Friday, December 19, 2008

A Little Sympathy for Pakistan, Please

I am certainly frustrated by Pakistan's inability to fully fight jihadis on their soil. But even as the black sheep of our alliance, the Pakistanis are trying in spite of the significant support for jihadis inside their country and even their security forces.

Secretary of Defense Gates put it well:



Well, the problem that we face is that, for most of its history, Pakistan has regarded India as its existential threat. And I think it's only been in the last few months that they have come to realize that what is going on in the western part of their country also represents an existential threat to their country from their own standpoint.

And so we've seen their army going from basically doing nothing in the northwest frontier area earlier this year to being pretty actively engaged in combat. They're getting better a counterinsurgency. They're a little bit like the U.S. Army 10 years ago, just as our Army was principally trained to take on the Soviets at the (folded gap ?), the Pakistani army is trained largely to take on the Indians.

And so they are learning as we learn here in Iraq how to do counterinsurgency. And they are suffering a lot of casualties. They are in the fight and have been for the last number of weeks.

We are eager the help them. We have to partner with them. We are ready, willing and able, but we are also sensitive to their sovereignty. They are very sensitive to the size of the American footprint in their country. But I think we are beginning to see the growth of trilateral cooperation among Afghanistan, Pakistan and the United States in trying to deal with this threat on the border.

I think it's a long-term problem, but I am heartened that the Pakistanis are taking it seriously and do, I think, now appreciate the dangers to them of what is going on out there in those ungoverned spaces.

So it's going slowly at this point, but they are making sacrifices. Pakistanis are dying in conflict with these violent extremists. And we just want to help them as much as we can.


It is admittedly tempting to just say screw 'em and put them in the enemy category. That would be a mistake. An imperfect ally is better than an enemy. Especially when that imperfect ally has atomic weapons.

When we rely on Pakistan for our supplies in Afghansitan and the major military effort against jihadis in the Pakistani tribal areas, it is wise to act grown up about the whole situation. Let's help Pakistan be a better ally and not just ensure they become an enemy.