it’s real or not, and what the student intends to do with it,” Alexandria Police Department spokesman Jody Donaldson told the Washington Examiner after the boy’s arrest.

Hey, nimrods, the kid probably wanted to play with the toy gun! I take it very seriously that the people charged with protecting us from actual threats are unable to distinguish between actual criminals with guns and children with toy guns.

Now this kid has a record of police interaction that will cast a shadow on his life. I'm thinking that if it saves even a single child's life, we need to punish school officials and police for such stupid assaults on a kid..

But hey, you have to admit that it is easier and safer to take on the kids with toy guns than actual criminals with real guns. I know most police are more than willing to confront real criminals. But if these officers don't stop this creeping idiots among them, they'll spend all their time protecting us from cap guns.

Freaking idiots. That's the real danger.

They Won't Botch it Forever

This professor says we shouldn't worry so much about Iran's nuclear program because they are botching it so far. He is wrong to advocate calm. It will be a problem if Iran gets nuclear weapons whether it is in a year or in 20 years. Just what does he think will happen in the meantime to make that less of a catastrophe?

Israel has put off their recent near-term projection of Iran crossing the nuclear threshold. This is the summary:

Nuclear weapons are hard to build for managerial reasons, not technical ones. This is why so few authoritarian regimes have succeeded: they don’t have the right culture or institutions. When it comes to Iran’s program, then, the United States and its allies should get out of the way and let Iran’s worst enemies -- its own leaders -- gum up the process on their own.

And the author makes two very bizarre statements in his essay about how he learned to stop worrying about the Iranian nuclear program.

One:

Overestimating Iran's nuclear potential might not seem like a big problem. However, similar, unfounded fears were the basis for President George W. Bush's preemptive attack against Iraq and its nonexistent weapons of mass destruction. Israel and the United States need to make sure that this kind of human and foreign policy disaster does not happen again.

And two:

Iran is not the only state with a dysfunctional nuclear weapons program. As I argued in a 2012 Foreign Affairs article, since the 1970s, most states seeking entry into the nuclear weapons club have run their weapons programs poorly, leading to a marked slowdown in global proliferation. The cause of this mismanagement is the poor quality of the would-be proliferator's state institutions. Libya and North Korea are two classic examples. Libya essentially made no progress, even after 30 years of trying. North Korea has gotten somewhere -- but only after 50 years, and with many high-profile embarrassments along the way.

The author is conflating nuclear WMD with chemical and biological WMD in regard to Iraq. Remember, Saddam was required to prove to us that he had completely dismantled his WMD programs. He refused. Our intelligence was wrong because many high-ranking Iraqis believed they had WMD. And just because we had no smoking gun, we knew Iraq had not proven his WMD disarmament and actively thwarted our attempts to do what we had no obligation to do--prove he did have WMD programs.

Further, we were sobered by prior failures in intelligence over Saddam's WMD programs. In 1991, we discovered how frighteningly close Iraq was to nuclear weapons before we defeated him in the Persian Gulf War. And in the mid-1990s we discovered Saddam had an active biological weapons program. We would not have known about that but for a surprise defection (the defector foolishly returned to Iraq to beg forgiveness and was executed for his trust). So we didn't know what we didn't know.

Further, we knew that Saddam actually produced and used chemical weapons against Iranian troops and against Kurdish civilians. And we knew that he retained the scientific, technical, and organizational assets to produce them if he had the opportunity.

In light of 9/11 and Saddam's support for terrorism in general and his and al Qaeda's shared hatred of America, it was understandable that we'd worry about future linkage even if there was no evidence of direct linkage between the two for the 9/11 attacks.

So to say our fears over Iraq WMD--as if that was the only reason for war--were unfounded is ridiculous.

Second, his dismissal of authoritarian regime nuclear programs ignores that Russia, China, and Pakistan have developed and deployed nuclear weapons.

His dismissal of North Korea's program is particularly astonishing if he thinks this bolsters his case for letting Iran pursue nuclear weapons without trying to stop them. North Korea has had three nuclear tests already and plan one or two more in the near term. If this black hole of the planet can do this, who can't?

And while it is comforting that North Korea didn't develop nuclear weapons earlier, why is that any comfort right now when North Korea is on the verge of having nuclear-tipped long-range ballistic missiles? If Iran takes another generation to get nuclear weapons, will that really be just fine? Will we really be able to smirk as we recall the high-profile embarrassments of their drive to get nuclear missiles? What rubes!

What rubbish. In the end, we have another directive from FUBARCOM here.

We are having the wrong Iran debate. We spend too much time calculating how far along the nuclear path psychotic regimes are, and too little time worrying about stopping the journey or ending the regimes that want nuclear weapons. Say what you will about the state of Saddam's WMD programs in 2003, but we know for sure Saddam's evil regime will not be getting WMD.

What's Black and Blue and Green All Over?

Our ground force generals, it seems. Tip to Instapundit.

Yet nobody responsible for overseeing the surge of domestic spending is held accountable by this administration for lack of economic progress.

And let's not even bring up that train wreck of intellect, Chuck Hagel.

Nile Warming

Perhaps our esteemed Secretary of State might take time out from giving speeches on global warming to address rule of law in Egypt.

Rule of law is essential to ending the crisis of governing legitimacy in Egypt. As long as the losers fear that winners will never allow the societal audit of their governing that free voting represents, the crisis will continue. Under the circumstances, it is a relief that the military isn't under the thumb of the Moslem Brotherhood government of President Mursi:

Egypt's powerful military is showing signs of growing impatience with the country's Islamist leaders, indirectly criticizing their policies and issuing thinly veiled threats that it might seize power again.

The tension is raising the specter of another military intervention much like the one in 2011, when generals replaced longtime authoritarian leader Hosni Mubarak after they sided with anti-regime protesters in their 18-day popular uprising.

It isn't optimal for the Egyptian military to have the power to over-rule civilian government based on rule of law. But we don't have an Egyptian government based on rule of law, do we?

But John Kerry has higher priorities than supporting democracy in Egypt--like alienating perhaps the most polite country in the world by droning on about global warming. Silly me, I thought we already had a head of EPA doing enough damage to our economy.

I swear, it sometimes hurts to watch "smart" diplomacy in action.

Do Not Become Confused

That breathing piece of garbage, the Iranian-sponsored Moqtada al Sadr, is birthing an Iraq branch of Hezbollah. If we weren't in such a confused state about whether the war we are fighting is receding or not--or whether we are even at war, really--we'd hardly give a thought to the question of killing him.

We will regret letting this three-time insurrectionist survive the Iraq War and tear Iraq apart:

The Iranian-backed Shiite group responsible for most of the attacks against U.S. forces in the final years of the Iraq war is busily reinventing itself as a political organization in ways that could enhance Iran’s influence in post-American Iraq — and perhaps beyond.

In recent months, Asaib Ahl al-Haq — the League of the Righteous — has been rapidly expanding its presence across Iraq, trumpeting the role the once-shadowy group says it played in forcing the departure of U.S. troops with its bomb attacks against American targets.

The group’s chief officers have returned from exile in Iran, and they have set about opening a string of political offices, establishing a social services program to aid widows and orphans, and launching a network of religious schools, echoing the methods and structures of one of its close allies, the Lebanese Shiite movement Hezbollah.

This is very bad. And I'll say it again, our invasion of Iraq did not "give" Iraq to Iran. Our failure to contest Iraq after ejecting Saddam Hussein's government is giving Iran a near-free run at influencing Iraq. Plenty of Iraqis want nothing to do with Iran. But Iran will be happy to simply fragment Iraq like Lebanon is fragmented to keep Iraq from developing into a counter-weight to Iran and to allow Iran another playground for terror to develop.

Throughout the Bush administration, I asked why Sadr wasn't dead. And I said we'd live to regret not putting him in a cell or hole. And now here we are.

If Sadr doesn't deserve to be on a presidential "kill list" to distribute to our drone operators for the number of Americans Sadr has killed--let alone the Iraqis dead because of him--I don't know who does qualify.

It's so confusing. Is this the "smart" part of our diplomacy or the nuanced part?

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Now They've Gone Too Far

It's one thing for the North Koreans to threaten South Korea with nuclear destruction. That's just rhetoric, right? But now The Un has gone and personally threatened The One! Now, it's personal.

Ho hum:

North Korea threatened South Korea with "final destruction" during a debate at the United Nations Conference on Disarmament on Tuesday, saying it could take further steps after a nuclear test last week.

"As the saying goes, a new-born puppy knows no fear of a tiger. South Korea's erratic behavior would only herald its final destruction," North Korean diplomat Jon Yong Ryong told the meeting.

So what, right? This is just one of those things that we have to endure from North Korea in between the acts of Dead South Koreans Theater that the North presents every once in a while.

If we can ignore a threatening video against our people, why would we care about a threat to destroy South Korea?

Wait. What?

A new North Korean video portrays President Barack Obama and American troops in flames and says the North conducted its recent nuclear test because of U.S. hostility.

North Korea threatens our president personally? It's almost like they could be considered part of an axis of evil--if such a thing existed in a world of receding war, of course.

Don't forget that one of the many reasons we went to war against Iraq in 2003 was that Saddam's regime attempted to assassinate former President George H. W. Bush.

They do this to a man with a kill list?

President Obama never seems to think much of history pre-Obama. Now North Korea's threats count.

It is such a mystery to determine why much of the world would be worried about North Korea and even hostile toward them. Well, a mystery to people like Pat Buchanan and the North Koreans, anyway.

Now We Have the Grid Coordinates

While I think we need to be proficient in cyber-warfare, never forget that physical smart bombs will kill the brightest hackers with even the coolest sounding handles.

I've long held that bombs are one response to hackers under certain conditions, as I recently opined:

It is necessary to prepare for war in cyber-space with sophisticated cyber-weapons as have been deployed against Iran. But in the rush to fight in cyber-space, don't forget that a physical smart bomb can simply blow up a room full of enemy cyber-warriors if they have an office park and we know the address.

We know the address:

Unit 61398 of the People's Liberation Army has been recruiting computer experts for at least a decade. It has made no secret of details of community life such as badminton matches and kindergarten, but its apparent purpose became clear only when a U.S. Internet security firm [Mandiant] accused it of conducting a massive hacking campaign against North American targets. ...

Mandiant says it traced scores of cyberattacks on U.S. defense and infrastructure companies to a neighborhood in Shanghai's Pudong district that includes the 12-story building where Unit 61398 is known to be housed. The building has office space for up to 2,000 people. Mandiant estimates the number of personnel in the unit to be anywhere from hundreds to several thousand. The surrounding neighborhood is filled with apartment buildings, tea houses, shops and karaoke bars.

I don't know what the threshold is, but at some point the damage that cyber-war inflicts shouldn't be treated any differently than a physical attack's effect.

It's kind of funny that a diffuse Internet battlefield has an office park that conveniently concentrates their warriors. Bureaucratic habits die hard, no?

Remain Calm, All is Well

Silly twits, don't worry about nuclear proliferation!

Now this is what echelon above reality in academia means The soothing analysis under-estimates the proliferation that has taken place already. It ignores the reduced threshold of producing 70-year-old technology. And it ignores the changing environment that once made the cost-benefit analysis for producing nukes lean to relying on American for deterrence:

Since the dawn of the nuclear era, various leaders and analysts have predicted that nuclear proliferation would take place rapidly and inexorably. Those countries that could build the bomb would do so, and others would build it in response. It has been predicted that almost 50 countries would eventually join the nuclear club alongside the five nuclear-weapon states recognized under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.

That prediction has proved wrong. Only four additional countries – India, Pakistan, Israel and North Korea – have acquired nuclear weapons. One country unambiguously tried and was stopped (Iraq, before it was foolish enough to invade Kuwait). In each case, the reasons why these countries decided to build nuclear weapons had to do with the specifics of their security situations rather than a reflex action. This record is hardly cause for celebration but also hardly the proliferation threat so often forecast.

Moreover, neighbours were threatened when these countries acquired nuclear weapons but decided not to build nuclear weapons in response. Japan and South Korea did not build them after China and then North Korea did, despite chilling rhetoric from the one-party states that easily matched anything Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has said about Israel. No Arab country built them after Israel did. Yes, Pakistan followed India into the nuclear club, but no other country in the region has.

See? Nearly 68 years after we built and used the bomb, only four countries have developed the bomb. If you exclude the countries Russia, China, Britain, and France who are "recognized" nuclear powers. And if you don't count South Africa, which actually dismantled their program.

To be fair, I won't count Ukraine, Belarus, and Khazakstan who inherited nuclear weapons from the USSR when that empire broke apart, since they gave them up.

But for something sobering, our vote to go to war against Iraq after they invaded Kuwait was quite close in the Senate--despite the invasion and conquest being a clear violation of international law. So we came very close to having another nuclear state despite the post facto "foolishness" of Iraq invading Kuwait.

So in 68 years, 9 states--not four--developed nuclear weapons after we did. Or 8 if you assume--as I do--that North Korea doesn't quite yet have a nuclear weapon rather than a nuclear device that can be detonated under laboratory conditions. And not counting Iraq which was frighteningly close. But North Korea soon will if we don't halt them the way we inadvertently stopped Iraq. Still, one per decade on average is nothing to sneeze at.

And consider that the threshold to building a bomb has fallen from requiring the world's leading economic power in 1945 to being within the grasp of grass-eating, Third World, Hell holes.

So Arab countries haven't gone nuclear after Israel did? Well, perhaps the Arab states know that Israel really only wants nukes for national survival and don't intend to use them below that threshold. Perhaps the Arab countries that built chemical weapons arsenals figured that with a small state like Israel, chemical weapons were sufficient to devastate Israel without the expense of going nuclear.

And while the author admits that Pakistan went nuclear after India did, that is a major hit on his argument that nations don't go nuclear in reaction to others going nuclear. Actually, it is two hits on his theory, since India went nuclear mostly to counter China's growing threat to India. And it adds a third since Pakistan's quick passing of the nuclear threshold after India did meant that they anticipated India going past that point and didn't want to risk a lag. How many countries are watching potential enemies with exactly the same fear in mind?

The academic, in arguing that countries are more likely to rely on our nuclear umbrella for deterrence, also ignores that the specifics of security situations are changing dramatically from the situations where countries did not need to "reflexively" go nuclear when their enemies did and instead relied on America's nuclear umbrella.

Consider that for years China did not possess nuclear weapons capable of reaching America. Once enemies can reach America, confidence that we will risk New York City for their capital declines considerably. Consider that Britain and France are nuclear powers given that they had doubts that we would retaliate against the Soviet Union if the Soviets hit London or Paris but left America alone. If the USSR still had thousands of warheads, would we really attack Moscow rather than just hope to contain a nuclear exchange to Europe outside of the Soviet Union?

So our extended deterrence was easy to offer when all we had to do was deter states unable to hit us with nuclear weapons. Once North Korea and Iran have nuclear weapons that can reach American cities, other countries will have a serious question to answer--will we risk New York City to save Riyadh and Seoul? When those nuclear-armed regimes might be nuts enough to believe they can get away with nuking Seoul or Riyadh and not face nuclear retaliation consequences from an uninvolved third party?

Yes, China can reach our cities. But not the heart of our power in the east. And China knows we have so many more nuclear weapons that it really would be suicidal for China to initiate a nuclear war. And up until recently, China's conventional forces have had limited power projection capabilities. But this is changing. Our regional allies will soon have to wonder whether we would initiate a nuclear exchange to defend them if our conventional forces fail to defeat them.

I'm thinking that the specifics of the security situations of a lot of countries are going to change dramatically.

Oh, and just as more countries might need to rely on our nuclear weapons for deterrence, our president--who already received a Nobel Peace Prize for his promise in this area--clearly wants to reduce our nuclear arsenal to a minimal level for our own narrow deterrence needs.

So don't don't worry, be hopey.



Just remember that disclaimer, "past performance is no guarantee of future earnings." Can we really afford to assume past trends will continue forever?

I mean, all has been well up to now. What could go wrong?

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Code Pat

Does Pat Buchanan mind that he is indistinguishable from any Code Pink Chapter? I mean no difference other than having less facial hair than their members, of course.

How can this man call himself a conservative and say this?

On this weekend’s broadcast of “The McLaughlin Group,” conservative commentator Pat Buchanan blamed the United States for the aggression of North Korea, whose recent surprise nuclear test brought widespread condemnation from the international community. ...

“Why should the United States — 60 years after the end of the Korean War — have 28,000 guys on the DMZ, when South Korea has an economy 40 times the size of the North, and they got twice the population? The point is, if the United States weren’t on the DMZ, this guy wouldn’t be building intercontinental missiles and nuclear warheads to attack us.”

We don't have 28,000 troops on the DMZ. We have about that many in South Korea. Of them, only a few thousand are in a single Army brigade combat team. Indeed, we've been pulling our troops back from the DMZ just as North Korea has accelerated their nuclear and missile programs.


Most of our troops are moving south of Seoul or to the southeast.

So Buchanan needs to find another cause and effect. Like, oh, I don't know, that the North Koreans are murderous, communist, bastards?

Once, Buchanan wouldn't have had a problem understanding that explanation. Now he just blames us for standing with an ally.

No doubt, Pat will get his own talk show on Current TV now that Al Gore sold it to Al Jazeera.

Good Girls Don't

The president gave hope and change to our press corps good and hard, and now they are shocked that he just isn't that into them and never calls.

But they'll still answer when he wants to get inside their memes because they can always talk about the Republicans that they hate.

Good grief, our press corps sucks.

Tip to Instapundit.

Fooling Themselves

Just as I've worried that we'll let our military hollow out as we cut our defense spending and leave our leaders falsely believing we have a fully capable military, I've also worried that Chinese leaders will believe their more powerful military is all-powerful.

Instapundit notes that the Chinese military's leaders are getting more aggressive in their rhetoric. The problem is that the Chinese might act on that rhetoric:

China is strong in some ways, but is really a paper tiger. But it may not realize that, as the hotheaded Japanese officers didn’t realize it in the runup to World War II.

Yes, in 1941 Japan's GDP was a tenth of ours. Yet they attacked anyway. But it did take us nearly four years to throw them back, recall, despite their miscalculation.

And we've seen other miscalculations regarding China. In 1950, their friend North Korea attacked our ally and we were taken by surprise before we recovered. And then China itself took us by surprise and nearly threw us off the peninsula before we recovered. China was fairly weak, then.

How much more difficult would it be to defeat China if they take us by surprise and throw us back from the western Pacific?

Remember, China doesn't have to be stronger than us to win a war in the western Pacific. No, China has to be stronger than their target and merely strong enough to delay our intervention long enough to defeat their target. Those are two different things. China has the great advantage of being close while we are far.

If we even try to roll back China, shouldn't we be worried about how long a war between two nuclear powers can remain conventional?

But yes, China is a danger because their chest is swelling over their regained military stature. And while their actual power will help decide the outcome of a war, their beliefs about their power will help decide whether they start a war.

I liken it to new soldiers just out of boot camp. You enter probably out of shape and a pure civilian. You endure and come out part of the mean green fighting machine, with new muscles and the new skills of killing planted in you. You think you are a bad-ass SEAL Team 6-level killing machine in your still-crisp BDUs (or whatever they are called now).

But you are not a killing machine. You aren't even a cog in the killing machine. You are just the first rough stamping of a cog that will eventually be sanded and polished into a part of the killing machine. I remember our drill sergeants telling us that we need to avoid being full of ourselves when we leave basic training and move on to a new base or go back on the block. We are stronger than when we arrived. Do not mistake that for being stronger than other people, they warned. If we do, we'll get our butts kicked.

China has gotten out of world power basic training. Let's hope they don't throw a punch before they realize how much farther that they need to go to be actually powerful.

Monday, February 18, 2013

It's Science Literacy, Damn It!

It frustrates me that the vast majority of those who adhere to the global warming creed have little background to justify their faith. Yet they are assumed to be "pro-science." No matter what. If you care, all is forgiven--and forgotten.

I'm sure I noted this study when it came out (why yes I did! Indeed, this is the third time. Forgive me.). But this take on it is both amusing and frustrating:

In a survey published last year, Americans rated as highly individualistic were the least concerned about climate change, probably because they tend to value freedom in private markets and industry. More community-focused people tend to blame industry for social inequalities and welcome laws limiting industry.

The study also revealed something counterintuitive: The people most knowledgable sbout science and who had the best grasp of math and numbers were the ones least concerned about climate change. [emphasis added]

Not that global warming believers uniquely lacked science knowledge. The article didn't say that and I'm not claiming that.

But the assumption that I am a global warming "denier" because I don't have my panties in a twist over the issue is ludicrous. I actually passed some college-level education in computer programming, math, astronomy, physics, and statistics. I would never claim to be a climate expert. But I think I can read about it with some ability to analyze what I'm reading and judge the reliability of those making claims.

Certainly I have a better ability to do that than the vast majority of those who think global warming is a major problem and that the global warming solutions proposed are correct. I could still be wrong, of course. But I do have the capacity to look at the issue.

Yet that ability cuts me no slack with the global warmers. Note the delicious turn of phrase in the article that displays an amazing lack of awareness, that the correlation between those who have more math and science knowledge and those least concerned about global warming is "something counter-intuitive."

I protest that it is only "counter-intuitive" if you believe that global warming science is a fact and you are simply trying to understand why the denier idiots don't believe in global warming--and you are shocked that you didn't find they are actually idiots.

Shouldn't the correlation between science and math knowledge and disregard of the panicky predictions of the warmists give the global warmers pause to consider that maybe the science isn't as settled as they claim? Maybe they are the ones who are wrong? Maybe their solutions are flawed? Maybe they are the ones influenced by their basic thinking patterns rather than the science?

Nah! Global warming is science, damn it! Smash the heretics! Banish them! Arrest them! Kill them! All of them! Deny space aliens an excuse to wipe us out!

Remember, the global warmists are super geniuses. I'm a "denier." And I am a "denier." I admit it. But I don't deny science. I deny the claims of the warmists. Two different things.

Now go and emit no more.

Sorry. This clearly strikes a sore spot. I live in ground zero of global warming faith and it affects my dating life. Life would be easier if I spouted the "right" things. I'll not deny that.

UPATE: Thanks to Pseudo-Polymath for the link.

UPDATE: Mark Steyn has related thoughts on efforts to enforce conformity in the purportedly scientific community. This is the necessary facade to convince people that resistance to the consensus is futile--and tiring. The vanguard of the warmetariat are dangerous people, at heart, and not just a danger to science.