Friday, December 10, 2004

Goldilocks Warriors

Some people will just never support the war we are in right now. It doesn't matter what the war is at the moment.

They will cover their opposition by saying they supported a past war that we won (or even a lost war) even when they opposed such wars at the time. Just listen to those who now claim that they supported the Gulf War or Afghanistan campaign or who even respect the soldiers who fought in Vietnam. It's just this war in Iraq they oppose.

They may even say that another problem is more severe and must be met first--possibly with force--before waging the war in question. North Korea and Iran spring to mind. But you can always be sure that if the issue they once said is more important comes up, there will be another problem that must be dealt with first.

Whether too hot or too cold, the question of a war to defend us is never just right.

One of the biggest "bigger" threats is al Qaeda. The popular stand to take if you oppose the war in Iraq but don't want to look like you don't care about defending America is to declare we must win the war on bin Laden first. But like every other "other war" that the opponents of the current war claim they would support, their commitment to fighting even this enemy is questionable. After three years of fighting Islamists, some on the left aren't sure that these Islamists are really a threat. As Jonah says:

So let me get this straight. The last two years of bleating and beating we've gotten from liberals all the how-dare-yous and the Iraq's-a-distraction stuff all of that was just a pose? You guys don't think any of it's a big deal after all? It was all just a way to smack George Bush around? How sad. How frick'n dishonest.

Face it, when they plaster "war is not the answer" on their Volvos, they really mean it. We are never justified in fighting because there is never an enemy--just understandably angry people reacting to our wrongdoing. And when they say that we need to address another problem first, they don't mean that either. Or when they say we need a perfect plan first, again they don't mean it. Or if they say they want more debate even after lengthy debate, they only mean they are losing and want a chance to change the conclusion.

Any objection is simply meant to delay and stall so that events will prevent us from going to war against a threat to us.

I guarantee that if fighting in Iran looms, suddenly we will have to win in Iraq--the good war--before we think of intervening. Just as the predicted quagmire in Afghanistan turned into a sad victory against a fifth rate power, the Iraq War will pass into that hallowed category of past victory that we can safely ignore.

War will never be just right for some.


I'm From Hollywood and I'm Here to Help

Michael Totten has an interesting post that touches on why movies don't seem to really dwell on our Islamist terrorist enemies:


In a recent conversation with a struggling liberal screenwriter, I brought up the Clancy film as an example of Hollywood shying away from what really affects filmgoers--namely, the al Qaeda threat vs. the neo-Nazi threat. He vehemently defended the script switch. "It's an easy target," he said of Arab terrorism, repeating this like a parrot, then adding, "It's a cheap shot."
A cheap shot? Kind of like making a movie about World War II without mentioning the Germans and Japanese. Or the Cold War without the Soviets. What is with some of us? I mean, even two Persian Gulf War movies I can think of (Three Kings and Courage Under Fire) were more about some Americans being the bad guys. Yet this guy thinks that avoiding calling Arab terrorism a problem--an enemy--is a cheap shot?

Look, we managed to convey that Germans were the bad guys without tainting German-Americans. We didn't do such a hot job with Japanese-Americans so I don't discount this problem. Indeed, I wrote to the president in 1990 to ask the president--as one of his soldiers who could be sent to war--to urge Americans to treat Arab-Americans as Americans. But over the past fourteen years we've managed to fight Moslem enemies without jailing or mistreating our Moslem or Arab countrymen.

Failure to call our enemies who are killing us our "enemies" for fear of tainting all Arabs or Moslems is stupid and counter-productive. Doesn't this tacitly say that our enemies and the loyal Arab- and Moslem-American here are one and the same? Why should all Arabs or Moslems be tied to the murderous behavior of a few? I am not personally offended by describing IRA members as terrorists even though I am half Irish. And I'd be offended if somebody thought that calling them terrorists would offend me because I am Irish! Personally, I think our Arab-American and Moslem-American citizens are loyal Americans. We can call our enemies what they are and still include all our citizens in the war.

The Coldstream Guards get it at least. British sergeant attempted to walk home drunk while wearing a suicide-bomber costume. While I concede (as did the regiment) that the soldier should not have alarmed the locals by doing this, he at least identified the enemy properly as the spokesman for the regiment said:


Given the perceived threat from terrorism, it was "perfectly fair" for soldiers to make fun of it, he said.

But of course, to make fun of it you have to identify it as part of the enemy. To my frustration, some can't bear to admit we have enemies.

So here's a handy guide:

Our enemies are those who are killing us and plotting to kill us. They happen to be Moslem.

Our citizens are targets of those trying to kill us. These include Arab- and Moslem-Americans.

Hollywood and their ideological ilk aren't helping Moslems by refusing to name our enemies.





Thursday, December 09, 2004

Full Metal Racket

The press appears to be in full-throated shrieking weenie mode over the Iraq armor question.

I had to turn off the news tonight after switching between the opinions of Al Franken and Fred Kaplan on two stations. The ability of people without a clue to give me their opinions on what constitutes military incompetence is astounding.

Yes, we should have more armored vehicles in Iraq. I've been a proponent of armor for a long time. Notwithstanding the revolution in military affairs, passive protection is still critical. Our troops need armor and we should get it to them as quickly as possible.

But the idea that this represents military incompetence in asinine. Truly, I would love to hear about a war that went as planned and did not require changes once in contact with the enemy.

Recall the World War II German army--clearly a first rate mlitary--that went to war with training tanks! With trucks for their "armored infantry" and wagons for supply units. They had to use captured Czech tanks to make up for deficiencies in armor and even when they went into France 8 months after the war started, they still had training tanks in their panzer divisions and armored half tracks were rare indeed.

Deficiencies in war occur from wrong peacetime assumptions and from enemy actions to take advantage of weaknesses they identify.

And truly, the people standing on a stool gripping their skirt hems and shrieking the loudest would never in a million years support a defense budget able to deal with any possible enemy action right from the start. Nor should we. Resources are limited and our military has done a good job. Not perfect by any means but good. Good enough to be awesome on the battlefield that's for sure. And good enough to adapt while fighting.

We are dealing with the problem. People need to get a grip.

UNlikely

So you want a better UN? You want a cleanly run, efficient organization that saves the downtrodden, deters and defeats aggression, and otherwise lives up to the highest ideals of the "international community."

Yeah, and Meg Ryan is going to put me on number three on her speed dial.

I don't care how many reports the UN writes about making itself more relevant, effective, and minty fresh, they will fail.

And really, I want the UN to fail.

Look, the world's thugs and reality averse nations of the EU will hide behind the skirts of the UN as an excuse to do nothing about the world's thugs no matter what. Effective UN or current ineffective UN, these states will pretend that the UN lives up to the highest ideals of the international community.

But if we actually get an effective UN, we might actually face some pressure from our own people to listen to the UN. And if you think an effective UN will side with us, look at the democracies of the world and count how many are supporting us in Iraq? I won't pause while you count since I know you are done already.

And as I wrote before, don't even think about withdrawing from the UN to form a League of Democracies. Those democracies are often less supportive of us than the thug regimes (let's see, Ukraine has 1,600 troops in Iraq. Belgium, France, and Germany have how many?).

No, work on improving the financial transparency of UN operations to keep the UN bureaucracy worried about what we will do to them rather than having time to worry about how to screw us over. And work on reforming the technical or humanitarian organs of the UN because it would be nice if those worked reasonably well. But leave the political organs alone to be ineffective. An expanded Security Council? Go for it! If aspiring veto holders want to add to the inertia of the international community of nations, I'm all for it. Twice in its history the UN has officially backed wars--Korea I and Gulf War I. The backing of the international community guaranteed that we could not actually make sure the war led to lasting victory. Just a ceasefire for our enemies to prepare for another round.

But I don't worry that the latest UN report will lead to anything:

All of the reformistas' efforts founder on the rocks of apathy and inertia. The reality is that most of the U.N.'s 191-member states, to say nothing of its 49,000 employees, aren't terribly interested in making it work better. They usually have other priorities. Even the Bush administration isn't making much of a stink over the oil-for-food scandal because it needs U.N. support in Iraq and elsewhere.

A slightly improved UN with a larger Security Council yet the same old political inertia will aid our foreign policy. We can rally the UN when we can to mollify those who give a rat's patootie about the UN's collective opinion. And when we can't? We'll defend our interests anyway and the allies we get will have an excuse to go with us based on the horrible nature of the UN. And the American people won't feel guilty at all about thumbing our noses at the corrupt institution.

I actually fear a reformed UN. But that outcome is highly unlikely.

Armor in Iraq

Our planning for the Iraq War is taking more hits based on the question of a soldier to Secretary Rumsfeld in Kuwait about inadequate armor.

I have only two things to add to his debate:

If the Army, over the last twenty years, had asked for the money to pay for armored Humvees and trucks (and yes they are much more expensive to buy and maintain) do you think Congress would have complied? Do you think the critics of defense spending would have said yes, our troops need the protection no matter how unlikely a future war will place them in harm's way? Or would they have complained that rear-echelon troops would not need the armor and that we can't afford the cost?

And weren't "reformer" critics of the Army complaining during the early stages of the insurgency by the Baathists that the Army was too heavy and needed to send light, mobile forces to Iraq and to get those troops out of their armored vehicles and into soft caps to walk the beat?

In peacetime, when nobody is shooting at us, we talk speed. In war we remember that armor rules. We're just remembering that rule. We really do go to war with the army we have and not the army we wish to have. We are and will successfully adapt to changing circumstances. This amazing ability to adapt is the real story of armor in Iraq. Not that the press or war critics care. They just found a new club to use against the war effort and they'll swing it. Check this out for some more perspective.

We also go to war with the enemy we have and not the enemy we wish to have. Remember that corrollary the next time somebody says nobody can face us on battlefield.

Ok, I had more than two things to say.


Wednesday, December 08, 2004

Yeah, That's the Problem

North Korea is a despotic, murdering, and quite insane regime that wants nuclear missiles.

Clearly, the problem is that America isn't offering the Pillsbury Nuke Boy enough money. That's what a panel of experts has concluded:

The United States should use incentives to entice North Korea to scrap its nuclear programs, including a "buyout" pegging aid to the amount of plutonium Pyongyang surrenders, a panel of experts said.

No matter that we tried to bribe the North Koreans into reasonableness ten years ago and it led to our current situation. Because, hey, these people on the panel are experts:

Formed in late 2002 after the crisis erupted, the task force is made up of prominent American experts on Korea, including former military officers and diplomats. It is chaired by Selig Harrison, director of the Asian program at the Washington-based Center for International Policy.

See, right off the bat the experts are confused. The crisis didn't erupt in 2002. We caught them violating existing agreements in 2002! There really is a subtle difference and this really should influence how you read the North Koreans. If the North Koreans wanted money from us, why did they hide their violations of the 1994 Agreed Framework until we confronted them in 2002? You'd think that an attempt at monetary blackmail would require some sort of note indicating they are working on nukes and have a price to halt development.

But no, the North Koreans worked in secret. Why? Here's a clue for the experts. BECAUSE THEY WANT FRIGGIN' NUKES. Once you say it out loud it really is quite clear. Try it.

But then the story provides explanations for this seeming inability to comprehend an evil foe:

The task force -- which includes critics of Bush's North Korea policy -- challenges other U.S. principles in a crisis that erupted in October 2002 when Washington said North Korea admitted having a secret uranium enrichment program.

The task force--hold your hats--has critics of the Bush administration's policy on it. Who'd have thought that? The task force also challenges other U.S. principles. I think one of the principles it is challenging is that we should prevent threats to our people from developing.

But the task force does embrace the principle of valuing hope over experience. If I was content to pretend we were succeeding with North Korea for a little while until they burst our bubble again, I might go with the principles of the task force experts. Then shoveling money into Pyongyang would be worth the lulling, soothing effect of believing the threat from North Korea was solved.

I'd rather squeeze those psychopathic monsters until they implode.

There Must Be Consequences

Syria is a source of problems in Iraq.

We have reports of convoys heading to Syria before and during the Iraq War main phase. We had jihadis from Syria fight us in the advance up to Baghdad. We've had fights along the border. One of our Marines mysteriously appeared in Lebanon after disappearing inside Iraq in a sure indication that he was sent back up the pipeline.

The Syrians are hip deep:

A network of Syrian mosques is sending men, money and weapons to Iraq, fuelling the insurgency.


An investigation by the Telegraph has shown that Arab volunteers are streaming across the border despite Damascus government claims that it is curbing cross-border terrorism.


Much of the traffic is financed by former members of Saddam Hussein's regime living in the Syrian capital and has the backing of prominent tribal leaders.


The evidence from Fallujah seems pretty clear:

U.S. military intelligence officials have concluded that the Iraqi insurgency is being directed to a greater degree than previously recognized from Syria, where they said former Saddam Hussein loyalists have found sanctuary and are channeling money and other support to those fighting the established government.

Based on information gathered during the recent fighting in Fallujah, Baghdad and elsewhere in the Sunni Triangle, the officials said that a handful of senior Iraqi Baathists operating in Syria are collecting money from private sources in Saudi Arabia and Europe and turning it over to the insurgency.


According to the article, we are exerting diplomatic pressure on Syria to cut down infiltration and to expel Baathists from Syria. We've also worked with the French to pressure Syria over their occupation of Lebanon.

Will it be enough? I continue to believe that Syria is vulnerable to non-military measures to change their behavior. They oppose us not from ideology but from their view of the usefulness of supporting the Baathists in Iraq. The Syrian government is narrowly based on the Allawite minority of Syria that Moslems are suspicuous of as it is. If we make this support hurt Syria, they will stop. But can we get our allies to help in putting economic and diplomatic screws to the Syrians? Well that is a problem now isn't it?

Military options are limited since we do not have the strength to fight everywhere. It might not be wise even if we had the troops. I'm no fan of expanding problems when the current problems are not yet solved. But since Syria is part of the current problem, this is not a suggestion that we ignore Syria. Certainly, once the Iraqi elections are over we should attempt to ease out of the daily counter-insurgency business by putting Iraqi units into the fight and move our units to the Syrian border to bolster efforts there to halt infiltration. Perhaps Syrian territory should be subject to attack when we see suspicious activity. And it might be a good idea for some things inside Syria to mysteriously start blowing up.

I'm not sure what we can do, but there must be consequences for siding with our enemies.

Tuesday, December 07, 2004

He's Got to be Kidding

Putin has to accept that free elections are going to go ahead in Iraq and Ukraine despite his wishes. Russia needs to lose these two issues in order to move forward. As long as the Russians pine for former imperial glories, they cannot move forward and become part of the West.

President Putin is trying to toss a monkey wrench into our Iraq project (no change in Kremlin policy there, that's for sure):

"Honestly speaking, I cannot imagine how it is possible to organize elections under the conditions of occupation by foreign forces," Putin said in televised comments during a Kremlin meeting with interim Iraqi Prime Minister Ayad Allawi.

He can't imagine?

Let's see. Elections. Violence. Under the conditions of occupation by foreign forces. I can't imagine where I've seen that recently.

Oh yes, now I remember, that would be Chechnya. The recent election there led Putin to gush:


Russian president Vladimir Putin called Alkhanov’s victory a “beginning of big and highly important work in the arrangement of peaceful life, the restoration of economics and social life in the Chechen republic,” Interfax news agency reported.

Why Putin thinks he has to imagine elections in a country enduring violence and occupation by troops from another country is beyond me. All he has to do is remember.

Not that I don't wish the Russians the best in going after the monsters of Beslan. I do. Those children didn't deserve that. But my sympathy doesn't cross over into understanding why the Russians would thwart us. Nor do I pine for the Cold War days. But again, when Russia is trying to screw us over, we can't ignore it.

We need to push for free elections in Iraq and in Ukraine. That Russia under Putin considers those free elections to be contrary to Russian interests should tell us a lot. We are beyond "trust but verify" but not by much it seems.

Ukraine Speed Bump

Despite the protests, the support of the Western democracies, and the ruling of the Ukraine supreme court, the pro-Russian corrupt elites in Ukraine are not giving up.

The Russians are trying to play on the fear of the US by reliving glory days of the Cold War in order to rally support. But this is not a Cold War ploy. In the Cold War we'd have kept our mouths shut to keep 1,600 Ukrainian troops in action at our side and swallowed our ideals about the form of the government in Kiev. Now, gaining a democracy is more important than the troops in Iraq. Secretary of State Colin Powell is going strong in his last weeks:

"It is not a matter of (spheres) of influence, it is a matter of allowing a country to choose how it wishes to be governed and who it wishes to have as its friends," Powell said on a trip to Bulgaria.

We can't go wobbly on this. We can't let the Russians and their friends in Kiev steal this election.

Go Orange.

Axis of El Vil Update

The United States government has not forgotten that cesspool of thuggery off our coast:

President Bush will be committed during his second term to the "liberation of Cuba" by extending moral and political support to the Cuban people, a top State Department official said Friday.

Those not on the top tier of the Axis of Evil should not feel they are safe from our attention.

And in a bow toward all those who claim that we planned insufficiently for the overthrow of Saddam there is this good piece of news:

[Roger] Noriega noted that Washington has a blueprint for providing social, economic and other types of assistance to Cuba in the post-Castro era.

The plan is spelled out in a report released last May and overseen by Secretary of State Colin Powell. The assistance is conditioned on whether Cuba is on a democratic path and whether such assistance is requested.

Yes indeed, since we are planning already there can be no complaints. Or will those who admire and fawn over Castro do what those who admired and fawned over Saddam did? Oppose anything like planning that might prejudice talks and the like or imply that war is inevitable.

Damned if we plan. Damned if we don't. And damned, of course, if our plan contains some wrong assumptions--never mind that we correct our plans as we go.

Still, as I said, it is good that we don't forget these scumballs so near to us.

Phoenix Rising

Just yesterday I was contemplating the apparent increase in attacks on Iraqi security forces by the enemy. We need Iraqis to fight the war and I worried that such attacks might intimidate the personnel we are training to carry on the fight. I see no indications of this but thought there could be an imbalance where anonymous Baathists did not fear for their families while public police and security forces did have that fear. To counter this terror, I thought it might be a good idea to go after the enemy leaders to instill fear in them. Capture or kill them in the dark of night and they would start to fear carrying out terror just as they fear taking on our troops directly.

Then I read this from Strategypage:

Western journalists have a hard enough time covering the battle involving American troops, but they are almost completely cut out of this other war. All you hear reported is the occasional killing of a prominent Sunni Arab (usually a clergyman). But the body count on both sides is quite high, and trending against the Sunni Arabs. If the Sunnis gather together in large groups, to overwhelm local police, they risk getting caught, and demolished by American troops. Operating in smaller groups, and there is increasing danger from Shia Arab (and even Kurdish) death squads. This is a very dirty war, which will eventually get reported as such.

The Shias and Kurds are doing what they have to do in the face of a brutal enemy that does not like losing its neck-stomping role. I'm just as glad the press has not caught on to this aspect of the war.

Monday, December 06, 2004

With Lovely Wax Stamps and Bright Ribbons!

Darfur continues to deteriorate. But don't say that the UN hasn't led the vaunted international community to doing something. Oh no. In the finest tradition of the Corps Diplomatique Terrestrienne, the UN has issued a report!

Chaos is looming in Sudan's western Darfur region as violence increases, order collapses, and the number of desperate people in need of humanitarian aid reaches nearly 2.3 million, according to a U.N. report issued Monday.

This is doubly disappointing because:


The optimism generated by an agreement between the government and two rebel groups on humanitarian and security issues has been overshadowed by the deteriorating security situation in recent weeks, Secretary-General Kofi Annan said in the report to the U.N. Security Council.

I'm sure the UN was optimistic that it could slide by a little longer without being confronted with the failure of its efforts to reign in slaughter and forced starvation.

But have heart, the UN has documented the deterioration:


The 15-page report details daily attacks, village burnings, rapes, hijackings of relief goods, theft of livestock, the forced movement of thousands of displaced people, and numerous deaths.

And don't think that Annan is oblivious to the problem:


The African Union warned that failure to do so would oblige it to refer the matter to the U.N. Security Council, the report said. The council has raised the possibility of sanctions.

That's right. If the Sudanese government doesn't stop killing its own people in Darfur, the possiblity was raised that there might be sanctions imposed! Imagine the audacity of that possible threat of referral to the Security Council! Imagine the impact on the killers!

Of course, we'll need several more reports in two official languages with nice official looking wax stamps and brightly colored ribbons festooning the leather-bound report before we can even consider such a rash act.

Because the situation is deteriorating and the international community is surely concerned. That has to count for a lot. Right?


Tales of the Bleeding Obvious (Part 12)

Sometimes you have to be amazed by the insights we get from stories. I'm not talking about those subtle points coaxed out of obscure facts like "the sun rises in the east." Oh no, I'm talking keen insights that only a journalism degree can prepare you to make.

Like this:

Iran's embattled President Mohammad Khatami conceded Monday he had failed to implement his democratic reform program, claiming he had bowed to the will of supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and his hard-line allies to avoid riots and preserve the ruling Islamic establishment.

It's a good thing Khatami gave a speech to explain this because I'm sure that a lot of Iranians have been scratching their heads about this mystery. Khatami wasn't ineffective in fighting for democracy. He surrendered to the mullahs to "preserve the ruling Islamic establishment." So that's why he did it. Because to his voters, preserving the Islamic establishment was right up there, right? I mean, that's why the Iranians voted for him--to preserve the mullah rule. Democracy was right out, correct?

But instead of contemplating his own absolute failure to push for any type of democracy, Khatami claims he let his supporters down because he feared unrest and violence. Or at least unrest and violence different from the unrest and violence the regime has imposed on the people. He failed the people who counted on Khatami to battle the mullahs who have made Iran a nuclear pariah and thug state that sponsors terrorists.

As some of the Iranian students who listened to his speech shouted:


"Khatami, Khatami shame on you!" Others yelled out: "Incompetent Khatami, may our vote not bless you!"

Shame, indeed. I hope we are working to inspire a revolt that will not end until the mullahs are on the run.

But until then, thank goodness Khatami cleared Iran's recent history right up--Iran's attempt at democratic reform failed. Duh.

Tantamount to Treason

A review by Bruce Thornton of Alexander has a useful conclusion:


And here's the most illuminating point about this forgettable movie: once more we see the left's romantic admiration of any mass-murderer who cloaks his slaughter in idealism. Wasn't it Lenin who said you can't make an omelet without breaking eggs? The "omelet" of Communist idealism took, as we now know, 100 million dead human beings, and ended up inedible anyway. But that hasn't stopped the left from continuing to excuse murder on the grounds of "idealism," provided it comes from the left (after all, Nazis were idealists too). Thus Stalin, Ho Chi Min, Mao and Castro continue to be more popular on college campuses than Ronald Reagan, and ex-terrorists like Bill Ayres and Bernadette Dohrn are professors at taxpayer-funded universities.

Once more we see the bankruptcy of the left, the hollowness of its populist rhetoric and democratic idealism. Behind all that lofty rhetoric is the old lust for power and domination, contempt for the average person, and a burning confidence in the superiority of its ideas no matter how bloody their application or how often they are discarded in the trashcan of history. Stone's Alexander may not tell us much about the Macedonian killer, but it reveals a lot about the pathology of the left.


This is something I see time and time again and it never fails to perplex me so utterly that I can never wrap my mind around comprehending it. Just how can so many people who oppose American policy make such an easy leap to supporting and idealizing our enemies? Why should it be so difficult to express dissent from official US policy and simultaneously see the targets of that policy as evil? It is as if such people are too simplisme to hold that a policy is bad and the target of that policy is also bad.

Of course, it isn't just idealism at play here. The idealism has to be hostile to America, our system of government, or our economic system. Hit on all three cylinders and you are guaranteed fawning coverage on our campuses.

Oh, and if you are wondering about the title, as long as some can call our prisoner policies "tantamount to torture" I think I can use "tantamount to" pretty freely from now on. Indeed, it is tantamount to a license to kill.


Sunday, December 05, 2004

No Mistake

As this article notes, CNN reports that Pervez Musharraf has critical words about our invasion of Iraq:
The U.S.-led invasion of Iraq was a mistake that has made the world a more dangerous place, but a swift withdrawal would make matters worse, Pakistan's president said this weekend.

This is a relatively common refrain over here. I think it is silly. If invading was a mistake, how is perpetuating the mistake the best option? One would think that if we made a mistake invading, the best option to redress the error is to get out.

If you think that staying will create a better Iraq that negates our "mistake" of invading in the first place, it would have to be the opposite of a mistake. After all, freeing the slaves surely made the monstrous sacrifice of the Civil War worthwhile did it not? Yet stopping the Union 0ffensive anytime prior to victory truly would have made First Bull Run a mistake.

It was not a mistake to invade and overthrow Saddam. He will never get WMD and he will never threaten the region and he will never kill more of his own people and terrorize them into submission. The insurgency has been tougher than I expected but in the end we will hold free elections in Iraq and help create new governmental and security organizations that will provide liberty to Iraqis long denied that what we take for granted.

Musharraf is quite wrong. Iraq was no mistake. The world is safer. And we will make things much better if we keep moving forward. Oh, perhaps for Musharraf things are less safe. Certainly, he probably does not like having to put down his own local Islamists. He was safer when he could coddle them and point them at somebody else. Musharraf has helped us quite a bit and I am grateful. But we had to push him kicking and screaming to get him to help.

With all due respect, President Musharraf doesn't have a clue.

The Devil We Know

As the headlines roll out from the United Nations, it is sometimes difficult for me to judge whether incompetence, anti-Americanism, or corruption are the defining characteristics of the body. In a crisis, without prodding from the US, the UN is capable of acting contrary to liberty and democracy or just studying a problem while people die, issuing an interim report (in French and English) two years later that calls for more study.

The United Nations appears to be a hindrance to American interests as it sadly does accurately represent the rogue's gallery of nations that are members. We can roll along as is, reform the UN, or get out as some would have us do and form some type of League of Democracies based on the Anglosphere and other democracies.

Certainly, change is coming, as this article notes:


A clock starts ticking this Thursday for major reform of the United Nations. That's when a panel of 16 prominent leaders, appointed last fall by Secretary-General Kofi Annan, will recommend how to overhaul an institution that's been articularly adrift since the US-led war in Iraq.

This is the report. I know what you're thinking. The UN is going to look at reforming itself? Where's the door? We're outta here. And certainly, only fools would trust the UN to reform itself. The UN document is a joke. I wouldn't trust any part of it. The parts on a new Security Council to replace the permanent 5 and the rotating non-veto ten envision adding non-veto members (either permanent or all rotating) to provide 24 members, 6 each from the Americas, Europe, Asia, and Africa.

This is ridiculous. I'm sorry, but there isn't a single country in Africa that deserves a permanent seat. South Africa might one day. Nigeria could a lot longer from that. Egypt or Ethiopia could conceivably aspire to qualifying but they can't even dream of that day yet.

Even in the Americas, only Brazil seems like it might one day qualify but again, not yet.

We don't need a study to know that Japan, Germany, and India are the real candidates for permanent seats.

And the talk of new permanent members without the veto of the current permanent members is ridiculous. If you qualify for the exclusive club, you should get the privileges. And the repsonsibilities, too. Which is why anybody but the above-mentioned three should be non-starters. Who is fooling who by suggesting permanent seats for anybody else?

My suggestion for reforming the Security Council isn't new for anybody who's read The Dignified Rant for the last couple years. I'd have seats for the USA (because we are the lone superpower), Russia (because they have too many nukes to ignore), Japan (because we should show that you don't need nukes to be a permanent), India (because they have nukes, are large, and are economically advancing), China (ditto), and the European Union (because they claim to be a unified--or unifying--political entity and are large, advanced, and have nukes). Britain and France would have to give up their permanent seats as members of the EU. Unless they opt out of the EU and then they are grandfathered in with their permanent seat.

Then keep 10 rotating seats but assign them to regional entities. Assign all nations to an Americas, African, Middle Eastern, European, Asian, or Pacific region with each region given seats based on population and GDP. Each would have at least one seat assigned to that region and the regions could decide how to fill their allotment.

So we'd have 10 rotating seats chosen by regional blocs, and 6 permanent seats with vetoes, plus perhaps 2 more permanent veto seats if Britain and/or France opt out of the EU. It is my hope that the British will stay out of the EU to keep their seats and the French and Germans will value an opportunity for leading the EU more than having their own permanent seats and so get submerged in the broader European entity.

But this structural change in the Security Council is only one part of the change that must take place for the UN to become a real body for liberty. We have to have open books so the freeloading incompetents who waste money at high salaries can be booted out. We need to make sure that simple things happen like making sure the members of the human rights committee actually respect human rights. There is so much to do and the current body is so biased against the US and freedom and democracy generally that I've read some calling for a body just for democracies. This is understandable. We associate with rank thugs in the UN.

But do we really want a League of Democracies? I think this option would actually be worse than what we have.

Just think, the world's democracies haven't exactly been eager to support us in Iraq. Sure, we do have support from many democracies, but just because we'd be in the company of free countries does not mean they'd support us. And if we were members of a League of Democracies, would we not have a greater obligation to follow the majority even if we don't formally have a majority rules agreement to be a member?

Face it, having thugs and fiends in the UN makes it easier for us to ignore that body when it sides with our enemies and instead gather allies outside the UN to support our objectives. If we gain the support of the UN, that's great; but as things stand now, we do not look too bad as far as I'm concerned when we ignore the UN's farcical moral authority.

So end the fantasy of creating a resolute body of freedom-defending democracies banding together to destroy our common enemies. We can't create that in a formal body. For every Australia, Britain, South Korea, or Netherlands that joins us in Iraq, there is a Spain, Belgium, France, or Germany that will snipe at us, work against us, and look for ways to charge us with crimes. We must live with the democracies as they are and not as we wish them to be.

So stay in the UN. Fire Kofi Annan. Reform the Security Council as I've suggested. Open up the UN books to open audit. Decimate the permanent bureaucracy (I'll settle for firing a tenth). And demand performance in exchange for our money. Heck, only let the performers stay in New York. Open up a satellite office in Kinshasha and send any underperforming bodies to the field office! That will improve effectiveness!

Better the devil we know, I think.




Saturday, December 04, 2004

He Was an Idiot

I'm both amused and appalled about this report. Dutch intelligence set up a fake Maoist group that attracted some Dutch to its call for a Maoist communist victory:

Set up and run by spooks in 1969, his party, the MLPN, had its own newspaper, De Kommunist, written and edited by the secret service. As well as Mr. Boevé playing Chris Petersen, the secretary-general, it had a chairman (another fraud) and a Central Committee stacked with secret agents. To add authenticity, the party let Mr. Wartena and a handful of other true believers join its otherwise nonexistent ranks, telling them that they were part of a network of underground cells. . . .

"I totally wasted 12 years of my life," says Paul Wartena, an ex-MLPN member who was so dedicated to the cause he used to donate 20% of his salary to the fake party. He says he "had some doubts now and then" about the MLPN but stayed loyal because "I was very naive and Mr. Boevé was such a good actor." Now a researcher at a university in Utrecht, Mr. Wartena wants Dutch intelligence to
pay him back for all his donations.

Mr. Boevé, now 74, scoffs at his acolyte: "He was an idiot."

At first I was simply amused at Wartena's actions. He joined a fake group and even contributed 20% of his salary to Dutch intelligence! That is a real hoot. We're used to hearing about "useful idiots" but a "useless idiot" is a welcome change.

But then as I think about it, it is appalling. He considers this episode to be "a waste" of twelve years of his life. So even after the horrors of communism have been revealed, this man regrets that during the twelve years he thought he was a Maoist cell member, he was not. One would hope that in the aftermath of the fall of communism, such a man would heave a sigh of relief that by good fortune he did not spend twelve years helping those murderous thugs. He should be happy that this failure of judgment on his part does not weigh quite so heavily on his conscience. Sure, he should feel guilty for trying to help the communists, but at least he did not. He has not taken this opportunity to reflect on his errors of thought. I guess if the Maoists had won, he'd be all giddy that he was part of the glorious revolution. What an idiot.

And Wartena wants his money back. Good grief, I hope that will never happen. I kind of have a good guess who he'd donate it to now.

But it is still pretty funny.

Friday, December 03, 2004

Girly Islamofascists

Real Clear Politics linked to this article from MEMRI. This part is just amusing as heck:

"You who shirk Jihad: I am saying to you what Ibn Al-Jawzi said to the people of his time: 'Oh people: the millstone of war is turning round and the call for Jihad was made and the gates of heaven have opened. And so, if you are not among the knights of war, then let your women grind the millstone of war and you go and makeup your eyes, you women with beards and turbans!'

Women with beards and turbans? Did the terrorists just call their brethren girly men?

I think recruiting is not going so well for the Islamists. I don't know what their problem is, since we are fully cooperating in turning any hopped-up volunteers who purchase the all-day pass to Jihadworld into martyrs. Who would have thought our Marines and soldiers could be so darned sensitive to an alien culture?

A New Draft?

Winds of Change asks if we need a new draft and asks for opinions. I'm game.

Back in January 2003 I wrote down some thoughts on this. (see "A New Draft?" posted January 1, 2003, in my old Defense Issues archives for the original) In it I assume a draft and look at how it should be structured. I remain opposed to a draft unless we are in a true massive war against a peer competitor (like China). Anyway, this is a modification of the original essay.

I am not terribly sympathetic to the idea of a new draft. Yes, I value my (limited) military experience. There is merit to having people of varying socio-economic groups get their lumps together in the cause of defending America. My own experience is an example-the white Detroit "old man" of the platoon sparring with Frear-the son (or was it nephew) of a Motown star. For the life of me I can no longer remember her name. He had graduated from Brown University. I was a University of Michigan graduate. We each claimed superiority and belittled the other's school. He carried his silver spoon in his mess kit! I liked him, actually. I have to respect someone who had no reason to join, yet still did. A lot of people could benefit from Army Basic Training.

Yet despite these societal advantages, our volunteer military does not need conscripts. We are an information age military and not an industrial age mass production military. Our military does not need massive numbers of cannon fodder. Since proponents of the draft today seem to base their argument on military necessity, this fact alone should end the talk before we even debate the societal pros and cons.

Nor am I persuaded by our war on terror to support conscription for the sole reason of calling on our people for "sacrifice." If even the modest efforts our government has made thus far lead critics to cry "police state!" how would they react to a needless draft? I think we are fortunate to live in an age when going to war does not require us to eat beans and put off all major purchases until after the war because every factory has to produce war material. Why do advocates of sacrifice think we have to mimic World War II conditions in the twenty-first century?

Yet maybe conscription would be a good idea. Oh, not to staff our regular military. Unless we must fight a peer competitor like China (if Chinese power and hostility grow over the decades-neither are guaranteed, however) or anything like that we just don't need masses of infantry for our high tech wars against small powers.

But in a decades-long war on terror, mass conscription could serve valuable purposes. The fact that we do not need conscripts to wage the war actually makes it easier to start universal conscription. If we wanted to use a draft to man our actual fighting military, we would need to take only a small percentage and exemptions would undermine the leveling effect. Making a draft nearly universal is a key to providing the socializing aspect a reality. So how would we use draftees in a Homeland Defense Corps?

We could train medics whose skills are obviously of use in coping with a terror attack even before they are mobilized. Such skills diffused throughout the population would save lives.

We could train security personnel who could augment military police type formations guarding our borders, bases, or civilian infrastructure in their communities during emergencies. This might be a pool of individual reservists available to the military services, state governors, and the Department of Homeland Security.

Recruits would need basic training, some advanced schooling for their skills, and civics education. This should take no more than four or five months. This will hardly be an onerous duty of citizenship. Of course, anybody could volunteer for any of the services as civilians do now for the higher pay and benefits of those services instead of doing the minimum draftee service.

We would train the members in basic squad-level infantry skills so that there is always a pool of troops who may be mobilized for additional training should we need infantry for war or peace operations.

Other skills might also be of use such as vehicle drivers, supply specialists, and other jobs that would allow individuals to fill out active units or augment them for war tasks.

After their initial training, these people would return to civilian life to fulfill their term of service. During their term of Homeland Defense Corps reserve service, we could exploit online or distance learning for refresher training every three months to validate their initial training.

We could require four years duty maximum in the homeland defense reserves. We could limit their mobilization to three months total duty during their term of service unless their was general mobilization for a large war.

Such service members would never rank higher than private first class (E-3). They would always be commanded by somebody from the traditional services. They could also transfer to the traditional services if this taste of military life suited them.

Nor should such service be considered the equivalent of military service for benefits unless the troops are mobilized by a military service. Their pay would also be nominal following initial training. We don't want this easier service to draw away recruits from the traditional services.

Establishing a new draft would mean we would have to gear up the training establishment to crank out graduates at a high rate without interfering with traditional force training. We would need a much larger training establishment so the regular military would have to be expanded just to run this program. I don't know whether basic training should be integrated with those going to the regular services or done separately. Doing it together would build confidence since all serving would know that everybody went through the same tough initial training. Done separately, the military could focus on skills needed and minimize skills that only regulars need. If I had to answer this now, I'd say use the same basic training and have separated follow-up schools for the Homeland Defense Corps focusing on their likely duties.

A draft with these attributes might have merit. It avoids foisting unwilling draftees on the military yet provides citizenship training with reasonable sacrifice and trains our people with actual useful skills should they be needed by the nation. Establishing such a draft-filled Homeland Defense Corps is worth a thought, anyway. And given that many of those calling for a draft are on the left, maybe it will silence those others on their side who bemoan the idea that our military recruiters visit high schools.

But in the end, while I think a Homeland Defense Corps has merit, it should be a voluntary force. We don't need millions inducted every year. And if we induct only those bodies we need, inequities will arise in who is exempted from service. But having some martial way for people to serve in this time of war without joining the active or reserve military services would help to induce people with higher education who have career aspirations yet would like to do something for our country. Although this recruiting pool would likely be sufficiently separate from the pool from which the military draws recruits, the pay (a nominal stipend) and benefits (Life insurance but certainly no college benefits) should be minimal to avoid any impact on the regular services. We won't benefit with a fully staffed Homeland Defense Corps if our military cannot meet recruiting goals. And the benefits to society will be people who, even after they leave the Homeland Defense Corps, retain first aid, weapons, and other basic military skills. They will have a greater understanding of what our military does for the rest of their lives.

for the War on Terror, we should not compel service. But we should provide a useful option that does not interfere with our current outstanding military.

So create a Homeland Defense Corps. But don't draft the members. And certainly don't foist draftees on our splendid military.

Thursday, December 02, 2004

A Larger Army

Many people want the Army to be larger to handle the current and future threats. I have been one of them. Recently, Centcom warned the Iranians:


"To deter a nation state you should never underestimate the air and naval power of the United States," General John Abizaid, the commander of US forces in the Middle East told AFP in a joint interview late Friday.

"Why the Iranians would want to move against us in an overt manner that would cause us to use our air or naval power against them would be beyond me. We have an incredible amount of power," he said.

Abizaid made the comment in response to questions about whether the United States, with the bulk of its ground forces tied down in Iraq, had the means to meet other contingencies such as a conflict with Iran.

If this isn't an admission that we need more troops, what is, right?

This article argues for a bigger, better, and badder Army. Certainly, it is getting better and badder with transformation so the author is really calling for bigger:



As of mid-November, approximately 180,000 reservists and national guardsmen are mobilized, of whom 154,000 are U.S. Army. They supplement an active Army force set by law at 480,000, but "temporarily" expanded to a little over 500,000. In total, then, there are about 650,000 soldiers actively in service.

For reasons that are hard to fathom, there is still a debate in the Pentagon about whether this requirement for ground forces is an Iraq-driven anomaly or a reflection of the "long, hard slog" that is the global war on terror. The answer ought to be obvious. Even if, in the next year, it proves possible to reduce the number of troops in Iraq, the need for larger land forces won't end. It's the nature of this war.

At one time I called for 40,000 more troops to create two new divisions organized as motorized infantry with some armor in support. Later, to get troops into the fight faster, I called for the 40,000 to be organized in 8 separate brigades or even separate battalion to some extent. These could fight under existing divisional flags. With 150,000 Army reservists (Guard or Reserves) on duty above the nominal strength of the active Army, it seems obvious that we need more troops.

But is this solution right? The Army is working to add combat brigades in a manner that undermines the assumption that we need to add more troops to the active army to get more relevant combat units. The military is converting Army jobs to civilian jobs, freeing up slots under the ceiling to add combat troops. Excess units that were once necessary to fight in the Fulda Gap such as separate artillery brigades and air defense units are being converted to units more relevant to today's threats. The result is that we will go from 75 active and reserve combat brigades to perhaps 84 in the relatively near future and maybe 10 or more after that without adding to the active Army personnel ceiling. This is how I'd organize the 84 brigades our Army will soon (within a decade?) deploy.

In addition, the Army is looking at the whole active-reserve mix. A lot of support units absolutely essential to go to war are in the reserves. A lot of these should be active and maybe some of our active combat units should migrate to the reserves while support units migrate to the active component so we don't need 150,000 reservists to fight a low intensity conflict such as Iraq. For example, heavy armor is key in winning, but we defeated Iraq's armed forces with 1 reinforced Army heavy division in the invasion. Half of our active Army battalions are heavy. While we would need lots of armor for a fight with China, do we need so much armor on active duty for smaller opponents? After all, even total mobilization would not bring enough land power for a war against China on the Asian mainland. We should explore moving heavy units to the reserves and infantry and critical support units to the active component.


Further, the Army doesn't want to add troop strength because it fears that it will be saddled with troops that Congress will not pay for once the Iraq campaign winds down. Certainly, I'd hate to argue that we will not win the current fight and so we should enlarge the Army to avoid straining the current Army in this losing fight. Either we will win the war relatively soon and the Army's assumption is right; or, if we aren't going to win soon, is the solution to reinforce failure by doing more of the same by adding more troops? Shouldn't we really be talking strategy and not numbers if we are not winning? For if the strategy is wrong, more troops won't address the basic problem. And I'll say it again, I think we have sufficient troops to win in Iraq. The key is getting Iraqi units into the fight.

But even with an Iraq campaign that will be won in the near future, with a broader war on our hands that will last a long time, shouldn't the Army be larger for future campaigns? I don't know. Perhaps the same argument I've used about Iraq itself applies globally. That is, if we are capable of doing the fighting will we be tempted to do so since our troops are more effective? The key in Iraq is getting Iraqis to fight the enemy with minimal combat help from us. Shouldn't our goal globally be to get allies to fight our enemies with minimal US ground forces? Wouldn't too many US troops available tempt us to just do it ourselves? In the long run, that would be self-defeating since we are not powerful enough to take such a global role for long. Where we can we should send equipment and provide training. If necessary, we can provide air support. When that isn't enough, special forces can fight with our allies to teach them on the job. When that isn't enough, small numbers of US ground forces could help. When we must, we can throw the entire US military arsenal at the enemy. I am decidedly not calling for a strategy of escalation! What I mean is that at the start, we look at what we need to solve a problem and help an ally and then throw in two corps to march on the enemy capital or an aid package (or something in between) right off the bat.

We may need to add more troops to the active Army. But I am willing to hold off on my calls for more troops until I see how the restructuring goes. The military's process for adding combat units has changed my assumptions about how to increase combat power and the number of boots on the ground.


Wednesday, December 01, 2004

Rotation Timing

For a long time, I've noted that if we were planning to do something in Iran in the spring of 2005, we could cover the troop build up with a troop rotation that overlaps troops temporarily to increase our troop strength in Iraq. Even though a straight invasion isn't in the cards because our ground forces are too small, if we are supporting a revolt in Iran we could use a few brigades from Iraq to bolster the Iranian rebels.

And now we have news that the military will extend troops in Iraq and deploy some extra temporarily so we will have extra forces in Iraq in early 2005:


This approved request adds an additional 1,500 active duty soldiers, and extends approximately 10,400 active duty combat forces, which includes 2,300 Marines from the 31st Marine Expeditionary Unit off of the ESSEX Expeditionary Strike Group. This extension is in conjunction with the current force rotation, and will increase the U. S. forces in theater from 17 to 20 brigades, increasing the force size in Iraq to approximately 150,000 personnel during the election period.

Well, that is a three brigade increase. And how long will they be there?


Takes them to the beginning of March to mid-March. And you know, you got to -- you got to spread it out 'cause they call can't come out at once, so it's about that time.


Mid-March, you say? Our Strategic Petroleum Reserve should be filled up by April 1st, I think.

Not that three extra brigades won't be useful for protecting the elections, but three extra brigades could be useful for other purposes, too.

Like regime change in Iran in support of a new Iranian revolution?

Europe is Very Much From Mars

We are told that the problem between America and Europe is that the Europeans have moved beyond force in their European cocoon while America still lives in the real world where force is still a tool.

As I've written before, I don't think that the long bloody history of Europe has been put safely into the past. Democracy is a thin veneer over a deep current of tyranny, war, and a killer instinct. The European Union, I fear, is the start of a new dictatorship that will create a potential enemy in fifty years.

This article argues that the EU is Europe's attempt to get beyond their bloody past:

Europe (particularly in the incarnation of Mr Chirac) does not have a deep commitment to democracy, at least not in the sense that the English-speaking tradition understands it.

The American Constitution may have borrowed much of its frame of reference from French revolutionary ideals, but the historical outcomes parted company pretty quickly. The United States ended up with a federalised system and an iron-clad Bill of Rights while France was descending into the Terror. We do not have a shared reverence for the robustness of democratic institutions because, in continental Europe, democratic institutions have been anything but robust.

That is why the EU is busily moving away from the idea of government being directly and transparently responsive to the popular will.

The monstrous global crimes of the 20th century - the collective guilt which is still the motor force of European political consciousness - were all thought to have been generated (or at least condoned) by popular will.

The political instincts of the people are far too inflammable and mercurial to be trusted. Better leave the serious business of law-making and governance to a professional class of administrators, an enlightened elite who will not be subject to the whims and volatile passions of the mob whose vicissitudes have brought such disgrace on our countries.

Public opinion manipulated by national political leaders has to take the rap for the hideous events of the two world wars and the Cold War that followed them, and so they will all be cut down to size. Democracy is all well and good in its place but the power of the people must be sieved, regulated and heavily supervised if it is to come to the right conclusions.

It may sound apocalyptic, but I do believe that the democratic experiment in continental Europe, begun just over 200 years or so ago, is coming to a close.

The European Union is creating what it hopes will be a benign oligarchy. Real political power will reside once again within elite circles (as it does already in France) which will conduct their business in the corridors rather than in the assemblies.

The EU elites believe that the public led them to slaughter each other again and again? In Europe's long history of warfare, do they really think that too much democracy was at fault? Even if you restrict the case to the 20th century, counting the World Wars and the Cold War, is this analysis correct?

In World War I, only Britain and France of the initial belligerents were democracies. Germans, Russians, and Austro-Hungarians lived under autocracies. While the public enthusiastically answered the leaders' call for war, was this really about the public pushing the leaders to a war they did not want? Hardly. The public, unaccustomed to war after a century of relative European peace, was ready to fight. But it was the leaders who called for war.

In World War II, the aggressors were all militaristic despots. Public opinion in the West did not push the democracies toward war. Opinion delayed war until it was too late to squash the threats in their infancies.

As for the Cold War, a communist dictatorship pressed the West and Western public opinion was barely kept in support of containing the Soviets.

So just where is this rabid public opinion that the elites blame for pushing the poor European elites to war again and again?

It is pure rot, of course. The elites are pretending that the public is bloodthirsty and that only erasing democracy in a smothering European bureaucracy can prevent future bloodshed.

Imagine that, the Europeans looked to their past, noticed that the rulers of Europe often rallied their publics into repeated wars against each other and the rest of the world, and concluded that the key failure in this is their own public that failed to stop the leaders! Never mind that it was the leadership that led Europe to fight. I just want to know how putting an elite that has been prone to war back in complete charge will end European wars? Isn't this recreating the Europe of divine right rulers that created the bloody swath that Europeans cut across the globe?

I sometimes think I am too pessimistic when I have written that in 50 years we could be fighting an EU dictatorship. Reports like this do not make me sleep better at night. When we are pushing freedom and democracy to forestall threats from the Islamic world, Europe goes its own way back toward their violent, aggressive, and unfree past.

Wonderful, eh?

Buh Bye Pillsbury Nuke Boy?

A week ago I noted that the signs from North Korea point to collapse and possibly quite soon. (UPDATE: Actually, I meant to link to this post.)

Strategypage notes that South Korea and China both expect the North to collapse:

North Korea accused the United States of carrying out 190 aerial recon missions against them in November. That would be entirely possible, because the rumors and scraps of information coming out of North Korea indicate that the government is falling apart. There have been more defections of senior North Korean government and military officials lately, and the border with China is more and more wide open to anyone with a little something to bribe the border guards with. For months, China has been moving more troops to their North Korean border. Partly this is to try and control the larger number of people fleeing the north, and to be ready if millions come across when the North Korean government collapses.

"When the North Korean government collapses." I hope we are pushing to help them along the way.

Could we really take care of the last two members of the Axis of Evil in the next four years?

Tuesday, November 30, 2004

National Security Affairs Page is Moving

Beginning December 1, 2004, The Dignified Rant will be partially moving to a new home at blogspot. I'm starting to run out of space at The Dignified Rant on Yahoo! Geocities and I have a lot of things I want to do there. Home Front, Landfill, and List of Annoying Things will remain at the Y!G site, along with archives of national security posts from July 2002 until November 2004. I will keep a National Security Affairs section there for special projects that aren't really blogging. This re-oriented site will be known as "The Dignified Rant: Home Edition." I still have a third of my storage space left and I plan to use it.

For those of you who read the national security posts, I've been dual posting on the new and existing sites since November 26th as a transition aid. Starting December 1st I will blog on national security affairs at the new The Dignified Rant site exclusively. I hope you'll visit both sites in the future.

And please have patience as I fix links on the old site and text to reflect the new mission of The Dignified Rant: Home Edition.

Who Are They Deterring?

I've read some articles that assume Iran will get nuclear weapons and figure that we'll have to live with it. These authors note that Iranian desire for nuclear weapons pre-dates the Islamic Republic and that Iran has reason to want nukes to deter foreign aggression.

Setting aside the easy assumption by these authors that Iran is lying when officials deny they want nukes and that their nuclear programs are for energy and economic reasons only, I want to know just who they are deterring?

America, the so-called Great Satan? Since Iranian nuclear desires go back to the Shah's day, this can't be the nationalistic reason for wanting nuclear weapons. We were friends back then and focused on the Soviet Union. Indeed, our Rapid Deployment Force was conceived of as a means of deterring and defeating if necessary a Soviet invasion of Iran. More on the US later.

Well what about the Soviet Union? True, back in the day they were a threat. But that little implosion of the Soviet Union in 1991 sent that threat to the dustbin of history. The Russian army is a shadow of its former Soviet glories and Russia is rather a distance from Iran now, their border having receded a good distance.

Their hereditary and recent enemy Iraq? Well, we seem to have taken care of that nuclear or chemical threat. And given Iran's much larger size and historical strength, Iran would be far better off rejoining the international community so they can buy better conventional arms. And since Iraq will not be a conventional threat to Iran for a good decade or more (assuming we don't discourage Iraq from fighting Iran), Iran's nuclear path to security from Iraq makes no sense at all.

What about Turkey? No Turkish nukes and their common border is not an invasion route.

Pakistan? Don't they have an "Islamic" bomb? Why would they be a threat?

Afghanistan? Get real. Even with Americans there, this is no threat.

The former Soviet republics to the north? Hahahahaha. Not a threat.

Well what about Israel? Iran and Israel used to be friendly before the Islamic revolution. And Israel isn't in any position to invade Iran nor has Israel used its nuclear advantage to nuke Iran while Iran is helpless. And there is the inconvenient fact that some Iranians spout off about nuking Israel and taking a counter-strike for the Islamic team. That surely isn't a motivation based on deterrence.

I suppose there is Saudi Arabia and the rest of the Gulf States. Please. They are pygmies militarily. Maybe if Riyadh went nuclear one could argue that Shia Iran fears Sunni Saudi Arabia but we aren't there (thank goodness).

So back to America. If we were not a threat to Iran when we were allies and Iran was pursuing nukes and if we never invaded or nuked Iran in the period of mullah hostility while we've maintained a nuclear arsenal sufficient to level Iran without really straining ourselves, why would Iran think we are about to invade and need to be deterred? Could it be that Iranian behavior has changed for the worst and that their crazy rhetoric and support for the vilest of terrorists is prodding us to take action?

So, if Iran was not a threat to us, we would not be hostile to Iran, and Iran could go back to the time when they did not need to deter a friendly America. With this causal relationship established between Iranian hostility to America and support for terrorism, and America's declaration of Iran as a member of the Axis of Evil, what makes more sense, figuring out how we can alter our behavior or how to alter their behavior? Since we certainly have tried to reach agreement with the mullahs ever since President Carter, how likely is it that we can change sufficiently to make Iran think they don't need nukes?

If we can help along a regime change based on real opposition to the mullahs, a new Iran will not see a threat from America and they may well be convinced that they do not need a costly nuclear weapons or energy program. And even if a democratic rational Iran wants nuclear programs, without the hostility of the mullahs to propel them it won't be a terrifying development.

Regime change in Tehran: 2005.

Great Moments in the Blindingly Obvious (Pt. 7)

The headline says it all:
"Iran Says Nuclear Freeze Won't Last Long"

When the Iranians proclaim the obvious why do we believe them at all? When the mullahs quibble over details indicating what they really want, why aren't their intentions to go nuclear clear to even the most senior State Department careerists? Why do some pin such great hopes on negotiating with these people?

The Iranians are simply buying time in order to get nukes and the Europeans are selling—nay, giving—the Iranians the time they need. The question is, will we go along with this program? Is our goal really just to shield ourselves from the blindingly obvious until our satellites detect a flash in the deserts of Iran indicating the Iranians just went nuclear and we can no longer live the life of the blissfully ignorant?

The mullahs want nuclear weapons and we won't like it if they get them.

Monday, November 29, 2004

Europe Wants to be Fooled

Euro-Disney has a long way to go before it rivals the fantasy world the Europeans have constructed to explain away Iran's nuclear behavior. Europe plays pretend games while Iran moves forward with deadly seriousness.

The Europeans continue to pretend to negotiate with the Iranians over Iran's nuclear ambitions and the Iranians don't even have the politeness to go along for more than a few days as Tehran publicly quibbles over the precise terms of the meaningless agreements the Europeans claim Iran has signed.

I've read some who say that all Iranians want nukes so we can't possibly stop them from going nuclear. Since I've argued for regime change to prevent Iran from being a nuclear threat does this mean regime change is pointless? Hardly:

Even if you believe that a nuclear Iran is inevitable, is it not infinitely better to have those atomic bombs in the hands of pro-Western Iranians, chosen by their own people, than in the grip of fanatical theocratic tyrants dedicated to the destruction of the Western satans?

And maybe it isn't inevitable. Faster, please.

You know, I don't worry about France with nuclear weapons. So while I'd prefer it if Iran did not have them, I'd sleep a lot better knowing that reasonable people in Tehran have them. And as Ledeen says, perhaps a nuclear-armed Iran isn't inevitable.

Regime change really is our only way out. Europe's detour into the world of process and pretend solutions does not change that. My only hope is that this Bizarro World dance runs parallel to our own preparations to really deal with the problem and that the pretend negotiations have not sidetracked us from our own action.

Saturday, November 27, 2004

Elections and Security

The Iraqi interim government will proceed with elections on schedule:
"The Iraqi government is determined, as I told you before, to hold elections on time," said Allawi's spokesman, Thair al-Naqeeb. "The Iraqi government led by the prime minister is calling for all spectra of the Iraqi people to participate in the elections and to contribute in the elections to build a strong democratic country."

Good. The idea that the Sunnis will somehow get mad if the elections go forward is absurd! The Sunni clerics are actually calling for a voting boycott to protest the capture of Fallujah! Are they more upset about the loss of the bomb factories or the slaughterhouses? Good grief, what are they going to do if the election goes forward? Start killing their enemies in Iraq? Good God, people, the Sunni Baathists are already mad enough to car bomb and murder and enlist the help of beheading Islamist whackjobs! Just what else would the Sunnis do if they “get mad?”

Hopefully, Prime Minister Allawi can convince the leaders of opposition groups to sell out the fighters and come inside the new Iraq. I don’t mind amnesties for the bulk of the Baathists as long as the worst offenders are exiled, executed, or imprisoned. And no, I don’t know what would constitute “worst” and what would constitute “acceptable:”

Iraq's national security adviser Qassem Daoud stressed on Thursday that there were different levels of Baathists -- a movement that predates the deposed dictator's rule -- and hardline pro-Saddam Iraqis.

Don’t get confused that pacification means killing all our enemies who killed Americans and Iraqis in the past. Pacification means ending the fighting by defeating the enemy. If that means amnesty for some—so be it. They must be roped into the new Iraq securely with penalties for conspiring against the government, but we cannot make them keep fighting by refusing all alternative options. Remember the objective.

The Iraqi government also is right on the money when it says security will only come with Iraqi security units doing the fighting. Iraqi deputy prime minister Barham Salih said:

"British and American troops, whom we admire and respect for their courage and sacrifice, without them we could not have overcome Saddam's regime, at the end of the day cannot establish security fully unless we have indigenous Iraqi forces."

"The Americans and the British cannot build a new Iraq" in the wake of the downfall of Saddam Hussein's dictatorial regime, he said. "You can only support us."

Heck, even the enemy knows that Iraqi security forces are key.
Those here who insist we must pour American troops into Iraq in order to put Americans on every corner to protect the Iraqis will prompt a disastrous result: Iraqis will let Americans fight and die for them. Since most of those calling for more troops are precisely the people who would cry for a withdrawal when the going gets rougher, I find this astounding advice. We blanketed South Vietnam with American troops and killed Viet Cong and North Vietnamese in large numbers. But the South Vietnamese were never allowed to step forward. The US-dominated ground forces in Vietnam smashed the communist Tet Offensive but we saw defeat here at home. Even the successful Vietnamisation program was too late. Even though the South Vietnamese forces did succeed in pacifying the country, US morale at home was too weak to help South Vietnam when North Vietnamese conventional forces conquered South Vietnam.

We are far better off pushing the Iraqis to fight for themselves (including former foes enlisted in the new Iraq—properly de-Baathified, of course) even if they are not as effective in a narrow military sense of kill ratios. It is their country and they must fight. They are fighting now, and we must give them the capacity to do so. I am pleased the Iraqis want to fight and the government sees its duty as such. In the end, we can only support the Iraqis in building a new Iraq.

And speaking of security threats, why is Sadr still walking free?

[Ali Smeisim, al-Sadr's top political adviser,] said the government promised in the August agreement not to pursue members of al-Sadr's movement and to release most of them from detention.

"The government, however started pursuing them and their numbers in prisons have doubled," Smeisim said. "Iraqi police arrested 160 al-Sadr loyalists in Najaf four days ago."

He also accused the government of conspiring with two major Shiite parties, Dawa and the Supreme Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq, to marginalize al-Sadr's movement and prevent its clerics from speaking in mosques.

"No gathering by the al-Sadr trend is allowed to take place at particular mosques," Smeisim said. "They want to drag the movement into a third battle. I call on the movement to show restraint and patience" to avoid "a Shiite-Shiite war."

They of murdering opponents and two uprisings are upset that the government is arresting them rather than thanking them for their civic involvement!

On the other hand, I am glad to read the government is cracking down on these two-time thugs. Don’t let them get strong enough to try a third uprising.

Elections and security seem to be moving forward satisfactorily.

Timing

So when do we go after Iran?

The latest EU-brokered “let’s pretend the Iranians don’t want nukes” deal is supposed to have a three-month period of testing before we look at their compliance. Already the Iranians are haggling over the meaning of the word “is” and related nuclear matters.

I wondered if a Kerry victory in November would prompt us to accelerate an operation to support Iranian rebels in Iran. No need now, so do we go in the spring of 2005? As I noted, our Strategic Petroleum Reserve is supposed to be filled in the spring (April 1st, I think). Assuming our European friends nail down an agreement in the next couple weeks, a three-month probation period puts us to mid-March where we would have the opportunity to declare Iran in violation of their agreements and put plans in motion.

Of course, this assumes the Europeans are at least somewhat on board. It assumes we are preparing to support Iranian rebels with air special forces support and perhaps some conventional units for stiffening. It certainly assumes that there are Iranians ready to put their hostility toward the mullahs into concrete action—particularly Iranian military forces.

I’m assuming a lot here, but an invasion can’t work with what we’ve got available. Air strikes are a last resort since we don’t know for sure what they have now; and after the strikes, they’ll dig deeper to prevent the next strike from working. Deterrence may not work if they think it is their Islamic duty to take one for the team by killing as many of us as they can. And coping with defense by deploying missile defenses around Iran depends on maintaining host country cooperation, deploying enough anti-missiles, and counts on the Iranians not using an old freighter to deliver a nuke to a port or some other way of bypassing the missile route. I think the Europeans are showing that diplomacy will not work.

But I’m also assuming that Iran is on the Axis of Evil for a reason and that we will not close our eyes to the threat just because the task ahead is hard.

I assume we have something in the works to deal with Iran. Since diplomacy, air strikes, invasion, deterrence, and defense won’t work; we must be planning regime change. And since regime change cannot simply impose a new regime, we must be supporting internal forces who will overthrow the unpopular mullahs.

A lot of assumptions on my part, true; but the alternative is to believe that we really are counting on the Europeans to talk their way to our safety.

I'm In Awe or Mad ...

The French are getting away with what we could never do without the Berkeley Women’s Studies Department knitting something in protest … or something equally annoying. The Diplomad (via Instapundit) has the scoop:
With genuine admiration we must say that there is no other country on earth that pursues its core national interests in as determined and ruthless a manner as France. Unlike the USA which has three thousand interests all competing for number one, France has pared down its interests essentially to [promote and pursue French economic and commercial interests above all else and to prevent American hegemony.]

Truly, I am in awe of the focus of France. They blow up a Greenpeace ship and their people shrug. We blow up a murderous dictator’s regime and a quarter of our people are outraged? The Diplomad adds:

Some might say, this is not too dissimilar from traditional US policy in parts of Latin America. Perhaps. But where our admiration for the French really comes in is that they get away with it with nary a whisper of international criticism! In fact, the French loudly condemned our interventions in Grenada and Panama, joining in the anti-US UN debate on those actions, but yet do the same thing themselves (with admittedly less military skill) in Ivory Coast and elsewhere in Africa.

This of course is the part that makes me mad. When the vaunted values of the international community are only focused on us, it is hypocrisy and not idealism.

We need to seriously remold the international community—the UN—to keep from getting the dirty end of the stick every time in international debate.

Friday, November 26, 2004

Ignore Them--Press on

A number of Iraqi political parties are calling for a six-month delay in voting, now scheduled for January 30, 2005.

Ignore them and hold the elections. People can decide to vote—or not—but hold the elections.

The Sunnis are suspect anyway because they hope for American withdrawal and chaos in which they can emerge victorious in a vicious war with the majority, counting on their experience in terror to put them on top once again.

But the Kurds? Aren’t they our friends? Certainly, but remember that for many Kurds a free Iraqi in which they are a minority is considered better than subjugation by a Sunni dictatorship, but not as good as independence. Why take chances of a Shia dictatorship, they may think. So the Kurds voicing this opinion have ulterior motives not in line with our policies, too. They don’t want to alienate America by unilaterally pulling out of elections, but they wouldn’t mind if the blame was spread around and they could say they tried, it failed, and darn it all but we need an independent state.

The article repeats what seems to be the conventional wisdom as divined by the press:

A widespread boycott by the Sunni community could deny the elected parliament and government the legitimacy that U.S. and Iraqi authorities believe is necessary to help bring stability to Iraq and curb the insurgency.

Why would this deny the new government legitimacy? Why would voting by 75% of the population lack legitimacy (let’s assume half the Kurds and Sunnis vote and a small number of Shias boycott)? Why should the desires of a violent minority dictate when or whether Iraq should hold an election? This is preposterous! Why tell the violent thugs that continued violence will cancel the elections? Isn’t this what they want? Don’t the Sunni Baathists fear a democratic Iraq?

I fear that failure to hold elections when the clear majority wants elections will erode legitimacy. Do not let a violent minority and an ambivalent minority put off the elections. For their own reasons, each would like a delay to mean a cancellation—and then they can move on to their real objectives.

Hold the elections. On time. And if some don’t take part? Oh well. This is not one man, one vote, one time. There will be another one and after a few years of contemplating their error, they’ll take part in the second free presidential election in free Iraq.

The Things You Find When You Crush a Sanctuary!

I didn’t have the time to go through the slide show about finds in Fallujah that Winds of Change noted. Luckily, Caerdroia did:

This slide in particular interested me. In one of the IED factories, we found a GPS unit that had clearly been used to guide enemy fighters from Western Syria (a whole other topic in and of itself!) through Iraq to Falluja. The GPS had not had its waypoints cleared (which is how we know where they went). How much do you want to bet that those waypoints are mostly safe houses?

Well, they’re burned now, and that route is under surveillance. Best part is, since there are likely multiple routes, and the enemy doesn’t know which route we’ve burned, they’ll likely keep using them. If not, they have to get a whole new set of safe houses – not trivial in the first place, and particularly not now, with the Iraqi and US troops on the offensive throughout the Sunni Triangle. So we can surveil this route (and others we’ve uncovered) and begin to take apart the networks using it in ways that don’t give away what routes we might have discovered.

I always figured there was a rat line to Syria. When our Marine who tried to defect/was kidnapped (I do tend toward the latter explanation though his Moslem faith may have been used to lure him out by making him think he was going out to help his Moslem brethren in some fashion). I assumed that he might provide some help although if he was blindfolded and sent along a trail in reverse his impressions would be of little tactical help. Still, he might have been able to report how many days the trip took and how many places they stopped, for example.

The GPS unit was a great find. I wonder how far into Syria the waypoints went?

Europe's Pearl Harbor?

Although I’ve been annoyed at European refusal to help us more in Iraq, I’ve noted their help in Afghanistan, some in Iraq, and generally in the law enforcement side of fighting terrorism. I try not to get too upset when even something like a Spanish withdrawal happens because this will be a long war and we need voluntary cooperation. If a nation drops out of one part of the coalition, another may join, and dropouts may rejoin as others tire and scale back. Only we are crucial to the coalition. We cannot fail. Since we are the prime target I don’t think we could scale back much or for very long before being reminded of our critical role.

Besides, in two world wars, we were nearly 3 years tardy in World War I (though as a European struggle it is excusable) and two years tardy in World War II when our excuses for standing aside were less justifiable (although we were militarily weak). We helped where we could and in the end were decisive additions to the Allies in both wars. So we should cut the Europeans a little slack as long as they are net additions to our war effort. At some point, more states may help us more enthusiastically in more areas.

So one has to ask, is the brutal murder of van Gogh Europe’s Pearl Harbor?
This Christmastime could be the moment when Western Europe finally joins our war on terrorism. Anti-Islamist fear and anger from the mouths of the European volk is breaking through the surface calm perpetuated by the elite European appeasers. The assassination and mutilation of Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh by an Islamic fanatic — and the retaliatory firebombings of mosques by ethnic Dutchmen — have forced high European leaders and news outlets to begin to publicly face up to the implications of September 11, 2001 and the migration of Muslims in large and hostile numbers into the heart of Europe.

Europe has great power still and I’ve written that I believe that when the Europeans sense the threat they will respond with ruthlessness that is part of their historical character but which has seemed to be bred out of them in the last 30 years of EUtopian dreams. As the article concludes:

Yes, through the blinding smoke of Iraq and through the endless fuming of M. Chirac, the common people — the timeless volk — of Europe are beginning to see their true enemy — radical Islam. The will to survive and prevail is not yet spent in the hearts of our European cousins. They are late to the battle that is now raging. But they are not too late. The second great anti-fascist Euro-American alliance is now beginning to form on the foundation of our two common democratic peoples. Their spineless governments will follow, and will soon be run by fighting leaders uplifted from the ranks.

We shall see if a slumbering giant has been awakened to the threat it faces.

China Stumbling?

I’ve written before that while China could become a peer rival to us in future decades, either regionally or even globally, this future is not assured. I think Chinese geography with numerous enemies surrounding them would hamper their efforts to become more than a regional power. In addition, I do not think that China must become more powerful. A future of civil war and secession is also possible.

This is what my Jane’s email reports:


IN RECENT months, Foreign Report has issued warnings about the state of the Chinese economy. By all accounts it is enjoying a boom. But there are clear signs that the economy is running into trouble. Protests and disorders are spreading in urban factories and through the rural community.

I’ve been skeptical of China’s economic gains. Not because they are not happening, since I imagine Chinese statistics are better than old Soviet numbers, but because of how those numbers are being racked up. Like the old Soviet Union, China’s economic growth is coming from moving peasants to city factories. And even the most productive peasant turned into the most inefficient factory worker will produce more GDP and bump up national statistics. This is not sustainable. Eventually, established workers must become more efficient for an economy to really take off.

While Chinese collapse is surely preferable to a growing, xenophobic, hostile nuclear-armed China, collapse won’t be a nice trip for anybody. Truly, our foreign policy toward China must be quite the balancing act. Throw in the goal of prodding a prosperous but peaceful and friendly China and you have a China problem that defies easy solutions.