Saturday, June 15, 2013

They Didn't Get the Memo

With all the talk about how Assad is winning, I guess these officers didn't get the victory memo:

As many as 73 Syrian military officers — including seven generals and 20 colonels — have crossed the border with their families "seeking refuge" in Turkey, the country's state-run news agency reported Friday.

The Anadolu Agency said the group — totaling 202 people — arrived in the border town of Reyhanli and were taken to a Turkish refugee camp that houses military officers who have defected from the Syrian army.

That's not the action of people convinced Assad is going to win the war. Generals and colonels usually aren't combat casualties, so personal survival wouldn't be an issue even in a victorious war effort.

People keep saying that Assad is winning the war. I think Assad has seized the initiative of late. But I don't think he can ride that to victory if the rebels keep fighting.

And with America finally weighing in on the war (quite possibly because it has taken us many months to set the logistics for arming and training rebels, and preparing limited direct assets just in case the rebels go south or chemical arsenals become unsecured), there is little reason to believe the majority Sunnis won't keep fighting the small Alawite minority and whatever Christian and Druze allies the Alawites can keep on board.

UPDATE: Ah, here we go:

The CIA is preparing to deliver arms to rebel groups in Syria through clandestine bases in Turkey and Jordan that were expanded over the past year in an effort to establish reliable supply routes into the country for nonlethal material, U.S. officials said.

The bases are expected to begin conveying limited shipments of weapons and ammunition within weeks, officials said[.] ...

“We have relationships today in Syria that we didn’t have six months ago,” Benjamin J. Rhodes, Obama’s deputy national security adviser, said during a White House briefing Friday. The United States is capable of delivering material “not only into the country,” Rhodes said, but “into the right hands.”

It may not be the case that President Obama didn't want to intervene, but that he didn't want to say we would intervene before we could make good on that decision. Good on him if that is the case.

UPDATE: On the question of winning:

Israel's defense minister suggested the pendulum could still swing the other way, despite the capture this month of Qusair, a former rebel stronghold near the Lebanese border.

"Bashar al-Assad's victory in Qusair was not a turning point in the Syrian civil war, and I do not believe that he has the momentum to win," said Moshe Yaalon, who is visiting Washington.

"He controls just 40 percent of the territory in Syria. Hezbollah is involved in the fighting in Syria and has suffered many casualties in the battles, and as far as we know, it is more than 1,000 casualties," Yaalon said in a statement.

"We should be prepared for a long civil war with ups and downs."

Huh. Hezbollah has endured over a thousand casualties already? That's gonna leave a mark.

UPDATE: Oh good grief. I give the president credit for making a decision and maybe he didn't?

What we know then from the administration’s public and on the record statements is this: the White House is going to do more than what it was doing before. But we don’t know if that includes weapons or just more non-lethal aid and equipment because the White House’s point man for strategic communications won’t say—he can’t inventory—what’s being sent. All of the reporting asserting that the administration is sending arms was sourced not to Rhodes’s public remarks but to officials who because they are unnamed have no reason to fear that their credibility is on the line should their information prove inaccurate or false.

I resume pounding my head in frustration against the wall. For 90,000+ casualties we've voted "present" in the Syria War. We still are, it seems.

Beat Assad on the Ground

Syrian rebels are already looking forward to weapons from us. This boost to their morale will help until arms arrive.

The scope and schedule of our arms support is unclear:

Free Syrian Army (FSA) commander Salim Idriss told Reuters on Friday that rebels, who have suffered setbacks at the hands of Assad's forces in recent weeks, urgently needed anti-aircraft and anti-tank missiles, as well as a protective no-fly zone.

"But our friends in United States, they haven't told us yet that they are going to support us with weapons and ammunition," he said after meeting U.S. and European officials in Turkey.

A source in the Middle East familiar with U.S. dealings with the rebels has said planned arms supplies would include automatic weapons, light mortars and rocket-propelled grenades.

Light and heavy machine guns, 23mm anti-aircraft cannons, light mortars, light rockets, anti-tank rockets, and anti-tank mines would be of great help.

I'd hold off on anti-aircraft missiles unless we have ways to limit them in some way to keep them from being diverted to terror uses. For moral and practical reasons we don't want any to shoot down a civilian plane--even one deliberately placed in the line of fire.

Could we put batteries that run out in a couple weeks and can't be replaced? If so, we could risk sending some into rebel hands directly, even deep inside Syria.

Could we send in contractor or friendly special forces teams with anti-aircraft missiles?

Could we limit rebels holding such missiles to Jordanian and Turkish territory under watch by Jordanian or Turkish forces? The short range would severely limit their usefulness but they would at least protect small slices of Syria.

But the best way to help the rebels deal with Syrian air power is to help the rebels put the airfields under threat. Small numbers of truck-mounted (or towed) 120mm mortars would help with that in addition to the lighter rockets and mortars.

I just don't think Syrian air power is as decisive as is being made out to be. Rebels were doing better even when Syrian air power was more active. Rebel reverses have taken place not because air power has become better, but because Assad has more troops for the space he is trying to control.

Assad has abandoned the fight for large parts of Syria and has added tens of thousands of loyal militias and thousands of Hezbollah troops to make up for the loss of infantry in the fight over the last two years. The rebels need weapons to kill that new infantry. The militias are not well trained and the Hezbollah too few to take many casualties and remain effective. Kill them and the air power has nobody to support.

And without enough loyal troops to defend Assad's air bases, the rebels can push mortars and rockets within range of those air bases.

And even limited anti-aircraft missile capabilities (assisted by heavy machine guns and those 23mm systems) as I suggest might make Assad's pilots worried enough about rebel air defenses to fly too high to be effective in bombing missions, or cause the pilots to dump their bomb loads fast without regard to accuracy.

I'm not going to complain about our efforts. Yes, I wish we'd done this a year and a half ago. But I'm relieved President Obama has decided to fight a war whose outcome we have a great interest in. We hoped it would turn out well for us without our help. Now we know that no war is predetermined in its outcome. We can still do a lot going forward to defeat Assad and defeat Iran in Syria, without sending American combat brigades into Syria or American planes over Syria.

UPDATE: Rebels want heavier weapons and they claim they don't have much hope:

"We welcome the decision, but it is a late step. And if they send small arms, how can small arms make a difference?" said Louay al-Mokdad, political and media coordinator for the Free Syria Army. "They should help us with real weapons, antitank and antiaircraft, and with armored vehicles, training and a no-fly zone."

Some rebel leaders expressed doubt that any meaningful support would actually materialize.

"We have honestly lost hope," said Mosab Abu Qutada, a spokesman for the rebel military council in Damascus. "We were promised a lot before, and they never kept their promises."

I'm not aware that we've promised much before. That's been the heart of my complaints.

The rebel quoted brings up something I was going to bring up but didn't--Jordan has some older tanks in storage--Centurions and M-48A5s--whose 105mm guns could take on Syrian armor successfully. Train rebels in Jordan to use them, along with some heavy towed mortars, and rebels would have a potent force to start supporting their light infantry forces to carve out a free zone in the south.

Oh, and in the heavy weapons category, I'd throw in recoilless rifles as a combination anti-tank and light infantry support weapon. Surely we can scrounge up older 90mm or 106mm models that we used to build.

UPDATE: Even if we don't send heavier weapons, our allies in the Gulf will do so now. I forgot that aside in some article I read (in the Washington Post, perhaps). Also, I'm kind of shocked that Cordesman is advocating intervention:

The time has come for the United States to take decisive action in Syria. It cannot do so without running all of the risks that have existed since the crisis began. It cannot control all the arms it sends and some may fall into the hands terrorist and extremists. It cannot control the government that emerges if Bashar al-Assad falls. It cannot be sure that an extreme Sunni Islamist regime will not emerge that will be more of a threat to friendly Arab states and Israel than Assad and make the prospect of a war between Sunnis and Shi'ites/Alewites in the Islamic world even worse. The United States cannot count on winning UN support or Russian tolerance or having the same nations and voices that call for U.S. action today not being critics tomorrow.

But, there are times when the risks of inaction outweigh the very real risks of action. For all the talk of sarin and "redlines," the United States has far greater reasons for action than the scattered use of small amounts of chemical weapons that may have killed 140 people. In fact, the "discovery" that Syria used chemical weapons may well be a political ploy. It seems very like that the administration has had virtually all the same evidence for weeks if not months. The real reasons are the broader humanitarian issues involved and far more urgent U.S. strategic interests.

That's the thing. We have the war we have and not the war we wish we had. Syria is bleeding and our absence hasn't kept it from getting worse, now has it?

Friday, June 14, 2013

Exploitation

Will Hezbollah go all in for Assad and lose more than they can afford to lose?

If all goes well in supporting the rebellion in Syria, at some point Assad and his people will flee Damascus. Perhaps abroad or perhaps to the Alawite home ground to defend a coastal enclave against advancing Sunni Arabs.

At that point, Israeli armor-led forces should probably punch into Lebanon and drive all the way to Baalbek to really gut Hezbollah after they've bled in Syria in defense of Assad.

Science is Not a Popularity Contest

A recent New York Times article I read is the kind of article that really makes me wonder why I'm considered to be on the so-called anti-science side. Let's look, shall we?

Let's start with the temperature record since 1850, which is the starting point for showing that industrialization is causing global warming by the excess introduction of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2067537/2011-set-10th-warmest-record-despite-cooling-effect-La-Nina-weather-system.html

Since 1850, temperatures have generally gone up. Although it was generally flat, with a rise and then decline around 1880, until 1910, there was a rise to the 1940s when there was a decline until the 1970s. then temperatures went up again until a period of about 1998 to the present when temperatures have been flat.

And that variation has taken place with carbon dioxide being added to the atmosphere which the models say will increase air temperatures.

Let's go to the article:

The rise in the surface temperature of earth has been markedly slower over the last 15 years than in the 20 years before that. And that lull in warming has occurred even as greenhouse gases have accumulated in the atmosphere at a record pace.

Note how easy it is to shade the data. A statistically flat period back to 1998 is described as showing surface temperatures rising at a "markedly slower" pace! Flat is markedly slower all right. Is it so hard to say the surface temperatures haven't risen in a decade and a half?

I have no problem admitting that the temperatures rose in that previous 20-year period. I have questions about the validity of the surface temperature stations over time, but at some level temperatures are rising even if we are over-stating the increase from shaded data.

Indeed, since the starting point for showing human-caused global warming has been 1850--the ending point of the Little Ice Age--it would be shocking if temperatures didn't rise even with no human activity at all. Wouldn't it?

But there's an out for this inconvenient "slowdown" (well, zero is much slower, to be fair), apparently:

The slowdown is a bit of a mystery to climate scientists. True, the basic theory that predicts a warming of the planet in response to human emissions does not suggest that warming should be smooth and continuous. To the contrary, in a climate system still dominated by natural variability, there is every reason to think the warming will proceed in fits and starts.

Yes! This is basically the heart of my position hitherto called "denialism"--other factors besides human activity affect the climate. Indeed, with periods of decline and no-change even as carbon dioxide climbs, those factors of natural variability seem to be stronger than human causes, no?

And until now, I've just seen predictions of global warming extending decades into the future with no caveats about plateaus and declines. I welcome this new embrace of natural variability that can be stronger than humanity's impact.

The article goes on to say that anti-global warmers say the recent lack of increased temperatures (the author finally admits this plateau to make this point) proves there is no global warming.

I don't pretend to speak for the entire global "denialist" community, but I'll say that while I accept that carbon dioxide has a theoretical effect on climate (warming it), I do not accept that our contribution is the determining factor in our climate change. If it was, why haven't temperatures increased as carbon dioxide levels have gone up? Obviously, there are other factors involved, and the idea that we should cripple our economy to limit what may not be a very important part of climate change is pure insanity to me. Climate has changed without us and is changing all the time. Why are we so important to this change?

Just because there is a theory that carbon dioxide is causing the rise does not make it so. And now even a pro-global warming article is admitting what had been my "denialist" position all along!

But then the author turns on the anti-global warming claim that temperatures haven't risen with a very unconvincing argument:

Rarely do they mention that most of the warmest years in the historical record have occurred recently. Moreover, their claim depends on careful selection of the starting and ending points. The starting point is almost always 1998, a particularly warm year because of a strong El Niño weather pattern.

Really? In what way does complaining about the starting point of 1998 invalidate the fact that temperatures have not statistically risen since around then? I'm not denying that going back to the 1970s will show an increase from that point to 1998 (or near that year), after all. Why choose those points? Because that's when the temperature vectors changed! Why wouldn't you read the data at the points before and after the late 1990s and the late 1970s to ask what changed?

And if you want complaints about arbitrary starting points, let me remind you that the start of our industrial age used to track carbon dioxide's effects conveniently starts at the point when the Little Ice Age is considered to have ended! All things being equal, of course temperatures will have gone up since then.

And here's a lovely straw man:

We certainly cannot conclude, as some people want to, that carbon dioxide is not actually a greenhouse gas. More than a century of research thoroughly disproves that claim.

Who is denying that CO2 is a greenhouse gas? I'm certainly not. And the sites I read don't deny it. I just wonder--as this author is newly wondering--what is being missed that isn't explaining real world temperatures as opposed to the certainty of the models' predictions?

Could the deep oceans be absorbing the heat that will eventually warm our atmosphere? Could be. Look into it. But until recently, the models simply claimed air temperatures would continue to rise with no caveats that the oceans would absorb the heat. Now that the atmosphere isn't warming, they are looking for ways to explain the real world. I welcome that effort.

And while the article evolves from calling the halt in global warming since 1998 a slower rate of growth in the beginning to calling it a "plateau" (that is, flat) as the article went along, the urge to slant is strong. Remember that decline from the 1940s to 1970s? Look how the author describes it:

Now, here is a crucial piece of background: It turns out we had an earlier plateau in global warming, from roughly the 1950s to the 1970s, and scientists do not fully understand that one either.

Huh, at this point an actual decline in temperatures--so much so that there were discussions of a new Ice Age--is called a plateau! Later the author calls this decline a "lull!" That was a heck of a lull. Why did scientists at the time interpret it as the trend?

Is the author unable to look at a graph and say temperatures declined? After all, the article explains that pollution caused the lack of warming from the 1940s to the 1970s (thanks planet-killing Clean Air Act and EPA!), implying that without that pollution counter-factor, carbon dioxide would have continued to warm the planet.

Is the Earth's atmosphere really dirtier today than in the 1960s and 1970s? Is that really the simple mechanism? Or is the heat sink of the ocean the cause? Why wasn't the ocean carrying out a heat-sink function in the 1980s and 1990s? What about volcanic activity in those decades?

If using a strong El Nino warming year of 1998 is not valid, should we eliminate the cooling years from the volcano effects in those decades, too? When that might extend the period of no statistically significant warming back farther? We really should clear that up.

And if pollution is bad enough to halt global warming the last 15 years, what makes the author believe that temperatures will soon start to go up again? Is China cleaning up their emissions? I see no evidence of that. So why will temperatures resume an upward trend in the absence of a change in the pollution factor? Will the ocean start putting heat into the atmosphere? What's the mechanism for that change?

If this plateau continues (and I have no idea if this is a lull, a plateau, or a trend), the factors that need explaining grow, don't they?

And what about that big hot thing up in the daytime sky that just might have some strange ill-comprehended way of warming our planet? Could variability in the Sun's output have an effect on our climate? Far-fetched, I know. Humor me.

Should we perhaps just give tax credits for large Hummers that cough planet-saving particulates into the air and ban those planet-killing EVs?

I deny that the science is strong enough to justify crippling our economy to reduce the amount of carbon dioxide going into the atmosphere. And the inability of an author in a major fact-checked newspaper to even accurately describe the temperature data without shading it to the pro-warming side discredits them in my eyes. What else they're shading that isn't so easily checked is worrisome.

Why I'm the anti-science one is beyond me.

UPDATE: I welcome this change:

The conversation is no longer solely about how to save the planet by cutting carbon emissions. It's becoming more about how to save ourselves from the warming planet's wild weather. ...

After years of losing the fight against rising global emissions of heat-trapping gases, governments around the world are emphasizing what a U.N. Foundation scientific report calls "managing the unavoidable."

It's called adaptation and it's about as sexy but as necessary as insurance, experts say.

It's also a message that once was taboo among climate activists such as former Vice President Al Gore.

Without crippling our economies in a futile effort to halt global warming that is probably beyond our influence, we'll have more wealth to cope when and where we need to cope.

And coping with weather events is useful at the point of impact whether or not global warming reappears or is generally harmful. So this is good.

I'd like to note that if our weather is increasingly "wild" it isn't because of global warming. Since the global temperature has been flat for fifteen years or so, that can't be a cause and effect, can it?

Personally, I figure our current wild weather is due to short memories, more building on the coasts, and paying attention to weather events more because the media is looking for proof of global warming's impact.

When the global warmers are moving closer to "denialist" positions, I call this progress for science.

UDATE: This is what I'm talking about:

What is far from clear is the influence, if any, from CO2. Its influence must be very small, for it seems easily overwhelmed by natural influences such as the PDO [Pacific Decadal Oscillation] and the three phenomena studied by SteveF. ...

Disentangling the true contribution of CO2 to warming from not only the numerous natural influences but also from the effects of data revisionism is near impossible. We shall have to wait and see. The one fact that is already clear, however, is that the warming rate predicted by the models on whose output the climate scare is founded is proving to be a hefty exaggeration.

The global warming industry has been promoting the simple idea that CO2 is the cause of increased temperatures and that our failure to dramatically reduce CO2 emissions (sadly--or not, for some--tanking our economy in the process) is a crime against humanity justifying those who question the centrality of CO2 as "deniers" with all the guilt baggage that term implies.

UPDATE: How is it scientific to fret that the search for explanations about why the Earth isn't warming as the models said will eliminate the simple explanation for warming that is being utilized to promote policies favored by the Greens?

That's the problem. The science is complex. The policies are simple. And I don't accept that the linkage between the science and the proposed policies has anything to do with science at all.

Get a Freaking Room, Fareed

Oh. My. God. Fareed Zakaria really wants to be appointed to something in President Obama's second term where his ginormous brain can go to work. His latest column's title--I kid you not--is "Hail, President. Well Met". Really.

Zakaria argued that unlike past summits, the recent one between President Obama and President Xi Jinping of China was of substance and not talking points.

Zakaria, who could not find his own buttocks with both hands and a GPS signal, dismisses recent scandals and crises to praise the significance of the California summit:

National Security Adviser Thomas Donilon. He explained to me that the two teams agreed to a format that was a real break with the past: "Usually at meetings like these, each leader brings a set of talking points. This creates a format that highlights problems. This was different: We didn't come in with a set of complaints. The leaders came with ideas about opportunities. It created a completely different discussion and dynamic."

And what did they achieve?

Xi discussed his future internal goals and his slogan "China Dream"--no mention of China leaning forward on disputed borders all around China--and creating new disputes every year.

Obama discussed his first term and hopes for second term goals. One can assume a lengthy discourse on the meanings of "Forward" and "Hope and Change."

Oh, and they discussed the challenges and opportunities of world crises! Metternich, doff your hat, you diplomatic piker.

And they exchanged their biographical backgrounds. The Chinese also busted out the Moutai for toasts. Score!!! As a first date, that's a success, I guess. But a diplomatic achievement?

Notwithstanding his attempt to fluff this president's record, Zakaria even admits nothing much was achieved:

While the purpose of the meeting was to build trust rather than produce a set of results, progress was made on specific issues.

Given the build up of expectations that Zakaria held out, mere trust building seems so pedestrian. But while there were no results in this summit that was a break from the past, there was progress! I can hardly wait! What was the progress, pray tell?

Let's see. China again said their priority is a non-nuclear North Korea. But this time they mean it. Although they are too late to keep North Korea from going nuclear--that ship sailed--in a diplomatic world of child-sex-soliciting ambassadors, I guess the State Department calls this a success (but go easy on the Moutai).

And the other progress?

In the discussions on economics, contentious issues like cyberattacks came up, and each side stood its ground[.]

So China said they wouldn't stop and we said we wanted them to stop--and that counts as manly standing our ground? Good God, this is getting sad. Cyber-war was grouped with economic issues rather than national security so Zakaria could add that we proposed some mutually beneficial energy deals. So it all balanced out.

I did mention that we obviously failed to get China to back off from cyber-warfare on us. So diplomatic progress in no way describes this issue.

Surely there is more to this hail-worthy summit?

Ah, foreign policy. This is where Zakaria pretends to have expertise. China, he says, was "impassioned" about their position on pushing Japan around.

Which means China won't stop trying to intimidate Japan and gain the Senkaku Islands.

Wow. I stand in the shadow of diplomatic giants. Learn me some more, Fareed!

And China stopped complaining about our pivot, he says. Maybe that's because the Chinese finally realized that the spin of the pivot doesn't match facts on the ground (or in the seas). I'd count that a failure. But that's me.

In the end, this meeting is counted as a foreign policy triumph because we established good will with China:

This is mostly rhetoric and atmospherics. "The true test of this summit will be in two or three or five years," Donilon acknowledged, "when this background goodwill has to get translated into specific actions on both sides."

What the Hell. Bonus points since President Obama didn't throw up on Xi, I guess. I'm feeling generous.

Yeah, alleged good will and a buck will get us a cup of coffee in Peking the next crisis. Conveniently, judging this Outreach to the Han World will be put off until after President Obama has left office. So for now sycophants can hail the achievement.

If Zakaria wants a job in the Obama administration, I suggest court jester.

God, two Zakaria brain spasms in one week to address. I'm being punished for something.

UPDATE: Hey, here's some increasingly impassioned talk about Okinawa!

The Chinese government itself has not asserted a claim to Okinawa or the other isles in the Ryukyu chain. But the seminar last month, which included state researchers and retired officers from the senior ranks of the People’s Liberation Army, was the latest act in what seems to be a semiofficial campaign in China to question Japanese rule of the islands.

I'm sure our newly forged good will with China will end this budding misunderstanding.

Slowly Crossing the Red Line

Now we say Assad's chemical weapons use is confirmed. And casualties are going to pass the 100,000 level soon. I assume that at some point President Obama will intervene in the Syrian civil war. But it takes many months to set up the infrastructure to move, command, and supply an intervention force. I suspect that is what we are doing.

I think we could get away with just arms supplies to rebels and humanitarian aid to civilians in areas outside of Assad's control.

I assume we'd help with air defense for Turkey and Jordan with both fighter aircraft and anti-aircraft missiles.

I also assume that Syria will be the new home of the "special forces Olympics" where special forces from us and many of our allies operate to support rebels.

The question is whether we jump in with a no-fly zone or air strikes over Syria.

I assume large numbers of ground forces won't be sent since both Jordan and Turkey have armed forces well capable of taking on Assad's rebellion-weakened army. We would support both with air power, I assume, if needed.

But the question of what ground forces we might send to deal with chemical weapons is up in the air. I've recently read that air attacks could destroy chemical depots--contrary to what I'd read in the recent past--so maybe we wouldn't need much in the way of ground forces. Just sufficient forces in Jordan to protect air bases and headquarters and logistics elements, and provide a rapid reaction force to help special forces if they get in trouble inside Syria.

A reinforced Marine brigade might be the ticket. And maybe a paratrooper brigade and some Rangers flown in as the operation gets under way, plus an Army infantry brigade flown in if we move afloat prepositioned equipment for that brigade to Aqaba.

And President Obama has the justification he's long said he needs:

The United States and its allies have concluded that the government of Bashar al-Assad has used chemical weapons in Syria's protracted civil war, leading President Barack Obama to broaden aid — including military support — to opposition groups.

The intelligence community concluded with "high confidence" that the Assad regime had used chemical weapons — including the nerve agent sarin — "on a small scale against the opposition multiple times in the last year."

I suspect we downplayed the use to buy time to get ready to intervene.

UPDATE: I wrote this last night. This morning, the news is we will send arms to the rebels and are thinking about a limited no-fly zone in the south, based in Jordan:

The United States is considering imposing a no-fly zone in Syria, its first direct military intervention of the two-year-old civil war, Western diplomats said on Friday, after the White House said Syria had crossed a "red line" by using nerve gas.

After months of equivocating, President Barack Obama's administration said on Thursday it would now arm rebels, having obtained proof the Syrian government used chemical weapons against fighters trying to overthrow President Bashar al-Assad.

This news alone will boost the morale of the rebels.

To bypass the UN where Russia would veto a no-fly zone resolution (they won't make the mistake of Libya again), we may create a safe zone within Jordan so we could defend Jordanian air space to protect rebels training and arming inside Jordan before going north:

Citing unnamed U.S. military officials, the Wall Street Journal has reported that the Pentagon has developed a plan to bring the Syrian rebels across the border into Jordan, and then keep the Syrian air assets at bay with a limited no-fly zone.

Strategypage says it will be a bloody summer:

Western governments see increasing aid to the rebels as the least bad choice. The rebels still contain a lot of Islamic terrorist groups, and these outfits make no secret of their desire to continue the fight against Israel and the West in general. Dealing with these terror groups during the fight against the Assads, and after the Assads are defeated, is just a given. Deal with it as you go along and get rid of the Assads first, who are now considered the unequivocal greater evil. In any event the Islamic terror groups are doing what they usually do and making themselves unpopular among the civilians they are allegedly fighting to liberate. The terrorists attempt to impose strict lifestyles and are quick to execute suspected blasphemers or “spies”.

Assad seems to be looking north to Aleppo. If our aid is going to the rebels in the south, what will the northern rebels get? Will Turkey help up there?

While Hezbollah is heading north, too, there just aren't that many and they've already taken some heavy losses at Qusayr. I wonder how many battles they have in them.

And we'll see how those new pro-Assad militias hold up under heavier combat with rebels who will be better armed--and may have other help.

Happy Birthday!

The Army is 238 years old today.

I'll have to hoist a beer in its honor later tonight.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Friends and Family

The "Vast Right Wing Conspiracy" that Hillary Clinton imagined had more substantial links to Kevin Bacon than to each other. Now this is a vast conspiracy way of life:

Let's start by going through the Post's article to create a list of journalists married to or closely related to officials within the Obama administration. The size and scope of this is bad enough. But what is most troubling is how high up this incest occurs in the worlds of both the media and the Obama administration[.]

It's a wonder the administration could find any journalists worthy of investigating and intimidating, to tell the truth.

UPDATE: Thanks to Pseudo-Polymath for the link.

Mursi's Precious Bodily Fluids

Egypt's military threats against Ethiopia over the latter's dam-building plans on the Nile are so ridiculous that it is pointless to even discuss the distances involved and the available forces.

Egypt should take what Ethiopia offers because if Egypt refuses Ethiopian offers Egypt has no military option to stop Ethiopia from building dams on the Nile.

Even if you could imagine some successful way to blow up dams in Ethiopia, what would Egypt do if Ethiopia simply fouled the waters of the Nile to make what reaches Egypt less than worthless to Egyptians? Ethiopia might even get Sudan's cooperation to move the point of poisoning further north.

I mean, if it is total war over water that Egypt wants, Ethiopia has the upper hand, gravity-wise.

UPDATE: Again, Egypt's military options are extremely limited. And it seems unlikely that Sudan would help Egypt.

Promotion

Elementary school is almost behind us.


Lamb was selected as one of five students to give a speech at the promotion ceremony at school.

Why, yes, she is my daughter! I am very proud of her poise and confidence.

Isn't This Our Cherished Shared Suffering?

I still don't see the weight of evidence tipping the NSA revelations into scandal territory. If you want scandal, look at the IRS, Benghazi, Fast and Furious, HHS private fundraising, or reporter investigations. There are others out there that I haven't followed, too. Otherwise, isn't this burden the shared suffering so many long for in the war effort?

The idea that we are like China over the collection of information about wire communications is ridiculous. It is the difference between a program to control your own people (China) and one to keep terrorists from killing us (America).

And the government is revealing some success:

The head of the National Security Agency said on Wednesday that extensive U.S. surveillance efforts had helped stop "dozens" of possible attacks, and warned that making details of the top-secret programs public had compromised national security.

Now, given the IRS and Fast and Furious episodes in particular, I think it is legitimate to worry about whether the NSA program could be abused. So proper oversight is a good point of debate. And I'd like to see the data erased after some reasonable amount of time.

But the program itself seems proper and reasonable. Unless something else comes out, I lean toward giving the Obama administration a break on this.

As an aside, I find it amusing that so many who lament that more Americans aren't suffering from the effects of being at war are so upset about suffering the loss of meta-data as a shared burden of the war effort. It's like they define "suffering" only as increasing taxes to fund non-war related things.

Of course, given that this program is obviously a wartime compromise with our ideals of privacy, I'd appreciate it if the government acted like we're at war and tried to defeat the jihadis so we can scale back the NSA program at some point when the tide of war really does recede.

UPDATE: This is about right (tip to Instapundit):

The case for the National Security Agency's gathering of metadata is: America is threatened not by a nation but by a network, dispersed and largely invisible until made visible by connecting dots. The network cannot help but leave, as we all do daily, a digital trail of cellphone, credit card and Internet uses. The dots are in such data; algorithms connect them. The technological gathering of 300 billion bits of data is less menacing than the gathering of 300 by bureaucrats. Mass gatherings by the executive branch twice receive judicial scrutiny, once concerning phone and Internet usages, another concerning the content of messages.

The case against the NSA is: Lois Lerner and others of her ilk.

I want to trust my government enough to let the NSA protect us. But our government isn't making it easy for me to do so.

UPDATE: Well, the suffering wasn't universal. Thank goodness there are some sanctuaries safe from governmental interest. Tip to Instapundit.

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

God Help Us if Zakaria Has Influence in the White House

If Fareed Zakaria thinks we should not intervene in Syria, I'm tempted to think we should send in 3rd Army right now.

The idea that someone might swoon over Zakaria's analysis of Syria is just depressing. The man couldn't find his own buttocks with both hands and a GPS signal, I say. Yet he says we should not intervene in Syria as Zakaria strokes the wisdom of President Obama for staying out (does Zakaria still hope for a position in the second term of the administration?).

We don't have to "own" Syria if we intervene. I don't think we need to impose a no-fly zone or otherwise strike Syrian targets, let alone send in ground troops. Our intervention can consist of sending arms to rebels, humanitarian aid to Syrians outside of Assad's control, and pressure to get Assad to go into exile so that even an Alawite mini-state might evolve away from alliance with Iran.

The idea that attempting to influence events to our favor and against Iran means we own the outcome is just ridiculous.

Because you know what Zakaria's analysis going back to the post-Ottoman Empire settling of borders and minority regimes in the region fails to mention? Iran.

Zakaria completely ignores Iran's interests and actions right now in Syria, perhaps eating up time on the video with his absolutely fascinating discussion of minority regimes. We have an interest in giving our enemy Iran a bloody nose and reducing their influence in the region by destroying the Assad regime, which achieves a bank shot of also weakening Hezbollah and Hamas.

Freaking idiot. I guess I picked a bad day to stop sniffing glue.

UPDATE: I didn't think Syria was a simple case of the Alawites being put in charge after World War I. My memory was that it was far more recent. Alawite domination was a more nuanced process than Zakaria makes it out.

And now that I think about it, Lebanon wasn't a case of Christians being put in control of the entire country, but a confessional system that reserved power to religious groups. The problem was that Christian demographics shrank while their share of power didn't, thus making maintenance the system less acceptable.

Why Zakaria has any fans is beyond me.

UPDATE: Humanitarian help for the rebels will be easier:

The United States on Wednesday eased restrictions on exports to opposition-held areas in Syria to help rebuild shattered infrastructure in a move U.S. officials said will help facilitate oil sales from rebel-controlled areas.

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry signed a limited waiver of the Syria Accountability Act, allowing companies to apply for export license for such things as software, technology, water purification, food and agricultural equipment, and construction materials to opposition-held areas.

Now we just need to arm rebels and provide Secretary Kerry with a brain. And a spine.

Models are Not Data

And the data shows the models are wrong:


Is there any warming not explained by the end of the Little Ice Age in 1850?

Certainly, the model emphasis on CO2 just isn't working to explain the observed data. We need to stop treating model projections as data.

Does High-Low Have to Mean Big-Small?

I'm willing to give the Littoral Combat Ship time to work out the normal kinks of a new type of ship. We do need a cheaper ship to provide numbers, but the LCS isn't anywhere cheap enough to be a brown water combatant and is too expensive for green waters, too.

I'm in favor of a high-low (in cost and capabilities) mix of ships so we have the numbers to afford losses. Otherwise, we won't commit any of our fewer high value surface ships to dangerous environments. But I was overly optimistic 8 years ago in thinking the LCS would be cheap enough for a true "low" part of the mix.

I concede the caveat that as a naval power whose ships have to travel long distances to reach patrol stations (some countries enter their patrol zone the moment they clear the harbor entrance), that we do need ships of some minimum size to be seaworthy enough just to travel to their destination. That may doom any efforts to field a globally mobile inexpensive combatant--although the Perry class frigates seemed to work out.

Unless we permanently base some truly small combatants overseas, some tonnage minimum will constrain a high-low mix differences.

Of course, I think Modularized Auxiliary Cruisers could have a role in providing numbers or a surge capacity in times of need. A high-low mix doesn't necessarily have to be the same as big-small, eh?

Going to War with the NATO We Have

NATO is worried about insufficient military capacity. At this point, I just hope NATO can be the dominant force within a thousand miles of a NATO border and if NATO could provide tribal auxiliaries to our division headquarters leading an intervention.

NATO is a vast headquarters with few non-American troops that are combat ready. I was recently horrified to see that Germany's ground forces are down to two division-sized units plus special forces and airborne elements, totaling fewer than 60,000 troops. I hadn't realized how far they'd fallen. And everyone else is cutting back.

So this won't have much of an effect:

NATO’s chief is worried that the alliance lacks military readiness in crucial areas and is urging European members to do more, Germany’s Spiegel news weekly reported Sunday, citing an internal document.

Europe could start by eliminating their ambitions to have an EU military force separate from NATO. After that, I just want Europe to be able to defend themselves, be capable of handling problems within a thousand miles of their border, and be able to contribute small contingents of air, naval, and especially ground forces trained and equipped to operate under one of our headquarters for more distant missions:

Could we convince our European allies to simply abandon their militaries above the brigade or squadron level and ask them to organize and equip ground battalions and brigades that plug into our brigades and divisions, with our higher level units taking care of logistics and command? Could the Europeans send squadrons to fight as part of our air wings, which we move and support logistically? And plug individual ships into our task forces that we supply on the move?

NATO isn't going to reverse course, regain military capabilities by spending more, and become the NATO we'd like to have. Asking them to do so will just alienate them. It would be far better to persuade them to spend whatever they want to spend on defense but in a manner that allows them to have some high quality capabilities that can be volunteered for a coalition of the willing led by America. I've always preferred help, however limited, willingly given than more capabilities drafted from resentful allies.

Face it, the Libya War was the apex of "leading from behind" by relying on Europe.

The Worst Anti-Tank Weapon, Ever

While this is a good description of the development of armed UAVs, the idea that they could have been a tool to stop Soviet armored vehicles is now clearly wrong:

While its original purpose was to bust up Soviet tanks in the first volleys of World War III, it has evolved into the favored technology for targeted assassinations in the global war on terror. ...

In the previous few years, the U.S. military had developed a number of “precision-guided munitions”—products of the microprocessor revolution—that could land within a few meters of a target. Wohlstetter proposed putting the munitions on Foster’s pilotless planes and using them to hit targets deep behind enemy lines—Soviet tank echelons, air bases, ports.

Nice idea but it would not have worked. Mind you, they turned out to be great for counter-insurgencies. Now that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are being ended as far as our participation is concerned, we find that the drones so useful in those campaigns aren't useful in high-intensity conventional combat.

The reason the drones worked in counter-insurgency is that they combined persistent surveillance with precision and low-yield explosives. We could identify and kill targets without less chance of collateral damage either from killing a civilian instead of an actual target or also killing nearby non-targets. And the enemy lacked the ability to shoot them down.

In a conventional war, long-range missiles and strike missions with conventional aircraft (and the secret F-117 which was actually a light bomber) are far more likely to survive to launch weapons at deep targets than sputtering drones that every anti-aircraft weapon could shoot at--and the Soviets had lots of automatic weapons suitable for that mission. I'm relieved we never had to rely on armed drones to stop a Soviet armored invasion of West Germany. And we certainly won't be using slow drones against any other conventional foe with any expectation that they'd survive use.

Mind you, I've been of two minds about the drone campaign. I don't find them uniquely awful weapons, so they should be used like any other weapon to achieve our objectives. But I also worried early on that their use might not achieve enough to make up for provoking anger at air strikes in Pakistan.

I've been pleasantly surprised that a backlash has taken so long to develop. But if it is developing (and isn't just Taliban information operations), we should consider restraining their use since using the weapon is a means and not an end. Petraeus was absolutely right when he wrote:

Retired general David Petraeus, in his 2006 U.S. Army field manual on counterinsurgency, made a similar point: “An operation that kills five insurgents is counterproductive if collateral damage leads to the recruitment of 50 more insurgents.”

Even so, as Petraeus noted, sometimes a commander has to fire the weapon regardless of the possible backlash; sometimes the target is too important, the threat too dangerous, to pass by.

If using drones to kill is ineffective--or worse, counter-productive--it's time to put them away. If I trusted the administration more on matters of national defense, it would be easier to believe we've reached that tipping point. As it is, I'll always wonder if we are simply responding to left-wing drivel about how evil drones are.

Oh, and don't send them against conventional ground units, of course.

Being There

Seriously, it's not like his pants creases are any less crisp.

UPDATE: Regarding that crease.

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

No Endless War

When faced with jihadi murderers, our strategy choices were going on offense to destroy jihadis and drain the swamps of governments and societies that incubate jihadis; and bolstering our defenses to stop jihadis from hitting us at home. An intrusive government that must sift everything we do to find jihadis here is the logical consequence of declaring the war on terror over.

This is a good summation of our options to avoid being killed by jihadis:

At the risk of over-simplifying, assuming we are not suicidal or (entirely) foolish, our methods of self-defense can be offensive in nature, defensive in nature, or a mixture of both. The PATRIOT Act is primarily defensive. It creates the legal mechanisms for greater intelligence-gathering and information-sharing that allows law enforcement to react more quickly to emerging domestic threats. It was specifically designed to close many of the legal holes in our defense that helped ennable the 9/11 hijackers. The Afghanistan invasion was offensive, designed to destroy the terrorist infrastructure, kill terrorists, and create a nation-state that would be an effective ally going forward. The Iraq invasion was similarily offensive, destroying a terrorist-supporting enemy regime, defeating the follow-on insurgency, then (at least by design) leaving behind a successful, democratic ally that could do military and ideological battle against jihadism in the heart of the Middle East.

The offensive strategy at least had the potential to render the comprehensive defense less and less necessary. After all, if jihadists were defeated and discredited, stripped of financial support, and decimated in the field, then they would have less capability to mount attacks against the United States.

I accepted the defensive nature of the war we were in as a complement to offensive action.

But I have always argued that we have to have a sense of urgency about going on offense so that our defensive measures didn't ratchet up controls on us and erode our civil liberties over time. I noted it 2-1/2 years ago, as well:

I've said it before (noting here a March 2003 post on my original site on the issue) and I'll say it again, our civil liberties depend on destroying our enemies on offense overseas (using military and non-military means) where the Islamists fight us and draw their justification and recruits. Sitting on defense, focusing on homeland defense inside our country just means our civil liberties will erode a little more every time the enemy hits us at home as we ratchet up defenses to cope with the last attack or attempted attack.

Fighting the Islamo-fascists isn't curtailing our civil liberties--failing to defeat them is doing that.

So the NSA revelations merely show what we must do--for the rest of time--when we declare the war is over while jihadis still try to kill us.

I know, I know, the Cairo Outreach was supposed to be the first step in convincing the jihadis that we aren't so bad. But that isn't working out.

I don't want an endless war. But I kind of assumed we'd try to win it rather than just deeming the war over while putting the screws to our own people as the superior alternative to killing jihadis; destroying or neutralizing governments that arm, encourage, and support terrorists; and supporting change in the Islamic world to move towards modernity and rule of law.

Still Not Bush, Of Course

Our president said he'd restore our reputation abroad.

Most recently, he spied on the citizens of  the international community and their businesses with the NSA, embarrassing allied governments and angering their people.

But let's not forget past smart diplomacy!

He brushed off the British--who fought and bled with us in Iraq and Afghanistan--and implies the Falklands just might be Argentina's property.

He frightened Eastern Europeans by bailing out on a planned missile defense system on the anniversary of the day the Soviet Union invaded Poland in 1939.

He escalated the war in Afghanistan.

He escalated drone strikes around the Middle East.

He violated Pakistani neutrality to kill a man revered in significant parts of the Moslem world in Abbottabad, and then dumped the body like a bundle of chum into the ocean.

He tricked the United Nations into granting authorization for a no-fly zone over Libya that he twisted into a bombing campaign (without Congressional authorization) aimed at regime change.

He keeps alleged Moslem terrorists indefinitely in Guantanamo Bay detention facility.

He wages cyber-war on a member of the United Nations.

He even bombed the moon. (Remember that one?)

I can't even say I'm against all of these things, in part or in whole (although the bombing the moon thing was a bit much). But does our president believe that he is uniquely able to do what he wants and enjoy the applause of foreigners regardless, simply because he isn't George W. Bush?

Hey, rubes? How'd that bestowing the Nobel Peace Prize on President Obama work to "encourage his initiatives to reduce nuclear arms, ease tensions with the Muslim world and stress diplomacy and cooperation rather than unilateralism?"

Lock and Load

We are cleared for action in the cyber realm, it seems:

The US Defense Department has been given a bright green light to draw up a global cyberattack target list at which it can deploy digital weapons with “little or no warning to the adversary or the target,” according to a Top Secret policy document leaked to the press.

The policy document, dubbed “Presidential Policy Directive 20” or PPD-20, is an 18-page cyberpolicy roadmap for the Pentagon that directs it to get on with the business of defending the US and its critical infrastructure, such as the power grid and financial sector, from foreign cyberattack.

I guess President Obama didn't get a satisfactory response from China's leader when the two met in California this week and the president brought the issue up.

We'll see if we are as good as I hope we can be.

Although it might take an e-Lusitania incident to awake the sleeping giant.

Obama 43.2

I'm still undecided on the NSA data collection effort.

While I'm prepared to believe the NSA data collection effort is either too broad or has been abused by this administration which doesn't seem to have a natural inclination against abuse of power, I've yet to see that evidence.

But I can't admire the leaker who seems to have harmed our security by the means of addressing his concerns.

As an aside to Peters' complaints in that article, I don't think a blanket condemnation of contractors for either intelligence or the military is justified. We need them and in the long run they are cheaper since they are hired based on needs of the moment and won't be collecting pensions for decades after their service.

[UPDATE: I meant to mention that if civil servants are so much more secure than contractors, explain PFC Manning who is under the UCMJ.]

And it is just a little funny that the leaker's actions are called Holy Dissent "treason" by Senator Feinstein:

“I don't look at this as being a whistleblower. I think it's an act of treason,” the chairwoman of the Senate Intelligence Committee told reporters.

From the Left's point of view, it's like George W. Bush is on his fourth term--complete with accusations of treason for revealing government secrets.

More will come out, I'm sure. For better or worse.

The Middle of Everywhere

Azerbaijan could use a little American attention.

Right now we seem to subcontract support for Azerbaijan through Israel. It would be nice if we could be a little more direct given its vital geographic location.

Measuring the Spin of Our Pivot

I've said that our pivot to the Pacific is more style than substance and that the actual amount of forces being focused on the Pacific is fairly small. Further, defense spending cutbacks might leave us with less in the Pacific post-pivot than we had before. Amazingly, the Brookings Institution has my back on this assessment:

In round numbers, the rebalancing may be in the process of swinging $10 billion to $12 billion or a bit more in annual Pentagon expenditures to the Asia-Pacific region.

Mind you, the flourish of highlighting our pivot combined with what should be a no-brainer on getting our Air Force and Navy fighting jointly in the Pacific (Air-Sea Battle) does serve a useful purpose of convincing our allies and neutrals that we won't be pushed out of the western Pacific by China.

So I don't dismiss the pivot. But let's not fool ourselves about what the pivot means in concrete terms.

Monday, June 10, 2013

Embrace the Revolution

Venezuela is a basket case. We should thank Venezuelans for subsidizing oil to our poor.

Venezuela has shockingly not prospered under the lunacy-tinged idiocy that socialism already represents (tip to Instapundit):

Despite some of the largest oil reserves on the planet and freedom from a US embargo like the one that beset Cuba, it turns out that Venezuela is an equally sad example of what a socialist paradise looks like. Food, medicine, toilet paper, and dollars are either impossible to find or priced out of anyone’s ability to afford them. Growth in this year’s first quarter clocked in at less than a percentage point, with GDP expected to contract by one percent at year’s end. Year after year, a vicious cycle spawned by a labyrinth of price and currency controls cuts off the oxygen supply to Venezuela’s import-dependent economy and ends up making goods more scarce and inflation more severe.

Venezuela still ships to subsidized oil to us, so I still think the best thing we could do to undermine Venezuela's nutball rulers would be to publicly thank them for helping us out:

I think we should take out full page advertisements in Venezuela thanking Chavez for selling Americans cheap oil. Have pictures of smiling Americans standing in front of their homes (with a car in the garage and the air conditioning unit clearly visible) thanking the people of Venezuela.

I think Venezuelans would be happy to know that even if they suffer under Chavez's idiotic economic theories that Americans benefit. Socialism only works with other people's money and Americans are benefiting from Venezuelan money.

A Problem--But What Exactly is the Problem?

While much seems to being made of the fact that the NSA leaker was not even a high school grad and that use of contractors for computer security work is a problem, my understanding of the situation is that we have no choice but to hire these people and hire them this way.

Sure, this seems like a problem:

Snowden was among tens of thousands of private intelligence contractors hired in the unprecedented push to “connect the dots” after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. They work side by side with civil servants as analysts, technical support specialists and mission managers. An unknown number have access to secret and top-secret material.

But when there are limitations on what our intelligence can do yet unlimited expectations of success, what are we supposed to do but hire contractors?

As for the computer people, the very best often have personal backgrounds that get in the way of traditional security clearance checks that we require for government employees. Sure, your basic Ivy League graduate in political science would have no problem passing a security background check, but that grad would be a useless asset for cyber-war or computer technology. So contractors have more flexibility to meet government needs.

That's my understanding of the dilemma we have.

The laws are the laws. But the expectations of security don't make allowances for limitations in the laws. So there you go.

I'd expect Strategypage to address this soon. I believe my memory of understanding comes from old posts of theirs, after all.

Stepping Stone to Oblivion

While I disagree that a single weapon system is a game changer for Syria (the S-300 Russian anti-aircraft missiles) or that it was a waste of money to fight the Iraq War or build missile defenses, I do think we may need to consider a negotiated settlement that lets Assad rule the Alawite core of Syria.

Assad has already lost much of Syria, making his concession of that a mere formality. And if we really want to stop the slaughter, this might be the way to go:

[The] US should back the partition of Syria into a Sunni majority state and an Alawite rump state in the northwestern quadrant of the country, where the Russian navy station happens to be located. The Kurds should get autonomy, just like their Iraqi compatriots.

He adds getting our Sunni Arab friends to purge the rebels of jihadis and attacking Iran's nuclear facilities and other key pillars of the regime.

I've mentioned it myself:

We'd need to give the Alawites and their Christian allies a province they demographically dominate on the coast and mountains of western Syria; the Kurds would get a province in the northeast; and the Sunni Arabs would get the rest.

Damascus would be a federal enclave.

Power would be devolved to the provinces, including foreign affairs excepting some symbolic aspects reserved to the mostly nominal federal government. Assad could become president of the Alawite province and carry on as he has.

The Kurds and Sunni Arabs would get their own provinces. Perhaps the Sunni Arabs get multiple provinces based on existing provinces or groupings of them. The various rebel factions could be bought off with control of these provinces.

Multiple Sunni Arab semi-autonomous states would allow a pro-Jordan entity near Israel and Jordan.

And perhaps add a provision for a referendum on keeping Syria whole or allowing provinces to declare independence after a decade and after talks to divide up assets and debts.

Talks two years ago would have kept Assad in control of Syria. Now talks would ratify Assad's loss of most of Syria.

I'd add working to remove Assad from power in his rump regime, so that a Rump Alawite realm is just a stepping stone to total defeat for Assad.

Round Two?

I guess we need to put Algeria on Arab Spring Watch.

People unhappy with the government, a comatose president and frozen government, and Islamists regaining credibility don't paint a good picture for continued quiet.

Heck, it's been a decade since that decade-long civil war raged in Algeria. Maybe everybody is tanned, rested, and ready to rumble.

Is Map Reading a Lost Art?

Assad's capture of Qusayr does not open up Assad's line of communication between Damascus and the coast. I just heard this claimed on the news, and since it isn't the first time I've heard it, I want to address it by the simple expedient of showing a map.

Please note the road network (yellow lines are highways, red lines are main roads, and faint pink lines are secondary roads):


I've expanded the map to make it clear. Al Qusayr does not lie on the main highway between Damascus and points north or the coastal region. Rebels already in Homs (Hims) haven't cut the line of communication even with rebels controlling Qusayr. Controlling Qusayr does not open the line of communication. Period.

What the capture of Qusayr does is make it more difficult for rebels to resupply Homs from Lebanon through Qusayr. But there is no reason for the loss of Qusayr to cut off that supply route. It is going to be more difficult, it is true. But it will not be impossible to continue supplying rebels in the Homs area.

Heck, give the rebels time and they can reinfiltrate Qusayr.

Qusayr was an Assad victory. It was not a turning point in the war.

UPDATE: Even Charles Krauthammer is in need of an atlas:

Last Wednesday, Qusair fell to the Bashar al-Assad regime in Syria. Qusair is a strategic town that connects Damascus with Assad’s Alawite heartland on the Mediterranean, with its ports and Russian naval base. It’s a major strategic shift. Assad’s forces can now advance on rebel-dominated areas in central and northern Syria, including Aleppo.

Once more with feeling, Qusayr is not a link between Damascus and the Alawite heartland. And no, the capture of Qusayr does not make rebel areas newly vulnerable to attack. Assad was free to advance on those named areas at any time in the last couple years--and he has.

Assad won a victory a Qusayr. For now. And the rebels should be able to recover from the loss.

I couldn't even bear to read the rest of the article after that lead off paragraph. And I respect the man ...

The Need to Know

While close to 5 million Americans have a security clearance, I think that number over-states the problem.

Mind you, I imagine we do over-classify information and there probably are too many top secret clearances out there reflecting that too much information is classified at a level requiring that clearance. But this is the apparent breakdown:

Most, but far from all, security clearances are held by government workers. They hold 2,757,33 "confidential/secret" clearances and 791,200 clearances designated as "top secret." Contractors claim 582,524 "confidential" clearances and 483,263 "top-secret" ones. There is another general category of people who hold 167,925 "confidential/secret" clearances and 135,506 top-secret.

Confidential/secret is pretty low level. I had a "secret" clearance when I was in the Army National Guard simply because I handled some advanced and expensive signals/encryption equipment. All it meant was that I didn't have a police record. I'm not sure how much easier the standard for just "confidential" would be.

So I wouldn't count confidential or secret as part of the problem. Are 1.6 top secret clearances too much? That does seem like a lot. Maybe if Congress set a ceiling for top secret clearances of 0.2% of our total population, the threat of over-work would lead to an easing of what is classified as top secret.

One-Front War?

I hope that Prime Minister Maliki's visit to the Kurdish region of Iraq is an effort to pursue peaceful options to resolve all divisions within Iraq. I fear Maliki just wants to make sure the Kurdish front is quiet while he deals with the Sunni Arabs.

Maliki met with regional president Massoud Barzani in the Kurdish north:

Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki's visit to Irbil — the first in the Kurdish regional capital since the 2003 U.S.-led invasion that toppled Saddam Hussein — was to hold a Cabinet meeting as part of an initiative started last year to better understand provincial-level needs.

I'm guessing Maliki just doesn't want a two-front war if he confronts the Sunni Arabs. Without active Kurdish support, the Sunni Arabs don't have a chance in a full-blown sectarian clash.

Hopefully, the Sunni Arabs stop provoking the Shias who are fully capable of expelling the Sunni Arabs into neighboring states. Sunni Arabs may not like the current situation, but struggling within the political system of a new Iraq where Shia numerical superiority gives them dominance is still their best bet to survive and thrive.

Now They Run?

During the so-called Bushtatorship, left wingers said they'd flee America for better civil liberties abroad. Today, the NSA leaker fled to China for safety. This hope and change stuff isn't what it is cracked up to be, is it?

UPDATE: Okay, since the leaker attempted to serve in Iraq by enlisting in the Army (but was discharged after breaking his legs in training), it isn't fair to assume the man is on the left. I just assumed based on his talking to a left-wing British paper.

Worthy of Further Study

People are undoubtedly putting carbon dioxide into the air. How sure are we that this is bad?

Plants seem to like more CO2 (tip to Mad Minerva):

Scientists have long suspected that a flourishing of green foliage around the globe, observed since the early 1980s in satellite data, springs at least in part from the increasing concentration of carbon dioxide in Earth’s atmosphere. Now, a study of arid regions around the globe finds that a carbon dioxide “fertilization effect” has, indeed, caused a gradual greening from 1982 to 2010.

Increased CO2 hasn't increased temperatures the last 16 years (or from the 1940s to 1970s), so that cause-and-effect doesn't seem as solid as we're to believe. But more foliage is actual data, isn't it?

So in addition to wanting to know just what is the ideal temperature (if we're to move heaven and earth to maintain some temperature, shouldn't we have a scientific basis for defending that number?), I now want to know what the ideal CO2 level is.

Let's not be chrono-centric. Shouldn't science establish those answers first before we sacrifice personal freedoms and economic progress to defend numbers that coincidentally existed in recent memory?

Sunday, June 09, 2013

When Hell is Invaded

The British lost a lot of sailors' lives to ship arms to the odious Soviet Union in World War II in order to defeat Nazi Germany. Get over reluctance to arm the Syrian rebels.

What the Hell? I thought Europeans had more nuance than this:

Britain said on Sunday it and other countries were "very reluctant" to arm rebels in Syria even as it warned that success on the battlefield by forces loyal to President Bashar al-Assad was undermining chances of a Geneva peace conference.

Come on, Prime Minister Cameron, you could make at least a favourable reference to the rebels in the House of Commons, couldn't you? Defeat Iran by defeating Assad--and just defeating Assad is a good thing alone, you know.

I know. Our president isn't any better. But nuance doesn't come naturally even for our first European Social Democrat president.

Crossing the Red Lion?

American-led exercises are beginning in Jordan. I suppose you are wondering why a clearly Syria-focused event involves naval maneuvers around Jordan's Red Sea port of Aqaba. I have my suspicions.

Eager Lion is underway in Jordan:

The 12-day "Eager Lion" exercises have brought together 8,000 personnel from 19 mainly Arab and European countries to bolster defense capabilities in the face of a possible flare-up from neighboring Syria.

"We don't intend to attack anybody," Jordanian Maj.Gen. Awni el-Edwan told reporters, while commenting on the deployment of U.S. Patriot missiles. He said the exercises would focus on border security, irregular warfare, terrorism and counterinsurgency.

So far, all makes sense. You worry about Syria and you practice these measures.

So what's with this?

Edwan said 6 unnamed nations are also expected to engage in naval maneuvers in the kingdom's sole southern port of Aqaba, near the borders of Israel, Saudi Arabia and Egypt.

Jordan does not have a maritime border with Syria. It makes no sense to have naval maneuvers down there as part of Eager Lion.

Unless they have a lot to do with Eager Lion and whatever remains in Jordan after the exercises are over, including Patriot missiles to protect the possible inflow of forces for an emergency at some point in the future:

With a shield in place, the question then arises about the sword that we might deploy in this southern front. Troops can be flown in, of course. But equipment must be shipped in. Crossing Israel or Iraq is unlikely. I'd guess we would ship equipment in through Aqaba. When we invaded Iraq in 2003, I kept looking for signs we were moving in enough equipment for a heavy division to advance out of eastern Jordan. ...

But this time our main effort has to be Jordan. And this time, shipping stuff north from Aqaba would be the way to get equipment in. The equipment we could ship in most quietly would be the afloat prepositioned equipment of our Army and Marine Corps.

Are we using the cover of naval maneuvers to prepare Aqaba for our prepositioned equipment ships? Or even moving them in to unload?

UPDATE: This article noting Canadian participation says we are sending 4,500 troops to the exercise, including amphibious assault vehicles. Is a Marine Expeditionary Unit in Aqaba?

I seem to recall a recent Stratfor naval update map showing an Amphibious Ready Group in the Red Sea.

I suppose this could have nothing to do with Syria. But it seems unlikely. And even if it wasn't planned for Syria in mind it would certainly help if Syria comes up.

UPDATE: Ah yes, the Kearsarge ARG with the 26th MEU is in Jordan for the exercises.

Unrestricted Cyber Realm Warfare

China isn't paying attention to our concerns about their cyber-war efforts that are hurting us. Could China take a step too far that ultimately enrages our people?

In his meeting with the leader of China, President Obama has brought up our concerns over their cyber-war attacks on America:

The United States and China are in "uncharted waters" as they tackle the contentious issue of cybersecurity, President Barack Obama said following the opening round of talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping at a summit in the California desert. ...

The issue of cyberespionage hangs over the summit, although both leaders carefully avoided accusing each other of the practice when talking to the press at the end of their first day of meetings. But they acknowledged an urgent need to find a common approach to addressing the matter.

China sees that they have an advantage. So they want to exploit it. In many ways, our security people are eager to fight back. While we are probably engaged in some defensive exploits to let China steal information we want them to steal, we have not counter-attacked China, it seems.

China needs to worry about whether exploiting their advantage is a game winner or a game changer that gets us in the cyber-war with blood in our eyes. Is their a cyber-Lusitania out there that China will strike one day because they can strike it?

Reaching the Top

Friday was a celebration of being at the top of the elementary school social structure.


Lamb gets her face painted at the ice cream social. The highlight for her was the 5th-grade splash device that allows people to pay a dollar to throw balls at a target to break balloons over fifth graders. She volunteered for that many times. Despite temperatures that only reached the low 60s, she had a ball.

A little cake walk--but she abandoned it after a couple minutes making this the first year ever she has not won something in this event's cake walk--and then it was off for something else. She even won a Red Wings poster for her big brother.

Since Mister and my Ex were working the fair, I got to escort Lamb. And it was a glorious day for her. In her joy of the day she didn't even worry about reaching out to hold my hand lest peers think less of her. And at one point she even reached up to kiss me on the cheek before dashing off to the next item on the agenda.

So yes, it was a great day.

This followed on the fifth grade trip to a local pool. I feared the worst but it turned out the pool was heated. So that was a grand time too, with Lamb making the most of the huge pool.

Despite lack of sleep after being up late playing Catan (and my performance in the second game was so awful that it will shame me for years to come) that sent me to bed by 10:30, the day was a huge success for Lamb. Soon, Lamb will be officially on to middle school where she will start over at the bottom of the social order. At least the climb to the top will be quicker--before starting over yet again. But she'll always be right there at the top for me (tied with Mister of course, but since he now looms over me the protective urge isn't quite as immediately felt).

It's a strange sense of pride, relief, love, and worry to reach this day. When she was born, I remember holding her in the hospital and worrying about her future. More than a decade later, she's a wonderful little girl who does well in school and is just a good person who is a pleasure to be around. And she's reached that first big hurdle, passing it with flying colors.

I'm a lucky dad. I just don't understand people who don't like or want children. I don't look down on them. It's a free country and surely there are many things one can do without children that are rewarding and enjoyable.

But at some level, I do feel sorry for them. All that worry and all those restrictions on what you can do are worth it when you get that brief little, heart-felt peck on the cheek.

As you watch them run off, of course. Parents can't remain at the top of their children's worlds forever, after all.

Somebody Needs to Help Iraq

We didn't invade Iraq for the oil, and the fact that we aren't pumping it out shouldn't bother war supporters. And shouldn't the "No blood for oil" outcome in Iraq make the anti-war side happy?

I don't get why people are upset that China is helping Iraq develop oil export capabilities. If it makes Iraq wealthier and stronger, they can resist internal strife and Iran better, even without us; and obviously if Iraq exports more oil, it makes oil cheaper for everyone. Heck, maybe China will keep the Iranians at bay in Iraq better than we can.

Seriously, maybe we should hope that China can help Iraqis resist the urge to restart sectarian killing. China apparently has a reason to preserve calm when we lack any reason or interest in doing so.

Well, that's not quite fair. We have sent the CIA back into Iraq to help go after al Qaeda again. I just wish we'd spent 2012 working to resolve problems in Iraq before they got to this point.

So in the short run and in the narrow issue of Iraq, I have no problem with China helping Iraq. Iraq needs help to succeed and we bizarrely aren't providing enough help.

In the long run, of course, I'd rather get China focused on overland energy supply routes so China won't invest so much in their navy.

Reach Out and Touch Someone

Sounds like we're going to need a bigger outreach:

Unease over a clandestine U.S. data collection program has rippled across the Pacific to two of Washington's major allies, Australia and New Zealand, raising concerns about whether they have cooperated with secret electronic data mining.

Thank goodness George W. Bush isn't alienating the world anymore.

Saturday, June 08, 2013

Defending the Top of the World

Of course NATO should be involved in the Arctic! Russia may not be a threat to central and western Europe, but Russia will always be a threat to Arctic interests.

This is a question?

Canada’s recent assumption of the Chairmanship of the Arctic Council prompted much discussion of Arctic issues, including security, an important element of which is the ongoing tug-and-pull over whether NATO should play a role in the region. Russia is, unsurprisingly, opposed. But there is division within NATO itself: Canada against, Norway and other Nordic states for, and the United States seemingly unsure. These divisions are rooted in the varied nature of the Arctic security challenges that each state or group faces. Therefore Arctic security solutions must be equally tailored.

It's an existing region of NATO. In an age when some argue for NATO relevance for out-of-area deployments (like in Afghanistan), why wouldn't a mission to defend the territory of existing NATO members like Canada, America, Denmark, and Norway (and possible members Sweden and Finland) not be a mission of NATO?

Yes. We should look north. Canada especially needs a major rethink--they really want to go it alone? Does Canada really think their disagreements with America on international waters issues makes Russia less of a problem? And expect NATO to look north.

We should establish a Polar Command while we're at it. Not that northern operations require a lot of forces, but they do require specially trained and equipped forces just to survive in that environment let alone to fight in it.

As long as the Russians continue to be so Russia-like, we need to watch them.

UPDATE: Thanks to Legal Insurrection and College Insurrection for linking as "post of the day" for 10 June 13.

The Gazi Trip?

Hey, should Israeli citizens organize a relief flotilla for the Gazi Park protesters in Turkey?

Too Close Enough for Government Work

Who knew that when Democrats said "government is the only thing that we all belong to" that they actually had data to back up their claim for our huge, diverse country?

Ever since Thursday's blockbuster reports from the Washington Post and the Guardian revealing the existence of the National Security Agency's PRISM — the government program that allegedly works with major Internet companies to collect (some) U.S. citizen data — tech companies have been fighting to distance themselves from the potentially privacy-violating government programs. The Post and the Guardian allege tech companies that participate in the PRISM program — Microsoft, Yahoo, Google, Facebook, PalTalk, AOL, Skype, YouTube, and Apple —offered the government "direct access" to their servers full of user information. "From inside a company's data stream the NSA is capable of pulling out anything it likes," the Post's Barton Gellman and Laura Poitras reported.

We may not have gotten the promised most transparent administration ever, but we do have the most transparent citizenry ever.

As Mark Steyn writes:

When the state has the capability to know everything except the difference between right and wrong, it won’t end well.

Remember, this is what an administration that doesn't even think we are at war is willing to do.

UPDATE: And yes, when everything is a crime, government knowledge of everything we do is a problem. Which fits with my long-running frustration that our federal government is criminalizing everything. Tip to Instapundit.

Remember when the expression "Don't make a federal issue out of it" was saying "don't make such a big deal of a small issue"? That was when states handled crimes and the federal government criminalized only the most important things of national importance or those that spanned state jurisdictions.

Now the expression doesn't make sense since the federal government is in everything. Which makes our constitution's protections against double jeopardy almost pointless since more and more crimes are crimes at the state and federal level, making it possible to prosecute twice for the same crime but under different levels of law.

Are we getting closer to finding that the Soviet practice of defining what is legal and assuming all else is illegal is more efficient than our practice of defining what is illegal? And they could boast of reducing the U.S. Code and administrative rules!

Remember, Murder is Already Illegal

There has been a mass shooting on California. It is early but we may know a few things.

The murderer is dead:

A semi-automatic assault rifle is again being tied to a US mass shooting, this one a chaotic series of events led by a body-armor-clad man who killed four and wounded five people before being shot and killed by police in a college library in the iconic beachside city of Santa Monica, Calif.

One, there was no automatic fire.

Two, the murderer slowly fired single shots, making rapid reload or magazine size irrelevant.

So it is difficult to see how a change in gun laws regarding the guns themselves would have stopped this crime. The only actual law on guns that might have made a difference would be to keep campuses from being gun-free zones. We shall see if pre-purchase screening changes might have had an effect.

Three, the murderer is not a white, dangerous Tea Party veteran--we know that since no motive is mentioned and no race or ethnicity is mentioned despite reports from an eye witness who said the man had corn rows in his hair.

Not that the race or ethnicity of the murderer is a reason to issue a blanket condemnation of all in the shooter's race or ethnicity--or gender for that matter--as if the actions of one condemn all of that race or ethnicity--I've said the same about Moslem jihadis, after all. But we all know how motive and group guilt would play out if the situation was different.

I'll surely update the post if my early reading of this first report has led me to draw erroneous conclusions. Or if the first reports are wrong, of course.

UPDATE: Other crimes not the fault of Tea Party right wingers.