Pages

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Grant Me That This is Funny

The Obama administration is going to continue the tribunal system for captured terrorists. The Obama administration insists the reforms meaningfully change the system from "bad" to "good."

Un huh:

At least some people in the White House must now be embarrassed by their boss's switcheroo, though you can't tell from Friday's declaration. Part of the tribunal face-lift is that "the accused will have greater latitude in selecting their counsel." Say what? Enemy combatants already have better access to attorneys -- white shoe and pro bono, no less -- than nearly every criminal defendant in America. Perhaps this means Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, 90 Yemenis and the rest will now be able to choose lawyers from both Shearman & Sterling and Covington & Burling, instead of one or the other.

Another red herring is supposedly tightening the admissibility of hearsay evidence. Tribunal judges already have discretion to limit such evidence, and the current rules are nearly indistinguishable from those of the International Criminal Court. The sensible exceptions involve evidence obtained under combat conditions or from foreign intelligence services, which are left untouched by Mr. Obama's nips and tucks.


If these tribunals are so different from the Bush-era trials, why are the so-called human rights activist so unhappy and why are conservatives congratulating President Obama for doing the right thing?

This has been fun!