Sunday, June 11, 2017

Too Big to Lose

We count on the aircraft carrier too much to control the seas:

The loss would of one would drastically weaken the force, leaving it significantly less likely to be able to accomplish the task at hand. Centralizing so much of the fleet’s firepower in a single ship is effective when that ship is impervious to enemy attacks but dangerous when it and all of its capabilities are at risk of being lost all at once.

Sinking the symbol of U.S. power also would have severe political implications. Today the carrier is a powerful diplomatic tool that the nation uses to reassure its allies and warn its foes. There is no better example of its influence than the 1996 Taiwan Strait crisis, in which two carrier strike groups reminded China of the might of the U.S. Navy. How effective would that message have been if a carrier had recently been defeated in battle?

The domestic effects of a carrier’s defeat likely would be even worse. How many political leaders could support U.S. involvement in a conflict after the nightly news broadcast video of a burning carrier? How many wars would the American people support if a carrier sank, potentially killing more Americans in a single day than the number who died in the attacks on Pearl Harbor and on 9/11, or in Iraq and Afghanistan combined?

Yeah, I've mentioned the potential loss of life in a carrier sinking and I've been worried about the carrier's centrality in our national morale for for a long time:

I've worried that the loss of a carrier (or more) in the western Pacific should we come to blows with China would be a major psychological blow to America given how much our super carriers are seen as a symbol of our power. Even though our Navy could fight and win without our super carriers, the image of a big carrier in flames and going down would be potent.

Funny enough, I wrote that sinking Chinese carriers would lessen the blow of losing our own carriers. In that sense, China's investment in the carrier is helpful to American morale.

Also, I assume that our surface ships, subs, and planes will have sufficient anti-ship weapons to cope with the loss of carriers. If they don't, I'm wrong about ultimate victory despite losing carriers.

Anyway, it is nice to see worries about the carrier's centrality and survivability make the pages of Proceedings. They purchased an article of mine in 1999 on this very subject urging the demotion of the platform-centric carrier in favor of network-centric dispersal of offensive firepower across the fleet, but didn't publish it (no, I'm not slightly bitter about that).

I'm amazed it has to be said, but if it floats, it can sink. It can certainly be put out of the fight for the duration.

I worry that the cost of carriers and the effort we must take to protect them are all out of proportion to the bang we get in the sea control mission.

If we need numbers of ships in the fleet, we can't rely on carriers. So pick a number we need and adjust our ship types accordingly.

Although the biggest problem in these debates is that people fail to recognize that we are really debating two different carrier topics: sea control and power projection.

Carriers are too big to lose for the former but valuable for the latter.

Of course, China might understand that the carrier is increasingly only a power projection asset and so deny our Navy the chance to sink one or two of theirs to lessen the impact of losing one or more of our own.

Do read all of that Proceedings article I quoted.

And I'd pay good money to have a Navy exercise about facing off against a Red fleet that starts with the American carriers being declared sunk at the start of the exercise, with the commander of the surviving ships tasked with facing the enemy and rescuing crews on sinking ships and in the water.

UPDATE: Expanding the fleet will cost a lot of money. Perhaps too much money to fully carry out.

So why not fill out some of the numbers with modularized auxiliary cruisers? These could be the ground force versions (see page 50) or pure Navy versions.

Saturday, June 10, 2017

It is Time to Equip The AFRICOM Queen

The Marine force designated as the crisis response force for Africa contingencies was focused on support for special forces operations. With bases in Spain and Italy, the force could use The AFRICOM Queen.

The Marines find themselves busy in Africa:

In preparation for its deployment last October, the Marine Corps' crisis response task force for Africa met and trained with Navy SEALs in Dam Neck, Va.; with the Army's 3rd Special Forces Group in Fort Bragg, N.C.; and with MARSOC Raiders aboard nearby Camp Lejeune.

And when the task force arrived in theater, forward-staged in Sigonella, Italy, and Moron, Spain, there was no question what was emerging as the most pressing mission for the unit.

"What we found during our deployment was the preponderance of our effort and focus the entirety of our deployment, seven days a week, was focused on support to special operations," Col. Dan Greenwood, the rotation's commander and commanding officer of 2nd Marine Regiment, said at a deployment debrief Thursday.

In "The AFRICOM Queen" I proposed a modularized auxiliary cruiser equipped as a power projection vessel to extend AFRICOM's reach beyond the range of ground forces located in southern Europe and Djibouti.

In many ways, it would be most useful as a special operations carrier. With a company of special operations capable Marines and supporting aircraft and other systems embarked, that's what it would be.

This would extend the range of ground forces currently tied to the southern shores of Europe beyond the northwest corner of Africa.

Unless the Navy makes Africa a higher priority for major ship deployments, how will Marines earmarked for Africa be more than Army troops with different uniforms stationed ashore?

I know the Marines are looking for alternate ways to put Marines afloat that don't rely on traditional amphibious vessels that never seem to make it to Africa (except when transiting to and from CENTCOM). A modularized auxiliary cruiser would provide that alternate platform.

R2D2 is My Copilot

That's interesting:

In April 2017 the U.S. Air Force demonstrated that F-16s equipped to operate as UAVs could successfully operate in formation with manned F-16s. This is all part of the “Loyal Wingman” program for eventually integrating combat UAVs with piloted warplanes. The F-16 UAV needed software that would allow it to fly in formation execute attack missions on its own, to avoid interference from jamming.

This is just the beginning of that capability. But it is beginning.

I had speculated on just such a capability five years ago when trying to think outside the box about Israeli attack option on Iran's nuclear facilities:

What if the Israelis haul out a bunch of their 200+ A-4s, F-4s, and Kfir C-7s from reserves and outfit them with GPS bombs? Would the Israelis get pilots to go on one-way suicide missions or simply land the planes after the strike at neutral sites so the pilots survive and who cares if the locals confiscate the planes in retaliation for unauthorized landings? Or could the Israelis turn these reserve planes into drones guided from the ground so only the ancient air frames are at risk? Or a mix, with a small number of piloted planes controlling 3 or 4 drone strike planes each?

America has a lot of retired F-16s to fill this role. It is interesting.

Let's hope the links can't be hacked. That would be interesting in a bad way.

How Many Divisions Does the Media Have?

The idea that jihadis want to divide people by provoking a "division" between nominally Christian Western citizens and their Moslem immigrant neighbors is nonsense all the way around:

When death stalks the land, make no mistake: He may look like a grim reaper, but he's really a grim sower. An entire sowing bee of experts has so decreed. Indeed, in their warnings about sowing division, our betters are so non-divided that they give off the faintly creepy whiff of fellows all reading off the same cue card helpfully biked round to them by the Central Commissar ten minutes after the "incident" occurred.

If division is the problem, the real division comes from the people who want to deny that Islamists are killing in the name of Islam and who want to carry on after a terror attack as if nothing as happened without mentioning that the jihadis must be defeated.

These people seem to think that if jihadis are named as the enemy, the dumb knuckle-draggers who sadly have European citizenship will confuse that identity with all Moslems and go on a "backlash" killing spree. Better to endure the periodic "lashes" of bombings than risk that!

But by refusing to say that Islamist jihadis are using Islam as a weapon, the people who want to just carry on are basically saying that there is no difference between the jihadis and Moslems. Why should naming and fighting jihadis paint all Moslems as jihadis? Isn't that assumption the true Islamophobia? Isn't basically saying that we can't fight "jihadis" lest the majority Moslems take it personally the failure of liberals to properly divide jihadis from Moslems?

While the minority that is jihadi-friendly or tolerant is distressingly high, the clear majority of Moslems don't support jihadis. But jihadis want to use the barrel of a gun (and the nails of IEDs) to compel Moslems to support the jihad--or else.

If we don't fight the jihadis--and help Moslems resist the jihadis--the jihadis will succeed in redefining Islam in their sick vision. Ah, the glorious end of division?

And at some point we may have to come to grips that maybe jihadis aren't trying to "divide" us. Maybe the jihadis just like to blow us apart.

Operation Overlong Wrapping Up

Victory in Mosul--it is basically done but for killing the last surrounded die-hards--is not the end of the fight against ISIL in Iraq. But it is a good milestone. The victory took too long.

This is a nice salute to the Iraqi troops who spearheaded the attack to liberate Mosul:

They are Iraq’s best soldiers — the lead battalion of the three brigades of special forces that are heralded as the “Golden Division,” the almost-invincible killers of ISIS — and they know the final battle in Mosul rests on their shoulders. Passersby had honked their horns and cheered when, two days earlier, they rolled north in a convoy from Baghdad. The highway shook as flatbed trucks hauled their bullet-marked Humvees toward the front lines, each painted in the trademark black of the special forces, with the black-clad soldiers perched on top like gargoyles as Iraqi flags thrashed in the headwind. The battalion’s commander, Maj. Salam al-Obaidi, 38, guided the convoy from a white SUV emblazoned with a screaming eagle. A compact and fiery man with a buzz cut and trim mustache, his exploits against ISIS have made him one of the most recognizable soldiers in Iraq. When he rolled through checkpoints, Iraqi soldiers and Shiite militiamen came up to his window to shake his hand and take selfies.

These troops have fought well and bled for this victory (along with other troops less celebrated). My complaint isn't with them.

The battle for Mosul took longer than I thought it should and the start of the offensive took way longer than I anticipated.

Prior to the battle there were signs of shaky ISIL morale, but we may have failed to exploit that opportunity to make the war go faster.

Once finally in action at Mosul, the Iraqis went slowly to avoid killing innocents by accident. That might have caused more casualties in the long run by stretching the fight out, but the media can't understand that cause of death due to failure to win faster.

Basically, while the flow of the war took shape as I wanted it, the fight has taken too long.

The Iraq front should have been won by the end of 2015. The Syria front by the end of 2016. We should be well into the fight against Assad while suppressing ISIL terrorism in Iraq and liberated Syria.

Seriously, this war is taking way too long.

In the same amount of time since ISIL took Mosul in June 2014 to crushing ISIL in Mosul, with perhaps 30,000 ISIL fighters under command across Iraq and Syria at peak strength, America reacted to the Pearl Harbor assault, built a military, invaded France (with side campaigns in Africa and Italy before this), and drove to the borders of Germany (all while waging offensive war on Japan) against millions of German troops battle-hardened in their campaigns since 1939.

Terror in the West is one result of letting the caliphate live for so long so needlessly, giving jihadis hope of victory. Why wouldn't jihadis think Allah is on their side given they've endured so long in their caliphate against a global alliance pulled together by America?

So salute the Iraqi troops who have defeated ISIL in Mosul. They've earned that.

But it is shameful that it took so long to carry out this offensive against such a weak enemy.

UPDATE: Just in time considering the Syria Front could heat up:

Syria said its troops and allied forces reached the Iraqi border on Friday, for the first time since 2015, a day after a US jet shot down a pro-regime combat drone.

State news agency SANA, citing a military source, said "army units in cooperation with allies managed to arrive at the border... with Iraq" and "set up positions in an area northeast of At-Tanaf".

That's a long way from support and reinforcements for those Syrian forces.

UPDATE: This front could heat up in different ways:

Russia said on Saturday it had told the United States it was unacceptable for Washington to strike pro-government forces in Syria after the U.S. military carried out an air strike on pro-Assad militia last month.

Russia would be at a disadvantage in a clash with American forces in the region. Russia could get a good first shot in, but unless America backs down, the counter-attack would go badly for Russia.

Is Russia really willing to risk war with America over a non-objective? Seriously, Russia has no interest in Assad extending his control to eastern Syria which strengthens Iran in Syria. Russia has an interest in having Assad control western Syria where Russian bases are; and having Assad reliant on Russia for survival.

I suspect these are just formal words that Russia has to say publicly. But it is inherently dangerous. Russia could easily give Assad weapons to strike American forces, keeping Russia out of direct action, even if it would not be enough to defeat American forces.

Friday, June 09, 2017

Hezbollah Thinks America is Their Biggest Problem?

Hezbollah might want to reconsider belligerent talk like this:

The Syrian government's allies will strike at American positions inside Syria if it crosses any "red lines," Hezbollah warned on Wednesday.

The Lebanese militant group, a close ally to the Syrian government, issued the threat via its military media arm — one day after American forces bombed pro-government forces in eastern Syria.

Given that Israel has a closer relationship with America now, and given that there have been some talk of a war between Israel and Hezbollah, Hezbollah should probably worry a little more about Israel conducting a thorough campaign to stamp down Hezbollah's threat to Israel.

When Up is Down and Bottom is on Top, It Gets Rather Strange*

I don't want to hear another Goddamn thing about conservatives being anti-science:

Whitney Stark argues in support of “combining intersectionality and quantum physics” to better understand “marginalized people” and to create “safer spaces” for them, in the latest issue of The Minnesota Review.

Because traditional quantum physics theory has influenced humanity’s understanding of the world, it has also helped lend credence to the ongoing regime of racism, sexism and classism that hurts minorities, Stark writes in “Assembled Bodies: Reconfiguring Quantum Identities.”

Yeah, societal winter is coming, all right.

These people earn obscene amounts of money churning out this dross. I wouldn't trust them to explain Fig Newtons let alone Newtonian physics.

And people are too afraid to say it is all utter nonsense and that the emperor has no science.

Tip to Instapundit.

*With apologies to charm.

Close Your Eyes and Think of England?

The notion that doing something prudent to take into account jihadi terrorism's impact on our lives is "letting the terrorists" win is nonsense. When attacked, it is smart to react to avoid the attacks, to stop the attacks, and to punish the attackers.

Consider this slice of life in 1970s New York City (in an era when 5 bombs per day went off in America over one 18-month period):

“Radical violence was so deeply woven into the fabric of 1970s America that many citizens, especially in New York and other hard-hit cities, accepted it as part of daily life.” When a bomb exploded at a Bronx movie theater on May 1, 1970, police tried to clear the building, but patrons refused to leave, demanding to see the rest of their film.

Perhaps it is just me, but I think that when terrorists plant a bomb in the theater you are in and you just stay to watch the end of the movie, the terrorists are winning.

UPDATE: Related thoughts from Mark Steyn:

The worst civilian massacre in the United Kingdom between the Second World War and the 7/7 attacks of 2005 was the Birmingham pub bombings of 1974. For good or ill, it convulsed the nation. In contrast to the now traditional response that the worst thing about an Islamic terror attack is that it might lead to a "backlash" against Muslims and the urgent priority is for everyone to pretend that they're "united" in "one love", the pub bombings led to the immediate cancellation of the city's St Patrick's Day parade, the third largest in the world, for the next decade. Twenty-one Birmingham pubgoers died that night. Now 22 people get slaughtered at a pop concert, and the public shrug it off with some candles and flowers. Eleven civilians were killed in the 1987 Enniskillen Remembrance Day massacre (a twelfth died after 13 years in a coma), and public outrage was so fierce that the Dublin parliament passed a fast-track UK extradition bill, the IRA apologized, Sinn Féin's electoral support didn't recover for 15 years, and Bono declared on stage "F**k the revolution" - which on the whole I prefer to Katy Perry saying touch the person next to you and tell her "I love you".

Please. Don't get used to these slaughters. That's when the terrorists truly win.

Thursday, June 08, 2017

Cast a Giant Shudder

Russia will conduct in the fall a large exercise in western Russia:

Although Russia has not disclosed the size of the Zapad (West) exercises that it holds every four years on its western borders, analysts have said that this year's drill may be the largest in quarter of a century, with a movement of about 100,000 Russian troops expected.

The Lithuanians are building a fence along their western border with Russia on the Kaliningrad exclave to prevent infiltration and incidents coming from the Russian side during the exercises (while hoping they remain exercises and not a cover for some type of aggression).

In light of the large number of Russian troops anticipated to participate, this is kind of pathetic:

The recent deployment of 1,000 NATO troops to Poland and each of the Baltic states has unnerved Moscow, which had warned in January that it was a bad idea.

Putin struts about like a modern Mussolini boasting of restoring the glories of Rome, yet a mere 4,000 NATO troops have unnerved Russia which can mass 100,000 troops for an exercise?

Seriously? Unnerved? By four battalion task forces stretching from the Gulf of Finland to the Ukrainian border?

That's pretty sad, dudes.

It is Better to Give Than to Receive

The Army is aiming for a lot more ammunition to deter the Russians in Europe:

An eye-opening item in the 2018 defense budget request is the serious money that the U.S. Army is pumping into its arsenal of high-tech missiles and munitions. ...

A ramp-up in munitions manufacturing is a direct consequence of the Army’s shift toward “offensive deterrence,” observed Hamilton Cook, senior analyst at the consulting firm Avascent. “What you’re really seeing in the budget is a shift to offensive fires.”

I noted the ammunition request. Which is related to heavying up the Army force structure.

And I've noted the scary quality of Russian offensive artillery.

So yeah, the Army needs to be able to return the favor. Apparently the Army has the same sense to worry given the scale of this budget request.

Keep it Soviet, Stupid

The world is more peaceful. Round up the Unicorns to thank!

Steven Pinker, the Harvard University scholar and author of the 2011 book “The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined,” says societies are becoming more “enmeshed” and seeking “a higher good,” resulting in less violence.

Two things. One, the disappearance of the Soviet Union is a big part of the decline in violence the last quarter century (quoting Strategypage here):

This is all a post-Cold War trend that has been going on since the 1990s. Let us hope it continues.

Most current wars are basically uprisings against police states or feudal societies which are seen as out-of-step with the modern world. Many are led by radicals preaching failed dogmas (Islamic conservatism, Maoism and other forms of radical socialism) that still resonate among people who don't know about the dismal track records of these creeds. Iran has replaced some of the lost Soviet terrorist support effort. That keeps Hezbollah, Hamas, and a few smaller groups going, and that's it. Terrorists in general miss the Soviets, who really knew how to treat bad boys right. [emphasis added]

Second, the violence that is raging out there is in areas of vital interest to America:

[The] overall decline in wars and deaths has taken place in areas where we don't have vital interests. Yet as we pivoted away from the Middle East to focus on Asia, and as we thought Europe was safe, Asia remains under threat by a rising China while the Middle East burst into flames again and Europe has again become a point of conflict as Russia attempts to reverse the territorial losses of our victory in the Cold War.

Face it, this is another example of the KISS principle. If the Soviet Union was still a going concern, we wouldn't be talking about a safer world.

And when a comedian (WARNING: Image of grotesque red-hued skull--plus a severed head, of course) and those on a mission from God both think that holding up a severed bloody head is pretty cool, I don't want to hear a Goddamn word about "enmeshed" societies seeking a higher good.

UPDATE: More from the Soviet archives:

Other revelations from the Moscow archives revealed that the Soviets had already created schemes that were indeed stranger than fiction. These included a plan to move saboteurs from Nicaragua across the Mexican border and into the U.S. disguised as illegal aliens. Radar stations, pipelines and power towers were all targeted in great detail as were port facilities in places like New York City. Other archive documents, available to researchers for a few years in the early 1990s (when a fistful of hundred dollar bills could work wonders) delivered all manner of disturbing and now well documented proofs. The Rosenbergs were indeed Russian spies, Alger Hiss was mixed up in Russian espionage efforts and the American Communist Party was in the pay of the Soviet Union and served as a tool for espionage, subversion and propaganda. Many left wing writers and politicians were either on the Soviet payroll, or eager to assist Soviet espionage activities.

Read it all. The death of the Soviet Union was a tremendous victory for the West. Have no doubt.

And yes, Russia was behind the Korean War--not China, which bled for Russia.

And in related news, the Chinese military isn't as good as it looks. Let's hope our military is.

Elsewhere I've read that if Korea had worked out the Russians could have tried that with divided Germany.

The Firepower-Protection Race Continues

Should Russia's new Armata tank with its active protection system worry NATO?

Active protection systems (APS) are being built into Russia's new Armata T-14 tank, posing a problem for a whole generation of anti-armour weapons, not least the US-supplied Javelin guided missile, used by the Norwegian Army.

The warning comes from Brig Ben Barry of the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) in London. He says this is a problem that most Nato countries have barely begun to grapple with.

APS threatens to make existing anti-tank weapons far less effective, and there is little real discussion of this among many Western militaries, he says.

The Russians pioneered this technology in the 1980s to counter the proliferation of more effective anti-tank missiles in NATO. But it wasn't deployed.

So assuming it isnt a Potemkin Tank, I guess one question is whether Russia can afford to build the Armata. I suspect the answer is no given the resources being put into upgrading T-80s (noted in this data dump).

Russia is not in good financial shape to put many Armata--if it works--into service.

In general, active protection systems that work are a problem to be overcome. But I don't see them as the final word in the race between tank survivability and the ability to kill tanks.

If APS works, logically you could lighten a vehicle by thinning the passive armor. But I don't think that APS can replace bulky and heavy armor because there are other ways to kill a vehicle protected by APS.

Surely, better minds than mine in the armored vehicle field have considered how to defeat APS that will have ammunition limits and limits on how many incoming rounds it can cope with.

Here are options off the top of my head.

What if anti-tank weapons fired by infantry use a "round" that drops a crawling smart mine outside of the range of the APS that then moves under the tank to explode against thin bottom armor?

Top-attack missiles were designed to cope with effective passive armor. APS counters top-attack missiles. Why not bottom-attack weapons?

Maybe the "round" fired is a one-shot weapon dropped outside of the APS radius that crawls forward to fire a HEAT round at the tank within the minimum firing range of the APS? 

Maybe volley fire is possible from a single tank gun in the 130-140mm range fires an anti-tank round that fires a half dozen penetrator rods each with different shapes to retard their flight in order to fire a "train" of rods that reach the target one after the other, making the defending APS fire at the early arriving rod only to let the following rods fly in unopposed by an APS still cycling for another salvo.

Even if the APS can kill 5 of the rods, the sixth would kill the tank if the velocity is high enough.

Worry, yes. But work the problem.

And any problem we have coping with APS should be a problem our enemies have. Why we aren't more ambitious about APS on our armored vehicles is a mystery.

UPDATE: It looks like APS is coming to an Abrams near you:

For the past few months, Army leaders have been openly touting the service's accelerated effort to arm the M1 Abrams tank and other key platforms with APS technology to counter the proliferation of anti-tank guided missiles (ATGM) and Russia's aggressive modernization of its armored fleet.

Good. It doesn't win the race. But it keeps our tanks in the race, at least.

Wednesday, June 07, 2017

America the Vital Ally

Europe can barely defend itself or the integrity of what they really care about--soccer.

European defense capacity is pathetic:

The U.S. defense budget, $680 billion by NATO calculations, dwarfs the alliance’s European members, which spend a total of $242 billion.

Europeans have tried for decades to more efficiently build military hardware and organize troops. That effort is littered with failures, delays and compromises. Today European allies spend roughly half as much as the U.S. on defense yet have less than one-sixth of its combat power, European officials acknowledge.

I'd be ecstatic if Europe had 36% of our military capacity to reflect their budgets. But they have just 17% of American capabilities.

And Europe doesn't have to send their military across the Atlantic to reach the theater and doesn't have a large nuclear force that serves as a deterrent to NATO's enemies as much as America's foes.

If Europeans matched America's spending effort and output, I'd likely die from my happiness level.

But no, America has to pick up the slack. And Europe is an objective to fight over even if Europe spent nothing, truth be told. So we must defend Europe.

Europeans seem to be reacting finally to Russian threats and overseas threats making it to their own streets. But it will take time.

Speaking of the Russians, they profess to fear the threat from European NATO. How pathetic is that?

But I digress (as I can).

And for real yucks in the realm of American leadership, America had to take the lead in fighting for the integrity of what Europeans laughably call "football" but which everyone knows is just soccer:

The U.S. investigation of corruption linked to FIFA has indicted or taken guilty pleas from more than 40 people and marketing agencies linked to soccer in the Americas since 2015. Many of the charges involve bribes paid around the organization of regional tournaments and World Cup qualifying games.

Europe couldn't even be trusted to fight corruption in the governing body of soccer. And America doesn't really care very much about it. How sad is that?

I'd Drop Them on Taipei If I Was Lord of the PLA

China has reorganized their airborne corps into independent brigades. Taiwan is one target.

China's airborne troops can now be deployed more quickly:

In early 2017 the Chinese airborne force, the 35,000 personnel of the 15th Airborne Corps, underwent a major reorganization in which the three airborne divisions and an aviation brigade became a force of nine separate brigades (six airborne, one special operations, one support and one aviation brigade). The airborne divisions no longer existed as the brigades report directly to corps headquarters. ...

Currently the 15th Airborne Corps is a major component in the new rapid reaction forces. China now has enough air transports (Il-76s, Yu-8s, Yu-7s) to move one of the 11,000 man airborne divisions to anywhere in China within 24 hours.

Or the 11,000 troops-lift capacity could focus on the assault elements of the six airborne and one special forces which could be landed first, I imagine, with the rest coming in future waves.

This fits well with a Chinese shot right at Taipei to capture the political capital as the main effort to disrupt organized resistance to a Chinese invasion that is part of a larger invasion .

I think the Chinese marines are mostly a distraction better suited to the islands of the South China Sea (and East China Sea).

So the paratrooper changes are far more relevant to China's threats to invade Taiwan.

On the bright side, Strategypage notes that China faces threats inland that could call on China's airborne forces:

These [air mobile] operations would be a major feature of an attempt to take Taiwan by force or quickly reinforcing remote Tibet in case there were a local rebellion. Another threat is the newly created Indian Mountain Corps that is based on the border and could cross the border unexpectedly in the 2020s, when this new Indian units reaches full strength of 80,000 troops.

Yes, we should want China focused on the interior of Asia to dilute their focus and spread their military out.

Into Raqqa

The battle for Raqqa proper began yesterday:

The U.S.-backed Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) said on Tuesday it had begun a battle to capture Raqqa, Islamic State's de facto capital in Syria, launching attacks from the east, west and north of the city.

Given that ISIL pretty much shifted their leadership away, I wonder how hard those left to fight for the city will resist?

Still, the Mosul defenders fought hard despite leadership escaping to fight another day.

I wonder how much the Kurds will participate? I've long figured that the Kurds are not reliable offensive partners for anything beyond their homeland. So I assume Syrian Arabs will dominate the fight for the city even if allied Syrian Kurds help hold he flanks and rear areas.

So will ISIL take the opportunity of Western focus on Raqqa to hammer the Syrian government forces at Dayr az Zawr further southeast that I'd heard was being prepared as the backup capital?

And how will Iran and Assad's forces react? Will they sprint to Raqqa to exploit the defeat of ISIL?

And what will we do if Assad tries to impose control over former ISIL-held territory being liberated by Western-backed rebels?

It's an odd war where you really need a scorecard to figure out who is with and against who.

UPDATE: The battle for Iran's supply line is looming and the Iranians aren't willing to wait until ISIL is destroyed to wage it:

American warplanes bombed an Iranian-backed militia that entered a supposed no-go zone near a U.S garrison in southern Syria on Tuesday, U.S. officials said.

The strike marked the second by a U.S. aircraft in less than a month and signals a growing risk of direct conflict between American and Iranian forces and their partners in Syria.

Iran has not been a friend since the overthrow of the Shah and after nearly 40 years of "Death to America!" the regime was not transformed by the soothing balms of hope and change into an ally.

UPDATE: The Iran-US stand-off is intensifying even as the Raqqa fight rages:

A US warplane shot down a pro-regime drone in Syria on Thursday after it fired at coalition forces, officials said, marking a new escalation of tensions in the war-torn country's south. ...

The shoot-down came after another incident earlier Thursday, when coalition forces struck "technical vehicles" advancing toward At-Tanaf and threatening coalition and partner forces, US Central Command said in a statement.

It was the third time the coalition has struck pro-regime forces near At-Tanaf in less than a month.

Does the ISIL attack in Iran pressure Iran to hold back in Syria while America takes ISIL down?

The situation is certainly perplexing for Iran after 8 years of a supine American posture toward Iran under the mullah regime.

UPDATE: ISIL will still have a truncated caliphate southeast of Raqqa. So we are not at the point that ISIL must abandon their cherished objective of ruling a caliphate and resort to pure underground terror. The former was their unique brand. The latter just makes them one of many Sunni Arab terror groups, eh? I assume ISIL won't give up that brand easily.

Tuesday, June 06, 2017

Fear is the Beginning of Wisdom

Opinion polls in China show that the Chinese are increasingly fine with the 1989 Tiananmen Square Massacre:

The bloody crackdown on pro-democracy protests in Tiananmen Square nearly three decades ago saved China from a Russia-style meltdown, according to a strongly held view among the generation that will enjoy unprecedented international clout as it takes up the baton of power in Beijing.

What do you expect them to say given the body count and aftermath of control?

Few are this brave.



As a wise man once said in the face of the power to kill:

What would they do to me,” [Captain Yossarian] asked in confidential tones, “If I refused to fly [the bombers]?”

“We’d probably shoot you,” ex-P.F.C. Wintergreen replied.

“We?” Yossarian cried in surprise. “What do you mean, we? Since when are you on their side?”

“If you’re going to be shot, whose side do you expect me to be on?” ex-P.F.C. Wintergreen retorted.

Wintergreen was a wise man. Not the bravest. But wise under the circumstances.

What Angers European Governments

Let's review what angers Europeans.

Saddam's oppression and aggression didn't anger European governments.

Russia's invasion of Georgia didn't anger Europeans.

Russia's invasion of Ukraine didn't anger Europeans.

Iran's drive for nuclear missiles didn't anger Europeans.

Assad's slaughter of civilians didn't anger Europeans.

Migrant/refugee crime problems didn't anger Europeans.

Bombings in France only momentarily angered Europeans, as the Manchester bombing that slaughtered little girls in Britain demonstrated by highlighting the "resolve" to carry on like nothing happened.

But President Trump pulled out of the Paris climate agreement, which even if it works and everyone carries out their BS "goals" through 2030, would have an impact predicted (by notoriously bad models) to be a global temperature in 2100 that is 0.05 degrees Celsius lower than it would be without the agreement.

And this has angered Europeans:

President Donald Trump said on Thursday he would withdraw the United States from the landmark 2015 global agreement to fight climate change, drawing anger and condemnation from world leaders and heads of industry.

This over-the-top anger and condemnation is based on a predicted change measured in rounding error margins.



Again, 0.05 degrees Celsius. This is angels on pinhead territory, people.

So I bet Europeans will come up with another sad emoji for the latest terror attack victims in London before getting back to righteous anger at the fate of a BS agreement signed in Paris.

Prime Minister May said "enough is enough" after the London attack. But I doubt that is really true.

Now go and emit no more.

I Grow Weary of People Who Look for Reasons Not to Win

Don't assume there is an Assad-friendly stalemate in Syria. We can still defeat Assad.

Is Syria effectively broken up?

Syria, after all, is today divided into no less than seven enclaves: the territory controlled by the regime, three separate areas of rebel control, two Kurdish cantons, and the Islamic State area. ...

The regime cannot now be militarily defeated, a significant success for its diplomacy and arms. But neither has it any clear road to victory. I asked one Information Ministry official about the future of eastern Syria, given the growing strength of the U.S.-backed SDF in the region. His response summed up the underlying reality of the regime’s current position: “We don’t know.”

The author at least recognizes that despite defeat at Aleppo, the rebels are hardly crushed.

But I think he over-states the security of the regime. After the tremendous casualties they have endured, I think that the regime could crack. Who knows what would trigger that?

Also, the regime territory is more fragmented than the author believes. It isn't just the rebel-held regions that Assad would have to reassert control over to recreate Syria as a political entity and not a geographic term.

That feudalism--if not overcome by Assad--gives America the chance to flip local warlords now fighting for Assad who both fear American power post-ISIL and hope for benefits.

The author also correctly notes that Russia only cares about securing the western part of Syria to have air and naval bases to operate in the eastern Mediterranean Sea.

But Iran has incentive to push for control over eastern Syria to gain an overland supply route through Iraq and Syria to Hezbollah in Lebanon.

So America can focus on the east and south--perhaps all the way to Damascus--where Iran has interests while minimizing Russia's appetite to resist our efforts to weaken Assad.

Monday, June 05, 2017

Making America Competitive Again

The hysteria over America leaving the Paris climate agreement is just astounding. But German car makers think it is good for America.

Even if the agreement works and everyone carries out their BS goals through 2030, the impact is predicted (by notoriously bad models) to be a global temperature in 2100 that is 0.05 degrees Celsius lower than it would be without the agreement.

I repeat, an effect of 0.05 degrees Celsius.

Yet America's withdrawal will destroy that planet-saving difference? Even though America did rather well in reducing CO2 emissions after pulling out of the Kyoto agreement in the Bush 43 administration?

And in America, supporters of the agreement have also been claiming that this withdrawal would be harmful to America's economy by denying America a leading role in green technologies (why that would be I don't know).

But economically, German auto makers are already worried that America's withdrawal from the agreement will benefit America at Germany's expense!

Germany's powerful car industry said Europe would need to reassess its environmental standards to remain competitive after the United States said it would withdraw from the Paris climate pact. ...

"The regrettable announcement by the USA makes it inevitable that Europe must facilitate a cost efficient and economically feasible climate policy to remain internationally competitive," Matthias Wissmann, president of the German auto industry lobby group VDA, said in a statement on Friday.

Shouldn't the Germans be chortling in glee at America's decision to abandon the lead in a glorious advance to Green autos?

Seriously, you people on the left need to stop turning the outrage dial to 11 every damn day over every damned thing. You make it way too easy to ignore you.

The Navy May Catch Up With The Dignified Rant

The Navy is looking at potential future fleet composition. One panel was tasked with analyzing three separate directions. Here is one aspect of the fleet the panel identified that I started flogging in 2007:

The Missile Is the Primary Weapon. Modern antiship missiles are nowhere near as large as their first-generation forebears. Even relatively small vessels can carry several. The Chinese Houbei-class catamarans, for example, carry eight YJ-83 antiship missiles with a range of more than 100 nautical miles. Moreover, if missiles are housed in a box launcher or a modified shipping container, they could be placed on almost any kind of ship. If the missiles are capable of being launched on remote command, the host vessel may not need to support them in any way other than an electrical power feed. This means that virtually any vessel could be a missile shooter. The key is a network that can supply the ISR-T data. [emphasis added]

Note that I proposed Modularized Auxiliary Cruisers in this 2009 blog post which I had submitted in 2007 to the publication that printed the above article:

Our Navy defends our nation within the incompatible and unforgiving boundaries formed by the tyrannies of distance and numbers. We struggle to build enough ships both capable of deploying globally and powerful enough for fighting first-rate opponents. Operating within a network-centric Navy, auxiliary cruisers could once again play a valuable role in projecting naval power. Using modular systems installed on civilian hulls, auxiliary cruisers could handle many peacetime roles; free scarce warships for more demanding environments; add combat power within a networked force; and promote the global maritime partnership. ...

Armored standard (20' l x 8.0' w x 8.5' h) general purpose shipping containers would be the building blocks for system modules. Other sizes are available as well, including 40' x 8.0' x 8.5' containers, "hicube" containers measuring 40' x 8.0' x 9.5', and 40' x 8.0' x 4.25' half-height containers. Because Containerized Modules would not be stacked to create a Modularized Auxiliary Cruiser, weapons, sensors, or other equipment could extend above the container roof.

We would build Containerized Modules using shipping containers that include missiles (surface-to-air and surface-to-surface) as well as modules with gun turrets for smaller weapons, up to 57mm. Other modules could support helicopters for anti-submarine (ASW), mine counter measures (MCM), or anti-ship missiles, as well as Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV), Unmanned Surface Vehicles (USV) and Unmanned Underwater Vehicles (UUV). Still others would contain power supplies and the command and communications systems to plug a ship into the Navy network. ...

Cooperative Engagement Capability could allow a Modularized Auxiliary Cruiser with a SUW [NOTE: surface warfare] Mission Package to have its Harpoons fired by a distant warship or airborne platform. Modularized Auxiliary Cruisers could not initiate a strike against a distant target, but would be additional platforms that contribute to the saturation of the enemy’s defenses and complicate enemy strikes. AAW Mission Packages could similarly be plugged in for air defense coverage. [emphasis added]

The Army picked up my proposal for a version used as an Army power projection platform for land power in the low-priority (for Navy hulls) Africa theater. I even noted in that article that the concept remains valid for the Navy for naval missions.

I welcome a Navy exploration of this auxiliary cruiser concept. In a network-centric world, dispersed missiles should take over the sea control mission from the platform-centric queens of the fleet, the super carrier (and yes, the same magazine bought an article from me on this topic late in the last century but never published it).

The Army got a head start over the Navy. We'll see who builds a Modularized Auxiliary Cruiser first.

The author of that initial article also noted the problem of coordinating land-based air power with the fleet. As long as my Navy ideas are getting a belated hearing, let me again suggest using carrier air wings on land bases.