Monday, March 18, 2013

Let's Talk 'Not Reassuring,' Okay?

The Russians aren't reassured by our missile defense plans for Europe:

A change in the United States plans for an anti-missile shield in Europe will not prompt Russia to drop its opposition to the system, a senior lawmaker allied to President Vladimir Putin said on Sunday.

U.S. Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel said on Friday the Pentagon would add 14 new anti-missile interceptors in Alaska, among others, after North Korea had threatened a preemptive nuclear strike against the United States.

To free up funds for that, U.S. officials said they were forgoing development of a new interceptor that would have been deployed in central eastern Europe and has been a focus of Russia's concern that the shield would weaken its nuclear deterrent.

You know what I'm not reassured about? Russian concern that we might be able to prevent them from nuking us. I'm funny that way. Britain doesn't worry about our missile defense plans. Not even France worries about our missile defense plans. Russia? They worry about our missile defense plans. Add them to North Korea in the "worried about our missile defense plans" category.

Ah, the Russians. They're a full-employment plan for the American Psychiatry Association, aren't they?

UPDATE: The Chinese pipe up:

"The anti-missile issue has a direct bearing on global and regional balance and stability. It also concerns mutual strategic interests between countries," Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei told a daily news briefing.

Hey, I have a notion for you supposedly patient, deep thinkers in Peking who excel at long-range planning: supporting your little pet psycho regime was a bad idea that had a direct bearing on global and regional balance and stability. You don't like our missile defense plans (because you want the option to nuke us, obviously)? Maybe you should have thought of that logical outcome of propping up your brutal little friend.

And let me take another swing with the clue bat: fail to rein in North Korea and you might face nuclear-armed Japan, South Korea, Philippines, Taiwan, Vietnam, Australia, Thailand, and Singapore. Oh, how silly to think of poor Philippines going nuclear? Right? North Korea is doing it. If they can, anyone can given enough time.

When you think about it, North Korea going nuclear leads to a number of logical consequences. I guess those lines of thought are beyond the capacity of the communist rulers of China. Reasonably enlightened though they may be.

Credit Where Credit is Due

President Obama takes credit for reduced American oil imports. This reduction in energy imports is based on increased energy supply from the private sector production, reduced energy production from federal areas, and weakened domestic demand due to a weakened economy.

Discuss amongst yourselves which areas are to his credit, blame, or good fortune.

Good grief, our president has a lot of nerve. But what the heck, who's going to challenge his claims? Our media?

Sunday, March 17, 2013

You've Got To Be Kidding Me

Anthony Weiner wants to be mayor of New York City.

His first campaign ad is disturbing:


The contest could only get more tawdry if Donald Trump runs against him.

If Weiner wins, there really is no such thing as bad publicity.

20% Crushes the Curve

I don't expect the press corps to get the Iraq War right. They didn't while we fought it and they don't get it now.

I guess I'm impressed that this writer got one out of five myths right.

Here we go with myth 1:

1. The troop surge succeeded.

The surge of 26,000 troops into Baghdad in 2007 had two objectives: tamp down the bloody sectarian civil war and forge a political compromise among the three principal groups in Iraqi society — Shiite Arabs, Sunni Arabs and ethnic Kurds — that would set the country on a path to stability.

He says that many other factors contributed to the surge success. I agree. That's why I wrote about the timing of the surge when some wondered why we didn't carry out the surge offensive earlier. There were other factors arguably more important than five more American combat brigades. But the idea that the surge failed because former enemies have not learned to love each other and work together is just wrong. The surge did get the three main ethnic/religious groups to largely abandon violence as the means to settle differences. The surge succeeded in its military goals. Politics is the realm of setting the country on the path to stability. But we aren't there to enforce political means as the method of resolving disputes.

The military surge succeeded in its military objective. Demanding it solve post-military objective goals is a bit much to expect of such a blunt instrument. Did military victory at Yorktown (with a large French assist in their own military surge in support of us) solve our post-Revolution political issues? No. That took a new Constitution--that increased the central government's powers--to replace the weak Articles of Confederation. No myth here.

2. Iraq today is relatively peaceful.

Levels of violence are far lower than they were in 2006, at the height of the civil war, when hundreds of people were being killed every week. But Iraq is far from stable.

Saying that Iraq is not stable or at peace is not refuting the idea that Iraq is not relatively peaceful. Sadly, there are still Baathists and al Qaeda types who want to kill. And Iran is still messing with Iraqi stability. But that is a problem caused by our failure to stay engaged in Iraq's security and future.

Iraq is relatively peaceful. No myth here.

3. Iraq is a democracy.

It is — on paper. It has held successive national elections; it has a parliament and a modestly functional court system. In practice, however, Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki is exercising authority and centralizing power in ways that remind many Iraqis of Hussein. His security agencies have rounded up numerous Sunni leaders in recent months, accusing them of supporting the insurgency. Sunni officials contend that Maliki is using terrorism as a pretext to neutralize political foes.

Both Japan and Mexico have democracies even though one-party rule was a feature for most of their recent history. Iraq does have a long way to go in rule of law--I've harped on this as a necessary component of voting for true democracy--but Iraq does at least have real elections and a parliament with power and a modestly functional court system. Given the damage that Saddam did to Iraqi society, that's a big deal. As for Maliki reminding people of Hussein, if Maliki really was like Hussein, people would be too afraid to protest. Have we forgotten his domestic terror apparatus already? And in practice, many Sunni Arab politicians do support al Qaeda terrorists. Some from fear rather than love, it is true. But there is a reason for Maliki to watch the Sunni Arabs. Many Sunni Arabs believe fervently that they should be running Iraq rather than the dreaded Shias. Heck, many Sunni Arabs don't believe they are a minority in Iraq. And again, helping Iraq develop democracy is the main reason I wanted our troops to stay in Iraq after 2011. But we don't have the 25,000 I wanted to stay.

So yeah, Iraq is a democracy in the making and a major improvement over Saddam's Iraq. No myth here.

4. Iraq is in Iran’s pocket.

Iran is still bigger and more powerful. But Iraq’s collaboration with Tehran is as often driven by its own interests as those of its neighbor.

This is a tough one. I agree with his contention that it is a myth that Iraq is in Iran's pocket. But his analysis to reach this conclusion isn't something I stand with. While Iraq certainly worries about a Sunni government in Syria turning on Shia-dominated Iraq, don't forget that the Alawite (viewed as basically Shia-related) government of Syria supported Iran in its war with Iraq and funneled Sunni Arab suicide bombers into Iraq during the Iraq War. So Iraq's government has plenty of reasons to hate the supposedly natural allies of the Alawite government of Assad. And trying to pretend that Moqtada al-Sadr isn't a tool of Iran--even if not a perfect tool--is folly.

Iraq's government has no love for Iran. But without a sizable American presence, Iraq has to cope with their relative weakness compared to Iran until Iraq is stronger. Our influence is far stronger in Iraq than pre-2003, and I don't assume Iran will win this struggle despite our failure to stay in Iraq.

So yeah, this is a myth. But how the author got the right answer with such flawed reasoning is a mystery.

Let's go to the last myth:

5. The Americans have all left.

There are still about 220 U.S. military personnel in Iraq. They work for the Office of Security Cooperation-Iraq, which handles the sale of military equipment to the Iraqi army and coordinates training. Those personnel work in an annex of the U.S. Embassy in central Baghdad, the largest American diplomatic mission in the world.

This is just stupid. Of course we haven't "all left" Iraq. But 220 military personnel is less than 1% of what I wanted to both deter Iran, reassure Iraqis about Iran, and make sure Iraqi factions don't view force rather than politics as a means to resolve differences. And all those Americans still in Iraq contrary to the "myth" are in our huge embassy where they are largely confined to the embassy compound. So yes, we have basically left Iraq. I wish it wasn't so, but there you go. And the other information the writer chooses to prove we haven't all left just proves that we have too few to have high confidence in our ability to help Iraq: "Concerns that the fighting in Syria could spill over into Iraq recently prompted the CIA to increase its support to Iraqi counterterrorism forces[.]"

So yes, we've basically left Iraq. No myth here, either.

Good God, our press corps sucks. After so long, they are clueless about military matters and war. This piece designed to inform the ignorant rubes self-selected five so-called myths and got its conclusion wrong on four while using poor analysis to somehow get the right answer on one.

So I guess in our press corps, this guy is a relative genius. With the ten-year anniversary of the start of Operation Iraqi Freedom beginning, I can expect to be pounding my head into my desk in bitter, hope-abandoning frustration a lot until the press herd moves on to some other topic.

Vhy Didn't You Tell the Vorld, Eh?!

So a former Taiwanese defense minister is catching grief for mentioning a missile that the defense department briefed their parliament on two years ago? Huh.

A former defense minister of Taiwan wrote a book that discusses a medium-range cruise missile that Taiwan developed. This reaction is fascinating:

The defence ministry, which often refuses to comment on reports regarding sensitive weaponry development and acquisition, condemned Tsai's revelations.

"As Mr Tsai has served as the defence minister, he should know that safeguarding national secrets is his due obligation and he should not have revealed sensitive information, a move which may endanger national security. We regret what he has done," ministry spokesman David Lo told AFP.

The defense ministry condemned what the defense ministry reported on more than two years ago:

"Mass production of indigenous weapons like the ones under the codenames of 'Chichun' (Lance Hawk) and 'Chuifeng' (Chasing Wind) is very smooth," Deputy Defence Minister Chao Shih-chang told parliament Wednesday. ...

The Chichun project refers to the Hsiungfeng 2E cruise missile, Taiwan's answer to the US-made Tomahawk. Chuifeng is project to develop the island's long-anticipated supersonic anti-ship missile. ...

The cruise missiles could be launched from land or sea, and would be capable of hitting airports and missile bases in southeast China, as well as cities such as Shanghai and Hong Kong, local media said.

The furor is odd, if I may turn to Doctor Strangelove for commentary:



The whole point of the Hsiungfeng 2E cruise missile is lost if you keep it a secret!

With all due respect, failure to disclose the existence of the missile endangers national security. Besides, the military did disclose the missile's existence, so both the Chinese and the Taiwanese public know about it. And even without the past disclosure, it is hard to deploy a weapon in large numbers without it being spotted. The Chinese knew about this weapon.

Of course, the blooming cross-strait love affair is a strange one. China arms up while smiling and pretending that they have no intention of invading Taiwan despite growing capabilities to do so. And Taiwan pretends that China has no intention of compelling Taiwan to join China while needing to somehow deter China from forcing Taiwan to join China and submit to communist rule. Perhaps this is how you remind people of something you don't want to officially admit you need.

But one day, the PLA will cry out, "Mein Premier! I can cross the strait!"

Saturday, March 16, 2013

Uh Oh

In what economic model does it make sense to convince savers that banks--required to loan money to keep businesses going--are not safe places for their money?

But that's what Cyprus has done, egged on by the European Union:

The euro zone agreed on Saturday to hand Cyprus a bailout worth 10 billion euros ($13 billion), but demanded depositors in its banks forfeit some money to stave off bankruptcy despite the risk of a wider run on savings.

Everybody in Europe is on notice, now. Where do the bank runs start on Monday? Surely, some people are going to think that if Cyprus has gone this route, their country is the logical next country that will confiscate money. This is Willie Sutton territory (When asked why he robbed banks, he said "because that's where the money is." At least according to urban legend, anyway.).

So yes, this man is quite correct:

"They call Sicily the island of the mafia. It's not Sicily, it's Cyprus. This is theft, pure and simple," said a pensioner.

Presumably, the money was already taxed as income of some kind. Now it is being taxed again.

And note that the spenders, who may be broke and dependent on the government because they did not save, paid no penalty for this bailout. That lesson won't be lost on people, either. Who will bother to save money let alone put it in banks?

Remember, this move was designed to allow banks to lend. How does spooking depositors help banks?

I've said that Europe had a dangerous inter-war vibe. Now the economic situation is matching it. I've got a bad feeling about this.

UPDATE: Ok, so Cypriot banks are havens for Russian money laundering crooks and Greek Cypriots haven't cared enough about their shady banking system for either to earn much sympathy (tip to Instapundit). But do the people of already shaky Europe really believe that only crooks will be targetted this way? Really?

A panic is not rational. I'm not so sure that bank depositors in other European countries can be so neatly insulated from the pure and simple theft in Cyprus, even if the EU is just stealing from crooks and promises not to do this to anyone else.

UPDATE: Really, are they trying to crush the European banking system? Tip to Instapundit. And these words of wisdom, too:

I have been predicting the dissolution of the EU for some time. I was expecting a Hollow Men sort of ending, not with a bang but a whimper. It now looks likely that there will be a few bangs after all.

On the bright side, crooks won't rob European banks any more.

UPDATE: Wow. Cyprus can't even pull off a simple bank heist. They really suck:

Frightened savers in Cyprus drained ATMs in a bank run, prompting parliament to postpone a crucial vote Sunday on a levy on all bank deposits, a move creditors had demanded in exchange for €10 billion ($13 billion) in rescue money.

The announcement of the delay set off an immediate scramble among top European financial officials. One lawmaker told The Associated Press that European Central Bank was pressuring Cypriot authorities to hold the vote without delay.

Like reversing or postponing the decision will work. Everyone has notice that their Cyprus deposits are not safe. What fools will keep their money in the banks?

Cyprus wrecked their banks, and that's that. The only question is whether depositors get robbed. This was the plan that the best and brightest of the EU came up with.

UPDATE: Who could have seen this coming?

A plan to seize up to 10 percent of people's savings in the small Mediterranean island nation of Cyprus sent shockwaves across Europe on Monday as households realized the money they have in the bank may not be safe. ...

"The damage is done," said Louise Cooper, who heads financial research firm CooperCity. "Europeans now know that their savings could be used to bail out banks."

Idiots.

What's With the Protest Fetish?

Syria is in the second year of civil war. The last year has been particularly intense. On the second anniversary of the first protest, this story notes the lack of protesters:

On the second anniversary of Syria's uprising, there were only small protests and a few firecrackers defiantly popping in the capital of Damascus — a grim contrast to the early days when crowds of demonstrators danced to the drums of rebellion against President Bashar Assad.

If I may be so bold, protest marches are rather pointless once you get to the stage of mass revolt. What would be the point of demonstrations? Is the Assad government unclear that people don't like it and want Assad to leave?

America, You Must Not Look Away (How to Finish Off the Jihad)

To this day, our media doesn't show us the videos of people leaping to their certain deaths from the Twin Towers on the morning of September 11, 2001, to avoid the flames that would kill them if they stayed. We just don't see them when we discuss Islamist terrorism. We don't see them on the anniversaries of the attack. They are too much for us to handle. Bitter clingers would be enraged enough to start a pogrom against all Moslems, apparently. Islamists recruit with snuff films of killing Infidels in gruesome fashion. But we are the ones who cannot see the results of their handiwork.

I believe someone in our media – a grieving parent, an upset firefighter, a citizen who has seen enough of this carnage – somebody, someday soon, is going to use the videos of people plunging to their deaths from the Twin Towers on 9/11 rather than die in the inferno. And when the American people see what pavement from a fall from a burning skyscraper does to a human body, that's the day the jig will be up for the jihadis. It will be the day the debate on fighting terrorism will come to an end. There will be nothing left to argue over. It will just be over. And every sane American will demand action.

So do we just release images that one side believes are advantageous?

Michael Moore might believe the sight of dead children will galvanize Americans into doing something to stop that horrible crime from happening again. But the public might not react by banning guns. Americans might react by putting violent criminals away for far longer rather than trying to rehabilitate them. Americans might react by insisting on the death penalty for killers. The American public might react by locking up the mentally ill and making identifying potential killers such a high priority that nobody will risk seeing a mental health professional for help lest they be flagged as a potential threat.

Actually, I don't actually believe that if people routinely saw the Twin Tower "suicide" falls (they were murdered as surely as those who stayed and burned) that America's debate over fighting jihadis would come to an end. I used to think they should be shown. I still do, I suppose. But I no longer think the videos would change the debate. Those who think we regrettably "deserved" the attacks (or that we really brought them on ourselves, so we need to change more than we need to fight) won't change their minds.

And I don't think that leaking the images of dead children will change minds. It is blatant manipulation. I don't need those images to be sick at the thought of little children being cut down by a lunatic. It breaks my heart. It should not happen.

But that isn't how policy affecting basic rights should be made. We surely want to keep our children safe. That's a problem that calls for reasoned debate. Just as fighting terrorism requires reasoned debate, no? How does making each side sure the other side is demented for not reacting as you do to horrifying images lead to good solutions?

And what if seeing those images of dead, mangled, children just inspires other sickos to commit crimes like that, too? Don't some want to censor violent video games or movies to keep us from being desensitized to violence? Why are real images of death somehow curative of the problem that fictional images cause?

Yet even after we change laws and make some more things crimes, things that should not happen will continue to happen. It was illegal to kill people before Sandy Hook and before 9/11, I'm pretty sure. And our hearts will be broken when many things beyond the scope of our laws take place. Laws designed to keep killers from slaughtering children will be used to convict people in situations far removed from what was intended, just as laws to prevent terrorist use of weapons of mass destruction are used to convict people far removed from the world of terrorism. Emotions have to be expressed in words to be laws and they can never be focused enough to deal only with the problem we want to address.

We can never finish off evil. Looking away from the brutal images of that evil is just a means to preserve our sanity in this world. That doesn't mean we ignore what we know happened. Just work the problem rather than ignore it, of course.

Friday, March 15, 2013

Who Knew?

North Korea says we are waging a cyber-attack on them. Who knew they had cyber to attack?

This is puzzling:

In the ongoing international spat over which country deploys the most evil cyber hackers, North Korea is lobbing accusations that the United States and South Korea took down the nation's webservers. On Wednesday, there were reports that the country's entire internet service had been taken down, and now the North's official media arm says their enemies are too blame.

The entire country? Well, that's not too hard, considering their tech. Did the North Korean IT try jiggling the cord in the outlet? It might be frayed.

Mine Eyes Have Seen the Glory

Al Gore is marching on, as he speaks about his vision of the future:

Gore makes his speech to a ballroom packed to the rafters, and the thousands who had been warned [that there was no room for them] camp outside the closed doors, watching the simulcast on their iPhones.

The title of Gore’s speech is “The Future,” and he draws the main themes from his book of the same name. As one might imagine, scaremongering about climate change weaves in and out of his presentation. From time to time, the usual enemies are brought out for applause: Congress is impotent and “does nothing” until it “gets the okay from special interests”; shadowy groups run the country, he claims, having “hacked” its democracy and corrupted its “operating system,” the Constitution. And the NRA, which defends a key part of that “operating system”? “A complete fraud,” Gore explains, “because it is financed by the gun manufacturers.”

Glory, glory, hallelujah.

He's quite mad, obviously. Now go and emit no more.

Maintain a Sense of Humor

The Assad government cracks me up.

The Syrian government is threatening to attack Lebanon if they don't control their territory better:

"Syria expects the Lebanese side to prevent these armed terrorist groups from using the borders as a crossing point, because they target Syrian people and are violating Syrian sovereignty," a diplomatic cable from the Syrian foreign ministry to its Lebanese counterpart said, Reuters reports.

According to state-run SANA, the Syrian foreign ministry said rebels have been inflicting violence in Syria, then fleeing across the border into Lebanon.

"Syrian forces have so far exercised restraint from striking at armed gangs inside Lebanese territory," the cable said.

It's almost like the Syrians have no idea what Hezbollah does as a state within a state in Lebanon, either against Israel or for Assad. Assad isn't outraged over Lebanon's failure to control Hezbollah, I bet.

And of course, we understand that it sucks when neighbors actively help terrorists.

Say what you will about Assad, but he retains his sense of humor.

We Have No Clue

I haven't been this reassured about Iran's nuclear ambitions since they revealed they might formally promise not to do so. We're sure Iran is a year away from getting nuclear weapons.

No worries yet:

President Barack Obama told Israelis Iran is still more than year away from developing a nuclear weapon and sought to reassure them that military force remains a U.S. option if sanctions and diplomacy fail to thwart its nuclear ambitions.

Of course, our president says we don't yet have a debt problem. Which is like me saying I don't have a debt problem yet because my $10,000 credit bill isn't due until the end of the month.

Iran will go nuclear, and we will be surprised when they go nuclear.

Lifestyles of the 1%

Roll out the welcome wagon for the new couple in the neighborhood.

If she wasn't Democratic royalty, she'd be considered a silver-spoon, greedy person. Or someone born on third base who thinks she hit a triple.

Oh, and she has "great security" where she lives. No need to wait however many minutes it takes police to respond to a 911 call for her and her husband, eh?

UPDATE: Related (via Instapundit):

The low and middle classes are being priced out of a life in New York City. Even as many residents spend fifty percent or more of their earnings on housing, the majority of the city’s “affordable homes” are still out of reach. House prices and rent have risen by more than forty percent since 2001, and landlords, betting on gentrification, are evicting existing tenants in favor of wealthier ones. The result is a skyrocketing homeless population and a threat of a mass exodus to other cities and states.

Oh dear. That's potentially inconvenient.

But it's not like some evil bankers or oil executives are moving in. Good grief, Chelsea cares, don't you know?

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Digging That Hole Deeper

Europe has severe problems, so naturally anarchism is rearing its ugly head. It never ceases to amaze me how people can take a bad situation and make it worse.

Stratfor discusses the situation.

I'm not so comforted by the lack of Soviet support that makes them less effective today than in the past. Jihadis will no doubt forge alliances with anarchists, given time. Perhaps the anarchists won't be much more effective, but they'll be far more deadly.

As the old saying starts, "A" plus "hole" equals ...

Don't Say We Weren't Warned

I keep reading that the North Koreans have renounced the 1953 armistice perhaps a half dozen times before, so maybe my gut feeling that this time seems different is not based on the record.

The history seems confusing. Strategypage has both reported that North Korea has cancelled the armistice before and that the latest declaration is new:

Once more North Korea is threatening to attack South Korea. This has been going on since North Korea signed a ceasefire agreement in 1953 to end the Korean War. The war itself has never officially been ended and now, for the first time North Korea has declared the ceasefire over.

So I have to ask, is North Korea just feeling the need to turn the Psycho Dial up to 11 to inspire the same amount of fear (and aid) that past lesser sabre rattling achieved?

Or are they prepared (perhaps from desperation rather than confidence) to do more and are dotting "i"s and crossing "t"s to justify an attack on South Korea?

And if the North Koreans are preparing for another performance of Dead South Koreans Theater, what scale do the North Koreans feel they need to kill on to work?

And when the South Koreans strike back hard, do the North Koreans plan to match South Korea escalation for escalation until South Korean troops push north?

I hope PACOM is looking at how fast they can react to a North Korean attack--at whatever scale--rather than focusing on coping with rising sea levels. Face it, we have no idea what the North Koreans think is rational.

UPDATE:IISS considers it likely that North Korea will strike South Korea this year--but after our joint exercises with the South Koreans are over. IISS judges this dangerous since South Korea will retaliate. Given that North Korea wants to shove South Korea's face in the dirt, unless North Korea responds to the retaliation, there is little point to starting this.

And if South Korea wants to establish deterrence against northern attacks, South Korea can't let this end with North Korean advantage. South Korea doesn't necessarily have to fire last, but there will need to be more rubble on the north side of the DMZ.

Grainville "Wins"

Oh please, at the first bad harvest--because neither the residents of Corntown or Flintstown ever met Guntown to trade their surplus with them--the overwhelming numbers of Grainville launched human wave assaults on the prosperous but few Flintstown people, slaughtered them and sent their corn stocks home, and then cowed the moderate people of Corntown into submission.

The people of Grainville lived pauperly ever after on the annual tribute from the people of Corntown, who gradually devolved into even poorer people because they had no incentive to excel and because they were under the deadening watch of Grainville, which feared that somehow the people of Corntown might become a new Flintstown if left alone.

Flintstown was an archaeological dig, of course. Nobody knew how they built their huge grain silos--or why they built them. Just what would they put in them, anyway?

And Yet We Re-elected President Obama

North Korea reports on the wasteland of America, kept alive by North Korean humanitarian aid. Mmmm, North Korean coffee ...

Tip to Weekly Standard.

So when you tell me that there is no way North Korea would start a war because North Korea is so obviously ill prepared for war, explain why we know for sure that the North Koreans know that they'd lose.

Or, if they really do understand that they'd lose a war, explain to me how we know for sure that North Korea understands that they can't start some limited armed conflict and expect South Korea to just back down and refrain from starting up the escalation ladder?

Or, explain to me why even if the North Koreans understand that there is a 99% chance that they'd lose any war, why they might not consider a 1% chance of victory--or just survival if the war can be ended before South Korean troops march on Pyongyang--to be better than a 100% chance of collapsing into chaos if they don't take that 1% chance.

Yes, barring a virtual act of God, we would pound North Korea into the ground at the end of the war. But the price in blood and treasure would be high to do so. And the price to help North Korea recover from the six decades of brutal Kimunist rule would be far more expensive in money.

Given the twisted reality that even the elite may believe up north, I'm not confident that I know what "rational" means to them.

And really, I'm not willing to give up any of my melted snow sustenance for the sake of North Koreans. I'd be bummed enough that I won't be able to go to Kimbucks any more.

An Issue for Organizing for Action, No?

You'd think that fighting for more than 11 years in Afghanistan would convince Afghans that as we draw down troops, we'll stand with them to beat our common enemies. But no, questions of our commitment cause people to waver in their resolve--including President Karzai, who wants hedge his bets on America.

Our commander in Afghanistan rightly notes the main problem he has during our withdrawal over the next couple years and the hand over of responsibility to Afghans backed by only a residual supporting force of American and NATO/Coalition forces:

To me, as I come in, the more significant challenges in the campaign are actually psychological and -- and although the Taliban has pushed away -- been pushed away from the populated areas and I know you've been briefed many times on that. And we -- we use a statistic that 80 percent of the violence happens where 20 percent of the population is.

The statistics aren't so important as I -- I believe that we have seen indications of Taliban leadership fracturing. We've seen issues of friction between the leadership in the Taliban and the fighters. And we've seen issues of resource problems.

But there is one place where the Taliban still are successful and that is in the messaging. And they're -- and from my perspective, there's two messages that are resonating inside of Afghanistan right now.

One is of the coalition as occupiers, and the other is that the coalition will abandon Afghanistan at the end of 2014.

And both of those messages, while seemingly inconsistent live in the same space here inside of Afghanistan right now, and they create uncertainty and -- and as I've gone around and talked to my counterparts in the Afghan Security Forces, but as importantly members of civil society and -- and Afghan leadership.

The fear of -- the fear of uncertainty actually from my perspective right now is greater than any fear I've sensed about the Taliban. The people really are concerned about post-2014.

And -- and -- and so as -- as the Commander of ISAF as I come in, one of the most important things that I need to do is convey to the Afghans that commitment. We need to work to develop the final bilateral security agreement that the United States will sign with Afghanistan.

Resolve is our rear guard in Afghanistan, as I recently noted. And we don't have it despite 11 years of fighting there and giving the Taliban a solid pummeling while building up Afghan forces. If we hadn't prematurely ended our presence in Iraq after 2011, perhaps our commitment wouldn't be subject to such easy questioning.

Regardless of whether Iraq had an effect on Afghan confidence in us (and it is possible it does not), we have to bolster faith in our commitment to win in Afghanistan. Our government can do that, can't it?

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Anti-Purple Prose

This admiral may want to take some remedial joint warfare course. Purple, he ain't:

Around the Pentagon, the budget cutters have put away their knives and are reaching for axes. In times like these, every service naturally circles the wagons around its share of the budget pie. The stress is so great that otherwise smart people take incredibly silly stands. Last week, for instance, the former chief of naval operations, Admiral Gary Roughead, published a paper that calls for cutting the Army in half and leaving the Navy’s budget untouched. He sums up the logic for this advice in a few simple words: “The force we propose accepts risk in the burden we are placing on our Army and Marine Corps.”

Good grief. The Army has a tough time justifying its existence--win or lose. That seems to be a fact of life.

But this proposal is ridiculous. Enemies couldn't break our ground forces in two wars over the last decade, but one of our own admirals wants a shot at it. Thanks.

I know, the Navy likes to say that 80% of the world's people live within 300 miles of a coast, as a justification for their role. That's an interesting fact, but quite irrelevant. If I may be so bold, 100% of the world's people live on the land.

Which is my main point of contention with Air-Sea Battle. I have no problem with the idea that we need to be able to pierce China's anti-access forces to operate close to China. But what do we do when we pierce that shield? Sail around broadcasting, "Here we are and there's nothing you can do about it!"? Presumably, we should have a point for wanting to operate near China, no? (Oh, and that paper I note there was rejected, so I'm reworking it into a shorter article for another try elsewhere.)

Not even the Air Force tries to argue that since all people breathe air, their service must get the priority.

As a virtual island nation, we need a powerful Navy to get our ground power overseas and keep them supplied and supported.

And since we haven't fought without air superiority since about 1943, I'd hate to start now.

But ground forces--whether Army or Marine Corps--are not luxuries. Ultimately, planes have to land some time, ships have to have a home port somewhere, and people--all of them--live on the land. Only in Budget World is it possible to say gutting the ground forces is an acceptable risk for the nation to take.

Look, we need a good Navy and a good Air Force. And it is no disrespect to these services to note that long before there was air power, armies decided wars. And without the ability to exploit control of the seas to project ground power ashore, navies haven't been decisive on their own.

I've said before that in some future crisis when someone has the guts to remind us that we go to war with the ground forces we have and not the ground forces we wish we had, remember that the future ground forces we will have is the result of decisions we make today about the ground forces we wish to have.

Ya Think?

The Taiwanese are reporting that notwithstanding the Chinese charm offensive, China's capabilities to invade Taiwan are being strengthened. Well, duh.

A Taiwan defense review highlights the limits of cross-strait detente:

The Chinese People's Liberation Army (PLA) has continued to upgrade arms for troops stationed with Nanjing and Guangzhou military units, which have the potential to threaten Taiwan, a MND-released Quadrennial Defense Review (QDR) said. The report said this situation, which has emerged despite improving cross-strait ties, poses a major threat to Taiwan.

For the past few years, the PLA has been conducting military exercises which focus on the scenario of taking an island should possible military conflict occur, the QDR also said.

China has not renounced the goal of absorbing Taiwan by force if necessary. China has just stopped issuing threats at such a high rate about absorbing Taiwan by force. And China's capabilities to invade continute to grow while Taiwan's defenses fail to keep pace.

Taiwan should return the favor by arming up and training while smiling at the Chinese about their wonderful cross-strait relations.

Taiwan should not be confused about this. If they don't defend their island democracy, they'll lose their freedom. Then they can take comfort in having shiny, new "Free Taiwan" bumper stickers right next to the faded "Free Tibet" stickers on the occasional car you might see in a college town. That's gotta count for something, right?

UPDATE: Taiwan needs to remember that we can't defend them. China will reach Taiwan's shores if they attack:

It is now accepted at the Pentagon that an attack by Beijing on Taiwan could not be successfully turned back by U.S. planes and ships. The dense deployment of missile batteries along the mainland Chinese coast has shifted the immediate balance of power, meaning that the United States will now depend on its ability to inflict massive retaliatory damage to deter China from crossing the Taiwan Strait. “We can no longer be a shield,” says a senior military planner. “We have to switch to being an effective spear.”

Right now, the best-case scenario is that we fight our way through China's growing arsenal in time to make a difference. Taiwan needs to provide more time for the cavalry to arrive.

Six Months Later

Over 6 months after the 9/11 attacks on our diplomatic and intelligence facilities in Benghazi and we still don't have official details on what was apparently a pretty impressive display of guts--or who they were (even if we can't know names for security)--by the few on hand to fight the jihadi attackers.

And we haven't struck back at the jihadis in that time, too. And no, I don't really count supporting the French effort in Mali even though some of those jihadis were linked to the Benghazi assault.

Why? To both failures, of course.

Burn Rate

During the Iraq War, I'd occasionally note how our casualties were really pretty light, historically speaking. While tragedies for the individuals and their families, of course, the casualties posed no danger to the integrity of our ground forces or their ability to complete their missions. Nonetheless, this was supposed to be a doomed quagmire if you believed the reporting of the war.

Hey, let's look at a real death trap for soldiers--the Syria Revolt:

As of Tuesday evening, the Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said it had documented the deaths of 14,521 soldiers. The activist group issues daily detailed updates on casualties on both sides.

Syria analyst Jeffrey White estimated that an average of 40 Syrian soldiers are killed every day, or about 1,200 a month. He said this is based on the analysis of funeral data, but he declined to elaborate.

In no year did our losses in Iraq ever exceed one thousand. Losing 4 troops per day represented a bad month. If accurate, this Syrian casualty rate is astounding. Add in the wounded who can't return to battle (most wounded can return to the fight) and desertions, and it is easy to see why Assad is recruiting militias to supplement the troops.

Further, the army casualties would be primarily in the poor bloody infantry, leaving an army with a higher proportion of support troops and artillery units rather than infantry. So there is more reliance on bombardment. And an increasingly brittle army of rear echelon types screened by not much.

And I still see no reports on training new army troops. Where one would properly put them through training without being targets is one problem, I imagine. You'd need troops just to guard the training facilities.

I don't know how long Assad's army can fight before its morale breaks. Assad has an advantage over us in Iraq because he has no choice but to fight--he can't just get tired, decide to cut his losses, and go home. There is no exit strategy but defeat.

But I might need to wonder how long the army can fight before it just dies off. Quagmire is the best case scenario for Assad, now.

UPDATE: Related discussion of US casualty rates.

UPDATE: Rumors of a military draft panic Damascus residents:

When a government-linked Islamic body in Syria said this week it was a "sacred duty" to join the army and fight the revolt, Damascus was ablaze with rumors of a mass military draft.

Men of military age panicked, worrying they would be given a gun and told to fight never-ending street battles with rebel fighters before being returned to their families in a wooden box, like thousands of soldiers over the past two years.

These men are unwilling to fight for their own government. Even in the Iraq War, we had no problem getting volunteers to enlist and fight in Iraq. Just as a point of comparison for what "an increasingly unpopular war" against an actual national resistance looks like.

The Assad regime denies that they are planning a mass draft, but if they could get away with it, they'd do it:

The International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) in London said on Thursday the Syrian army's strength has roughly halved to around 110,000 men due to defections, desertions and battlefield losses.

"Essentially, the regime could only be certain of the loyalty of the mainly Alawite Special Forces, the Republican Guard, and the elite 3rd and 4th Divisions - perhaps 50,000 troops in total," the think tank said in its annual report on the world's militaries.

Strategypage has more, describing how Assad has about 200,000 loyal forces, with half being mobile forces he can count on:

Two years ago the Syrian security forces had 450,000 personnel (50,000 secret police, 300,000 troops and 100,000 police). About half this force is now gone. Over 30,000 have been killed or badly wounded. Over 100,000 have deserted and nearly 100,000 troops are in units that the government is reluctant to send into combat because of loyalty issues. Over the last year about 100,000 armed men have joined the Assads, mostly as local militia. But the Assads have fewer than 100,000 troops they can move around to fight the rebels. There’s another 100,000 that are, in effect, garrisons in places like the [west] (near the coast) Damascus and towns and cities in central Syria that will fight defensively, but will not (or the government will not order to) move elsewhere. The government is having difficulty finding replacements for existing soldiers and police (especially the secret police who are the most loyal and effective armed men the government has). Several thousand of the security forces are being killed or wounded each month. Add in over a thousand desertions and you have a situation where the Assad forces keep getting weaker while the rebels grow stronger. There’s little doubt where this is going. ...

Throughout the country there are now over a million armed men organized for fighting. Less than a third of those are loyal to the government and there only about 100,000 troops and secret police that the Assads can really depend on.

If the rebels really have 700,000 armed men, I assume that represents 70,000 in combat. I thought the general rule of thumb was that only about 10% of insurgents are really full time rebels while the rest are part-timers who assist from time to time and are a logistics and intelligence resource for the active fighters.

Recall too, that in both Iraq and Afghanistan, our enemies relied on mines and IEDs and avoided direct combat with our troops. In Syria, press reports show lots of infantry-type fire fights. I haven't seen break downs of casualties, but I'd bet that the vast majority of Syrian security force casualties are from direct fire weapons. That's another indication of the strength of the Syrian rebels in contrast to Iraqi and Afghan insurgents in our fights.

I will say, if Assad really has 200,000 ground security forces available, they probably have enough on paper to hold an arc from the western coastal region down to Damascus--but excluding Aleppo. But Assad would have to evacuate security forces, key assets (like ammunition, arms, chemical weapons, missiles, and aircraft), and supporters from areas outside that core area. And Assad would have to restore the morale of his supporters and troops. I still think a Russian combat contingent (say a naval infantry regiment at Russia's naval post in Syria and a parachute regiment to screen the truncated border with Turkey) might do the trick.

But Syrian morale might not survive such a big withdrawal. Which is rough since Syrian morale won't survive the current fight, either.

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

The Pinky Swear Gambit.

Iran has come up with the obvious alternative to intrusive inspections to verify they are not pursuing nuclear weapons.

Pity we didn't think of this years ago:

A news agency says Iran plans to submit a written promise to the United Nations that it will not seek nuclear weapons.

Well, then, never mind. I feel so silly for worrying.

A Feature and Not a Bug

When people have gotten worked up over the potential threat that militias can pose, what you set them up to do really matters. Assad wants them to kill and that is the difference between his militias and our militias in Iraq and Afghanistan.

When we've set up local defense force militias, either in Iraq or Afghanistan, critics here have opposed it worrying that they'd become little warlord militias that would contribute to violence rather than fight insurgents. While their worry about possible outcomes is justified, local defense forces properly trained and regulated are a key factor in generating the numbers you need to protect/control populations at an affordable cost.

Face it, even if you could recruit and afford it, it wouldn't make sense to have SEAL Team 6-level troops for every security task from storming an outpost behind enemy lines to manning a traffic circle check point.

But you have to watch militias and retrain them when they stray or disband them when no longer needed to avoid them becoming a threat. Indeed, early in the Iraq War I counted Shia militias in the government column because they did carry out needed self-defense missions against Sunni Arab terrorists. But by 2006, they were just Iranian-backed death squads that were purely part of the threat. So they can go bad.

But Assad shows what critics of local defense forces really worry about: militias whose purpose upon establishment is just to kill:

The Syrian government is reportedly using local militias known as Popular Committees to commit mass killings which are at times sectarian in nature, U.N. human rights investigators said on Monday.

But of course, that reflects the difference between why we set up local defense forces--protecting people from insurgents and terrorists--and the Syrian government' objectives which the militias complement rather than undermine:

"Indiscriminate and widespread shelling, the regular bombardment of cities, mass killing and the deliberate firing on civilian targets have come to characterize the daily lives of civilians in Syria," Pinheiro said.

What you are fighting to achieve really matters. Assad's militias are doing exactly what he intended them to do. They're just another means to kill and terrorize civilians.

Give Pyongyang a Sea of Fire

We are way too used to North Korean threats and violence. Show North Korea what a localized sea of fire looks like.

North Korea's leadership hopefully know that their military is so poor that the only uncertainty of starting a war is how badly North Korea would lose that war. But they may believe that they can debut another season of Dead South Koreans Theater and get away with it, daring South Korea to risk the casualties by striking back and possibly causing an escalation of fighting.

The island of Baengnyeong, with 5,000 people living there, is in the cross hairs:

North Korea leader Kim Jong-Un threatened to "wipe out" a South Korean island as Pyongyang came under new economic and diplomatic fire Tuesday from US sanctions and UN charges of gross rights abuses.

And this analysis of the crisis is simply depressing in the assumptions it carries:

Recent Korean history reveals a sobering possibility: It may only be a matter of time before North Korea launches a sudden, deadly attack on the South. And perhaps more unsettling, Seoul has vowed that this time, it will respond with an even stronger blow.

Really? It is perhaps "more unsettling" that South Korea would likely retaliate? It isn't more unsettling that North Korea periodically kills South Koreans and we are supposed to breathe a sigh of relief that they didn't kill more, and just go on with our lives? And perhaps ship off some rice and heating oil to North Korea?

Isn't it more unsettling that a North Korean regime that is expected to carry out a low-level killing campaign against South Korea--and we are to accept it--is far closer to having nuclear weapons in their arsenal?

South Korea will respond to another round of Dead South Koreans Theater. We should back the South Koreans in inflicting a hard blow in return that will be an obvious defeat for North Korea that no amount of Pyongyang propaganda can disguise. Pick a naval facility and destroy every navy vessel and military structure in and around it, and shoot down any North Korean plane that gets within missile range.

Let's make starting a military crisis the most unsettling thing. If we can't do that now, how will we do it when North Korea has nuclear weapons?

UPDATE: Thoughts on North Korea.

Sea Sick

Will somebody explain to Admiral Samuel J. Locklear III that our pivot to the Pacific isn't for the purpose of combating global warming?

Via The Weekly Standard comes this disturbing analysis of Pacific Command's mission:

Navy Admiral Samuel J. Locklear III, in an interview at a Cambridge hotel Friday after he met with scholars at Harvard and Tufts universities, said significant upheaval related to the warming planet “is probably the most likely thing that is going to happen . . . that will cripple the security environment, probably more likely than the other scenarios we all often talk about.’’

“People are surprised sometimes,” he added, describing the reaction to his assessment. “You have the real potential here in the not-too-distant future of nations displaced by rising sea level. [emphasis added]

Are you effing kidding me?

Let me assure the admiral that if we ever need to evacuate entire nations displaced by rising sea levels--which goes on regardless of global warming's effect--that he won't need to rush in amphibs to rescue people as water visibly rises above their heads as we watch with horror from on board our ships. Really, people will have plenty of time to go and it won't require the Navy. I bet we can charter ships and planes. Or people might start moving out decades before they are swamped all on their own.

And it certainly won't happen during his period of command.

Honestly, the statement is so blatantly stupid that I can't imagine our admiral actually believing it except in a very narrow "I think it is less likely that China will start a war, so technically losing a nation to sea rise is 'more likely'" sort of way.

I would also like to remind the admiral that wars sometimes happen not because somebody decided to start one out of the blue, but because some small incident spirals out of control. Is that really less likely than rescuing the people of Tarawa? During your time in command?

It just sounds like blatant sucking up to the White House where such worries pass as strategy. And worse than that, it is just stupid.

Unless Admiral Locklear was ordered to make this statement by his civilian superiors. In which case, I commend him for his ability to salute and follow orders despite the idiocy level so apparent. His is but to do and die of embarrassment, and all that.

And I assure you, the Chinese aren't ever going to believe that we are pivoting to the Pacific and developing Air-Sea Battle doctrine to combat rising sea levels. Indeed, it is an insult to the Chinese for the admiral to dismiss China as a threat scenario he needs to worry about in favor of global warming.

If this is the best salvo our Navy can come up with in the budget battles with the Army and Air Force, I swear to God the Navy deserves to have a shrinking fleet. After all, fewer hulls in the water theoretically reduces the sea water level doesn't it? I mean, if that's really his main worry.

I'm going to go silently weep for our Navy for a bit, now.

Blinking Requires Eyes to Be Open At Some Point

Did we just "blink" in talks with Iran? That would require going in to the talks with our eyes wide open, wouldn't it?

Instapundit notes this piece:

It was no mere chance that Iran’s representatives left the talks with big smiles on their faces, declaring that the “ice was melting” in their relationship with the US, and that they were optimistic about their talks with the rest of the world. After two years of facing the six world powers as a united and unyielding front, in Kazakhstan the Iranians saw those powers blink for the first time. It seemed as if the Americans and some of the Europeans exchanged their hard line with a desire to make some “progress” in their talks with Iran, and provided de facto recognition for the continuation of that country’s nuclear program.

Reset worked so well with Russia. What the heck.

Iran has bought time. We seem happy to provide it since in my most cynical moments, I think we're buying time, too:

Heck, time is really just what most Westerners want, too. If only Iran will go nuclear before we strike, these Westerners can claim it is too late to do anything about Iran's nuclear program--darn the luck, we were so close to doing something--and we just have to stop worrying and learn to love the Iranian bomb.

Yeah, I think a lot of people in our adminsitration are more upset that Iran is taking so darned long to go nuclear. If they'd just get on with it, our administration could get on with learning to love deterrence and defend its many glorious nuances.

Monday, March 11, 2013

A Core Interest

So far, Lebanon's involvement in the Syrian civil war has been limited to Lebanese fighting for both sides inside Syria, but refraining from widespread, all-out fighting inside Lebanon. But tensions are rising and that home restraint could end. The retreat from Damascus by the Assad government could signal that eruption into warfare.

Michael Totten writes about the friction building in northern Lebanon:

Lebanon always looks and feels like it's ready to erupt into armed conflict, but today it's more ready than usual. The Syrian civil war next door weighs heavily on this place. Sunnis and Alawites are fighting round after round with no end in sight in the city of Tripoli, and now the Northern Bekaa Valley, between Mount Lebanon and the Syrian border, is likewise gearing up to explode.

Northern Lebanon will explode when Assad finally realizes he can't hold Damascus and points south with the ground forces he can field. That's because Assad will want some strategic north-south depth by dominating if not controlling northern Lebanon; and because Assad will need a route to supply Hezbollah in order to maintain the support of Iran even in a shrunken rump Alawite-based state.

But thank goodness we didn't militarize the conflict by arming the Syrian rebels at the beginning of last year.

Go West, Young Han

China is eying the former Soviet republics in central Asia for economic advantage. Russia worries that the flag follows trade, with the PLA right in the middle of that hand off. A Chinese pivot to the interior of Asia certainly helps our pivot to the littorals of Asia.

China wants better rail links to central Asia:

China is offering to build new railroads into Central Asia. This is part of a $300 billion plan to upgrade and expand Chinese railways over the next two decades years. Chinese businesses are investing more billions to create new businesses in Central Asia and the cheapest way to get goods in or out of this landlocked area is via rail.

Which raises interesting possibilities:

Something Russia does not like to discuss openly is the fact that Chinese railroads extending into Central Asia would make it easier for China to carry out major military operations in the area. With rail lines extending deep into Central Asia China could more easily threaten a long feared invasion of Russia to take back the eastern territories that many Chinese believe are theirs.

Strategypage says China is unlikely to do that as long as Russia has lots of nukes, but I'm not so sure. Does Russia really carry out a nuclear murder-suicide pact over control of limited peripheral areas outside of the core of European Russia?

Still, getting China pointed to the interior of Asia is surely in our interest. It might also end that annoying tendency of the Russians to loudly complain about the non-threat that NATO poses to Russia while pretending to ignore rising Chinese power that could start round three of territory shedding, following the 1989 loss of Eastern Europe and the 1991 loss of many non-Russian republics of the USSR.

A Good Plan for Last Year

Assad is losing control of most of his country, and is focusing on a western core of Syria. He has too few troops to hold that smaller territory.

This is interesting:

Assad, fighting to maintain his family's four-decade-old grip on Syria, appears to be focusing his military campaign on holding the main cities, along a highway axis running north of Homs to Hama and Aleppo and south to Damascus and Deraa, according to opposition sources.

This fits with my thinking of over a year ago that Assad had to pull back his troops to hold an arc from the Turkish border on the coast, and then down to the Jordanian and Israeli borders along the main highway mentioned above. My major difference is that I didn't include Aleppo in the area to be held.

Another difference is that by holding a core Syria over a year ago, it could be done with excess forces allowing strategic outposts in the non-core areas to be held until Assad could build up forces to expand out from his core Syria. As late as July 2012, I calculated that Assad could hold a shrunken Core Syria.

But Assad no longer has the troops to hold even a Core Syria. Strategypage estimates that Assad has 100,000 reliable ground forces (army and para-militaries). That's half of what I figured Assad would need to hold just the Core Syria.

Assad is a step behind in adjusting to reality. He tried to hold all of Syria when he had the troops only to hold a Core Syria. Now he tries to hold a Core Syria when he only has the troops to hold a rump Alawite state from the coast to the main north-south highway for some strategic depth. Even extending that border down to Damascus is just too much land to hold with the troops he has.

A strategic retreat isn't going to be easy. But expecting too few troops to hold what he has when those troops can only rotate out of the war in a pine box or by deserting/defecting is impossible. That's the reality that Assad hasn't accepted yet.

Screw You, Smug Planet Killers

I've long suspected that electric cars would turn out to be more polluting in their life cycle. Depending on how your electricity is generated and how many miles you drive your car, your electric car can easily be more polluting than a conventional car.

I enjoyed this article a lot, since I've been waiting for this kind of analysis for many years:

If a typical electric car is driven 50,000 miles over its lifetime, the huge initial emissions from its manufacture means the car will actually have put more carbon-dioxide in the atmosphere than a similar-size gasoline-powered car driven the same number of miles. Similarly, if the energy used to recharge the electric car comes mostly from coal-fired power plants, it will be responsible for the emission of almost 15 ounces of carbon-dioxide for every one of the 50,000 miles it is driven—three ounces more than a similar gas-powered car.

Even if the electric car is driven for 90,000 miles and the owner stays away from coal-powered electricity, the car will cause just 24% less carbon-dioxide emission than its gas-powered cousin. This is a far cry from "zero emissions." Over its entire lifetime, the electric car will be responsible for 8.7 tons of carbon dioxide less than the average conventional car.

Those 8.7 tons may sound like a considerable amount, but it's not. The current best estimate of the global warming damage of an extra ton of carbon-dioxide is about $5. This means an optimistic assessment of the avoided carbon-dioxide associated with an electric car will allow the owner to spare the world about $44 in climate damage. On the European emissions market, credit for 8.7 tons of carbon-dioxide costs $48.

That doesn't even mention the carbon expenditures to replace the battery during the life of the car. If you hope to have even a chance to spare the planet, you'd best drive that electric car until a full charge on your battery that will hold less and less of a charge over the years gets you to the end of your driveway.

And for the fun of it, my federal tax dollars subsidize wealthy people who can afford the more expensive electrics to the tune of a $7,500.00 maximum subsidy to buyers per vehicle--not including direct aid to the electric car industry.

So those smug jerks who are "saving the planet" are actually killing the planet (by their beliefs), adding to the federal budget deficit, and screwing the 99% they probably think they are part of.

Sunday, March 10, 2013

The People Have Spoken. Damn Them

In a world with too much voting theater where thug regimes go through the motions of voting and pretend it is democracy, actual voting that includes rule of law will be an inconvenient exercise for much of the world.

Yes, the people of the Falkland Islands are voting on their future:

On Sunday and Monday, the inhabitants of the Falkland Islands, a wind-swept, sparsely populated archipelago that was a final way station for early 20th-century explorers like Ernest Shackleton en route to the icy wastes of Antarctica, will go to the polls in a referendum on the islands’ future.

How can one deny the obvious democracy taking place? Denial with a dose of a shudder at the implications, of course:

The Argentine foreign minister, Héctor Timerman, calling the islanders “settlers,” has been equally blunt. “The Falkland Islanders do not exist,” he has said.

They "do not exist." They are "disappeared" in plain sight. I wonder why so few will think the alternative to British rule is joining the mainland?

The Obama administration does not back Britain in their claims. It is a bit misleading to say that this is the same as the Reagan administration's position. One, recall that in the early 1980s we were in intense competition with the Soviet Union over the future of Latin America. We didn't want to throw the region to Moscow by openly siding with Britain. And two, we did quietly support the British with weapons and logistics. And we would have done more, if needed:

Mr Reagan would have loaned Britain the use of the amphibious warship USS Iwo Jima should harm have come to either HMS Invincible or HMS Hermes, which the Royal Navy had deployed to defend the islands from Argentinian forces.

The amphibious carrier would have functioned just like the light British carriers. Really, if we were actually so awful to Britain during that war as some allege, why were Reagan and Thatcher so close after?

Good luck with the French being as generous with the carrier they are supposed to share with Britain. Just hope the French overseas territories minister isn't the one making the call. He's probably the only one in the French government with views like that, right?

Make sure France has enough contracts for oil exploration around the Falklands, just in case.

A Reminder to Read the Foot Notes

When we speak of promoting "democracy", never forget that it is really shorthand for voting and rule of law. We assume the latter because it is pretty ingrained here as the necessary companion to voting, but plenty of countries show that it is possible to have voting without democracy because rule of law is absent.

Speaking of Kenya:

Uhuru Kenyatta, indicted for crimes against humanity, was declared winner of Kenya's presidential election on Saturday, but rival Raila Odinga said he would challenge the outcome in court and asked supporters to avoid violence.

This isn't even getting to the big violators like Iran and Venezuela.

Not that we should be cocky in the West, when you consider Italy.

I won't be so cruel as to suggest America as an example, too. But we do have problems with rule of law, at times. We're at least not at the fascist clown stage. But even without big floppy shoes, this isn't really what we signed up for, is it?

Democracy* is hard. Voting is easy. Voting is certainly necessary for democracy, but they aren't the same thing.

Gone Native

Sadly, the French minister didn't mean "dead" when he said this:

Victorin Lurel, the minister for France's overseas territories, was impressed by the late Venezuelan leader Hugo Chavez’s funeral and said on Saturday that the world needed “more dictators” like him.

At first, I thought, "way to go!" More dead dictators! But no, the nuance--she oozed:

“I’ll be criticised for saying this, but the world needs more dictators like Hugo Chavez, if it’s a dictator that he actually was. He showed a strong respect for human rights.”

Wow. The idiocy, ideology, and ignorance are just astounding. But no worries for Minister Lurel. His social calendar will remain full. In his own social circles, he'll be praised for being so brave.

Still, what do you expect? French elites traditionally love any thug who hates America. What's the excuse of our left wingers who shed real tears for the death of that man? My only regret over the death of Hugo Chavez is that SEAL Team 6 didn't get him. But I'm compassionate that way, hoping for a quick rather than lingering death for Hugo, I guess.

As for simpliste moi, I do think the world needs more dictators like Chavez--dead.

Saturday, March 09, 2013

The New Measuring Stick

India's defense budget is unlikely to match China's modernization effort. Until India can strengthen their economy to get closer to China's defense budget, they'll need better diplomacy to gain allies to distract China's power from the India front.

This analyst is worried about the future India-China balance (tip to Defense Industry Daily):

Despite the long list of obsolescent weapons and equipment in service with the Indian armed forces, the present military gap with China is quantitative rather than qualitative. However, as India’s military modernization has been stagnating for several years, this gap is likely to soon become a qualitative one as well. By about 2020-25, China will complete its military modernization and will then be in a position to dictate terms on the resolution of any territorial dispute if India continues to neglect defense preparedness.

One basic problem is that until recently, India measured their military against Pakistan's threat. India easily matched that threat. Now that India recognizes China as the main threat with their own pivot to face China, the basis of judging sufficiency skyrocketed.

And frankly, corruption and inefficiency in India's domestic arms industry is a luxury that India cannot afford when the main threat is China rather than Pakistan.

Despite that change in measuring stick, the current situation isn't too bad at all, considering China's own defense needs. Once India is measuring their defense needs against China, the calculations get far more complicated and far flung in the variables to be considered.

India needs to pay attention to quality more than quantity despite the author's worries about quantity in addition to the quality trend. I know the Chinese have beefed up their transportation infrastructure on their side of the India-China border, but China's ability to send troops to that remote front can't be that great. How much air power could China base in Tibet and other nearby areas to threaten India? Further, the Chinese navy has a long way to go to secure sea lines of communication across the Indian Ocean. So quality matters more than quantity since China can't put the bulk of their forces into the fighting theaters close to India.

I still say that air power is India's most pressing need.

And until India can afford to match China's military with high quality forces in a quantity that can defeat the limited forces China can send to fight India, India will need better diplomacy to keep the many nations worried about China willing to confront China--and thus tie down Chinese power away from India.

Which means India needs to count on America being strong enough to inspire confidence in those nations that they can count on America to back them. Given India's many constituencies that are suspicious of--if not hostile to--aligning with America, that might be the biggest defense hurdle India must face to match China.

India is right to worry about their own defense quality. In the short run, India is fine. In the long run, India needs sufficient military power to divide China's growing power to make their own defense needs affordable. That requires their own power and America's power to be enough to keep small neighbors of China willing to resist China's growing power.

If either India or America falter, smaller neighbors of China will eventually conform their policies to appease China. Each nation that aligns with China will free up Chinese power and add pressure to other neighbors to similarly cut a deal with China.

And that trend will make the power gap with China more difficult for India and America to close. Keeping that gap from widening will be far cheaper than closing the gap in the future once it appears.

Or we might get lucky, I suppose, and get a China that nobody worries about. If China changes to be a nation that no neighbor worries will dismember them or dominate them in ways that hurt them, neighbors won't worry about the military balance with China.

I know, I know, we're big, bad, and evil in the view of many in the world. But the defense budgets of our only two land neighbors, Mexico and Canada--despite past wars--don't really reflect any worry that America wants to invade them, do they? We're easy to hate because it is really fairly safe to hate us. Good grief, we have trouble getting worked up to concrete actions about North Korean and Iranian threats, let alone contemplating wars against Canada or Mexico. But not everybody is lucky enough to be the neighbor of America. So I don't wonder that India worries about being the neighbor of the China they have rather than the China they'd like to have.

How Do You Solve a Problem Like Mursi?

I may not think much of the Obama administration's abilities, but I'll not deny that even a hypothetical perfect administration of my dreams would have a lot of problems solving the Egypt issue.

Egypt's miltiary can't be a third force between protesters and the government if ultimately it defends the government.

Egypt's police forces withdrew from the streets of the restive Egyptian city of Port Said on the Suez Canal and the military took over main security duties Friday, trying to calm a wave of protests and deadly clashes that turned into virtual revolt against the government.

In round one of Egypt's Arab Spring, the military essentially took the side of the protesters in regard to the fate of Mubarak. Obviously, they were looking out for the interests of their officer class and supporters, but the military did ease Mubarak out of office in at least a symbolic protest victory.

But now, with Mursi drawing the anger of protesters, would the military really pressure Mursi to step down or back down and give up some powers?

Or is the military hoping that their presence on the streets of Port Said will make the protesters stay home out of some sense that the military is on the protesters' side?

Given the events of the Arab Spring's outcome thus far in Egypt, with a new dictatorship shaping up under the Islamist Mursi, I kind of doubt the protesters have that kind of faith in the military.

Will the military enforce security when the protesters come out again? And not just give the orders. Will the lower ranking soldiers obey orders to shoot protesters?

Heck, given that the lower ranking soldiers probably like Mursi, will the corrupt higher ranking officers live to regret unleashing soldiers loyal to Mursi more than they are loyal to their own leadership? If Mursi sees the army willing to shoot, might he not just figure he can purge the officer corps and leave himself with a loyal military?

Who cares if the newly minted generals can't fight a war? They can certainly beat down and kill civilians. Really, a purge of the military isn't going to affect the outcome of a war with Israel. Israel would win whether or not the current officers are giving orders. And Egypt would retain enough military power to overwhelm either Hamas, Libya, or Sudan in any armed conflict.

Egypt is tough. A lot of conservatives condemn President Obama for not backing Mubarak in the first place. But I don't think that was a viable strategy. I also assume that unless Egypt makes a clean break with us, that the Camp David Accords require us to pay Egypt to keep the peace with Israel. That's worth the price even though I have no doubt Egypt would lose that fight. And I do want to keep influence with the military in the hope that some semblance of rule of law can be established in Egypt, and that the military will see that as the best way to protect their privileged status. So I don't support halting weapons shipments to Egypt.

Our objective should be to strengthen rule of law. I'm not happy with Mursi and his band of Moslem Brotherhood Islamists. But unless we want to drive Egypt into chaos by cutting them off from aid or invading them, what are we to do? Be patient. Keep pushing Egypt to enact economic and legal reforms that limit the government's powers, and hope for the best. We may get the worst, but I'm in no hurry to see it arrive.

I can't say I know that the administration is trying to push Egypt to reform, but coming down hard on Egypt doesn't seem like much of an option right now. So I can't in good conscience criticize the Obama administration too much on this issue.

This Seems Different

I know we are used to bombastic North Korean threats and even bouts of violence since the Korean War was suspended, but North Korea has upped the ante to actual actions that seem to clear the decks for higher levels of violence.

This seems qualitatively different from past bouts of threats:

North Korea says it is scrapping all non-aggression pacts with South Korea, closing its hotline with Seoul and shutting their shared border point.

Add in large-scale North Korean military maneuvers, and this paints a far more ominous picture.

Granted, if North Korea starts a war, the chance of them surviving the war let alone winning it is pretty low. Their military has rusted away over the last couple decades.

But if North Korea starts something, it will be particularly ugly for the very reason that the North Korean military is so poorly prepared to fight a conventional war. North Korea would have to initiate the war with mass use of chemical weapons to have a chance of winning. Slam Seoul with chemicals to sow panic and confusion in the government (messing with command and control and distracting leaders with immediate civilian needs) while hitting military targets in the hope that chemical weapons will cause enough panic to open wide gaps in the front line allowing North Korean troops to motor south with minimal resistance.

Perhaps closing the hotline, shutting the border post, and declaring the ceasefire dead (or is that included in the pacts scrapped?) are just more of the same, but I don't recall these things being done before. I might just be unaware of past similar incidents.

And given that South Koreans have gotten used to threats to turn Seoul into a sea of fire, perhaps the North Koreans feel they need to turn the Psycho Dial to 11 to generate the same amount of fear.

UPDATE: North Korea says the armistice is no longer valid. In 2003, according to this article, North Korea said that they might have no alternative but to stop honoring the armistice; and in 2009, the North Koreans said they were no longer bound by the armistice.

The 2003 event seems more like a threat to abandon the 1953 ceasefire. Whether not honoring the ceasefire is different than declaring it invalid is beyond my comprehension of North Korean legal thought.

Does this mean we get a free shot at North Korea? I mean, we are on a break, right?

Some Opinions Are More Respected Than Others

School insanity continues:

In the latest incident of anti-gun hysteria to erupt in a school setting, officials at an elementary school in small-town Michigan impounded a third-grader boy’s batch of 30 homemade birthday cupcakes because they were adorned with green plastic figurines representing World War Two soldiers.

The school principal branded the military-themed cupcakes “insensitive” in light of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting, reports Fox News Radio.

“It disgusted me,” Casey Fountain, the boy’s father, told Fox News. “It’s vile they lump true American heroes with psychopathic killers.”

Well, sure. Considering that deranged World War II veterans burst into Sandy Hook Elementary and gunned down innocent children. Wait. That didn't happen? Oh ...

And even with time to think, the school's administrators defended their action to remove the toy soldiers:

"These are toys that were commonplace in the past,” Wright said. “However, some parents prohibit all guns as toys. In light of that difference, the school offered to replace the soldiers with another item and the soldiers were returned home with the student.”

“Living in a democratic society entails respect for opposing opinions,” the principal also said. “In the climate of recent events in schools we walk a delicate balance in teaching non-violence in our buildings and trying to ensure a safe, peaceful atmosphere.”

Apparently, those with anti-gun views aren't to be exposed to the opinion that American soldiers in World War II used their guns to defend our freedoms and liberate conquered people. We don't even have to get to the last decade plus of American troops going overseas to help protect us. We're talking the ultimate "good" war fought by the "Greatest Generation" here. They fought Nazis, Fascists, and Militarists! Communists may have their fervent defenders here despite the higher body count, but not even Fascists have that many supporters these days.

Yes, that failure to distinguish is vile.

So no, the school is not respecting differing opinions. The side that doesn't allow their children to have toy guns has a veto over displays of opinion on that subject.

Which is kind of confusing, since in the gun debate, the control side keeps saying that only people in authority should have weapons. Don't toy soldiers then represent both sides of the debate?

And no, that decision did nothing to keep the school safe.

Look, I could at least respect the school more if they defended their action on the refusal to allow any type of decoration like that. I could see some parents wanting to send in little pro-abortion adornments, crosses, hammers and sickles, peace signs, Darwin fish, Metallica logos, or whatever, to make a point. And there will be parents who will get upset over any little thing. Why invite more grief in your work day, eh?

But to say that banning World War II toy soldiers helps teach non-violence is ridiculous. How do they teach any history at all?

If ensuring a safe and peaceful atmosphere is the issue, have more adult supervision during recess!

Heck, in this day and age I should be grateful that the school allows cupcakes into the school. For some reading the story, that was probably the biggest outrage of the incident. Put swastikas on a plate of carrot sticks, and they'd be fine with that.

UPDATE: At least we aren't as bad as the British (tip to Instapundit):

For 15 years she has proudly served her country as a Royal Navy engineer, risking her life in Afghanistan when she fought against the Taliban.

But far from showing Nicky Howse the respect she deserved as she flew back to her latest posting, Virgin Atlantic staff chose to humiliate her – by demanding that she remove her uniform because it was ‘offensive’.

They warned the 32-year-old helicopter technician she would not be allowed to fly unless she took off her combat fatigues and wore a sleep suit instead.

That's shameful.

And perhaps the sidebar showing how Americans still support our troops even after more than a decade of war, maybe Virgin Atlantic will be shamed into changing their policy.

UPDATE: Idiots have power over us.

Since we can't stop idiots from using the petty authority they have to muck things up, stop granting that authority in the first place rather than trying to find non-idiots to exercise that authority.