Monday, June 05, 2017

Survive the Threat and Be the Threat

While I welcome a review of what a frigate should do, the problem isn't that threats are changing but that the Littoral Combat Ship (LCS) was a failure for the threat it was intended to face.

Okay:

A planned $143 million review of the Navy’s future frigate design was prompted by a changing threat environment that will require the ship to complete more missions, top service officials told Congress this week.

The review was included as part of President Donald Trump’s fiscal 2018 budget request, released Tuesday.

The money, budget documents say, will allow the Navy to “reassess the capabilities required to ensure the multi-mission frigate paces future threats.” Priorities, according to the request, include maximizing lethality and survivability, particularly in the areas of surface warfare, air warfare through local area defense, and anti-submarine warfare.

The future frigate is set to be based on the controversial littoral combat ship, a platform that saw major cost overruns in its early years and still faces harsh criticism from oversight authorities on survivability and ability to execute its major mission sets.

We want a frigate instead of the LCS (which was good in concept with modularity but failed in practice) that was to replace the frigate, but the LCS is not survivable and doesn't have the firepower to fight blue water threats. So this review is a good development.

But let's not pretend that the LCS would have been great if only the threat environment hadn't changed.

The original mission was always impossible. The LCS was horrible for the littoral environment for which the Littoral Combat Ship was intended!

Sunday, June 04, 2017

Weekend Data Dump

Solar/Wind Apples and Fossil Fuel Oranges. If renewable energy is so great at producing jobs, why do renewable boosters have to lie about the benefits? Tip to Instapundit.

When we need a "why do they hate us?" debate we won't get it. Yeah, nobody is proclaiming "we are all journalists, now."

If Trump demanded that Canada not prosecute Americans in their country for certain crimes, it would be rightly called an awful, modern version of extraterritoriality. But when Denver virtually green lights domestic violence by illegal aliens to avoid deportation, that's compassion. Or something. Probably something. Isn't it odd that citizens and legal foreign residents will be punished more harshly for crimes than illegal immigrants? Membership has more privileges for being an American Express cardholder than just being an American in Denver's criminal justice system. Tip to Instapundit for the Denver news.

Ethnic cleansing for a day.

Aerial jousting over Syria. Let's hope we learn more than the Russians.

We are not in end days. So just stop the panic-mongering.

Sigh. They should really be less concerned with carbon footprints and more concerned with car bomb footprints. Seriously, stop that.

Actual Resistance to actual dictatorship. I point this out as a basis of comparison to the faux resistors in America who preen about their so-called bravery.

For liberals these days, you are either against Trump or you are for him. I don't think the world nuance means what they think it means. Tip to Instapundit.

A hateful man killed two men who intervened to defend two Moslem women from a hateful tirade in Portland, Oregon. The men who were murdered (and a third survived) should be hailed as much as the man who killed him should be punished to the full extent of the law. His tirade against the women and murderous actions against the men were unacceptable in America. He is free to hate, of course. As awful as that is. But taking action on the hate is unacceptable. Keep your damn hate to yourself and whoever can stand your company. Where did he get his hate? Trump is the obvious suspect, I'm sure. Sadly, the killer seems to be a Bernie Sanders (socialist) and Jill Stein (Green--socialist who recycles) fan. Oops for the narrative. I hate to go here. It shouldn't be about politics. But Stein blamed the killing on "Trump's America." How's Stein's Portland looking, eh?

Are journalists rushing to claim a Republican Congressional candidate who roughed up a journalist was due to the hostile environment established by President Trump's criticism of the media thinking things out? If anything happens to President Trump, how can we describe the environment established by almost uniformly hostile media coverage of the president? Where will the blame fall for an assault on the president in that environment?

Laws are for the little people.

I'm not going to pretend I know enough to say this domestic spying under the Obama administration is as horrible as it sounds. I wasn't horrified at necessary meta-data retrieval during the Bush administration and didn't get outraged when Obama did it, too. So I will wait. What I will say now is that if the media had reported Trump or Bush doing this spying there would be widespread media talk of dictatorship and the need for impeachment and prison for the president involved rather than relative radio silence.

It's nice when stupidity has consequences.

What happened to Max Boot? I'm no fan of Saudi Arabia (or of Pakistan, for that matter), but in the real world we have to deal with them and use them as allies. But according to Max Boot's logic, FDR should be condemned for allying with Stalin to fight Hitler rather than resisting both. My guess is that Boot is tired of not getting invited to Georgetown and Upper West Side cocktail parties.

"Climate change" is keeping Americans up at night because of the heat. I don't suppose it would matter that the global temperature has been flat for about two decades? I didn't think so. Then I guess I can only hope that decades after we could send a man to the moon we could figure out how to lower temperatures and humidity of indoor air ("condition" it?) so we could at least get a good night's sleep. I am a dreamer, I know.

Oh, if only a single "teach in" could educate the dunderheads upset about GPA redistribution.

Yes, as I've written many times, it is a fool's game for conservatives to focus on controlling the federal government rather than reducing its scope so it just doesn't matter much who runs it.

And I'm going to ask again why our military didn't respond to the Benghazi attack on September 11, 2012. I want to believe that our military naturally prepared to move to the sound of the guns. If they didn't, we have a bigger problem than the now-departed (well, except for stay-behinds wreaking havoc) Obama administration. The September 11, 2012 Benghazi attack confirmed my contempt for the Obama administration in its lack of seriousness about the war we remain in.  Do remember that two days before that attack I wrote that our government felt the need to raise the issue of zombie attacks to encourage emergency preparedness. They honestly couldn't come up with a real-world threat. Will we ever get an honest accounting of why our military in Europe sat on its hands that day? Do I have to ask this question every week?

This last week I culturally appropriated the Hell out of Mexico and the Arab world by making a taco-meat and shredded cheese on Arabic flat bread in a sort of ersatz (yeah, I'm taking that from the Germans, so suck on it) soft taco.  I love the taste of cultural appropriation in the morning.

At some level, just carrying on as usual after a terror attack just gives the government the opportunity to do nothing to end the threat. Did the British carry on as usual during the Blitz? Or did the British hunker down, sending their children north to safety (sadly, Manchester is no longer a safe haven from murderous bombers of the human type), and fight the threat?

The military's recruiting base is too narrow. I had an article accepted on addressing this problem that is not yet published.

Is it any wonder that liberals think conservatives are the biggest terror threat to America when any killer is portrayed by the left-friendly media as a right-winger regardless of the facts? And recall the Orlando mass murderer who was portrayed as a symptom of conservative alleged homophobia rather than Islamist rage.

This is supposed to be scary but it cheapens the value of Russian deterrence: A Russian legislator said Russia would use nukes if American or other NATO troops entered Russian-occupied Ukraine. So would Russia nuke Russian-occupied Ukrainian territory to strike "invaders" or would Russia fire at America? Because if the latter, Russia would be nuked. Is this threat to use nukes against a less than fatal military action really credible? And isn't it a sign of weakness that Russia would need to resort to nukes so close to home while NATO would be far from its home territories? America would not nuke Russia if Russia invaded Alaska and held some of our territory. We'd drive them out. Because we can. I think that Russian legislator is writing a check that Russia can't afford to cash.

"No, You’re Not More Likely to Be Killed by a Right-Wing Extremist than an Islamic Terrorist[.]" Yeah, don't embarrass yourself by making that ridiculous claim.

These judges are assaulting rule of law. Is that where we want to go? Seriously, we need to push politicized policies back to states so these battles stop tearing America apart.

At what point do gender studies departments get charged as criminal enterprises for taking a lot of money from people to give them worthless degrees that are based on "scholarship" indistinguishable from bullshit?

Seriously, what is going on with this low-profile probe in Congress that has Democrats so upset?

I'd be open to the idea of a basic government (taxpayer)-provided income to all that was simply the base of whatever else you earn, if this led to the elimination of the vast majority of the welfare bureaucracy that dispenses needs-based expenditures. This bureaucracy is so large that it seems more like a jobs program for the well-paid employees than a means to help the poor. I wonder how that Canadian experiment will work?

Putin says he is certain Syria did not use chemical weapons in April. But keep in mind he is certain his army didn't invade Ukraine and is certain he looks good shirtless, hunting tigers.

The rise of Jack D. Ripper in the Democratic party? Duh. I was all over that development 7 months ago! Yeah, the 1980s called and the Democrats answered--but misheard the warning as Russia being our greatest political threat. That kind of threat will get a reaction. As an aside, the Democrats demonized a moderate and decent man in that election simply because he had an (R) after his name.

France is updating their armored vehicle fleet to network it.

America has invited China to RIMPAC 2018, our major naval exercise. I think this is a mistake. China will never learn to fear us, only to believe they understand how to defeat us.

Liberals have (of course) turned the outrage dial to 11 (tell me this is a science issue rather than a matter of faith!) over President Trump's withdrawal from the toothless and unnecessary climate deal signed in Paris. But I'm sure liberals will come around. How many decades did the Democrats ignore the Russian threat? But liberals did discover that! After all, just wait until liberals discover that the now-hated Russians oppose fracking, drilling, and low oil prices in general in order to prop up their economy through energy exports! "Resist Russia" bumper stickers can't be far off on a Prius near you, eh?

Will the Russians (again) cripple their economy for an arms race with America?

The Democrats and the media seem to be unwittingly causing chaos in America, which suits Russia just fine. This is totally unique in that the Democrats are now doing it "unwittingly" unlike their deliberate actions to undermine America for the Soviets in the Cold War.

Demonstrators in Venezuela have taken to pointing out how their socialist ruling class seem to be doing just fine financially as the country dissolves in hunger and poverty around them.

The Sky is Falling! The Sky is Falling!

President Trump isn't ignoring the world's concerns. He's just concluding that the world is concerned about something stupid that serves their interests rather than ours--and certainly not the planet's.

This should shock nobody:

The US president has announced the withdrawal of the world’s largest economy from the Paris agreement. Europe and China have vowed to push ahead without Washington [emphasis added].

They will push ahead with a toothless and irrelevant pact?

China isn't even required to reduce emissions under global agreements prior to this BS agreement that even Warministas disliked--until America exited--because nothing was mandatory.

And Europe set their base against which they measure reductions the period after the collapse of the Soviet empire in eastern Europe in order to include emissions from heavy industries that would have been shut down anyway as inefficient enterprises unfit for Western economies. So it is fake progress that Europe boasts about even as America made better progress than Europe even after pulling out of the Kyoto agreement under Bush 43.

Truly, the fake progress is baked into the Paris agreement. It just doesn't matter if anybody keeps their commitments let alone whether America does.

This is religious faith--not science. I swear, interpretative dance is next.

I remain far more worried about car bomb footprints than carbon footprints.

How long before some global warming fanatic tells us that the little girls butchered at Manchester will at least be saved from the scourge of living in a world 0.05 degrees Celsius warmer than we'd be if Trump kept America in the Paris agreement?

Enjoy the volume at 11. I'm sure Trump will do three more things to destroy the world next week, too, and keep the shrieking going.

And the odds are good that there will be three more killing sprees by jihadis in that week that won't enrage any leftist one bit.

Saturday, June 03, 2017

Terror Attack in London

There seems little doubt that there was a terror attack in London based on running down pedestrians with a van and then stabbing people. There are reports of gunfire but perhaps that was security forces trying to hit attackers. And I'm assuming jihadis. But it is early. So facts may sort out by morning.

One sign it was a terror attack was the alert given to the British people by the government to "run, hide, tell." I assume that means run from the terrorists, hide when you are clear, and tell the authorities what you know.

I think the British government had better start a new order for their police, intelligence, and military forces: "find, kill, repeat" for the jihadi scum who do this.

And get on that new terror level system I've suggested.

UPDATE: Some fought back before the British armed response that shot the attackers after they exited their vehicle used to run down people and begin stabbing people.

I've heard 7 dead victims plus 3 attackers shot dead by armed police.

In related news, the British army may be slashed even further:

Officers are preparing to reduce the size of the army to as little as 65,000 after the Conservatives dropped a pledge to maintain the force at its target of 82,000, The Times understands.

Options being considered within the military include reducing the army by 17,000 personnel to less than two thirds of the size of the French army and only slightly bigger than Germany’s land force, according to two defence sources.

I'm not sure how the British will fight jihadis inside Britain let alone overseas with this size of a force.

An option as low as 55,000 is not on the table. But give it a few years. Then it will be the middle "prudent" option.

Churchill promised to fight the Nazis on the beaches and in the streets, if necessary. The British military prevented that from happening.

Jihadis have managed to reach what German military might could not.

A Whole New (Old) War

Once, President Obama said Assad had to leave office. That was several hundred dead Syrians ago, a nuclear deal with Iran to make them a responsible power, and an interlude of fighting ISIL that is getting nearer to the end. So President Trump might be the one who gets to enforce that old demand.

Strategypage looks at the Syria battlefield. And I've noted the new fight developing in Syria.

Saying Assad has won the civil war confuses surviving with winning, as a map of the territory shows:


Yes, the defeat of ISIL in Syria just punches the ticket for the new (old) problem of Assad as a threat and vassal state of Iran:

Islamic State’s self-declared caliphate in eastern Syria is surrounded by some of the world’s strongest military powers. Their forces are advancing on several fronts. The battlefield odds aren’t even close.

That’s why the commanders of those armies -- in Washington, Moscow and Tehran, as well as Damascus and Ankara -- are looking beyond the coming showdown with the jihadists. When they’re killed or driven out, who’ll take over? It’s an especially sharp dilemma for President Donald Trump. Because for the second time this century, the U.S. risks defeating one Middle Eastern enemy only to see another one, Iran, emerge as the big winner.

The defeat of Hitler led to the rise of the Soviet problem. The defeat of militaristic Japan led to the rise of the China and Soviet problems. The defeat of the Soviet Union eventually gave us a Russia problem. That's life. Deal with it. Don't hope that an outreach speech and being not-Bush can resolve our problems.

Hoping for a magic victory that resolves all problems was as futile in the last century as it is in this century.

If President Trump is serious about resisting Iran, the Syria front is critical to win. So yeah, America will need to target Assad's regime.

And that's apart from whether it is safe to leave Assad in power after half-heartedly going after him ("when you strike a king, kill him" is a saying because a king merely injured will use his power to exact lethal revenge. Are we really willing to leave Assad in power even if he isn't a vassal of Iran?).

I did say Syria was about to get interesting, did I not?

UPDATE: A looming assault on ISIL-held Raqqa pushes forward the day when the post-ISIL portion of the war will be fought:

A U.S.-backed operation by Syrian forces to capture Islamic State's Syrian "capital" of Raqqa will start in the next "few days", the spokesman for the Syrian Kurdish YPG militia said on Saturday.

ISIL seems to have already relocated much of their state east closer to the Iraqi border. So I doubt the battle for Raqqa will be very long.

A Cyberclusterfuck

You know how upset you get when you lose your Internet connections and can't check Twitter? Imagine the Army being unable to use the Internet.

Good grief, who screwed the pooch on this one?

The Army’s chief of staff told lawmakers Thursday he’s not convinced the service’s troubled Warfighter Information Network-Tactical will survive the rigors of combat.

WIN-T was part of the Army’s Future Combat Systems effort in 2003. After FCS was canceled in 2009, the service tried to salvage the program as part of an effort to create secure battlefield communications for mounted forces on the move — an effort led by General Dynamics Corp. and that has cost about $6 billion.

Thanks General Dynamics!

The whole premise of my article on virtual squads requires a successful, robust, and survivable battlefield Internet.

Indeed, I mentioned WIN-T in the article! And now I find that it is a pile of steaming waste?

At least it has drawn Congressional attention. The Army needs something that works just for what it needs to do now, let alone future projects that could include something like virtual squads.

UPDATE: This writer defends WIN-T. Is this normal development that shouldn't be stopped just to start over on a vitally needed capability?

I lack the knowledge to judge the competing claims.

Friday, June 02, 2017

The Battle for Iranian Supply Lines

American operations in eastern and southern Syria in support of anti-Assad and anti-ISIL militias, including our air strikes on Iranian-backed militias tend to block Iran's efforts to establish secure overland supply routes to Hezbollah.

We are working on the Syria portion of the supply line:

Syrian rebels say the United States and its allies are sending them more arms to try to fend off a new push into the southeast by Iran-backed militias aiming to open an overland supply route between Iraq and Syria.

The stakes are high as Iran seeks to secure its influence from Tehran to Beirut in a "Shi'ite crescent" of Iranian influence through Iraq, Syria and Lebanon, where Sunni Arab states have lost out in power struggles with Iran.

Strategypage looks at the Syria battlefield.

But we can't do much to stop Iranian efforts within Iraq given that the Iranians are guests to fight ISIL there:

An Iraqi Shi'ite force backed by Iran said it pushed Islamic State out of several villages on the border with Syria on Monday, potentially reopening a supply route to send Iranian weapons to President Bashar al-Assad.

The maneuver could also be the prelude to a connection with the Assad's Iranian-backed forces, although they are yet to reach the Iraqi border from the Syrian side.

I hope that an American decision to remain in Iraq in force after ISIL's caliphate inside Iraq is dismantled will encourage the Iraqi government to eject Iranian influence.

And as I've noted, Russia is unlikely to help Iran with this objective because Russia doesn't want Iranian influence in Syria to grow and because Russian objectives--air and naval bases--are secured with just western Syria in Assad's hands.

We're getting closer to a post-ISIL struggle surpassing the struggle to defeat ISIL.

UPDATE: America appears to be serious about blocking Iranian control (in Assad's name) of this supply line:

The U.S. military said on Thursday it had bolstered its "combat power" in southern Syria, warning that it viewed Iran-backed fighters in the area as a threat to nearby coalition troops fighting Islamic State.

We dropped leaflets to warn the Iranian-sponsored militias against moving into the area.

Actual Resistance to an Actual Threat

The NATO Baltic states are getting serious about coping with the Russian threat. They can't stop the Russians but they can resist until liberated.

Take a moment to spare some sympathy to our Baltic state allies whose best defense option is to resist a Russian occupation and hope that NATO liberates them:

Latvia, like the other two Baltic States, is not just spending more money on defense but also implementing many reforms in an effort to deal with return of the Russian military threat and the fact that the three Baltic States are tiny compared to Russia and in need of some new thinking on how to keep the Russians out. ...

The Russian government said it was willing to work with NATO in areas of mutual benefit but that did not work out. Now there is a state of undeclared war between Russia and NATO. These new NATO members are more worried about the renewed Russian aggression than the original NATO members (the U.S. and Western Europe). The nations of “east NATO” are asking for more presence by troops from “west NATO.” Some of the eastern members (especially Poland and the Baltic States) have called for the permanent basing of U.S. troops on their territory. The smaller states Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania believe Russia could overrun them in two days and senior NATO military commanders openly agree. Russia considers such talk more evidence of NATO aggression against Russia. Lithuanians have heard this kind of talk from Russia before and want to avoid the usual outcome.

The Baltic states are too small to build forces capable of halting the Russians at the border.

And the geography of the Baltic states is too dangerous to risk a Russian thrust through Belorus and Lithuania to reach the Baltic Sea and isolate any NATO troops sent to the Baltic states to defend them.

So the best hope is for NATO to preserve its combat power while the Russians overrun Estonia and Latvia, hold the line somewhere in Lithuania (while conquering Kaliningrad), and building up a force to counter-attack and liberate the Baltic territory controlled by Russia.

If our Europe-oriented special forces would focus on working with resisting Baltic citizens and soldiers to harass and kill Russian occupiers until the counter-offensive, that would help.

If American Marines operated in the island of the Baltic Sea off of the mainland to distract the Russians, add to the mayhem, and support the resistance, that would be great, too.

Indeed, we might consider a Tobruk-like bastion in Riga held by Marines and surviving Baltic state military units that retreat there.

I noted these options in a basic outline shortly after Russia invaded Ukraine.

Obviously, I anticipate that NATO allies would contribute to these efforts even as I specify American forces.

We should not let our Baltic allies down given what they will endure should Russia invade.

Thursday, June 01, 2017

The Weapon of the Losers

Strategypage has a good overview of the use of IEDs in Iraq.

NOTE: Oddly, this was drafted for October 31, 2008 but I did not publish it (or it did not publish from a glitch).

It seems relevant since President Trump (accurately) labeled jihadis as "losers" after the Manchester, England terrorist bombing.

I Fully Understand Why So Many People Want to Say to Hell With the World

If "the world" thinks that removing a bloody and aggressive dictator and then spending our lives and treasure to defend those once-oppressed people so they can build democracy destroyed our soft power democratic appeal to "the world," then to Hell with those people because there is no satisfying them.

Really?

[Edward] Luce doesn't mince words: "It is hard to overstate the damage the Iraq War did to America's global soft power -- and to the credibility of the West's democratic mission."

And the damage continues: "[I]n the eyes of the Islamists, Trump has simply dropped the pretense. The West was always at war with Islam. Trump has removed the mask. At a moment when ISIS is on the military retreat in Iraq and Syria, Trump has made their drive for fresh recruits much easier."

Democracy, it turns out, is difficult to promote at the end of a gun.

I will remind you that jihadis attacked America on September 11, 2001, a full year and a half before we led the invasion of Iraq to topple Saddam and liberate his people. And planning for the al Qaeda terror attack went back well into the Clinton administration.

As for Iraq being an assault on Islam in the eyes of Islamists, what on God's green Earth doesn't set them off?

Also, explain the 2011 Arab Spring's (failed) drive to replace autocracy with democracy rather than hope Islamist rule will solve the Arab world's problems? After 8 years of American presence in Iraq fighting to defend democracy those young people in the Arab world rose up calling for democracy.

Let me note that I am repulsed at how racist it is not to admit that eight years of the soothing balms of hope and change and a perfectly lovely outreach speech to the Islamic world by President Obama didn't restore our soft power wrecked by overthrow of the brutal dictator Saddam Hussein.

Ponder that Islamists simply think Obama was just a better concealed version of Trump in Luce's analysis that condemns America.

So doesn't blaming Trump for inspiring the recruitment of killers of little girls lead to the uncomfortable conclusion that only one portion of the alienated "world" has decided that mass murder of Western children and other civilians is the right response?

You can't get democracy at the end of a gun. But you can sure end or prevent democracy at the end of a gun.

So guns in the hands of good guys are necessary to provide the opportunity to build democracy in the face of bad guys with guns who don't want it. That's what we did and that's what Luce condemns as alienating the world.

That glorious soft power didn't protect us on 9/11 and it won't protect us in the future as long as killers who rejoice at the deaths of little girls are allowed to live.

I guarantee that when we drive those loser killers into the ground and drive their faces into the dirt with defeat and a jihadi body count so bad that they can't spin it into victory, their recruitment will decline.

To Hell with Luce. So I'm not mincing words, you understand.

Not Too Bad for Six Days

The 50-year anniversary of the Six Day War is coming up.

This article about the war between Israel and the Arab states Egypt, Syria, and Jordan notes:

The Six-Day War did not, however, lead to peace, even a partial one. That would have to wait until the October 1973 war, which set the stage for what became the Camp David Accords and the Israel-Egypt peace treaty. The Arab side emerged from this subsequent conflict with its honor restored; Israelis for their part emerged chastened. There is a valuable lesson here: decisive military outcomes do not necessarily lead to decisive political results, much less peace. [emphasis added]

So the war in 1967 didn't really achieve much of a result and had to await a future war with less decisive (at least initially) outcomes?

But the author states of the 1967 war in the paragraph just before the one quoted above:

The one-sided battle and its outcome put an end to the notion (for some, a dream) that Israel could be eliminated. The 1967 victory made Israel permanent in ways that the wars of 1948 and 1956 did not. The new state finally acquired a degree of strategic depth. Most Arab leaders came to shift their strategic goal from Israel’s disappearance to its return to the pre-1967 war borders. [emphasis added]

Did I miss something important unstated between those paragraphs?

I'm going to make the amazing statement that putting an end to the dream in the front line Arab states that Israel could be eliminated and making Israel a permanent fixture of the Middle East was a decisive political result.

But that's just me, I guess.

Wednesday, May 31, 2017

I Wish Someone With a More Nuanced Brain Than I Have Would Explain Our Libya Policy

When it comes to the West's Libya policy, the left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing.

Western nations are mostly united to fight jihadi terrorists. That's good. America carries the burden, but others do help.

But then we come to Libya where the West doesn't seem to have a freaking clue about what we are fighting:

The basic problem is that the UN and most Western nations continue to back the GNA despite the fact that the GNA relies too much on Islamic conservative militias and senior Libyan Islamic clerics who favor imposing Islamic law on Libya, something most Libyans don’t want. The GNA is also more tolerant of corruption, in part because GNA is the conduit for most foreign aid and thus there is more to steal. Western groups are pressuring the UN to concentrate on prosecuting militia leaders, especially those loyal to Hiftar, for war crimes. But most Libyans note the majority of alleged war crimes being committed by militias aligned with the GNA and rarely criticized by the UN. This reinforces Libyan distrust of the UN as a foreign force trying to impose itself on Libya.

I will continue to ask just what in the world are we doing backing the GNA when it is jihadi-friendly?

Are we stupid? suicidal? What!?? The UN I expect to be stupid and hostile to the West when it comes to issues of Islamist extremism. What's the West's excuse for encouraging Islamists in Libya?

The Manchester bomber's family came from Libya!

And there is more:

But although the [ISIL] jihadists are down in Libya, they are not out. And they may have international reach. Many of the fighters have regrouped in a swathe of desert valleys and rocky hills south-east of Tripoli. British police are probing links between Salman Abedi, the suicide-bomber who murdered 22 people at a concert in Manchester on May 22nd, and IS, which claimed responsibility for the attack. Mr Abedi was in Libya recently; his brother and father were arrested in Tripoli on May 24th. The militia holding them says the brother is a member of IS and was planning an attack on Tripoli.

We have an interest in pretty much doing the opposite of what we are doing in Libya. How is this possible?

Carry That Tiger Inland

China's push inland to Asia to reach Europe with their One Belt One Road initiative (aka New Silk Road) is a dangerous maneuver to pull off:

Shi Yinhong, an academic who serves as a counselor to China’s government, the State Council, has warned of the growing risk of Chinese strategic overreach. And he is already being proved right. Xi has gotten so caught up in his aggressive foreign policy that he has undermined his own diplomatic aspirations, failing to recognize that brute force is no substitute for leadership. In the process, he has stretched China’s resources at a time when the economy is already struggling and a shrinking working-age population presages long-term stagnation.

I'm fine with China's ambitions. Go west, young Han.

Truly, I love it when a plan comes together.

Tuesday, May 30, 2017

We Conducted an Actual FONOP at Mischief Reef

Well I'll be, Dewey carried out an actual freedom of navigation operation:

The guided-missile destroyer operated normally and did not conduct the transit under the rules of an innocent passage – the restrictions that allow a warship to pass through another country’s territorial waters with no notice.

The ship was within 12 nautical miles of Mischief Reef for about 90 minutes zig-zagging in the water near the installation. At one point during the operation, the ship’s crew conducted a man overboard drill, a U.S. official told USNI News.

I'm not clear whether the zig-zagging or the drill counted as conducting routine warship activities.

Regardless, the article specifically notes that this was beyond innocent passage so I'll go with that.

Well, I said I'd wait to hear details about this operation to see if it was more of the same.

It seems that the emphasis in this operation about the nature of the FONOP highlights that past operations in the South China Sea were mere innocent passage missions.

Kim Jong-Un Prays for a Successful Test

America is going to test ballistic missile defenses today:

Vandenberg Air Force Base in Central California is preparing to launch a missile designed to shoot down an incoming warhead.

CBS Los Angeles reports a Ground-based Interceptor, which is scheduled to be launched between noon and 4 p.m. Tuesday, is part of a missile defense test, according to the Air Force base.

If this doesn't work, it puts pressure on America to take offensive action before North Korea has any ICBMs, doesn't it?

Shouldn't the Pillsbury Nuke Boy be praying for a successful American test, under the circumstances?

UPDATE: The test worked:

The ground-based interceptor launched from Vandenberg Air Force Base in California shortly after 3:30 p.m. ET. A little more than one hour later, the Pentagon confirmed that it had successfully collided with an ICBM-class target over the Pacific Ocean.

A successful test doesn't mean we won't strike North Korea--a successful missile defense system helps us shoot down missiles that survive our strike, after all.

But it does give us more of an option to wait a bit and see if China steps up.

UPDATE: Thoughts on the test.

The Beginning of Wisdom

Secretary of Defense Mattis finally framed the war against our enemies in the right way:

“I keep other people awake at night,” Mattis told CBS’s John Dickerson on “Face the Nation.”

Dickerson, reflecting the wrong way to look at war, had asked Mattis what kept him up at night.

The failure to think this way has long been a pet peeve of mine. As General Grant once expressed:

Oh, I am heartily tired of hearing about what Lee is going to do. Some of you always seem to think he is suddenly going to turn a double somersault, and land in our rear and on both of our flanks at the same time. Go back to your command, and try to think what are we going to do ourselves, instead of what Lee is going to do.

Relentlessly hunt and kill our enemies so that in the short time they have left on this Earth, they fear us.

Islam is Not Irrelevant to the Problem of Girls Being Slaughtered

There are some reasonable points in a Brookings Institution article in the issue of countering Islamist terrorism.

Yes, reforming corrupt and autocratic rulers in the Arab and Moslem worlds is important to preventing radicalization. That isn't a problem of Islam, strictly speaking:

There is a growing body of research on what drives support for terrorism and, counter to earlier conventional wisdom, it is generally not religion, ideology, or the internet that attract would-be violent extremists. Rather, military or police abuses of one’s own population are among the single largest drivers of terrorist recruitment. Corruption and the biased delivery of public services that erodes the trust between the government and its citizens are also among the key sources of grievance within communities that terrorist propaganda exploits.

This is why I was hopeful for the 2011 Arab Spring; and why I did not mock or dismiss it when it largely failed. Just demanding democracy as an alternative to the traditional choices of autocracy or Islamist rule for Arabs was progress as far as I am concerned. It's a long struggle to successfully change thinking enough to get it.

But the actual response of those unhappily living under that corruption and autocracy is a problem of Islam. The mass murder of little girls at a pop concert in a country far from your homeland is not a normal response to your own government's brutality and corruption.

And even if the misrule of the Saudi government excuses the mass murder of Westerners in America on 9/11 (it doesn't), for example, did the abuse and corruption of Britain inspire the locally born jihadi who killed little girls in Manchester? 

Unfortunately, Islam gives those victims of their own governments a higher purpose for killing and a convenient targets abroad (who include little girls) to blame when fighting their own governments becomes too hard to do without being killed or put in a dark jail until they die from torture, starvation, or despair.

So Islam is not completely beside the point, you must admit.

Chicago has the ingredients of corruption and virtual autocracy necessary to provoke crime and murder, perhaps; but what Chicagoans don't have is a world view that blames Canadians for their misery and celebrates the killing of Canadians--whether English- or French-speakers--as the solution.

If you don't like that comparison, why aren't Venezuelans, Ethiopians, and Zimbabweans strapping on suicide vests to kill civilians far away as logical responses to their poverty and oppression?

Face it, we spend too much time trying to figure out why the jihadis hate us and why we didn't spot their latest plot to kill us:

We indeed have traveled a long way since 9-11. Too many people are back to 9-10. [The jihadi terrorists] hate us, people. All of us. Not just the current administration. Not just the Red State citizens. Owning a bongo and tie-dyed shirts won’t save you. Nor will spouting sympathy for their cause. We’re all targets and they’ll dance over our graves if we let them.

Stop debating to the point of paralysis over what dots should have been connected and what dots existed. The dots keep killing us in the most gruesome manner they can come up with. Just kill the freaking dots! We are at war and we must win.

Sadly, I wrote that plea 13 years ago.

As I've long said, killing jihadis isn't the sole solution to fighting Islamist terrorism. It may even be the smallest part of success. I have no problem admitting that human rights and reform within the Islamic world are necessary in the long run. This is essentially an Islamic Civil War about how Islam will be defined and we are collateral damage in that fight.

But whatever percent of the solution killing jihadis represents, it is damned well the first thing that needs to be done given that in the short run the murderous, hate-filled scum aspire to slaughter our children in our own cities.

PRE-PUBLICATION UPDATE: Related thoughts.

Monday, May 29, 2017

What Can We Live With?

We are counting on China to control their little pet psycho before they get functional nuclear missiles. Can we?

Perhaps we can't count on China to stop North Korea:

On the evidence, China -- despite its public expressions of disapproval and disappointment over each North Korean nuclear test -- has nonetheless, for decades now, allowed North Korea to proceed. It is past time to ask quite seriously whether Beijing (never mind its public posturing) reached a quiet decision quite some years ago that China can live comfortably enough with a nuclear-armed North Korea that dedicates itself to bedeviling such leading democracies as South Korea, America and Japan.

So China can live comfortably with a nuclear-armed North Korea that aims weapons at America, South Korea, and Japan?

Well maybe we can get China's attention by letting China know we can live comfortably with a nuclear-armed South Korea and a nuclear-armed Japan.

As I've said, if it was just North Korea, I could live with a nuclear-armed North Korea facing off with a nuclear-armed South Korea and nuclear-armed Japan backed by our power. Deterrence would be the least bad situation compared to war and what might happen when the shooting starts.

But the strong possibility that Iran could buy North Korea-developed nuclear weapons or technology changes the game. I'm not confident that Iran in their religious-based nutballery can be deterred.

And even if Iran can be deterred from using nuclear weapons, the chaos Iran can foment in the vital Middle East (we aren't isolated from global oil disruption despite fracking) behind the shield of nuclear weapons would be far greater than what they do now without nukes.

Our options for North Korea are all bad. But we can at least leave China and Russia with a bad option as payback for their refusal to control their little psychotic friend and ally.

America could live with more nuclear weapons pointed at North Korea and potentially pointed at China and Russia. Can China?

UPDATE: Moon, South Korea's new and more North-friendly president, is upset that the full THAAD battery was deployed without knowing about it?

South Korean President Moon Jae-in has ordered a probe after the Defence Ministry failed to inform him that four more launchers for the controversial U.S. THAAD anti-missile system had been brought into the country, his spokesman said on Tuesday.

Sounds like this is a known fact, if you ask me. And wasn't this the plan?

If South Korea is less willing to cooperate with American and Japan in confronting North Korea to stop their nuclear program, we could face an interesting divergence of interest where South Korea considers a new nuclear threat to Seoul not so much greater than a chemical or conventional threat to bombard or capture the city, which South Korea has faced for many decades; while Japan and America consider new nuclear threats to Tokyo and Seattle completely unacceptable.

If South Korea doesn't care enough to prevent a new threat to their Japanese and American allies, will America and Japan care enough about a North Korean counter-strike on Seoul to refrain from doing something about North Korea's looming threat to Japan and America?

We Remember Our Dead

The Army remembers memorial day. The day is for all services, of course.

For those who are confused about the difference between Veterans Day and Memorial Day, veterans survived the war.

This picture means the most to me. Years ago when I explained to my daughter, Lamb, why I had my flag at half staff one Memorial Day morning, she made her own memorial to remember our dead.


A few pay the highest price.

We can be grateful that so few pay the price these days, but the price is no less heavy for those fewer who pay it.

Sunday, May 28, 2017

Kabuki or Kablooie?

While the third carrier could just be to replace one carrier going home, we will for a time have 3 carriers near North Korea (tip to Instapundit):

The U.S. Navy has decided to deploy the USS Nimitz as a third carrier-led strike force to the western Pacific to increase pressure on North Korea to rein in its arms programs.

Nimitz, one of the world's largest warships, will join the USS Carl Vinson and USS Ronald Reagan there, sources close to the U.S. military said May 26.

That's a lot at sea in one place at one time and takes an effort to engineer.

This is either serious pressure to convince China to do something about North Korea to avoid instability on China's border (and a humiliation to have America police China's neighbor); or it is a serious preparation for war in the near term?

Will China do the deed and overthrow/invade with the promise of economic benefits to sweeten the threat of doing something so we won't?

Are South Korea and Japan on board?

Did Duterte of the Philippines play a role in conveying American seriousness to the Chinese?

Heck, could it be a joint American-Chinese-South Korean-Japanese attack/regime change (to China friendly and nuke-unfriendly)?

Is this all a bluff?

UPDATE: Voice of America notes the carrier deployment and also this:

The Missile Defense Agency said it will test an existing missile defense system on Tuesday to try to intercept an ICBM. The Pentagon has used the Ground-Based Midcourse Defense (GMD) system to intercept other types of missiles, but never an ICBM.

If America leads a strike campaign against North Korea's nuclear infrastructure, missile defenses will be necessary to fend off missiles we miss in the strikes. The strikes hopefully make the number of missiles North Korea can launch small enough for the thin missile defenses to stop.

And hopefully North Korea doesn't yet have nuclear warheads.

If this is all a bluff, it's a good bluff.

UPDATE: Strategypage looks at the sorry state of North Korea and related matters.

I never complained about President Obama's "strategic patience" policy of essentially waiting for North Korea to collapse. I'd long wanted a "talk, talk; die, die" policy of talking but offering few or no financial concessions to North Korea to wait for them to die.

I didn't imagine North Korea could decline this much without a regime or state collapse; or without a military or popular uprising.

Perhaps ominously in that post, I did say that one day we might have conditions better suited to taking action:

So let the talks drag on. I don't care. We can't let the North Koreans succeed in holding their own people hostage confident that we will care more for their welfare and so give in to save them.

In time, we will have missile defenses. In time, our Army won't be busy in Iraq. In time, even the South Koreans may start to worry about Pyongyang if the North rattles sabres to get our attention.

And here we are. We have some missile defenses; the South Koreans stopped paying money to North Korea, tired of the Dead South Koreans Theater production that Pyongyang loved; and America's military is not so busy fighting.

As presidents have played musical chairs while North Korea advanced their nuclear program, Trump may be the one unlucky enough to be left standing when the music stopped.