Saturday, April 08, 2017

Weekend Data Dump

The Ares was a concept for a low-cost ground support plane that looks like a scaled-down version of the A-10. Not only didn't the Air Force want it, but the Army didn't want a plane that would threaten the AH-64 attack helicopter. So in my post on an Aerospace Force, I guess my question of what the Army might do if it got the A-10 was answered at least once. Although my question includes the money to support a ground support plane, too. So perhaps the question still needs answering.

Yemen's Houthi rebel/separatist group is using modified SAM-2 anti-aircraft missiles as surface-to-surface ballistic missiles. This brings back memories of the pre-Iraq War when news reports noted that Iraq was importing SAM-2 engines without any media awareness that the reason to import engines for such an obsolete anti-aircraft missile was to build ballistic missiles with a range prohibited by the Gulf War ceasefire. No, that little fact was seen as demonstrating that Saddam was only trying to get defensive weapons. And here we are with a volley of missiles aimed at Saudi Arabia.

Russia is ordering small but heavily armed corvettes for their navy. Not only can they be exported, but they make sense. Russia does not need a large blue water navy. Their core fleet needs to be corvettes for coastal defense, ballistic missile submarines for a survivable nuclear deterrent, and attack subs and anti-submarine ships to create defended bastions for the ballistic missile subs. If they can afford it, amphibious warfare ships for coastal areas are useful. Once they have that, they can consider "show the flag" blue water ships. Aircraft carriers are purely the red sports car of the Russian navy.

Did the Russians help cause the 2010 plane crash that killed the Polish president and a lot of top officials?  It was a convenient loss for the Russians. If true, at least Moscow didn't blame the Nazis.

The international naval patrol mission did finally suppress piracy off of Somalia. But the cost was to allow hostages to languish for years on shore. I hoped for punitive missions to smash up the pirate bases ashore. But the mission did work. Until the international warships went away. So what will India do now that one of their ships was taken? India as a non-Western country has more room for error in a response.

I have expressed my worry that Egypt could be flirting with Russia as part of Egyptian worry about the American alliance and Russian efforts to rebuild their presence in the eastern Mediterranean Sea. This author worries that America is pushing Egypt to Russia. Luckily, Egypt is still transitioning to American military gear long after Egypt's flip to America. Flipping back would be rough. And Russia is in no position to finance a flip. Nor is Iran even with the financial windfall of the Iran deal. China could pay the price to be Egypt's patron, but would they? And America shouldn't be quite the problem for Egypt in the post-Obama era, I imagine. So I suspect that Egypt is really just trying to tell America and Saudi Arabia (which also finances Egypt) not to take them for granted.

It is interesting that Norway's defense upgrade plans focus on air and naval defense. What about ground forces?  I'm assuming that the Norwegians see little territorial threat beyond losing their far north to an overland attack that doesn't threaten more settled areas let alone the core of southern Norway. Air and sea capabilities will stop airborne and amphibious invasion threats, of course. And they can support Sweden and Finland more easily. And there are the American Marines, of course.

In the current era of a Democratic "Red Scare" about potential Russian ties to Trump. let's spare a moment to recall the "Red Yawn" of Democratic concern about communist China's influence with Bill Clinton.

I do worry that South Korea will go wobbly with a new left-wing president. But my worry about a major shift to China is tempered by the hostility that North Korea and China show toward South Korea that should limit any lowering of South Korea's guard. And again, I won't blame President Obama for not doing something about North Korea. I find it hard to believe South Korea or Japan would have agreed to any military action when we--but not they (especially South Korea's capital, Seoul)--would have been vulnerable to a North Korean response. Was betting on a North Korean collapse in 8 years really a bad bet to make under the circumstances?

The implication that it is troubling that President Trump is delegating routine decisions on waging war to the military (the military is "seizing control" of more responsibility) is just odd. What should be troubling is the past trend to make the president a squad leader from the Oval Office. Heck, it is bad enough that generals sometime act like squad leaders from the Pentagon. Civilian control over the military means the civilians decide when to use force and what the goals are. It does not mean that the civilians make military decisions on how and when to fight the enemy the civilians designate.

The problem of Obama fans leaking information and otherwise undermining the Trump administration wouldn't be as bad as it is if Trump would actually appoint the people he can appoint to executive office positions--like at the Department of Defense. A sense of urgency please. The transition period wasn't long enough to get a jump on this?

Democratic complaints that Russians hacked the election (although the Russians failed to hack a majority of voters for Trump) seem to rely on the theory that Russia managed to poach the most stupid of the Democratic coalition who fell for Russian fake news.

Susan Rice seems to have been prominent in unmasking Trump people caught up in the giant Hoover vacuum that is our signals intelligence apparatus. But hey, at least she didn't blame Trump's victory on some obscure video maker and imprison him.

Tina Fey is certainly proof that feminists are just the women's auxiliary of leftism, considering she slams the 44% of college educated white women who voted for Trump (and the 52% of white women overall, I suppose). Fey heard them roar and then accused them of being animals.

We're making nice with Egypt, which lessens the chance of Egypt flipping to the Russians--if that was a real Egyptian option.

Look, I know I'm deficient in nuance. But this leaves me confused: "Unemployment among 15-to-24-year-olds is now at a staggering 25 percent and has led to an exodus that has rendered London the sixth-largest French-speaking city in the world." This exodus of young French people from France makes no sense. I keep reading that France (and European countries in general) need mass immigration from the Moslem world to take jobs in birth-poor Europe that doesn't have the workers to fill jobs.

Is there a Watergate level scandal emerging for the former Obama administration?

Seriously, that Left-wing screening of 1984 as a warning against Trump is absolutely hilarious when you consider that the book is a warning against socialism. I assume that after watching the movie, attendees screamed about Trump for about a couple minutes, eh? Tip to Instapundit.

We need FISA to fight terrorism directed at America, but we need federal employees to be responsible with the enormous power they have rather than abuse it. So as reauthorization comes up, the abuses revealed by the whole "unmasking" issue by the Obama administration provides us a choice: Congress refuses to reauthorize the law because the executive branch can't be trusted to use the power that is supposed to protect Americans; or the executive branch employees who abused the law are punished enough to deter future abuse, so we can keep FISA intact.

So it is suspicious if you deposit $10,000 dollars in your bank account; and it is a crime to deposit less if it looks like--to the government, of course--you are avoiding that threshold. Which means the government can seize your money. Those "buy gold" commercials are looking more appealing, eh? Oh, and I thought the bank was required to report higher deposits to the government and not the responsibility of an individual or business making the deposit, as the article states. Tip to Instapundit.

Iraqi forces have suffered 800 dead and 5,000 wounded in the 5 months of the Mosul offensive. The remaining ISIL defenders are disorganized and demoralized in their tiny corner of the city. This compares well to the 7,000 killed and wounded Iraq suffered in the 7-week assault on Iran's city of Khorramshahr in 1980. Given that the casualty ratio in 1980 was likely closer to 3:1 wounded to killed, about 1,700+ Iraqi troops likely died in the 1980 assault.

I see, Trump is the problem for trying harder--with more effort rather than many more troops--to win (and end) Middle East wars that already raged under President Obama who was happy to just avoid disaster he might be blamed for until he left office. Ah, a former Obama administration official now serving as a professor. Consider the source.

Mysteriously vague "youth" beat up a gay couple in the Netherlands for the crime of holding hands in public. When gay rights conflict with "youth" bigotry, you know who wins in Leftist victimology.

A French soldier was killed in Mali which is the center of France's efforts to check jihadi advances in the region.

Liberal hatred of Trump supporters is ridiculous: "'I absolutely despise these people,' one woman tweeted at me after I interviewed Trump voters. 'Truly the worst of humanity. To hell with every one of them.'" I've long said that it is a crime against language that "liberal minded" is taken as a synonym for "open minded." Truly, those haters need to scrape their COEXIST bumper stickers off of their hybrid cars.

When speaking of media bias, this article will do as well as any to illustrate it. No mention that super-majority voting is a relatively recent procedure for court nominees. No mention of Democratic obstruction in Republican nominees since the Reagan administration.  No mention that Democrats abandoned the super-majority for lower court judges (calling it "filibuster reform," I believe). No mention that Democrats raised the issue of not nominating a judge in the final year of a (Republican) president. No mention that Senator Reid prior to the election when Clinton was believed to have a lock on the presidency had said the "nuclear option" (aka the Reid Option) would be a good idea (when Democrats were assumed to have a lock on a narrow win in the Senate). No, the reporter just notes the destruction of tradition by Republicans. This is bias in action. The writer may not even realize it.

Do you really doubt that feminists are the women's auxiliary of leftism rather than a group that promotes and celebrates the success of women?

This week saw the anniversary of America's entry into World War I. One of my grandfathers was a World War I Army veteran. My other grandfather was sent to the Mexican border before the war. Here are Army links to brochures on both.

India has sheer size to deal with threats from Pakistan. That advantage disappears when dealing with China. So India really needs to break up and sell for parts their dysfunctional procurement bureaucracy before China gets too far ahead. If India wasn't a democracy, I'd say some people should be shot as a lesson to others.

Those damn Swedish neocons with their wars in the Middle East and refusal to accept Moslem refugees into their country deserved this kind of terrorism, no doubt. Wait. What? Sweden has accepted lots of refugees and migrants from the Middle East? And Sweden barely has a military let alone used it in the Middle East? Huh.

Somebody's Clinton Privilege is showing. Tip to Instapundit. She was born on third base and thinks she hit a triple? Good Lord, her family bought the team for her!

Climate models just don't work, and you really can't deny that fact.

Friday, April 07, 2017

Salon Has Gone Full Jack D. Ripper

Salon is worried about Trump having his finger on the nuclear button when they write this headline?

"Donald Trump, who’s totally not Vladimir Putin’s puppet, warned Russia before airstrikes on Syria"

The author is aware that this was not intended to be the opening salvo of a war on Russia, right?

This cruise missile strike on Assad's air base was a belated defense of Obama's chemical weapons red line, if Salon can reach that far back in its memory.

And Salon realizes, as Instapundit noted, that if we hadn't warned the Russians despite the Obama era deconfliction process that the Russians would be justified in being angry if their troops died in our attack, right?

Pretty soon, Salon writers are going to complete their change and drone on about our precious bodily fluids.

Tip to Instapundit.

UPDATE: Wait. What? Nancy Pelosi wants a Congressional debate over the single strike mission?

“Congress must live up to its Constitutional responsibility to debate an Authorization of the Use of Military Force against a sovereign nation,” Pelosi wrote in the letter sent Friday morning. “The American people are owed a comprehensive strategy with clear objectives to keep our brave men and women in uniform safe and avoid collateral damage to innocent civilians in Syria.”

Just like Pelosi wanted a debate on the "time-limited, scope-limited military action" against Libya in 2011?

UPDATE: Russia suspended the deconfliction protocol:

Even as Russian officials expressed hope that the strike against Syrian President Bashad al-Assad’s forces would not lead to an irreversible breakdown in U.S. relations with Moscow, the Kremlin’s decision to suspend the 2015 memorandum of understanding on the air operations immediately raised tensions in the skies over Syria. ...

Later Friday, the Russian Defense Ministry announced that it has officially informed the United States that it is suspending its obligations under the memorandum at midnight.

Which means two things. One, Russia or Syria might accidentally drop bombs on American troops inside Syria. We'd best move around, dig in, and have air defenses handy.

And two, future American strikes on Assad's forces will have a greater chance of killing Russians, raising the stakes in punishing Assad and perhaps deterring more strikes--Salon fire-breathing passions to smite the Russians notwithstanding.

UPDATE: Never mind:

Russia has not suspended a military communications channel meant to help U.S. and Russian forces to avoid inadvertent clashes in Syria, despite a U.S. cruise missile strike on a Syrian airbase that has angered Moscow, senior U.S. officials said on Friday.

Perhaps Russia thought better of risking a US-Russian clash.

A School and a MOUTFOR Final Exam

We have schools for desert, jungle, mountain, and cold weather schools--and other schools to maintain a base of knowledge for the requirements of fighting in specific environments and with specific methods. So an urban warfare school is a good idea. But I still don't want any of our Army brigades to become a specialized urban warfare unit.

No problem:

It is time that changed. The Army needs to establish an urban warfare school to prepare soldiers to fight and survive in dense urban terrain.

I'll add that an OPFOR-like (Opposition Force) unit and training area that makes our Army so good at open-field maneuver warfare should be replicated with a MOUTFOR (Military Operations in Urban Terrain Force) with its own wired urban battlefield.

But I don't want combat maneuver brigades to be focused on urban warfare as a mission that makes them less useful for other missions.

Truth be told, I'm on record (see my article on page 38) as thinking that the Marines should be the force tasked with urban warfare given that the amphibious assault mission requires skills that more easily translate to city assault.

The Marines already have a decent-sized urban training environment using shipping containers as building blocks:

Shortly after Brig. Gen. H. Stacy Clardy III cut the ribbon on the Marine Corps Air Ground Combat Center’s new $170 million urban warfare training facility Tuesday, Jan. 25, [2011,] the base commanding general stood atop one of its 1,250 cargo-container buildings with an enthusiastic group of visitors and watched a platoon of Marines storm a building in one of its seven districts.

The Army should be prepared for such urban missions by training officers and putting out doctrine. I think our engineers would be a good home for honing the tactics and equipment for urban warfare because their engineering help would be crucial for leveraging the infantry and armor of the Army in fighting inside a city (with fires support from artillery and other services of course).

Although I will concede that if the urban warfare brigade is outside of the force pool, it would be useful as a testing platform.

And maneuver units could get trips to MOUTFOR to expose them to this environment just as units get tested in maneuver warfare by the OPFOR.

We Struck a King

Belatedly enforcing America's red line over Assad's chemical weapons use--and demonstrating the utter failure of the glorious Kerry-Lavrov deal to remove Assad's chemical weapons (but the Iran deal will be much better!)--American cruise missiles hit Assad's forces in retaliation for his use of chemical weapons against civilians.

American ships fired 59 cruise missiles at Syrian targets:

President Donald Trump cast the United States assault on a Syrian air base as vital to deter future use of poison gas and called on other nations to join in seeking "to end the slaughter and bloodshed in Syria."

The U.S. blasted the air base Thursday night with a barrage of cruise missiles in fiery retaliation for this week's gruesome chemical weapons attack against civilians.

Which is fine. Assad paid a price for using chemical weapons that he isn't supposed to have.

But chemical weapons are a minor part of the Assad killing machine. If Assad stops using chemical weapons, does it really matter?

Unless this strike is just the first step in an effort to ultimately defeat Assad, it is pointless.

Kill the king and his regime.

Oh, and obviously this sentiment is no longer operative:


Here come the giant puppets!

UPDATE: The Pentagon issued a statement on the strike:

At the direction of the president, U.S. forces conducted a cruise missile strike against a Syrian Air Force airfield today at about 8:40 p.m. EDT (4:40 a.m., April 7, in Syria). The strike targeted Shayrat Airfield in Homs governorate, and were in response to the Syrian government's chemical weapons attack April 4 in Khan Sheikhoun, which killed and injured hundreds of innocent Syrian people, including women and children.

The strike was conducted using Tomahawk Land Attack Missiles (TLAMs) launched from the destroyers USS Porter and USS Ross in the Eastern Mediterranean Sea. A total of 59 TLAMs targeted aircraft, hardened aircraft shelters, petroleum and logistical storage, ammunition supply bunkers, air defense systems, and radars. As always, the U.S. took extraordinary measures to avoid civilian casualties and to comply with the Law of Armed Conflict. Every precaution was taken to execute this strike with minimal risk to personnel at the airfield.

The strike was a proportional response to Assad's heinous act. Shayrat Airfield was used to store chemical weapons and Syrian air forces. The U.S. intelligence community assesses that aircraft from Shayrat conducted the chemical weapons attack on April 4. The strike was intended to deter the regime from using chemical weapons again.

Russian forces were notified in advance of the strike using the established deconfliction line. U.S. military planners took precautions to minimize risk to Russian or Syrian personnel located at the airfield.

We are assessing the results of the strike. Initial indications are that this strike has severely damaged or destroyed Syrian aircraft and support infrastructure and equipment at Shayrat Airfield, reducing the Syrian Government's ability to deliver chemical weapons. The use of chemical weapons against innocent people will not be tolerated.

Less than half a percent of the deaths in Syria are from chemical weapons.

UPDATE: More from Strategypage.

Let me add for those who think a year-long investigation by CSI Damascus is necessary to prove Assad did this beyond a reasonable doubt, past investigations have concluded long after the fact that Assad has used chemical weapons.

So even if this Sarin strike is somehow not Assad's fault (and I don't think the persuasion approach works in international relations to this degree--their rational is nor our rational), we've still got a way to go to catch up with punishing Assad for killing civilians with poison gas.

UPDATE: Note that this strike may make Turkey more willing to work with America to overthrow Assad and end Turkey's flirtation with Russia; and the Russian guarantee to thug leaders is lessened as the Russians watched the missiles come in without doing anything.

But this is just one strike. We'll see if President Obama's demand that Assad step down will be enforced by Trump in the aftermath of the chemical attack.

UPDATE: Interesting note: The launch of all the missiles took about half an hour and the early missiles loitered until all the missiles could be sent on their way to the targets to hit in a short period of time.

I wonder if Russia or Syria could see the loitering missiles, giving them a little time to react even if we hadn't warned the Russians to get our of the way.

UPDATE: Oh, and ordered during meetings with China's Xi Jinping, China now has to wonder what Trump would do about North Korean nukes if we will do this over chemical weapons.

UPDATE: Saturday morning I hear a Democratic partisan darkly note that "we discovered" that Trump warned the Russians prior to the strike. Yeah, it was "discovered" because that Pentagon statement I quote in full above told us that fact.

Socialism? What Socialism?

To aim this perhaps not so unsubtle hit piece on Trump, you have to ignore the elephant in the room:

When Hugo Chávez took power in Venezuela nearly 20 years ago, the leftist populism he championed was supposed to save democracy. Instead, it has led to democracy’s implosion in the country, marked this past week by an attack on the independence of its Legislature.

Venezuela’s fate stands as a warning: Populism is a path that, at its outset, can look and feel democratic. But, followed to its logical conclusion, it can lead to democratic backsliding or even outright authoritarianism.

Populism does not always end in authoritarianism. Venezuela’s collapse has been aided by other factors, including plummeting oil prices, and democratic institutions can check populism’s darker tendencies.

Was it populism that led to authoritarianism in Venezuela? Or was it the socialism that undermined democracy and rule of law?

You have to get deep into the article to see the term "Bolivarian socialism."

Speaking of socialism's darker tendencies:

Venezuelan security forces quelled masked protesters with tear gas, water cannons and pepper spray in Caracas on Tuesday after blocking an opposition rally against socialist President Nicolas Maduro.

The clashes began after the authorities closed subway stations, set up checkpoints and cordoned off a square where opponents had planned their latest protest against autocratic government and a crippling economic crisis.

How long before the mass killings begin?

Unless Trump tries to pack the courts in response to setbacks by judges oddly uninterested in the text of his orders and the statutes that allow them, don't even talk to me about the lessons of Chavez and Maduro for today's America.

UPDATE: Hoo boy:

Venezuelans in poor areas blocked streets and lit fires during scattered protests across the country on Tuesday night, and two people were killed during the growing unrest in the midst of a crippling economic crisis.

In a worrying sign for leftist President Nicolas Maduro, groups in Caracas' traditionally pro-government hillside slums and low-income neighborhoods took to the streets, witnesses and opposition lawmakers reported.

That is a major change in support. Maduro may be down to just having the people with guns backing him. Which is enough in the short run if you are willing to kill enough opponents.

Thursday, April 06, 2017

Will Ukraine Try to Win?

Nobody ever won a war sitting on their ass, and the Russia-Ukraine War will be won by whoever wins the last major offensive.

Maybe Russia will suffer internal unrest and leave Russian-occupied Donbas. Russian poverty is rising, after all:

The number of Russians living in poverty reached nearly 20 million last year -- a decade high -- after sanctions over Ukraine and an oil crisis battered the economy, official figures showed Wednesday.

Or maybe Russia will resume their war when they feel like it and complete the conquest of the Donbas region to supplement their conquest of Crimea.

Ukraine is eating away at Russian control of the Donbas region, but a real offensive is needed to defeat the Russians.

I know that people object that if Ukraine fights that Russia will just escalate.

I have news for people, Russia's conventional escalation potential is not unlimited.

And Russia has escalated when they wanted to; so they will again if needed.

So failure by Ukraine to wage war won't prevent Russia from escalating. It just allows Russia to escalate on their terms and for a duration that Russia can handle.

If Ukraine wants to regain their east, the Ukrainians need to wage an offensive to take ground and break the enemy resistance.

And if Ukraine worries Russia will escalate to beyond the Donbas? Well, Ukraine could make sure they have their air force and ballistic missiles able to bombard the Sevastopol naval base and ships in port; while having forces able to lay mines off of Crimea's ports while issuing a port closure order for what is legally Ukraine's territory.

Country First?

If your pride in America varies with the administration, your level of pride isn't about America.

Really?

Sixty-seven percent of Democrats say they are "extremely" or "very" proud to be Americans, down 11 percentage points from a year ago. Republicans (92%) and independents (73%) are about as likely now as in 2016 to express such patriotic sentiments.

My pride in America didn't waver during the Obama years.

If your pride in America declined since President Obama left office, I suspect that your "pride in America" was actually pride that a leftist ran America and not pride in America itself.

The Deep Roots Feed Chinese Autocracy

The idea that China has a long history of democracy impulses with "deep roots" when you have to ignore a couple millennia of Chinese autocratic imperial history to rely on the previous century of near-non-existent democracy in China is nonsense:

Still, some historical perspective is in order—not because Mr. Xi shows any signs of relenting in his oppressive agenda but because it would be a mistake to confuse the present reality with permanence. Democratic ideals have deep roots in modern Chinese history and have surfaced again and again over the past century. This legacy should serve to remind us that not all Chinese, even in the worst of times, have been resigned to a politics of one-party rule.

Seriously, "Historical perspective" about China and democracy requires us to ignore the vast history of China to just note the failed impulses for democracy that even over the last century of focused "perspective" are nearly non-existent?

And in that past century representing but a sliver of Chinese history, the only real democracy has been built away from mainland China in Taiwan--with a partial nod to Hong Kong that got it late from the British before being handed to the Chinese who do not take their so-called deep roots of democracy seriously enough to allow democracy in Hong Kong.

At best China had their own Han Spring that was crushed by the weight of Chinese tanks in 1989 at Tiananmen Square. Those first green sprigs of democracy never had a chance to put down any roots at all.

God save us from experts who sometimes seem to live in the echelon above reality.

Wednesday, April 05, 2017

Technically Unlawful, I Know

These Japanese options to deal with Chinese dominance of the South China Sea which potentially interdicts vital Japanese sea lines of communication are valid. But there is another option for Japan.

Basically, Japan can resist Chinese control by patrolling the South China Sea or move shipping lanes to the Middle East and points west to the east and to the south.

Of course, the former option does not overcome the ability of China to use their nearby assets to stop the Japanese from escorting sea traffic during wartime.

The options are certainly reasonable. But they must be combined with strengthening alliances with nations along the sea lines of communication who are themselves arming up in response to Chinese ambitions.

And a strengthened Japanese submarine force to operate in the South China Sea to blockade China in response to Chinese strangulation of South China Sea lines of communication would be a useful complement to defensive efforts.

Sure, technically that violates Japanese constitutional prohibitions about offensive military weaponry.

But sometimes you have to go on the offensive to defend yourself. Because ultimately the distinction between "offensive" and "defensive" weaponry is silly.

UPDATE: Related.

Assado Delenda Est

It looks like Assad has (again) used chemical weapons against rebels:

"If it’s what it looks like, it is clearly a war crime," said a senior State Department official, adding that the government was still gathering information.

A U.S. government source said Washington believed the chemical agent sarin was used in the attack and that it was "almost certainly" carried out by forces loyal to Assad.

"Those outside backers who are said to be guarantors of the (Assad) regime obviously have a lot to answer for,” the State Department official said, referring to Russia and Iran, which have provided military backing for Assad.

I know, you're thinking this chemical attack is impossible because President Obama, super genius that he is, and his idiot savant secretary of state Kerry negotiated a deal to remove Assad's chemical weapons after Assad crossed the president's "red line" against using poison gas:

The Assad regime ordered the use of chemical weapons on Ghouta [on August 21, 2013]. In so doing, it clearly violated President Barack Obama's now infamous August 2012 "red line" forbidding the use of chemical weapons against civilians by Assad's forces. Obama was saying he would not permit a war crime of that magnitude on his watch.

But when Assad crossed the red line, Obama failed to take punitive military action. Obama failed to support his strong words, exhibiting what Sean Spicer identified as "weakness and irresolution."

Obama tried to obscure his fecklessness by making a deal with Vladimir Putin. Russia would assume control Syrian chemical weapons then move the weapons out of Syria and destroy them. That deal didn't alter the bottom line to the red line: Assad committed a war crime forbidden by an American president, and did so with impunity.

Syrians have suffered scores of chemical attacks since 2013, many involving chlorine. In March 2017, two attacks occurred where Assad's forces allegedly used sarin.

Somehow, against all the odds, Assad still has chemical weapons. Go figure.

Funny that Assad wasn't content to use chlorine gas not covered in the deal (although still illegal to use as a weapon) but used a purpose-made poison gas.

I guess Assad wants to rub our nose in our failure to stop him and our apparent willingness to let him survive this civil war. Showing rebels that Assad can crush them by any means necessary without anyone doing a damn thing is surely useful.

One wonders whether the compassionate class will yell about Assad's killing spree that includes this weapon when the total body count in Syria is heading toward half a million now.

Probably not.

I'm so old that I remember when the Obama administration went to war against Khaddaffi of Libya--without Congressional affirmative authorization--under the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) doctrine.

And you have to wonder if the Obama deal to ban Iran's nuclear ambitions will be any better than the Obama deal to ban Assad's chemical weapons.

Unquestionably not.

Have a just lovely nuanced day as we are reminded of just how badly the Obama administration sucked.

We've struck Assad. We must kill him (and his regime) after ISIL is defeated or he will resume his hostility and body count of Americans that have been suspended by this civil war.

Statements that the Syrian people will decide the fate of Assad--as if we have no role--make me worry that we will refuse to work against Assad. Is this a walk back?

The United States does not believe that the Syrian people want President Bashar al-Assad as their leader any longer, U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley said on Monday.

Assado Delenda Est. And the Iranian horse he rode in on.

UPDATE: President Trump said the attack can't be tolerated.

We'll see. President Obama and the international community tolerated 500,000-dead worth of inaction in regard to Assad so far.

UPDATE: My interest in defeating the Assad regime predates ISIL, but since America launched Iraq War 2.0 my interest has always been in having a final stage, after defeating ISIL in Iraq and then in Syria, that targets Assad:

The fourth step is to continue the win over ISIL by helping non-jihadi Syrian rebels in the east, in the south, and in the north to overthrow Assad. I'm not sure the Obama administration is on board with this final step.

This is more important than ever because Assad owes so much to Iran and Russia which Assad will pay if he survives this civil war.

UPDATE: Remember that arguments against toppling Assad rely on the idea that deposing him would collapse Syria's government and allow ISIL to exploit the void.

But our campaigns against ISIL have dramatically reduced ISIL to 10,000 fighters split between Iraq and Syria; and Assad-run Syria has already fragmented into near-war lord regional commands that would survive the loss of the center and perhaps give the regional commanders reason to switch sides.

Defeating Assad is no gift to ISIL.

UPDATE: Syria makes a very specific denial while Turkey conducted autopsies:

Foreign Minister Walid Moallem reiterated that stance on Thursday, telling reporters in Damascus that his government never used and will not use chemical weapons in Syria.

"The Syrian Arab Army has never used chemical weapons and will not use chemical weapons against Syrians and even against terrorists," Moallem told the news conference.

In Turkey, state-run Anadolu and the private DHA news agencies quoted Justice Minister Bekir Bozdag as saying that "it was determined after the autopsy that a chemical weapon was used."

The Syrian army didn't use chemical weapons? What about the air force or perhaps a civilian organization?

Meanwhile, the Turks confirm the use of poison gas.

But who thinks the UN Security Council will do anything with Russia's (and China's) veto standing in the way?

Britain, France and the United States on Wednesday held off calling a vote at the UN Security Council on a resolution demanding an investigation of the suspected chemical attack in Syria to allow time for negotiations with Russia.

Any resolution that satisfied Russia will be worthless.

And truth be told, a resolution should be unacceptable to Russia. Make the Russians veto a tough resolution that punishes Assad for killing children with poison gas.

And then introduce that resolution every week to remind the Arab world (and Iranians) of what support for Assad means.

The Samson Option?

Could ISIL damage a dam overlooking Raqqa, Syria, sufficiently to kill thousands?

Control of the dam is split between ISIL and forces friendly to the United States. 

The author also notes the dam in Iraq that could make that casualty count appear minor league if ISIL or some other jihadis hit that hard enough. I've mentioned my worries on that issue.

On the bright side, ISIL's effort to drive friendly militias away from the Syria dam failed:

U.S. backed Syrian forces repelled a major counter-attack by Islamic State militants holding out at the country's largest dam and in the nearby town of Tabqa, the group and activists said on Sunday.

ISIL is going down. Will they in desperation try to pull everything down around them in the hope that somehow God will allow them to survive and emerge victorious from the calamity?

Tuesday, April 04, 2017

The Germans are Seriously Getting on My Nerves

I'm really getting tired of the Germans and their refusal to recognize that when the sh*t hits the fan, there is no substitute for having an adequate military.

Just stop this BS, okay?

Foreign Minister Sigmar Gabriel said it was "quite unrealistic" to believe Germany would spend 2% of its economic output on the military.

Other spending such as development aid, he said, should be taken into account.

Nobody is claiming that non-defense spending items are not important for defending a nation against threats.

But where does this excuse for failing to spend on defense end?

Is K-12 education spending really a substitute for defense spending because you need educated soldiers to have an effective military?

Is pre-natal care a defense spending item for similar reasons?

Surely nice highways are needed to move a hypothetical German tank brigade around, right?

And really, in this context I don't care how many poor Kenyan children have access to clean water from some German development project, because those healthy kids aren't going to stop Russian armor from closing on the Oder River line. 

Germany can spend whatever the Hell it wants on development aid. But they need to get over their psychological issues and prepare to defend themselves against a resurgent Russia:

I keep reading that the Germans hate their militaristic past so much that they don't want to fight.

Let's try applying the clue bat to Germany's collective skull on this issue.

Conquering and setting up death camps under the shield of a powerful military? That's bad. By all means, don't do that.

Having a military capable of fighting death cult enemies or stopping the Russians from moving west? Well, that's a good thing. Try doing that.

God almighty, I don't ask the Germans to join us in fighting in the Middle East. I couldn't have cared less that they sent troops to Afghanistan where they could practice their video game skills in the barracks while American and other allied troops fought.

All I ask is that the bloody Germans be prepared to defend NATO Europe. Is that really too much to ask of the wealthiest country in Europe?

For 75 years the Germans rampaged around the continent. But now that they are our allies they can't bring up the nerve to defend themselves and the free West?

UPDATE: An argument that Germany is becoming serious about defense seems to require a very long term definition of "becoming."

The Internet of Killing Things

The Army is seeking a battlefield Internet:

The US Army is embarking on a potentially decade-long quest to prepare soldiers to operate in the Digital Age.

In a $52 million initiative to create what it's calling the Internet of Battlefield Things, the Army Research Lab plans to redesign everything the soldier wears – and uses – so that it connects to the military's vast digital communications networks.

This is far harder for the Army (and Marines for that matter) who have many more "things" to track and empower (soldiers and vehicles) than the Air Force or Navy with ships and planes in combat.

And while the problem of security to prevent hacking is obviously a huge concern, I take some comfort that the Army is aware of this and that the hacking-prone Internet wasn't designed with this kind of threat in mind.

This kind of success is absolutely vital to have virtual squads.

Come to think of it, virtual vehicle drivers, at least, might be possible, if the connections were robust enough.

Loading physical rounds would require a real gunner on the vehicle and it would really really look bad to have the track commander back at headquarters as a virtual leader.

Anyway, that's the objective some decades away.

Real Control

The Russian domination of their eastern Europe empire and large parts of their Soviet Union empire escaped Moscow's control with less difficulty than Britain is having throwing off the yoke of European Union dominance.

That's just friggin' amazing:

The scale of the task facing UK legislators as they try to extricate Britain from the European Union was revealed on Thursday when the British government set out how the process would work.

Unveiling plans to convert EU law into domestic law, the government disclosed that 12,000 EU regulations are in force in Britain. About 7,900 "statutory instruments" -- government orders -- have implemented EU directives. Some 186 acts of Parliament passed between 1980 and 2009 "contained a degree of EU influence," the government said.

I assume Putin, who considers the dissolution of the Soviet Union a historic catastrophe, is really jealous.

The Soviet Union relied on lots of tanks and secret police to keep their restive imperial provinces in line. And in the end it was not enough.

Who knew that 10,000 cheese regulations would have been more effective in tying the imperial provinces to the motherland?

UPDATE: This makes me wonder about how successful a California secession movement (or Texas, or wherever) could be given the huge role the federal government has now in every state and local government, unlike in 1861 when the federal government had the post office, customs, and the military, with not much else really entangling the states.

Monday, April 03, 2017

Iran's Man in Baghdad

Will Iraq and America be partners to resist Iran after ISIL's caliphate is defeated?

I'm worried about the Trump administration's intent on the question of Iraq. The administration's new willingness to resist Iran seems to have a potential hole in Iraq which is the main prize for Iran right now.

While the Iraqi government seems to want us and President Trump and our generals have made positive comments about staying in Iraq, I've read other things that shake my confidence.

And that walking piece of breathing garbage Moqtada al-Sadr could hamper that partnership:

On March 26, the Iraqi government officially announced it favors the idea of some US forces staying. Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi said in a Fox News interview that he supports retaining enough US troops to support Iraqi forces in a post-IS Iraq.

"We are concentrating on training, logistical support, and intelligence cooperation and gathering; these are three important elements for which I think we need some US troops to stay in Iraq to continue the task," he stated.

It appears that parliament's Security and Defense Committee has information that work has already begun on some US bases. Committee member Majid al-Gharawi told Al-Monitor, "The US troops, present in Iraq in rising numbers each day, are meant to stay in Iraq." Gharawi, a political representative of the Sadrist movement, not surprisingly opposes the idea. "American forces in Iraq will be met by resistance at the hand of Iraqis. Any foreign military presence on Iraqi soil will not be tolerated," he said.

Jaafar al-Moussawi, the spokesperson for Sadrist movement leader Muqtada al-Sadr, concurred. He said, "Any continued presence of foreign forces in Iraq, whether they are American or not, without agreement by the Iraqi parliament is considered an occupation. Hence, it will face resistance by the Sadrist movement or the rest of Iraqis, as the movement's stance on a US presence hasn’t changed."

Sadr is Iran's man in Iraq who leads forces that have fought the Iraqi government and our troops several times in Sadrist uprisings since the overthrow of Saddam.

I've long and still worry that we will live to regret letting that man live.

As we look forward to the defeat of the ISIL Sunni caliphate in Iraq (and Syria), will we let the Shia caliphate that Iran has been since the overthrow of the Shah and the start of an Islamist mullah-run Iranian government make Iraq their province?

Remember, Jihadis Hate Everyone

My sympathies go out to the Russians of St. Petersburg who appear to have been killed and injured by a terrorist attack on their subway system.

Unless Democrats here decided to strike back over Hillary's loss, it wouldn't be too shocking if this is the work of Chechens either alone or for ISIL.

UPDATE: Of course, the initial Russian push into Asia was really just another crusade against Moslems, right?

So I'm sure the Russians totally deserved the terrorism today because of that history.

The False Compassion is Everywhere

These so-called experts really just don't get it:

President Donald Trump's approval of greater U.S. military authority to pursue al-Qaida-linked extremists in Somalia will put civilians further at risk, experts say, especially as drought displaces thousands of people in areas that now will be considered a war zone.

You know what else kills people? Letting jihadis run free to kill and prevent a government from forming to set a minimum level of security to allow non-jihadi problems to kill in even larger numbers.

The false compassion of the sort that moans about the risks of fighting jihadis more effectively is just astounding.

At some level, these idiot experts think that if you could just get jihadis to attend an Up With People! show that they'd see the error of their murderous hateful ways and finally apply for that associate training program at Macy's.

Oh What a Bloody Giveaway!

The European Union is no friend of America.

Oh, did I say that out loud?

In an extraordinary speech the EU Commission president [Jean-Claude Juncker] said he would push for Ohio and Texas to split from the rest of America if the Republican president does not change his tune and become more supportive of the EU.

European states and people can be our friends. A politically united European imperial state cannot be our friend.

American policy should be to oppose any single power from controlling the economic, scientific, and demographic power of the continent of Europe.

We resisted a kaiser, a fuehrer, and commissars who hoped to control Europe. We should resist the EU Gucci-stepping autocrats, too.

In case I'm unclear on my view of the European Union.

Sunday, April 02, 2017

Weekend Data Dump

Travel bans (that aren't actually bans) are racist, I'm told. But so is getting upset about them. Man, how do liberals even keep track of what they are supposed to be really upset about? Is there an app? Truly, the interstupidality is impressive.

I'm sure it is a toxic masculinity problem. It takes a child to raze a village, it seems.

American-backed militias fighting ISIL in Syria grabbed most of the Tabqa air base near Raqqa, which was the site of an Assad defeat that shook the regime's base of support. Those militias are also, I assume, anti-Assad rebels. So it will be interesting to see whether Assad orders an assault on the base and whether America will support the rebels to hold the base.

NATO is starting to notice Russian Arctic activities.  Operating in that environment requires special equipment and training just to survive there let alone fight and win there. I've long felt that we need a POLARCOM (Polar Command) as a separate regional unified command to address the threats and unique problems.

The X-37B robotic space plane (with a pickup truck-sized cargo bay) set an orbital duration record (for that craft) last month. There is a lot of speculation about the purpose of the craft, of course. Never say the Air Force doesn't aim high.

China will disband 5 of their 18 corps headquarters. The corps are 14, 16, 20, 27, and 47. I sincerely doubt that the 200,000 troops in those corps will be discharged. I assume this is just streamlining with the awareness that large-scale conventional warfare is unlikely in the near future and that 13 corps-level commands will suffice. Those troops might supply the manpower for China's announced dramatic expansion of their marine force, or paratroopers, as the article notes. There may also be a political angle.

Good God, these people are morons. Trump is certainly making them stupid. Tip to Instapundit.

China is nearing completion of interlocking radar and offensive and defensive capabilities in the South China Sea.

I was going to mock this plan to provide bedtime snacks for Army recruits by asking what's next, drill sergeants tucking in recruits at night in their bunks? But if it helps reduce casualties during basic training, I guess I won't whine too much about what it was like way back in 1988.

The ethnic Chinese community in France has learned from Moslem riots and car torching outings that this is the way to get attention, after French police called to deal with an altercation shot a Chinese man. How long before Iran get nukes and learns from China in this incident that Iran can call in a French ambassador to demand explanations for the shooting of a Moslem person in France?

Russia is concerned about United States Navy ships in the Black Sea because the Russians don't know what kind of missiles the ships carry. Note to Russia: They're the kind that explode. So don't buzz them in a dangerous manner.

Russia has a lot of problems, but don't assume that those problems will moderate or depose Putin. Bad regimes know how to endure.  And for real fun, if Putin goes, his successor could be much worse.

Kudos to United Airlines for resisting the fake outrage brigade that gathered to indict the company for preventing girls flying on virtually free tickets available through employees from boarding a plane because they failed to meet the dress code. I have some experience as a "non-rev" (non-revenue) passenger flying on a space-available basis. There was a dress code and a code of conduct with rules of engagement, too. You were expected to be quiet and not make requests of flight attendants who are busy serving paying customers. You can accept service or consumables if offered, but don't ask. But no, rather than understand the issue, the Outrage Brigade looking to recruit more victims for the unit opened fire on a company that did nothing wrong in a program that benefits employees.

The Democratic Party purge is on. Let's see if the party moderates in reaction to their long slide across America at the federal and state level, or whether the new DNC head decides it needs more cowbell and doubles down on leftist policies. An indicator will be if Green (a party of socialists who like to recycle, basically) presidential candidate Jill Stein joins the party, eh?

Russia continues to play spoiler in the Balkans, relying on Serbs as the anchor.  Trouble there is a potential distraction for NATO to holding the line against Russian advances in Ukraine and the Black Sea and in the eastern Mediterranean Sea.

Seriously? Reducing online privacy is a Republican priority?

Is America producing too much oil? A lot of time the impact of prices is focused on the effects on oil exporters and on the effect on alternative energy production. But a lot of countries import oil and the less affluent countries surely appreciate the relief on that burden. Is it possible that lower oil prices are the most effective anti-poverty program in the developing world? Drill baby, drill.

I don't know. I realize that I was just a Signal Corps REMF--and quite some time ago--but a third mechanical arm to hold a soldier's personal weapon looks stupid. Adjusting it to fire prone is one thing, but how do you hit the deck fast with that thing in front of you? Far better in the long run to have an exoskeleton to help lessen the burden of carrying and aiming a weapon, among other things, I think.

The British Prime Minister triggered the Brexit process formally. Good. Sometimes you have to escape the continent to emerge victorious. Let's hope the British aren't the only country to escape. The EU is no friend of America. We should not back a multi-ethnic anti-democratic imperial power that controls the continent west of Russia. Isn't one of those things in Europe problem enough?

Note to Democrats: This is actual Resistance to a dangerous government.

I don't believe Senator Schumer's rage is any less calculated than his tears. But the rubes love it.

The top American general in Europe wants more aerial surveillance and a full heavy division permanently based there. I'd rather have a full corps (see p. 15), but a full division is a start.

US-backed rebels in southern Syria have gained control of territory that ISIL had controlled as the ISIL fighters pull back to defend Raqqa.

Modern feminists get outraged that so many women refuse to call themselves "feminists." The feminists point to the big battles won in the past without realizing that modern feminists basically focus on trivial bullshit given that the big battles are past--and won. Feminists are now just the women's auxiliary of leftism, as far as I can see. Tip to Instapundit.

It is bad enough that modern feminism is largely the women's auxiliary of leftism, but the auxiliary has a stupid wing that is mind boggling in its ignorance.

America is increasing support for the Saudi-led coalition in Yemen. Which should be good news for Democrats since this fight against Iranian influence there is an example of "leading from behind," no?

China is upset that Japan will promote civilian settlements on their East China Sea islands. China has a lot of nerve to complain about that relatively small effort.

"Although critics would later point out the simplicity of Bierut's final design—a blue 'H' containing a rightward facing red arrow—a lot of thought went in to creating it, according to the essay. 'I put together a three-person team: me, designer Jesse Reed, and project manager Julia Lemle,' Bierut wrote. 'We would work in secret for the next two months.'" Funny, I always thought the Hillary Clinton campaign logo looked like a prison door being slammed shut. Tip to Instapundit.

If Democrats are truly outraged at Russian/Soviet interference in our elections that finally targeted them, why haven't any of them in Congress introduced a declaration of war bill to strike back at Russia? No worries, their sudden outrage will dissipate as Russian hostility returns to traditional Republican targets.

A police chief is upset that too many veterans being hired under veteran preference rules derails diversity goals. The chief should look on the bright side by remembering that many don't survive going to war to get non-disabled veteran status. It could be worse, eh? So the chief has that going for him.

South America's geography curtails its potential to be influential in world affairs.

Heh: "So you drastically expand the definition of 'sexual harassment,' and then promote an ethic that says that all accusations must be believed, and then you’re shocked that workplace men don’t want to hang out with women? How stupid are you?" Actually it is no laughing matter.

Venezuela's socialist autocrat made his loyal judiciary the legislative branch. Amazingly, protests led the court to rescind their order. For now. Thank God no American liberals want to do the same thing here! Although the court kept in place Maduro's power to loot the oil industry. So he can starve the opposition into submission more easily.

A proposed overall 1.2% decrease in discretionary spending by the Trump administration is not "gutting" the budget. What liberal bias? As an optimist, I'm encouraged that back in the day, a simple slowdown in the rate of growth was considered "gutting" the budget.

Sure, Trump's coal action won't by itself reverse coal's decline. But at least the free market will do the job rather than being killed by a government decision that is final. And who knows, with coal no longer under death sentence by the government, perhaps a free market will find ways to make coal more acceptable and useful, saving it and the jobs required to mine it and adapt it. If coal dies off because it is inferior to alternatives, so be it. But if coal can adapt and survive, will you really be upset?

Because Hillary Clinton was so trustworthy as a steward of our nation's secrets.

You'd think scientists could manage to make more than 1% of their scientific papers follow the scientific method. Speaking of which, the Slope's Mannkey Trial drags on with Mark Stein fighting Mann's defense of his discredited creation of the hockey stick.

With the need for NATO states to project power into and through Poland during a potential crisis with Russia, Poland's purchase of Patriot air defense missiles is a welcome addition to Polish defense capabilities.

I still want to know why the American military didn't move toward Benghazi in 2012 the way our para-military forces did. Arguing that the consulate couldn't have been saved assumes we knew when the crisis would end. Until it ended we didn't know how long the crisis would last. I never focused on the lies about the video. As odious as that explanation was, that was a political spin issue that was best resolved by politics. The voters didn't punish that, so the political angle is over. But we had plenty of forces in Europe and they did not even begin to move. Why?

Useful summary of issues around Obama spying on and Russian involvement with Trump allegations.

I don't know if my personal concerns about General Mike Flynn are because he has been targeted for reputation destruction or not. But the pattern of the politics of personal destruction by Democrats has long been clear; and the growing politicization of disagreements is equally clear. So I don't assume that Flynn's offer to testify in exchange for immunity means that there is Trump-damning information as much as I assume it is general self defense in this disturbing era.

The Fulcrum of Empire

The Spanish think they have been clever to get the European Union to grant Spain a virtual veto on Gibralter's future relationship with the EU. Spain may want to consider who is being clever considering Spain's potential separatist states.

Ah, nuance!

After reported lobbying from Spain, the EU's Brexit negotiation strategy is that decisions affecting Gibraltar will be run past the Spanish government.

Sure, Spain thinks Brexit is an opportunity to pry Gibralter from Britain.

Does Spain really want to encourage an EU policy that rewards and encourages separatism?

When Spain has enough separatist tendencies (and outposts in Africa) that might draw encouragement from a successful separation (even though Gibralter residents are overwhelmingly in favor of remaining part of Britain)?

And are other European states with separatist populations active or dormant really going to be supportive of such a self-defeating policy by the EU elites?


Because in my opinion, the European Union's ambitions to be a multi-ethnic empire would be advanced by breaking up European states that might decide--like Britain--to resist losing sovereignty to Brussels (even if those states resist from within the EU rather than leaving):

Why should the Brussels bureaucrats care if they ignore Belgians or Flemish and Walloons? Hell, the more the merrier. If larger states have difficulty moving the central proto-state, how will little specks on the map have any impact at all? Only the nation-states smart enough not to subdivide will retain any influence at all. But they will likely be swamped by population numbers. And who will be smart enough to resist the lure of their own flag!

There could be a Flemish Oblast and a Walloon Oblast to join with scores of other administrative entities.

This is classic divide and conquer.

Consider this incentive to divide a feature of the European Union rather than a bug. The Brussels transnational elites will laugh all the way to their new undemocratic empire while the silly people atomize their once-influential nation-states into little ethnic theme parks.

Let the people have their postage stamps and flags, the EU overlords likely think! The power will lie in Brussels, and who will be large enough to stop them?

The EU imperial project doesn't need to unify Europeans with a common European identity. The EU imperial project needs to atomize Europeans so nobody can resist the ever closer union that becomes a multi-ethnic empire with Brussels at the center playing one group off another before anyone notices.

The Rock might be the fulcrum that Brussels needs to leverage further fragmentation in Europe.

For Want of a Survivable Nail

Is India thinking of a counter-force nuclear doctrine?

Pakistan felt it needed nukes to stop an Indian invasion. India doesn't want to invade Pakistan, but no matter.

India could not let Pakistan be a nuclear power without becoming one, too; and with an increasingly powerful China on its border with claims on Indian territory, India figured having nukes to stop a Chinese invasion of India would be nice as well.

For Pakistan, India's possession of nukes now nullifies Pakistan's ability to deter an invasion by threatening Indian cities because India would just nuke Pakistan right back. So India's conventional advantage is again dominant because Pakistan's choice is to let India take Pakistan's cities or nuke them.

If India wanted Pakistan's cities, which they don't. But that reality is beside the point now.

So Pakistan now builds "tactical" nukes designed to go after India's conventional invasion forces.

Which is a problem itself since those "tactical" strikes on Indian units invading Pakistan are hitting Pakistani territory. So the solution is that now Pakistan is self-nuking? That might work for a bit.

Until India replies with "tactical" nukes hitting Pakistani conventional units inside Pakistani territory.

Then a low-level nuclear war is all fought on Pakistani territory. Is this what Pakistan is trying to achieve?

India is now saying that it won't just let its conventional units be nuked:

Mr. [Shivshankar Menon, India’s national security adviser from 2011 to 2014], in his book, seemed to settle on an answer to India’s quandary: “Pakistani tactical nuclear weapon use would effectively free India to undertake a comprehensive first strike against Pakistan,” he wrote.

The word “comprehensive” refers to a nuclear attack against an adversary’s arsenal, rather than its cities. It is meant to instigate and quickly win a nuclear exchange, leaving the other side disarmed.

So India will feel free to strike Pakistan's nuclear arsenal in a preemptive nuclear attack?

So India wants the ability to hold Pakistan's cities hostage by disarming Pakistan's nuclear arsenal and leaving Pakistan open to Indian conventional military superiority?

Oh, and how many Indian nukes will explode on Pakistani territory to achieve that?

Which means that Pakistan goes on hair-trigger alert in a "use them or lose them" posture to launch their nukes before the Indian nukes detonate over them.

If I may be so bold, gulp.

We really need to get Indian and Pakistani nuclear policy people to study our long history of thought on this subject from the Cold War.

The sooner India and Pakistan focus on smaller but survivable nuclear deterrents rather than starting an offensive arms race (to make sure something survives a disarming strike) that drags in China--which then might pull in Japan, Taiwan, South Korea and then Australia and Indonesia--the better.

Not to mention inspiring nations west in the Middle East to arm up.

The really, really funny part of this is that India has no desire to conquer Pakistan.

Have a super sparkly day.

UPDATE: More from Strategypage on the Pakistan-backed terrorists who are the first rung on the escalation ladder to nuclear war.

Saturday, April 01, 2017

False Compassion in Action

I assume this professor is racist because Iraq War 2.0 and the Mosul offensive itself began under the Obama administration:

George Ciccariello-Maher, who teaches at Drexel University, tweeted Sunday: "Some guy gave up his first class seat for a uniformed soldier. People are thanking him. I'm trying not to vomit or yell about Mosul." Ciccariello-Maher's account is private, but screenshots of his tweet were shared by others.

Apparently, the Bizarro World compassion as defined by that man requires America to stand down in our effort to help Iraqis liberate Mosul from killer terrorists and simply let ISIL continue to run the city and kill and abuse largely Moslem people.

So perhaps the professor is just Islamophobic.

I wonder if that hyphenated asshat-teacher "yelled about" Mosul since mid-2014 when ISIL took it over?

Has the teacher "yelled about" Mosul when ISIL herds civilians into buildings that ISIL uses to fire at advancing Iraqi soldiers?

Does that man "yell about" the Syrian/Russian/Iranian approach to air strikes?

Air strikes struck a hospital in western Syria last week, killing two people, and there is evidence chemical weapons were used, Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) said on Friday.

Maybe the chemical weapons charge is wrong--this time--but the deliberate bombing of civilians is standard operating procedures for our foes.

Let me respond to that fool in higher education's echelon above reality with the comments of LTG Townsend, who addresses the issues around casualties and responsibility:

Yeah, I'd like to say something before we close it out here.

A little disappointing to me that all the questions were about our airstrikes and our process and our decisions. And it almost seems to me like it was completely lost on everybody, and I hope it's not lost in your reporting, what I said about who is killing innocents here in Iraq and Syria. If -- if these innocents were killed by the coalition, it was an unintentional accident of war.

And ISIS is slaughtering Iraqis and Syrians on a daily basis. ISIS is cutting off heads. ISIS is shooting people, throwing people form buildings, burning them alive in cases, and they're making a video record to prove it. This has got to stop. This evil has got to be stamped out.

And in my mind, all the responsibility for any civilian deaths, the moral responsibility for civilian deaths in Iraq and Syria belongs to ISIS.

I will close with that. Thanks.

I'm sure if pushed the professor would say he's against ISIL, of course. He just has in mind some vaguely defined magical thinking-based solution to ending the ISIL occupation and brutalization of a city full of people without the need to close with and destroy the enemy that fights among civilians as a deliberate tactic.

Perhaps a hashtag campaign: #ISILstopbeingmean.

Or maybe a safety pin worn on his lapel.

But probably not.

Sometimes people aren't dissenting or even compassionate--they're just on the other side.

I will try not to vomit about the ignorant tweeting of an ignorant-repulsive man who isn't worthy of polishing that soldier's boots.

Somebody should scrape the COEXIST bumper sticker off of that professor's Prius.

After ISIL

I've been hearing generals talking about keeping American troops in Iraq after the defeat of ISIL in Mosul. But does the Trump administration really plan to otherwise walk away from Iraq and risk Iraq War 3.0?

Seriously?

The Trump administration has indicated it plans to largely abdicate a U.S. role in Iraq's political future, despite the certainty that driving the Islamic State group from its remaining stronghold in Mosul – months, if not weeks, away – starts the clock on a dangerous new era for a country on the verge of fracturing along rival warring factions.

The prospect of a reduced U.S. role leaves a vacuum in crafting a long-term political solution to reassemble Iraq. Chief among the concerns is that the country's religious and ethnic populations – minority Sunni Muslims who felt victimized by the central government in Baghdad and now fear retribution, ethnic Kurds certain to seek independence for their semiautonomous region, and a majority Shiite population thought to be under the sway of Iran – will turn on each other without a common enemy to unite their efforts.

The Shias are hardly all--or even a majority of them--in thrall to the Iranians. Nor are the Kurds a unified block. And Sunni Arabs have those sympathetic to jihadis and those not.

But is the bottom line that we won't make sure that Iraqi factions--more than the three the article highlights--don't resort to violence to achieve goals outside of a political process within a system that is reasonably close to rule of law democracy?

That is disturbing.

And this is disturbing in the post-ISIL arena:

The United States is no longer making removing Syrian President Bashar al-Assad from power a focus of its policy in the war-torn country, the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations said on Thursday, in a departure from the Obama administration's initial stance on Assad's fate.

Of course, the idea that Obama was on anything other than a path to accept Assad even if it was a hope for Assadism without the actual Assad is ridiculous.

But I had hoped that Syria under the Assad clan had a long enough record of killing Americans, from the Iraq War all the way back to the Marines in Lebanon in the 1980s, and otherwise being a thorn in our side--including as a hand puppet of Iran--that deciding that the Assad regime should be destroyed even aside from its bloody record against its own people would be an easy choice to make.

Apparently not.

We will regret not trying to shape Iraq and Syria after ISIL is defeated. Let's hope these apparent choices are reconsidered.

UPDATE: Good grief, what part of "when you strike a king, kill him" is unclear?

The White House on Friday backed top aides' comments that the United States is not now focused on making Syrian President Bashar al-Assad leave power, saying the U.S. focus is on defeating Islamic State militants.

Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and U.S. ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley on Thursday drew criticism for playing down a long-standing U.S. goal of persuading Assad to leave power to help end the six-year-long Syrian civil war.

Assad has been our enemy. He will continue to be our enemy if he survives.

And the idea that under Obama we had a goal of persuading Assad to leave power should not be misinterpreted as having a policy to get rid of him. The Obama administration's policy really was a policy of figuring out how to ask nicely with the right words for Assad to step down while helping enemies of Assad enough to get Assad mad at us but not enough to defeat Assad.

So a Trump policy of accepting Assad is no change in policy given that Assad doesn't want to step down.

Leaving Assad in power is a mistake. What part of Iranian puppet and host for Russian military bases is unclear?

UPDATE: Bonus warnings about threats to Syria and Iraq from our absence in Iraq a year before Mosul fell and 6 months before Anbar fell in Iraq.

Will we make the exact same mistake again?

And ... in Libya

Factions in Libya are seeking to control oil export infrastructure. Which is necessary to win a civil war, of course.

You have to pay your supporters and buy weapons:

A power struggle for control of Libya’s oil is threatening to deepen splits in the country and undermine the fragile authority of the UN-backed Libyan Government of National Accord, the GNA.

As I wrote early in the Libyan revolt, if you want to have a civil war you have to have the financial resources to back it.

The simmering civil war could get ramped up if the West doesn't get the factions to unite and focus their firepower on surviving jihadis so they don't rebuild and not on each other.

Responsibility to Protect in Libya was implemented as a drive-by shooting of Khadaffi without any real effort to help one faction win.

However much Khadaffi deserved that end, 6 years after the start of that war, not much is better and in some ways Libya is much worse as nobody has won the sputtering civil war that may yet go full bore.

UPDATE: So far it is more flying elbows rather than sustained civil war:

East Libyan forces said on Wednesday they had carried out air strikes and a ground attack on an air base controlled by rivals from the western city of Misrata, prompting a pledge of retaliation from the government in Tripoli.

Tamanhent air base, near the city of Sabha, is on a frontline between loose armed alliances based in eastern and western Libya that have been vying for power in an on-off conflict since 2014.

That can change.

Russia loves chaos to insert themselves in as a reliable partner willing to do what it takes to win.